Awakening Heart — 2012-10-31

1 h 46 min · 4,780 words · 31 October 2012 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart — 2012-10-31
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Kyabje Rinpoche opens with everyday observation to establish a core teaching: self-cherishing—our habitual egoism—is the root of anger, envy, jealousy, and suffering. In this 106-minute session, he explains a key metaphor: we cannot cover the earth with leather to prevent thorns, but we can protect our feet with shoes. Similarly, we cannot eliminate external harm, but we can transform our minds. He presents two paths: Hīnayāna, which pursues individual liberation through eliminating self-grasping, and Mahāyāna, which counters egotism by cultivating altruism and compassion. Rinpoche then teaches reliance on the spiritual teacher as practice foundation, covering visualization and the seven-limb offering. An extended Q&A addresses practical methods for countering anger through patience and reasoning. For practitioners following structured Buddhist study.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2012-10-31 – KR.mp3

UUID: c56e24b5-6f86-4591-8999-3f757d79c93a

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Awakening Heart

Date: 2012-10-31

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~4,810

It’s pretty hot today. Maybe 23, isn’t it? Today, 23, 23 degrees. Yesterday, probably 33 temperature. If we reflect in a relaxed fashion about things quietly, we can see that whether we actually follow dharma, a spiritual tradition, or whether we are not a follower of dharma, of a spiritual tradition, in reality, the so called afflictions, in other words, envy, jealousy, anger, desire, are harmful to all of us.

There is probably none of us who doesn’t have a modicum of time in which to engage in these practices and it is critical to reflect on the faults of the afflictions, taking anger as an example. It is critical to reflect on the faults of anger in a relaxed fashion before anger arises because in doing so we will prevent it from arising. Otherwise, once it has arisen, it is very difficult to counter even to the practice of forbearance. The same is true for all the other afflictions such as envy and so forth. One must reflect on their thoughts before they arise within our minds.

And then if we take the case of anger, we have to try to understand what anger arises from. Now, it will be our shared experience and it is something we hear as well from others that when we are angry and we ask a person what is the cause of your anger, the responsibility lies 100% in the other person or enemy, our foe, who has given rise to anger within us. There is not one iota of responsibility in us and this is a common experience to all of us. The same is true for envy, for jealousy and so forth. It is always the other person’s fault.

So the Tibetan term has two possible translations in English. It can be translated as envy or it can be translated as jealousy. We make a distinction in English which is not made in Tibetan. This envy or jealousy is an extremely problematic affliction which we are all aware of and whether anger, envy or jealousy arises within our mind stream, it is important for all of us to try to understand first what it is when it arises and where it arises from so as to be able to counter it. All of us have experienced envy and jealousy in the past and we will experience it again in the future.

It is a shared experience. However, if we analyze our reaction, whether it is envy and jealousy or anger which arises in our mind and ask ourselves whose fault it is, I think all of us have the experience that we always blame the other person. Now if we take these three afflictions, anger, jealousy and competitiveness, and let us assume for the sake of argument that 90% of them, or 90% of the affliction arises because of the thought of the other person. Let’s just assume this. Then even if this were the case, this other person who is responsible at 90% of our anger, our jealousy or our competitiveness.

Is this someone who is permanent or impermanent? This is clearly someone who is impermanent. They may move away to another place, for that matter they may die. Then we should ask ourselves what happens in that case to our anger, to our jealousy and to our competitiveness. Do they decrease or not?

Then it is clearly asserted in the Bodhicaryāvatāra that the source of affliction such as anger, jealousy or competitiveness is self-cherishing or egotism. This is evident to us. If we observe our own mind, we can see it is our own egoism which gives rise to anger, to jealousy or to competitiveness. Things become more delicate when we try to analyze the manner in which egotism or self-cherishing arise themselves. And there one must study carefully and analyze carefully.

All of us understand what egoism or self-cherishing is. It is a state of mind which says, apart from me, there is nobody else, as the Tibetans say so beautifully. Then in this world, perhaps most people are like that. As Candrakīrti says in his Madhyamakāvatāra, it is from the view of the transitory collection that desire and all the afflictions arise. Here specifically, what arises explicitly from the view of the transitory collection is self grasping whereas what arises implicitly from the view of the transitory collection or indirectly is self-cherishing or egoism.

Whereas Dharmakīrti says in his Pramāna Vartika, all of the thoughts arise from the view of the transitory collection. Here, the view of the transitory collection gives rise to desire and from desire arise all thoughts. Finally, Śāntideva in his Bodhicaryāvatāra says all sufferings in this world, all hardship in this world, excuse me, without exception arises from the view of the transitory collection. Here, this world refers both to this world understood as the container and the contained. In other words, the physical world and the sentient beings within it.

So reflecting on the meaning of these quotes at first is difficult but as we conjoin it with our own experience over time there will be tremendous enhancement of our mental faculties. As you said in Śāntideva’s Bodhicaryāvatāra, since sentient beings are infinite as space, how would it be possible to abandon anger with respect to every single one of them? The meaning of this quote is fleshed out in the example which Śāntideva gives in Bodhicaryāvatāra. When thorns pierce our feet, instead of covering the earth with leather, simply cover your feet with leather. Covering one’s feet with leather here is an old fashioned expression which refers to wearing shoes.

So, while it is possible to eliminate the suffering of thorns by covering the earth with leather. This is not feasible in practice and it remains quite feasible to protect oneself by covering one’s own feet with leather. In the same way, we cannot address the anger we have towards each sentient being, but we can address the cause of this anger within our own minds and eliminate it. So while it might be difficult for us to abandon egotism or self-cherishing, nonetheless, we can address it and counter it whenever it arises. As Geshe Chekawa says, he is guilty of everything.

He here refers to egotism or self-cherishing. Now generally speaking, there is not extensive reference to countering self-cherishing or egotism within the great treatises such as Pramānavārttika or Madhyamakāvatāra. In these treatises, what is mainly explained is how to counter self grasping or grasping at the inherent existence of the self. It is the explanations of self-cherishing and how to counter it are given mainly in Śāntideva’s Bodhicaryāvatāra. Then it seems difficult to be able to abandon self-cherishing from the root unless we are able to generate the wish to abandon it from the root even in the dream state.

And for this to arise, we need a form of renunciation. So while all of us understand clearly whether we are dharma practitioners or not, whether you’re practitioners of a spiritual tradition or not, the thoughts of the afflictions such as anger, desire, competitiveness, jealousy and so forth. Nonetheless, to give rise to such a renunciation which abandons these, then one must not only be the practitioner of a spiritual tradition, but probably one would have to be as well the practitioner of a Buddhist tradition. Then once this wish to abandon self-cherishing arises even in the dream state, in other words, once an uncontrived spontaneous wish to abandon self-cherishing and egoism arises, then one can indeed say that renunciation is born. And as Geshe-la has explained previously and this is something which is important for us to understand, at this point there are two roads or two paths.

Someone who understands at this point that the root cause of self-cherishing or egotism is self grasping will probably at this point put tremendous effort in the elimination of self grasping and will become a practitioner of the lower vehicle. The second type of practitioner, however, understands that the cause of all this hardship is self-cherishing and instead of trying to eliminate the root, the cause of self-cherishing, which is grasping at a self, wishes instead to generate the opposite of self-cherishing, which is cherishing others, in other words altruism. And focusing on generating altruism counters thereby self-cherishing. To do this, one must reflect over and again on the qualities of altruism. Then such a being has probably entered the great vehicle, the Mahāyāna, and has probably generated the Mahāyāna type or nature.

This is how I should think about it. Then yourselves and Geshe-la himself for that matter have to decide at this point which road, which path they are going to follow. Are we going to mainly counter self grasping and probably follow the Hīnayāna, the lower vehicle, or are we mainly going to counter egoism or self-cherishing and then probably follow the Mahāyāna? That’s the way it is. That is red, that’s the way it is, isn’t it?

So, Geshe-la, I would like to ask you a quick question. What road are you going to follow? And here it’s not appropriate to answer without thinking. Think carefully before you commit yourself. There are two roads.

Which roads will we follow? Self grasping is the cause of self-cherishing. self-cherishing arises from self grasping. That is perfectly possible to counter self grasping without countering self-cherishing because the opposite of self grasping is the mind which understands the emptiness of the self. You can generate that without countering self-cherishing.

When you say altruism, are you talking about bodhicitta? Is your question about both of the paths or about altruism being bodhicitta? So regarding your first question, the answer is no. The first path is actually a path of the Hīnayāna or the lower vehicle which is not related to bodhicitta whereas the second path in which one strives to counter self-cherishing through generating altruism is a path which naturally leads to the generation of bodhicitta. So since it would be inappropriate inappropriate to train an altruism without this eventually leading to bodhicitta.

Regarding your second question, the relationship between altruism and bodhicitta, there is a very major difference. Altruism, in other words, cherishing others is actually the cause of bodhicitta. bodhicitta, in other words, is the result of altruism. First one trains in altruism and as a result of this, then one engages in the training of the interchange of self and others. And at this point, one engages in the practice of Tonglen or giving and taking, which may be conjoined with breath and here bodhicitta arises.

You are welcome. I was just gonna ask what would the Dalai Lama do in response to the question? What was the question? Excuse me. I didn’t hear.

Since these teachings are teachings of the great vehicle or the Mahāyāna, then it would be inappropriate to attend them and not to put them into practice. Therefore, the path we should be following is the path of the Mahāyāna or the great vehicle. And frankly, the very essence of the Lamrim or the graduated stages of the path is training in the Mahāyāna. So the Mahāyāna is a path we should be following. I just wanted to check-in the mind of an arhat.

In the mind of an arhat, I thought they had they still had they eliminated self-cherishing, but they still had self grasping. But how can that be? A Hīnayāna arhat. My hearing is not good tonight, Rosanna. Yes.

I thought they had eliminated self-cherishing. It’s basically the opposite. Arhats, Drachompa in Tibetan have abandoned the ignorance of self grasping, but they have not abandoned self-cherishing. When we speak of in Tibetan is an enemy, is to overcome. So they have overcome an enemy.

Which enemy have they overcome? They have overcome the enemy of the ignorance of self grasping. Now if they actually had abandoned self-cherishing on top of this, it is difficult to see how they could not have generated other cherishing, altruism and they have definitely not generated this. A few Sundays ago, Geshe-la mentioned or he asked us whether practitioners on the Theravadan path practice the perfection of patience and he suggested that perhaps they didn’t, which I can understand from the perspective of patience being a stepping stone to countering self-cherishing, which is done in the Mahāyāna path. But if we look at Śāntideva’s presentation of patience in the Bodhicaryāvatāra and as an antidote to anger, Does that imply then that anger still exists in the mind of an Arhat?

So just to clarify your question, it’s about the perfection of patience or patience? Then there’s definitely no anger within the continuum of However, in this matter, what Geshe-la was talking about on Sunday was which of the six practices of generosity, ethics, forbearance, enthusiasm, concentration and wisdom were engaged in by the Hīnayāna hearers and Pratyekabuddha. And in this matter and this is Geshe-la’s private perspective, the Hīnayāna practitioners would focus mainly on five of these six practices. In other words, they would focus on generosity, on ethics, on enthusiasm, on concentration and on wisdom. But they have no particular connection with the practice of forbearance.

This does not mean, however, that there is anger within their mind stream since a Hīnayāna arhat has abandoned ignorance of self grasping and therefore the cause of anger does not exist anymore. The reason Geshe-la feels this is the case is because Hīnayāna practitioners are practitioners of lesser strength who are mainly focused on their own interest and their own liberation. Then when one engages in the practice of patience or perhaps it is better translated as forbearance, This forbearance is twofold. Initially, when oneself is harmed by another person, one does not react. But in addition to this, one generates a mind of compassion which wishes to benefit the other person.

This type of practice is absent within the Hīnayāna. Lily, come. Does anger no longer arise in the mind of a being with regards to being an Arhat? Is it perhaps when they are conceptually or conceptualizing emptiness, or is it when they have a perceptional understanding? Or where on the paths and grounds does the anger not rise?

Excuse me. What is your question? Is does anger arise in the mind of an at all? Or where in the path leading up to does anger stop? Where on the path there?

Okay. Then anger is abandoned for a Hīnayāna practitioner when self grasping is abandoned. Since self grasping is the cause of anger. Then self grasping is only abandoned when one becomes an arhats. Therefore, before becoming an Arhat, it is not possible to abandon anger.

Do you mean that after the arhat has meditated non conceptually on emptiness, conceptions about emptiness arise within his mind? So when one trains in meditating on emptiness, initially one meditates on emptiness conceptually and then eventually these conceptions disappear and there’s a direct experience of emptiness. Oh yeah, alright. That’s a little bit. Then altruism or cherishing others will not appear at once or easily within our minds.

It will take time and therefore we should reflect each day a couple of minutes, five or six minutes on the reasons for which we should be altruistic and the reasons countering egotism. Then as we relate to others, we will see that we become less partial, less obsessed with ourselves and more open to others. This does not mean, however, that we must give up all our possessions and all our bodies to others. This is a mental training. And then in this context of abandoning self-cherishing or egoism and generating altruism or cherishing others, who is the person or who is the individual who teaches us the path which enables us to abandon egoism.

It is none other than the spiritual teacher who teaches us the path. And obviously in this case, if our spiritual teacher is someone who has a lot of anger, lot of competitiveness, a lot of jealousy in her mind, in his mind, then this is profoundly inappropriate since such a person cannot teach us how to get rid of our own anger and we should not rely on such a person. Instead, ideally, we should rely on a spiritual teacher who has abandoned all the afflictions. If that is not possible, at least we should rely on a spiritual teacher who does not or who does not fall under the sway of the coarser forms of desire, of anger, of jealousy and so forth. Do you understand?

Do you understand? Really? Very important. We have to be very clear here. Geshe is not saying that he has abandoned anger or the delusions in any respect.

This is within the context of teaching the Lamrim and he is presenting the approach of the Lam Rim and how we should behave. That that that is right. There is in this matter a very big difference between someone who is or someone who accepts Dharma on the one hand and someone who does not accept Dharma on the other hand and here Dharma or spiritual tradition specifically refers to the Buddhist Dharma or the Buddhist spiritual tradition. When we speak of someone who accepts Dharma, we are not referring to sociological Buddhists. Buddhists who are Buddhists because their parents were Buddhists and their forefathers were Buddhists.

This is not what is referred to. We are referring to people who try to put into practice the Buddhist teachings. Then Geshe-la hopes that you who are present tonight are people who are trying to put into practice the Buddhist teachings. If you are not, what exactly are you doing here tonight? You’re wasting your time and you’re wasting his time.

And those of you who come on Sunday who do not put in practice the teachings are wasting your time as well. So one attends teachings to try to put them into practice. There is a huge difference in terms of attitude and behavior between someone who accepts Dharma and the Dharma teachings and someone who does not accept Dharma and the Dharma teachings. And a while ago Geshe-la gave as an example two persons, one accepting Dharma and one not accepting Dharma coming into an empty house in which there is a lump of gold. Then the one who does not accept dharma will be very tempted to take the lump of gold especially if he thinks the police will not find him and has no way of knowing that he stole the gold.

The only thing which prevents him from stealing is fear of the police. On the other hand, the one who accepts dharma may indeed fear the police, but more importantly will reflect if I take this lump of gold which is not mine in future lives, I will experience great hardship as a result of this. And out of a fear of the result in future lives will not engage in this behavior. There is a tremendous difference. Then Geshe-la hopes that all of you tonight are students who accept karma and causality.

If you don’t, he wonders what precisely you were doing here. Then among those of the students assembled tonight who actually accept dharma and karma and causality, the presence of the police is completely unnecessary. It’s easier if you think about it like that. Then we will reflect for one or two minutes on karma and causality and how to practice with them in our mind. So at present, to develop on the passage from the Lamrim which states train in relying on the spiritual teacher, the foundation of the path.

Geshe-la has explained that reliance on the spiritual teacher is twofold. Through mental reliance on the spiritual teacher and reliance on the spiritual teacher through behavior. Mental reliance on the spiritual teacher involves training in the development of faith and veneration. If we recollecting the kindness of the spiritual teacher and this has been presented and to present at present in a concise fashion relying on the spiritual teacher through behavior, This actually relies to physical deeds with respect to the spiritual teacher. And if you remember the presentation of the six preliminary practices before engaging in the Lamrim, this reliance on the spiritual teacher through behavior begins at the level of the force of these six practices.

In other words, initially you set up a statue on an altar, then you make non deceitful offerings to the statue and then you rest on a cushion in the appropriate position. These three first preliminary practices are not part of relying on the spiritual teacher’s behavior. Relying on the spiritual teacher to behavior therefore begins at the level of the fourth preliminary practice. It begins with the entreaties which follow inviting the field of accumulation of merit in space in front of oneself and it includes specifically practices such as the seven limb offering which include as you know the offering of prostration offerings in general and so forth. In this context, the field of refuge is the excuse me, the field of accumulation of merit is the field of accumulation of merit in accordance with the lamrim, specifically in accordance with Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand.

Therefore, visualizes in the center of the field of refuge Buddha Śākyamūni, surrounded by Maitreya and by Mañjuśrī. In front of Buddha Śākyamūni, one visualizes Atisha. And within the four layers of this field of refuge, the second layer includes Je Tsongkhapa surrounded by Gyaltsab Je and Khedrup Je. The third includes the author of From the Mouth of Mañjuśrī, one of the main sources of Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand, which is the fifth Dalai Lama.

And the fourth finally includes whatever gurus one has requested the Lamrim from. However, if this is too cluttered and too difficult for you to visualize, you can simply visualize as Geshe-la previously explained, the root guru encapsulating all refuges in the space in front of you and offer the seven limb puja with prostrations and so forth to him. Alright. He has stopped to talk tonight. So we will be finishing, pretty soon the presentation of reliance on the spiritual teacher.

So there’s a written question from Lily. What actually is the status of faith in an invalid object? For instance, the faith in the mind of a non-Buddhist in the existence of a creator God when there is no creator God. Does this qualify as faith or not? And if so, what mental factor is it?

And Geshe-la’s answer is that generally speaking, faith does not have to be faith in a valid object. There are many forms of faith in invalid objects. However, he will look into it. It’s a good question. It’s a good question.

Yes, honey, another? Just one question. We’ll take one other question. Good. Is that working?

I just had a question. When Geshe-la was talking about altruism being a mental training and that it’s something that’s not just practical. Well, surely that a mental practice is designed to give rise to behavior, not just in I’m really sorry. I can’t hear you. My apologies.

If you could speak louder. That’s said at one stage when he was talking about altruism and giving rise to and and that it’s a practice of the mind. Uh-huh. He said it was a mental training. Yes.

Yes. But surely, mental trainings are to give rise to behavior. Is your question about Guru Yoga? The two types of Guru Yoga, relying through faith and through behavior? No.

Sorry. I didn’t even know what that is. Maybe write it down for next time. Maybe somebody else can ask a question. Her question was, altruism Geshe-la mentioned that altruism was a mental practice.

And, the question is, surely the mental practice should give rise to altruistic behavior. Then Geshe-la thinks that that is, precisely it and therefore, he would encourage all of you when the opportunity arises after generating altruism to give your eyes, to give your blood, to give your body, and so forth. Go for it. I really wanted to ask if you were harboring a lot of anger that was directed at a particular person, what would be the best way to purify or negate that anger? Through meditation?

Or discussed tonight, we discussed perhaps looking at your own, the source of your own anger through attachment or self-cherishing. Or would the best way be possibly to develop enough compassion for that object of the anger so that instead of anger you actually felt a deep sympathy for their actions or the negative karma that they were producing? So anyway, does that does that make sense? So there are multiple ways to counter anger. They are generally explained in Śāntideva’s Bodhicaryāvatāra.

Generally speaking, bodhicitta and compassion indeed are means to counter anger but they are not the specific antidotes to anger. The most powerful antidote to anger is a practice of patience or forbearance. And the lines of reasoning which are used are explained in Śāntideva’s Bodhicaryāvatāra. For instance, when someone strikes us with a stick, we are never angry with a stick but with a person. Why is this the case?

Because we consider the stick to be non-sentient, to be unconscious, to have no control. But in reality, if we analyze curve carefully, we can see that the person as well has no control. They are controlled by anger. Otherwise, it would if it was in the nature of the person to beat us, then they would be beating be beating us continually, which is not the case. They only beat us when anger is present in their in their mind stream And therefore, if we should be angry with anything, it is not the person but the anger in their mind stream.

Think of the difference between a human being and a dog. If you strike a dog with a stick, the dog will bite the stick. He holds a stick for guilty of his pain. But if you strike a human being with a stick, he comes after you, doesn’t he? Just a couple of announcements.

Firstly, as Jampa Tenzin is sneaking out the door, it’s Jampa Tenzin’s last evening for a month as she heads off to South Africa to visit her family. So we wish you a very safe and fulfilling trip in South Africa. Look forward to seeing you when you get back. Also there is a special puja on Tuesday night to celebrate the anniversary of the Buddha’s descent from Tuśita to earth, Lha Bab Duchen at 07:00. So that’s on Tuesday, and there’s also a puja on the regular one on Friday.

Also, Ilya’s interview on channel forty four will be airing on Monday the fifth at 07:30 then again on Wednesday at 01:00, Friday at 04:30. So it was a very successful little interview about Ilya and his work and they want him to come back next year. This is where Aaron’s mum works. And also people who have Yamāntaka and Vajrayoginī empowerments, the commentaries are ready for you to order. That’s the draft copies, Lily.

There’s the draft copies and they’ve been unchecked by the translator so the price is reflected accordingly. And Khensur Rinpoche’s representative here in Australia is Tenzin, and I think he would like to have a word. Alright. I have announced November 16, November, there is a Tibetan community in South Australia, and ATC will held a Tibet talk, you know, what’s happening in Tibet in current. And we have a special guest, Sarah Hanson-Young from the Greens in the Senate.

And, also, entry is $10, and bring your own plate and make it 5 or 10 of you know? And there will be also entertainment as well afterwards. So, yeah, if you’d like to and we will send you an email continuously. Sixteenth of Friday night. Yeah.

And it’s it will be held at the North Adelaide. I haven’t got any information yet, but, yeah, North Adelaide Community Hall. And there will be two speaker, Sarah what’s her name? Sarah Hansen and ATC from Sydney. So, you know, that would be a great, and we talk about what’s happening in, you know, current in Tibet.

You know, so many self-immolations happening. You know? You know, now it’s near over 60 people self-immolated since 2011, which is a lot. You know? So I hope you can join.

And yeah. And we will send you the email, and there will be a phone number you can, you know, register. Okay?

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
guru yoga lama nel jor (Tib)
A practice in which one views the guru as inseparable from a deity or the Buddha, in order to amass the two collections of merit and wisdom and to purify negativities and obscurations. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
preliminary practices ngondro (Tib)
The practices that prepare the mind for successful tantric meditation by removing hindrances and accumulating merit. LYWA
puja chö pa (Tib)
Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Is altruism the same as bodhicitta, or how are the two related?

There is a very major difference between them. Altruism, which means cherishing others, is the cause of bodhicitta, and bodhicitta is the result of altruism. One first trains in altruism. As a result of this, one then engages in the training of the interchange of self and others. At this point one practises Tonglen, or giving and taking, which may be conjoined with the breath, and here bodhicitta arises.

Has an arhat eliminated self-cherishing but kept self-grasping, or is it the other way around?

It is basically the opposite. Arhats (Drachompa in Tibetan) have abandoned the ignorance of self-grasping, but they have not abandoned self-cherishing. The Tibetan term means 'enemy destroyer', one who has overcome an enemy. The enemy they have overcome is the ignorance of self-grasping. If they had also abandoned self-cherishing on top of this, it is difficult to see how they could have failed to generate cherishing of others, or altruism. They have definitely not generated this.

At what point on the paths and grounds is anger completely abandoned, so that it no longer arises?

For a Hīnayāna practitioner, anger is abandoned when self-grasping is abandoned, because self-grasping is the cause of anger. Self-grasping is only abandoned when one becomes an arhat. Therefore, before becoming an arhat, it is not possible to abandon anger. Anger no longer arises only at the stage of arhatship, when its cause, self-grasping, has been removed.

Scroll to Top