43 min · 2,006 words · 11 October 1988
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains afflictive emotions such as miserliness, jealousy, attachment, hatred and ignorance as causes of suffering, and constructive mental factors such as contentment, self shame, regard for others and conscientiousness as causes of happiness. It stresses habituating oneself to positive states gradually, like learning to write. A question-and-answer period follows on distinguishing shame, the motives for holding power, and whether sharing power is an antidote to attachment.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 44 min
UUID: d2f0b90a-8351-4f01-8986-f0ff8619c456
Date: 1988-10-11
Words: 2,002
So, you know, these various afflictive emotions which we’re listing as the causes of suffering such as miserliness. If we go into the study of awareness and knowledge when we study the various types of minds and mental factors, study these individually. For example, in the case of miserliness. Miserliness is the thought to hold to oneself all the various objects which one thinks will bring one’s happiness, holding them to one’s, clinging to them for oneself only. Whereas, for example, jealousy is not being able to, not liking an, not liking someone else’s attainment or advancement.
Not, not, not being able to like not liking someone else’s coming up in the world. There’s attainment. Attainments. Yeah. Obtainments.
On the other hand, attachment is, you know, seeing someone else’s possession. You think, ah, that’s very good. I like to have that. This is, attachment or desire. So the phrase the another afflictive emotion such as hatred is is anger directed toward another person, such that one, thinks to bring them harm.
So, with respect to the obscuration, it’s a confusion with respect to the nature of the various objects. It’s as if the object appears unclear to the mind. So it’s a it’s an ignorance and unclarity with respect to the nature of an object. So these are some of the examples of the various types of causes of suffering. Therefore, it is through the cultivation of mind that we seek to reduce the force of these causes.
There are the causes of happiness, the various types of mental factors such as contentment. Contentment is being satisfied with whatever is presented, example food or clothing, thinking, Oh, is enough. This is good enough. I can be finding satisfaction thinking that this is satisfactory. This is a constructive mental factor.
And then another constructive factor would be, for example, self shame. Or perhaps we can say, that’s good enough. Self shame. This would be that, the state whereby one would be feel embarrassment, having engaged in a particular action, a negative a particular negative action from the point of view that if others were to know about it. If others were to know about this particular negative action that you engaged in, you would feel embarrassed.
This is self shame. So I made a mistake with respect to self shame. This would be one would feel embarrassed even if others weren’t to know about it. One feels for one’s own side, one feels ashamed or embarrassed that one had would lose self respect if one had this from one’s own side. Whereas, for example, this next constructive factor which is called regard for others, something like regard for others, would be if one engaged in a particular negative action, one would feel embarrassed if others, someone who you respected, were to find out about it such as your teacher or your friend.
If they were to find out about it, if they were to know about it, you would feel embarrassed in front of them. Whereas, in the case of self shame, even if they weren’t to find out about it, you yourself from your side feel embarrassed or have lost some self respect about having engaged in this negative action. Another constructive factor is conscientiousness. And this would be understanding and not engaging in various types of negative actions, but on the contrary, understanding and engaging in the positive types of action. Discriminating and nonengagement in in these two types of action.
These are constructive factors in the mind. When we generate these, we experience happiness during their actual presence and being in that state of mind, and they also act as causes for future happinesses. So these various constructive actions that we’ve talked about, these constructive states of mind, positive states, positive mental factors, we’re not particularly habituated or accustomed to these. More than not, we’re accustomed to the negative side, the negative mental factors. Therefore, you know, now at this opportunity that we have, having attained the all the qualities of a human being, And now we can actually begin to reverse this trend and begin to accustom ourselves more and more habituate ourselves, get used to positive states such as these constructive states that we’ve just mentioned.
And, you know, we can just one day, you know, can’t do it all at once. One day we can make some effort and we’ll have perhaps an increase, a slight increase in our constructive states of mind which we experience in that day. And the next day, we increase a little more, and a little bit more, a little more, more, a little bit more. And this way, we will, you know, completely develop our mind. Nice.
So it’s, you know, this is just like, you know, a small child who’s first learning to write the alphabet. When he first begins to write, it’s extremely difficult for him. But he can’t even write his name. But, you know, after making effort over a period of time, it becomes natural to him. It becomes second nature, as it were.
It comes quite easily. This likewise, these constructive states of mind can become our second nature. So the Śāntideva has said that there is nothing in this world does not does not become easier upon habituation. So, we can develop these positive factors in mind, you know, slight every day, slightly. We can become more and more habituated, accustomed to these positive factors.
Such factors as contentment, self shame, regard for others, conscientiousness, that when these states of mind are, are, when exist within our, within our continuum, we are abiding in constructive states of being. So we have about twenty minutes left, and Rinpoche would like to know if you have any questions. Does anyone have any questions? You have a question, Doug? Yes.
Yeah. Well, one of the points that came up was feeling embarrassed or self shamed. That is feeling shame about a particular act from from one’s own side without telling it to another. Obviously, there are degrees of acts in terms of malice or goodness. Right?
And our own sort of upbringing or social programming sort of dictates those those acts that that we feel embarrassed of from our own side. Now some people have confided to me that some of the things they’ve done, they felt great embarrassment act, and I would tell tell them not to feel embarrassed at all. So I mean, how do they know? Mhmm. Right?
From a Buddhist point of view. The the So what it comes down to is coming to a decision what types of actions are negative and what types of actions are positive. And so we can’t just rely on anybody’s determination. We have to rely on experts in the field. And therefore, we have to, you know, look to those who we see as being straightforward and being expert in the field and who as a group state clearly that this type of action is negative, this type of action is positive.
And this is the basis upon which we decide what we should feel shame about and what we shouldn’t feel shame about. But in general we can say that any action which harms another or harms yourself is a negative action. And any action which benefits other or benefits yourself is a positive action. Positive activity. The great difficulties of people seeking powerful means of happiness, for instance, being prime minister, and that they will always they will always have enemies and always be in conflict.
Can we apply that to our own lives in as far as, say, being offered positions of authority or responsibility. And oh, that’s better. My my dilemma is always well, maybe I may have something to offer in that position. But am I just being seduced by the power power of it? I’ve I’ve I’m deciding that it’s probably more the latter.
It’s very easy to be seduced by that. If you understand what I mean, quite Yeah, go ahead. You don’t understand. Well, I can sort of infer what you’re How can you distinguish between having the right motivation to, say, in being in a position of responsibility and just being seduced by the power of something? How do you know?
So, someone who’s practicing a spiritual path is not to say he wouldn’t try to become a prime minister or some official with power. That’s not the question. He would be aware of the suffering that could be, that one could undergo. For example, you know, in what’s going on now in The United States with the election campaign, have all these debates, all these disputes, they each have to go a lot of trouble. They’re undergoing a lot of trouble in this contest.
And all the various types of suffering which even if he were to attain it, he would undergo. But the spiritual practitioner understanding that all this suffering would come about because of an incorrect attitude for trying to attain that position in the first place. That seeking power and fame is the reason seeking power and fit. This position is an expression of seeking power and fame. And therefore, it is the cause, that is to say, seeking happiness only for this life.
And therefore, in this trying to become a prime minister, for example, would involve one in suffering. Whereupon the other hand, someone who is only a spiritual practitioner would not have this incorrect type of attitude for trying to become the Prime Minister. And he could go ahead and become Prime Minister with the motivation of seeking happiness for future lives. But it’s not to say that he shouldn’t try to become a Prime Minister. There’s nothing wrong with becoming a Prime Minister.
Whether you’re a spiritual practitioner or worldly practitioner, worldly practitioner in seeking that same position will experience suffering and the spiritual practitioner will not. So, we’re not saying that there’s anything wrong with being, for example, a prime minister. We were talking about the suffering which could entail depending upon whether you’re a practitioner or not. There’s, for example, the suffering of not attaining their position in the first place. And then once having attained it, perhaps, and you lose, you’re not able to keep all your old friends, and you create a lot of new enemies.
And there’s all this suffering involved. So it’s not but there’s no question about whether it’s it’s good or bad to be a prime minister. So Āryadeva said that those in high places undergo mental suffering, those in low places undergo physical suffering. Therefore, wherever we go, we undergo suffering. I just wanted to ask, if someone is in a position of power, does Rinpoche think that if that power that that if someone shares that power, then that is more of a Buddhist way of of using power because if one’s attached to power then it becomes corruption and problems.
But if one uses the process of consultation and things like consensus and, you know, like in the case of prime minister that would be like checking what people want and things like that. Does he believe that some actual sharing of power would be the more Buddhist way? So it would if he could the the the main he shouldn’t, the main necessity is that he be honest in his dealings. That, you know, whatever he does must be straightforward. Now as far as, it would if he could share his power, then he would not this would be a method, an antidote to development of attachment that he may that may develop toward his power.
So this would be a good way to deal with this situation. If he were willing to give away part of his power, would be an antidote to developing attachment to it. Good. And so on like this. Good. And so on like this. So we’ll we’ll stop here for the evening.
Key terms in this teaching
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
How can you tell the difference between the right motivation for taking a position of responsibility and simply being seduced by power?
A spiritual practitioner might well try to become a prime minister or hold a powerful office; there is nothing wrong with that. The difference lies in the attitude behind it. Seeking power and fame is an expression of seeking happiness only for this life, and this incorrect attitude brings suffering, such as the strain of the contest, failing to win the position, or losing old friends and making new enemies once in office. A practitioner can take the same position with the motivation of seeking happiness for future lives, and then does not suffer in this way.