53 min · 3,136 words · 1 November 1988
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk begins with motivation for listening to the Dharma and then moves to the two truths, briefly noting that conventional truth follows the ultimate truth already covered. It explains the categories of aggregates, sources and constituents, including the five aggregates, the twelve sources and the eighteen constituents. It also discusses revelatory and non-revelatory forms, with the example of subtle forms created by taking vows and their benefits.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 53 min
UUID: 391acd47-2393-403b-bad3-fb7a3dbfd8db
Date: 1988-11-01
Words: 3,132
So we’ve spoken about the great benefits to be derived from listening to the Dharma. But as to whether it’s going to be of great benefit or not is determined by your motivation for listening. Therefore, we should try to set our motivation such that we are going to listen to this teaching on the Dharma so that we may be able to liberate, to place in enlightenment all sentient beings. And with such a motivation, then our listening will be of great benefit. In this section we’ll be discussing the two truths.
That is the ultimate truth and the relative or conventional truth. And we’ve completed the explanation of the ultimate truth and then we’re going to go into a brief discussion of conventional truth. Though we’ve only gone into the discussion of emptiness slightly, we can go into it much greater depth in the future in more detail. There are a great number of texts that we can use as sources. Are the various texts by the great master Tsongkhapa in his Praise of Dependent Arising, his three principal aspects of the path, etc.
And then there are the text, the root text such as the text by Candrakīrti,, Entering into the Middle Way and the foundation text of Root Wisdom by Nāgārjuna. So if we can, if we’re able to realize emptiness, that’s really wonderful. But even just listening to a teaching on emptiness plants latencies within the mind. It plants the seeds whereby later we will be able to realize and understand emptiness that much more quicker. You know, the past great scholar yogis who have understood emptiness in its most profound sense.
First, they themselves had planted the seeds of listening within their continuum, within their mind. And then, dependent on having listened to the various teachings, had the seed planted. Then they began they made great prayers, aspirations to be able to realize it. And then through their process of meditation, they went on to great realizations. And just as these great past kalpas, yogis have done, and likewise, we are going through the same process.
The text quotes two lines by Vasubandhu from his Treasury of Knowledge in which he says, the heaps, doors of production and type are the meaning of aggregate source and constituents. So what is meant here is that the various phenomena are being divided into three categories. The first, categories are aggregates, sources, and constituents. These are merely categories, categorizations of phenomena. So we discussed this first categorization, which is that is to say heaps.
And what we mean by heaps are aggregates. Now, when we say an aggregate, we can talk about the physical aggregates, that is, those aggregates which are form, or that is to say, physical objects. These are an aggregation or the coming together a collection of atoms. So we have a composite or a heap or a bunch of atoms coming together. In this collection, that is which composed of atoms, this aggregation of atoms, is what we mean by a physical aggregate.
Then there are the two types of nonphysical aggregates, the aggregate of non associated compositional factors, non associated compositional factors. And this would be, for example, the compounding of the various directions. The parts, the various directional parts, this collection of various directions coming together is an aggregation or collection of directional parts. Then there would be the consciousness aggregate and this would be, for example, the aggregation, the collection of the various moments in a continuum of a particular consciousness, the collection of the moments of consciousness. So these are the different ways we can look at the aggregations or collections of parts making up a heap or an aggregate.
So when we classify the aggregates, can classify them into five types. There are five aggregates. There’s the aggregate of forms, the aggregate of feelings, the aggregate of, discriminations, the aggregate of compositional factors, and the aggregate of consciousnesses. Forms, feelings, discriminations, compositional factors, and consciousnesses. So when we divide up the aggregate of forms, we can divide it up into various further categorizations.
For example, in the discussion of the study of mind, we’ve been discussing, for example, the sense powers. So this would, there were the five sense powers. The eye sense power, ear, nose, tongue, body sense powers. Then there are the objects of these sense powers. For example, the visible forms, which are the objects experienced by the eye consciousness, that is the object of the sense powers.
Then there’s the, eye, ear, there’s the sounds heard by the ear consciousness or the object of the basis of the ear sense power. There’s the nose, pleasant smells, unpleasant smells. There are the delicious tastes un delicious tastes, unpleasant tastes. And then there are tastes such as sweet and sour, etcetera. And then there are the objects of the body consciousness such as the smoothness and roughness, etcetera.
So the eye’s five sense powers and the five objects of the senses. So we can add one further category. There are degrees, or there is a classification into gross or coarse and subtle form. Coarse and subtle form. So these 10 we’ve listed so far are coarse forms.
There’s one more to be added, which is a subtle form, and this is called non revelatory, non revelatory, non revealing, non revelatory form. So this makes 11 in total. And the So these various forms are made up an aggregate of the elements or the atoms. Those are the elements of earth, water, fire, and air. Upon the aggregation of these elements, are able to be held by the eye consciousness, etcetera, and they act as objects for the eye consciousness.
So then, what is meant by the one non revelatory form? An example would be the, upon taking a vow, for example, if a monk were to take, if a person were to take a novice vow or a fully a fully renounced, the full ordination of a monk, then at the time of taking the actual vow, a subtle form is created in the mind. This subtle form is a form, but it’s a non revelatory form. So we can talk about revelatory forms and non revelatory forms. When we say revelatory forms, there are revelatory forms which are speech, revelatory forms which are body.
What we mean when we say revelatory form which is speech, is the fact of being able to ascertain the motivation or the intention behind someone’s speech. If the intention or the motivation behind someone’s making a statement, that is some speech, if we can ascertain that, then this is called the revelatory form of speech So the difference between these two types of subtle forms, these are both subtle forms, there’s the revelatory and non revelatory subtle forms. If we are able to ask, if we can understand or we can know the intention or the motivation behind the speech or the bodily action, then it’s a revelatory subtle form. For example, if someone were to hit you, motivated by anger, then we could understand as hitting that he was motivated by anger. So, it’s just, you know, if someone hits you, then this is, this is not a subtle form. This actual activity of hitting is a form.
For example, the bodily hitting. Someone hits you and knowing the motivation. This is an example, it’s not the knowing, it’s the action of being hit. If we can understand the motivation behind it, then it becomes a revelatory form. It’s a revelatory form.
That is to say, it’s being revealed. Why is it revealed? Because we can know the motivation behind that action, behind this form. This activity itself is a form. Now, if we cannot know the form, the motivation, such as the having taken the, a vow of individual liberation, for example, you know, a monk’s vow, for example, this creates a form, but cannot, others cannot understand the motivation behind this form, then this is said to be a non revelatory, a non revealing type, and it’s a more subtle type of form.
Therefore, it’s a non revelatory form, a subtle form. So then an example of being hit is a bodily non revelatory, a bodily revelatory form. Example of a verbal revelatory form would be for example if a beggar were to ask you please give me money. Would, and dependence upon that sound that you heard, you would be able to understand what his motivation behind that, making that sound. So this sound would be an example of a verbal revelatory form.
So we can, mostly we can understand what the motivation is behind when someone says something, you know. Just in general, when someone says something, if we can think about it, we then we can come up with an idea of what his motivation behind that making those sounds was. For example, you know, you’ve come here, you’re sitting here and this act, this sit, this bodily posture sitting here, Rinpoche can infer from you by sitting here, if he thinks about it, he can infer that you’ve come here to listen to this teaching. And therefore, this bodily posture, this form that you’re taking, can be motivation behind it can be inferred or thought about. He can understand it through some reasoning.
So then when Rinpoche actually gives the teaching, you know, he’s speaking all these all these meanings, terms, then you can understand from your side, you know, having set our motivation initially, what his motivation is behind speaking these words, and therefore you can come to understand that these sounds that he’s making are a verbal revelatory form. So this physical revelatory form, no bodily, bodily revelatory form and verbal revelatory form are forms which we can understand the motivation behind their taking this particular aspect, know, whether it’s a particular forms of sound or the particular bodily configuration. We can understand why that’s coming about. We can understand the motivation behind this person taking this particular bodily posture. For example, sitting at a teaching or behind what’s being said, the motivation.
Therefore, because we can understand the motivation behind these, these are called bodily and verbal revelatory forms. Then on the other hand, the nonrevelatory forms are the, for example, the subtle forms which are developing the mind upon taking vows. Now, for example, if we were to take a vow of some sort, and when you take a vow, actually there’s a point in taking a vow where you think that you have taken the vow completely perfectly. Now, actually it’s very difficult to know what is your motivation from behind taking that vow. You may not even know your real motivation.
Therefore, taking this vow, since we cannot come to understand what our motivation is, in actuality for taking that vow, we think we’ve taken it well. We try to come to this firm belief, but in fact to understand what our motivation is, is difficult. Therefore these are called non revelatory forms or forms the motivation for which, the development for which we cannot understand. Dharmakīrti has said that the taking of the full monks vows develops a type of subtle form which is he compares it to the moon and that it’s brilliant, it’s white, but even though it has this aspect, still we cannot know the motivation behind it, therefore it’s called a non revelatory form. So this creation of this subtle form in the continuum of the being upon taking a vow is the reason why it is said that the taking of vows is so great of importance that these vows, these various ethical vows that we are able to take is said to be one of the skillful means that the Buddha enacted by, you know, we can take the various vows of a lay person, we can take a one day fast vow, and having taken these vows, there’s a subtle form created within the continuum of the person.
And while this form is in existence within the person, no matter what you may do, whether you’re sleeping, whether you’re working, engaging in various activities, this vow is creating positive energy. It is said that the various vows that the Buddha gave us the skillful means to help lead the practitioners on in their spiritual journey was the skillful means of the Buddha. That you know for example we can take the vows of a lay person. This consists of five vows. The abandonment of killing, stealing, sexual misconduct, lying, and intoxicants.
And that no matter having taken these vows, the subtle form created is created and no matter what we might be doing, the various activities, whether we’re eating, sleeping, all the actions and work that we do during this period, we’re creating a great deal of positive energy, a great deal of positive potential, and therefore this is why it’s said to be the entrance way into the teachings of the Buddha. So there’s a difference between the same action performed by a person who has taken a vow and someone who hasn’t. That is to say a person who has not taken a vow even though he may refrain from for example killing does not compare with the positive energy, the positive potential created by someone who actually commits himself to abandoning killing, for example. Having taken a vow, I am today for now on, for however many years he may wish to take the vow, I am not going to kill. From that time on, no matter what he may be doing, in all his actions, he’s creating uninterrupted positive stream of energy.
Likewise, if we were to take the eight precepts, there, within both the eight precepts of the common fasting vows, the twenty four hour precepts of taking eight vows, eight precepts, or the motivated by the, with the great vehicle motivation, twenty four hour vows of the great vehicle. And you know, had said that you know that we just having taken these is unimaginable even though it’s only for one day it’s unimaginably beneficial you know that the power that we create within ourselves not only is it going to benefit us in this life, but it’s going to benefit us in in the future lives. And this is the way we can really engage in the in the actual practice of the Buddhist teachings. So there’s a quotation from a discourse by the Buddha in which he said those who take the various vows will be within the circle of disciples of Maitreya and they will quickly achieve enlightenment. So the Buddha said, you know, it’s in enumerating the benefits of the methods for creating positive energy.
He said, by taking precepts and vows, we don’t have to make much energy we don’t have to make much effort, but we create a great deal of positive energy. So this first categorization is aggregates, then the second categorization is sources. There are 12 sources. These are the So there are the 12 constituents. I’m sorry, 12 sources.
There are 12 sources. Now, in dependence upon a sense power and the object of that sense power, we develop a particular consciousness. For example, in dependence upon the eye sense power and the object of the eye sense power, the visible form, we develop an eye consciousness. So there are six external sources and six internal sources. The sense power and the object are external sources, and the consciousness developed is an internal source.
So there are, there’s six external, six internal making 12 sources. Okay. So I made a mistake. There are 12 sources. Six internal sources and six external sources.
The six internal sources are the six sensory powers. For example, the eye sense power is referred to as the eye source. The eye sense power is referred to as the eye source. So there’s the eye, ear, nose, tongue, body and mental sources. And then there are the various and there are the six external sources, the various objects of these sense powers, of these sources, which are the forms, sounds, tastes, touch, smells, tastes, touches, and phenomena.
So there are the six internal, six external sources. In dependence upon the eye or the eye source, that is the eye sense power, the eye sense power, the eye source, the eye in combination with the object that is a visible form, there arises an eye consciousness. That’s why they call these sources. And dependence upon these two, the eye source and the eye, the object of the eye that is the visible form, dependence upon these two, these act as a source to develop an eye consciousness. So the same is true of the ear.
The ear or the ear sense power or the ear source in combination with the sound produces an ear consciousness and the same for the rest. So it’s similar for the rest of the eye, ear, nose, tongue, body, and mental sources. These are similar can be inferred from the previous two examples. So then the next way of categorizing phenomena is into the, constituents. So there are 18 constituents.
So we the way we can make up 18 aspects of the 18 constituents of the constituents is that just as before we had six sense powers, eye sense power, ear, nose, tongue and body and mental sense powers. And we had the various objects of observation of the mental sense powers, the visible forms, sounds, smells, tastes, touches and phenomena. And these, in addition to these, we generate the six respective consciousnesses, the eye consciousness, etcetera, making a total of 18. Six sense powers, six objects of observation, and six consciousnesses make 18 constituents. So the the the six objects of, observation, the visible forms, sounds, smells, tastes, objects of touch, and phenomena.
Those are the objects of the observation. Then there are the basis, the six bases. The eye sense power, ear sense power, nose sense power, tongue, body, and mental sense powers. These are the six sense powers. Then there are the six consciousness generated, the eye consciousness, the ear consciousness, nose consciousness, tongue, and bodily, and mental consciousness, making a total of 18, and these are referred to as the 18 constituents.
Are getting bored? So when we talk about consciousnesses here, we’re referring to, between minds and mental factors,, we’re referring to minds. That is main consciousnesses rather than but they are simply consciousnesses. But between mind and mental factors, we’re referring to the minds. There are six.
Now, from where do they develop? They develop from the basis. And these basis are the various respective six sense faculties or six sense powers.
Key terms in this teaching
- conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
- As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
- eighteen constituents dhatu (Skt); kham (Tib)
- The six sense powers, the six consciousnesses and the six objects. LYWA
- individual liberation
- The liberation from cyclic existence achieved by a hearer (shravaka) or solitary realizer (pratyekabuddha), as compared with the full enlightenment of a buddha sought in the Mahayana. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
- The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.