Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2016-04-06 – KR.mp3
UUID: f3b5162d-1953-43cd-b3a5-627091f9614f
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2016-04-06
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 32m
Words: 4,210
Mhmm. So in the promise to compose of Chandakirti’s Madhyamakavatara, instead of paying homage to the Buddha, the Dharma and the Sangha, which is the usual homage which is paid instead. Chandrakirti pays homage to the root great compassion. This is very profound. Why is this the case?
Why does Chandrakirti pay homage to great compassion? It is because great compassion is not only the cause of bodhicitta and by extension the cause of full enlightenment but because the triplicity of love, empathy and great compassion are also the causes of all the qualities in this world of ours. All of the difficulties which are experienced in this world of ours are due to the absence not merely of altruism but of an empathy and of a love which are focused on others. Then, clearly when we encounter someone who is facing considerable difficulties in this life and who has no connection with the teachings, if we say to this person, you should train in love, compassion and empathy, there may be some personal risk for us. So instead of this, we should realize that some 70% of the difficulties we encounter in this life can be addressed actually by oneself through thinking and effort.
And the remainder are to be addressed through love, kindness and empathy. Then probably if we examine, we can say that none of us experience hardship through strife on a large scale. And therefore, when we speak of hardship in our lives, what exactly is this hardship we refer to? When we get up in the morning, how can we say that we experience hardship in a country like this? Well, if we examine carefully, a fair bit of this comes from lack of contentment.
And lack of contentment in turn gives rise to an absence of love, empathy and compassion for others and out of this arises eventually the cause afflictions, pride, arrogance, anger and so forth. Then we say that the Mahayana is profound and the Walnut is true. If we examine, we can see that, let us say if we take the Four Noble Truths, the Four Noble Truths are common to the path of the being of the middling and of the great scope. But the uncommon specificity of the path of the being of the great scope is love, compassion and bodhicitta. And certainly love and compassion are already in an ordinary form present within our mind streams.
So really the Mahayana from a certain standpoint is very simple. It’s a matter of enhancing preexisting qualities. Love and empathy exist already within our mind streams but their object is ourselves. So really, what is the Mahayana other than changing the object of this love and this empathy from ourselves to others? We can identify that as the Mahayana.
Then when one strives for one’s own liberation as the hearers, the Srivakas or the solitary realized, the Prateka Buddhas do, then obviously one’s object of attainment is liberation. But one is doing this only for oneself, for egotistical purposes. Many majority of those who strive for liberation do not attain it. So if one is striving for liberation for one’s own sake and one doesn’t attain it, one becomes very narrow minded, very small really. And there is in this respect a big difference with the practice of the Mahayana, the great vehicle, where one becomes much more relaxed, much more at ease.
So on the one hand, the object of abandonment of the path of the being of the small scope is the happiness of this life. And that is not easy. It is quite difficult to abandon. Then the object of abandonment of the being of the middling scope is all of psychic existence. One strives for a definite emergence from cyclic existence.
This is even more difficult. Then in this world of ours which is beset by war and violence, the Mahayana which focuses on altruism is extremely important. Then when we speak of altruism, literally in Tibetan, to help others, to benefit others, what do we mean by altruism? Do we refer to charitable actions such as giving others food, clothing, the necessities of life, education and so forth? This is undeniably a component of altruism, but it is not the totality of altruism.
When we refer to benefiting others through altruism, we refer to benefiting their body, their speeches and their minds. And what benefits the mind which is the fundamental form of benefit is bodhicitta. So in addition therefore to helping others with our body and our speech, what is critical is benefiting them with our minds. And this is done through transforming our motivation, through transforming our motivation into one of bodhicitta. At present, our minds are beset by afflictions.
These afflictions arise from within ourselves under exterior influence, and if we lose control of our minds under the power of the afflictions, eventually what happens? We go crazy, we become insane. Then once one is crazy, can one really be said to be a human being anymore? The mind is not dwelling in its natural abode. Craziness, insanity, does not arise in dependence on exterior circumstances.
It arises from within ourselves, independence on uncontrolled afflictions. Do you understand? And if you have understood, you can abandon. Then, if we try to benefit others through our wealth, through giving them the financial means to take care of themselves. That may or may not be of help to them.
But what is really of help is if we are able to transform the way we think. And if we do this, from one, on the one hand, it is not something which is that difficult to do. It is certainly not expensive, it doesn’t cost us anything. But on the other hand, even though we don’t have to experience the hardship of cold, of heat and so forth to do this, we must study, we must understand how to do it. Then obviously when we generate such a state of mind, it will stop the afflictions.
It will not stop them permanently because we will not have abandoned the root which gives rise to the afflictions, but it will stop them temporarily. And then, obviously, we have to meditate. But meditating on the mode of abiding of this life is difficult. Then we do have love and empathy within our mind stream, so we have something to build with. But when it comes to the view, the view which understands or realizes emptiness, That is another story altogether, we don’t have and the even though we use the word emptiness, we don’t have a clue what it means.
What emptiness means from the prasanika standpoint that phenomena mere nominal designations is something we do not begin to understand. Then it is remarkable, it is extraordinary to think about a topic like this but for beginners like ourselves it is very difficult. Then in brief, the practice of the being of the middling scope is none other than having generated definite emergence to strive to eliminate the object of abandonment which is none other than the vanities of these aggregates. The vanities or the appearances of these aggregates, these contaminated aggregates, this is something which is very difficult to abandon. So our topic is at present the path of the being of the great scope.
And here we must identify the object of attainment of the path of the being of the great scope. What prevents this attainment and what the means are to gain such an attainment. Now for instance, if we take the path of the being of the middling scope, we covered last year, then the object of attainment is liberation. The means for this attainment are the path, the noble truth of the path, and the object of abandonment are the afflictions and ignorance which grasp at itself. In other words, the four truths, the four noble truths are intricately woven in the path of the being of the middling scope.
So, now, you probably know the object of attainment of the path of the being of the small scope, so please give it to me now. Small scope. Object of attainment. Object of attainment. Small scope.
Scope. Yeah yeah. That’s good. What’s the means? Means?
What’s the object of abandonment? You could also give the 10 non virtuous deeds since its practice is an ethics which trains at the 10 virtuous deeds. It’s the same thing. So what’s the object of attainment of the path of the being of the middling scope? So what are the means to attain such liberation?
The noble truth of the path. If you say the four truths, it’s a bit strange. What you can say is it is a practice of the four noble truths. But if you say the four noble truths, that means that the noble truths of suffering and of the origin of suffering are objects of attainment which they aren’t. You’re doing quite well of you, all of you.
You get a bit mixed up sometimes. Then the precise answer is that the object of attainment of the path of the middling scope is the noble truth of cessation. The means is the noble truth of the path and the object of abandonment are the two noble truths of suffering and of the origin of suffering. In brief, we are speaking of cyclic existence and nirvana. Nirvana is the object of attainment, cyclic existence is the object of abandonment.
Now, what is the object of attainment of the path of the being of the great scope? What does it means for attaining this object of attainment? Specifically, the union of method and wisdom. However, both wisdom and method are necessary. Thank you.
What’s the object of abandonment? Now there is a reason for which we should engage in this training where we appropriate dharma and we try to abandon the non virtues. And this is because once we understand that the abandonment of self cherishing and the training in altruism give rise to gives rise to immeasurable roots of virtue, we will wish to do so. Then there is a reason for which virtues which are upheld by bodhicitta are continuous and immeasurable in their result. And this is a case because the mind of bodhicitta is a mind which focuses on infinite sentient beings in number, the sentient beings of the future, the present and the past.
Now sentient beings do not dwindle in number. We see in this world of us, human beings seem to constantly be increasing in number. So when a mind focuses on an infinite object like that, the virtue arised or arisen through depending on such a mind becomes infinite as well. Now this is very different from the virtue accrued by the hearers or the solitary realizers who are focused only on their own liberation. Their virtue has completed its function once they attain the state of an Arhat.
However, the virtues accrued to bodhicitta remain until one attains full enlightenment. Then Mahayana, the great vehicle arises from compassion and altruism. What do we mean when we refer to the Mahayana? This book for instance, Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand is not the Mahayana. It’s a book therefore it’s matter, it’s an object.
So what is the Mahayana? Mahayana is something which is upheld within our own minds. As Lamrim Chenmo says, it is not the dharma which has to be the Mahayana, it is the practitioner who has to be a Mahayanist. So as Lamrim Jemos says, it is not the dharma which has to be Mahayana dharma, it is the practitioner who has to be a Mahayana practitioner. Whatever a Mahayana practitioner practices becomes the practice of a bodhisattva.
Then, as the Mahayana Rimchenmo says, ideally, one has generated uncontrived bodhicitta. If one has not generated that, then one should have generated contrived bodhicitta and if not that, at least a familiarity with bodhicitta. Then we say the Mahayana exists, but what do we mean by that? The criterion for the existence of the Mahayana is the existence of love, of compassion and of Bodhicitta. Love, compassion and Bodhicitta are consciousnesses, they are states of mind.
They are by definition subsumed within our continuum. How do we know whether these states of mind exist or not within the continuum of another? It is extremely important for us to understand that the distinction between the great vehicle and the lesser or the small vehicle is not made in terms of the view. It is made in terms of behavior. The distinction between the Shravakas, the Prateka Buddhas and the Bodhisattvas is not made in terms of the view emptiness, it is made in terms of whether or not bodhicitta is present.
Previously I explained in great detail the distinction between a Hinayanist and a propounder of Hinayana views. We shall not enter in that again. But at present, in the context of the explanation of the Mahayana, I would like to clarify the important distinction between a Mahayanaist and a propounder of Mahayana views. Have you understood the difference between a being who is a Mahayana practitioner or a Mahayanist and a propounder of Mahayana tenets? Yeah, you know, didn’t give up.
Yeah, I think Lily, can you? So what’s the distinction between a Mahayana person or being and a propounder of Mahayana tenets? So focus, the Mahayana person is a person who has generated bodhicitta within their mind stream. A propounder of Mahayana tenets is either a Chitamatra or a Madhyamika. A propounder of Chitamatra or Madhyamika tenets.
It is not the case that if one is a Chitamatra or a Madhyamika, in other words a propounder of Mahayana tenets, one is necessarily a person who is a Mahayanist or a Mahayana being. Okay, do you understand? So I explained this already but maybe you got mixed up. So in the context of generating the motivation, let us reflect on the importance of generating a motivation of altruism and understand that even though benefiting others physically or verbally is important, nonetheless, the most important is our attitude or our motivation and try to generate such a motivation For a couple of minutes. Over to favorite page one.
We recite one b two three four and the page five, number six, Mandal offering, verse one and three. Even though at present we have reached the topic of the path of the being of the great scope, nonetheless, I will continue to ask you periodically questions on the paths shared with the being of the small and the middling scope which we have already covered, just to keep them in your minds and to strengthen your memory. Now, don’t think that there is only one path, one object of abandonment let us say of the path shared with the being of the small scope. There are numerous objects of abandonment, but even though the names differ, their meaning is one and the same. For instance, if we take the path shared with the being of the middling scope, some of you have said that its object of abandonment is cyclic existence.
That is true. But you could also say its object of abandonment is the first two truths. The noble truth of suffering and the origin of suffering, that is also true. You could also say its object of abandonment is the ignorance which grasps at itself. These objects of abandonment are not mutually contradictory.
Then an alternate presentation of the object of abandonment which is extremely important is that the object of abandonment of the path shared with the being of the small scope is grasping at one’s permanence. The object of abandonment shared with the being of the middling scope is grasping at a self. And the object of abandonment shared with, or the object of the uncommon object of abandonment of the being of the great scope is self cherishing. So at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope, it is precisely because of grasping at our own permanence that we are unable to understand that we shall not dwell in this life for long and it is as a result of this that we are unable to train in contentment. At the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope, it is precisely because of the ignorance grasping at a self that we accumulate non virtuous karma under the power of affliction such as desire and anger and transmigrating cyclic existence.
Now the main object of abandonment at the level of the path of the being of the great scope is self cherishing. It is under the power of self cherishing that we relinquish and abandon others. Self cherishing is present within arhats when they attain the state of an Arhat. Now the criterion for being a Mahayana being or a Mahayana practitioner is a presence or the absence of bodhicitta. Bodhicitta’s main cause is great compassion.
The question or the doubt which arises then is whether great compassion can be present in a being who is not a Mahayana practitioner and if so, this is a little bit odd. So this is a topic we’ll have to study and reflect carefully about. So the way one should study is the following. One should ask oneself, well, we posit Bodhicitta as the criterion for being a Mahayana person, a Mahayana being. But why precisely wouldn’t great compassion be the criterion for being a Mahayana practitioner?
What difference is there and why? And when one thinks in this way, one expands greatly the scope of one’s understanding. So here when we speak of a great compassion, we are not speaking of mere empathy. We are speaking of a compassion which extends to all sentient beings and for instance, to all 7,000,000,000 or so human beings. This is not limited to the mere empathy which is partial and focused on oneself.
Instead, such an empathy is focused outwards on all beings. To generate a great compassion or an uncontrived empathy which wishes spontaneously to free all sentient beings from suffering and here suffering does not refer only to physical suffering but to mental suffering as well, which is the worst suffering. The cause for such a great compassion must be present. And its uncommon cause is an uncontrived definite emergence or an uncontrived renunciation which wishes to be freed from cyclic existence. As is said, without focusing on the faults of the noble truths of suffering and of the origin of suffering, how can the mind striving for liberation arise.
Therefore, one should initially focus on the thoughts of these contaminated aggregates. And once an uncontrived, in other words, an unfabricated mind, which is striving for liberation from these contaminated aggregates has arisen, then such a mind is an uncontrived definite emergence. At this point, one will have fully entered the path of the being of the middling scope. And here one must examine carefully what the boundary with the path of the being of the great scope is. So at present, once one has generated such an uncontrived renunciation, such an uncontrived definite emergence, one must be very careful and very wary.
Because if one has not repeatedly become familiar with altruism, at this point, there is a very high risk of engaging in the Hinayana and of striving for liberation for one’s own sake. If one strives for liberation for one’s own sake, eventually one will attain the state of an Arhat or a foe destroyer. And in such a state, there is no suffering whatsoever. There is profound peace and happiness to the very depths of the mind. One does not need to eat, one does not need to drink, one experiences neither the suffering of heat nor of cold, one is in a constant state of bliss.
It is then very difficult to leave the state and enter the So I shall stop here for today. We shall take questions at present. I have a question from Chris. Geshela said that the way one passed from the middling scope into the great scope was to reflect on the causes of the afflictions and to realize that their cause was self cherishing. If this was the case, why wouldn’t all those seeking liberation come to this conclusion?
Clearly they do not. Would it not be logical to say that it’s only via the ripening of previous seeds of compassion when confronted with the cooperative condition of the suffering of another that one realizes that eliminating self grasping for oneself has in fact given rise to self cherishing? So perhaps the doubt is, as Geshela explained, that when one has generated uncontrived or unfabricated definite emergence, one has not technically yet entered the path. And as a result of this, it is only when independence on this definite emergence one generates in addition the strong wish to attain liberation for one’s own sake that one will enter the paths of the hearers or the Pratyaka Buddhas. It is not sufficient for a being, let us say, who has entered the path shared with the beings of the middling scope to understand the faults of self cherishing and to understand the qualities of altruism and bodhicitta for such a being to as such have entered the path of the being of the great scope.
For instance, now all of us understand the force of self cherishing and we understand the qualities of bodhicitta, but we have not entered the path of the being of the great scope. And Nada? I kind of do not think that contrived and uncontrived renunciation, it is a zero or one scale. I kind of think the contrived renunciation should be, say, from zero to a 100. So for example, as one subdues more and more afflictions, subdue coarse afflictions, subdue less coarse afflictions, then the scale of uncontrolled renunciation should be higher and higher.
That’s my understanding. So yes, as one relinquishes the afflictions, one moves further and further away from cyclic existence. So is it possible to say focus more on the process of subduing the afflictions more and more? Because I kind of think that focusing on making progress is more encouraging than always thinking that I cannot attain uncontrollable renunciation. I cannot attain uncontrollable renunciation.
This is very depressive. Yes, that’s a very good point. And that is why in the great treatises, the object of attainment is always presented first. And then when we study the object of attainment, in turn aspiration arises. Independence and aspiration faith.
And then independence on faith eventually through effort, appliances arises. When pliancy arises, then there is no difficulty whatsoever in the practice. Karen? I heard at the beginning of the teachings, Geshela say that if someone hasn’t received teachings, it may be a risk to give them love, compassion and empathy and so to instead give love, kindness and empathy. Can you explain the difference between compassion and kindness?
Compassion and? Kindness. So the difference between compassion and empathy is basically non existent. It is pretty much one and the same thing. There is however a big difference between great compassion and empathy.
In our minds at present we have compassion, we have empathy, but they are partial, they are biased compassion or empathy. Great compassion is unbiased, impartial. And another question? Sorry. This is a really stupid question.
But so is liberation is only attain is only attained by hearers and solitary real realizers and is then never attained or aspired to by Mahayana beings whose aim is full enlightenment for sentient beings. No, the bodhisattvas are beings who strive for liberation just as hearers and solitary realizers. They do not strive however principally for liberation even though they strive for liberation which is an abandonment of the afflictions. Unlike hearers and solitary realizers which strive principally for liberation. Just one question.
About the propound bodhicitta and the practice is it practice bodhicitta? I did not hear the first Propounder, you know, like you you say before, you know, in the Propounder of Mahayana Tenets? Yes. Yes. And Mahayana.
So, the difference is as follows, a Mahayana being or a Mahayanist is someone who has generated bodhicitta within their continuum. A propounder of Mahayana tenets is someone who subscribes either to the Chitamatra or the Madhyamika system of tenets. Someone who subscribes either to the Chitamatra or the Madhyamika system of tenets is not necessarily a Mahayana being or a bodhisattva. Because there are Chitamatras who are hearers. Yet.
Why are the propounders of Mahayana tenets Chitamatra and Mariamika? Only. Only. Only. Because there are no propounders of tenets who are not either Chitamatras or Madhyamikas, that’s what there is.
Then I’ve given you the reason. The Chita mantra, which country practice this? The Chitamatra view originated in India and then it spread to China, to Japan, to Vietnam, to Korea. It’s dominant view of Buddhism in all those countries. Then the view in all the Buddhism of those countries, Vietnamese Buddhism and so forth is Chitamatra.
Okay. Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.