VenNamgyel Thought Transformation — 08 generosity2

52 min · 6,717 words · Buddha House Adelaide

VenNamgyel Thought Transformation (Ven Lobsang Namgyel)
VenNamgyel Thought Transformation (Ven Lobsang Namgyel)
VenNamgyel Thought Transformation — 08 generosity2
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 52-minute teaching on generosity, Ven Lobsang Namgyel guides practitioners through the structural pillars of the practice: four excellent factors that transform giving into merit, three supreme qualities that elevate it to a bodhisattva’s action, and—for advanced students—six supreme qualities encompassing the full scope of the six perfections. He walks through each pillar concretely: the four factors (giving from the heart, protecting merit from anger and regret, purifying the mind of wrong motivation, and dedicating the merit); the three supreme qualities (bodhicitta-based motivation, wisdom perceiving emptiness to counter self-grasping, and immediate dedication to enlightenment for all beings). He explains the three circles of emptiness—the giver, gift, and recipient all lack inherent existence—using modern examples like the illusory value of money to make the teaching vivid. The final section addresses outer and inner generosity, noting that physical gift-giving requires wisdom about timing, recipient readiness, and harm to others, while inner generosity (giving body and flesh) is only for advanced practitioners with great compassion. Throughout, he emphasizes that understanding these frameworks turns even small acts into vast causes for enlightenment and benefit to all sentient beings.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 08 generosity2.mp3

UUID: 9f5ed117-2082-4c17-bfa5-b48f821ba9ef

Teacher: Ven Lobsang Namgyel

Collection: VenNamgyel Thought Transformation (Ven Lobsang Namgyel)

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 52.6 minutes

Words: ~6,712

Okay. So I’ll try and finish as quickly as possible. I want you to go home. Don’t want to keep you here all night. In future, I’ll try and finish by nine o’clock, but you know the first night it’s always like this.

All those prayers. So, in order to make the practice of generosity very good, you want to incorporate four, it’s what’s called four excellent factors. So you need four excellent factors. The first one is giving. So you’re practicing generosity, and then you’ve got to practice giving.

So from the heart, you train to give your body without any regret. And I’ll I’ll explain this in a minute. So from the heart, train to give your body without any regret. The second factor is protecting. So protecting is you protect the merit from delusions such as anger or regret because you don’t want to give and then afterwards you get angry about it or you have regret because you’re going to take away the power of the action, the power of giving.

So be careful to protect your merit from delusions, and then you need to protect your body until it’s the right time to offer. You don’t want to offer your body until it’s the right time. The third one is purifying. This is the action which is made perfect by purifying the mind of wrong motivation and delusions. And you don’t use your body to pursue non virtue.

So don’t use your body for harm. And the fourth factor is increasing. This is that you dedicate all the merit to all beings for enlightenment, And you use your present body to gain the eight special attributes of precious human rebirth. Do you know in the Lamrim where it gives the qualities of precious human rebirth, there’s eight special qualities and ten freedoms and eight endowments. That’s what it’s talking about.

Okay? So if you don’t know, you have to look it up. There’s your homework. Homework. So use your body in order to gain those eight special attributes, which are is in the, Lamrim under precious human rebirth.

Could you Google it? You could probably Google it. Am shocked that in this holy environment somebody would come in here and say, you can Google it. Would we do something like that? I use Google quite a lot for that sort of thing, actually.

If I can’t figure it out, I Google it. Google it. Yeah, yeah. I’m sure you’ll find an answer. But, you know, it’s in any Lamrim book, you’ll find it.

It’s not something difficult to find, but it’s something that you should be reading because then you need to look at what are the qualities that you have as a human that you don’t realize you have because you don’t know about it? Right? So by you having to Google it and you find the answer, you’ll never forget, isn’t it? Whereas if you just told the answer, think, oh yeah, that was obvious. So by using these four excellent factors, your generosity becomes a bodhisattva’s action, and you will accumulate far greater merit.

Okay? So having these four factors will help you to become wiser in your action, because we want to use every action of generosity as a cause for achieving a lot of merit, as a cause for gaining enlightenment, as a way of benefiting all sentient beings. Isn’t it? Then our life is worthwhile. Okay, so you clear about those four?

Everybody’s okay? Okay, I haven’t finished. Now you’ve got three supreme qualities. So you write this down and then I’ll tell you why you’ve got all of this. So three supreme qualities.

The first one is reliance, Reliance. You rely on bodhicitta as a motive for generosity. So before giving, check your motive. This seems obvious, but we forget. So you need to be told.

The second one is supreme method. So the first one was, why are doing it? The second one is, how do you do it? Supreme method. While giving, you have to conjoin that action with the wisdom perceiving the lack of inherent existence of phenomena.

Simple, right? Have you written that down? The wisdom perceiving the lack of inherent existence of phenomena. So usually we say emptiness, but I’m sorry to say, I think the word emptiness is very confusing for beginners who when they hear the word emptiness think they know what emptiness means. Emptiness doesn’t mean there’s no tea in the cup.

Right? So this word emptiness means lack of inherent existence. Something, an object, or a person which is lacking inherent existence. So whenever you say wisdom or emptiness, you should always think, what does that mean? It means lacking inherent existence.

So what does lacking inherent existence mean? Then you think there is a self who’s giving, there is an object that I’m giving, and there’s a person that I’m giving to. That’s how we think. Okay? So you think, I’m giving to you this object.

So if you don’t remember the three circles of emptiness, then you think, I’m giving to you, and I’m great because I gave it. I’m a good person. Now we have to think, the I which is giving is empty of inherent existence. It lacks inherent existence. There is no self which is giving.

So this is hard for some of you. Anyway, this is the weekend. Don’t worry. There is no self which is giving. Because you might think, I am giving, so I is a great person.

I’m a really wonderful person because I’m giving. So the act of giving actually makes you more egotistical. Buddhist practices reduce the ego. So you don’t want to increase the ego by giving. So the So reduce the ego.

Then, if I don’t exist, the self doesn’t exist, then how can the other self exist, the person that you’re giving to? If you can’t find your own self, then the other person doesn’t have a self either. That’s logical. If I don’t have it, they don’t have it. So I’m empty of inherent existence.

They’re empty of inherent existence. And then, where is the intrinsic existence of the object? The object that we think is valuable. Where’s the value in the object? So take a hundred dollar note.

Right? You think, oh, this is a hundred dollars dollar note. I’m giving this hundred dollar note, but where is the value in the note? Is there value in the note? If there was intrinsic existence of money, of value in the note, somebody coming from a country where they’ve never seen this note before would know that this note, this piece of paper with printing, has value.

Somebody coming from another planet, you know, in their spaceship, when they arrive and we hand them money, they would know what money is. But it’s a convention. It’s something that’s acknowledged as a convention. We know what it means because we work with it every day, and that’s why we give importance to it. And it’s supposed to have the equivalent amount of gold in the bank to ensure that this hundred dollar note really is worth a hundred dollars, isn’t it?

It used to be there was gold worth a hundred dollars securing that hundred dollar note. And so it wasn’t an illusion, but now definitely it’s an illusion. Right? The gold’s been sold. It’s gone.

Right? In Australia and New Zealand, I think, they sold it off. Why keep the gold? These people believe there is money in the bank. So off went the gold.

So it is an illusion. It’s all based on a convention that the government say, we guarantee because it’s on there, I will pay the bearer. So this is worth a hundred dollars. But where’s the hundred dollars in the note? Is it in the printing?

Is it in the writing? Where is it? So there’s no intrinsic existence of money in there. It’s something that’s imputed from our side onto the note. And we all agree, and so we stop even thinking about it.

We just use the money as a convention. Right? So there is a conventional truth. There is money there. There is a self there, and there is a person that we’re giving to.

There’s a conventional existence. We’re not saying I don’t exist at all, because that would be wrong, wouldn’t it? I do exist. I am talking. You are listening.

But how do you exist? Then Buddha said, you don’t exist inherently. And inherently means you’re not, an angry person when you say, I am an angry person. I am miserly. I’m a bad person.

I can’t do this. These sort of statements that we make, you are not inherently those things. You are full of potential. Buddha said, you have all the potential to become enlightened. You have all the potential for wisdom and compassion.

And so emptiness, not being inherently existent, means that you have all potential, and no matter what you’re experiencing in that moment, you are not that. It will pass by, but your potential is to achieve enlightenment. So this is, something maybe we need to, revisit because we don’t have much time. So supreme method is, thinking about empty, empty, and the object is being empty. So this is eliminating self grasping.

Self grasping is I’m grasping onto a self, believing that self to exist. Because you grasp onto the self, you believe there is a self, there is a me, there is an I. Me, mine, you, yours. I want, I don’t want. Where do all the problems come from?

Self grasping. From self grasping, we have self-cherishing. So in order to counteract all negativities, we need to look at self grasping. This is the very foundation of all negativities, all delusions. It all comes from there.

This is the hardest, the very I think the most difficult antidote to apply to all the delusions is wisdom Because it completely eradicates all delusion. You know, it’s it’s the big one. But you’re not gonna get it immediately. When you hear these phrases, you go, and you can try and figure out what the words mean. But it’s not that.

It’s many, many years of getting deeper and deeper and deeper. Please remember in the monasteries, they spend five years just studying the text on wisdom. We talk about it for ten or fifteen minutes and people think they’ve got it. So you really need to keep going back to it and revisiting it and meditating on it and gradually approach it, you know, just at the moment, don’t worry about it too much. So we think the self exists, but Buddha said the self is like a rainbow, a mirage.

Remember in that part where we read an aberration of the eye, you know, thinking that, yellow exists, the yellow snow mountain exists because you have hepatitis. So we project these things onto the world, but we project them onto the self. We think the self exists, and then we cling, we grasp onto that self, and then we say, this is mine. That’s yours. I’m giving to you.

So the three circles of emptiness are let it go. Stop grasping. You know, to to say it in a very short way, try and stop grasping in that moment that you’re giving. Let go of yourself and what you’re expecting to get. So give up all expectations.

Give up regret. Give up reputation. Give up anything coming back. Try and give it all up. Just have trust and faith.

It will all be okay. Then the third of the supreme qualities is supreme dedication. So you need to dedicate to enlightenment for you and for all sentient beings to become enlightened. This is very important that when you do any action that immediately you dedicate. You need to put that karma in the bank.

Right? If you don’t, you haven’t said where that karma goes. So you can just go to the top of the building and throw all the money off the top of the building. Because once a delusion appears like an angry state of mind or regret, immediately you can lose the merit if it’s not dedicated. If you’ve dedicated it, you can’t lose it.

So that’s why we say dedicated immediately, just in case a negative state of mind appears. So by using these three supreme qualities, a small act can become a very skillful way to create vast amounts of merit. By incorporating three supreme qualities, you’re able to gain great results with small effort. And then the results, I’ll give you the results from three supreme qualities. What will you get back?

From supreme reliance, the first one, you will achieve an illusory body. Do you know what the illusory body is at the time of death? Your body’s going to disappear. Rainbow body. You’ll disappear into light and you’ll just leave behind your hair and your fingernails.

Great. That’d be nice. Yeah? And people in our time have had this experience of their teachers, and people in the present time having this happen. So it’s not just a story from Tibet, it’s still existing until today that if you’re a good practitioner, then you can dissolve into the illusory body.

You can attain the holy form body of the Buddha and the complete enjoyment and the emanation body of the Buddha. So this is all from supreme reliance. The holy form body body of the Buddha, which is complete enjoyment and the emanation body. Again, if you don’t understand, you can look it up on Google. I just hope that whatever you’re Googling is right.

Also, you know, Venerable Gelton’s first name is Google. Oogle Gyelten. Just giving you extra work. So the second one, method. This gives you Buddha’s mental abidings, which are the nature body and the wisdom truth body.

The nature body and the wisdom truth body. These are mental abidings of the Buddha. Do you have a book on on, the Buddha’s qualities? Mhmm. There’s a very good book by, Geshe Lhundup, which is all about the Buddha’s qualities.

I haven’t found another book which describes every every one of the Buddha’s qualities. You know, why, all these qualities appear, what the karma is for them to appear. I’ll find out the name of the book. I can’t remember, but I’ll find out the name. Then the third one is dedication.

That’s the third, supreme quality. From that, you continually experience wealth and good conditions until enlightenment. And your merit can’t be destroyed by anger or delusions because you’ve dedicated it. It’s like putting a drop of water in the ocean. It will last until the ocean dries up.

I dedicate for myself to become enlightened in order to benefit all sentient beings. Oogle Gyelten has great, great dedications and and motivations. They’re quite lovely. Oh. That’s true.

Yes. And for, you know, yeah, but if you just say, may I achieve enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings and may all sentient beings be alleviated of their suffering or something like that. If you write something down that’s short and then you memorize it, then very quickly, each time you do something really good, dedicate it, you know? Because what I say is that when we do something negative, we rejoice. This is really extraordinary.

If we did something in an angry way, and then we believe that we did it in a very good, angry way, and then we hurt that person, we can think afterwards, well, was good. I was really clever. I said good thing, and I did it in the right way, and da da da. So you really rejoice in the negative, and the very positive, we can feel a bit embarrassed about it. It’s a bit strange, you know?

So when you come into Buddhism, we’re saying the good things rejoice, and the bad things try and remove. It’s actually the other way around, isn’t it? So it’s really good to think about when you’re doing something negative, at least don’t rejoice. If you have a negative thought, don’t rejoice. Regret it.

When you have a positive thought, immediately you think, oh, that’s really nice, and then you dedicate it. Just in a really short way, do a nice dedication. And the the best is, I’m going to become enlightened in order to liberate all sentient beings from their suffering. So then if you practice generosity without the three supreme qualities, the karmic result of the action will be uncertain. This is why you need to know about those three things.

The karmic result will be uncertain. So if you’ve been practicing generosity up till now without the motivation, without the good action, without the dedication, it’s not sure what you’re going to get back from it. The result of generosity may ripen as temporary experience of wealth within cyclic existence. So you can have some temporary good qualities, you know, wealth around you. Or you could get a higher rebirth, but you can’t be sure it’s going to help you to achieve enlightenment.

If you want to make sure that it’s going to help you to achieve enlightenment, you need to dedicate for that. Don’t just leave it out there. You know that, oh, I did a great action and you forget. And we often do. Without supreme dedication, it may be wasted and it could bring no result.

It would be such a shame. So the four excellences and the three supreme qualities are the basic method for practicing pure generosity. This is the basic method. If possible, you should practice each each action of generosity. Now we have six more with six supreme qualities and six perfections.

So if you’re the top practitioner, you’re practicing with six qualities, which I’m about to give you, incorporating the three, but extending it, and you should include all the six perfections in each action. This would be the best practitioner. I think most of us are not. Maybe Rinchen is. Yeah?

Rinchen and his friend. But for the rest of us, we’re just starting. And so to be practical, you have to start in whichever way is appropriate for you. Don’t feel inadequate because you can’t do it all. Okay?

So for advanced students, then you’ll think, oh, this is great. I can do all of this. But if you think it’s too much, try the four excellences or try the three supreme qualities, right? Think think what you can do. And once you do it and once you feel that it’s working for you, you can always extend it.

You can do more. Now the six supreme qualities are the first one, supreme reliance, rely on bodhicitta. Three of these are the same. Okay? So the first one, supreme reliance, rely on bodhicitta.

The second one is supreme object. Make the gift the best possible quality. So the object should be a good quality. So when the person is receiving it, they will enjoy the gift. That’s important, isn’t it?

They don’t notice that it’s been scratched and so you got it cheap. You know, marked down or something like that. So, I think you, okay, you get the point. Okay, so clothes. If you’re giving clothes, give new clothes if you can, or at least give very good clothes.

You know, they’re second hand, give good clothes, but not with big holes in them, stuff like that. If you’re giving food, give fresh and give very good quality. So it’s important to think about the quality of what you’re giving. If you’re giving Dharma teachings, be informative. You should be correct and you should be skilled.

So this is important. Not what you get out of me, but somebody else. In the same way, you like good quality, so do others. Alright? So don’t think you’re the only one who likes good quality and you don’t give it to others.

You use what you know about yourself and give that to others. I always say to people, you like the biggest piece of the cake. Right? When they cut up the cake, immediately your eye zooms into the biggest piece. Well, that’s what the others want.

Right? That’s what they’re looking for. So give that to them. Then the third one is supreme purpose. Supreme purpose is to bring temporary and ultimate happiness to all other living beings.

So even when you’re giving to one, include everybody else. Okay? Temporary and ultimate happiness for all other living beings. When you’re giving to one, remember to give to everybody else. So also, your generosity to one shouldn’t harm anybody else.

So don’t kill a chicken to feed the dog, as an example. I doubt if you would, but be careful that you’re not harming one being in order to give to another being. I heard of somebody the other day, the girlfriend of a man, and she was using her boyfriend’s credit card to pay for drinks for other men that she met in a bar, could come under this heading. I like colloquial examples, you know, things that are up to date, modern. Good?

Yeah. That, be careful, you know. He noticed she keeps taking the credit card and going and buying a round of drinks for all these guys, and he said to her, what are you doing that for? I mean, if you want to practice generosity, use your own money. You don’t take somebody else’s credit card and, right?

The fourth one is supreme method, while you’re giving conjoined with wisdom. So this is the same as the one I explained before. I won’t go all through that again. So supreme method, number four. Number five, supreme dedication.

We already talked about that. The enlightenment of all sentient beings. Number six is supreme purity. So four, supreme method. Five, supreme dedication, same as what we talked about in the three.

Number six is supreme purity. This one we haven’t talked about. Give with an attitude to be free from obstructions to liberation and omniscience. You want to remove all obstacles to you becoming liberated and becoming omniscient. So keep your mind free of negativity while you’re practicing generosity.

Because while you’re doing this practice, a negative mind could arise. So be careful if that mind arises. You have to remove the obstructions. So, these six practices, the first three, sorry, the three supreme qualities that I already told you about are number one, four, and five of the six. So the same ones, number one, number four, and number five are the three.

So number two, number three, and number six are the different ones. Okay? Am I confusing you? Is it okay? I’m trying to speak as quickly as possible.

And then to finish, the six perfections. So when you’re practicing the six perfections, which we’re talking about, you know, today, Saturday, Sunday, each time we’re talking about a different perfection, each time you have to practice all of the perfections with that one that you’re practicing on that day. So today we’re talking about generosity, so you need to practice generosity with generosity. So that means generosity plus generosity equals, you’ve got merit. You’re, developing merit or, accumulating merit.

Then the second one is ethics. So ethics with generosity is you want others to be happy and experience less suffering. So you don’t cause them harm while you’re practicing generosity. So this is practicing ethics with generosity. Then the third one is patience with generosity.

Then you’re patient with any difficulty. And if the person doesn’t like what you’re giving, and they say something hurtful, what did you give this to me for? You don’t lose it. You don’t get angry. You stay calm and peaceful, and you say, well, you can always take it back to the shop and exchange it if you want to.

So don’t get irritable. Don’t get angry. This is the third perfection when you’re practicing the six perfections. It’s perfection of patience with generosity. You don’t respond to a hurtful comment with a hurtful comment.

You don’t get angry if they’re not happy with the, the, the gift. So if the recipient is dissatisfied or they’re critical, you as the giver stay patient. This is really important. The fourth one is joyous effort. So joyous effort and generosity means you bring joy and energy into the situation.

You overcome any laziness holding you back from giving. So you might think, well, it would be really nice to give, but I don’t have much energy for it. So you try and develop some joy and energy when you’re giving. The fifth one is concentration with generosity. So during the time that you’re practicing generosity, you keep your mind tranquil and undistracted.

You need to be mindful and you need to concentrate without agitation or dullness. So these are the two extremes. Your mind can become very agitated. Your mind can become dull. So try and hold your mind in the middle, concentrate and be mindful.

Don’t allow allow your mind to wander. That’s concentration. And then the last one is wisdom, which we already mentioned. So this is using analytical wisdom. So wisdom with generosity.

Use analytical wisdom. What’s the appropriate gift and the circumstances of giving? So you have to look for the right time, the right gift. This is using your wisdom. So use analytical wisdom in order to know what’s the appropriate gift.

And then you think about the three circles of emptiness. So now I’m going to quickly talk about, inner generosity, which is giving of your body and flesh. I thought you’d want to know about that. Very important for you. James, you didn’t know what you’d stumbled into, did you?

Since I mentioned giving your body, it’s important to know what that means. So, inner generosity is giving of body and flesh, and it’s only practiced in very special circumstances. It’s not for you ordinary people. So I think it’s everybody in this room. Don’t go out thinking you can give away your arm and your eyeball and stuff like this.

You have to be a special practitioner, and it’s special circumstances. So we have to think about, whether the time is suitable. So you don’t give your body or your flesh until you have the mind of great compassion. When you have the mind of great compassion, you can do it. Then the purpose must be when it benefits everybody, not just one person.

Okay? So there has to be a greater benefit. So the time, when you have great compassion. The purpose, when it’s going to benefit not just one being, and the recipient has to be somebody who’s not insane or insincere. You don’t want to give away everything you’ve got.

They don’t really want it. Right? So make sure they’re not insane or insincere. So this is inner generosity. And then outer generosity, which is giving things other than the body.

And we might have to avoid this according to the time. So what that means is, you shouldn’t offer dinner for those holding vows not to eat after twelve o’clock. So if there are people who have vows, somebody could be doing a fasting retreat, monks and nuns, then you shouldn’t offer them dinner because it’s not the suitable time. Then the recipient, if a person is vegetarian, you don’t offer meat, and you don’t offer leftovers or unclean food to the ordained. Good news.

Throw all that stuff out of the fridge. Well, we give it to ourselves, don’t we? According according to this, it’s that you shouldn’t give I I know this from the monks and nuns’ vows that you’re not supposed to have leftovers for unclean food. Right? Because everything was the begging bowl.

You ate everything in the begging bowl, and that was it. You didn’t have anything apart from that. So we need to think about this. The third one is, the giver. The giver.

If the giver is free of miserliness, that person should be careful what to give. This sounds strange. If the person is free of miserliness, they should be careful as to what they give. It’s getting darker. I feel my life is coming to an end.

Oh! Yeah. Now it should stop, shouldn’t it? No? One more.

Well done. It’ll it’ll go in a minute. We’ve only got two more minutes. Listen to the dharma. Oh well, an opportunity came and an opportunity lost, isn’t it?

So if the giver is free of miserliness, you should be careful in what you’re giving. For instance, if you have a dharma text and you haven’t finished studying it, and somebody says, give me that dharma text. If you’re free of miserliness, you might just give it, but then you haven’t finished the text. And that text could be the text that takes you to enlightenment. So if you’re free of miserliness, be careful.

If you’re miserly, you should give it, because then the giving of it is going to liberate you and provide you situation, the circumstance to become enlightened because the giving of it is the antidote to your miserliness. So you have to think wisely in the situation whether to give or not to give. Do you have miserliness or not? If you don’t, be careful because you might need the dharma text in order to become liberated and enlightened. And the next one is the object.

Some things are never appropriate for the ordained to give. So for monks and nuns to give, they should never give their robes. So you never give, the three robes because that’s what monks and nuns have to have. And parents shouldn’t give their children for work or for slavery. It sounds incredible in this day and age, work or slavery, but still it happens.

In some countries, there are still children who are slaves and working. So shouldn’t do that. And the last one is purpose. You don’t give poison or weapons when the person asking for them can harm others, can use what they’re asking for to harm others. So if they’re asking you for poison or weapons, you don’t give it because it’s going to hurt others.

So it’s not just that you give anything to anybody because they’re asking for it. You have to use wisdom in order to not harm others. Done. Okay. Any questions?

Is it clear? Yes. Includes oneself. Right? There’s a question that comes up in my mind, like, when you dedicate for all sentient beings It includes you.

Yeah. If you’re dedicating for enlightenment, alright. Right? But if you’re dedicating, may all beings have every, you know, what about this? Is that is that quite okay?

Or is that I guess it depends on the angle the mind’s coming at. I mean I I yeah. Moving it nicely towards myself can be actually it feels a bit negative. Yeah. But if you’re like, okay, give it all to all sentient beings, I’m gonna give it to you.

You know? Yeah. Yeah. Then it feels like, maybe There’s still something in it. There’s still something in it for me.

Yeah. Like, everybody gets everything right. It’s not split evenly. It’s not like the million dollars goes and everybody gets a small piece. Yeah.

Everybody gets all of it. Yeah, yeah. So if I get all the merit too, well then, well then we’re all covered. Yeah. You know?

Yeah, it’s true. Feels not like But it doesn’t feel quite right. But I think that, you know, when we’re dedicating, maybe for a beginner practitioner, we need to say, I want to get it. I want to become enlightened. Because we’re coming from the point of view of the I.

We grasp onto this I. We cherish the I. We very much feel the I exists, don’t we? You know, even right now, if you’ve been studying Buddhism for years, you still think there’s an I that’s going to become enlightened. And so at the beginning of the practices, when you first come into Buddhism, then if you negate the I completely and you just say forget about that I completely, just think about others, I think there is a feeling that arises in the mind that gets quite tight and uncomfortable that says, but what about me?

And then you say, well, but you’re included in all sentient beings. If you say, give the merit to all sentient beings, you are included in all sentient beings. But still there’s that feeling in the person that’s been saying, I, I, I, that because I haven’t said I, maybe I’m missing out in some way. And so I think that the beginner practitioner says, I want to become enlightened in order to benefit and liberate all sentient beings, you know, like that. And then I think that you move along the path a while and then you see, well actually, wouldn’t I rather go slower rather than quicker?

If I was accumulating lots of merit in order to benefit others, would it be better for me to stick around or better for me to get out? And then it comes into these three motivations of whether you’re going to be, the king or the queen, I say now, the boat person or the shepherd. And so in the beginning, we want to be the king or the queen. I’m going in front of all of you, and I’ll be back. You know?

Don’t worry. When I’m liberated, I’ll be back, and I’ll help you all. So this is the lowest motivation. But it’s where we are, where we start from, right? Then the medium motivation is the boat person.

Let’s all go together. I don’t like the idea of going alone, leaving you behind. So why don’t we just all go together like being in a boat? And then the highest motivation is the shepherd or the shepherdess who makes sure everybody is safe, gets them inside the fence, locks the gate, and then says, Oh, now I can relax. So this is actually the highest motivation.

All go first. I sometimes get a bit confused, and I haven’t resolved this. In the Bodhisattva vows, it says, you should get enlightened as quickly as possible. You shouldn’t think that staying around in cyclic existence is a good thing. Right?

As a Bodhisattva. So I haven’t resolved that. I think I’ve heard it said that actually, you know, you have to get enlightened first. But then the shepherd is the highest motivation. Yes, it’s gorgeous.

So it’s an interesting conundrum in that when you’re the shepherd, you’re going to be enlightened first. For sure. Right? But in the Bodhisattva vows, it says, you should not hang around. You should work as quickly as possible in order to become enlightened.

And I think it’s always Buddha’s skill. I mean, this guy was pretty amazing in that for this range of minds, he came up with different motivations, different practices that suited every type of mind. So depending on what sort of mind you’ve got, you’ll find something that stimulates you, that says, oh yeah, that’s what I want to do. I love this prayer that says, I’m going to become enlightened in order to liberate all sentient beings. And then after a while, that same person will say, well actually, I’m not so worried about myself anymore.

I’m more concerned about others. So I’m just going to, excuse me, I’m just going to dedicate for all living beings, for their enlightenment, for them not to have suffering, for them to have compassion. And I’m very happy to do that. And what is the change? It’s the loosening of the grip on the I, which you started with.

And who did that? Śākyamūni Buddha. Isn’t it? The great skill of Śākyamūni Buddha, two thousand six hundred years ago, that recognized the suffering of that attachment and the clinging to the I, which is exactly the same as it is today. It hasn’t changed.

When we say, I want this, and I want that, and you know, I don’t want that, we find the I very distinctly. In desire attachment, and in anger and hatred, we find the I. And if we leave it as it is, then we can do terrible actions. And if we negate that I, we’ve got so much space to do so many wonderful actions. When we’re talking about the practice of generosity, we’re not talking about being rich people.

We don’t have to be rich people, but we have to open our heart to wanting to benefit all sentient beings and using our time and energy and resources in order to do that. And how do you do it? You develop bodhicitta. And you think, well, that’s easy. All I’ve got to do is think for the sake of all sentient beings.

Just to say it is different from feeling it in the heart. And when you feel it in the heart, all sentient beings, there is no self that’s experiencing it. It’s just an experience. You know, the heart opens up and experiences that. What would it be like to liberate all sentient beings from their suffering?

It’s not that sense of I’m doing it, but just it being done. There’s a huge difference between I’m doing it and it being done. I’m like a vehicle for the merit to be accumulated, and as the merit’s accumulated, I give it away. It’s accumulated, I give it away. So there’s no sense of I accumulating, no sense of I dedicating, I doing the action, then it’s perfect.

But where we are is, I’m doing it, I’m dedicating, and I’m going to get enlightened, and I’m this, and I’m that, and I’m the other. I think that’s where we start. Practically. We start there. And then gradually we start switching over to you, they, and you start dropping the I.

Anyway, now scientists and I think his Holiness said recently, the people who say in in their speech, I, the most, are the ones who have the heart attacks. Right? They’re the ones who have heart problems. Because everything relates to them. Me, me, me, me.

And the world is doing things to them. So it’s very healthy to start switching it over. So the practice of generosity, I think, really gives us an opportunity to do that. Drop this need for oneself to get things, and then pick up the need for others to gain things, to have things. And then get your joy from them, not from yourself.

Because you go shopping for yourself, you know. You buy something for yourself, and then afterwards you think, it doesn’t feel so good when you buy and you take it home. But when somebody gives you a gift, it can be small, not expensive. You feel such a sense of joy because they went to all that trouble. They really thought about it and they did such a nice action.

It can have a strong impact on you. So you know that giving to others makes others joyful. And the result is you’re going to have joy. You’re going to have so much joy in your life that it’s worth doing. Right?

Because then you’ve got joy to give to others. When we’re talking about the practice of joy and joyous effort, it’s worth having that joy in your life to be able to give to others. Okay, we’ll stop. Any other questions? Dave, you’re okay?

Everybody’s okay? Yes, Wei? You’re gonna start giving now? Now? Did you bring the checkbook?

Left the checkbook at home. We don’t need the checkbook. We need the mind, isn’t it? Just mentally keep writing those checks. Yeah?

You keep doing it in your mind, like that. Okay. So we’ll dedicate. We want to give away all the merit before we lose it. Which page was it?

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
illusory body gyu lu (Tib)
A subtle body generated through practice of the completion stage of Highest Yoga Tantra; the cause of the rupakaya. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
nirmanakaya emanation body; tul ku (Tib)
The emanation body of a buddha that manifests in a variety of forms for sentient beings. LYWA
rupakaya form body; zug ku (Tib)
The form body of a fully enlightened being; the result of the complete and perfect accumulation of merit. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top