2 h 6 min · 11,460 words · 3 March 2009 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Ven Jampa Gendun opens this 126-minute penultimate session with an unexpected parallel between the AA saying “I’m not okay and you’re not okay, that’s okay” and the Buddha’s First Noble Truth — arguing that honest acknowledgment of dissatisfaction is the precondition for real change. A guided meditation then invites students to consciously review and value past moments of wisdom and generosity across different time periods, an unusual exercise in healthy self-respect. He works through the closing verses of Tsongkhapa’s Three Principal Aspects of the Path on emptiness: using a rosary to illustrate how objects depend on mental imputation, he explains why dependent arising and emptiness are not two separate ideas but one entity, unpacks the two truths, and maps the middle way between eternalism and nihilism. The session closes with Tsongkhapa’s final verse alongside a Thoreau passage about building foundations under castles in the air. Best followed by those who have been with the series.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 40 3PA 2009 03 03.mp3
UUID: 0854fa6f-1067-4bcc-b534-3e89d0276770
Teacher: Ven Jampa Gendun
Collection: Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Date: 2009-03-03
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 126.0 minutes
Words: ~11,455
How is everybody? Would you tell me if you weren’t? Yes. Oh, it’s mine. It’s good to meet an honest man.
I’m okay. The twelve Step program, one of the, you know, for Alcoholics Anonymous, it’s one of the most successful self help programs ever developed and maybe one of the of the perhaps reasons behind that is that there’s kind of a saying, I’m not okay and you’re not okay, that’s okay. Situation is workable, but we have to at least acknowledge where we’re actually at, if we’re ever going to bring about any kinds of change. I think that’s why, you know, the very first teaching that the Buddha gave subsequent to his enlightenment, his awakening, was the Four Noble Truths in which he outlined the entirety of his the path that it would take the next forty five years to expand upon, to explain. And it all began with the acknowledgment of suffering.
I remember when I first came, you know, I spent a number of years, as most of you know, I spent a number of years in India and I came to the West after a number of years in India and Thailand and came to Australia. Had never you know, talking to people about, you know, how should I approach this? I was quite apprehensive. I still am, but anyway, that’s beside the point. And they said, Oh, well, the one thing is don’t talk about suffering.
People in Australia don’t suffer. And so, well, maybe I’ll talk about dissatisfaction. I kind of dress it up in the words which are a little more palatable. We can, willing to identify with. You know, like people in India, they suffer.
If you break a bone, if you’re in a car accident, okay, that’s suffering. But what we generally experience, that’s not suffering. But it seems as if, you know, in terms of the Four Noble Truths, without that first acknowledgment of the high degree of unmanageability in our life or sense of passionhood or feelings of alienation, anxiety, which permeated our life, let alone the more dramatic difficulties and traumas and the pain that we go through in particular instances, without that awareness and that recognition and that acknowledgment, then there’s no reason to change. I think we have to we have to be aware there’s some degree of resistance to change. We’d rather not.
You know, if you’re sitting in a nice comfortable chair, you know, why get out of it as long as you conceive of it as being comfortable? You’re reluctant even to change your position in the chair, let alone to get up and to turn the television channel. That’s why people have remotes. But the moment you become aware that your position in the chair has become uncomfortable, then quite naturally, spontaneously, you shift to another position. And there’s some resistance to change.
You know, change is, and always has been, always will be uncomfortable. It’s frightening. You go out into the unknown, giving up to some degree the familiar. And so I think, you know, we have to it has to be when you get sick and tired of being sick and tired, you find a way to get well. You know, when the uncomfortability of staying where you’re at is greater than the fear of the prospects of the unknown, then maybe we’ll actually do something to bring about a difference, a difference that’ll make a difference rather than just changing the scenery and the I’m just looking for a quote about kind of jogs my memory sometimes about change.
Don’t mind me. Just just amuse yourself. Everybody wants to lock himself up after having undergone a few transformations in adolescence. And perhaps for a few years after that, everybody chooses some state of being, usually without even realizing that chooses it, and says more or less explicitly, That is the way I am or happen to be. Or, I have always said that, or, I am the kind of person who, or one takes refuge in heredity or environment or if one has read some of the psychoanalysts, one blames one’s parents.
Is all their fault. Choose to be changed is not only a call for continual growth, it is an implicit denunciation of all these myths. And that wasn’t the quote I was looking for. That was quite interesting, wasn’t it? And, know, that very much to do with seeing our problems external to ourselves as we normally do in terms of, If it weren’t for you, I’d be happy in one way or another, some form or another, or if only I had the right job or the right degree or the right amount of money or the right car or the right house.
As if Samsāra we could find what it is that we’re looking for and still remain very much the same person who we are now in terms of our attitudes, our opinions, our ideals, our views, and so forth. That somehow manipulating the things and the people or situations about us, could find that perfect constellation of externalities and find peace. That’s kind of a myth, isn’t it? So, in this process, you know. We do this every week.
I guess we do it more often than not in the sense of, you know, we take the time, a few minutes just to pause and to quit distracting ourselves from ourselves and take a look, I guess, what is it, to reflect upon what it is we’re doing, where this is all taking us, how Maybe it would be nice to do this on a Friday after work. How has your week been? Have you gotten any further in your goal of life, however you might conceive of it, to become that kind of person that you want to be to achieve a successful life. It’s mundane. It’s like more of the beginning, isn’t it?
But is the overall, you know, what you’re doing and the ways you’re thinking and how you’re expending your energy and using your time, is that all is it all adding up to something which is taking you where you want to go? Not in terms of, you know, who we could be and what we could do with our life, this one wild, precious life of ours. That’s all that we really have that we can call our own. And if it’s not, what are you going to do about it? And work, how are you going to make a difference?
We can try and persist in trying to change the things about us to make that difference that we want to make. At some time, if we’re to live our lives intelligently, sensitive to our own lived experience, we can see that that project is futile. It’s not to say that we have a comfortable home, the right job and enough money and a significant other can’t all add up to, you know, these are all components of a good life. But they aren’t sufficient in and of themselves. You know, we can have all the riches of the king and still be miserable, can’t we?
And that’s quite evident, or it should be evident by now. It’s our attitudes, our ideas, opinions about the people and things situations which are which are most in a in a we have to create some balance. I don’t want to exaggerate. So that’s what we’re working with, right, with our own minds and turn to these teachings and so forth in terms of changing the way that we relate. Our attitudes and the way we approach our perspective, our views, these all have to change in some or another.
There’s no getting around it. If we ever hope to find what it is that we, I think in our heart of hearts we’re all looking for in one way or another. However, you know, that you might conceptualize that to be our deepest, most held values. So in this process we go for refuge. And, you know, this is this I guess, you know, the refuge is something internal to ourselves in a way, in terms terms of our our own minds and our own Buddha.
Instead of Buddha, everybody’s got a little Buddha inside of us. We forget. We grow deaf to the Buddha withinside of ourselves, the inarticulate whisperings of our own hearts. So we have to listen. What is that Buddha telling us?
So that becomes inner focus. But manifesting, expressing that Buddha, or the awakened state in the little ways that we can in our everyday life. We have to actually do something, you know. And so we make use of the Dharma, these guidelines on how to manifest Buddha, how to become more Buddha. Essentially the truth of things of your life.
And this, you know, we need each other to support this project, this endeavor that we’re all embarked upon. Mental health is a social phenomenon. It’s something that we, and in the world, is a hospital where healing takes place. So we depend upon each other in various ways that we do. And I guess committing ourselves to that commitment, know, acknowledging that dependence and being willing, place yourself in a position where you allow yourself to be dependent upon, kind of interdependency.
And we continue to try to raise the level of our motivation. The why behind it, the purpose for what it is that we do. And then we can try. Mean, aren’t super humans, and we aren’t dharma robots. We act to be honest with ourselves.
But the endeavor is worthwhile. I mean, just the trying, there’s some sense of fulfillment in just that. Whether we succeed or not, whether we can fulfill these lofty visions and our aspirations, okay, maybe. Maybe that’s a long way off. But it’s just in the But trying, there’s some kind of easing of solace of the heart.
We respect ourselves and feel good about what involved in. What life brings us, it might throw us from time to time, but that’s okay. We’re sane enough to be able to end it. And still, we won’t die the same person we were born. We will move to, if only a small ways along that journey that we’re all on.
And we can have that kind of perspective. And there’s a kind of peace, a kind of easing struggle that we seem to be constantly involved. We can relax a little bit. Yes. So the inner focus of our life becomes Buddha, which we actualize by means of the Dharma within the social context of a spiritual community.
And again and again trying to raise the level of motivation. Just one other person. To learn how to love one other person thoroughly and completely and as altruistically as we can. That’s a life worth living. It’s a real life project.
I go for refuge until I’m awakened to the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Sangha. Through my practice generosity and the other perfections, may become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings.
May all beings sentient beings have happiness and the causes of happiness. May all sentient beings be free from suffering and the causes of suffering. May all sentient beings be inseparable from the joy that is without sorrow. May all sentient beings abide in equanimity, free from attachment for some and aversion toward others. Thus did I hear at one time that Bhagavan was dwelling on Mass of Vultures Mountain in Rajgir, together with a great community of monks and a great community of bodhisattvas.
At that time the Bhagavan was absorbed in the concentration on the categories of phenomena called profound perception. Also at that time, the bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara looked upon the very practice of the profound perfection of wisdom and beheld those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature. Then through the power of the Buddha, the Venerable Śāriputra said this to the Bodhisattva Mahāsattva Ārya Avalokiteśvara, how should any son of the lineage train who wishes to practice the activities of profound perfection of wisdom. He said that in the Bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara said this to the Venerable Śāriputra, any son of the lineage or daughter of the lineage who wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom should look upon it like this, correctly and repeatedly, beholding those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature. Form is empty, emptiness is form, emptiness is not other than form, form is also not other than emptiness.
In the same way, feeling, discrimination, compositional factors and consciousness are empty. Śāriputra, likewise, all phenomena are emptiness, without characteristic, unproduced, unceased, stainless, not without stain, not deficient, not fulfilled. Śāriputra, therefore, in emptiness, there is no form, feeling, no discrimination, no compositional factors, no consciousness, no eye, no ear, no nose, no tongue, no body, no mind, no visual form, no sound, no sound, no odor, no taste, no object of touch, and no phenomenon. There is no eye element and so on up to and including no mind element and no mental consciousness element. There is no ignorance, no extinction of ignorance, and so on, up to and including no aging and death, and no extinction of aging and death.
Similarly, is no suffering, origination, cessation, path. There is no exalted wisdom, no attainment, and also no non attainment. Śāriputra, therefore, because there is no attainment, bodhisattvas rely on and dwell on the perfection of wisdom, the mind without obscuration and without fear. Having completely passed beyond error, they reach the endpoint of nirvana. All the Buddhas who dwell in the three times also manifest, they completely awaken to unsurpassable, perfect, complete enlightenment in reliance on the perfection of wisdom.
Therefore, the mantra of the perfection of wisdom, the mantra of great knowledge, the unsurpassed mantra, the mantra equal to the unequal, the mantra that thoroughly pacifies all suffering should be known as the truth, since it is not false. The mantra of the perfection of wisdom is declared, Tayata Om Gate Gate Pāragate Pārasamgate Bodhi Svāhā. Śāriputra, the bodhisattva, Mahāsattva should train in the profound perfection of wisdom like that. Then the Bhagavan arose from that concentration and commended the Bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara, saying, Well said, well said, son of the lineage. It is like that.
It is like that. Once you practice the profound perfection of wisdom, just as you have indicated, even the Tathagatas rejoice. The Bhagavan having thus spoken, the Venerable Venerable Śāriputra, the Bodhisattva Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara, those surrounding in their entirety, along with the worlds of gods, humans, asuras, Gandharvas, were overjoyed and highly praised what had been spoken by the Bhagavan. We’ll sit and meditate. So if you like to stand up for a second and stretch.
So I didn’t bring my without the words I’m lost, I didn’t bring what I was going to meditate on. Had some notes, but so we’ll just stare at each other for a while. Meditate. Reality is attention. What we pay attention to becomes our reality.
I think it’s a useful notion to keep in mind and to reflect upon from time to time. And more than not, as I’ve mentioned, our attention is directed through unconscious habit. So we continue paying attention to those things which we might not choose otherwise if we were conscious of what we’re penchant to. But more than that, we’re simply reinforcing a lot of old patterns simply by paying attention to those elements within our experience which tend to support and maintain and extend those patterns of ways of thinking and ways of being which perhaps haven’t served us all that well up to now. So know, it’s interesting because when we’re talking about the four noble truths, I mentioned that the first noble truth is truth of suffering, and that there’s a cause to that, which is the second noble truth, the truth of the origins of suffering.
But then the Buddha taught the third noble truth, which is cessation of suffering. Sometimes in our haste to make change, we overlook those times when there is a natural cessation, when we aren’t experiencing the problem, when we act with profound wisdom, with real love, with where we express the real genuine inner strength, when we are caring, loving, happy, sane human beings, when there is is there is the cessation of the problem and there is an expression of mental health. And sometimes we overlook those times because they don’t quite fit with the self image that we are continually reinforcing by what it is that we pay attention to. And so sometimes I think it’s very useful to consciously review and bring to the forefront and emphasize the significance of when we did act with great caring, we did make a right choice, when we did exercise wisdom, when we did, you know, act with the strength that we perhaps weren’t even aware we had, when there was clarity of mind. It’s not so useful always to think that somehow we’re these just keep looking at what we do wrong.
There’s a story about you know, in the Zen tradition, the type of Buddhism which is very much practiced in parts of China and Korea, Japan, parts of Vietnam. Is they often the students will go to the Zen master and report on his progress and his practice and his meditation and so forth. And there was this one occasion where the student went to his teacher, his master, and he bowed to his teacher and he, quite hesitantly, he blurted out, teacher, teacher, there’s something wrong. There’s something wrong. And his teacher, what’s what’s the problem?
What’s the problem? And the student said, I I I I’ve been thinking I’m a dog. I said, yes? Oh, yes. How long has that been happening?
And the student said, ever since I was a puppy. You know? Sometimes we get so wrapped up in our stories that we believe our stories, We buy into our stories that we have about ourselves. That, you know, that it we lose sight of any actual reality whether they actually reflect who in effect we are. The story becomes a substitute for our actual experience.
You know, if I’m a puppy if I’m a dog now, then I must have been a puppy in the past. And that’s just logically follows, doesn’t it? And if I’m I’m gonna be an old dog in the future, you know, slobbering and limping around. I mean, that’s that’s what happens when you when old dogs when dogs get old. You know, it just logically follows.
And so we have an idea about who we are and we and we’ll logically follow-up on that. And our life becomes to a large degree a self fulfilling, self defeating prophecy. You know, sometimes we don’t even look to our actual experience to see whether what we’re actually doing and saying and feeling are actually an accurate reflection, are actually reflected in the stories, the self image that we have about ourselves. There can be a wide discrepancy quite often, so sometimes I think it’s useful. So that’s what we’re going to meditate on.
I decided. Okay. We’re just going to move from different periods of our life and really, you know, some of the things that we can feel good about, something that we did right, where we exercised a great judgment and our wisdom was operating, really had a real sense of altruistic caring, acted with real inner strength. And, you know, like, give yourself a pat on the back. And it’s okay.
A little pride maybe is useful sometimes. The healthy pride. There’s a pride of a bodhisattva, for example. Know, feeling good about yourself, respecting yourself can go a long way. So that was a nice thing I did.
That was really wise. That was really it’s quite caring thing I did. Don’t pat yourself on your back. Value what you do. So we’re going to work with different time periods in our past and then work toward the present, reviewing and just picking.
Sometimes we overlook them. We dismiss them. We discount them for one reason or another. You know, oh, that’s not really who I am. I did that blah blah blah.
No, that’s not true. Okay, so take in a comfortable, firm posture. So first getting in touch with the body, beginning at the crown of the head, the scalp, and feeling the wrinkles in your brows smoothing out. The pressure in and around your eyes diminishing. The muscles of the face softening, relaxing.
Of relaxing. Your jaw is relaxed. Bring your awareness to the back of your neck and perhaps gently turn your head to each side a few times, gently stretching, loosening the muscles of the back of the neck. Relaxing the muscles of the throat. Bringing awareness to your upper back and shoulders and perhaps rotating your shoulders a few times.
Raising them up towards your ears and just allowing them to drop comfortably to the sides and with that feeling some kind of burden or weight that we maybe have been unwaringly carrying around on our backs and our shoulders is some some sense of relief. Some some weight’s been lifted from your your shoulders. And bring your awareness all the way down to your hands. Your hands are soft and relaxed, loose. Relaxed, loose.
Relax in your lower arms. Your upper arms. Your chest is at ease. Throughout the heart area and the lungs. The central region of the back, the stomach, releasing the tension that we hold in our stomach muscles, allowing the belly to go soft throughout the abdominal cavity.
And keeping your back straight, your trunk erect, relax your lower back muscles. Buttocks, throughout the upper legs, thighs, and the lower legs, and finally your feet. Bring your awareness to your body in general, roughly scanning through the body, noticing any tightnesses, any tensions which might remain in the body, any areas of discomfort. And breathing in and down to that area of tension wherever it might be in your body. And just imagining as if you were breathing out from that area of tension wherever it might be in your body, upward and out.
And with that, the tension diminishing, breathing in and down to an area of tightness wherever it might be in your body and breathing out from that area. Imagining the tightness loosen. Breathing in and discomfort in the body, and without avoiding it, not resisting or struggling against it, breathing in and down, surrounding that area of discomfort, like a mother cradling her her child, cradling that area of discomfort with the kindness of your breath, and breathing out from that area. And as you do so, experiencing a softening and accepting, allowing it to be, it’s okay if it’s there. Breathing into the areas of tightness and tension and discomfort, breathing out from those areas.
And with that, the body becoming comfortable, at ease, and feeling the physical well-being pervading the entire body. Sometimes we forget how comfortable it is just to be with the body. So there’s no place to go and nothing that needs to be done, nobody to please. Just give yourself a break for a while. A chance simply to be with your body, to be with the body, at rest, at ease, experiencing the body, whatever is there.
Staying with the experience of the body. Then we’ll do the simple breath exercise, breathing in comfortably normally, breathing out, extending the exhalation, just very gently forcing all the air out of the lungs. Again, breathing in comfortably normally, allowing the lungs to fill naturally. And again, extending the exhalation. And then bringing your mind to the breath.
The easy, gentle, in and out flow of the breath, wherever the sensation associated with the breath is most clear and obvious. Focusing your attention on that sensation. Bring your mind back to the breath. Now we’re going to meditate on valuing and appreciating, and we’re going to look back to something that we did or said or even thought more than one year ago. Looking back to some incident, it doesn’t have to be dramatic or major.
You didn’t have to win the Nobel Prize or find a cure for cancer, but something that you can reflect upon and feel good about, bring to mind and value it, congratulate yourself. Something that you did or said more than one year ago, that was really a nice thing I did. That was really quite clever and intelligent. That was really a powerful statement. So reviewing, looking back more at something that you said or did more than one year ago and bring it to mind and value it, appreciate it, congratulate yourself.
Really go over the top. And we’ll do the same, simply shift the time period from more than one month ago up to one year ago. More than one month ago, but less than one year ago. So just reviewing, picking out some incident and valuing it, appreciating it, congratulating yourself. There’s always something.
It can be even. It can be it can appear very minor, but perhaps you’re just discounting. There’s always And, again, we’ll change the time period. More than one week ago up to one month ago. So reviewing that time period, finding something to rejoice in, to value and appreciate about yourself.
Again, changing the time period from yesterday up to one week ago. And one last time period, today. Again, it doesn’t have to be overly dramatic. It could be just smiling at someone, a gesture, finding something you can value, that you can appreciate, that you said or did or thought today. And then bringing the mind back to the breath.
And getting in touch with your body, the pressure of your buttocks on the cushion, on the chair, feet on the floor. Becoming aware of the sounds around us. And becoming aware of your surroundings. So, we’re coming to these final verses, some of the final verses of the three principal aspects of the path the path by Tsongkhapa. So there’s some more copies of the if you want to look at them as we go along.
How are we doing here? Here. Here. Here. Here’s another one.
So for some of the new people, you’re welcome. This particular discussion, this talk around these, the three principal aspects of the path we’ve been going on for some time. And we’re in the closing stages of it, so you might have to bear with us. We’ve covered a lot of ground. I’m just kind of bringing some especially around the third principle aspects of the path.
So the Three Principal Aspects I’m having trouble talking tonight. The three principal aspects of the path tonight the path are the will to awaken. This is kind of my mumbo jumbo. The will to awaken. Most of the time it’s translated as renunciation or the freedom or the determination to be free.
So the first principal aspect is simply, you know, as we talked about at the very beginning when we were discussing our motivation, developing a determination to change. Without that then there probably won’t be any change, at least not in the direction that we might like to go if we were to constantly become aware of that. And then how do we change? What are the directions that we’re moving toward? The second principal aspect of the path is the awakened heart, the development of love and compassion.
And finally, the third is the awakened mind, which sometimes is translated as the view of understanding emptiness, seeing deeper, deeply into the nature of reality. So this is the we’re coming to the final verses on this third principle aspects of the path. So on the back of the of the translation, I think it’s one, two, three, four, the fifth verse down. It says, As long as the two, appearance as infallible, dependent arising, and emptiness as freedom from assertion as true appear distinct one from the other. You have yet to realize the Subduer’s thought.
So, as we’ve talked about, dependent arising is the other side of the coin of emptiness. Phenomena dependent arisings because they’re empty of independent existence, and they’re empty of independent existence because they’re dependent arisings. So, you know, we discussed that the meaning of dependent arising is emptiness. They say empty of something. Whenever we use the term empty, we mean empty of something.
There’s an absence of something. There’s lack or a nonexistence of something. That something is hard to get a hand on, hard to identify, but it’s essential that we do. And we can use many different terms to try to get at what things are empty of. More than that, it’s simply a fantasized way of existing.
So we’re always talking about not whether things exist or not, not whether this table exists or not, or the I, the self exists or not. We’re not calling that into question. What we are calling into question is the way they exist. How does the table exist? How does the I exist?
We have some misconceptions with regard to that wrong beliefs, which we call ignorance. So these fantasized ways of existing, that which phenomena are empty of are termed independent existence, inherent existence, true existence, objective existence, intrinsic existence, existence from its own side. Lots of synonyms, but they’re all trying to get at the same thing. That things have a way of abiding, which is independent of everything outside of themselves, independent of causes and conditions, independent of their own parts, and importantly and most subtly, of language and thought. You know, we talked about this labeling process.
All products, all things, tables, buildings, people, I, self, are dependent upon causes and conditions. They’re dependent upon their parts. They’re dependent upon language and conceptuality, which uses those terms and thoughts. Nothing exists independent of those. They are dependent arisings.
This table is a dependent arising. I am a dependent arising. You are a dependent arising. Significance of this is that ignorance holds the completely opposite position with regards to phenomena. It holds that things have an inherent nature, that things have intrinsic intrinsic characteristics which don’t depend upon our thinking them as such, which don’t depend upon cause and conditions and so forth.
Beauty is in the very nature, the ability to bring bliss. Ugliness is in the very nature of the object. You know, it’s it’s it’s intrinsic quality. That ability that, you know, that that repulsive quality of that object is intrinsic to the object itself, itself, coming from its own side. These appearances of good, bad, beautiful, ugly, friend, enemy, stranger do not rely upon our thinking them as such.
They are in the very nature of the object, divorced of my opinions, my ideas, my attitude toward them. They are inherent qualities. They objectively exist within the object themselves. So we can see that which holds that as being the way things in fact exist is ignorance. Due to that to that grasping at this these these the the objects themselves and all their characteristics as being inherent, as being intrinsic, as being objectively existing from the side of the object, we then go on to react to that belief in that with hostility toward anything which appears to us to exist, to appear as a threat threat to ourselves.
We act with we generate attachment to anything which appears to have the potential to enhance our existence. So all the various afflictive emotions, the passion, the reactive patterns which are set into motion, all depend upon our seeing those corresponding characteristics as existing out there, having nothing to do with the way that we’re looking at the object, the way that we’re thinking and considering and talking, the way our beliefs about the object. In this way, it’s logical. It’s reasonable. If things existed in that manner, if things were inherently repulsive, inherently beautiful, then attachment, you know, taking these various positions that we do, these reactive positions, example attachment or repulsion, hostility, make sense.
This has by its very nature the potential to bring me bliss. If I can make make that mine, I can I can imbibe that bliss eternally? That’s kind of the the internal logic of ignorance and all that follows from that. So we act in a manner which is inappropriate to the reality of the object. There’s a discrepancy between our beliefs about the nature of the object and the way the object actually exists.
Discrepancy, it’s interesting because I think Buddhism is always you know, we talk about the Dharma, don’t we? Sometimes we talk about it being the truth. It’s the truth which makes us free, which brings about cessation, peace. Brings about cessation, peace. As long as there’s a disparity between our beliefs and our belief laden perceptions on the one hand and reality on the other, disparity, that discrepancy is experienced in some manner or another as disappointment, frustration, anxiety, fear.
Suffering, basically. We can dress it up any way you like. It’s only when we in in a way, we have no choice if we’re able to find peace. We we have to give up. We have to you know, to demand that reality be other than the way it is is to lead a dishonest life.
And moreover, one that is bound up with disappointment, frustration, anxiety and so forth. We have no choice but begin to accord our ways of viewing the world with the way it actually exists. And to do that we have to overcome ignorance. To do that we have to develop the wisdom which opposes that ignorance. So we’re trying to develop the wisdom understanding emptiness.
Emptiness of what? Emptiness of these fantasized ways of existing. Everything is a dependent arising. That wisdom which understands that is the other side of the coin of the wisdom understanding emptiness, of these fantasized ways of existing. The text says, As long as the two, appearance as infallible dependent arising and emptiness as freedom from assertion as true, appear distinct or we could say appear as separate, one from another, you have yet to realize the subduer’s thought.
You know, over the course of coming to a correct understanding of the subduer’s thought, the Subduer is the Buddha, that is an epithet of the Buddha, on the ultimate nature of reality. We may pass through a phase in our understanding where the view of dependent arising and emptiness appear as two separate entities, almost incompatible qualities. The appearance of whatever appears to us arises in dependence. And, you know, it arises in dependence upon causes and conditions, it arises in dependence upon its parts, but it also arises in dependence upon language and conceptuality, our thinking of it as such. This is called the conventional nature of phenomena as merely dependent arises.
This table is a dependent arising. This building is a dependent arising. I am a dependent arising. But when we investigate this very appearance, this table, this building, this I, these things appear. They appear due to causes and conditions and so forth.
They appear. We can’t deny that appearance, that there is something appearing to it. But when we investigate that very appearance, we come to understand that discover that the emptiness as freedom from assertion is true. Like it says in the text, Appearance as infallible, dependent arising and emptiness as freedom from assertion is true. Assertion is true, it means that when we investigate these very appearances, when we perform an ultimate analysis, can’t find the object that appears to us, that appears so vividly to exist objectively out there.
We can’t find it. So, you know, it seems, on the one hand that these two ideas, that these two ideas, that of dependent arising and emptiness, are mutually exclusive, like hot and cold water. You know, how can one thing, how can this table be both a dependent arising and at the same time be unfindable upon analysis? How can those things which arise, this table which rises, it depends upon cause and conditions, you know, parts and language and so forth, which we can’t deny its appearance, at same time be unfindable analyze it, when we perform ultimate analysis. The same object.
So it seems like we were talking, you know, they’re almost incompatible. How can that which actually appears be unfindable? So this brings us An emptiness as freedom from assertion is true. Okay, the word true here means things exist the way they appear. This table appears to exist independent of my mind, independent of cause and condition, independent of its part.
Does it actually exist that way? If this table appears one way and exists another, therefore it is not true. It is a falsity. This table is a falsity. This building is a falsity.
It is only true for ignorance. It is it is false for a wisdom consciousness which analyzes, which understands the ultimate. Emptiness as as freedom from assertion is true. This table is empty of true existence. Why?
Because a falsity. Why is it a falsity? Because the way it appears and the way it exists are incongruent. There’s a disparity. It appears one way and exists another.
Therefore, it’s not true. It’s false. But when they no longer alternate but coincide, let us say appearance as infallible, dependent arising, emptiness as freedom, assertion as truly existent. When these understandings, when they no longer alternate such that the mere seeing of the infallibility of dependent arising, definite knowledge totally destroys the way you conceive of things as real, then your analysis of the view is complete. So at some point in coming to an understanding of emptiness and of dependent arising, some point, these two seemingly separate understandings of dependent arising and emptiness are integrated.
Dependent arising and emptiness are seen not as mutually contradictory. We realize how both dependent arising and emptiness can apply simultaneously to one and the same object without there being any conflict. This table, it is a dependent arising, yet it is empty of true existence. This one and the same object, it is both of those. And I’ll read a quotation to give you an idea of an example, what’s trying to be gotten at here.
Consider, for example, a rosary, okay? So you have this, you know, a mala, a rosary of beads. A rosary is dependent upon being imputed by mind. Okay, so, you know, you get some beads and you, I guess, drill a hole through the center of the bead, maybe a hundred and eight beads, maybe a hundred and eleven beads, whatever. And you you you get this collection of beads and you thread a string through the holes.
And then, in dependence upon this collection of beads, you think with regard to that rosary. It’s imputed. It’s dependent upon being thought of as such. Okay? It’s designated as a rosary.
The existence of the rosary is dependent upon being thought of as such, being labeled, being designated. A rosary is dependent upon its being imputed by the mind, okay? So there’s no rosary which exists independent of that imputing process being thought of as a rosary. Therefore, it does not exist as an autonomous entity independent of mental imputation. Okay?
So we can begin to have some sense of that. There’s this collection of one hundred and eight beads threaded upon a string, and dependence upon that with regard to that we think, rosary. in dependence upon that mental imputation, the rosary comes into existence. There’s no rosary which is independent of that mental imputation. The rosary’s mere lack of independent autonomous existence is the emptiness of the rosary.
So that rosary is empty of existing, independent of being imputed by thought and language. Okay? And this emptiness is the ultimate mode of the rosary. When we perform, you know, we can analyze things at various levels. We can analyze this table at relatively superficial level in terms of its size, its being a rectangle, its being made of wood.
Depending upon what kind of information, our use we’re going to make of it, we analyze and find different qualities about the object. To an antique dealer, they would look at it from one point of view. A botanist might be interested in a type of wood, a carpenter might be interested in how it was constructed and so forth. A constructed and so forth. A molecular physicist would say, Well, that table is just a collection of atoms and so forth, molecules.
It’s mostly empty space. If we were to analyze it in its deepest mode of being, what we would come to would be its emptiness. So this is what we call ultimate analysis. When we go to its when our analysis comes to final conclusion as to the way the table exists, this is an ultimate analysis and what we find is an emptiness of a fantasized way of existing which, okay, its ultimate mode of being. And thus there are two aspects to the rosary, its ultimate mode of being and its conventional mode of being.
Its ultimate mode of being is what we find upon ultimate analysis, that it’s empty of a fantasized way of existing. It’s empty of true existence. It’s empty of independent existence. Its conventional mode of being is that it is dependent for its existence upon mental imputation. Okay?
But although we think of these two aspects as distinct qualities, in essence they are identical. This is to say the rosary being merely a mental imputation and its being void of it existing independently, a mental imputation can be thought of and spoken of as distinct, but in reality they are one and the same thing. So the conventional nature of the table, we would describe it as being existing in dependence upon mental imputation and its ultimate mode of being, we would talk about it in the sense of it being empty, of existing, independent. And it’s just like using double negatives in a way, independent of imputation. So this is getting at the idea of what we call the two truths.
These are One truth is hard enough and we’ve two truths. It’s fundamental doctrine or notion within Buddhism. The two truths, the conventional truth and the ultimate truth. The appearance of the table is its conventional truth. Appearance of this table establishes the conventional existence of this table as a dependent arising.
And it refutes its nonexistence. The table appears. It refutes that it doesn’t exist. The emptiness phenomena establishes the non intrinsic existence and refutes ultimate existence. So the table, all phenomena conventionally exist.
Nothing ultimately exists. These are difficult concepts, aren’t they? Conventional existence, that is to say, they rely upon they are conventions. They rely upon everything is simply an agreement in terms of the names that we use to designate it and so forth. Nothing ultimately exists.
If something were to ultimately exist, it would have to be found upon ultimate analysis. What do we find when we search for the table? We don’t find the table. We find the emptiness of that table. Nothing can withstand ultimate analysis.
We find the emptiness of the table. So the appearance so we just have things simply appear. Can call it like superficial truth. It’s valid. You know, we’re demeaning appearance.
Things simply appear. They perform functions. This table, I can put books on it. But it doesn’t truly exist. But it still performs a function.
And I can drink this water, it will quench my thirst, but the water doesn’t truly exist. It’s empty of that way of existing. So know, this appearance establishes the mere existence of the object. Its emptiness establishes that that very appearance does not truly exist, that it’s empty of object existing from its own side, existing by way of its own intrinsic nature and so forth. So the point Tsongkhapa is trying to make, and I’m creating a lot of confusion around it, think, is that when these two understandings no longer alternate or coincide, The conventional truth and ultimate truth are one entity.
It is two ways that we can talk about the same object. We can talk about the conventional truth of this table, this glass, this building, my eye, in that it’s able to perform, it has certain characteristics, is able to perform per particular functions. The glass can, the water can quench my thirst. It’s able to perform that function. That’s its conventional nature.
Its ultimate nature is that that water does not truly exist. You have to be satisfied with mere appearances. If you try to find what those appearances, if you investigate those appearances, you will not find the object. And this is why we talk about illusory like qualities. Things appear, things function, they work.
So we cannot, to a mind which is not investigating the nature of the optics, everything fits together quite well, reasonably well. Drink the water and it quenches your thirst. If you aren’t satisfied with mere appearance and you want to know the nature of that appearance, you will not be able to find the object which appears. You will find the emptiness of that object. Yeah?
Can you apply that to a concept? To a concept? Because a concept is a dependent arising. Everything’s a dependent. And if you try and search for it, it doesn’t ultimately exist.
Yeah, that’s right. So this table is a dependent arising. So everything convention ally exists. Nothing ultimately exists. So what Tsongkhapa is trying to get at is that these two understandings apply to every single object.
Dependent arising emptiness appear differently to conceptual consciousness. You know, we can think of, for example, a house and the material from which house is made, the cement, the bricks, the wood, the glass and so forth, all the materials that went in. We can think of them as separate entities. When we think of house, we don’t have to think of what the house is made of. We don’t have to think, is it a brick house, is it a wooden house, is it a fibro house?
We think we can just think of house. You know, I’d like to buy a new house, you know? And at that moment I may have no idea about what type of house, how many rooms, where I want that house. I just have a house. And then I can think about, well, you know, I can think about the materials from which the house is made.
But in fact, they’re the same entity, aren’t they? I mean, we can’t in fact, when you have direct perception, when you actually look at a house, you see the wood, the cement, the brick, the glass. We can conceive of things as being different entities when in fact they’re the same entity. To thought, this is the way thought operates. It abstracts characteristics.
Whereas direct perception is called a collective engager. It we see all the elements of the object. Let’s take an example. Let’s figure out an example. This table, you know.
I can think of a table. I have no, you know, I need a new table for my room. I could it might be a plastic table, a wooden table, it might be, you know, it could be all I just have an idea in my mind of a table. I can think of various materials, plastic, wood and so forth, that a table can be made from. And I can think of those as being two different entities.
But in fact, the material that the table is constructed from and the table are the same entity. They’re not two separate entities. Likewise, dependent arising and emptiness are one entity. We can think of them as being separate and distinct, but in fact they’re one. When we think of, you know, this idea, it’s called technically it’s called, it doesn’t matter what it’s called technically.
Thinking of a house, don’t necessarily have to think of the materials from which the house is made. Thinking of the materials from which the house is made, we don’t necessarily have to or the house doesn’t have to appear to our mind. But when we see them directly, then they both appear to our mind, the house and the materials from which it is made. They are one entity. They can only be conceptually separated out, not in fact.
We think so the idea which is Tsongkhapa is trying to get here and I’m trying to get here is that though we may think of dependent arising as being something separate from and distinct from emptiness because we can think about the dependent arising of this table and we can think about the emptiness of the table as being can think of them as being separate, but in fact they’re one entity when we directly see them. So this is what, you know, when we read the Heart Sūtra, which we’ve been doing every evening together, where it says, Form is empty. Emptiness is form. Form is not other than emptiness. Emptiness is not other than form.
Exactly what the point which is being made here. The form, which is the appearance of the object, which is the conventional nature of the object, and its emptiness are not Emptiness isn’t some kind of added on, stuck on to it, like a tumour or something like that. It is in the very entity of the object, in the very nature of the object. The emptiness of this table is in the very nature of the table. It is not something that we are imposing upon the table.
It is the same entity as the table. There’s a quote here. Maybe we can go through this together. So it’s just two modes of the way that the table exists. The table has two modes of existing.
One of it is a conventional mode of existing, which is that it exists a dependent arising and depends upon causes and conditions, and it has an ultimate mode of existence, which is that it’s empty of inherent existence. It’s just two modes of the same object, two ways of viewing the same object. Yeah? It’s a very yeah. They aren’t separate.
The basis of these two are not different, are not separate. They’re one and the same. So when the significance of dependent arising is understood to mean that nothing intrinsically exists, so if something is, you know, the meaning of dependent arising is that things are, you know, shorthand notice, shorthand way of talking about it is that things are merely imputed, things are merely designated, when meaning is understood that nothing intrinsically exists, nothing objectively exists. When this reinforces our understanding that dependent arising is infallible, then as Tsongkhapa says, Tsongkhapa says somewhere, I’m sure he said it. If he didn’t say it, he should have said it.
And what’s that? Oh, here it is. Such that when they no longer alternate but coincide. So these two understandings, these two understandings about the way the table exists. One understanding is that it’s a dependent arising, that it depends upon mental imputation, and the other understanding that it is empty of inherent existence.
These two understandings, when they no longer alternate, you know, it seems as if the two are incompatible, but when we can understand both simultaneously with regard to one object such that the mere seeing of the infallibility of dependent arising, definite knowledge destroys, totally destroys the way you can see that things is real, then your analysis of the view is complete. One and the same thing appears but is unfindable upon analysis. This is what we mean by the illusory like nature of objects, that without investigating the object they perform all the functions that we assign to them. The world operates. It works.
But when investigate those appearances, we understand that they are unfindable upon analysis, upon ultimate analysis. Moreover, okay, the extreme of true existence is dispelled by appearance and that of non existence emptiness. If you understand the way emptiness finds expression within the context of cause and effect, you will no longer be captivated by extreme views. So previously we said that while dependent arising and the emptiness of a phenomena are thought of as separate, they are a single entity. We can posit phenomena in a twofold way.
This table, I, all objects. Are trying to avoid falling into. We talk about the middle way. One meaning of what we mean by middle way is a way of viewing reality, the way things exist, avoids the two possible extremes. What are the two extremes?
One is called the extreme of permanence. By permanence we mean that you see you hold things as being inherently existent, as truly existent, as objectively existent. You know, the extreme of holding this table to be inherently existent, intrinsically existent. The other extreme is nonexistence. If things don’t exist inherently objectively, then they don’t exist at all.
That’s a falling to the extreme nihilism. Nothing exists. So the middle way is a view which avoids these two possible extremes, that of eternalism eternalism and nihilism, the extreme of permanence and nothingness, that nothing exists. So how does the middle way avoid these two extremes? Through denying that phenomena have any inherent existence, we avoid the extreme of permanence.
You know, that things exist. If, you know, if thought if things existed inherently, that would be their very nature from the very beginning. Things would necessarily have to be as they are without beginning and without end. They could never have come into existence in reliance upon any cause and conditions. They are what they are without depending upon any other factor outside of themselves.
They would have to be what they are from beginningless and endlessly unchangingly so. That’s kind of the implication of what inherent existence would involve. What a thing is, it has to be always that, unchangingly so, because it is that by way of its own nature, which is independent of any other factors, causes, conditions. It would be unchanging in what it is. It could never it doesn’t depend upon anything outside of itself for what it is.
It is static, frozen, unchanging nature. Therefore, that is the view of eternalism. It is that always. The other is, you know, that is the So by positing the By that phenomena are dependent arisings, we avoid the extreme of eternalism because it arose. It hasn’t been always what it is.
It is dependent. It came into existence and dependence upon cause and conditions. It arose independence. It arose in dependence upon our thinking of it as such. So it can’t be frozen, static, unchanging, have an intrinsic nature.
By understanding that they are empty, we understand that if phenomena were not empty, they could not come into existence. Emptiness is like, you know, this line from the Heart Sūtra, Form is empty. Emptiness is form. Form is not other than emptiness. Emptiness is not other than form. It’s like emptiness is the very ground from which allows for things to come into existence.
‘s like space. Without space there would be no abode where things could abide. Space allows for form to exist. Space supports that very existence by providing a allowing for and providing for form to have an abode for its existence. If there were no space, something could not exist there.
Form could not exist there. Emptiness is like that in a way. Sometimes it’s spoken of that it is things are manifestations of emptiness. Emptiness is what allows objects to actually come into existence. Because they are not intrinsically existence, because they are dependent on existence, then they can arise.
Allows for the coming it allows for change. If things were not empty, if things were true if things were in intrinsic existence, things would be static, unchanging. They would be what they are for eternity because that is their very nature. But things are empty of that. So this very factor of emptiness allows for transformation, allows for change, allows for coming into existence.
It is like the space which allows for for form to come into it, to abide. Things are a manifestation quality of emptiness, if you follow what I mean. So Anyway, the extreme of true existence is dispelled by appearance. Because things appear, they cannot cannot be inherently existent. They cannot be the very fact that there are these appearances is significance of this is that they cannot be truly existent.
They cannot be inherently existent. For things to appear, have to How do things appear? They appear in dependence upon the perceptual process. The perceptual process involves labeling, designating what they are. The very fact that they appear means that they’re empty of true existence.
Because why? Because their dependent arisings. Why? Because their dependent those very appearances are dependent upon our thinking them as such, that this is a glass, this water and so forth. On the other hand, the very fact of emptiness negates that they’re nonexistence.
Something has to exist for it to be empty because it’s empty of a fantasized way of existing, therefore it must exist. So the very fact of existence, the significance of emptiness establishes that phenomena are not nonexistent, they exist. Moreover the extreme of true existence is dispelled by appearance, okay? The fact that appearances arise demonstrates that they are dependent, that they do not exist from their own side, and that of nonexistence by emptiness. So the fact that things are empty of this fantasized way of existing means that they cannot not exist, that they do exist but not in this but they don’t exist in this fantasized way.
If you understand the way emptiness finds expression within the context of cause and effect, so even though simply a is simply a manner of speaking, is simply dependent upon our thinking of as such does not mean that pineapples come from apple seeds. Apples come from apple seeds. The law of cause and effect is infallible even though it’s only a matter of convention. That there is, within this emptiness of any true existence, of any objective existence, there is the law of cause and effect is infallible and that there is always a similarity between the result, a similarity of type between the result and its cause. Apples come from apple seeds.
Pineapples do not come from apple seeds. Even though they don’t truly exist, even though they’re illusions, still the cause and effect operate within the universe. It’s not chaos. Even chaos really, yeah, doesn’t truly exist. Yeah?
You will no longer be captivated by extreme views. The extreme views of eternalism on the one hand that things are static, frozen, they have intrinsic nature, on the other hand that they don’t exist at all. The extreme view of eternalism on the one hand and nihilism on the other. We’re trying to find a you know, it’s very hard to find this middle way, you know. When you begin to refute these appearances, you fall to the extreme of nihilism.
Nothing exists. If I don’t exist the way I appear, I must not exist at all. There’s a fear. Extremism. It’s probably a little bit better to fall into nihilism.
Once Lama Yeshe said, Only a very intelligent person who really analyzed very deeply could fall into nihilism. Or you just had a bad trip or something, maybe. One of the two. You know, where you think, Oh, nothing, nothing exists. If things don’t exist the way they a solid concrete, the way they appear to me, then they don’t exist at all.
To see that there’s some middle ground there, to penetrate that, is very subtle. And I think it requires a great deal of diligence and intelligence and perseverance. To believe in this illusory like world still operates, functions, but there’s nothing we can grab onto. They’re just appearances, but they work. We can’t ask for anything more than that.
There’s nothing behind the appearances. Okay, let’s see. Then finally, his final verse. Final verse by Tsongkhapa where he says, Then when you have realized, just as they are, these essentials of the three principal aspects of the path: the will to awaken the awakened heart and the awakened mind resort to solitude intensify your joyous effort and quickly, my child, fulfill your ultimate dream. You know, Tsongkhapa, he wrote this short text, these three principal aspects of the path, at the request of one of his close disciples.
It was actually in the form of almost a letter to one of his disciples by the name of Ngawang Drakpa, and who he refers to as my child. But in fact, it’s addressed to us all. And this is a quote by Henry David Thoreau from Walden Pond. So, you know, we’ve gone through a long journey, know, working through these three spiritual aspects of the path. I learned this, at least by my experiment, that if one advances confidently in the direction of his dreams and endeavors to live the life which he has imagined.
He will meet with success unexpected in common hours. He will put some things behind, will pass an invisible boundary, new universal and more liberal laws will begin to establish themselves around and within him, or the old laws be expanded and interpreted in his favor in a more liberal sense. And he live with the license of a higher order of being. If you have built castles in the air, your work need not be lost. That is where they should be.
Now put the foundations under them. So, you know, next week will be the last week, and we’ll just go through a rough review of these three principal aspects of the path. But, you know, we I think, Tsongkhapa is helping us to dream about another order of being sometimes that we lose sight of. This is the tyranny of normality. Our society, you know, it’s not the society as individuals, but the institution.
It has its ways of forcing us back to think of ourselves normalizing effect. This is about all I can expect. The range of our vision becomes very, very narrowed. And we keep, and even though we aspire to something more, these, the seeming pressures of of I’m looking another word. Conforming.
Conforming. That’s a good one. Thank you for that. Conforming, you know, it’s difficult to step outside the boundaries of, you know, of our ideologies and our psychologies, our taken for granted truth. What, you know, religious indoctrination of what is commonly accepted in terms of the pressures of our culture and begin to dream for yourself and to begin to but we all do.
Maybe we’ve lost touch with those dreams. And to resurrect those on the dreams and begin to to put the construct the foundations beneath them. So next week we’ll just do a very quick review of these three aspects of the path just to of jog our memory, just to remind ourselves of some of the points involved. Okay. So that was quite a trip tonight, wasn’t comments?
Any any we got a few minutes. Any questions or yeah. So so where where do we go from here? Where do you go? Well, you could get yourself a cup of tea.
Mean, practically speaking, I mean, there are in terms of continuing your studies, there’s possibilities in terms of Geshe la’s teachings on Tuesday night and Thursday night and on Sunday mornings. Then John Young will be teaching. I don’t know. I haven’t been advised of what’s going to happen on Monday nights, if anything. So I really can’t say.
And there’s Khensur Rinpoche, at Tārā Institute. So by all means, you know, finding something that works for you and continuing your studies. I think, you know, this we’ve talked about these three activities of listening, reflecting, and meditating. So, you know, it’s I think we you know, what we come to understand arises in a context. It’s a dependent arising.
These new realizations, they don’t come from nowhere. And they arise within a context. And this context is, to a large extent, the studies that we’ve made, you know, like reading books and listening to teachings, and then questioning, reflecting upon those. So I hope, I’d like to encourage you to continue your studies. You know, the possibility that we do have some good teachers.
So they’re, you know, can engage Geshe-la and Rinpoche and explain things from their own experience in a very clear manner. I mean, it’s hard to get through sometimes, you know, I’m not going to pretend that sometimes it’s hearing it from a Westerner can be much more meaningful at times, but nonetheless, if we’re willing to persevere, we can derive a great deal of benefit, you know, and we can have a lot of our doubts cleared up from people who actually have a thorough knowledge of the subjects and have some experience. They aren’t just talking from, you know, the few books that, for example, that I’ve read. And then there’s the blessing of these these teachers, which is is not, you know, which isn’t outside of the rational and the logical, but nonetheless isn’t to be discounted. They’re just, you know, listening to these teachers, you know, who live who have led a pure life, who live within the vows of monks and so forth and nuns, can have an impact upon the mind, maybe isn’t as apparent as we might demand.
But nonetheless, there’s something going on at an unconscious level. I don’t know if that answers your question at all, but that’s about the best I can do for now. We dedicate the positive energy we created together. May beings everywhere, plagued by suffering of body and mind, obtain an ocean of happiness and joy by virtue of my merits. May no living creature suffer, commit evil, or fall ill.
May no one be afraid or belittled with a mind weighed down by depression. May the blind see forms and deaf hear sounds. May those whose bodies are worn with toil be restored in refreshing repose. May the naked find clothing, the hungry find food. May the thirsty find water and delicious drink.
May the poor find wealth, those weak with sorrow find joy. May the forlorn find hope, constant happiness and prosperity. May there be timely rains and bountiful harvests. May all medicines be effective and wholesome prayers bear fruit. May all who are sick and ill quickly be freed from their ailments.
Whatever disease there are in the world, may they never occur again. May the frightened cease to be afraid, and those bound be freed. May the powerless find power, and may people think of benefiting each other. For as long as space remains, for as long as sentient beings remain, until then may I too remain to dispel the miseries of the world. Through these skillful actions, may I quickly become an awakened spiritual master and lead each and every living being to that awakened realm.
May the supreme jewel, the awakened heart, that has not arisen rise and grow. And may that which has arisen never diminish, but increase more and more. In the land encircled by snow mountains, you are the source of all happiness and well-being. Powerful Chenrezig Tenzin Gyatso. Please remain at the end of cyclic existence.
So if you’d to get a cup of tea, we’ll have a talk, chat. If not, thank you. Good night. Resort to solitude. Resort to solitude.
That’s what Tsongkhapa says.
Key terms in this teaching
- conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
- As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
- The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
- two extremes tha nyi (Tib)
- Eternalism, seeing things as having an intrinsic reality, and nihilism, seeing things as having no reality at all. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.