36 min · 3,513 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains emptiness (Śūnyatā) as the open, unlimited potential behind all phenomena rather than nothingness, and that things appear yet are empty and impermanent. It teaches that grasping at permanence causes suffering, that letting go of attachment allows love to flow, that interdependence reduces anger, and that good heart and not harming others are central to practice.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 36 min
UUID: 174187ca-dae3-4fc8-be91-cb8d8ed6cf30
Words: 3,509
The most important is the transforming the mind and in a sense leading to understanding nature mind or the nature reality. Remember that mind has two aspects. There’s apparent aspect and the essence nature of mind. Sometimes Dalai Lama calls it appearance and reality. I spoke about how saṃsāra’s mind turned out loss in projection, whereas nirvana is mind turned inwardly recognizing nature.
So to re how to realize the essence of mind, the nature of mind, the is connected with. Is explaining the nature of realities. Like, for example, you see the modern science. It’s very amazing. His Holiness has been very interested in science.
Now about twenty years, he’d been dialoguing with some of the top scientists in many different fields, learning from them, and they have also learned from him and other Buddhist scholars. And it was extraordinary. In some ways, that gathering, coming together, that really deep dialogue, has led also a subtle or a kind of a deeper movement in the scientific field. Science previously dealt only with matter. But now even the dimension mind is beginning to manifest.
And that’s the modern science, physics, quantum physics, saying that, you know, previously held view was that the smallest existing particle is the atom. Atom is the small existing part. Isn’t it? Modern physics says that even doesn’t exist. It’s a field of energy.
And that’s little bit saying like. It’s like, you know, in a sense is like the background to everything and nature reality from which everything manifests. And that in a sense, you see very much the understanding of Śūnyatā in a deeper way is actually understanding the nature of God. Yes. Now for example, the Thomas Merton, the great trappist monk, who developed with many, for example, like Dalai Lama and many great Buddhists, and really found that the deeper aspect of understanding of the god lies in the understanding of nature mind, ain’t you?
Because you see, when you talk generally, you see God as you see the creator of the world, creator like that. But actually, when you look deeply among the Christian contemporary, the good Christian monks and real practitioners of contemplation, they see God not outside. They see God in the nature of mind. And that we have seen is quite accord with Buddhism. What is emptiness, Suryatta?
Śūnyatā. Śūnyatā. Or emptiness is the measurable, indefinable potential that the background of all phenomena uncreated, unaffected by changes of cause and condition, the actual reality. And remember when I used the example of the cup. That bring it to you because you see how things are.
In reality, they appear, yet they’re empty. The trouble with us, you see, because we we very much grasp. We grasp, and then we we believe things are permanent, grasp onto, and the grasping is the cause of pain. Yeah. All of us.
And then you see what happens is when you really realize since everything is impermanent that what you grasp on is not graspable. You got it? Because normally, you see, when things exist, we immediately put permanent to existence. And so we grasp. But in life shows that not true.
Things change, and so they’re suffering. Because what they grasp on is not permanent. So that’s why the suffering is that. So even we assert it impermanence to, like you know, sometimes when you say impermanence, you kind of have a sense of impermanence means there’s nothing. Yeah.
If everything is impermanent, then, like, you know, you feel kind of lonely. You feel like there’s nothing nothing to grasp, nothing to love. No. At all. No.
Not at all. In fact, you look other way around. It’s a grasping that cause pain. Particularly grasping onto someone or something that’s not there. For example, if you fall in love with somebody who’s absolutely unreliable Who will not love you, and you madly fall in love With the concept.
Because we fall in love with concept. Idea of what somebody should be. We fall in love with concept. And then reality is not that. And then you’re paid.
But from the beginning, if you knew this person or situation, if you already knew before, then you will not put so much attachment to it. And when it goes, you say, well, I kind of knew that. But otherwise, we have such a belief that’s true, it exists, then we grasp then pain. You got it? Yes.
That’s why the nature of all phenomena, everything. Yesterday, I was demonstrating with the glass. You see glass? Glass. You see?
Look. It it really exists and looks very permanent. But if I throw it, the glass breaks, and they’re no longer glass. Just pieces. And that further if you break into atoms, atom also can be further broken.
Just a merely field of energy or light. Energy or light. Depend on the perceiver. So it’s empty, which mean not permanent. So which shows that we should not grasp onto, believe in the idea of permanence.
That’s a concept, A false concept. The things are permanent, and they are reliable. You got it? And when it’s not? If you know that from before to the teachings, you see, then you begin to have more understanding of nature of how things really are.
You’re more close to reality, And then you’re not deceived. Mhmm. Is that clear? It’s like that. And then at the same time again, doesn’t mean it’s nothing.
It’s nothing. Like, you know, you think emptiness is like, you know, impermanent. Nothing. No. It is not.
In fact, it is also not nothing. It neither permanent nor nonexisting. So it’s not nonexisting. Why? Because here.
See, also, you and I, we are example of we are all impermanent, but we are also not nonexisting. We are not nothing. We are here. But then if we are not permanent, and then you must say, what is this that exists? It comes from many, many things come to put together.
Many cause and conditions, which science again demonstrate that. For example, you know how they discover, how this is made, how camera, how plane, a piece of metal that flies in the air. And maybe even three or four thousand years ago, the possibility plane was always there. Potential was there. But then we have understanding of interdependence.
The scientists, they put together and make this discovery. And there are more and more discoveries to be made. That’s why means all possibilities. And means it beyond our senses and beyond our concept. Concept.
Limited concept. Empty in the sense of you see that? Yes. Is that clear? Yes.
The true message of this The same was in sacrifice. Is that when you realize things are impermanent Now this, if you read Tibetan book of living, dying, read chapter three. That will tell you that. What we can learn from impermanence. They did learn from impermanence.
Really? Is that clear? Learn. And from when you really learn from impermanence No. It is impermanence.
And whose true nature is emptiness Yeah. By the way, emptiness doesn’t mean nothingness. You understand? Yeah. It’s empty of concepts.
In fact, the definition means empty, but only in the sense of something beyond the ability to perceive with our senses, beyond our capacity to conceptualize. So better translation Tongva could be inconceivable or unnameable. Yet, me means Mhmm. Conveys the sense of possibility. Sense of anything can rise and anything can happen.
So that when Buddhist speak of emptiness, it does not mean nothingness. Rather an unlimited potential for anything to appear, change, and disappear. Very fluid. The scientists are beginning to understand. You see, when matter is broken, becomes energy in light, and then begin slowly understand deeper, deeper.
Implications are very profound. So what is the wonderful thing if you really understand that? Is it how things appear, yet they’re empty, but yet that emptiness appears in the form of form. Form is emptiness. Emptiness is form.
When you really realize things are empty, they’re impermanent, you realize that you see it is futile to grasp. Then if you can let go of that grasping and attachment, then love can flow. Love can flow. Love can flow. And then also when you let go, when you realize on a profound level.
Like, for example, I’ll give you an example. During the time of Buddha. This is also in the event of a woman called Krishna Gautam. She lost her only child. And she was so grief stricken.
She want the child back alive. She took the corpse, went everywhere if anything can bring this child back to life. So some consoled her, others ridiculous. This is a mad woman. And finally, someone said, if anybody can bring her child back to life, perhaps it’s Buddha.
Buddha was there during that time. So she went to the Buddha with the body of the child. Because she had so much grief. She couldn’t let go. She couldn’t accept death.
And then, you know, said, would you bring child back? And the Buddha, if he said, you know, if he spoke very directly, he she would not accept it. So Buddha said, I can bring the child to life. But on one condition. That you have to find a bowl full of mustard seed from a house that has never experienced that, from a family that never experienced that.
She said, oh, that’s wonderful. She gave her hope. Oh, it was a chance. So she went round from one house to the next and next and next. And everywhere, there’s all you know, so many stories of death.
You know? And when we everywhere, there’s nobody nowhere that death is not visited. When he saw then the universality of death and not something a special punishment for her and her son. Then you see she came back to Buddha. She took the child’s body to the charnel ground, and she came to Buddha.
And Buddha said Did you find the mustard? She said, no. She said, I now I realized the lesson that you’re trying to teach me. Because when you realize that impermanence is the nature of everything, then letting go becomes easier. For example, when we lost our country and lost everything.
Like, for example, my family, we’re actually a royalty. Royalty. And not only that, we were the most wealthy family in Eastern Tibet. Dates back to before even thirteenth century. Family name was given by Tsongkhapa himself, the founder of the school.
Belongs to. And and he prophesied it become a very wealthy family, and so we became the benefactors of them. So generation to come, my family supported all the work of all the great masters and all the monasteries. There’s not a major monastery in Tibet whose main practice or monastery is not supported family. And so but then?
All gone. And so what all the elders would say You see, instead of losing heart, they will say, just as Buddha taught us that everything is impermanent, what is happening now is this great impermanence. Instead of losing heart, they realize the truth of this. It’s a teaching. Most profound teaching.
And that’s a consolation. Is that clear? So if you realize things are impermanent in a deep way and can let go. But letting go doesn’t mean when we let go of attachment
Doesn’t mean letting go of love. You can love even more and fearlessly. Is that clear? And you see, put it this way. Trouble with us with all the thoughts, concepts we hold on to very strongly.
That’s why many conflict in the world come because of concepts, philosophical, religious ideology, these things. Yeah. Like, for example, Judaism, Christianity, Islam, they came from the same source. But yet there’s so much conflict. So sometimes concept really are source of.
Do you understand what I’m saying? Because if you go beyond the concept that’s realizing god. The nature of God. When we let go of all our ideas, thoughts, judgment, and projections, ideas, notions. Then you become open.
You become flexible. You become tolerant. You understand it? I do. Like, for example, you see, the view of interdependence, which which when you really realize deeply, lead to the understanding of.
His Holiness always speaks of very practical application. Now, for example, maybe you get angry. Situation, circumstance make really makes us mad. Crazy. And then what happens is we’re very angry.
We’re angry, angry, and we blame that person for that circumstances. And you see what happens is you get more and more angry. That’s when you think when you think there’s one independent, you know, independent cause and, you know But then you see when you look back. When you have the teachings, teachings say things are not independent. These are interdependent.
When you really look that there are actually many cause and conditions. If something happens, situation, it’s not just one cause. One particular person’s situation, it’s just one aspect. There are many cause and conditions. And you sometimes realize very much often that we ourselves are to be blamed for.
So when you realize and look at how everything is interdependent, then initial anger or the object of your anger is diminished. Diminished. So therefore, like, if there’s no object of anger, you know, like, for example, if there’s not a screen to project the movie, there’s no movie. You’d always object to, you see. So in that way, His Holiness says the view of interdependence is very practical.
Work with anger. And then you see what happens is this. When you do that, when you hear things, then you see the you know, because the violence in us Okay. Is that is diminished. Mhmm.
So therefore, it brings nonviolence. You have to conquer your mind, your emotions, through reason, through analysis. That you know, that’s when you train it that way, then you see whatever situation you see, you can deal with with composure, with wisdom, and with compassion. So that when you realize things are impermanent, then what happens is that, you know, that when impermanence happens to us, it almost brings a very profound understanding of nature of things. I remember one.
He was very seriously ill in in New York. He was and when I called him, he said, oh, it’s saṃsāra. Because saṃsāra is by nature suffering. And when you accept nature of saṃsāra is suffering, then when suffering comes to you, it’s more acceptable. Like, when you come to Spain, Barcelona, airport, you see everybody speaking Spanish or whatever.
They’re talking about the Spanish? Not English. So they said, why? Why? This is okay.
Why? Because you are in Barcelona. So just as when you are in saṃsāra, there’s suffering. Suffering is the natural landscape. There’s suffering everywhere, and everybody suffers, including ourselves.
Whether you’re rich or poor, everybody has a In fact, one great master, He was in Chinese prison for twenty years. He came listening to learning to teach. And he said he did not suffer at all. Didn’t suffer suffer at at all. All.
He didn’t suffer at all because he rely he accept nature of saṃsāra, nature of impermanence, and karma. So when you realize the nature of impermanence, actually, it gives you space, gives you more acceptance, Understanding. Okay. Is that clear? Because if you look in life like, for example, if you look, you touch it.
If it doesn’t tick, if it doesn’t beep, you’re dead. That mean changes. If the watch is not clicking and changing, it’s dead. If you don’t breathe, you’re dead. But all this breathing, it change.
This is change. Change It’s that keep life alive. Discontinuity is a part of fundamental continuity. When you realize that, then you have greater understanding, wisdom, compassion. Then as we said before, the two aspects, it’s it’s empty, it’s not permanent, it’s not permanent, it’s impermanent, but yet it’s not nothing.
It exists because of many cause and conditions. Because if you say it’s just empty or it’s impermanent, then we say, well, you know, then you become a nihilist. Then nothing matters. You know? Eat, make, merry, and then tomorrow you die.
But that’s not like that. On the relative level, you see, like this this glass you see? When you say glass is not just one glass, there are so many glasses. So this is not so many glasses. Yeah.
There are so many cups. There’s Chinese cups. Many different Chinese cups. All this. Because that also shows impermanent.
That also shows because of many indeterminate cause and condition, you can create many different appearances. So that will mean that, you know, there is karma. There is cause and effect. Therefore, whatever we do or say has consequences. So therefore, we have to be responsible for our actions, for our words, and most important, our mind.
That’s why in the essence of teaching Buddha, most important is, as the master say, if you cannot help, at least don’t harm. Don’t keep any malice and malice and hatred now. If you don’t keep any malice and hate in your heart, you are a great Buddhist. You are a great Christian practitioner. You are a great, I think, a Jewish practitioner.
Islam, the best bet. Do you understand? She if you cannot help, at least don’t harm. And most important is good heart. Where you told how this great master, Atisha, she never says, you know, how’s your family?
She may ask, but he always asks us, how is your good heart today? Good heart. Most important is good heart. Good heart. That’s what I had the great honor to serve his Holiness Dalai Lama, organize his first visit to the West in 1973.
I also traveled to the Vatican. And in those first visit with the journalists, he always says, he talked about good heart. Always good heart. He says, my religion is very simple. My religion is kindness.
So the most important thing is don’t keep malice and hatred in your heart. Don’t harbor a black heart. Instead, good heart. Kind. In fact, if you don’t keep malice in your heart, Hatred.
All of you. You’re a winner. And if you are kind Yes. And loving Yeah. And also I think then when you die when?
You’ll be quite okay. It’s not here. Two things count when you die. How you lived your life. Us.
You should live your life not harming others, but helping others, then your life is meaningful. And then or the state of mind when you die. Is that clear? So very much about but the sunyata really is keep an open mind. Never judge.
Also, sometimes, you see, interesting, we all have concepts, ideas, notions. Like, for example, there was this great master. Great master. He was a man who teaches. His wife, some say she was the dragon lady because she’s quite severe looking.
And they came in 1972, I think, to England. I was in Cambridge University. I was just a student. I had no money, no means. I barely made to the school.
But then suddenly, I was contacted. He was coming. And so I don’t know what to do. Then I was so scared. She might say, who the hell you think we are?
You think we are going to see stay in this place? Because that was kind of reputation some people created. But when I met her, she was the kindest, most most in fact, she gave her own money to shop. She was the kindest, you know. And so and I have many, many such examples.
Never believe what people say about people. Never judge. You understand? Never judge. And Jesus said, if you judge, then you shall be judged by the same way.
You know that saying goes, he who uses the sword shall be severed by the same you know? The person who made the guillotine in France, He was the first one to be killed by the way. So therefore, if you judge, so shall be judged. So not to judge. Be open.
Give the benefit of doubt. And always look at the goodness in people. Goodness. Focus on the virtue, but not on the failure. That’s the advice I’ve given in chapter 11 of the Tibetan Book of Living and Dying.
When people are faced with death and you help them, you really help them to focus on their virtues, not on their faults. This all comes from where? The holy view. Śūnyatā. So definitely not nothingness.
In Zen, they’re the same. Zen some speaks in paradoxes. It says, it’s not emptiness. It’s fullness. So you see the wonderful thing is how things are appearing yet empty, like reflection in the water.
That’s how nature of things are. Things appearing yet empty. We should enjoy them. At the same time, do not be attached to them. Because they’re illusory.
Key terms in this teaching
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.