1 h 0 min · 9,177 words · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Venerable Lobsang Namgyel teaches on generosity, the first of the six perfections, in this 61-minute session from a longer Thought Transformation series. He opens by defining generosity as actions of body, speech and mind motivated by bodhicitta—the aspiration to become enlightened for the benefit of all beings—and argues that without this motivation, generous acts remain imperfections rather than perfections. He explores the mental obstacles to giving, particularly miserliness and attachment, through reflection on impermanence and the impossibility of taking possessions at death, illustrating with stories including a Buddha teaching about taking a needle into the afterlife. Namgyel walks through the four types of generosity: material giving (advised especially for laypeople, starting small rather than grand gestures), dharma giving (any speech conveying Buddhist meaning in accessible language), protection (helping others overcome fear and anxiety), and love (continuously viewing others through eyes of compassion). He emphasizes that the power of a generous act depends entirely on motivation, not the gift’s monetary value, and illustrates the bodhisattva ideal through extended examples of Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s tireless teaching and immediate re-gifting of all offerings.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 07 generosity1 edit.mp3
UUID: 6e2c93ac-9e2a-486a-ac31-8a94513a776d
Teacher: Ven Lobsang Namgyel
Collection: VenNamgyel Thought Transformation (Ven Lobsang Namgyel)
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 60.7 minutes
Words: ~9,176
And that means something particular, doesn’t it? So I’ve made lots of notes because, as you know, I can get off the track and ramble, tell you stories of my life, and then you won’t know what giving is. So giving is the actions of body, speech and mind. So generosity giving. The actions of body, speech and mind motivated by the virtuous thought to give.
So this is the the definition of what we’re talking about. Actions of body, speech and mind motivated by the virtuous thought to give, and any generous action, any generosity that you’re performing, that you’re motivated by bodhicitta becomes the perfection of generosity. So this is the sort of key phrase that you need to know, that it’s got to be an action which is motivated by bodhicitta. So how many actions do we have in our daily life that are motivated by bodhicitta? And who doesn’t know what bodhicitta is?
Yeah, there has to be somebody, right? So, bodhicitta is the mind that wants to become enlightened in order to liberate all sentient beings from their suffering. So it’s the mind that says, I’ll do it. Right? It’s a big mind.
It’s what they call big mind. Or Lama Yeshe used to say, big love, big mind, as opposed to mind, love. Right? So big mind, big love. Do we have big mind, big love?
Do we have that sort of mind that really wants to become a bodhisattva, then wants to become enlightened, and wants to continue to work for the benefit of all sentient beings until every sentient being is liberated from their suffering. So when you think of it, it’s it’s a big deal, isn’t it? It’s not a walk in the park. So it’s something really special. And what about starting the day thinking, this is what I’m going to do with my day?
So perhaps, as we’re talking about these six perfections over, it’s nearly two weeks, isn’t it? So thinking about using these as motivations instead of just, you come to the teaching, and then that’s the end of it, you know, onto the next one. Instead of that, actually thinking about using it in your daily life. How can you bring this activity into your daily life? So these are the practices that a bodhisattva would be doing.
They’re not, the practices that we do and bodhisattvas do something else. Bodhisattvas practice the six perfections, but they perfect them. They don’t do them in an ordinary way. We do them in an ordinary way, right, because we don’t think very much about the motivation. And even if we do think about the motivation, do we think about bodhicitta?
As I said, this is very lofty, isn’t it? It’s a high ideal. So how much do you think about that motivation of bodhicitta? Now, if you don’t think about bodhicitta, are you going to become a Bodhisattva? So we’re all saying, I want to become enlightened.
You know, get me to enlightenment as quickly as possible. But if you’re not motivating with bodhicitta, you’re not becoming a bodhisattva, and you’re not going to become enlightened. So we better start motivating with bodhicitta, because otherwise our actions are not perfections, they’re imperfections. And so that’s what we’re discussing is how to make them perfect, how to utilize the occasions that we have right now. We give right now, don’t we?
We give food. We give presents to people. We just miss Christmas. We should have done this before Christmas. See, that’s your fault.
You should have invited me before Christmas, wherever I was. So you can think about next Christmas now. This is really good to think about next Christmas, but also the birthday’s on the way, and there’s other times, Easter, isn’t it? Easter’s coming. You give eggs, don’t you?
In New Zealand, I guess you give eggs, and you give presents. Give presents. Nobody sell them like everyday Christmas? Yeah. But let’s calm down, you know, please.
Don’t get too hot, right? Little, little. Start slowly. Right, so if you can do it every day, it’s great. If you can’t do it every day, if you can’t think in sort of a very big way, very quickly, start in whichever way you can.
But thinking about whenever I’m being generous, then what’s my motivation? How am I doing this action? Right? So you’re thinking about the state of mind that is being generous. Why are you being generous?
So it’s not the physical act of giving, and it’s not the gift itself, it’s the virtuous mind of generosity motivated by bodhicitta that proceeds and accompanies the act of giving, which makes it the perfection of giving. Did you get it? Okay? It’s not necessary to eliminate all poverty for it to become a perfection of giving, because if the definition is you need to eliminate all poverty, why wouldn’t Buddha have done that? Right?
If Buddha’s an enlightened being and Buddha had the perfection of generosity, then if the definition of the perfection of generosity is to remove all poverty, Buddha hasn’t done that. Right? Many, very famous Lamas that we are experiencing now and in the past haven’t been able to do that. So then that’s not the definition of the perfection of generosity. It’s something that you’re perfecting in your own mind.
It’s not dependent on the gift. Okay? So it’s not, you have to give a million dollars to FPMT, although they would be very happy with it. But if we said, Oh, the perfection of generosity is you give a million dollars to FPMT, oh, this is great, right? I’ve got a million dollars, I could do that.
Or a thousand dollars or a hundred dollars. It’s not the amount, it’s the way that you’re giving. So that’s what’s really important is how do you give? Which way do you give? So Śāntideva said, I have a little saying, the thought to give all beings everything together with the fruits of this is said to be the perfection of generosity.
Thus, it is simply a state of mind. Okay? So this is what Śāntideva said. The thought to give all beings, I often say, whenever we say all, we say, oh yeah, except for the neighbor that I don’t like, and except for that relative I’m not talking to anymore. You know, so then you have your list of the people you’re not giving to and you’re not practicing towards.
So everybody except for them. What he’s saying is all includes the beings that we don’t like, includes the creatures that we don’t like. Every single being is our field of merit. So that’s really worth thinking about. When Śāntideva is saying all, he really is talking about every single living being without an exception.
Okay? We’re not just talking about humans. We’re talking about every being. So Śāntideva said, all beings, everything. That means everything you’ve got, including your body, and we’ll talk about that later.
Is it, logical to give your body? So we have to talk about that. Together with the fruits of this. So the fruit is the the merit. What you’re receiving from the giving is the merit.
And then you’re not even holding onto that. So you don’t even get the merit. So you might think, well, I’m giving, but I get the merit. You know, I’m doing okay. I get the merit.
Well, you don’t even get that because you’re giving that away too. So then what do you get? Is there anything for me? It’s said, this is said to be the perfection of generosity. Thus, it is simply a state of mind.
Right? So this is really difficult for us to get around because we have, I think in the back of our mind, often that thought, well, I’m not giving to everybody, and if I do give, there must be something in it for me. There’s a hook, right? I want something back from it, because otherwise, what’s the point in giving? Right?
If I give, I want something back. And then you wait. You gave something, and you wait. And you wait. And you wait.
And you’re building your anger, you know? How come they don’t remember my birthday? Or how come they don’t remember I gave a present? Or you give an expensive present and you’re expecting a more expensive present, and they give you a less expensive present, then you’re really cranky because it’s not as expensive as how much you spent. So these are all the things that we really need to think about because giving can cause a lot of angst, can cause anger, can cause resentment.
So we want to use this situation of generosity in order to create as much merit as possible. Why? Because we want to become bodhisattvas. We want to become enlightened. We want to benefit all sentient beings.
So to develop generosity, need to reflect on the disadvantages of miserliness, and reflect on how your body and your wealth are impermanent. So in order to develop generosity, you need to think of the opposite. This is your analytical meditation. You think about miserliness. Is there anybody who’s not miserly?
Miserly means you hold onto things, you have things, but you don’t want to give them, you don’t want to share them. I mean, come off it. You know, we have miserliness, don’t we? For sure. And even you’re a very giving person.
There’s some things that you don’t want to give. There’s something that you leave for yourself. Right? I’ve got that in the bank, so I know I’m okay. Or, I’ve got that in the cupboard, so I know I’m okay.
I noticed for myself when I was in retreat in Dharmasala, I didn’t have a fridge. And that situation was quite frightening for me, because I was always used to having food in the cupboard. Right? And now there was no food in the cupboard. And when it snowed, one year we had heavy snow, and so we had no water, no electricity, It was deep snow.
It was really difficult to get down to the market, and very little food in the market. We didn’t have tin food or anything like that in India twenty years ago. So I found the fear and anxiety coming up in me. You know, I could go to bed and feel anxious about tomorrow, and I couldn’t quite understand why I was anxious. And then I realized one day during the retreat, oh, the reason is that I don’t have those tins of food, or I don’t have frozen food, you know, the food in the fridge, the food in the cupboard.
So we might think, well, I’m okay. I’ve got the biscuits, and I’ve got the tins of stuff, and I’ve got the Woi Woi, Woi Woi, Woi Woi, isn’t it? Woi Woi? You don’t know Woi Woi? Very popular in Kopan monastery.
Woi Woi noodles. It’s the little packet of noodles that you put hot water. The monks love it. Eat it without putting water. They just eat it like a snack.
So you got your woi woi. You’re okay. So you have to go into the mind that feels that it has to have certain things in order to feel that it’s comfortable. That’s what generosity is counteracting, isn’t it? Because there’s that feeling of miserliness.
I need certain things in order to feel comfortable, safe. What happens when you start giving it away? The miserly feelings arise, or the feeling of anxiety or anger could arise, and you don’t quite know where it’s coming from. Alright? So think about the impermanence of your body.
Think about the impermanence of your wealth, of your house, of your car. Whatever you have, its nature is impermanent. The situation is impermanent. Anyway, you’re going to lose your body sooner or later. So this is the death meditation, thinking about how you’re going to die.
And can you take your wealth with you? So since you can’t take it with you, since it is impermanent, why don’t you use it while you can in order to create some happiness with it and some merit with it? Why not do something constructive with it rather than being attached to it, holding onto it, and then it creating suffering for you? Because we know when we’re really attached to something that we suffer. Don’t we?
I mean, we do, right? So at the time of death, you could be really attached to your money, your possessions, your house. You don’t want to go, but you have to go. There’s no choice, right? And it’s an incredible suffering for you because you haven’t decided, I give it all up.
And this is training now for that time when we’re going to have to give it all up. It’s better to start thinking about it now than when you’re on your deathbed and you’re having terrible problems with having to give up whatever you own. So it’s better to start working on your mental attachment. We’re not talking about giving up your house, giving up your car. Don’t give it all up and then arrive at FPMT and say, Well, I did what you said.
I gave it all up and now take care of me. Right? That’s not the point. The point is that you have to give up your mental attachment, the suffering that you’re creating with your own mind. And this is a very important practice, isn’t it?
That we start working with our attachment, and because we’re subduing, reducing our attachment, we’re feeling happier, and we’re feeling more connected with others, and wanting to use what we have in order to benefit others. This is the heart starting to open up. And so this is why generosity is given as the first practice, because it’s the easiest. Of the six perfections, it’s the easiest. And some of you may think, well, that’s not easy at all.
But, you know, the others, comparatively are more difficult. So, you’ve done your meditations on impermanence, on death, and where does miserliness take you? I think it’s really important to sit and meditate on the type of mind that is miserly. You know, the type of mind that holds onto things and says, me, me, me, me, my, my, my, What sort of mind is that? Does it produce happiness?
Do you like it? What’s the feeling of it? Because people can tell you, oh, you shouldn’t be a miser. I mean, we all know it, don’t we? Don’t be a miser.
Give. Be a kind person. Give. But actually, we can have feelings that are miserly. So it’s better to go into that feeling.
How does it feel? Do you enjoy it? Does it make you feel happy? Is it what you want in your life? And of course, if we’re honest, we realize this is not what we want.
And so then you start to counteract that negative feeling. Instead of just saying, miserliness is no good, get rid of it. You want to go into the feeling of it, allow it to arise. If those negative feelings do arise, don’t immediately say this is wrong, but allow them to arise and then look at them. Why are they arising?
Why do you feel so attached to objects? Right? Don’t just say, this is wrong, I shouldn’t, because that’s not the way to change your mind about it. So where does miserliness get you? We have a suffering existence in this life.
You can be super rich, and yet acting like you’re poor. I remember a few years ago reading about an Englishman who died in front of the gas fire without the gas fire being on in the middle of winter. He didn’t put the gas fire on, and he had over a million pounds in the bank. He was rich, but he wouldn’t spend his money on the gas. He thought heating was a waste of money, and so he died of the cold.
How awful, you know, to have all that money and you don’t even put the gas on because you can’t stand the fact that you’re spending some money, you know, a few pounds. It’s nothing in comparison with what you’ve got in the bank. So that’s where miserliness can take you. You can become like that, so tight. He wouldn’t throw away newspapers.
He wouldn’t give anything away. His house was full of junk. You know, what we would call junk, not antiques, but just junk newspapers all over the place. And, you know, I read about this in the newspaper and I thought, how is it possible to have that sort of mind? But we can have those sort of minds on a smaller scale.
We haven’t got a million dollars maybe, or a million pounds, but we can do that. We can think, oh, I’m not gonna recharge the phone, not because you can’t afford it, but you’re feeling miserly, not going to switch the light on or the TV or something. When you get worried about the bills, you can start getting really tight. Does it create the mind of generosity? So, the future of miserliness, the future rebirth is poverty, and usually, the lower rebirths, so human below, so lower rebirths.
And many people, could be reborn as hungry ghosts. So do you know hungry ghosts? Some of you don’t. hungry ghosts are, beings that are a ghost, and they have a very thin throat, and they have a very big stomach. Horrendous existence.
Yeah. And they’re searching and searching and searching for something to eat or drink, and even it’s in front of them, they can’t see it. Because the the karmic appearance for them is not one of food and drink. So that’s the karma that’s created, is that even when there’s food and drink around, they can’t access it because they can’t see it. They’re not aware of it.
So can you imagine how that miserly mind creates that sort of karma, that in the future, that’s the type of existence that you have? I’ve got a question. Yeah. It comes up. It’s like the I was just wondering.
Does she have generosity also? Does she give? Yeah, she does. Yeah. So it’s often those two extremes, isn’t it?
In that really count, I remember growing up with the saying, Count the pennies. Don’t waste the pennies, that sort of thing, which I think is valid, isn’t it? We don’t have to throw away money. We don’t have to waste anything. I think in our present society, we waste so much, you know?
I mean, twenty years ago, things are vastly different than they are today. If you think about packaging, supermarkets, you know, the amount of wastage that we have, maybe if we lived like your mother, if we were drying preservatives and bottling and stuff like that, we’d all be in a better situation. But we’re so reliant now on supermarkets and packaging and stuff like this. So I think to try and find a balance between not being wasteful, but also not being obsessive. It’s that sort of obsessive mind that doesn’t want to give.
And so, thinking about, I need more, I need more, I need more. But your mother doesn’t have that. She’s doing things in order, I think, to have something to give. You know? And then that’s a much nicer mind.
If she had the house stack full of preservatives from nineteen forty seven and never gave away anything, I’d be worried. Know, I think there’s something wrong with the woman. But if she’s bottling and giving away and using it and stuff like this, I think it’s a great vehicle to live. I think we should, more of us should be doing that. So looking at the balance, and what I noticed about my mind was that my mother had been through the Second World War and the rationing and the difficulties with all of that.
And I think when I was born, it was about seven years after the war. There were still a lot of problems with food seven years after the war. And so even at that time, we couldn’t get everything that we wanted. So I remember as a child, money was always a big problem, you know, a big sort of thing to think about, and we couldn’t waste anything. And we had to make do.
It was always about making do, wasn’t it? And so reusing the clothes and cutting the bottoms off and sewing them and making them for somebody else. The first child got the new clothes and everybody else got the used clothes. But these are very practical. Nowadays, it’s just throw it all away and buy new.
So I think, what’s the motivation? You know, nowadays it’s about buying new things in order to maybe look good, but in those days it was about saving money because you just didn’t have the money to spend. So, I think just keep looking at one’s own motivation. It’s very hard to look at the motivation of anybody else, isn’t it? You can’t know what’s going on in other people’s minds.
We can’t judge that. But at least look at your own motivation and are you doing your activities from the point of view of bodhicitta. And then with what you know, to educate others around you as to having good motivation. If they don’t know about Buddhism, you can’t talk about bodhicitta, but you can talk about love and compassion, you know, opening the heart with love and compassion, sharing what we have with love and compassion, isn’t it? So I better get on because I’m sure I’m not going to finish.
So, where was I up to? So the rebirth, thinking about the rebirth that you’re going to have, and is it going to be a beneficial rebirth? Is it going to be a rebirth that is going to be good for your Dharma practice, for you to continue what you want to, practice in the future. So developing good habits in this life that will continue into the next life. So, when you practice, when your practice of generosity, when you practice generosity, the benefits are limitless.
You’re going to have wealth, you’re going to have resources, and because ordinary beings like good conditions, then it’s going to give happiness. Because who doesn’t like having good conditions? Who doesn’t like having a nice home, nice car, or nice things around them? So, you’re going to have wealth, you’re going to have resources, but also, just for ordinary beings, because they like good conditions, you’re going to have good conditions. And that’s going to give happiness.
You’re going to attain liberation, and it’s said that you will encounter a superior being, somebody who can teach you how to attain liberation from saṃsāra. So this is pretty incredible. You know, this is good advertising. You’re going to achieve liberation from saṃsāra, And this all comes from your practice of generosity. Because you’re providing a fertile ground in order to be able to meet this type of being who can teach you, but also so that you’re opening your heart to the situation of others.
Right? It really means there’s a change of heart involved when you’re practicing generosity. So you need to counter the opponents to generosity. When you’re trying to develop this generous state of mind, you need to counter opponents. So when the feeling of miserliness turns up, which it inevitably does, especially nowadays, you know, we’re talking about the economic downturn, and people are worried about jobs and money and things like that.
Suddenly, you can get really tight. But if you go really tight, is that going to create future success? So this is what the text says. If you become very miserly, again, you’re going back to the instinct of preserving everything for yourself, holding onto it, but that’s not going to create success for the future. So life is short, death is definite.
The only thing that helps you at the time of death are your realizations and your merit. So this is worth thinking about. What am I taking with me? You know, there was a man at the time of, Buddha, Śākyamūni Buddha, and he asked Śākyamūni Buddha about taking all his wealth with him. He said, you know, I’m really desperate.
I like being rich, and I wanna take it all with me. And Śākyamūni Buddha said, no problem. I’m gonna teach you how to do it. He said, take this pin, like a needle, take it away with you, and you figure out how to take this needle. And when you figure that out, come back and I’ll tell you the rest.
So the man went away and he’s thinking, I can put it in my mouth. So the time of death, it’s in my mouth and it’ll go with me. And then he said, no, no, no, that doesn’t work. It’s not going with me if it’s in my mouth. That’s a silly thought.
So then he put it in his skin, you know, sort of sewed it into his skin. Ah, that’s a good idea. It’ll go with me that way. No, no, no, that’s not gonna work. So he was thinking all these tricks.
You know, how do I take it? How do I take it? So for ages, he’s thinking this way, this way, this way. Can’t figure it out. So he thinks there must be another way, a trick that Buddha knows.
Right? So he goes back to Buddha, and he says, well, I’ve tried and tried and tried. I can’t figure it out. I just don’t know how to do it. So how do I do it?
And Buddha said, you don’t. There is no trick. Right? If you cannot figure out how to take that small pin, how are you gonna take all your wealth? How are you going to take your money, horses, cows, whatever you have?
How are gonna take all that with you? And in Egypt, they thought they could, right? They built these pyramids, and you put all the family in there, closed it up, and said, you’re going with them. You put the elephants, or you put the camels, or whatever it was. So they had this idea, you could take it with you.
But Śākyamūni Buddha said, Nothing goes with you except your realizations and your merit. So, the Bodhisattva’s practice of giving, the Bodhisattva promised to help all living beings. Think about that. What’s what’s our motivation? Why do we do things?
Do we want to give to all sentient beings? And do we want all sentient beings to be happy? So when a bodhisattva gives, they feel a great sense of joy by seeing sentient beings being happy. Right? Not that the bodhisattva wants anything else for themselves, but just by seeing others’ happiness, they feel naturally happy.
And, you know, for me, this was the experience with Lama Zopa Rinpoche. I don’t know if you’ve ever seen Lama Zopa Rinpoche, how he delights in teaching. And so you can be there for fifteen hours, and you think, how does he do it? You know, he just teaches hour after hour after hour, and not even a cup of tea, not even going to the toilet, but just, it goes on and on and on. And he delights in it so much.
And you think, how does he do it? Because he’s a bodhisattva, he’s giving the dharma. It’s his greatest joy to give the dharma because he’s giving the solution to all your problems. He knows this is, what he needs to give you. And so he’s delighting in the giving.
And so he must see these little light bulbs going on, you know, around the room as people gradually light up, understanding what he says, because I think sometimes he needs to talk fifteen hours until the very last light bulb goes on. We used to look around and try and figure out who it was. Sort of slip them a note. This is what the answer is. So we can all go to bed.
But, you know, he keeps trying and trying and trying until every single person has got it. It’s an incredible way of dedicating your life to others. You know, just wanting others to be happy, not wanting them to suffer. And then I’ve seen him, when I’ve been to give him a present, you know, you give him maybe, a Buddha image or, you know, something special that you find. So you shop all over Bodh Gaya and find something for him, and you think, Oh, this is unique.
I’m sure he hasn’t got this. And you take it to him, and he says, Oh, wow. He said to me once, Where did you find this? What sort of clay is it? I don’t know the clay.
He said, wow, the clay is beautiful. I wonder where they get the clay from. So I had to go all over Bodh Gaya asking about the clay of this statue. Nobody knew what this clay was, but Rinpoche was fascinated by this particular clay. So I gave him the statue, and he was raving about the clay, and how wonderful, you know?
So I thought, wow, I’ve done it this time, you know? I’ve made Rinpoche really happy, given him something he really wanted. I came out and I sat in the office outside. The next person went in, and they were in a short time, and they came out and they were carrying my Buddha image. And I think, Buddha, Buddha.
You know, but, that was, that was, yeah. So, really, he startled me in the beginning, because I’ve never met a being like him where you could give something and five minutes later it was gone to somebody else. He doesn’t hold on to anything. And sometimes I used to slip things onto his table, you know? Like once I found a little Tārā and I put it on his table when I was just in there doing something for him.
Just put it there. And days later he said to me, Do you know where this Tārā came from? And I said, Oh yes, I put it there. And then I’m sure it was gone. He wouldn’t give it away while he didn’t know who put it there, why it was there, just in case it wasn’t his.
So, this is an amazing mind of just giving away. And what I’ve seen from Rinpoche is that he’s become more and more and more successful in the way of the more he gives, the more gets, the more he gives. I can remember we were in Sera Monastery, nineteen, I think nineteen ninety, maybe nineteen ninety one, around that time, and Rinpoche then said, I’m going to feed all the monks. And Roger went, Oh, out comes the calculator. How many monks?
You know, Roger’s the practical one, right? How many monks? And they said, Oh, three thousand or four thousand something. How much does each meal cost? And then, Rinpoche.
That means we need a million dollars. I think Rinpoche didn’t have a hundred dollars at that time. We need a million dollars. Oh, that’s okay. That’s no problem.
Roger said, Well, okay. You know, he has faith. Okay, Rinpoche, if you think you can get a million dollars, fine. The food project has been running ever since then. Isn’t it two two meals a day now?
Three meals. Three meals a day? Three meals, and I think Sera May and Sera Je, or just Sera Je. But I think four thousand, at least four thousand monks anyway, isn’t it? The whole of Sera Je.
Incredible that Rinpoche’s continued this on, has never failed to feed those monks. From that very first small beginning of having nothing. But his mind was, I need to help the monks. I need to repay the kindness of the monastery, which is like the mother. So you repay your mother’s kindness.
And that’s where it all started. I was sitting there when he said, I’m gonna feed the monks. So I’ve seen Rinpoche’s joy in the giving, and I always thought, well, if you could do it like that, you’d be so happy yourself, and you’d give so much joy to others. It’s an incredible way of living. So then, we need to think about the divisions of generosity.
There’s material, there’s dharma, there’s protection, and love. So the first one is material. Material, dharma, protection, and love, in case you want to write the four down. So material is obvious. It’s, you know, the gifts, whether it’s flowers or whether it’s money, whatever it is, something material.
But my advice is start small. If you haven’t done this as a practice before, don’t start big and cut back. Better to start small and increase it. Don’t be a lump-sum donor and say, I’ll give a million dollars, you know? And then you don’t have the resources to be able to do it.
So start small and work up, and then you’ll really enjoy it because it’s manageable. You can do it. All right? So start with a bar of chocolate, flowers, you know, whatever makes the other person happy. And we’re going to talk about also, what’s appropriate.
So the power of the generous act depends on the motive, not the value of the object. So this is what you need to keep remembering, because you might forget sometimes, and you start thinking, oh, it’s too small, it’s insignificant, but it depends on the power of your motivation, not the amount of money that went into the object. And then you need to give without expectation of reward. Now this is a difficult one, because we might have the mind that says, When I give, I’m going to get something back. So don’t expect any reward.
Can I just ask you something? Yeah. That doesn’t sort of fit with Śāntideva. Right. The thought to give all beings everything.
Right. Together with the merit. Well, it should be unconditional. If you can do it totally unconditional, you actually know that from that, you’re going to get even more. But that’s another bribe.
I know. Can’t do anything about it. You know? But you give that too. But you still know from even, from giving that, you’re going to get even more.
Isn’t it? I mean, you know that if you can give as openly and as generously as you can, inevitably there’s a reward. So that’s problem with the practice, is that when you’re thinking, oh, there is a reward, then you can get egotistically involved in the reward. And then it’s not the practice of generosity, the perfection of generosity. So those sorts of aspects, are they to encourage You to start.
Oh, they’re to encourage. I mean, otherwise you wouldn’t even start, would you? Well. Many people might not start. If they think no reward in the future life, no reward in this life, don’t get anything back, I’m going to give everything, I don’t get any presents, I don’t get, don’t get, I don’t get.
So what’s the point? You know, you could have that sort of mind that says, So what’s the point? Because some people are very worldly. Yeah? Obviously you’re not as worldly as those people.
And so you’re thinking, well, I don’t need that reward in the future. You know? Like some people are praying to go to hell. Right? Actually, some people want to go to hell because they think if I’m spiritual, the best place to go is hell.
To do as much good. To do as much good as you can in hell. So that would be the best thing for some people. But some people are really worried about going to hell. They have a fear of going to hell.
And so that fear then generates a mind that says, I’m going to do some Dharma practice. So it doesn’t matter. Is the motivation still pure? Long as you try and have as pure a motivation as possible. Well, It’s not very pure, isn’t it?
No. So try and have as pure a motivation as possible. Removing the self. We’re going to talk about the three circles of emptiness. That’s when it addresses that aspect of it.
So, giving without expectation of reward, repayment, result, so that’s what you’re talking about. And if you give with bodhicitta, you will have karma that results in enlightenment. Right? So Buddha taught that what you achieve with this is the result, enlightenment. And should we not be concerned about that?
If you’re enlightened, can’t you benefit sentient beings? And if you’re not enlightened, aren’t you just one of the people in the queue asking for help? So actually, if we can become enlightened, aren’t we better off? Now if we look at it in that way, wouldn’t we be much better, at benefiting all sentient beings than as we are at the moment? So think about the difference between ordinary beings and then Buddhas.
Think about ordinary beings, Bodhisattvas. Huge difference in what they can do. Okay? So then, the result, you’re going to be wealthy in the future. This is by practicing the generosity of material, things.
The result is you’ll be wealthy in future. So if you give food, clothes, medicine, anything that benefits others’ bodies, you will benefit your body in the future. So you’ll have a healthy body. This is important if your body’s falling apart, like mine is. So it’s good to know, well, what sort of practices can you do which will ensure that you have a healthier body in your next life, if you have a problem with your body in this life?
But anyway, giving food, clothes, because it’s protection, medicine, is very good for ensuring the future. Then, with wealth, what can you do? If you don’t have a generous state of mind, but you are very wealthy, there’s very little that you can do. You’ll have all your money in the bank, and you’ll think this is mine, and I’m not giving it to anybody, and I’m not sharing it with anybody. But imagine if you have huge wealth, and you have the state of mind that wants to use it for the benefit of others.
So the result of practicing material generosity is you’ll be very wealthy, but you’ll also have the state of mind that wants to use that wealth to benefit others. So we need both. No use being really rich, but you keep it in the bank. Yeah. So it’s nice to see Bill Gates giving away some money.
Right? He’s giving money to India, Africa for AIDS and different projects. He’s been giving away, quite sizable amounts of money. It’s really nice to see that happening because it’s those type of people that can really, change the course of these severe illnesses like AIDS and TB. Now, you know, there’s a new TB which is, sorry, which is virtually, untreatable because of the drugs that they’ve been giving.
They don’t finish the drugs. Now, the drug resistant TB, drug resistant AIDS. So we need lots of money in order to counteract these sicknesses. So if you’re involved in taking care of others’ bodies, then in the future, this will come back as the ability to have a healthy body. And this is important because you’re going to work for the benefit of all sentient beings.
You’re going to need a healthy body. Then the second one is the giving of dharma. So the giving of dharma is any speech, this is the definition, any speech which conveys the meaning of dharma. Any speech which conveys the meaning of the dharma. It doesn’t mean that you use Sanskrit terms or Tibetan terms or anything like that.
So you can talk without using any special terms, but the, if the meaning is giving Dharma, then that’s Dharma generosity. So Lama Yeshe used to say, you should be able to talk about all of Buddhism without using a single technical word. This would be the ideal. It’s not using any Sanskrit terms or Tibetan terms. Just talking about Dharma in a way that any person can understand it.
The meaning of dharma. Yeah. I mean, sūtra, a mantra, a sentence, often saying something to somebody like, you know, thinking about impermanence, you know? But you have to be really careful, because when you say these things to some people, they get really upset, because right at that moment, they don’t want to hear, This will pass. This is impermanent.
Right? You have to wait for the moment when you can say something that really calms them down. So sometimes you have to let them be emotional for a little while, and then when you see they’re starting to settle down, say, have a cup of tea, sit down, you have a chat, and then you say, You know, these things pass. Or you talk about your own life and how you’ve had very difficult situations, we all have, and how you’ve got over it, how it passes. But I think not to make light of a difficult situation, you know.
I’ve been in various countries where you hear terrible tragedies, you know, people telling about terrible things, about kidnappings or murders and, you know, stuff like that. And when you hear about this, you think, gosh, you know, yes, this is really terrible. And it’s probably not something that happens in New Zealand, but it happens in many other countries in the world. And you can’t just say, Oh, well, don’t worry about it. You know, we all die.
Isn’t it? Because that doesn’t soothe somebody’s feelings or help their heart. So you have to really listen. And sometimes all you can do is just listen, you know, just to listen and say prayers for them and dedicate for them, because it’s really hard to know in some situations exactly what to say. And so you have to think very carefully before you do say something to somebody who’s in a very difficult situation, right?
So the meaning of the dharma, rather than spouting out, you know, sort of, things that you’ve memorized. You have to know the meaning of the dharma and then know how to apply it in particular situations. So that means you need to have done that for yourself. You know how it works for you, and then you’re able to advise others, isn’t it? When I was making these notes, something I thought of was dharma email.
Instead of drama email, you can switch over to dharma email. So dharma email and dharma SMS. I heard a nice thing about one country somewhere, I think it was a Muslim country, where every hour or two hours, they send out automatically on everybody’s mobile phone, they get a saying. It would be really nice if you’re Buddhist and you receive something, you know, like every two hours that would just inspire you to keep your bodhicitta and your good heart throughout the day. So thinking about Dharma generosity in the way of knowing somebody’s feeling a bit depressed and sending an SMS or sending an email to make them feel better.
But be very careful with emails, because often they lead to confusion. Right? You can misread emails because you don’t remember the person writing the email, and so it’s out of context. So you always need to put emails in context, and if your email is being confused, you know, they don’t quite get it and they write back a little bit, you know, sort of upset about your email, then you write back and it gets worse, I think stop, you know, stop writing backwards and forwards, because often it builds up and builds up and builds up. So leave it, let it cool down a bit, or maybe send one of these nice cards.
You can do an email card. I found a nice site which was Acts of Random Kindness, and it’s a site for random kindness, and they have e cards, and they have sayings by Gandhi, Mahatma Gandhi, Helen Keller. And so these cards are really nice to send to people, you know, because it helps to remind them of just, how they’re feeling and lifting their their thoughts. So, still talking about dharma, when you’re reciting prayers, then you can think of the spirits and the beings around you, and you can offer the prayers, whatever you’re doing, to the beings that you can’t see. So often you might be sitting alone and reciting, and you think, well, there’s nobody around, but there could be spirits around you, so you should offer, whatever you’re reciting to them.
But also, I’m sure in every house, there’s countless sentient beings who are residing. Ants and all the termites in India have lots of termites. So offering all your prayers to them, that’s Chenrezig. Dying people, I don’t know if anybody here has had experience with dying people, but offering prayers, There’s a point where they can’t do the visualizations themselves, so you can do the visualizations for them, so you could offer that that for them. Talking to them about love and compassion, bodhicitta, wisdom.
But again, this has to be relevant to the person. If they’re not Buddhist, please be very careful what you say to them. Don’t arrive to, the bed of a Christian with your Buddha pictures, and you’ve never talked about Buddhism before, and you suddenly arrive and you say, you know, Buddha’s the way. Give up everything. Come over to Buddhism.
You know? This is really going to disturb somebody at the time that they’re dying. So be very, very careful when somebody’s dying to make sure that you know what their belief system is, and you give the advice in accordance with the belief system. You don’t contradict their belief system. So if they believe in Jesus, that’s fine.
You know, you talk about love and compassion. And just leave it at that, yeah. Animals. Some people really interested in helping animals because they rely on us for their future, you know, future spiritual development. So you can recite texts to them or prayers to them and you make dedications for them so that they meet the dharma in future.
It really inspired me many years ago when I saw Rinpoche, Lama Zopa Rinpoche in a field with speakers set up, and he would spend hours, you know, just with a microphone. And in the beginning it was like nobody there, know, just Rinpoche with an empty field and blah blah blah, you know, and cows and sheep, miles away. And gradually they’d come. And then the photograph in the end was like a rooster sitting on the fence, and the sheep and the cows, and all the beings had gathered right in front of Rinpoche, and they were all just sitting there, listening to Rinpoche reciting. So they seemed to just get attracted to it, know, and they come.
But thinking of your own cats, your own dogs, your own birds, this is very important for their future. You know, there’s this story about the bird who used to listen to the texts, And when the bird died, he was reborn, down the road, and this Lama went to find that child, and that child could recite all the texts that he’d heard in the previous life. So it’s not lost. Then protection. So this is, another one of the the generosities.
So protection is helping others to overcome their fear and anxiety. This is really important now because many people are starting to experience fear and anxiety, and they don’t know why. So helping others to overcome their fear and anxiety. It could be life threatening situations. So nurse nurses, doctors, firemen.
It could be people who save the lives of animals. You could do, St. John Ambulance training, you know, so that in an emergency, you can help others. So your motivation is that you want to save others from life threatening situations. That’s one way of doing it.
Protecting the lives of others by giving medication, but then again, you need to be trained in order to do that, so it’s a professional thing. Helping them to change behavior so that they remain healthy. So if their behavior is creating an unhealthy situation, then giving them advice in order to help them to change so that they remain healthy. And then the result is that you in future will be free of anxiety and fear. You’ll have a long and healthy life, and you’ll be able to help many living beings.
And then the last one is love. So the giving of love is unusual. This is taught in the Guhyasamāja Tantra. And the giving of love is continually viewing others through the eyes of love. And the result is to experience continuous happiness for yourself and to be able to easily make others happy.
So the advice I give people if they want to practice this is when you’re walking around the city or shopping centers, places like that, you take one of the verses, one of the lines from the Four Immeasurables. You know, the one that says, may you be happy. And you just keep thinking every time you see somebody, may you be happy. This is the giving of love. May you be happy.
May you be happy. Because often when we’re walking around the or you’re on the bus or you’re on the train, if you’re not very happy, you can look at sentient beings as they’re really a bit painful. You know, why is the train so crowded? Why are these people there? Know, your mind can become a bit negative sometimes in the city.
So then it’s particularly important to take that practice, may you be happy, and keep projecting it onto everybody that you see. And then it’s an imprint, a seed, which will ripen in the future as the result, love. So love is wanting all beings to be happy, and then compassion is not wanting them to experience suffering. So the other line in the four lines of the four immeasurables, may they not experience suffering. So start with, may you be happy.
Just keep saying, may you be happy. May you be happy. May you be happy. May you be happy. And then when you’ve got that, may you be happy and may you not suffer.
Right? May you be happy, may you not suffer. That supposes that you’re not going to make them suffer given the opportunity, Right? So that works on your mind in the way of pulling you away from creating others’ suffering and pushing you into doing something if you can to make them happy. It’s those seeds that you need in your mind stream.
So lay people generally should practice material giving. I agree with this. I think it’s wonderful that they should. And monks and nuns don’t. So we practice Dharma giving, they practice money giving.
It’s not me who said this. Why? Because if monks and nuns have to practice giving of objects, material giving, then it means that they need to have more resources in order to give more. And so then they’d have to start actually, thinking about what they’ve got in order to give. So it’s said that, when you’re a layperson, then it’s easy for you to give, material things, to give protection, to give love.
When you’re a monk or a nun, you’ve taken vows, then the, I think the way of viewing your world is one of dharma and not being concerned about having money, material possessions, so you don’t have so much to give. Again, that can be dependent on the individual. There’s some monks and nuns that maybe do have more, and so then they can also, do what they should in giving Dharma, and they can also give material things. But generally, it’s said in the Lamrim text, lay people should practice material giving. It’s also said in the text that if you find it really hard to give in the beginning, you can take something like a carrot, a carrot.
You hold it in one hand and you give it to the other. And you say, Here you are, have this carrot. And you say, Thank you very much. Here you are, have this carrot. Thank you very much.
You can give it a go, you know. If so difficult for you to practice generosity, you can try doing it like that. Or you can give a coin from this side to this side. So you can start with a vegetable, work up to a coin, work up to a note, and what you’re doing is you’re putting imprints into your mind that hopefully ripens into being able to give. When you see some suffering, when you see somebody that you’re able to give to, you see it as an opportunity, you see it as a joy rather than seeing it as a nuisance.
And the problem with being in New Zealand is you don’t see many beggars. You know? In Bodh Gaya, we used to see fifty, a hundred, two hundred in a day. And sometimes, you know, people complain and they say, I can’t give to all these beggars. And I say, Yeah, but when you go back to the West, you can’t find them.
Right? It’s really difficult to find. So when you see a beggar, you sort of take joy in it, and you think, how wonderful, instead of thinking, why are they living on the street? Why are they like that? If you can’t find beggars and you want to give to somebody, then maybe you look at an organization that helps others, something that you’re particularly interested in.
And then you give money to the organization. If you know that the organization uses that money in order to benefit others, that most of the money goes to helping others, not to running the organisation. So you’ve got to check that out, isn’t it? So maybe, should we have a short break or shall I keep going? Do people feel that you need a break?
You do. She’s saying yes, yes, yes, yes. I take her word.
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- four immeasurables caturapramana (Skt); tsä mä zhi (Tib)
- Also known as the four immeasurable thoughts or the four sublime attitudes, these are four states of mind or aspirations: loving kindness, compassion, sympathetic joy and equanimity. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
- two extremes tha nyi (Tib)
- Eternalism, seeing things as having an intrinsic reality, and nihilism, seeing things as having no reality at all. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.