Awakening Heart — 2014-04-30

1 h 31 min · 3,628 words · 30 April 2014 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart — 2014-04-30
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 91-minute teaching, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen explores the inextinguishable fruits of bodhicitta by contrasting it with other virtuous practices, drawing on Śāntideva’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara. He clarifies that bodhicitta—the aspiration to achieve enlightenment for the benefit of all beings—is the defining characteristic of Mahāyāna practice, whereas the results of other virtues eventually exhaust themselves. The teaching then shifts to examining what qualifies as genuine Dharma practice, emphasizing that only mental virtue acts as a counter to afflictions and the deep-rooted misperception of permanence. Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen spends considerable time on meditation on death and impermanence, presenting practical analytical approaches: meditating on the uncertainty of life span, reflecting on dangers during daily activities like driving, and understanding how such reflection reorients priorities toward future lives. He concludes by stressing that pure Dharma practice requires genuine renunciation of preoccupation with this life’s concerns. A Q&A session follows, addressing the relationship between physical restraint and liberation, the nature of contrived versus uncontrived bodhicitta, and Tonglen practice.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2014-04-30 – KR.mp3

UUID: f01f1220-3977-40ea-adb8-1a849119c483

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Awakening Heart

Date: 2014-04-30

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~3,633

As you said in Śāntideva’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara, whereas the results of other virtues are eventually extinguished, the result of bodhicitta is inextinguishable. This is a very profound passage, its meaning is as follows: in the case of virtues which are accrued for one’s own sake such as wishing for a higher rebirth, this virtue is exhausted or terminated when it gives rise to its effect, in other words attaining a higher rebirth. Likewise, if for one’s own benefit alone, one strives to attain, for instance, the state of an Arhat or nirvana, then once one has attained the state of an Arhat, that virtue has reached its completion and there will be no other results beyond that. bodhicitta, on the other hand, is an extremely extensive wavelike vast intent. On the other hand, the roots of virtue which are held by bodhicitta are inextinguishable since they do not cease upon the attainment of full enlightenment.

Far from there, the attainment of full enlightenment is only the beginning of the results of these roots of virtue which are actual cause of the attainment of all of the grounds and paths by the trainees which are subdued by the fully enlightened being after that. Let alone uncontrived bodhicitta, even the generation of contrived bodhicitta is an extraordinary state of mind. The criterion distinguishing the Hīnayāna from the Mahāyāna is the presence or the absence of bodhicitta. Whichever practice of Dharma is upheld by bodhicitta becomes thereby a practice of the Mahāyāna, otherwise not. For instance, the Four Noble Truths are foundational for both the Hīnayāna and the Mahāyāna.

If they are engaged in in the light of bodhicitta, they become Mahāyāna, otherwise not. As a quote from Śāntideva’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara indicates, even the practice of the ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non-virtues becomes Mahāyāna practice if bodhicitta is present. The distinction between Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna is a distinction from the standpoint of the method aspect of the path. It is contingent on whether bodhicitta is present or not. If bodhicitta is present, a practice becomes Mahāyāna, if it is not present, it is of the Hīnayāna.

Now, as far as these schools of tenets are considered, this is a distinction which is made from the standpoint of the view. And there are both Mahāyāna schools of tenets and Hīnayāna schools of tenets. However, someone who belongs to a Hīnayāna school of tenets is not necessarily a Hinayanist, there are Mahāyāna practitioners who subscribe to the Hīnayāna view. Likewise, someone who belongs to the Mahāyāna schools of tenets is not necessarily a Mahayanaist. There are Hīnayāna, Shravakas and Pratyekabuddha who subscribe to the Mahāyāna view.

This is an important distinction. Now we always instruct the students to generate the motivation at the beginning of the teachings. What does one mean by generating the motivation? It refers to generating bodhicitta. In our case, probably nobody has uncontrived bodhicitta and it is open to question whether somebody has contrived bodhicitta.

But this is what we must try to generate. Then in our cases, when we are instructed to generate a motivation of bodhicitta, what is meant is that we should think a bit about bodhicitta, think in other words about its nature and its benefit. Then we if we think a bit about bodhicitta, eventually through familiarity we can get a taste of contrived, fabricated bodhicitta. This is already quite an extraordinary experience. Then in our cases, what should we do?

We should generate the motivation, resolve not to allow our body, speech and mind to fall under the sway of the three poisons for the rest of our life, for the next years, for the next months, for the next weeks, for the next day. Then ideally, we would meditate on this for one hour, but since that seems unpractical, a couple of minutes will suffice. Then on this basis of the resolve not to allow our body, speech and mind to fall under the sway of these three poisons, we then generate the wish to benefit others. In other words, bodhicitta. And with this as a wish, we then try to listen for one hour or so to these teachings.

Then if we proceed in this way, this motivation will be somewhat weighty. It is therefore critical after the six preliminary practices to engage in the practice of the Lamrim since we now have the opportunity to do so. Now generally speaking indeed the Lamrim is Mahāyāna Dharma, but as was explained previously, whether a Dharma is in effect Mahāyāna or not is contingent on the motivation with which one practices it. Therefore, if through the previously explained reflections, one can generate some sort of a feeling for bodhicitta, then that will eventually lead to contrived bodhicitta. Then through the practice of Dharma, indisputably roots of virtue will arise.

Whether these roots of virtue are directed to full enlightenment or not is contingent on whether the motivation of bodhicitta has been created or not. Alternatively, should one’s focus be the attainment of liberation for one’s own self as long as the motivation is a motivation of uncontrived renunciation or probably of contrived renunciation as well, one’s roots of virtue will lead to the attainment of liberation. At the minimum, one’s roots of virtue should be dedicated to attaining a higher rebirth in future lives. And just as well, for this to happen, these roots of virtue must be subtended either by an uncontrived motivation wishing for a higher rebirth in future lives or at the very least by a contrived motivation wishing for higher rebirth in a future life. Then as to this Dharma of the practice of which we speak, this is a difficult topic.

What is Dharma? Virtue in and of itself may or may not be Dharma, there is no certainty. For instance, those of us who engage in debate assert that everything which is dharma is necessarily virtuous, but not everything which is virtuous is necessarily dharma. Then it is open to debate whether virtues of body and of speech which are undeniably virtues are Dharma or not. For instance, the abstention from the 10 non virtuous deeds is virtue, whether it is Dharma or not is another question.

Then when we say to practice Dharma and that one must practice Dharma, one is referring to mental virtue and the practice of mental restraint. Then, since it is mental virtues which are Dharma, we have to see whether there is any Dharma at all within ourselves or not. I cannot say. You yourself should examine yourself. You will know.

For instance, just reciting commitments is difficult to consider as dharma. Then when we say that Dharma are mental virtues, what we mean specifically is that Dharma are the antidotes which are applied to the afflictions. Then we obviously have the right to think that we practice Dharma, but we must examine what the so called Dharma practice is. If it acts as a counter to the afflictions within our mind, then it is Dharma. Otherwise, if it is a cause of some higher rebirth, that’s another question.

As our holy teacher, Khensur Rinpoche Kangurwa Rinchen said, and this is a very important point, physical and verbal virtues will not act as the cause of liberation. It is only mental virtues which will act as the cause of liberation. Therefore, strive at these. Then what criteria should dharma satisfy to be called dharma? Not only should it act as a counter to the afflictions, but in addition it should act as a counter to the apprehension of our own permanence, which is something with which all of us without exception are afflicted.

All of us without exception have been afflicted for a long time by this apprehension of our permanence. This deep rooted conviction that we will be around for a long time. Something becomes dharma when it acts as a counter and destroys this. What is the dharma which acts as an antidote to the apprehension of our permanence? It is the dharma on death and impermanence.

Death and impermanence. And when we say death and impermanence, the first syllable chiwa, death, was qualified by Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen Rinpoche as the means of passing to the future. This is quite elegant, isn’t it? And as Je Tsongkhapa said, as Je Tsongkhapa said, if you do not reflect on death and impermanence, you shall not engage in virtuous practice. Albeit you were to do so, it will not be long-lasting.

There it is said in the Lamrim that there is no Dharma which is more important and more profound than the meditations on death and impermanence, nothing is more beneficial. The practice of meditation on death and impermanence is divided into two, practice during the session and practice between meditative sessions. It is actually during the period between meditative sessions that we will know whether the key points of the practice during meditative sessions has been accomplished or not. If indeed between meditative sessions, we refuse to engage in non virtue, even the slightest non virtue such as stepping on an insect, then indeed, we will have accomplished meditation on death and impermanence. As Lama Tsongkhapa says in The Foundation of All Good Qualities, since sin follows us from life to life like shadow follows the body, relinquish, forswear engaging even in the slightest non-virtue.

Once one has understood that sin will follow us like the shadow follows our body, then one will forcefully forsake engaging in the slightest non-virtue such as stepping on an insect. What is the method for meditating on death and impermanence? Here, when we refer to meditation on death and impermanence, it is to meditation on coarse impermanence, not on subtle impermanence. Then through repeated habituation, such experience will arise. Then if we analyze, this will become clear.

If you’re a literate person for instance, do you sincerely believe that you could sign a written statement guaranteeing that you would still be alive next year? If you think carefully, you cannot sign such a statement. Then could you sign such a statement guaranteeing that you would be alive next month? It’s difficult, could you sign such a statement guaranteeing that you will be alive next week? It’s difficult, Could you sign such a statement guaranteeing that you will be alive in twenty four hours time at five 06:00 tomorrow evening?

If you think carefully you cannot sign such a statement. So yes or no. All of us are convinced that we will die, it is a truism. Yet in the very innermost reaches of our being lies this apprehension of our own permanence, which is convinced that tomorrow I will not die, next month I will not die, next year I will not die, and this is what prevents us from practicing pure Dharma. Then if one can think about this for fifteen minutes or so, it is very helpful, otherwise if one has time for half an hour or one hour is even more helpful.

I’m sure you have the time. Who doesn’t have time to do something like this? You must read the Lamrim. You must initially have the wisdom arisen from hearing. How on earth can that arise if you don’t read the Lamrim?

Then after this, you must reflect on it. There are numerous presentations of the path of the being of the small scope in a variety of Lamrims. The presentation and liberation in the palm of your hand is excellent. Read this over and again and then venture in the other Lamrims. As the holy being said, we must give rise to the feeling, tomorrow I will die.

This is very profound advice, we should give rise to the feeling akin to tomorrow I shall die. And a second part of this advice is, as far as study is concerned, we should give rise to the feeling I shall be around for a long time. These two verses are very profound. Give rise to the feeling, Tomorrow I will die, and study as if you will be here for a long time. Then think over this again and again and try to accomplish the welfare of a large number of human beings.

Then these reflections on opposing your signature to a statement that you will be still alive tomorrow are very profound. If we think about it, what guarantee do we have when we go to sleep that we will rise the next day? After all, we are in a state akin to death for several hours, and many things could happen. A criminal could break in the house, for instance, and kill us. These things happen.

If you think like this, there’s a great benefit for your mind. Then at the end of this teaching, I will stay here and you will all return to your homes by car. Then when one drives, many things can happen. You yourselves can make a mistake driving and kill yourself. Even if you are careful drivers, there are many drunk drivers on the road, you may encounter them and through no fault of your own you may also be killed.

Think about this, this is very helpful for the mind. And think about these lines of reasoning again and again, the more you think about them, the more helpful they will be for your minds. Don’t waste your time and your lives. And then if you think about this a lot, you will want to practice Dharma carefully. Then regarding past and future lives, irrespective of whether there have been or not past lives, for sure there will be future lives.

And karma and causality is operational whether you believe in it or not. If one thinks in these ways, then the next world, future lives become more and more important and this world, this life becomes less and less important with its enjoyments. Then, for future lives, there’s really only two options. There are happy rebirths and lower rebirths. Then if we want to be reborn in the happy rebirths, we must accumulate good causes, worthy causes, and these good causes are virtue.

Once we start thinking about this, we will wish to engage in these practices and once we realize that there is no 100% certainty that we will be there tomorrow, we would want to engage in these practices now. It is through thinking that we will live for a long time, that in turn we feel we need the necessities for life and we start working. Once we start working, we are beset by all sorts of fancies and conceptions, and as a result of this, the three poisons increase in their power. Then, when we focus mainly on future lives, our contentment with whatever happiness we can get in this life will increase. As our contentment increases, our fancies and conceptions will dwindle.

And we have at present reached the third outline of liberation in the palm of your hand, how to practice Dharma purely. The pure practice of Dharma is contingent on whether or not we have given up the vanities of this life. If we have given up the vanities of this life, we can practice Dharma purely, otherwise not. When it is said to practice Dharma purely give up your body, this does not mean that one should beggar oneself and give everything one owns away. It does mean that one should stop being preoccupied by the affairs of this life.

As the yogi Chekhawa asked Atisha, should I meditate or should I teach? What is preferable? Atisha answered, give up the affairs of this life. And as Geshe Dromtönpa said, Atisha said, yes, to practice generosity is good, but Dharma is to give up the affairs of this life. And, Atisha added, if you cannot give up the affairs of this life, in other words, whatsoever so-called Dharma you engage in is but the eight worldly dharmas.

Therefore in brief, today’s topic was how to meditate on death and impermanence. I encourage you for the details of these meditations to consult the numerous Lamrim texts on this topic and to meditate as much as you can on death and impermanence. The more you can the better. When one says that one should meditate on death and impermanence, one is referring to meditating on the essence of the path of the being of the small scope. Then one should meditate on this for one or two hours.

What sort of result do you think you can hope for if you meditate for five minutes? If you meditate for one or two hours, numerous lines of reasoning and thoughts will arise, and then you move onwards with your practice. Then I have nothing left to add today. If you have questions, please feel free to ask them. Just going back to that Dharma is virtuous but not everything which is virtuous is Dharma and then that dharma is a mental virtue and that physical and verbal virtues don’t cause liberation.

When I engage in physical restraint or verbal restraint or whatever that is precipitated by the mental motivation to restrain a physical or verbal behaviour. So isn’t that a cause for liberation? Generally speaking, mental virtue in and of itself over time can become a cause for liberation. I certainly understand that mental virtue can lead to liberation, but I think earlier it was said that, Khensur Rinpoche said that physical and verbal virtues will not cause liberation. And so my question really is when one engages in physical or verbal virtue, the motivation for that has been a mental motivation in the first place.

Only another question. Thank you very much, Geshe-la. Yes. You’re welcome. What does contrived bodhicitta mean?

Contrived. Contrived means manufactured or artificial. Contrived bodhicitta arises when one starts meditating on the causes leading to bodhicitta up to the interchange of self and others, compassion and so forth, and eventually thoughts related to bodhicitta, an impression of bodhicitta arises. This is contrived bodhicitta. Transformed in the process, but one has not yet generated uncontrived spontaneous bodhicitta, that is contrived bodhicitta.

So contrived is the same as the English word contrived? Yeah. Thank you, Geshe-la. I have a question from the weekend. Is it appropriate to ask?

I was trying to think about the question that I asked about Patrul Rinpoche in his explanation of Tonglen saying that it’s a practice that should make you fear for your life when you take on the sufferings of others. Should fear for your very life because you should be really convinced that you have actually taken on their sufferings. And then Namkha Pel’s Mind Training Like the Rays of the Sun, that was the translation by the Library of Tibetan Works and Archives and in that, after talking about the process of taking the sufferings onto ones self it said that this Tonglen practice is a practice to give protection from fear. So I was wondering if perhaps when one takes the suffering on oneself, it’s meant to bring the self-cherishing to the forefront and so therefore the self-cherishing becomes very afraid. But because of the equalising of self and others it creates the feeling of equanimity and that equanimity then reduces fear in general.

They’re trying to Can you summarise your question? It’s a concept I have to translate here. When one takes the suffering on oneself, it the case that one one is meant to become very afraid but over time by equalising and developing equanimity between self and others, is that the part of the practice that would protect from fear? Yes, I have not had the time to check, my sincere apologies. Then Geshe says that we will look into it and give you a definitive answer.

It is probably a problem of translation. I’m wondering what the result is of virtue that’s not Dharma. I’m thinking suppose an example where a person is a vegetarian simply because they’ve grown up where nobody eats meat and it’s never occurred to them to eat meat and so there’s no mental practice involved. It’s simply a virtuous bodily action. So it just take that as an example.

What’s the result of that? Does that give them a better life this life but have no impact on future lives? Take your example of vegetarianism, vegetarianism if it was culturally defined and for one’s health for instance would not be virtuous. Virtue depends on motivation. So what would be an example, say in connection with not eating meat of an action that is virtuous but is not dharma?

For instance, if you were to give up eating meat, so thinking of the welfare of animals, that would be virtuous, but probably would not be dharma, because dharma entails trying to counter the afflictions, and that is absent there. The program for the next three months is now available. It’s online. There are a few copies here outside. We’re just waiting on a final piece for the magazine and that will be out as soon as possible.

And you’re welcome to have some chai, drive carefully. And Tenzin? Good evening. Anyway, I have a very special. We got one of the students who sent a few items from Singapore.

So if you like to look at and some most half items from Singapore, half item from India. Alright. It’s the mother day is coming soon. So they hear their salesmen come here. Alright.

Very special beautiful things, You might be have a look and browse through. So this is special and all the funds go to Rinpoche’s stupa. So if you’re welcome to look at. Thank you. Okay.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
three poisons dug sum (Tib)
Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

What does contrived bodhicitta mean?

Contrived means manufactured or artificial. Contrived bodhicitta arises when one meditates on the causes leading to bodhicitta, up to the interchange of self and others, compassion and so forth. Eventually thoughts related to bodhicitta come up, and an impression of bodhicitta arises. This is contrived bodhicitta. One has been transformed in the process, but one has not yet generated uncontrived, spontaneous bodhicitta.

What is an example of an action, such as giving up eating meat, that is virtuous but is not dharma?

Giving up eating meat out of concern for the welfare of animals would be virtuous, but it would probably not be dharma. The reason given is that dharma entails trying to counter the afflictions, and that aim is absent in this case. So an action can be virtuous without being dharma if it is not directed at countering the afflictions.

Scroll to Top