Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2016-04-05 – KR.mp3
UUID: bbca7b78-af62-4785-98f5-932169a8e68b
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Emptiness (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2016-04-05
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 3m
Words: 2,800
So there was one point I did not mention last week regarding the course on Salamu Grounds in Paris. We mentioned that there would be an exam concluding the course. What I did not mention is that if there are among you those who are unable to sit the exam, then you can attend the class as auditors and just listen to the class without sitting the exam. Generally speaking, exams are a way to study in-depth to stabilize what has studied, what one has studied in one’s mind. If one sits an exam, then one will have to study much more seriously and one will remember what one has studied.
Generally speaking therefore an exam is a means to study and His Holiness the Dalai Lama and Khensur Kangaroo Lingpoche both said many times in this temple that the reason for which this center exists is study. These 10 grounds are specific to the Mahayana. There is no real explanation of the 10 grounds in the Hinayana or the paths of hearers and solitary realizers. So what specifically are the 10 grounds ranging from the first ground, the extremely joyful to the tenth ground, the cloud of dharma. In brief, these are levels at which the power of the antidotes to counter the innate self grasping or the innate grasping at an I with which we have been habituated since beginningless time increases again and again.
Now when we speak of the powerful antidote in this context, what is this powerful antidote to the innate sense of grasp, self grasping? It is none other than the wisdom realizing emptiness. Here, it is not sufficient to have a familiarity with emptiness. It is not sufficient to have ascertained emptiness. These will not enable us to abandon the afflictions within our mind stream.
One must distinguish between the wisdom arisen from hearing, from thinking and from meditating. Initially one generates a wisdom arisen from hearing regarding emptiness. Independence on this, one generates a wisdom arisen from thinking regarding emptiness, which still cannot abandon the afflictions. Finally, independence on this with great habituation one generates a wisdom arisen from meditation which can begin to abandon the afflictions. Generally speaking, when we refer to a realization of emptiness by means of a valid cognizer, this occurs at the level of the wisdom arisen from thinking.
In other words, within the three wisdoms, the wisdom arisen from hearing, thinking and meditation, it occurs at the second level, the wisdom arisen from thinking. Now this is something which calls for great effort. At present, we do not have it. It is only with great effort something like this can be obtained. This realization of emptiness by means of a valid cognizer in and of itself is insufficient to lead to the abandonment of the afflictions or to the abandonment of the innate sense of self grasping.
Since such a, an experience of emptiness by means of a valid cognizer can already be present within beings who have not entered the path. So what is necessary to begin to abandon the afflictions and to abandon innate self grasping? What is necessary is an experience of emptiness arisen from meditation. So, how can we therefore abandon the afflictions and abandon innate self grasping? It is only through great familiarity with emptiness.
As the antidote, the mind realizing emptiness increases in its power, that which is being abandoned, the innate apprehension of the self dwindles in power until eventually progressing up through all the ground, one reaches the tenth ground. So as you remember from the presentation of the 37 facets of enlightenment over the long Easter weekend, within the seven fold subdivision of the 37 facets, we have the five powers. The five powers are present at the level of the path of seeing and it is when the five powers are generated that one begins to abandon the afflictions. The stages before the generation of the five powers are stages in which afflictions within the mind stream of such beings are akin to those within our mind streams. So this treaties of grounds and paths by Jason Chugi Guilty is actually written from the standpoint of the Svatantrika Madhyamika School of Tenets.
There are some slight differences in the presentation of the paths with grounds and paths from the standpoint of the Prasangika Madhyamika School of Tenets. And since we ourselves are more familiar with Prasangika Madhyamika and study it in the context of lamrim, it seems more relevant to explain it. So now at present, it is important that you have a clear understanding of the meaning, in other words of the definition of a path and retain it in your minds. So today, our main focus will be the meaning of the definition of a path. As you remember, the definition of a path is a sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived definite emergence.
Now if we analyze this definition, it has two parts. The first is sapience and the second is which is upheld by uncontrived renunciation. That second part which is upheld by uncontrived renunciation is a genitive in Tibetan and here indicates the agent that in other words which performs the deed. So we should therefore familiarize our mind with the definition of a path as a sapience which is upheld by uncontrived renunciation. So within the definition of a path, a sapience which is upheld by a sort of uncontrived definite emergence.
What is meant by uncontrived? Uncontrived here refers to unfabricated from within the fabricated and unfabricated. And the meaning is therefore that we should rely on such an unfabricated renunciation or definite emergence. So when we speak of definite emergence on Nianjung in Tibetan, it is definite emergence from what? What is the base in other words we emerge from?
The base is cyclic existence or if you prefer are contaminated aggregates or body would be an instance of that. So when we speak of samsara, cyclic existence of Korwa in Tibet and the wheel and we try to identify what is it. It is our contaminated aggregates, if you wish our body and mind. So when we say that one must emerge from psychic existence, one must initially understand the defects of the force of psychic existence and for this one must study and receive teachings. So when these aggregates are created from the instant of their establishment or their creation, we experience suffering.
This is probably self evident to all of us. And when we refer to the four sufferings, the sufferings of birth, of aging, of sickness and death, all four are intimately related to our aggregates. Birth probably do not remember, but aging is definitely related to the transformation of the aggregates. Sickness is intimately related to the aggregates and death is the end of the aggregates. So these sufferings are clearly explained in the lumbrim and I encourage you to refer to the lamrim and they are evident in our own experience.
If we take the suffering of old age for instance, it is obvious in conversation that people experience the suffering of old age. When we ask someone how old are you, either they don’t want to answer or even they give the wrong answer. Sometimes they even lie about their age. So clearly the suffering of old age is intimately related to the body. Since our age is an imputation on the basis of the form aggregate or the body.
It is on the basis of the process of transformation of the form aggregate that we say we ourselves are older or younger. Then regarding the suffering of death, all of us are aware of the fact we will die but we are profoundly uncomfortable with the notion and that is a suffering of death. So when we are able to generate a state of mind which thinks, why shouldn’t I be free of these contaminated aggregates and the state of mind is stable, then we have generated uncontrived renunciation. Let’s take an example. Let us imagine that we have fallen in a huge river or expanse of water and we have some ten minutes before we drown.
Then obviously, we will strive ceaselessly during those ten minutes to find a way out of the water. Likewise, a mind, a state of or a thought of uncontrived definite emergence arises when a continuous striving to be freed from the contaminated aggregates occurs. So I have given you an example for a thought of uncontrived definite emergence and I would like you to reflect on the meaning of the example and how it is related to the topic and bring this in your mind. So I would like you to try to imagine how you would feel, not how someone else would feel but how you would feel if you had fallen into a huge tumultuous river and were going to almost certain death. You would be desperate to escape from the water and you would experience great fear, wouldn’t you?
Now obviously this does not resonate in us if we apply these examples to other people who don’t really concern us, but it is our own predicament. This is how one feels when one generates uncontrived definite emergence. Now the example given the Lamrim is somewhat different. It is that of a person who is trapped in a burning house and all the exits are closed wherever they look there is only fire. So in the definition of a path, a sapience which is upheld by a thought of uncontrived renunciation as we said there are two parts.
The first is a sapience which is upheld. The second, by a thought of uncontrived renunciation. So here by a thought of uncontrived renunciation functions as an agent. In other words, this is the actor, the actor of what? The actor which gives rise to a sapience.
And a sapience here just means a consciousness which understands something. Well, do you understand? I have explained what a sort of uncontrived renunciation is. Now we talk about the sapience which is upheld by that. Do you understand?
That’s good. So once we reflect in this way on definite emergence, we should ask ourselves well how precisely do we get free from these contaminated aggregates and to get free from these contaminated aggregates does not mean to chop off bits of our body. All that will happen is we will die and we will still not be free of the contaminated aggregates. Instead, as is explained in the Lamrim, we are bound to psychic existence by the fetters of karma and affliction. So here the contaminated aggregates rest or rely upon the afflictions.
There is an intimate relationship between them. If we do not eliminate what the contaminated aggregates rest upon, it will be impossible in turn to eliminate them. Therefore, we must eliminate the afflictions. So what precisely is the root of these afflictions from within afflictions in karma? The root is the innate apprehension of a self.
It is this innate apprehension of a self or of an I which gives rise to the desire for what is close to us and the anger towards what is removed from us or hostile to us and independence on this all the afflictions such as desire, jealousy, anger and so forth arise. So at present, all of these afflictions are present within our mind stream. What is not present within our mind stream? The wisdom realizing emptiness. We have heard teachings on this, we may have some wisdom arisen from thinking, but we do not have the wisdom arisen from meditating.
Now, the wisdom, which realizes emptiness is the antidote, the powerful antidote to the ignorance which grasps at the self, simply because their modes of apprehension are different. By modes of apprehension, we mean their way of thinking. In other words, as the wisdom which realizes selflessness increases in power or potency, in turn, the ignorance which grasps at itself decreases until eventually it will cease. When it ceases, one has attained liberation. So as we apply the wisdom which realizes emptiness to our mind stream, progressively the ignorance which grasps at a self will decrease in power.
It will continue decreasing until it is extinguished. This extinction corresponds to the application of the 12 limbs of dependent origination in the reverse sequence. Having eliminated the first of these 12 limbs, we will have eliminated the afflictions which arise in dependency on this. And therefore, through familiarity with emptiness, we will eventually generate a definiteness regarding emptiness, which leads to a valid cognition realizing emptiness and eventually leads to an extinction, which is an extinction of the afflictions and is none other than liberation. Therefore, through becoming repeatedly familiar with emptiness, eventually we will generate a valid cognizer of emptiness and independence on this valid cognizer, we will gain a realization of emptiness which will lead to the progressive extinction of the ignorance which apprehends or grasps at a self.
Once this has happened, we will have generated a valid cognizer ascertaining liberation. And not just any valid cognizer ascertaining liberation, but a valid cognizer ascertaining liberation motivated or impelled by renunciation or definite emergence. This is what is referred to as a sapience, which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence. So let us take the following example. Let us imagine that someone, let us say we ourselves have fallen in a great river and are facing imminent drowning.
And when the fear of death overwhelms us, someone on the shore, a savior extends a staff or throws us a rope. And thanks to this staff or this rope, we are saved from the roaring river. At the point when we land ashore and we think I am saved from the roaring river, I am liberated. This corresponds to the generation of a valid cognizer realizing liberation, independence on an uncontrived thought of definite emergence. So now in the context of generating the motivation, let us reflect on three subdivisions of this issue or this topic of the path.
Within the definition of the path as a sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence. Let us first reflect on a sapience which is upheld. Secondly, by an uncontrived sort of definite emergence and thirdly, if we can because it is important, let us reflect on emptiness. Then during a couple of minutes, let us meditate on this. Please open the pre book page one.
We recite 1b, two, three, four and page five, number six, number three. So if you have questions regarding what we talked about tonight, I will take one question, only one question and after that there is discussion. Geshela, could I just clarify please? I think you said the 10 Mahayana grounds but in the reading it speaks of two bodhisatt for ordinary being grounds and 10 bodhisatt for superior grounds. So are there 10 or are there 12?
Sorry, in our system, the article we had it says there are two bodies sat for ordinary being grounds, the path of accumulation, the path of preparation and then from the path of seeing 10 body sat for superior. I kept rereading it because I wasn’t It’s probably inappropriate to refer to path such as a path of accumulation or preparation as grounds. Grounds only exist from the path of seeing onwards. Then another question. Yes, one question.
You mentioned that wisdom on emptiness can arise from hearing and thinking. What is the obstacle to the experience of that? Is it purely a lack of habit or habituation, or is it Geshela referred to with the fear of death? What is exactly the obstacle to stop us from going to hearing and thinking into experience? So probably that the wisdom realizing emptiness based on hearing is present within the mind stream of most of us who have received teachings.
As to the wisdom arisen from thinking for that to be present a valid cognizer realizing emptiness must be present. And for this to be present, whatever we look at, whatever we experience, even though it appears to us as existing inherently and from its own side, we should automatically and regularly think it does not exist in this way. So at present, we will have debate or discussion by pairs as usual on the topic which was covered tonight. In other words, the definition or the meaning of a path, a sapience which is upheld by a thought of uncontrived renunciation, analyze the meaning of the definition and the meaning of its two components. The first, a sapience which is upheld.
The second, by a thought of uncontrived renunciation. Then by pairs. Yeah.
Key terms in this teaching
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- five powers
- The five practices to be applied in this life and near the time of death. LYWA
- grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
- Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
- The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.