Awakening Heart — 2012-10-21

1 h 28 min · 4,110 words · 21 October 2012 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart — 2012-10-21
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 88-minute teaching, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen explores bodhicitta training through a detailed comparison of Theravāda and Mahāyāna approaches to overcoming self-cherishing. He begins by posing a direct question: does Theravāda practice include patience, and why? From there, he unfolds the logical structure underlying both paths. The Theravāda approach traces self-cherishing to ignorance and seeks to eliminate ignorance itself, while the Mahāyāna approach investigates self-cherishing directly and cultivates its opposite—cherishing others—as the antidote. Geshe-la emphasizes that both methods lead to renunciation, but only the Mahāyāna approach provides the foundation for bodhicitta and the six perfections. He walks through two methods for generating renunciation: reflecting on impermanence and death, and recognizing the immediate suffering caused by negative mental states rooted in self-cherishing. The teaching concludes with practical advice on honest self-assessment, mindful use of time, karma, and maintaining ethical conduct. Pitched at serious Buddhist students with foundational study experience.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2012-10-21 – KR.mp3

UUID: af8d4cc6-e018-4736-9076-9a180922e039

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Awakening Heart

Date: 2012-10-21

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~4,152

Thanks. As we’ve been talking about training in bodhicitta and gaining experience in the practice of it and working our way towards an experience of bodhicitta. We understand that we can engage in trainings that make that possible such as training in the six perfections that involves giving ethical discipline, patience, diligence or effort, concentration and wisdom. Now there’s, Geshe-la quotes from the Bodhisattva’s Bodhicaryāvatāra which says, it is like the supreme gold making elixir for it transforms the unclean body we have taken into the priceless jewel of a Buddha form. Therefore firmly seize this awakening mind.

So training in bodhicitta in the awake what is referred to there as awakening mind enables us to make this radical transformation from the basis upon which we attain this life and through practises and trainings, suitable practises and trainings are able to transform ourselves into a suitable vessel for the awakening mind or bodhicitta So when we talk about the practices specific to the Theravāda tradition, we can see that they engage in trainings that involve probably five of these six. They engage in the wisdom, concentration, diligence, ethical discipline and giving. But it is doubtful perhaps that they engage in the trainings of patience and we might seek to understand the reason for that. We know that they are not aspiring in the Theravāda path. One is not making an aspiration towards attaining the awakening mind or the mind of bodhicitta.

And therefore, patience does not form an integral part of their training. So now Geshe-la poses you the question and would like to hear your feedback in terms of this question of the practice of patience. Specifically asking if you from your side believe that the Theravāda practices would involve patience and why is that so? Or do you think that the Theravāda tradition does involve the practice of patience and the reason why or doesn’t involve the practice of patience and the reason why? Geshe-la would like to hear your opinions on that question.

Well, that’s what we are seeking to explore through the answers. Okay. So if the question is, if you take, the view that Theravāda practitioners take patience as part of their practice then why is there no aspiration for bodhicitta or the preceding states of love and compassion that leads to bodhicitta. That’s wrong. Now actually understand.

So if you are familiar with the Lama Chöpa text, the Guru Puja, you’ll know that within, the text there are six verses pertaining to the six perfections and of the section of Lama Chöpa that is concerned with the six perfections. Of those six verses, the third is the verse that relates to patience and it is a verse that is, very important to have some knowledge of if you are able to if you practice Lama Chöpa you should be familiar with that verse because it’s very insightful as to the reasons of practicing patience. So there’s great, benefit to be had, from investigating this question of the practice of patience in relation to the different paths and the attainment or aspiration to attain bodhicitta. It’s very, valuable investigation to make from your side. So when we talk about the actual training patience, we understand that in order to do the training in patience, we require an intimate connection with other living beings.

Okay. We are entirely dependent on other living beings to engage in the training of patience. And that is the case more so with patience than any of the other of the six perfections when it comes to cultivating the training of patience, where it is intimately entwined with a connection and relationship with other sentient beings. And further to that, it’s worth considering that in order to train in and accomplish, the love and compassion that leads to bodhicitta and by here when we talk about training, we are talking about having some sophisticated level of accomplishment within the training. So it’s not merely a training, the aspirational training but to have some accomplishments in the trainings of love and compassion and bodhicitta, it’s preceded by the necessary requirement of having attained some definite emergence or what we call renunciation.

So renunciation is required before we’re able to have this really accomplished training in love and compassion. And that is another point that is well worth you considering in your own time to explore and come to come to some understanding and have some opinions about. So now we talk about renunciation. And once again, we’re talking about accomplishment within the training of renunciation, not merely the investigation or aspiration towards, but to have some accomplishment in attaining renunciation. We know that it is important for us to have a method by which we are able to accomplish it and to make, to that it is important that we have a method by which we are able to train in order to accomplish renunciation.

And as Geshe-la has said in previous teachings we talked about the two methods that are the most common by which we can train in order to attain a sophisticated level of renunciation. And the first that we spoke about in previous teachings was the one that is based on our reflection on the processes of aging, sickness and death of past and future lives and death and impermanence and cause and effect. Now these observations that are made most intensely generally speaking, these are observations made most intensely as someone ages and approaches the end of their life lifespan. They begin to develop renunciation based on their experiences of the way their life is drawing seeing the way their life is drawing to an end. And they have an intimate sense of what impending death and impermanence and therefore past and future lives and cause and effect really means.

So that is one method that we have discussed in the past that can be relied on for becoming accomplished in renunciation. The other method that we spoke of was one that can, that older and younger people alike. When we spoke about it previously we spoke of it, particularly in terms of, younger people being very cognizant of these things such as the detrimental effect of the negative mental states, negative emotions, jealousy, anger, spiteful competitiveness. We have an observation of the suffering that these mental states cause and the cycle of suffering these mental states trap us within. We trace back the reason for these mental states arising to the self-cherishing mind and understand that because of self-cherishing these negative mental states of jealousy anger and spiteful competitiveness are bound to arise.

So we begin to have a strong distaste, a strong dislike for self-cherishing and seek to diminish it in any way possible and ideally with the greatest strength possible. So this is a way to, this is the second method by which we’re able to train in accomplishing renunciation. So of the we set about to attain a true sense of renunciation. There are the two methods and we know that, we are able to train in each of them. They will lead to the same result of a sense of definite emergence or renunciation.

So when we understand the way that we live within our social world, within society or our social world, our social relationships, we know that when we come under the sway of the negative mental states that there is a great deal of suffering that is experienced. There is disharmony. There is discord. There is a great deal of suffering that comes about on the basis of these negative mental states, the mental afflictions. Anyone, whether they have a commitment to one way of training or not, can see this very clearly.

It doesn’t take an enormous amount of insight to be able to see the damage that these negative mental states do to within our social relationships. So having seen the damage that it causes and seeing and trying to find a way to understand the nature of the the way this damage is being caused, we trace it back to this sense overriding obsession with a sense of self. The obsession with a sense of self that is comes about because of self-cherishing. This self obsession is what generates or creates the conditions in which these negative mental states are likely to flourish. And we can all see the damage it causes and we can all therefore through this method of investigation see damaging self-cherishing is and wish to train in a method that will diminish it and ultimately eradicate it.

Jealousy. So now when we seek to accomplish a state of renunciation to actually attain to set about the training that will enable us to truly have an experience of renunciation. We come to a fork in the road where we are able to make a decision about the methods by which we seek to pursue our training. Now if we look at the problems that the negative mental states cause to us and cause others in our social worlds, then we can trace it back to self-cherishing. We then direct our attention towards understanding the nature of self-cherishing and ultimately trying to find the cause of self-cherishing.

If we are able to find the cause for self-cherishing and eliminate that cause, then the end result of self-cherishing will not occur. So how can we find the cause of self-cherishing? If we make a serious investigation into the causes of self-cherishing, we can trace it back to the mental state that we know within Buddhist terms as ignorance. And ignorance is the ignorance toward the nature of reality. The true nature of reality.

Ignorance concerning the true nature of reality is what is the cause that gives rise to self-cherishing. And therefore we may decide to follow the path that specifically seeks to focus on ignorance and eliminate ignorance as a way to get rid of self-cherishing. Now this direction that we can choose to take is generally associated with the Ther Theravāda path. Okay. So we’ve established we’re talking about, cultivating renunciation, reaching a fork in the road.

The first direction that we saw was the one that, observed ignorance to be the root of self-cherishing and seeking to eliminate ignorance from our minds. Now the alternative is the one that similarly takes a very, makes a great deal of investigation into the nature of the negative mental states and sees the damage that self-cherishing is causing. Understands that all hardship and trouble comes from this self-cherishing. Therefore seeks to find a way to eliminate it. And in trying to eliminate in in making this investigation into the way that self-cherishing exists within our mind gives rise to imagining that which is the opposite to self-cherishing.

Now we’ve covered this in previous weeks that if we are to make an observation as to the way self-cherishing can exist in the mind, it is also possible to imagine what the opposite to self-cherishing would be. And we know from previous weeks that the opposite to self-cherishing is cherishing others. We make an investigation into what it exactly means to cherish others and is it possible to cherish others at the same time as harboring self-cherishing? And we begin to see that it is impossible to be committed to cherishing others and have self-cherishing arise in the mind at the same time. Therefore cultivating this cherishing of others enables us to observe some particular qualities that cherishing others has.

We have seen in previous weeks that the qualities of cherishing others that they provide the basis upon which we are able to cultivate bodhicitta and therefore improve our training and progress towards the realisation of bodhicitta and the ultimate state of Buddhahood. Therefore if training in cherishing others will diminish self-cherishing, it can become a focus of our training. Okay. So we remember again, we’re talking about two distinct paths. The first one was tracing self-cherishing to its root cause ignorance and eliminating ignorance.

And now on this other path we’re talking about seeing self-cherishing, investigating it and seeing that the opposite to self-cherishing has certain quality. The opposite to self-cherishing, which is cherishing others has many qualities that we seek to achieve and that if we are able to cultivate a training in cherishing others we will diminish and ultimately eradicate self-cherishing. So this is more, this path is what we will find within the Mahāyāna tradition. So we have the first one, the root of ignorance that goes to that we attribute to the Theravāda tradition and the second one that we attribute to the Mahāyāna tradition. Now the nature of these two paths and the results they seek to attain are things that, you should investigate, that you should think about, you should analyse and come to your own sense of what is pertinent in each of these two methods, these two techniques.

And have some understanding about why it is that one is more, suitable for your aspirations in terms of Buddhist training. So when it comes to analyzing this, we see that cherishing others has great virtues. It has great qualities because it will enable us to attain the qualities that lead to a full realization of bodhicitta. So now we need to make an investigation from our own side and try and analyze and see which way is the most beneficial to oneself and make some investigations specifically into the qualities of cherishing others to see if engaging in the training of cherishing others is actually bringing some benefit to your own well-being in the here and now. If you are able to observe that self, replacing self-cherishing with this training and cherishing others is actually, bringing benefit and most immediate benefit to your own well-being.

Then it is obviously well worth engaging in and devoting oneself to, But you have to make that investigation for yourself. You have to make that you come to that understanding by yourself in the way that you respond to the teaching, the training and implementation of cherishing others. This is up for you to decide and see. Ultimately, generally we say it brings enormous benefits not just in terms of this vast expansive aspirational benefit for all, but has very concrete benefit for our own personal well-being in the here and now. So making your own investigation of this, you’ll understand I’m sure that the power of love and compassion is crucial and of great benefit.

So we seek therefore to cultivate love and compassion and from our previous teachings based from, like, mind training like the rays of the sun, the text that, these teachings are based on. We know that when it comes to cultivating love and compassion, it itself has two distinct methods. And we have talked about the seven point cause and effect method and we have talked about exchanging self for others method which is what the text concerns itself with. And that is what we have been studying. So understanding this and the reasons why we are approaching the study like this will bring great benefit to your understanding and your capacity to train.

In training in this cultivation of love and compassion, we know that we will accumulate a vast collection of virtue and that virtue will enable us to and the benefit that we will accrue by having accumulated such virtue. And the way that we are able to engage in the practice and the way that we minimise harm, that we are able to make a positive contribution in every way. There is great benefit to be had and it is of great importance to our lives to be able to understand and train. So now we may having spent time going through this dissection of the trainings and specifically in relation to, love and compassion and the generation attainment of bodhicitta. We should spend now a couple of minutes, using that as the basis for setting our motivation.

And we will take the next couple of minutes to do that now. So we know from the text that our teachings are based upon Mind Training Like the Rays of the Sun that there is a great deal of specific advice and trainings and how we are able to cultivate love and compassion and bodhicitta. And within it, there is the opportunity for great success in both our study and training if we are able to pay close attention to the detail. Now we know that within the system of Buddhist training and practice, there are enormous amount of texts. There are the texts composed by the Buddha.

There are those that are composed as commentaries on the teachings. And there is a vast array of different texts that one could engage in the study of. But if we, if we try to, find the essence of what all the advice that these texts give, know that we can, can narrow it down to this advice concerning ignorance and self-cherishing and the damage that self-cherishing does. The teachings provide a way that we are able to inspire ourselves to transform the actions of our body, speech and mind in such a way that we are able to accrue an enormous amount of benefit both in the short term and in the long term. And it is a way that we are able to diminish the power of self-cherishing and and cultivate the skill in cherishing others.

And it is something that will bring enormous benefit to ourselves both now and in the long term. So now we know that from the, for people who have spent time in study and practise of Buddhism and who are able, you are able to direct your attention to the advice that is contained within this text, Mind Training Like the Rays of the Sun, you’ll know that it is written in such a way that we are able to gain great benefit from the explanation of the practices. Have been, Geshe-la is assuming that we are reading this text, and keeping up with this text as he makes commentary on aspects of it rather than going through a sentence by sentence analysis of the text. Geshe-la is assuming that we are reading this text and studying it and therefore having our study supplemented by the advice we get on the Sundays. Now we should by now have reached up to page [English page number omitted]; in the Tibetan it’s 140.

If you are able to read this text up to page 88, the bottom you’ll see there is the measure of having trained the mind. Now we, Geshe-la is assuming we have read up until that point. So remember that the commentary that Geshe-la is giving assumes a reading of the text even though, we’re not having a specific blow by blow deconstruction of the text, but Geshe-la still assumes that we’re reading it. Nice, Geshe-la. Now if we truly are able to engage in study and practice in such a way that we are able to achieve that we’re able to accomplish the fruits of study and practice.

If we have some accomplishments based on our study and practice, then it’s something that becomes immediately observable to other people. Now, if you really have engaged in serious study and serious training, one’s characteristics will undergo a transformation and people will be able to observe in you that you are kind hearted, that you are generous, that you are humble, that you have achieved certain qualities within your personality that reflect the teachings and the trainings that you have devoted yourself to. People will be able to see that you are kind, that you are generous, that you are humble and that you, what we might say that you are good from the inside that you are a good person in the most profound way of using that word good. Now from our own side, we need to continually investigate our own mind and the way that we engage in our study and our training. Specifically, we must make a concerted effort to catch ourselves engaging in self deceit, in cheating, in cheating ourselves, in deceiving ourselves to think that we have achieved certain things when perhaps we really haven’t.

And that our progression on the path depends on our willingness to make this critical self investigation into the way that we are living our lives to determine whether we are having success in our study and our training. And this critical self awareness is vital to stop to stop us from kidding ourselves that perhaps we attained something that we haven’t really. And it’s very important that we are mindful of this self critique in order to keep ourselves committed to training and practice and not to be inclined towards shortcuts or jumping over essential points or taking shortcuts or jumping over essential points. So, one of the great benefits that comes from focusing on this text and incorporating it into our understanding is that it gives us cause to realize that every single moment that we have is precious and should not be wasted. And that getting into a habit of allowing time to drift by, to allow time to be, to not be utilised is something that we must really attempt to avoid at all costs to appreciate the fact that within every single moment of our lives there is an opportunity by which we are able to engage in practice.

So there is our commitment to making sure that we are diligent with our time and refuse to allow even a moment or two that we refuse to allow even a moment or two to escape our attention whereby we might be practising and putting into practice things such as death and impermanence and our other understanding of Buddhist training. So if you’re able to think like that, it is of great benefit to you. But if you feel that you are unable to do that it’s well worth investigating, why that is. So we understand that as we exist in this world within our social worlds, we have, people who we may call as enemies or people who adversaries that we come across in the course of our normal life, People who are causing us problems of one kind or the other who seem to always be in our ear and causing us, this mental discomfort, and unhappiness. Now it’s always important for us to remember the advice of, Śākyamūni Buddha and the advices that he has given in terms understanding of the way results come about.

The things that we experience are results of previous actions accumulated in, everything that we experience is the result of a previous action. And keeping this within our mind, it gives us cause to cultivate forbearance and an ability to be patient and to always maintain a state of mind that we wish to have no matter what kind of negative influences we feel are pressing upon us. And so from understanding the way that, karma is accumulated from previous lives, we come to an understanding of the diff when we are engaged with other lives, with animals, we can see that everything that has come about is coming about not by random, not by luck, but is coming about on the basis of previous causes that have been established. And having an understanding of that is something that we should be able to use as a great fortifier for our mind to be able to continually keep mindful of our practices. So understanding that causal relationship we need to be very, we also need to be very mindful of the way that we engage with all forms of like other living beings and seek never to cause harm to other living beings.

Understanding the basis upon which future outcomes will arise. We know that we must refrain as best as we possibly can in each and every circumstance that confronts us within our life through our actions, through the way we behave, through the way we talk, that we do not bring harm upon other living beings. We know that within the context of, the way that future results come about, we must always be mindful never to inflict in any way seek to inflict harm on other living beings knowing full well what ultimately the outcome will be of such actions. Yeah. Geshe-la, again reminds you of the importance of reading very carefully this text, studying it very carefully.

You know? Yeah, yeah.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
puja chö pa (Tib)
Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top