KI Retreat — 17. Day 3 Teaching morn

2 h 1 min · 5,636 words · 2005 · Buddha House Adelaide

KI Retreat (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
KI Retreat (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
KI Retreat — 17. Day 3 Teaching morn
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this two-hour morning teaching during a Karmapa International Retreat, Venerable Thubten Dondrub guides retreatants through core Tibetan Buddhist doctrine on suffering and patience, drawing on a classical commentary. He begins by grounding the session in motivation: understanding why ordinary pleasures trap us in suffering, and why retreatants should approach practice with enlightenment and all beings’ liberation in mind rather than personal gain. He then systematically explains the three kinds of suffering—the obvious pain and hardship, the deceptive “suffering of change” (pleasures that cannot last), and the pervasive suffering that arises from being driven by karma and affliction since beginningless time. He stresses that intellectual understanding alone is insufficient; deep meditative investigation and merit-gathering are required. The teaching moves into patient endurance and the illogic of anger, drawing on verse analysis: neither anger nor its targets arise independently; both stem from conditions, so blaming a person is irrational. Rather, the practitioner should recognize that ignorance—the false perception of inherent, independent existence—is the true enemy, fought not with weapons but through realizing emptiness. Throughout, he emphasizes the distinction between contaminated happiness born of affliction and the uncontaminated happiness of liberation, which requires both bodhicitta and emptiness realization. The session includes student questions on uncontaminated virtue and the paths of practice.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 17. Day 3 Teaching morn.mp3

UUID: e40c0fae-0892-416d-af0f-791c7f6f6fde

Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub

Collection: KI Retreat (Ven Thubten Dondrub)

Date: 2005 (exact day not recorded)

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 121.8 minutes

Words: ~5,630

So, Geshe-la was quoting a verse that I couldn’t remember which verse it was, but he was explaining the whole meaning of the verse. So it goes something like this life, this precious human rebirth with all the eight freedoms and the ten advantages that we have, is very difficult to find, and it’s very easy to lose, because it’s impermanent and so forth. And then, you know, in order to gain such a human rebirth as we ourselves have gained, we have had to to accumulate great great sums of merit and virtue. And then so now we should how do you say? So and then we find in we find in this life, we find a lot of happiness.

Again, I explained it was samsaric happiness, and then all these things towards all these things, develop a lot of attachment, and we shouldn’t. We should avoid developing attachment to all these things because while we develop attachment, we will engage in many, how to say, unwholesome activities and so forth. Geshe-la says that so in this life, we find all all these these happinesses, all these things that make us happy. And then and then we we how to say, we work hard to achieve all these these happinesses. And then, again, I explained that it’s due to attachment to this life that we we have we we labor so hard in order to achieve all these samsaric happinesses.

So, and then we work, we strive to achieve happiness for the sake of this life only. And then doing so while we’re doing so, we that we’re not how to say? We are not really practicing good Dharma. So then we So we we we shouldn’t we shouldn’t work for for the for finding benefit to this life alone. In this life alone, we should think of engaging in whatever whatever virtues we’re engaging in, we should think of of of our future lives and and liberation and enlightenment of working for for that for those reasons, So then, Geshe-la says, we should we should not engage in any activities just for the sake of this life.

We are going to achieve very, very small results. And then we should think before engaging virtuous activities, again, should think of doing these virtuous activities for the sake of achieving enlightenment and liberation. Then we can create a lot of virtue. So then the guy is is saying that we we all came here to this place and and for for this five or six days to study the dharma, and then he says, but we shouldn’t we shouldn’t be doing that just for the sake of this life alone. We should we should be doing it thinking of we are now studying the dharma in order to achieve enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings.

Like that we should think. So he says, we should we should always give rise to to a proper motivation, a good motivation. He’s asking venerable if if you if you have been doing that, if you have been giving rise to this motivation altogether in the meditation. Yes, yes, we spend quite a bit of time. That’s very good.

So he says that if if you if you if you manage to to how to say give rise to to this good motivation or decision, it’s no problem if we if we don’t do a very good job. So we should think that before engaging in any virtuous activity, we should think now I’m going to engage in this activity in order to achieve enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. So then we we go back to the commentary right after verse the twenty first verse, which is relating related to the topic of extensive explanation on on the meditation teachings on suffering. And so the commentary goes on to explain the verse, and it first first says that meditation on on on the on suffering is an extremely important practice. So Geshe-la is going further into the the topic of meditation and suffering.

He’s saying, what meant with meditation on suffering? He says, we should think analytically about the various kinds of suffering. There are and he he Geshe-la mentioned that there are three kinds of suffering, and then we should think over and over again over these different kinds of suffering. So there is, Geshe-la explains that there are two kinds of meditation, one is analytical meditation and the other one is how do say concentration meditation? Stabilizing meditation.

And he says that the meditation of suffering is of the first kind, is analytical meditation. It is not stabilizing meditation. So so Geshe-la explains so meditation on on suffering is analytical meditation on suffering, and then that means that we should learn what suffering is. We should understand what suffering is. And Geshe-la says there are three kinds of suffering, and these three kinds are the suffering of suffering, the suffering of change, and or pervasive suffering?

Compounded pervasive suffering. Compounded pervasive suffering. Loss. This one? So, again, say, what is the suffering of suffering?

The suffering of suffering, there are there are so many kind sufferings of suffering. There is we we get sick. We we find with we meet with hard situations like cold or heat and so forth. We meet with those things that we do not wish to meet and and so forth. This all this suffering is suffering is very easy.

The last phase is not difficult to see. We just look at our lives and we will be able to understand that. So Geshe-la is explaining what is the the suffering of change. He says it’s it’s more difficult to understand what the suffering of change is about, but he gives an example. For example, when we buy a nice house and we have good food and so forth, and we are happy and satisfied with that.

And we say, oh, this is all good. And so but that that happiness, those all those things, and all those things, they are, in fact, the suffering of change because they cannot remain the same. They are bound they are bound to change into something else. So, all those things, they are actually suffering, but because we don’t know that, we don’t understand that, then we we strive. We do everything we can to to acquire those those things that give us this samsaric happiness.

So, see Geshe-la says that we see all these things that bring us this samsaric happiness as having the nature of happiness, but in fact they do not have because they change into something else. Then Geshe-la further explains that all these things, they arise from from karma and afflictive emotions and thoughts. So mean, actions, activities, afflictive emotion, thoughts. So after we see something that we are attached to, and then we grasp at it. So this this is the afflictive emotion grasping and attachment will be the afflictive emotion or thought.

And then out of that, we start we start to to to, how do say, to strive in order to to keep it or to acquire more of it, and that would be the action that follows, how to say, the afflictive emotion or thought. And in this way, all these things are in the nature of suffering and and not happiness. So Gela is explaining now compounded, all pervasive suffering. So Geshe-la says that it refers to cyclic existence. It says that cyclic existence is all in cyclic existence is pervaded by this compounded suffering.

So, because everything everything from beginningless time has arisen, arisen from, how do you say, actions and and afflictive emotions and thoughts. So from from from the beginning, it has been like that, from afflictive emotion and thoughts up until now. So so then everything in in the whole cycle of existence, because of that, is is pervaded with suffering. The uninterruptedly So through all this time, uninterruptedly, we have been, how’s it, overpowered by karma and afflictive emotions and thoughts from since beginningless time also. And then, yeah, we have absolutely, I think, completely no no independence no independence whatsoever.

So can I can I say that so continually, I mean, uninterruptedly, have been overpowered by by this karma and afflictive emotions and this, and but this is very difficult to to see, to understand? Also, I’d say the suffering of change is also very difficult to see and understand. We are very habituated to think, thinking that all these things that we have, are happiness and so forth. So, they are very difficult. We have to meditate a lot and put a lot of effort and study.

And he says furthermore that if we don’t, not understanding these sufferings, both the suffering of change and compounded pervasive suffering, there is no way we can achieve liberation and enlightenment. So, Geshe-la, it’s easy to understand the suffering of suffering, so that is obvious. So what we need to put effort in analyzing and investigating and studying is the suffering of change and compounded or pervasive suffering. And then, yeah. So we need to study very hard and meditate very hard, and yeah.

And that’s what we we have to we we are trying to do even now. Yes. So, yeah, first I forgot to mention that also besides studying and meditating, investigating, should also Geshe-la said we should also accumulate a lot of merit. And then now Geshe-la comes to explain that, for example, food, for example, so delicious food that we we have or whatever it is that we have that we we find it we believe it to be in the nature of happiness, and Gela explains this is samsaric happiness. This is the happiness of cyclic existence, and the happiness of cyclic existence is in the nature of suffering.

So so all this samsaric happiness, all these things that give us samsaric happiness, we we out of attachment for them, we will engage in all these activities, in all sorts of actions to obtain them or to keep them, and all these actions and activities, I mean, the How to say? Through these actions and activities, we accumulate the causes of more the causes of more of saṃsāra or cyclic existence. So, Geshe-la says, so far we not experienced any real happiness. I mean, not in this life, not as gods or anything else. Have we ever experienced real happiness, only the happiness of cyclic existence, which is in the nature of suffering.

I just say, furthermore, Geshe-la says that the only real happiness there is, is the happiness of liberation and enlightenment. So then Gela says that because we have never experienced the happiness of liberation and enlightenment, then we don’t really know what it is. But Gela goes on to explain that happiness of freedom and enlightenment is is called uncontaminated happiness as opposed to to contaminated happiness, and contaminated refers again to to karma and afflictive emotions. So the happiness that we experience very much that we experience all the time, the only happiness that we experience all the time is this contaminated happiness that arises from karma and afflictive emotions. So, Geshe-la says that we shouldn’t most of the time, engage whatever activity we engage in in meditation and studying and so forth, are doing for the sake of this life, for this contaminated happiness, and then that will bring only the causes of more suffering, cyclic existence, and so forth, then we shouldn’t, how do say, engage in any activities for this purpose.

We should we should engage in activities for the purpose of attaining non contaminated happiness, which is liberation and enlightenment. So Gela is Gela is saying that while we we strive to achieve all the pleasures and and and and and whatever objects and material possessions for the sake of this life. And then we are doing it we are doing it out of of attachment. And then out of attachment, we engage in all these contaminated activities that we would generate only more more will give continuity to more to to cyclic existence. So he explains that contaminated contaminated happiness comes out of, how to say, action.

The word is le, which is karma, which is activity activity together with afflictive emotions or thoughts. And then these two together, they give rise to the samsaric happiness which is in the nature of suffering. And then non contaminated happiness is is activity again, is the same word, is activity or action or karma that is associated with non afflicted non afflicted mind. So this non afflicted mind, Geshe-la explains, is a mind that has with faith aspires to achieve liberation and enlightenment. So these two minds and if you if you generate these minds, and then and then you engage in an activity, and then you you are accumulating, how to say, uncontaminated the causes for uncontaminated happiness to come about.

So then then last is that we should we should not we should not try try to accomplish this samsaric happiness by any means, and we should we should only as the text say, this meditation on on suffering is very important because we should we should only strive, how to say, to achieve this uncontaminated happiness of of liberation and enlightenment. Uh-huh. This one? Ticks. Oh, yeah.

So then we’re on the text, and then it’s commentary on the verse. So it’s saying, what are the qualities of the mind that sees the faults shortcomings of the faults of suffering. Right? So, the first one, it says is, how do say, by the force of suffering by by the force of the by experiencing suffering, we are, how to say, we are disheartened, disheartened, and then, let’s say, pride and conceit and so forth are are, how do you say, diminished loss. So, Geshe-la briefly explains that pride is is that state of mind that thinks of oneself as better than any others.

Like, if if so if, for example, if somebody who is rich and healthy and strong and so forth will think of himself as better than anyone else. But if he understands the nature of suffering, as Geshe-la has explained, three sufferings and so forth, if he understands that, he will realise that, in fact, there is no no no there is no no real reason for him to to be to be proud because he’s suffering as everybody else. So the text, Gela follows is following the text. So the text goes on to say that having experienced suffering and then seeing it on others, we wish others to be we have the thought, we think we wish others to be separated from it. Then that’s and that that’s that thought that wishes others to be separated from from suffering is is called compassion.

And on top of that, Geshe-la says, Geshe-la explains that following this, we also generate, how to say, loving kindness, which is the thought that wishes all other sentient beings to be to have the causes of happiness. So then then Geshe-la says explains one word. There is a drowa, which is usually in English translated translated as migrators. And he says that migrators are all those who are in cyclic existence by the force of karma and negative afflictive emotions and thoughts and so forth. And then, so to those towards those those beings, we generate we generate we can generate compassion if Geshe-la says we understand, we have studied and understood these three kinds of suffering.

So the text goes on to explain that suffering, that those sufferings are the results, are the effects of non virtue, and seeing that we have a mind that does not wish any more suffering, we avoid any negativities. Then Gela explains that this suffering that is being mentioned here is of the first kind, is the suffering of suffering. So, yeah. So then the text follows on to to explain that not wishing suffering and wishing happiness, wishing to meet with happiness, then we see the, how to say, the effects. We we see the the effects of virtuous deeds, and then we we how to say, the the the liking a liking for for virtuous deeds arises in us.

So then Geshe-la explains this line is mentioning happiness. Right? He’s saying that virtuous deeds are the cause of happiness and seeing that we create our liking for virtuous deeds. So then, Geshe-la explains again that there are two kinds of happiness, and this line refers to both kinds of happiness. So one kind of happiness is the contaminated happiness, which is a virtuous deed together with an afflicted mind.

And then the other kind of happiness, which is uncontaminated happiness, which is a virtuous deed together with a non contaminated mind, a virtuous mind also. So then we go to we start again with a whole lot of divisions. We I mentioned it before. It’s a second division, it’s one of the second major divisions, it’s called cultivating patience that is intent on the Dharma, Right? And then that again has two parts to it.

The first one is an extensive explanation and the second one is a synopsis. So then the the and then the first one, which is the extensive explanation, has three parts to it. And the first part is okay, as anger, the one who is angry and etcetera and so forth, all of them rely upon causes, so they are not independent. Okay? So in the second part okay, the first part was what I just mentioned now.

The second part is, again, those causes those causes also are not independent. Right? The causes of anger and the one who has anger, they are also not independent. That’s the second topic. So the and the third topic is is called the need to overcome anger or to oppose anger.

So, okay, there’s three divisions to the extensive explanation, right, of the topic, the patience intent on Dharma. And then the first division, which is anger, the one who is angry and so forth rely upon causes, so they are not independent. So this first topic, again, has two parts to it, which are the first one would be neither anger nor the one who is angry are independent, and their causes and conditions are also not independent. That’s the second topic. So then the first topic, which is neither anger nor the one who is angry are independent, has three parts to it.

And then so the first part is the reasons why Okay. The reason why it is it is the reasons why it is unreasonable to be angry at an afflicted person. And then the second part would be anger is not willingly developed. And the third would be the shortcomings, faults faults in general. They arise from causes and conditions, so they are also not independent.

Okay? So the first one, which is So the first one, which is the reasons why it is unreasonable to be angry at an afflicted person, right, goes on like this. The text the text the commentary goes on to ask if we to say if if we we say if we say that it is alright to to be angry at somebody, someone or something that causes us harm, and then and then the text follows into the next verse, which is verse twenty two. It goes something like and now I’m following Stephen Batchelor’s translation. It goes something like, as I do not become angry with great sources of suffering such as bile disorders, then why be angry with animate creatures?

So it’s just the the first three lines of the verse. Okay? So so then then Geshe-la goes into the commentary, and he says so the commentary goes on to say, if we say it is unreasonable right? So first, we we said the text went on to say, if we say that it is reasonable to be angry at at an external phenomena that causes us harm. So why it is not reasonable, the commentary goes on to say.

Why it is not reasonable? So in this case, jaundice and so forth, and Gela explains that so forth here is referring to not only diseases, but it’s also referring to afflictive thoughts and emotions. So all these all these things that cause a lot of commotion and disharmony and so forth, and then from which great suffering arises. It is so we don’t So so so because we don’t get angry with those with those things, with, let’s say, those those those sicknesses and those states of mind and so forth, So why why do we get angry with with a sentient being? So then the text goes on and says jaundice and so forth, they are they arise out of conditions.

They come out of conditions, causes and conditions, Geshe-la explains. And then so they are they are not they are not independent, and that being so, we do not get angry with them. So if we say that, then also we shouldn’t get angry with people, for example. We shouldn’t get angry with people. It’s not reasonable to get angry with people.

And Geshe-la explains because people too, they arise out of causes and conditions. So then we get into the next verse, I mean, the last line of verse twenty two and into the whole of verse twenty three. So the last line of verse twenty two goes to say that they they are provoked they too are provoked by conditions. So it’s they they is referring to to the animate creatures of the last verse, the last three lines that were read before. And then the verse goes on to to put forth an analogy that says, although they are not wished for, these sicknesses arise.

And then in the same way, although although they are not wished for, this disturbing afflictions, so to say, forcibly arise. Okay. So then Gela commented on top of that, on top of this verse, that when we get angry, we get angry out of an afflictive emotion, which is which is caused which comes out of causes and conditions. So even though how do you say? Even when somebody does some harm to us, we to think that this person is doing it out of an afflictive emotion again, that comes out of causes and conditions.

And so, in fact, there is nothing there for us to get angry with. So then the the the commentary goes on. So, it goes on to say that because all those beings, all those people who are afflicted by negative thoughts and emotions, because all of them are impelled by the conditions which are those negativities, those negative afflictive thoughts and emotions. So those beings, they are not independent.

They don’t have independence. Right? The so they are not doing this, meaning that they are not doing these things out of their own they’re not wishing to do these things. That’s what Geshe-la explains. They’re not wishing to do these So, for example, even if we do not wish, when all the conditions are complete, when all necessary conditions are present, then a certain disease will come about.

And like that, so even though we don’t want to get angry at a certain at a certain being or person by force of causes that are, how do you say, a distressed mind and so forth, by force of such causes, afflictive emotions will forcibly come about. So and then the the commentary goes on to finish this part, saying that if if you get angry, then get angry at the afflictions. It’s alright to get angry at the afflictions, but it’s not alright to get angry at the person. So we should get angry at the what what is afflicting the person, no? The person is gonna say this.

So can I can I say that, okay, when when the text mentions that we should get angry at the afflictions, he says, we shouldn’t get angry like with any affliction? We should get angry specifically with ignorance, because all other afflictions, they arise from ignorance, then which is which is, I’d say, a mistaken a mind that has a mistaken knowledge that, for example, thinks that something that that something that is not thinks of it as as as being, if if or or of something that is, think think of it as not being. Okay? So this kind of mind is what we have to be angry with, Geshe-la says. So Geshe-la says that this ignorance is what we have to engage in.

We have to fight with this ignorance, and then we don’t fight with ignorance with using weapons or clubs or sticks and so forth. We have to fight, how do say, we have to fight through understanding, understanding what specifically it says, understanding, for example, that this ignorance is a mind, how do you say, with a mistaken knowledge, we have to find it, fight it, for the realization of emptiness, for example, by realizing emptiness, and then we eliminate this mind with mistaken knowledge. And then also, we eliminate the grasping mind, and eliminating all of these for the understanding of emptiness, whatever action we engage in will not bring about will not be contaminated by afflictive emotions and thoughts, and will not bring about any more suffering. So then Geshe-la goes on to elaborate for another line of of reasoning that if if we have a particular object, and then not knowing the nature of this object because because of being afflicted with ignorance, and then we we develop attachment, we we grasp at this object, and and a lot of negativities and afflictive emotions will follow after that. And then, so this ignorance that we have to fight with, we have to fight it realizing for the realization of emptiness, and realizing emptiness, we will understand the nature of of the object, and we won’t attachment won’t come about, we won’t grasp to it, and so forth.

This one. So so knowing the nature of the of the object of of the objects, and then and then afflictive emotions won’t won’t come about. So, Geshe-la says, we have to think that in order to achieve liberation, in order to achieve enlightenment, we have to develop the mind of enlightenment but also it’s necessary to, how do say, to realize emptiness. So Geshe-la explained that So he says that all all phenomena, they So says the line says that all phenomena appear to us as So all phenomena appear to us as existing from their own side. So and this is this is this is the ignorance that we we have to fight with, and then Geshe-la explains that.

We have to understand that, in fact they do not exist from their own side, the way they appear to us. They do not exist from their own side. So then we have to realize that all these phenomena do not exist in the way they appear to us, as being existing from their own side. And then we have to realize emptiness. Realizing emptiness is realizing that, that they do not exist the way they appear to us.

So then if we can realize that ignorance that sees objects as existing from their own side, the way they appear, if we can realize emptiness that eliminates this ignorance, then how do say, afflictive emotions will not follow. If afflictive emotions do not follow, then contaminated activity will not follow, and then non virtue will not follow. So if so we go into the second division, which is anger is not willingly developed, is the name of the title of the topic. And then the text goes on to say, if we say if we say that it is alright to get angry with with the being who is causing me harm, and and that it’s it’s not alright it’s not alright to get angry with with the afflictive emotions. If we say that, and then the text follows into the next verse, verse twenty four.

So the next verse So then then the next verse goes on goes on like this. Without thinking that I will be angry, people become angry without any resistance. And without thinking that I should produce myself, likewise anger itself is produced. So, Geshe-la explains that anger does not arise out of one’s will, out of one’s wish for it to arise.

It arises when all the causes and the conditions are present, and then it will inevitably arise. It is beyond our power to to decide if it’s going to arise or not, to make it arise or not. And then the same goes yeah. Well, that’s it. Yes.

So then the the commentary goes on to explain the verse. It’s just saying that by the causes, not thinking, So not thinking not thinking not giving rise to the thought that things may give rise to all the causes of of anger, then the causes, all these causes of anger, they are complete, only when they are complete by themselves, then then then anger will arise. So it’s like and then So, yeah, it says but it’s basically saying it is it’s not our choice. It is not for us to think or may the causes of anger arise, because they won’t arise. They will arise only when all the causes and conditions are present by themselves.

And then, again So, again, the same goes for the afflictive emotions and thoughts. So, it’s not up to us it’s not up to us to think that may the afflictive emotions arise, no, they they will anger and so forth, they will arise, they will come about, how to say, independent independently of our of our will. And because of that, So and then so and then it goes to conclude. So because of all that, then it is clear that half of it is a person, and the other half of these conditions are the afflictive emotions.

So it is not there’s no reason for us to get again, there’s no reason for us to get angry at a person because it’s only half of the whole collection of causes and conditions necessary for the rise of those afflictive emotions. Yeah. So Try it. Yeah. If you have any questions now.

Have a question. Could you clarify? Seems a little bit unclear about the uncontaminated virtue and so on. Isn’t uncontaminated virtue created when the mind is free of ignorance? Okay.

So yes, uncontaminated happiness. Right? So Geshe-la says, yes. You have to realize emptiness in order to to have, to obtain uncontaminated happiness. It is based on the realization of emptiness.

It’s an is liberation and and enlightenment. He says. You were talking about the creating of this contaminated virtue and uncontaminated virtue, right? Virtue you mentioned. Yes.

So doesn’t this have to be done? An uncontaminated virtue has to be created with the mind free of ignorance, doesn’t it? Yeah. Again, I again, I’m saying that again, I’m saying maybe I didn’t convey the meaning properly. Again, I’m saying that uncontaminated non contaminated happiness is necessarily follows the realization of emptiness.

Before that, there’s nothing there’s no obtaining uncontaminated happiness without the realization of emptiness. Yes. Try try again. Put it this way: Myself, I have ignorance and delusions. Can I create uncontaminated virtue as I am now, right now, today?

So what he says that, no, you cannot get that virtue or that uncontaminated happiness, but you can collect the causes. What you can do is collect the causes for it, to achieving it in the future. The causes for what? This happiness or the virtue? Both, he says.

Create the causes for the virtue? Yes. What does that mean? So, yeah, well, he he’s saying he’s saying talking about uncontaminated happiness yet. I’m not asking about it.

Yeah, know. Know. I’m not asking about it. Uncontaminated. I know.

karma. karma. That’s what I’m asking about. Yeah, yeah. Not that way.

Yes, you can accumulate, attain this uncontaminated virtue, but you cannot attain the uncontaminated happiness. Yes, but how can you do the uncontaminated le? That What is it? Uncontaminated virtue, Yes. Okay.

Let’s see. Let’s see. Is that you need you need two things to to accomplish non contaminated virtue. So one of them is is is virtue, a virtual activity. And then sorry.

Excuse me. So So okay, so, a bit confusing, but, so he said that we need a mind that is uncontaminated and virtuous, that has these both aspects. That is something that can only be accomplished from the paths of seeing onwards. But then he says that the causes of uncontaminated virtues we can accumulate. Next time, this lunch.

Yeah, if you want later, you want to come back to this later, no worries. So that So Virtuous le creates gewa. Right? Virtuous le creates gewa. Right?

Virtuous? Virtuous activity, virtuous karma. Oh, virtuous lei. Yes. Yes.

Creates merit. Oh, virtue. No, maybe Are you Is she calling What is virtue? What’s this Tibetan word you’re calling? Gewa.

Gewa. Gewa. This is going to go too long. So, yes. So this the cause of this uncontaminated virtue is, for example, meditating on having a mind that aspires to enlightenment and so forth.

Yeah. He says meditating on the mind of enlightenment is both the cause of attaining uncontaminated happiness and uncontaminated virtue. Yes, yes. Okay.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
eight freedoms dalwa gyä (Tib)
The eight states a perfect human rebirth is free of: birth as a hell being, hungry ghost, animal or long-life god; as a barbarian; in a dark age when no buddha has come; with wrong views; or with impaired faculties. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top