1 h 51 min · 11,863 words · 1 September 2009 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Using the image of clothes growing wet in morning mist — gradual, unnoticed, transformative — Ven Jampa Gendun opens this nearly two-hour session by reframing spiritual progress as slow saturation rather than dramatic breakthrough. A guided empathy meditation then asks practitioners to inhabit the viewpoints of a loved one, a homeless stranger, and a difficult person in turn, looking back at themselves through each set of eyes. The commentary then turns to the third of Tsongkhapa’s Three Principal Aspects of the Path: wisdom realizing emptiness. Gendun explains why renunciation and bodhicitta alone cannot cut saṃsāra’s root, defines ignorance as projecting inherent existence onto objects and self, and walks through four philosophical stages for approaching emptiness — from naive realism through to the Consequentialist Middle Way. A table, the fashion industry, and a river-and-log analogy make the abstract concrete, before a Q&A closes the session.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 39 3PA 2009 09 01.mp3
UUID: 31d4949e-6aba-4258-9a2e-fa1547a36994
Teacher: Ven Jampa Gendun
Collection: Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Date: 2009-09-01
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 111.7 minutes
Words: ~11,857
How is everybody? Good. Can you hear me okay? I was thinking how fortunate, how lucky we are, and to be thinking about these topics, the subject matter, having made some priority in our lives in terms of developing our own minds, how important that is in the overall quality of our lives, it’s like an auspicious intention. It’s like a blessing in a way, I think.
Sometimes we aren’t aware of these little subtle blessings that we say, we expect heavens to part or something like that. You know, the interest in wanting to develop your mind, change your mind for the better. It’s like a blessing, I think. So it’s useful to take advantage of that and bring ourselves to the present moment. To receptive, though quite often Jampa just goes on and on as if within his clouds of confusion.
Sometimes the teachings are significant or powerful enough that even some ray of sunlight breaks through and can serve to illuminate some darkness in our own minds. Maybe something comes through, and our time together is worthwhile through the blessings of our teachers and the Buddhas, and the consequence of the force of our past merit, our creative potential that we have created. There’s some kind of illumination on a dark night, just a little flash of something perhaps. So anyway, opening ourselves to that possibility and developing a positive motivation, the intention behind what it is that we’re doing here together. I think it’s really a wonderful thing.
I hope we all appreciate ourselves and what we’re doing together. You know, maybe it’s I think sometimes we approach our practice and endeavors with perhaps a bit of spiritual materialism. You We keep looking perhaps in the wrong places for dramatic changes for the better in our lives. Breakthrough insights where everything radically changes in some way or another. We have these bizarre physical or mental experiences in some way or another, we have visions of some kind or another.
I don’t know, maybe I’m getting old, I don’t know. Maybe I’m just leading you up the wrong path. But I have a sense that change is taking place, unbeknownst to us all, perhaps. Maybe there are significant moments, dramatic moments in the course of this process. It’s like when you go off in the mornings in the mist and you’re walking through the mist and you don’t notice it, but slowly your clothes are becoming saturated over time.
Not until sometime later do you realize how wet you’ve become. There was never any single moment when there was any significance or you didn’t notice the wetness. It was just the absorption of what was about us over time, and some kind of change has taken place. Maybe, you know, I guess we should gauge to some degree, but sometimes we look for changes perhaps in the wrong places. Know, bigger, better, more of some pleasure or something like that.
I think just being a little less selfish, a little less caught up and absorbed in your own problems. And your mind just doesn’t get this Velcro mind of ours that keeps getting caught on everything. It’s a little bit smoother, a little more flexible. Life perhaps runs just a little bit easier. You know, we keep falling in the holes again and again.
Shit happens. But maybe we don’t stay in them as long as we used to. We can climb out of them. We take responsibility for being the holes in the first place. I heard a joke.
I’ll show you. My mind’s made a joke. I’m sorry, am I digressing? This man, this folding down a hole reminded me of it. I hope I can get it right.
I shouldn’t have started. Anyway, this man, he fell down a hole. And he’s down in the hole and this doctor walks by and he yells up, Help me out! Help me out! And the doctor writes him a prescription, folds it up and throws it in the hole.
And he’s still down the hole and he sees that there’s a priest who walks by. And he yells up, Help me out! Help me out! And the priest writes down a prayer, folds it up and throws it down in the hole. And then finally, he sees a friend of his walk by and he says, Help me out, help me out.
And the friend jumps down in the hole with him. And he says, Why’d you jump down the hole? Now we’re both in the hole. He says, Yes, but I’ve been in here before and I know a way out. So We can help each other out of these little holes that we’re continually falling into.
Once we’re able to work our way out, even what was that? It was funny the first time I heard we take responsibility of ourselves, then we can help others. If we don’t help ourselves, there’s no way that we can help others. If we try to help ourselves, others can help us. If we don’t try to help ourselves, no one can help us.
In Judaism they have this expression, God helps those who help themselves. It’s kind of paradoxical in a way. It’s like a blessing when you help yourself. But anyway, as we begin to solve problems working with our own mind, we can really be of use to others, and then our life has meaning. We’re not only working, you know, what we do is not only to help help ourselves get out of the hole, but be familiar with how to get out of the hole so we can help others who are in the same, similar holes to what we were in.
And we’re willing to share that with them. I don’t know. What do you think about that? The inner focus of our life becomes that, this person that we can all become, what we call Buddha. We all have a sense about what the good life, what that person might look for each of ourselves, and that changes over time.
The model of well-being, of mental health. That becomes our north that we keep coming back to. We don’t get lost in the story, the habitual stories of the negative stories that we keep telling ourselves about ourselves, which are kind of whole in themselves. But we have to do something to get ourselves out of these holes. We practice the Dharma, the methods, the techniques, all of what we’re talking about here, these teachings, and trying as best we can to implement them in our daily life, to bring about the kinds of changes that we want to make.
Together. That’s important, isn’t it? We’re all in this whole What is it? It reminds me of something else. It’s a quote by We’re all lying in the gutter.
It’s just that some of us are looking at the stars. You know, we’re all very much in the same place, but some of us are. You know, maybe we can, you know, it’s like this mountain, and we’re all trying to climb this mountain in some way or another. Maybe some of us are a little bit further along to others, and we can reach up and grasp the hand of someone who lives a little bit further than ourselves, at least for the time, and reach down and help somebody else over that boulder that’s in front of them. Help them work around that crevasse that they might fall into.
So it’s a joint kind of a community effort, a joint effort getting up this mountain together. Interconnected in that way. I go for refuge until I’m awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha through my practice of generosity and the other perfections. May I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha through my practice of generosity and the other perfections.
May I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. May all sentient beings have happiness and the causes of happiness. May all sentient beings be free from suffering and the causes of suffering.
May all sentient beings be inseparable from the joy that is without sorrow. May all sentient beings abide in equanimity, free from attachment for some and aversion toward others. Oh, I forgot to hand out the I’m sorry. We can listen to you. We’re going to recite the Heart of Wisdom Sūtra for the sake of auspiciousness.
Just did I hear at one time the Bhagavan was dwelling on Vulture’s Peak in Rajgirha together with community of monks and a great community of bodhisattvas. At that time, the Bhagavan was absorbed in the concentration and the categories of phenomena called profound perception. Also at that time, the bodhisattva mahasattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara looked upon the very practice of the profound perfection of wisdom and beheld those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature. Then through the power of the Buddha, the Venerable, Śāriputra said this to the bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara, how should any son of the lineage train who wishes to practice the activities of profound perfection of wisdom? He said that in the Bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara, said this to the Venerable Śāriputra, any son of the lineage or daughter of the lineage who wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom should look upon it like this, correctly and repeatedly behold ing those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature.
Form is empty, emptiness is form, emptiness is not other than form, form is also not other than emptiness. In the same way, feeling, feeling, discrimination, compositional factors, and consciousness are empty. Śāriputra, likewise, all phenomena are emptiness without characteristics, unproduced, unceased, stainless, without stain, not deficient, not fulfilled. Śāriputra, therefore, in emptiness, there is no form, no feeling, no discrimination, no compositional factors, no consciousness, no eye, no ear, no nose, no tongue, no body, no mind, no visual forms, no sounds, no odors, no taste, no touch, and no phenomenon. There is no eye element and so on up to and including no mind element and no mental consciousness element.
There is no ignorance, no extinction of ignorance, and so on, up to and including no aging and death and no extinction of aging and death. Similarly, there is no suffering, origination, cessation, and path. There is no exalted wisdom, no attainment, and also no non attainment. Śāriputra, therefore, because there is no attainment, bodhisattvas rely on and dwell on the perfection of wisdom, the mind without obscuration and without fear. Having completely passed beyond error, they reach the endpoint of nirvana.
All the Buddhas who dwell in the three times also manifestly completely awakened to unsurpassable perfect complete enlightenment and rely on the perfection of wisdom. Therefore, the mantra of the perfection of wisdom, the mantra of great knowledge, the unsurpassable mantra, the mantra equal to the unequal, the mantra that thoroughly pacifies all suffering should be known as the truth since it is not false. The mantra of the perfection of wisdom is declared, Tayatha Gate Gate Pāragate Pārasamgate Bodhi Svāhā. Śāriputra, the Bodhisattva Mahāsattva should train in the profound perfection of wisdom like that. Then the Bhagavan said this, saying, Well said, well said, son of the lineage.
It is like is that. One should practice the profound perfection of wisdom just as you’ve indicated. Even the Tathagatas rejoice. The Bhagavan, having thus spoken, the Venerable Śāriputra, the Bodhisattva Mahāsattva Ārya Avalokiteśvara, those surrounding in their entirety, along with the worlds of gods, humans, asuras, and Gandharvas, were overjoyed and highly praised what had been spoken by the Bhagavan. Difficult names to pronounce.
So if you’d like to stand and stretch, we’re going to meditate. Have discussed the second of the three principal aspects of the Path, the awakened heart, among the various practices within the meditative tradition of equalizing self and others and exchanging self for others. And we discussed this one method, which is called the contemplating the exchange of self and others. This is kind of a variation on that that we’re going to work with in meditation. Okay?
It’s simply helping us to become more sensitive to how we are affecting others and become more sensitive to where other people are at, the development of training empathy, and being able to identify with others. Sympathy means to feel into or feel for, to feel for. Like someone’s having a difficult time, I’m sorry you’re having that hard time. But empathy, we’re able to recognize some parallel experience within our own history, what’s happened for ourselves. You know, someone perhaps is going through relationship difficulty, and you have experienced that yourself in the past, so you know what it feels like.
You can identify approximately what they must be feeling like. And we feel into empathize. We can enter into, to some degree, their subjective experience. I think it’s a wonderful quality to have when people are sensitive and aware of others around them. Others know that you can trust, you can let your defenses, that this person is sensitive to where you’re at.
Think it’s just in our everyday quality of our life, it’s a useful quality to develop. This ability to empathize with others and be there with others with understanding. So we’re simply going to and this is just an exercise, it may evoke different understandings that we’re just going to put ourselves in other people’s places. Try to identify as best you can with what’s going on for them. How would it be to be them?
For example, taking a loved one. This is just by way of example that we’ll use. We’ll use four different individuals. Step into their subjective world, look at the world out of their eyes. How would it be to be them?
As best you can. Completely, but you do know approximately where they are coming from quite often. Looking at the world of their eyes, and then looking back at your former selves. We are going to place ourselves in their subjective experience, identify as best we can with them, and look back at ourselves. And what do you see when you look back at your former self?
How do you feel? Do you feel loved? Do you feel valued? Do you feel respected? Do you feel understood?
And then we simply express what it is that we see, that we feel to our former self. So we’re placing ourselves as best we can within the limitation of the brain, our separation places on us into another subjective experience, identifying as best we can with them, entering in and trying to experience their world, looking the world out of their eyes. And then we look back at our former self, Jampa. How do I experience Jampa? Does Jampa understand where I’m coming from?
How does it feel when somebody walks into the room late? What do you think they’re feeling? Do you think they’re embarrassed? Everybody is looking at me. Now Jampa is talking about me.
I am joking. It’s like when you see that one Chinese basketball player, that’s what, seven foot four is how it is. How would it be had that, trying to put yourself in that place, how would you experience that? You had some kind of prominent difference, as best we can. And then you become sensitive when you do meet people who have prominent differences.
You’re about to have a multifaceted perspective, see things from different points rather than myopic vision. Know what to bring to our experiences. So take in a comfortable, firm posture. Begin with a relaxation of the body, starting at the crown of the head, the scalp, feeling the wrinkles in your forehead, your brow beginning to smooth out, the pressure in and around your eyes diminishing, The muscles of the face softening, relaxing. Your is relaxed.
Bring your awareness to the back of your neck, perhaps gently turning your head to each side a few times. Gently loosening, stretching the muscles in the back of the neck. Relaxing the muscles of the throat. Bringing your awareness to your upper back and shoulders, perhaps rotating your shoulders a few times. Lifting them and allowing them to drop comfortably to the sides.
It’s as if some burden, some weight has just been lifted from your back, from your shoulders, moving down and through your body into the ground. And bring your awareness all the way down to your hands. Your hands are soft and loose. Relaxing your lower arms and your upper arms. Your chest is at ease.
The heart area, and the lungs, In the central region of your back. Stomach. Releasing the tension that we hold in our stomach muscles, allowing your belly to go soft. Relaxing throughout the abdominal cavity. Keep your back straight, your trunk erect, consciously relax, soften your lower back muscle.
Your buttocks. Through your upper legs. Your lower legs. And finally your feet. Bringing your awareness to your body in general.
Just roughly scanning your body, working through the body, noticing if there’s any tightnesses, any tensions which remain in the body, any areas of discomfort. And focusing upon those particular areas. And consciously relaxing, softening, feeling the tension diminish, the tightness loosen. If there’s discomfort, don’t avoid it or struggle against it. Just breathe in gently into that area surrounding it with a kind acceptance.
It’s already happening. It’s part of who you are at present. Be kind to yourself. It’s okay if it’s there. Your body becoming relaxed, at A feeling of physical well-being pervading every part of your body.
No place to go, nothing to do, nothing that needs to be thought about. Just give yourself a break. Just be. Just for a few moments, just be your body. Just be aware of your body.
Stay with your body. Practice the breath exercise, just breathing in comfortably, normally. Breathing out, extending the exhalation, completely emptying the lungs. Breathing in comfortably, normally. Out, extending the exhalation.
And then bring your mind to the breath. The easy, gentle, in and out flow of the natural breath, wherever sensation associated with the breath is most clear and obvious. If it’s helpful, can use the techniques of counting and labeling. Bring your mind back to the breath. Bring your mind back.
Now we’re going to practice the meditation and exchange. And we’re going to begin with someone that we like, that we love, someone we’re close to. Imagine that person there in front, but it’s not so important if you can’t see them, the visualization. The feelings are most important. And we want to exchange with them.
We’re going to put ourselves in their place and look at the world out of their eyes, feel their feelings. How would it be to be them? As best you can, enter into the subjective experience of this loved one. How is it for them? And looking back at your former self, out of their eyes to the person that you were?
What do you see when you look back at your former self? How do you feel? Do you you feel respected? Do you feel understood? Do you you’re loved, valued, cared for, used, express what it is that you see, that you feel to your former self.
We’re going to work with the second person. Imagine this person as a derelict, as a beggar, someone who’s homeless on the streets. Perhaps they haven’t washed in a few weeks, their clothes are dirty. As best you can understand it, as best you can feel it enter into their subjective experience, how would it be to be them? And then approaching your former Self, holding out your hand for asking for a bit of spare change.
Looking in your former self’s eyes, what do you see? Do you see fear, hostility, compassion, indifference? When you hold out your hand to your former self, looking into your former self’s eyes, what do you experience? What do you see? And then finally, a third person, somebody you’re having some difficulties with, problems.
And as best you can, enter into their viewpoint, how they’re experiencing the situation. Try to look at it from their side as best you can. And when you look back at your former self, what is it that you see, you feel? Do you sense some kind of open mindedness or closed mindedness, hostility, defensiveness? And express what it is that you see, that you feel.
And then bring your mind back to the breath. And get in touch with your body. Perhaps the the pressure of your buttocks on the cushion, on the chair, just some feeling sensation within the body. In an easy and relaxed manner, just slowly become aware of your surroundings, taking your time. If you’d like to stand up and stretch, you’re welcome.
So we’re going to carry on from where we are just beginning our discussion of the third principal aspect of the path, the awakened mind, looking at Tsongkhapa’s Three Principal Aspects of the Path, the verse, where he says, But even if you were to instill within you the will to awaken in the awakened heart. So even if you were to genuinely wish to bring an end to your own suffering, and even if you wish to help others to do the same, he goes on to say, Without the wisdom realizing reality, the awakened heart, without the wisdom realizing emptiness, ultimate truth, the deeper nature of the way things exist without that wisdom, understanding the nature of the Self and the things about us, the world about us, he goes on to say, Still have not cut the root of conditioned existence. Present approach to the living of your life, which is rooted in ignorance and bound up with suffering, will never come to an end. You know, there’s only one doorway to peace, and that is the wisdom, understanding, emptiness. So no matter how determined we are to grow, no matter how determined we may be to end our suffering, no matter how determined we might be to help others do the same.
We simply don’t have the skills, the necessary wisdom and understanding to bring that off, to bring it about. We’re not fully awakened. We haven’t achieved the ability to help others in the fullest sense of the word. Tsongkhapa goes on to say, Thus work with the means of realizing dependent arising. So this word, dependent arising, is a big word, isn’t it?
We’ll discuss it, what it means to rise in dependence. Just for now, dependent arising is the other side of the coin of emptiness. We have to discuss what emptiness is, don’t we? Things are empty because they’re dependent arising, and they’re dependent arising because they’re empty. We need to work back and forth, initially dependent in that way.
Tsongkhapa is emphasizing that we have to develop this wisdom realizing emptiness, the ultimate nature of reality, because it is only this which can totally remove ignorance. And it is this ignorance which is the basis for all of our dysfunctional patterns, all our frustrations, disappointments, all our struggles, everything that is undesirable within our experience in our life that binds us to suffering, that obstructs us from realizing ultimately the Buddha, the awakened state, and thereby being of greatest possible benefit to others. So if you really want to help yourself and to help others, we have to begin the journey no matter how faltering and tentative our first steps might be on this path of understanding emptiness. So, you know, the basis of all our problems is ignorance. We’re talking about a particular type of ignorance, what Buddhism means by ignorance.
Most generally, ignorance is kind of a stubborn, closed mindedness about learning anything which we feel might threaten our self identity, who we conceive ourselves to be, the nature of ourselves, the nature of the things about us. Anything that would upset our sense of security that we derive from our particular model of reality. No matter how many times that model of reality, no matter how many times our sense of who we are is invalidated by our experience, invalidated by our rational reasoning, we still hang to it. So it’s a kind of a stubborn, closed mindedness about learning, essentially. So ignorance is an absence of precision, a lack of clarity out of which is created all of the various mistaken models about the nature of the Self and the nature of phenomena in this world about us.
So it’s like a cloudiness. So this is what ignorance means in a very general sense. We’re going to hone in and become a little more particular. But just for now, it has a sense of a cloudiness, a sense of veiling, obscuring quality. It prevents us from seeing the true nature of things.
It also prevents us from seeing the absurdities of many of our fundamental beliefs which we’re basing our life on, our mistaken beliefs, you know, our mistaken assumptions that were some of our wrong ideas, that we’re basing the way that we conduct our life apart. So it functions to hinder basic sanity from learning about ourselves and about our condition. You know, here, when we talk about learning, we just don’t mean, you know, gathering more information. We’re not just talking about accumulation of knowledge. You know, like, the spiritual journey is just a matter of becoming like an encyclopedia or something like that, earning twenty PhDs, and having all these certificates on your wall, therefore you’re highly realized.
There’s no correspondence. It means that we’re trying to see things the way they actually are. The extent Learning means that we’re able to begin to eliminate many of the mistaken models of deception upon which we’re basing our life. And that we begin to replace these assumptions, these ideals, these models with more accurate ones, more models which are more in keeping with the way things are. Until ultimately, what we’re aiming to do is to see things directly, devoid of all models, all representations, to know things as they actually are, without any interpretations.
This is what essentially Buddhism means when they talk about realization. Realization is the elimination of superimposition, the projections we are placing upon all things, the world about us and ourselves, in terms of either exaggerating its qualities or depreciating its qualities. In one way or another, we’re not seeing things accurately the way they actually are. So realization means to remove the overlay that we’re projecting on the way things are. The world is as it is.
Is like use this analogy of wearing sunglasses and looking at a snow mountain, therefore you see the snow mountain as green. So there’s a projection, there’s an overlay, which distorts what it is that we come to know. So, you know, we see and then the realization is as if comfortable. Where were we? Sorry.
We’re talking about snow mountains. There I was skiing down the snow. Pardon? Snoring mountains. Snoring mountains.
That’s good. Realization. So realization is like when you take off the sunglasses and you remove the overlay, that veil, that obscuration, that distorting factor, and you see things as they actually are. It’s not a building up of knowledge, more and more information. It’s just seeing what’s already there.
It’s removing what prevents us from seeing what’s there. So, you know, if we see the snow mountain is white, that’s its nature, That’s what it actually, in fact, is. You know, if we had but we have to understand it. If we had some emotional investment in green snow, then there would be a natural resistance to even the question about whether that snow actually existed the way it appears. We wouldn’t even call it into question.
We derive some kind of security. Is there some kind of payoff from the snow being green? But once we begin to see that it’s not working in our life, you know, this is an absurd example perhaps, seeing green snow, but that the conception of a conception of a green snow mountain was continually being invalidated by our reasoning, by our experience, and moreover, it was bringing about outcomes which we don’t want. You know, this inconsistency in the way that we’re relating with the object, his experiences, some degree of dissatisfaction, disappointment, or frustration in some way, then we will be moved to question, perhaps that snow mountain is not really green after all. It looks green to me, but maybe it’s really not.
Gosh. It’s weird. So the so the process is just that. It’s a process. It’s a a kind of unfolding, a restructuring, letting go of what we come to see as mistaken and replacing it with what we presently deem reality to be.
And that’s going to evolve, our notion of reality. But it begins to approximate the way things actually are closer and closer and closer. So, you know, this involves this three, what we described this process before, this threefold process of listening, reflecting, and meditating. You’re listening to the instructions, coming to understand the meaning of emptiness and selflessness, the terms, what do those terms mean, and get the overall sense of the what’s being gotten at, the significance of what’s being gotten at here, and then reflecting on it. You know?
Mhmm. Examine it, investigating with your reasoning, with your logic, your understanding, using your experience, testing, seeing whether it’s valid or not. And then finally, when you at some point, you know, having clarified, you know, creating doubts. You know, doubt is tremendously important, healthy doubts. You know, wow, I don’t know if that’s I don’t know if that snow mountain’s really green or not.
It looks green, but I’m maybe there’s something wrong with the way I’m seeing it. You’re not sure anymore. Even that doubt with regard to the nature of reality is said to shake the very foundations of cyclic existence, these dysfunctional patterns within our mind. And They begin they we they’re begins to they don’t quite flow as readily as they once did, you know, because they’re based upon misconceptions, misunderstandings, misunderstandings, and we’re beginning those are beginning to be called into question. They’re not quite as solid or concrete as they once were.
And then finally, all doubts and hesitations finally having disappeared, then we we experience directly the truth, way things actually are. And it’s raining, reality, but it’s like water off a duck’s back. It keeps running off. And we keep missing the lessons life has continually bringing us. So We accustom ourselves to this new understanding, this new found experience again and again and again.
And it becomes our second nature. There is an evolution in our mind. There is transformation. Finally, we begin to awaken. Here, when we talk about an awakened mind, this third principal aspect of the path, awakening our minds to reality, we mean seeing deeply into the nature of reality, the way things actually are, divorced of our beliefs about them, our superimpositions, our wrong notions, our preconceptions, ignorance as projection, if you like.
An undistorted, unhindered, direct understanding, we understand things in and of themselves beyond this overfiction that we’re continually projecting upon the world about us. When we see deeply, we see deeply into the nature of reality, the way things are. Deeply refers to an ultimate way things are, their final reality, their most basic nature, that we come to see upon ultimate analysis when we investigate the nature of the object. What is it we finally come to? Beyond the mere appearances, like seeing beyond the shadows cast on the wall and seeing the objects which are actually casting the shadow.
So in Buddhism, this comes down to emptiness. Buddhism, emptiness is the ultimate nature of reality. It is the endpoint of our analysis. In other words, it’s the most basic element within our experience of the way things exist. You know, it’s like, you know, you know, okay, we’re, you know, trying to for example, for example of a clay pot.
We’re we’re just trying get across the notion of what we mean by final nature of reality, what it is that we’re in with, how we’re looking. If you take a clay pot, for example, a potter might say that in absolute terms, is made up of clay. That’s what the potter is interested in. That’s what a potter is concerned with. That’s what he observes and sees.
A scientist might say it is a collection of atoms. If the scientist were to be more precise, then he would say that the atoms are again made up of subatomic particles. And if they were to go on even further that, then in absolute terms, these atoms can no longer be defined precisely these days. We have to talk about probabilities, waves. So it becomes very difficult to actually pinpoint what it is that we come to, what the scientists would come to upon a deepest analysis of the nature of that clay pot, for example.
In the same way, ultimate truth presents itself at various levels in the course of our practice. Over the time of an individual practitioner, it emerges at different levels. It occurs And this is mirrored in the historic development of the teachings of Buddhism, and within the Buddhist scriptures. The description, the way that this coming to understand the deeper nature of reality has evolved with the teachings based upon the teachings of the Buddha. And this mirrors the understanding that an individual goes through in coming to a deeper and deeper understanding.
Ultimately, we’re trying to understand emptiness. As it is set out, we’re going to talk about and we’re going to work through different levels. It’s a process, it’s like an unfolding. Like we Buddha taught for, what, forty five years. He was a real teacher.
That is to say, one of the axioms of teaching, which obviously I can’t do, but a good teacher does, is to teach the student, not the subject. That is to say, according to the dispositions, capacities, the interests of the student, you teach according to that. One teaching does not work for everybody. You have a variety of capacities, a variety of dispositions. The Buddha would always tailor his teachings according to the needs of all of the individuals that were gathered together.
What would be of use for that particular individual on their particular path at this particular time? So out of this, over forty five years, there was a great variety of teachings that the Buddha gave, even on the same subject, even with regard to the nature of reality. Different levels of understanding, different levels of presentation, different ways of coming at it. It became rungs of a ladder, you know. In order to get to the top of the ladder, you have to step on the bottom rung, then you step on the next rung.
So these eventually systematized by Buddhist commentators, and they went into four stages. So, in coming to realization of reality, there are four readily recognizable stages that we’re going to work through. I hope you don’t find this overly detailed as we go through this. But I think you’ll come away with some sense of what we’re talking about. You may not come away with a realization, but you’ll have a sense of, Well, I know what Buddhism means when they talk about emptiness, the nature of reality, and so forth.
And I think that’s very valuable as a context to carry on your practice. We’re going to work through four stages: the hearer stage, the mind only stage. I’ll go through these as we go along. You’ll get sick and tired of hearing me about doing this. The hearer stage, the mind only stage, the autonomy middle way stage.
The autonomy, middle way stage maybe I’ll use the Sanskrit, it’s easier and the consequence, middle way stage. So we’re going to work so in approaching reality there is a progressive deepening, a penetrating into the final thought of the Buddha, beginning with the Hearer stage, and then what’s called the Mind Only stage, which in Sanskrit is Cittamātra. And the autonomy middle middle way stage, which in Sanskrit is Svatāntrika. And then finally, the final thought of the Buddha. What was his final thought?
If he had his best student right there in front of him, and this student was just ready for the deepest teaching, what would he say about the nature of reality? That would be the Prāsaṇgika, the Consequentialist Middle Way stage, the Prāsaṇgika. So although each of these stages are named after Buddhist schools that formulate them, they represent stages development of a single individual. It’s a progressive unfolding. So, you know, the awakened mind is the awakening of the mind to ultimate reality, the ultimate way things exist.
We’re not talking when we talk about ultimate truth, when we talk about emptiness, we talk about selflessness, we’re talking about its analysis of the way things exist. Not whether this glass exists or not. That I can understand with my eye consciousness. I can see glass, I can validate, I can understand the existence of the glass with my eye consciousness. I don’t need this whole, you know, philosophic explanation and this reasoning process and methods of investigation to understand that.
But I want to understand the way it exists. The reason I want to understand it is because I am making some mistakes with regard to the way objects exist, with respect to all phenomena myself, my I, the person, but also with respect to all other objects. This is ignorance. It is a misconception with regard to the way things exist. It is projecting a fantasized way of existing, a hallucinated way of existing.
Out of that arise as a consequence, all of the various dysfunctional patterns of mind. The basis of our way of relating with ourselves and the world about us is mistaken. Based upon that mistake, then the rest of the process begins to unfold. We develop hostility, attachment, and all the various dysfunctional patterns in the mind, which result in all the various types of experiences of suffering that we’re continually going through. It all comes down to that single linchpin of ignorance, this basic misconception, wrong belief in the nature and the way things exist.
And this is what we’re going to try to get at, what we’re going to to come to. We want to understand what is that we come to, what do we understand upon ultimate analysis of the way things exist? So, of analysis, if you were to analyze that object as deeply as possible, what would you come to? For example, depending upon our purpose, we could analyze this table in lots of different ways, depending on what we’re looking for, how we’re looking for it, what level we’re looking for it, what are we going to make use of that information. We’re going to make our analysis, our examination will go in various different directions.
Looking at the table, a relative superficial examination of the table would describe the table in terms of, oh, it’s a it’s, you know, what is that? Meter? It’s we would describe it in terms of its size, its color, its shape, you know, it’s rectangular. Rectangular. So that would be a way of analyzing the table, wouldn’t it?
A way of examining the table, investigating the table. That yields some valuable information, you know. I need table to put my books on, so it has to be a certain height. Like aesthetically it’s a nice looking table, solid, strong. So what we’re looking for, we’re going to find.
What level of examination? A carpenter might look at a table, Oh, it’s really constructed well, know. It’s dovetailed, you know, good glue, the nails are hidden, the finish is nice. So a carpenter is going to look at it from another point of view. An antique collector will look at its age, its condition, its rarity.
He’s looking at it from another point of view, examining it in terms of that. A particle physicist will look at it in terms of a comparatively deeper level, look at it in terms of its molecular composition. A botanist, we look at it in terms of the species of wood it’s made from, hardwood or whatever it might be. To a large extent, we find what it is that we’re looking for. What we find is determined by how we look, what use we’re going to make use of that information, and what level of organization we’re trying to understand the object.
In this context of the awakened mind, we’re trying to understand. We’re not looking at We’re also examining the table, just like the carpenter, just like the botanist, just like the physicists. But we’re trying to find, what we’re looking for, is way the table exists. What is the deepest mode of existence? There’s a word which is very useful.
It’s an unusual word, but it’s not mentioned often, but it’s primary in this area of Buddhism. It’s called ontology. Ontology is the branch of metaphysics dealing with the nature of being, the nature of existence. This is what this is all about. We want to understand what is the ontological status.
I’m not trying to snow you with words, but just introducing maybe some new vocabulary, but we’re going to refine this and work them out and try to bring it as best as I can down to some understandable form for all of us, because I don’t understand half of what I’m saying anyway. So I’m just as in the dark as you are, okay? Ontological status, the way the table is. How what supports its existence? How what is the nature of its being on the table, for example, or whatever the object might be?
If this analysis penetrates deeply enough, we will find the emptiness of the table. The table’s lack of inherent existence. And these words are difficult to understand. I’m going to explain why. We will find an absence of a particular fantasized way of existing.
There are many different terms that we use for fantasized way of It’s a way that the table exists which is completely fabricated, completely made up, hallucination. We use different terms for this fantasized way of existing in different contexts in order to gain a handle from the same point, from different avenues, different viewpoints. We use the word inherent existence, true existence, intrinsic existence, existence from its own side, objective existence, independent existence. I think there are about nineteen. Anyway, there is not some one term, but we just going to use a few.
Now we are going through this process of listening, aren’t we? We are trying to define our terms. What do we mean by emptiness? What do we mean by inherent existence? Trying to get some kind of coherent bringing this all together so we can understand the structure of the teaching.
There’s something that ignorance is projecting, that appears to be there, and we believe it ignorance believes to be there, which isn’t there within our experience. Just like the snow mountain wearing these green sunglasses. It appears that something’s there, but in fact it’s not there, and we relate to it in an inappropriate fashion. We use these terms, inherent What is there? We call inherent existence, or true existence.
What is appearing to ourselves? What appears is that the glass is inherently existent, truly existent, objectively existent, independently existent. These are of existing, but these concepts are not made up by philosophy. They’re not imposed by philosophic systems, but refer to the ordinary way that we relate, that we see objects all the time due to the force of ignorance. What we are trying to understand is the fact that nobody or nothing anywhere has anything that inherently makes it what it is.
This is we’re trying to understand the absence of something. The total absence, the total non being, the total non existence of anything that is not there through its own power. We said the other side of emptiness is dependent arising. Everything is dependent arising. This glass is a dependent arising, this table is a dependent arising, I am a dependent arising, the Self.
We arise in dependence, for example, on causes and conditions, on on parts, on language and thought. Everything depends upon language and thought. The object does not inherit in itself, independent of language, independent of our thinking about it as such. But it appears as if it did exist independent of all that. That’s what we’re superimposing, an independent existence.
It appears to inherently exist as if it is what it is by way of its own nature. It is self defining. We don’t define it. Beauty is in the nature of the object, not in the eyes of the beholder. It is if the very object is in the nature of beauty from its own side objectively, independent of culture, independent of value, independent of being seen like that.
That is its very nature. That’s the way it appears. And we believe that appearance. And therefore attachment arises. We want that because that desirability, that ability to bring pleasure, the beauty abides within the very nature of the object.
If I can only make that object mine, I can permanently experience that desirable quality of the object. That’s the logic behind it. But it doesn’t exist that way, does it? Beauty is in fact in the eyes of the beholder. Desirability is something that’s a social convention.
It depends on our thinking of it as being desirable, our conditioning. The advertising industry spends billions of dollars every year teaching us what is desirable in terms of fashion, and it keeps changing every year. You can’t wear what was desirable last year is not desirable this year. You’ve got to keep up with your fashions, don’t you? When you put on that latest fashion, you feel good about yourself, don’t you?
They say clothes make the man, don’t they? Something like that. It is as if that quality, whatever we associate with it, its desirability, its beauty, its status, all the things that we the stories that surround the fashion are in the very fabric, woven into the fabric itself. I just have to make that mine, and I can abide with it, I can imbibe that, I can partake that permanently. That’s simply a projection.
It appears that the quality is independent of the advertising industry, my thinking of it such, the conventions of my society, causes, conditions, parts, all of that. That is to say, that the desirability, that beauty is inherent in the object itself. It is intrinsic, it’s in the very nature of the object itself. With regard to the I, the Self, we have a sense that there is a solid, concrete core to our being which we identify as I, which doesn’t depend upon body, which doesn’t depend upon mind, which doesn’t depend upon name or language. So this is all working through the force of ignorance.
This is where we’re we’re going wrong. This is the basis of the evolution of our problems. Everyone and everything, all phenomena that exist, exist in dependence upon something other than what they are. Nothing is able to define what it is in and of itself. These are probably difficult concepts, aren’t they?
Emptiness, what do we mean by emptiness? And when I say emptiness, what arises in your mind? It’s just kind of empty. An emptiness is a lack, isn’t it? It’s a very emotive word trying to get at the sense of an absence, a nonexistence.
There’s something that we think is there, but it’s not there. Is a lack, it is an absence of a particular fantasized way that things exist. Trying to understand what that fantasized way of existing is the most difficult part of understanding emptiness. The rest is a piece of cake. It’s hard to identify what it is within our experience that is appearing to ourselves, but in fact isn’t there in reality.
There’s an element within all of our experience. I’m not just talking by experience, I don’t mean just visual experience. In all objects that we come to know, whether through all the various physical senses or what we think about, there is an element of error in that appearance in terms of the way the object exists. Now we’re not talking about whether this glass of water is this is a glass of water, whether it’s wet, you know, its color and shape and so forth. The element which we’re mistaken about is the way that glass is existing.
It exists as if it were cut off and at a distance, as if it didn’t depend upon my thinking of it as such, or a popular convention. We’re going to go into this. I’m really jumping way ahead. We as cognitive systems, systems, such as the human mind, are model builders. We’re trying to make sense of our world.
We develop representations of our world in order to think about it. We juxtapose these models, these symbols within our mind, making sense of our world, gaining the sense of we understand our world, therefore I can begin to have some predictability around this chaos. I can begin to gain some kind of control, at least in my own mind. The human mind is working with symbols, representation, models. For example, if I said to you, I don’t know, in the next room, there’s a book I left on the table.
Would you please bring it? Okay. And you go out of the room, a minute later you come back and you hand me this book. I said, Thank you. So, you know, I can assume that you understood what I said, that you brought the correct book, what I wanted.
That we were using we had commonalities in terms of the symbols and models. We’re using models of book, table, next room. And we have commonalities in terms of the same symbols and models that we’re using. We work those around and I communicate to you and some similar idea comes up in your mind because I can tell because you actually brought me my book. If you brought me a cow, would say, Oh, wait, no, wait, we aren’t communicating.
There is something going wrong with our symbols here. We are getting them jumbled up here. Or maybe you have a different concept of what a book is. You think it has big ears and has four legs or something. Your symbol for a book is different than my symbol.
So, that happens a lot, actually. Yeah, we won’t go into that. So, our models fit, and we can have predictability, we can gain control of the world, can do things, and we assume that we understand. But there’s a big difference. But what we do is, there’s mental models, these words, these symbols that we’re using, you know, these words, symbols like I’m talking about the symbol, the word.
Book, table, next room, room, okay? That we make use of. The name book, the symbol book is not a book. The name table, the symbol table, the mental representation, the idea table is not a table. So forth, room, you know, it also applies to room.
They representations of them. They are like maps which stand for the territory, but they themselves are not the territory. You know, we can’t drive our car on those little red lines. You know, we can’t go shopping and there’s little black dots. But so what we’re saying is the map is not the territory.
The the the thin red lines and and the and the little blue line the blue lines, they stand for real roads which we which we can find out there. They they are metaphors. They are symbols for something that’s findable in reality. That that, you know, within those little black dots we can would stand for, you know, Sterling. We can go shopping, we can go to a restaurant or something.
So our thoughts, our ideas, the symbols that we use, these mental representations that we play around with in our thoughts, they correspond to something out there. It gives us a sense of predictability, sense of control, so we can begin to make sense of our world. We find a sense of security because we sense we know our world. That’s the way we know our world. There’s no other way to know our world.
We know them through these ideas and thoughts and so forth. There is correspondence between the symbol, the idea, the model, and what we can actually find. You found my book, and you brought the right book. But there are maps and there are maps. For example, Tolkien, you know, he wrote Lord of the Rings.
Describes this fantastic world, you know, Middle Earth. It’s inhabited with all these hobbits and elves and all these strange creatures. And he even has a drawing of a map where all the villages are and the rivers and so forth. But though there is a map, there is nothing which corresponds to that map. No matter how long you study that map that Tolkien gives you in his Lord of the Rings, and how much you search, you’re never going to find Middle Earth.
I don’t think I’m going to find it. So there is a map, but there’s nothing which corresponds to it in the real world. It’s something that Tolkien just fantasized. He made it up. But there’s nothing findable in reality which accords with that.
There’s no actual findable reality. No matter how long we might search, we will never find that reality that Tolkien has fantasized. So, if I said, Would you bring me the book on the table outside that I bought today? But I had not really bought any book today. No matter how long you searched, no matter how hard and how much conscientiousness you went through, you can never find that book.
So I can use words, I can use symbols, I can use thoughts, and we can understand what each of them mean, but they don’t reflect anything which accords with the reality, which the way things actually are. Under the influence of ignorance we have fabricated models of an I, a self. We have fabricated notions about the way things exist, about the nature of these objects, and we take them as if that were in fact the way they exist. These these models of the way they exist are called that ignorance is making use of have the names like inherent existence, intrinsic existence. Through the influence of ignorance, we have fabricated models of the way things exist which do not correspond to reality.
Have mistaken beliefs, which conceives of a fantasized way of existing, we are continually superimposing upon ourselves and the world around us. It’s a process of beginning to It’s just like this green mountain, beginning to investigate whether that mountain is in fact green. Can sustain that belief in a green mountain in the face of contradictory logic and reasoning in your own experience. Even though it appears that way, you begin to think, you begin to introduce a notion of doubt, and it begins to undermine that ignorance. Letting go of our most deeply held beliefs is not an easy process.
It’s said that, you know, if somebody has little merit, that when they first realize and gain some kind of sense of emptiness or selflessness, they generate fear. You know, it’s like losing something that was so familiar to you, like an old friend, somebody that was always there for you. But for those who have great merit, it is said that having some suspicion about whether things exist the way they appear, about emptiness and so forth, is like some great burden has been lifted off your shoulders. And there’s a relief of having to carry around this burden of having to guard your territory, defend your space, this sense of All built upon this sense of a concrete reality which has never been there. Gaining insight and overcoming, there’s some kind of resistance to let go is a gradual process.
And this gradual process is said to be evolving in four stages. And we’re going to work through these four stages. You know, it’s like right now we’re like what we call naive realists. Believe like we’re standing on the bank of a river. It’s very solid and concrete.
We just accept everything the way it appears. We don’t question appearances. World is out there, real, solid, objectively existent, unquestionably so. And know, we begin we’re beginning a process of analysis and investigation whether, in fact, the world really exists. We can’t deny its appearance, but does it really exist that way?
So we’re beginning to step off the solid bank of our naive realism into the waters of emptiness. We are this secure bank of our fantasized world, and we begin to step into these unfamiliar waters. But there’s a sense of, you know, maybe we’re going to be swept away. You know, we’re going to lose ourselves in the solid world as we know it out there. So we’re in unfamiliar waters, as it were, so we hold on to a log to make sure we’re not to keep us anchored.
Step by step we venture out further and further into the river and continually holding onto this log. Finally, that is the last vestiges of our old beliefs to ensure that we stay afloat. We don’t want to sink. We want to lose ourselves. We don’t want to go out of existence.
There’s some kind of fear. But gradually we grow in confidence. And develop in our skill in dealing with a newly evolving reality until we reach a point when, with great fearlessness and great understanding, we let go of the log altogether. And we dwell in the way things actually are. And we realize that there was nothing all along to be afraid of.
That we never really needed the security of the bank, of the log. And our life becomes spontaneous joyful sport in the flowing waters of emptiness. We’re so afraid as it is now, and quite rightly so, because as we see the world and and all our belief systems are based upon a basic misconception as to the nature of the I, and we’re afraid of losing that I. But it can never go out of existence. We can never go out of existence.
We don’t have to hold on to ourselves so tightly. We don’t have to be so afraid. So from standing anxiously on the seemingly solid shores of our fantasized world to frolicking, you know, playing in the ocean of suchness involves a process, the gradual unfolding of a deeper and deeper insight through more and more profound training. So it’s like learning technical subject. It’s necessary as a gradual working through from the basic principles to the more subtle details.
As I mentioned, the Buddha always taught in accordance with the predispositions, the capacities, the interests of a student. And these teachings were systematized by later commentators who formulated them into what we call the four tenet systems, or the four schools of Buddhism. You know, there is the Great Exposition School, the Sūtra School, the Mind Only School, and the Middle Way School. These schools represent a gradual progression of subtlety in the presentation of the nature of reality, from the atomic theory of the Great Exposition School up to the non-inherent existence view of the Middle Way School. When we study these, these two lower schools, the Great Exposition School and the Sūtra School, because of the similarity of their views, when we’re looking in terms of the ultimate nature of reality, we’re going to combine them into one stage.
We’re going to call that the Hearer Stage. Then because of the distinction in the view of the Middle Way School, we are going to divide that into two. One is called, as we just mentioned, Autonomy Middle Way, and the other is called Are you catching all this? The Consequence of It Away. Midway between these two, subtlety, it’s the mind only school.
We’re going to work through this in four stages. I hope I haven’t turned you off or overly confused you in all of this. I’ve got a minute or two. Do you have any questions around this? I take responsibility for my message that I make.
I know I can pick up that the idea of trying to grasp this idea of emptiness is so we can attain Buddhahood, but in a in a simpler form, is it so we can relate to things in a more appropriate fashion? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, mean, through eliminating ignorance. All of our afflictive emotions arise in dependence. All karma and afflictive emotions arise in dependence basically on ignorance.
If you remove ignorance, you no longer generate afflictive emotions, hostility, attachment, pride, jealousy, and you no longer are motivated to create karma. So you’re liberated from the afflictive emotions of karma, you’re free. So you attain nirvana, peace. So all the various afflictive emotions attachment, hatred, all of them arise on the basis of this misconception which we call ignorance. We misunderstand the way things exist, the way I exist, the way objects exist.
Out of that arises attachment, aversion, and all the other afflictive emotions. Once you remove that linchpin, they all cease of themselves and you experience peace. So we don’t have to weed out each afflictive emotion one by one if we pull out the linchpin. Jampa, that table doesn’t exist. No, In all of this, we’re never questioning whether an object exists or not.
We’re talking about the way it exists. I can see the table. I have no reason to doubt. My eyesight’s okay. So the table exists.
I’m making a mistake with regard to the way the table exists. So it’s not a table. It’s a table. But it’s a table because we labelled it a table. Oh, that’s good.
When you talk about labelling, now you don’t talk about whether it’s a table or not, but the way it is a table. How did it come to be a table? Oh, one way it became a table is because we label it a table, we talk about it as a table. It’s dependent upon that. So we’re not talking about whether a table exists, but how it comes to exist.
So what part of the table is the table? What is tableness? What is tableness about that table? There’s nothing which makes it a table from its own side. It is simply a popular convention.
What is beauty? Know, I was talking about the fashion industry, we’re conditioned. You know, they spend millions and millions of dollars conditioning our mind to think, that’s beautiful. So it’s it’s merely a popular convention. It’s renowned as beautiful.
It’s renowned as a table. There’s nothing which makes it a table from its own side. There’s nothing which makes a thing beautiful from its own side. It’s that we’ve come to understand it. We’ve been conditioned to think of it as beautiful, and therefore I want it.
There’s nothing from its own side which makes it it. Nothing whatsoever. There’s nothing from its own side which makes this a table. There’s nothing from a beautiful dress which makes it a beautiful dress. We’ve come to think of it as a beautiful dress.
The language, the conditioning, the conceptuality of the thoughts. It depends upon that. It becomes a beautiful dress. It depends upon my thinking of it as a beautiful dress. It’s not a beautiful dress from its own side.
But what part of that table is table? When we talk about the way things exist, when we talk simply about existence, we don’t perform analysis. We accept appearances for what they are. We just accept there’s a table. We all agree that’s a table.
Now once we begin to question how it exists, then we have to analyze. Is this the table? Is the leg is this the table? Is that the table? Is this the table?
We don’t find the table. But that’s only when we’re looking for its deeper nature, not its superficial nature. Superficial, it’s a table. No question. Look, I put my books on it.
If it weren’t a table there, couldn’t put my books on it. But when we begin to question the way it exists, then we perform analysis. So it’s not a table. It is a table. It’s not ultimately a table.
Not conventionally a table. Ultimately, it’s not a table. There’s two levels of truth. Is another way of coming to understand emptiness coming to understand dependent arising? That’s the other sign.
That’s called the king of reasoning. This table is empty of inherent existence because it is a dependent arising. One of the reasons that we can use to understand emptiness is because it’s dependent arising. It’s empty of independent existence. Why?
Because it is dependent, the existent. But we have to understand in what way is it dependent. But you’re right. That’s right. So dependent arising is a very powerful reasoning that’s made use of in coming to understand emptiness.
This table is empty of independent existence. Why? Because it is a dependent existent. In what way is a dependent existent? It’s dependent upon its parts It’s dependent upon causes and conditions.
The carpenter, the wood that’s made from, the varnish, the nails, fabric being made. It’s also dependent upon language and conceptuality, thinking of it as a table. It’s dependent in those three ways. So we have to begin to fathom that. Ignorance is trying to hold it to exist independently.
We’re trying to develop a wisdom consciousness which sees it exists dependently because that’s in keeping with the way it actually is. So it’s like hot and cold water. The stronger this wisdom comes, the force of ignorance diminishes, diminishes, diminishes, then we can reach a point where that ignorance can no longer arise in our mind because the wisdom, understanding the actual nature of the object is so powerful. Once that happens, all the afflictions which depend upon ignorance, which are in dependence upon that misconception, they cease of themselves, just like that snake in the grass that we talked about. Get rid of that misconception, that all that fear, that aversion, which arose in dependence upon a misconception ceases of itself.
Once you see that the rope is intact, once you see that the snake, upon examination, there’s no snake there. You see it for its true nature, what it really is. Does that make sense? Anyway, answer this. It’s not all that hard.
I’m just making it hard. It’s not all that hard. I’m probably making it harder than it needs to be. Okay, then we will go through this slowly. We’ll work out all the terms.
As I mentioned last week, I don’t know if I mentioned that, please, by all means. As I said, this is not a matter of just gathering more information. Really have to think about this. And so I really invite you to question everything and anything I say, and I probably won’t be able to satisfy your questions. And I hope I don’t create too much confusion in going through this, but I really invite you to stop me and say, Wait a minute, I don’t understand that.
What do you mean by that? Really, we just investigate this as we go along. We’ll meditate together on this, a group meditation. We have to get the information together, but that in itself is not going to get where we want to go. We have to integrate it to begin to lessen our ignorance.
That’s the purpose. This is really an investigation. I invite you to question as we go along. Then it’ll be fun, otherwise it’s just philosophy, it’s abstract. Except for you.
I’m joking. There’s a table there. It’ll hit you. Then you’ll find out. So we can dedicate the merit that we created.
Actually, we canI haven’t done it. I should have. Anyway, we come to May the jewel of the awakened heart, we can substitute May the jewel of the awakened mind. Just in keeping with our present studies. May all beings everywhere plagued by sufferings of body and mind attain an ocean of happiness and joy by virtue of my merits.
May no living creatures suffer, commit evil, or fall ill. May no one be afraid or belittled with a mind weighed down by depression. May the blind see forms and the deaf hear sounds. May those whose bodies are worn with toil be restored and find in repose. May the naked find clothing, the hungry find food.
May the thirsty find water and delicious drink. May the poor find wealth, those weak with sorrow find joy. May the forlorn find hope, constant happiness and prosperity. May there be timely rains and bountiful harvests. May all medicines be effective and wholesome prayers bear fruit.
May all who are sick and ill quickly be freed from their ailments. Whatever diseases there are in the world, may they never occur again. May the frightened cease to be afraid, and those bound be freed. May the powerless find power, and may people who think of benefiting each other. For as long as space remains, for as long as sentient beings remain, until then may I too remain to dispel the miseries of the world.
Through these skillful actions may I quickly become an awakened spiritual master and lead each and every living being to the awakened realm. May the supreme jewel of the awakened mind that has not arisen arise and grow, and may that which has arisen never diminish, but increase more and more. In the land circled by snow mountains, you are the source of all happiness and well-being, powerful Tenzin Gyatso. . Thank you.
If you’d like to stay and get a cup of tea, we’ll have a discussion. Otherwise, good night. Thank you. Sleep well.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
- The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
- Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
- The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Is the purpose of understanding emptiness only to attain Buddhahood, or also, in simpler terms, to relate to things more appropriately?
Understanding emptiness works by eliminating ignorance. All karma and afflictive emotions arise in dependence on ignorance, the misconception about how things exist, including how the self and objects exist. From this arise attachment, aversion, hostility, pride, jealousy and the rest. If ignorance is removed, these emotions are no longer generated and there is no more motivation to create karma. One is then liberated from afflictive emotions and karma, and attains nirvana, peace. Ignorance is like a linchpin: once it is pulled out, all the afflictive emotions cease of themselves, so each one does not need to be weeded out one by one.
If a table is a table because we label it a table, what does that say about how things exist?
When talking about labelling, the question is not whether a table exists but how it comes to exist. One way it becomes a table is that we label it and talk about it as a table; it depends on that. There is no part of the table that is tableness, and nothing makes it a table from its own side. It is simply a popular convention. Beauty works the same way. The fashion industry spends millions of dollars conditioning the mind to think something is beautiful, so it is merely renowned as beautiful. A dress is not beautiful from its own side. It becomes beautiful in dependence on language, conditioning and the thought that thinks of it as beautiful.
Is understanding dependent arising another way of coming to understand emptiness?
Yes. Dependent arising is called the king of reasoning: a table is empty of independent existence because it is a dependent existent. We need to understand in what way it is dependent. It depends on its parts, on causes and conditions (the carpenter, wood, varnish, nails), and on language and conceptuality, thinking of it as a table. Ignorance holds it to exist independently, while wisdom sees that it exists dependently, in keeping with how it actually is. As this wisdom grows, ignorance diminishes until it can no longer arise. The afflictions that depend on that misconception then cease of themselves, like seeing there is no snake in the rope.