Awakening Heart — 2012-10-17

1 h 35 min · 3,491 words · 17 October 2012 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart — 2012-10-17
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 96-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche works through Je Tsongkhapa’s explanation of relying on a qualified spiritual teacher as the foundation of the Buddhist path. He starts with why faith—not intellectual understanding alone—is crucial for gaining realization in renunciation, bodhicitta, and emptiness. He develops this through Atisha’s example: having studied with 156 teachers across India, Atisha traveled to Sumatra to receive bodhicitta instruction from Guru Suvarnadvipi because that specific teaching could not be found elsewhere. This illustrates a key point Rinpoche returns to: a teacher need not know everything, only teach authentically what the student needs. He then covers the three types of faith and argues that a living teacher’s kindness surpasses even the Buddha’s, since we receive transmission only through direct instruction. The talk concludes with Q&A on practical application.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2012-10-17 – KR.mp3

UUID: 0c2124b0-a3ba-455f-a158-48e1fcfb4db4

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Awakening Heart

Date: 2012-10-17

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~3,490

Just one. Alright. The passage in Je Tsongkhapa’s Great Stages of the Path, the root of the path, the manner of relying on the spiritual teacher is foundational. The first part of this phrase means the root of the path in Tibetan and it is critical here to understand fully what is meant by the term path. The term path refers to the totality of trainings one engages in starting with reflections on past and future lives and moving onwards to reflections on karma and causality before leading to the generation of renunciation at which point one can start to train in bodhicitta and eventually the correct view, the view of emptiness.

The totality of these trainings as well as the totality of the grounds and paths is what is referred to by the term path in this context. And the root of the path, Lam Gyi Tsawa refers to the cause or the foundation of this path which is none other than reliance on a fully qualified spiritual teacher. Generally speaking, this is what is meant by a spiritual teacher who is an authentic foundation for practice. Now the doubt may arise in this context whether a Mahāyāna spiritual teacher must necessarily be able to teach the totality of the teachings leading to full enlightenment. This is not necessarily the case.

What is however necessary is that such a spiritual teacher have experience based on training in bodhicitta either by means of the sevenfold cause and effect instruction or by means of the training of the interchange of self and others in the elements of the path which he chooses to teach. This is why to practice that foundation of the path which is the method of reliance on the spiritual teacher, it is said one must train in the root thereof which is faith. Here it is the training in faith which is the foundation for such practice. You might wonder and we are all the same in this matter after all, we go to so much trouble to study renunciation, bodhicitta, the correct view. Why do we need faith on top of this?

Why not just rely on a book, on a text? And it is true that relying on a text, just reading for instance, Lamrim, we can understand the words which refer to renunciation, to bodhicitta, to the correct view and so forth, but not the experience. To actually gain the experience, we must receive teachings from someone who is teaching based on realizations rooted in experience. This we do not get from books. To know the words, to understand the words, don’t need faith.

But the Buddhist path is a path which has two components, a component of faith and a component of wisdom. Both of these must actually be fused, must be made indissociable in one’s practice and for this one needs faith. This is why it is said train in faith. Then faith is counted or counted as very important. And you might wonder what precisely is this faith, this faith which we are talking about.

There are three types of faith. Faith which is rooted in reason, faith of conviction and pure faith. Now in this context, when we refer to a spiritual teacher who is able to teach us the path, we really are referring to a spiritual teacher in the sense in which refers to him in the Essence of Nectar Lamrim as a holy being who is able to teach the supreme path leading to full enlightenment. In other words, as a being who can teach the totality of the path. And reflecting on the various elements of the path ranging from renunciation through love, compassion, bodhicitta, the correct view and so forth, and thinking about them over and again, over and again, eventually we will give rise to a conviction first in the Buddhadharma in general and then within this in the Mahāyāna specifically.

This conviction becomes none other than the faith of conviction. Faith is not a means to give rise to hearing. It is probably not necessary to have faith to engage in hearing or even perhaps in study. Faith is the means to generate experiential realizations. And when one’s faith increases, then in turn one’s desire to study becomes ever more powerful.

The intensity of one’s studies increase and with the increase in the intensity of one’s studies, the experiential realizations increase as well. Without faith, it is therefore not possible to give rise to experiential realizations. This is obviously not the case for perception. We need no faith to be certain of what we see, what we hear, what we smell, what we taste and what we feel through bodily sensation. But faith is necessary to generate conviction in the existence of the realizations of the stages of the grounds and paths of which we have no experience at present.

Reflect on this by yourselves. It is said that a practitioner without faith is akin to a parched seed. If a seed is parched, if it’s bereft of humidity, then that seed cannot sprout. When we generate belief within our mind stream and when we generate faith within our mind stream and we rely on a spiritual teacher, then as this faith increases, we will put ever greater effort in studying what he teaches and we will be ever more enthusiastic in our practice. As a result of this, we will move higher and higher and we will find it easier and easier to generate eventually great realization such as bodhicitta.

The faith which is referred to here eventually moves towards belief and veneration. It is eventually of the nature of veneration and this is what we have to try to generate. As Je Tsongkhapa says, when one who has studied much abandons the Dharma, this is the result of the teachings not dawning as instructions for practice. And this is the crux of the problem. When those who have attended many, many teachings actually abandon the Dharma, it is because they never took it to heart in the first place.

Reflect carefully on the meaning of the second verse. This is the result of the teachings not dawning as oral instructions as instructions. This is therefore the result of the teachings not being seen as instructions to tame one’s own mind. So this is one of Geshe-la’s own doubts and perhaps you have a similar one. This is one of Geshe-la’s doubts because what if he said that through relying on the spiritual teacher, one trains in the grounds and paths.

If we take the case of the Buddhas, it is said that they still rely on their teachers, yet the very definition of a Buddha from the standpoint of the two Tibetan syllables, which means to dispel and which means to enhance, is a being which has dispelled all thoughts and enhanced all qualities measurelessly. It is said by Śākyapandita that one should train in relying on the spiritual teacher in the same way as a swan is able to separate milk from water. It was traditionally said in ancient India that the swan was able to separate milk from water in a mixture of milk and water. And we can understand the level of reliance on a spiritual teacher which is called for through remembering Atisha’s life. It is said in Atisha’s biography that when Atisha had reached 29 years of age, he had 157 spiritual teachers and wishing to attain full enlightenment swiftly.

He swiftly set out trying to find the means to attain full enlightenment and searching high and low throughout the reaches of India, he eventually gained the conviction that no teaching was superior than that of bodhicitta to attain full enlightenment. He then set out on a thirteen month journey to Sumatra to receive the precious instructions on the interchange of self and others directly from Guru Suvarnadvipi. And receiving the oral instructions for training in bodhicitta through the interchange of self and others from such an extraordinarily accomplished practitioner as Guru Suvarnadvipi, Atisha himself quickly gave rise to bodhicitta. For this reason, he viewed Guru Suvarnadvipi as supreme among all his teachers. One of the possible etymologies of lama, guru in Tibetan is la na mepa, which means peerless.

This is not to say that bodhicitta alone was sufficient to attain full enlightenment. bodhicitta has to be accompanied by subsidiary practices such as an understanding of the correct view. And in this regard, the view of Guru Suvarnadvipi was the Cittamātra or the mind only view. Reflect on this carefully because even though Atisha viewed Guru Suvarnadvipi as supreme among his teachers, nonetheless, Guru Suvarnadvipi espoused the lower view of the mind only school. The Cittamātra, the mind only school.

Now by taking him as a teacher, Atisha had already decided to view him as a Buddha. Nonetheless, he maintained his reservations regarding the view. You must understand clearly the distinction between the general and the specific characteristics of the spiritual teacher in this context. What in general, the spiritual teacher must be able to teach the totality of the path all the way up to full enlightenment. In the specific context of a given disciple, it is not necessary for the teacher to be able to teach the totality of the path but only that aspect of the path which the disciple requests him to teach.

In the case of Guru Suvarnadvipi, this would be the teachings of the interchange of self and others. Atisha was a Bodhisattva on the path of preparation who espoused the Mādhyamika view. Whereas Guru Suvarnadvipi for the Bodhisattva espoused the mind only or Cittamātra view. Therefore, from the standpoint of the view, Atisha was superior to Guru Suvarnadvipi. Nonetheless, he relied on Guru Sovanadvipi and took him as a teacher because he received from Guru Sovanadvipi the instructions on the generation of bodhicitta.

Reflect on this carefully. Among the great jewels of ancient India, Guna Prabha, the jewel of Vinaya, Dharmakīrti, the jewel of Buddha logic, Pramāna, and Vasubandhu, the jewel of Abhidharma or Buddhist metaphysics. It is said that Vasubandhu was the spiritual teacher of Ārya Vimuktisena who is referred to in Haribhādra’s commentary on Maitreya’s Abhisamayālamkāra, the so-called commentary which clarifies the meaning. In this commentary, it is pointed out that even though Vasubandhu’s view was the Cittamātra view, the mind only view, He nonetheless had as disciple Ārya Vimuktisena who himself espoused the Mādhyamika view and probably progressed to the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika view. His Holiness the Dalai Lama has pointed out that this is an extremely strong and interesting point because Ārya Vimuktisena recognized Vasubandhu as his teacher even though Vasubandhu’s view was inferior to his simply because it was from Vasubandhu that he received the oral instructions for the generation of bodhicitta. And it was thanks to him that he became an Ārya Bodhisattva.

This points out that a spiritual teacher is not necessarily someone who teaches one everything but only one specific topic. Do you understand? It’s a very delicate point, isn’t it? This is a very delicate and important point because otherwise one might think that one single spiritual teacher must impart to one the totality of the teachings leading to full enlightenment. This is not necessarily the case.

Every teacher from whom we have received some element of training on the path should be seen as our teacher in the same way as Atisha saw Guru Suvarnadvipi as his teacher or Ārya Vimuktisena saw Vasubandhu as his teacher. It is probably for this reason that Atisha had 157 teachers, each of which brought him something different on the path. Now you might wonder since Atisha had 157 teachers, what should be our own position regarding the number of teachers? And there is actually debate between the Kadampa Geshes whose names Geshila does not remember, which is reported in the great treatise on the stages of the path of Je Tsongkhapa. The conclusion of the debate is that when one is a beginner such as ourselves, it is better to have few teachers.

Later on, when one has studied and one thoroughly understands what it means to have a teacher, then it is very useful to have many teachers. So Geshe-la was explaining the foundation for training in the root of the path, reliance on the spiritual teacher. The foundation for training in the root of the path is training in faith. And he would like us at present to reflect on the three categories of faith, how they are to be generated and in turn to reflect on the meaning of love, great compassion and bodhicitta if we are able to generate uncontrived bodhicitta, if we are unable to to at least generate contrived bodhicitta. It would seem that most of you have attended numerous Lamrim teachings and therefore Geshe-la would not enter into great detail.

He would just suggest that you reflect carefully on the fact that when Atisha was 29 years of age, he had 157 teachers in ancient India and had heard every oral instruction of note. Nonetheless, he chose to rely on Guru Suvarnadvipi of Sumatra. Training in the root foundation, the root faith as a means of training in reliance on the spiritual teacher means seeing the spiritual teacher as a Buddha. Now, generally speaking, ideally, we should actually generate uncontrived bodhicitta and gain total realizations on the path. But even if this is impossible, nonetheless generating contrived bodhicitta, we should generate contrived realizations on all the levels of the path.

All of this is contingent on receiving teachings on this topic from the spiritual teacher. In as much as a spiritual teacher has taught all of these topics to us, even should a Buddha actually come, how could we posit a difference between him and the spiritual teacher? This is one way of viewing the spiritual teacher as a Buddha. Otherwise, it will be very difficult for us to do so. There is a passage from sūtra which is of tremendous benefit in this matter.

The Buddha said, I do not cleanse the sins of beings with water nor do I liberate beings with my hand nor for that matter do I transmit my realizations from mind to mind. I liberate beings through teaching suchness. The totality of the benefit the Buddha extends to beings is through teaching the four noble truths. There is no other benefit extended to beings. Then looking at it in this way, we can see the extraordinary benefit we derive from receiving teachings on bodhicitta.

One should think of the kindness of the spiritual teacher as superior to that of the Buddha simply for the reason that when Buddha Śākyamūni taught twenty five centuries ago, we were not there. When Ārya Nāgārjuna and Āryadeva taught two thousand years ago, we were not there. When Atisha and Dromtönpa taught some nine hundred and some years ago, we were not there either nor when Marpa and Milarepa taught nor when Je Tsongkhapa taught. All the teachings we have received, we have received from the spiritual teacher. Therefore, kindness is superior to that of all of the Buddhas.

We should more ever reflect on his benevolence in teaching the Dharma. We can see this from experience if we compare reading by ourself on a topic such as bodhicitta in the text and then receiving instruction from the teacher. It is very difficult to gain any type of realization through just reading. Then that will be it for tonight. If you have questions, please feel free to ask them.

Have any more questions? I have a doubt which is it seems odd that Atisha would have 157 teachers and not one of them could teach him on the interchange of self and others? Yes. The instructions, the oral instructions on the interchange of self and others were not existent in India at that period. What is the relation between conventional bodhicitta and ultimate bodhicitta such that the view is not important?

The the the view the view espoused by the master is not important relative to the teachings on conventional bodhicitta? I misread your question, my apologies. There is a distinction between those of course and or those of limited and of sharp acumen regarding the mode of training in the mind which realizes emptiness. Indeed, ultimate bodhicitta is a mind which realizes emptiness. But Atisha himself was of sharp acumen.

Being of sharp acumen, it is probable that first he realized emptiness and then after realizing emptiness searched out instructions for generating bodhicitta. Unlike beings of limited acumen who first must generate bodhicitta and then receive instructions on generating, on realizing emptiness. Geshe-la suspects that your doubt is that instructions on ultimate bodhicitta are less important than instructions on conventional bodhicitta since Atisha relied on Guru Suvarnadvipi whose view was inferior to his own. In Atisha’s case, what happened is that as Atisha was of subtle faculty or subtle acumen, he realized emptiness first and then setting out for those specific instructions on generating conventional bodhicitta relied on Guru Suvarnadvipi. Doubt.

Have you doubt? Conventional bodhicitta. Conventional bodhicitta. Is ultimate bodhicitta as in English. Problem.

No problem. Alright. Asked us to reflect on the three types of faith. Could we please have them again? The first being faith rooted in reason, the second in conviction.

What is the third? So I’m sorry, the listing is a little bit different from the one I gave you. You have three faiths. The first is a faith of conviction rooted in reason. The second is pure faith and the third is faith which aspires to realization.

The first of these faiths, the faith of conviction rooted in reason would for instance be a faith which is convinced of the benefit of training in renunciation and bodhicitta when after training initially in renunciation and bodhicitta we see the tremendous benefit for our mind. The second faith, pure faith is the faith which arises when we recollect the qualities of great beings of the past which we have not met such as Je Tsongkhapa and so forth. The third faith which is a faith which wishes for actualization or realization is that faith which wishes to generate within our mind stream renunciation or bodhicitta. There are numerous types of faith apart from these. There is one type of faith very common in Tibet where people have faith in Buddhism and the Buddha simply because their ancestors were Buddhist and have been so for the last one thousand years or so.

This is an extremely unstable and fragile faith which is rooted in nothing. And if you were to ask them to point or to illustrate what the Buddha is, they would probably point at a statue. Best the best faith however is the faith which arises through repeated study and the conviction born therefrom. What are the other questions? Lama Yeshe, who, as Geshe-la knows, was trained at Sera from eighteen months until eighteen years and then left and is now reincarnated.

The quote of Je Tsongkhapa when one who has studied a lot abandons Dharma, this is because the treatises have not dawned as oral instructions applies to someone who even though he or she has become a scholar abandons the teachings. This is not at all the case for the reincarnation of Tenzin Yeshe who did not study a lot at all. He studied a mere one or two years at Sera, which is basically the very beginning of studies and simply was raised there as a child. Right. So the discussion between the Kadampa Geshes was one concerning strong practitioners.

Then a strong practitioner can have as many teachers as he or she wants since he or she will see all of his teachers as of one mental continuum with the root teacher as one with the root teacher. And another? I am applying what I have learnt tonight to eight verses for training the mind which Geshe-la has also taught. In eight verses for training the mind it says that one should regard one’s enemies, someone who has hurt one badly, as one’s spiritual teacher. In what sense my way of reading that is that that person or persons is my supreme teacher in interchange of self and others.

Is this correct? Or is there some other what is the way that I regard this person or persons as my supreme teacher? This teaching in the eight verses is one for Bodhisattvas. Therefore, is difficult for us at present to truly see our enemy, our foe as our spiritual teacher. Initially, we should train in bodhicitta.

And then within the context of training in forbearance, we should indeed see our foes as our teachers and on this basis, we can progress from realization to realization. Oh, yeah. Finish. Hello. Come on.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top