2 h 38 min · 13,378 words · 2 March 2009 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 160-minute session, Ven Jampa Gendun opens with a Michael Leunig verse on love and fear before leading a structured guided meditation that teaches the “naming” technique — labeling breath, sound, and thoughts to gain perspective on mental chatter and recurring painful stories. The main teaching works through the first two of nine essentials for analyzing emptiness: ascertaining the object of negation (how a car, a letter, or a five-dollar note appears to exist from its own side) and ascertaining the pervasion. A lively in-class exercise, passing around a pen while students debate which part actually constitutes “the pen,” makes the analysis vivid and grounded. Gendun closes by drawing out the two truths: understanding that a bully has no intrinsic bully-nature does not mean you leave the room any less quickly — it means you act without being overwhelmed by appearances. Suited to practitioners already following this ongoing series.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 36 3PA 2009 03 02.mp3
UUID: de75b98c-cb91-41a2-bb89-5d132e3b75dd
Teacher: Ven Jampa Gendun
Collection: Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Date: 2009-03-02
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 158.7 minutes
Words: ~13,376
How are you? Good. Good. Oh, good. Everybody enjoying the rain?
Doctor. Absolutely. I’m looking at the garden and thinking how much the garden is welcoming it. Doctor. Is there any estimate on how much we’re supposed to get?
Doctor. It varies throughout the state, but I heard as I came out maybe six millimeters. It’s just tiny. Really? Heavy millimeter helps.
There’s a a quote by, Michael Leunig. Everybody comfortable? That’s okay. It’s very refreshing. Is that?
Yes. It’s nice to see women make themselves comfortable and enjoy themselves. I I agree. They’re just much friends here. God help us to change.
God help us to change ourselves and change the world, to know the need for it, to deal with the pain of it, to feel the joy of it, to undertake the journey without understanding the destination, the art of gentle revolution. Amen. Know, sometimes, you know, we we like to know where we’re going. It gives us some feeling of security. But change always involves some kind of risk.
It always has and probably always will, the unknown, the unfamiliar. It’s like uncharted territory, places we’ve never been before that we’re not quite accustomed to. We have to have some kind of faith, don’t we? Generally we talk about faith in the dharma. Sometimes we can talk about faith in emergence.
That something good will come out of. Know, that we don’t quite know all the you know, demanding that we know all of the details of the outcome of change is simply one way of ensuring and be assured that nothing will ever change. You want kind of an insurance policy. There’s always kind of some kind of fear involved. And I guess I’m fond of the expression.
Again from Michael Leunig there are two basic emotions, love and fear. Either consciously or unconsciously we’re probably choosing one or the other. Of the significant, probably insignificant choices that we make every day of our lives in the various ways that we do. And whether to choose more of the same, to secure ourselves in the patterns of the past, to extend the past into the future, or whether to extend ourselves to unfamiliar areas, unfamiliar situations and new relationships and new ways of feeling, new possibilities. It means that we have to bear with a certain anxiety, I think, that we can have some kind of faith that out of this is something new or something positive, something that we unexpected.
Positive, something that we unexpected. I guess there’s some kind of basic faith in the goodness of life and the goodness of our basic selves. I don’t know what do people think what do people think about that? I’m always sitting up here talking in these ways. I don’t know.
Does do people have any feelings around that? Any thoughts around that? In some way or another. Yeah. Whether to have coffee or tea or something.
That’s a helpful one for you have a lot of trouble with as well. Just to sort of bring it back to that. Oh, yeah. Probably break it down enough. It’s probably just fear on their part.
It’s something you find it a bit easier to be passionate if you just you know, rather than seeing them as somehow inherently evil or something like that. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Just afraid in some way. So the inner focus of our life becomes Buddha and to live out as Buddha as fearlessly as possible in our everyday situations that as they arise, living out and expressing as best we can and as well as we can, there’s wisdom, love and compassion, inner strength, and living these out as skillfully and fearlessly as we can. So we have some means of working with our minds, minds, which we call the Dharma. I think essentially the various teachings, but also simply the truth of things. And I guess being fearless in trying to find out what is the truth and living out that truth and having the support of those about us or Sangha, our spiritual community, even if it’s only one other.
Someone who inspires you or you can seek some kind of advice from or share your feelings with. The possibilities beyond the superficial ways that we normally relate with one another. Sharing that the hidden side of ourselves, probably the finest part of it, you know, the gold within the shadow. So, you know, maybe making that kind of an orientation in our life, making that important in our life, some kind of priority in our life. And then, you know, trying to in what we do, I guess creating some balance in our lives in terms of where our what a successful life is going to look like for ourselves.
We all have our it might not be very clear to ourselves, but we have some notion about what a good life might be like and seeing if we can include within that vision of it, at least in part, it’s including others in our definition of what a successful life might look like in terms of how we can be there for others in whatever way. You know, even if it’s only in a smile, whatever limited way we can at present. But, you know, maybe always aspiring to be able to do a little bit more than what we’ve been able to do in the past. I guess central most is just the sense and just keeping our minds open to the need to develop our inner qualities and how these express in relating with the world and people about us. Aside from all our other priorities in life, developing material prop priorities and a nice home and a car and all the good things of life.
That the intangible inner qualities are just equally as important, if not more important. I guess kind of keeping that mindfulness is like going for refuge, isn’t it? So we can we can form this if you like. If you’d to read along, you’re welcome. You’re welcome to sit and join us if you like.
I go for refuge until I’m awakened to the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I’m awakened to the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha.
Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings may all sentient beings of happiness and the causes of happiness may all sentient beings be free from suffering and the causes of suffering may all sentient beings be inseparable from the joy that is without sorrow. May all sentient beings abide in equanimity free from attachment for some and aversion toward others. Thus did I hear at one time that Bhagavan was dwelling on Vulture Peak Mountain in Rajgriha together with a great community of monks and a great community of bodhisattvas. At that time the Bhagavan was absorbed in the concentration on the categories of phenomena called profound perception. Also at that time the bodhisattva Mahāsattva Avalokiteśvara looked upon the very practice of the profound perfection of wisdom and beheld those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature.
Then to the power of the Buddha the Venerable Śāriputra said this to the bodhisattva Mahāsattva Avalokiteśvara how should any son of the lineage train and wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom he said that in the bodhisattva Mahāsattva Avalokiteśvara said this to the venerable Śāriputra any son of the lineage or daughter of the lineage who wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom should look upon it like this correctly and repeatedly beholding those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature. Form is empty, emptiness is form, emptiness is not other than form, form is also not other than emptiness. In the same way feeling discrimination compositional factors and consciousness are empty. Śāriputra, likewise all phenomena are emptiness without characteristics unproduced unceased stainless not without stain deficient, not fulfilled. Śāriputra, therefore, in emptiness, there is no form, no feeling, no discrimination, no compositional factors, and no consciousness.
No eye, no ear, no nose, no tongue, no body, no mind, no visual form, no sound, no odor, no taste, no object of touch, and no phenomenon. There is no eye element and so on up to and including no mind element and no mental consciousness element. There is no ignorance, no extinction of ignorance and so on up to and including no aging and death and no extinction of aging and death. Similarly there is no suffering, origination, cessation, path. There is no exalted wisdom, no attainment, and also no non attainment.
Śāriputra, therefore, because there is no attainment, bodhisattvas rely on and dwell on the perfection of wisdom, the mind without obscuration and without fear. Having completely passed beyond error, they reach the endpoint of nirvana. All the Buddhas who dwell in the three times also manifest the completely awakened to unsurpassable perfect complete enlightenment relying on the perfection of wisdom. Therefore, the mantra of the perfection of wisdom, the mantra of great knowledge, the unsurpassed mantra, the mantra equal to the unequal, the mantra that thoroughly pacifies all suffering should be known as the truth since it is not false. The mantra of the perfection of wisdom is declared, Tadyatha Om Gate Gate Pāragate Pārasamgate Bodhi Svāhā.
Śāriputra, the bodhisattva Mahāsattva should train in the profound perfection of wisdom like that. And the Bhagavan arose from that concentration and commended the bodhisattva Mahāsattva Ārya Avalokiteśvara, saying, well said, well said, son of the lineage. That. It is like that. One should practice the profound perfection of wisdom just as you have indicated.
Even the Tathagatas rejoice. The Bhagavan having thus spoken, the venerable Śāriputra, the bodhisattva Mahāsattva Ārya Avalokiteśvara, those surrounding their entirety along with the world of gods, humans, the asuras, and the gandharvas, well rejoiced and highly praised as spoken by the Bhagavan. So we’re going to sit and meditate. Can I just quickly say, BPF one two three, there are lights on on the car? Stat.
BPF one two three. Is that anyone’s car here? Car is it? Don’t even know my last name. I don’t know.
What color was it? Gray. Is that you? No. I think it’s Thank you.
That’s okay. No worries. Yeah. Thanks. So one of our foundation teachings is mindfulness and mindfulness is simply most, you know, it asks the question of what am I experiencing now in the present moment?
It’s always coming back to that and then help us in developing that ability to clarify for ourselves just what we are experiencing in the present moment. We, you know, we can use the technique of what we call naming. And we name our present experience simply a way of clarifying for ourselves, making it clear to ourselves what it is that I’m actually experiencing. And so So Volkswagen, that’s another of you guys? It might be someone in the office today in the meeting.
Yeah. So and when we’re when we’re using it in conjunction with the breath, we can simply name our present experience, breathing in, knowing that we’re breathing in, simply naming that experience in, breathing out, knowing that I’m experiencing the out breath, the sensation associated with the out breath, naming that out. But as we normally as often times is the case, our minds wander, distracted. That’s what minds do. And, you know, the moment we become aware of the distraction, we can simply name that distraction, you know, whether it’s external, like someone in the parking lot laughing, internal, maybe it’s a physical sensation, maybe it’s internal to the mental consciousness, maybe it’s thinking, whatever.
We can simply name it, hearing, feeling, thinking and so forth. And I thought we can practice an exercise using these various objects of mindfulness, but it’s useful if you practice using the technique of naming. So we’re going to work with as we normally do, working with the breath. You use you can, if you would, make use of that practice of naming your experience. And we’re going to work with sound.
You know, it can be, for example, people in the parking lot or something in the environment and so forth. Just naming hearing. But if your mind is distracted from that hearing, you know, naming that experience, thinking and so forth. And then we’re going to work with the mind itself. And this is when the naming becomes important or useful, I should say.
Normally we identify, we get caught up with our thinking, with stories that we tell ourselves about ourselves. And one way that we can helps us to keep some kind of perspective on this internal dialogue, this thinking chatter that’s almost always going on one way is simply to name it as for what it is. And then we’re not concerned with the content, but the process and the process is thinking, for example. So simply naming that experience thinking, you know, and without this will help you not identify with the the internal process that, you know, the internal dialogue, what’s actually content of the of what you’re thinking. You are just thinking.
It’s only a thought. Whether it’s a good thought or a bad thought, it’s only a thought. And this can become very useful, a way of stepping out of a lot of unproductive stories and feelings and emotions. Being able to simply to name them without having to identify, without getting caught up and losing ourselves. I think it’s a useful life skill.
For example, you have these repeating loops of self talk that are continuing I think fascinating sometimes how we’re actually willing to repeat stories in our head, which are painful. But nonetheless, we keep telling ourselves these painful stories again and again and again. And we are terribly attached to them. And we know how they are going to end each time, but we keep going through them again and again, replaying them, sometimes from our childhood even, that we would cause ourselves pain. I find it fascinating.
But anyway, it seems to be the case. We have various ways of relating to ourselves, stories that we build up around ourselves, you know. And developing this skill about, you know, we we oftentimes take our thoughts as being reality, as if what we’re thinking is actually happening. And we we actually reliving as it were these experiences. In fact, what it is, we’re only thinking.
It’s nothing more than a thought. But we take it to be reality. We take it to be truth. We take we take our thoughts seriously as we take our thoughts, know, sometimes they’re even threats. We take our thoughts to be wise.
But they’re nothing but thoughts, you know, just like waves rising on the ocean of the mind. And then if we if we if we neither indulge in them nor repress them, they will cease of themselves. So being able to relate with this these this content of the mind, these thoughts stories and so forth in a little more skillful way, it can be quite useful. It can. It can.
Interrupt the process of how we normally become lost in our thoughts and in these stories and so forth. You know, was thinking one one you know, we can’t we can’t we can’t avoid them in the sense that we can’t suppress them. You know, if what you resist persists, it will return all the more that’s that’s stronger subsequently when you let down your guard, when you when you are no longer trying to avoid the thought, the thought will return all the much more intensely, the pattern of thinking of the story and so forth. But, you know, the the one thought, you know, if you the way that we can get a get a sense of this is how we take our thoughts to be reality. You know, you have a thought, you take a thought, I’m no good.
You know, I have a rather negative self image that maybe comes up from time to time, you know, I can’t do this. And we take, you know, or I’m a failure. It’s a foregone conclusion that you’re going to fail in whatever it is. Have that part our self identity. We take that to be a reality.
But in fact, if you simply were to put the words I’m having the thought I’m a failure, you you have the thought I am a failure. If you simply put the words I’m having the thought I’m a failure, then it automatically creates some distance between you and that thought. You get some perspective. It’s only a thought. You can create even more perspective on that.
You can I notice I’m having the thought I’m a failure? I notice I’m having the thought I can’t do this. I notice that I’m having the thought I’m I’m overwhelmed. We never we, you know, we take our thoughts very personally, as if there’s some kind of reality about us. But they’re only just thoughts.
And we can create some kind of space, some some some perspective, some some distance from our thought. And we don’t have to react to the thought and not reacting to the thought, neither indulging or repressing. This thought will cease of itself. The story will dissolve itself. We don’t just like the wave returning to the ocean.
We don’t have to do anything about it. So I think it’s a it’s a very useful life skill. So what I’d like to do is, is, you know, we’re going to practice mindfulness of the breath and then we’ll we’ll shift the focus of our attention to the sounds about us. Then we’ll shift the focus again to the thoughts within our mind. And it’s quite useful if you use this technique of naming.
You know, it’s not a mantra. It can’t be done mindlessly. But if you’re thinking, and we’re watching the mind, you know, it’s pictures, you know, and the kind of words in our head. We call thoughts. Thinking.
So just simply thought. It’s simply thinking. And that this will give you some perspective, some space between you and the content of that thought. And then I like to just open it up to what we call conscious, choiceless awareness. And this is when it’s useful to use the technique of naming.
It’s not necessary to direct the mind to any particular object. Just allow the mind to become involved in any object that it naturally tends toward. But as opposed to the way that we normally relate, you know, getting caught up in the objects of our awareness, simply note what it is, or name the object, thinking or hearing or feeling or smelling or touching. Simply see if you can maintain awareness using the the technique of naming. But there’s we’re not going to choose the object, whatever is predominant in our environment, whatever our mind naturally tends to become involved in.
But maintain the perspective by naming that experience from moment by to moment to by moment. Okay? So take a comfortable firm posture. And we’ll begin by relaxing the body, bringing your awareness to the crown of your head, the scalp, Feeling the wrinkles in your brow beginning to smooth out. The pressure in and around your eyes diminishing.
The muscles of the face softening, relaxing. Your jaws relaxed. And bring your awareness to the back of your neck and perhaps gently turn your head to each side a few times, very gently stretching, loosening the muscles of the back of the neck. Relaxing the muscles of the throat. Bringing awareness to your upper back and shoulders and perhaps rotating your shoulders a few times.
Just lifting them up toward the ears and allow them to drop comfortably to the sides. And feeling some kind of weight that perhaps you’ve been carrying around on your back, moving down and through your body at the ground. It’s like some kind of relief. A burden’s been lifted from your shoulders, from your back. And bringing your awareness all the way down to your hands.
Your hands are soft and loose. Relaxing your lower arms. Your upper arms. Chest is at ease. Relaxing throughout the heart area, the center of the chest.
The lungs. And central region of the back. Stomach. And releasing the tension that we often hold in our stomach muscles. Just allow your belly to go soft.
And through out the abdominal cavity. And keeping your back straight, your trunk erect, relax your lower back muscles. Your buttocks. Through out the upper legs and lower legs. And finally, your feet, soft, loose.
And then bring your awareness to your body in general. And just roughly scanning through the body, noticing any tightnesses, any tensions within the body, any areas of discomfort. Breathing in and down to the tension and imagine as if you were breathing breathing out from that tension upward and out, the tension diminishing, breathing in and down to the tightness wherever it might be. Imagine as if you were breathing out from the tightness upward and out, feeling the tightness loosen, breathing into the tension, the tightness, breathing out in that area. If there’s some discomfort in the body, don’t try to avoid it or struggle against it.
Just breathe in and down, surrounding that area of discomfort like a mother holding hurt child, surrounding it with a breath of care-ness and breathing out from that discomfort, upward and out, opening to the discomfort accepting allowing it to be. Breathing into the tension the tightness the discomfort and breathing out from those areas. The body becoming comfortable, relaxed, at ease. We’ve forgotten how comfortable the body can be. It’s a nice place to be in the body.
So there’s nowhere to go, nothing to do, nobody to please, yourself. Just for a few moments, we’re going to take a break from it all and just be with our bodies. Just resting in entirety, the wholeness of our body, staying with the body. Coming back to the body. Staying with the body.
Practice a simple breath exercise, just breathing in comfortably normally, breathing out, extending exhalation gently, forcing all the air out of the lungs again breathing in comfortably normally allowing the lungs to naturally fill again extending the exhalation And then bring your mind to the breath. The sensation associated with the natural gentle breath. Wherever it’s most clear and obvious, focusing your attention on that sensation of the breath. If it’s helpful you can use the techniques of counting and naming the breaths. Bring your mind back to the breath.
Now we’re going to shift the focus of our attention to the body, just noticing whatever sensations, feelings naturally arise within the body. So there’s no particular agenda, just becoming aware. And it might be useful to simply to name the experience sensing, feeling. If your mind is distracted, you can name that. Focusing the attention on the primary object of the sensations of the body.
Just watching the sensations of the body. Watching the sensations of the body. Whatever sensation is predominant, being aware of just that. And again, the focus of our attention to sound. It might be helpful to to name name that hearing, hearing, or if you’re distracted naming that distraction.
Focusing our awareness on sound. Listening to sound. To sound. Staying with sound. And again, shifting the focus of our attention, this time to the mental consciousness itself.
The pictures, the thoughts, the words arising in our minds. And here it’s helpful if you name that experience. Thinking. Thinking. So simply watching, observing the mental consciousness itself.
Thinking. Thinking. So you have to stay aware, stay awake to maintain awareness. Staying aware of the thoughts. And then lastly, we just allow the mind to become involved in any object that it naturally tends toward.
We don’t choose the object, but we want to maintain awareness. And it’s useful simply to name our present experience, whatever it might be, hearing, thinking, sensing. Just watching from moment to moment with choiceless awareness, just resting in awareness without becoming involved in any particular object, meaning maintaining a perspective. So you have to stay conscious, stay aware. It’s useful if you name what you’re experiencing.
Stay aware. And then bring your mind back to the breath. And get in touch with your body, perhaps the pressure of your buttocks on your cushion, on the chair, your feet on the floor, sensation feeling within the body. Become aware of the sounds about you. And slowly become aware of your surroundings, taking your time.
Just no hurry. Okay. So we are looking at the awakened mind. I guess it’s been something of a theme throughout most history of philosophy, both in the East and the West, that there’s we’re making some mistakes. There’s been lots of arguments about where the mistake lies.
Some people say it’s in the senses that we can only trust our reasoning. Some people say, Well, we can’t trust reasoning. We can only trust bare sensations. Within what we’re describing describing here is the mistake we term ignorance, which is a misconception about the way things exist, not if they exist, but how they exist. You know, I tried to you know, it’s like as if some people, when they suffer from jaundice, they they see everything has a yellow tinge.
This would appear slightly yellowish. That’s my understanding. And you know, if you said, well, you know, you’re not seeing that piece of paper in its true nature as far as its color is concerned. And you say, you know, it’s obvious. It’s a yellow piece of paper.
And you convince them through a process of reasoning that they’re in fact projecting or overlaying a color which isn’t present. There’s some factor within that appearance which is isn’t actually in the coming from the side of the object, isn’t in the nature of the object. It’s something that has to do with your way of perceiving it. And how are you going you know, how how you know, what what is it what is that factor within that appearance which is mistaken? And how would that recognizing that factor within that appearance, you know, when I talk about the paper is present, that’s not the factor we’re considering.
You know, I’m using analogy. Right? And and trying to identify that factor within our appearance. But if we had always had jaundice or it would be tremendously difficult for someone to say, well, you know, that’s a whiteboard. Oh, yeah.
That’s a whiteboard. White is yellow, isn’t it? I mean, that’s what what white really looks like and what is it within that appearance which is mistaken to to be able to to to we’re using a process of reasoning and and observation and analysis to be able to even though appearances to the contrary identify that there is a factor within our appearance which is mistaken. Somebody’s always had jaundice. To be able to identify that yellowness that’s always been there that I’m seeing is not really there.
That’s terribly difficult, I I think. Nonetheless, we have to do that. As a factor, we are always taking it for granted. It’s most apparent. There are many categories.
There’s different ways to divide emptiness. One. One one division of emptiness is into two. selflessness of a person, and selflessness of phenomena And a phenomena here means all things other than persons, tables, buildings, and so forth, my arm, and so forth. These are selfless phenomena.
There’s no difference in the emptiness. They’re both the same. The only difference is in the basis. One is the emptiness of persons or I or self, and one is the emptiness of things, you know, tables and so forth. The emptiness are exactly alike.
But it’s said that coming to an understanding emptiness, it’s easier to identify the object negation with regard to the self, the person, the I. You know, it’s something that most of us would never take in never call into question, isn’t it? The I, the Self, the way it normally appears to us. We’ve never you know, it’s just it’s always been like that. There would be no reason to call it to question.
The Buddha was interested in the source of suffering. And he found that suffering was always associated with a sense of a solid concrete I. There was always either a distant or near association. There was always a relationship with this. And so he investigated that nature of that I.
And he found that a solid, concrete, isolated entity, what we call an inherently exist ent I or inherently existent self or intrinsically existent, substantially existent. When he searched for it, couldn’t find it. It appears it doesn’t exist. So he was trying to begin to identify something which in our normal appearance, is mistaken. We’re using a method of analysis in order to help us to identify we have to the first step is to identify it, and then analysis show it that, in fact, having once identified that that element, it necessarily is mistaken.
It can’t exist that way it appears. So we are contradicting what we take for granted. Our normal intuitive or common sense conception of things. You know, when you get the sense of a very strong I self, that needs to be defended, that needs to be enhanced. We haven’t really taken that into question.
We’ve just taken it for granted that it was the case and we related on that assumption. What is in fact a misassumption? So we’re looking at we’re going through the nine essentials and we’re using simply as a way of learning the method methodology of using this analysis. We’re taking a very simple object such as a car. Maybe not so simple after all.
I don’t know. The the first of these nine essentials is ascertaining the object negation, and we talked about this. This is trying to gain a sense of what how the car is appearing in terms of the way it exists. And we used and we used other types of examples or like the letter a and a a five dollar note, a bill. You know, how they how they and the same exact whatever whatever insight or whatever sense we or feelings we got with regard to the letter a and with regard to the five dollar bill, we we we can use that with a car.
And then with the a, the letter a, somehow, when we before analysis, it seems as if it is an A from its own side, by way of its own nature. It seems to be broadcasting its own self, its definition of what it is. I’m an A. And we are simply receiving a message where we just tune into that message of I’m an A, and we, as it were, simply identify what’s already there. It defines itself.
We don’t define it. But upon analysis we can readily understand that A is simply a popular convention that we learned as a child. And when a certain shape appears, the mind with regard to that thinks A. There’s nothing inherent about that shape which makes it an A. It simply has been defined as such in terms evolution of our language.
And we learned that, that convention. That’s all we mean by conventional reality. We also took the example of a five dollar note and saw that it has no intrinsic value. Value. The value that it has is a matter of convention.
The shifting currency market assigns a certain value to this piece of paper. And accordingly, you can take that piece of paper into coals and you can buy a loaf of bread and so forth. It works, even though it has no intrinsic value. It is simply conventionally, in terms of the context of the social convention. So, you know, we can apply that to a car.
How is the car appearing? For us, a car appears as a whole existing in its own right. And this, you know, I I think maybe right now these are simply words. And maybe, you know, describing some kind of Martian from people, something that has very little to do with our actual experience. The difficulty is and I don’t want to propagandize you or to indoctrinate you into some way of thinking.
So I can only say these are only suggestions. And for you to look, know, take the time to reflect and look into how you might be actually be experiencing is, are you seeing things in this way? It’s difficult because my very suggestion may cause you to identify them. There’s way of getting a perhaps around that. We have to talk we have to talk about these things.
A car appears as as a whole existing in its own right, independent of the perceptual process. It is out there just like that a was out there, just like that five dollar bill was out there. You know, the the opposite of this way of existing we call nominal existence or imputed existence. The fact that car depends upon its existence on being conceived of as a car and being and depends upon the term car. Without the term car, there’s no car.
Without our conceiving of the object as a car, there’s no car. It doesn’t appear that way. It appears that it’s a car from its own side. It has a carness about it by way of its own nature. That’s its intrinsic identity.
It it it it it defines itself. We aren’t defining what it is. It seems as if it’s not being imputed by language or conceptionality. You know, seems as if if if if it it seems as if without being imputed by language and conceptionality, it would not exist at all. It wouldn’t exist at all.
You know? If it it appears it does not depend upon us to define what it is. It defines itself from its own side. Regardless of our thinking about a car of what it is as a car, it is by way of its own nature a car. So this car existing, independent of the perceptual process, independent of language, independent of its parts, independent of cause and conditions, independence of our thinking of it as such is the object of negation.
Just like the a, which the letter a, which does not depend upon social convention or thinking of it as a, or having learned it to be an a, that that shape is by its very nature a independent. That is an object of negation. The five dollar bill, which has an intrinsic value from its own side, regardless of currency markets, you know, the fluctuation, the the the economic crisis and so forth, by way of its own nature, it has a has a has a an objective value of its own. That is an object of negation. So we’re using, you know, all of these different ways to get a sense of the object of negation.
Maybe maybe one of them works better for you or not. We’re going to we’re using this if an object, and we eventually, we’re going to use it to analyze the self, the I. Okay? The second of the nine essentials. So this project has practical value.
It’s not just mere philosophical exercise or something like that. It has implications because it has as its goal, the elimination of ignorance, which is the source of our suffering. So it’s pragmatic. It’s not simply It influences our actions, doesn’t it? Yeah.
Our understanding influences our actions. Yeah. Very much so. Our thinking influences our actions, behaviors, and our worldview is being shaped. Ascertaining the object of negation.
The second is ascertaining the pervasion. You know, we went over this when we looked at the Four Essentials, when we looked at the hearer stage. The pervasion, or sometimes it’s called the entailment, is the commitment to what we call binary logic or excluded middle. Yeah. Whatever exists, whatever object we we examine, it necessarily whatever phenomenon we look at necessarily falls into one either one of two categories.
It is either the same or different. It is either one or many. It is either a singular or a plurality. It is either identical or distinct. So these are all dichotomies, aren’t they?
They cover within the all phenomena are are included within one of these within these dichotomies with either the object is the same or is different. Either it’s one or many. A singular plurality, identical or different. They they these these two extend to all phenomena whatsoever. There’s there’s there’s nothing which is excluded from being included within these two categories.
Whatever existent, we might exist. You know, for, like, for example, a dog and a cat, that’s different. A dog and a dog, same. A book and a table, different, many, distinct. A table and a table, same, one, singular, identical.
So, you know, no matter what object we choose, it necessarily is included in one of these two categories. And it sounds simple minded, but it’s necessary that we get you know, we’re trying to be as methodical as possible. Right? We have to, you have to assure ourselves. Now having ascertained the object negation in the first essential, that is, say, an inherently existent car, we’re going to go on to analyze whether or not this this identified car is the same as its parts or different than its parts.
Whether it’s distinct from its parts or identical with its parts. It has to be one of the two. There’s no third possible way of it existing with relationship to its parts. We have the have the car that we identified, and we’re going you know, it’s it’s an it’s it is is involved with its parts. And what is it?
We want to we want to analyze what is the relationship between those two? The car and its parts. Okay. We we have to we want to narrow down the possible ways that those two can relate. Either the relationship between the car and its parts is that they’re the same, identical, one, no difference whatsoever.
You know? Whatever is one is the other. Whatever is the other is the is the other is the one, Or they’re different. The car and its parts are distinct. Their plurality, they’re different.
They’re not the same. It has to be if they exist, they have to exist in one of these two ways. The relationship then has to be either one of identity or or distinction, single or plural, one or many, same or different. Yeah. And we have to it’s like there’s no third possible way that the two could exist.
We have to become convinced of that because we’re going go on to analyze. If this inherent ka exists, if the car has its appearance as we’ve identified it in the first part, if it in fact exists, it has to be the same as its parts or different than its parts. If it’s neither one of those two, it doesn’t exist. If it exists, it has to be one of these two ways. So we have to feel, you know, somebody might eject all.
Maybe it’s both, same and different. I’m being clever like some people try to be. Maybe it’s worth it. It’s a mixture of the two. Little bit of same, a little bit of different.
But really this is not a real possibility. If two things are not the same, how can they be both the same and different? A mixture of chili and sugar is definitely not the same as sugar. Don’t ask me to have a cup of tea at your house. A mixture of chili and sugar is different than sugar, isn’t it?
It’s not the same as sugar. So it’s not a real possibility. So simply stated, if the car exists as it normally appears to us, and then say inherently exists, and we’re trying to get a sense of what inherently exist feels like. What is, you know, it must exist in one of the following seven ways. If it doesn’t exist in one of the following seven ways, it doesn’t exist at all.
Appearances Appearances to the contrary. It’s going to appear to inherently exist. It’s going to just like a person with jaundice, that piece of paper still appears them to be yellow. But you can through reasoning and explanation that you have problems with your liver. When you have problems with liver bile enters into the bloodstream.
It affects the I know all the physiology of it. It’s not important. It affects it can affect your vision. Therefore, I understand that this piece of paper appears yellow to you, but in fact it’s not. I don’t want you to take my word on it.
You don’t have to trust me. I want you to understand that at least introduce some kind of doubt that maybe this piece of paper doesn’t quite exist the way it appears to you. And there’s a good reason why, because you’re suffering from jaundice. And when you have jaundice, you have certain consequences for it. One of them is everything appears with a yellow tinge.
So he said, Okay. Begins to reason about. And he said, well, it still appears to me, but I I I’m never I’m not going to accede to that appearance. I’m not appearance to the contrary, I’m never I’m not no. I’m no longer quite going to believe as assuredly as I once did that, in fact, that piece of paper is yellow.
We’ve at least introduced an element of doubt. Even the appearances to the contrary, they don’t quite buy into that appearance the way they once did due to the to the force of reasoning. And this is what we’re trying to work with here. If we know what we’re looking for, if it exists that way, in relationship to its parts, it has to exist in one of these seven ways. If it doesn’t exist in one of seven ways, it doesn’t exist.
It’s still going to appear to exist. It will appear to exist all the way up to Buddhahood. Up to up to just the prior to the moment of Buddhahood, everything that exists appears to inherently exist. It appears to exist independent of the perceptual process. Subsequent, there’s still a factor of falsity in the appearance, even all the way up to prior to Buddhahood.
Once you’ve achieved Jain Buddhahood, that that mistaken appearing factor is removed from the perceptual process. And this is in fact what’s called the obstruction to omniscience. Things appear to truly exist, independent existing. It’s even said that’s why because that wall appears to exist. There’s a reason we can’t see the other side of it.
Otherwise, if it didn’t appear that way, we wouldn’t be able to see the other side of it. But that’s another story. None etheless, we can remove ignorance. And therefore, though things still appear to truly exist, we no longer believe in that appearance. Ignorance is the belief in that appearance, in that independent existence, in that inherent existence.
in dependence upon that belief, in that inherent existence, in that true existence, the various afflictive emotions of attachment and hatred arise. They all are contingent upon that taking that kind of position with regard to the object, that it inherently exists, that it truly exists, that exists from its own side, independent of the language, independent of my thinking of it. All they all all they all have their evolution out of that basic misconception. Without their basic misconception, an attachment won’t arise. Hatred will not arise.
Although they they’re they’re just like, you know, like, they’re layered one upon the other. These misconceptions like like an archaeological dig, you know, like civilizations based upon this this this fundamental misconception ascertaining the pervasion. We’re going to begin the process. So, we’ve seen these before in the Four Essentials, at the Hearer stage. These first two of these nine essentials, ascertaining the object of negation, ascertaining the pervasion.
Now we’re going to look at the seven fold reasoning, and we’re actually going to begin our analysis. And the first of these two, the third and fourth, are exactly the same as the third and fourth of the Four Essentials that we looked at in the Hearer stage. So whatever you remember from the Hearer stage when we looked at the Four Essentials, you can apply that here, but we’re going to go over it again. The third and fourth are the two possible positions. The remaining, the fifth, sixth, seventh, eighth and ninth, are simply elaborations on the third and fourth.
They are simply ways of going into this analysis in a little more detail to show up different significances from different points of view. So, you know, we’re analyzing whether the car on the one hand and its parts and by parts I mean like the axle, the wheel, the motor, the frame, and all on the other are they inherently the same or are they do they but when I say inherently the same, do they define themselves identically? Does a car and its parts, do they do they define themselves identically? Are they are are they do they have the exact same characteristics? Does do the parts of the car have the same car characteristics which define the car?
You know, the car and its parts, are they undifferentiated the same? Undifferentiated the same. No difference whatsoever. Okay. No car there’s no car there’s no car which is inherent the same as its parts.
There’s no car which is inherently the same as its parts. No car which I mean, generally we would think that, wouldn’t we? The car is its parts. Okay? When we think that, we have when we have that sense that that everything which defines car defines parts, and everything which defines parts defines car.
And if the car and the parts were inherently the same, then each of the parts would have the characteristic of carness. We have a sense that the car is kind of like peanut butter spread on bread. There is a car-ness which kind of spread throughout the entirety of its parts. Homogenous, homogenized peanut butter. And there’s no separation with the oily part to it.
And it’s kind of just the car and its parts are one. It’s undifferentiably fused together. You have that sense. Mean, this is the analyzed sense. Of if the car and its parts were one, then every car every part would have the quality, the characteristic of car-ness.
The car-ness seems to cover its parts. Seems to be a characteristic of car-ness homogeneously spread throughout its entirety. You know what? That’s the reason they homogenize milk. I don’t know.
Before your time when they didn’t have you you used to get these the the milk milk milkman would leave a bottle of milk on the back porch and the cream would be on top. And you’d of course, you’d nick off the cream first thing. But now it’s homogenized and it’s consistent throughout all. There’s no separation of the cream. There’s this sense of this car-ness which is homogenously spread throughout the entirety of its part.
If that were the case, each part would have the characteristic which defines the car. Whatever defines a car as a car, every part would have that characteristic. For example, every part would have the quality of being a means of transportation. The motor would be transportation, the bumper would be transportation, the axle would be transportation, which a defining characteristic of car. If each part had the defining characteristic of car, then there would be as many cars as there are parts.
You know, the axle would be a car, the wheel would be a car, the motor would be a car, the frame would be a car, the bumper would be a car. Each of them would be a means of transportation because whatever defines a car defines the part. Every part would be able to perform the function of a car since the parts in the car have the exact same characteristics. Am I trying to pull the wool over your eyes? Shifting like the shells here.
On the other hand, because there is only one car if if everything which defines the car defines its characteristic of parts, then because, you know, because there is only one car, there could only be one part. Because every characteristic of the car is a characteristic of the parts. Since there’s only one car, there could only be one part. So you can go either way. Either there either there have to be many cars because there’s many parts, or there would only be one part because there’s only one car.
If exactly the same, whatever one defines the other. Also, if the parts in the car were inherently the same, then upon searching through the parts, we should be able to find the car. But we we don’t. The axle is not the car. The wheels aren’t the car.
The motor is not the car. The frame is not the car. The bumper is not the car. You know, know, we does anybody have a a pen that I can take apart? Can I take?
Okay, thank you. So, you know, I don’t know, it’s hard. It’s not easy. You. Nice pen.
There’s a pen. Looks I mean, we have to admit, it doesn’t look like it depends upon my mind or language or conceptuality. It’s just very solid, extends out there in space, and it sounds this is a pen. And that’s of that’s what it is from its own side and I’m just a mirror and I’m just kind of reflecting that image and that there’s a pen out there, a pen out there. But if we were to go on and analyze it, know, we can question.
Is that a pen? Is that a pen? This is a not a pen. We can call it a knot pin. Is that a pen?
You’re doing very well. This is a knot pin. Is that a pen? Yes. Yes.
Yes. Okay. I didn’t wanna I didn’t wanna do anything. How about how about the I’m not gonna take off the tip. The plastic barrel, the white plastic barrel.
I if I take off the tip, is that a pen? That nib is a pen? You’re saying yes or no, or you want to argue and punch him or something? Why do you say that’s the pen? Because that’s the intrinsic thing that makes that a pen.
But it can’t write, it doesn’t get the ink into it. But that little hollow nib, just that little iron metal iron nib, is that a pen? Well The nib is a pen. The ink is a separate entity. If you say, can I borrow your pen?
I gave you that little piece of metal there. Yeah. It’s a pen. Ink is ink. It’s a separate entity, isn’t it?
So that’s a pen? Well, it’s the writing pen. Okay. I’m being a bit of a pest. No.
That’s it. The thing is if you So so what If you had a quill a quill, the the nib is is the pen. Okay. Well Yeah. Is then It’s not it’s not the ink, but it’s the pen.
Is it able to function as a pen? That little iron nib there? With in conjunction with ink? No. No.
No. It’s just just an iron nib. Iron nib. Well, is not the ink separate from the pen? Is is is that a pen?
A pen is a writing instrument. Is that a writing instrument? You need ink to go with the writing instrument. It has to work in conjunction. Okay.
Let’s see. If if if if I is the is the bottom half if I cut that in half, and I show you that one one half, is that a pen? Okay. I’ll I’ll No. No.
No. No. You’re just gonna keep going. I mean, I I can dissect it a little bit. I can but the thing is, you know, you can go down to the atom or That’s right.
That’s right. Then it would not be a pen. But the thing is, it depend depends what you what defines pen. And and what defines pen? Do I define it, or is this object object from its own side define it?
Oh, I don’t know. You tell me. But the thing is the the there is a lot of these these parts are an elaboration of what a pen is. So but none of them are pen? None of them are pen.
They’re elaboration of the of the pen. Okay. The pen is the writing or the the instrument of writing as far as I’m concerned. Okay. So What what is the pen?
It’s the nib. It’s the thing that writes. What what makes it a writer is the ink. You have to have two things. You can’t have you can’t be by itself.
It has to leave something behind when the So so a a pen without ink is not a pen? It’s still a pen. It’s still a writing instrument. But it can’t write. We only define it as being a a a ballpoint pen because it’s got ink in it.
But pens don’t necessarily by definition, they don’t have to have ink in them because a quill So that’s a An quill is a pen. Okay. A quill. Okay. So is a pen without the ink.
Yeah. The most the most It it has to have something else to make it work. Yeah. You can write in the sand. You don’t need ink.
You don’t in the sand? Yes. Don’t need ink. My gosh. So my finger is a pen?
Yeah. You can use it in everything. Just get different materials. That’s a pen, right? Yeah, you can cut and you got So we could call that a pen.
It’s got function. Could be a writing in the sense. We can call this a busy, is there any, what makes it a pen? We can call it pen but they got a function of writing. Because it functions as writing.
They got functions writing. So it’s depend on the definition of the pen. Right? In conjunction with the thought that you want to write, it’s a pen. Alright.
Let’s see how are we going to do this? Where was I? This usually works. So anything can be a pen. Anything can be a pen.
Can anything be a car? Even if you have water and you just pull away, that can write something. So water can be a pen too. It really depends on the definition of what’s really pen is. If it’s just the function of writing, everything can write.
Everything can make the shape. How about it was not able it was not able to perform the function of the pen? Yeah. For example, when six years ago, seven years ago, there is no pen. You can use anything to write and to make a mark.
So What about this building? Is this a pen? Is this a Not a book. Not really big. Man, too big.
It’s the Pick a carrot. So something is a pen because of the convention that that is we we we have a definition that that is a pen. Yeah. I agree. Yeah.
And with without it falling within those rules of convention Yep. It’s not a something. Like A brush is a pen too. Chinese use it for calligraphy. It’s not called a pen.
But but the no. The thing is it depends on your definition. If if your definition is false, if it if it’s got if it’s got exceptions and everything like that, then it could be anything could be a pen. It’s like it’s like if you go to are you American? Yes.
You know, food No. I’m Australian. You know, the the Food and Drugs Administration in America defines what peanut butter is. And if it doesn’t have certain constituents, it’s not peanut butter. It has to be something else.
It’s the definition that makes it peanut butter. So it’s a definition, but where does that definition come from? Well, it’s a convention. So is it is not in it not in the nature of the object? It’s not in the nature of the object.
No. This is not a pen anymore. For the By your definition. It doesn’t you can write in sand. You got more?
Away with that phrase. If we were to yeah, pen, pen. The difference between a pen and writing instrument isn’t there? Not all writing instruments are pens. True.
My finger is not a pen. It could be a writing instrument. Yeah. This can be a pen too. Pardon?
This one can be a pen too. Okay. So what is not pen, what is not pen, assembled together. Of what is not pen. Oh my gosh.
This time an elaboration of a Does does does this work when you brought it? Yeah. Not worry. Not to worry. I’ll fix it.
It’s a good thing I know. It depends upon where it is not pin. As if by magic. It’s quite mysterious I think in a way. Because if it gets I Essentially none of the parts are pen.
But, so if the pen were one with its parts, if we’re the same as its parts, then you know we can determine like in a car, each of the parts is not a car. Then how can how can how can the car be the same as its parts? How can the pin be how can the pin be the same as as its parts? How can the car be the same as as its parts when the the parts of the car are not car? The parts of not a car are not car.
How can the car be the same of its parts? Okay? It’s like if you if you glimpse at the pen, if you look at it as a pen, but then if you take it apart and then glimpse at it another time, you’re not gonna see it as a pen because it’s the thought that arises in your mind So yeah. Rather than the actual because you can work back from the nib and say it’s a pen. Yeah.
But, really, you’re doing a lot of you’re filling in a lot of sort of analysis. Because if you just glimpsed at it, you’re not gonna think if you saw the nib, you’re not gonna think straight away pen. You’re gonna think nib. You might think could be you, could was a pen, or But you can go the other way too because without language, you you wouldn’t know what it is. Yeah.
Or or someone might not even seen a pen before, and they wouldn’t know. No. They’d say, yeah. What what is that? Yeah.
Oh, pen. Okay. As you were saying, without analysis, that object is able to function as a pen quite well. And that’s conventional reality, it works quite well. When you begin to analyze, you know, well, what is the pen, actually?
Well, then we go through the various parts and say, none of them are the pen. Just like with regard to the car, you know, the car is able to function and and depends upon its parts of the car. We we can label car. We can designate car. So that that kind of unanalyzed appearance can able to perform the function that we assign to it.
But when we begin to analyze, we cannot find the car. It is, in fact, none of its parts are a car. Okay? Isn’t it a sum of its parts? Well, we’re gonna come to that.
That’s number seven. Okay. Number eight is the mere collection of its parts, the sum. But actually, it’s the same. But this is an elaboration on that point.
That’s the common sense. It seems as if the car is the sum of its parts. It’s all, you know, a collection of its parts. But we’re going to see whether that’s the case or not. Okay.
So the first of the seven fold reason is there is no no car which is inherently the same of its parts. We know what we’re looking for. We identify the object of negation. This very solid concrete car which exists independent cause and condition, independent of its parts, independent language and conceptuality. It has a certain thingness about it.
And now we’re looking for that. We’re trying to say, well, is it the same as the car, as its parts? That car is not the same as its parts. Then we’re going to look, there is no car which is inherently different than its parts. Okay?
And what does an inherent difference mean? So inherent difference means unrelatedly different. Like a table and a chair. Like glass of water in this table. Un they’re not just different.
They’re unrelatedly different. That is to say, the that that is to say, you have a if you have a table and a chair, the existence of the chair does not rely upon the existence of the table, and the existence of the table does not rely upon the existence of the chair. They don’t rely upon one another. So they’re different, they’re unrelatedly different. You could destroy the chair and the table would remain, or you could destroy the table and the chair would remain.
So that’s what we mean by unrelatedly different and that’s what we mean by inherently different. When we think and here we begin to make some distinction between the way we think with our mental consciousness and the way things appear to our physical senses. When we think about an object like color and shape, we can think about colors without thinking about shapes. And we can think about shapes without thinking about colors. I can think red, blue, green or yellow without thinking of any particular shape.
I can say, I like the color green. Fine. I don’t necessarily have to be thinking about a particular shape that the green takes. On the other hand, I can think about shapes, triangular shapes, circular shapes, rectangular shapes, without thinking of them as being any color. You know, they you know, a circle has three hundred and sixty degrees interior angles.
Doesn’t have a color. It’s just an abstraction of a shape. So it appears that colors and shapes can be separated, that are separate entities, that they are unrelated in the same manner that a table and a chair are unrelatedly different. We can have a sense that color and shape are somehow similarly unrelatedly different. But in fact, there is no color.
In fact, outside of our thoughts about colors and shapes, is no color without a shape and there is no shape without a color. They are one entity. They appear to thought to be separate entities. That is say, we can think of them differently. Therefore, we assume that they are different, can be a different They can be separated out one from another.
But in fact, they’re one single entity. If have a white piece of paper and we put a red square on it, if we remove that red, we remove the square. If we remove the square, move the red. And you kinda cut out the the the the one single entity. They cannot be, in fact, separated.
They cannot be, in fact, they cannot be separated in physical fact. Only in terms of our thoughts about them do they appear separate or different. Different entities means that you can separate the two, things like a table and chair. A car and its parts appear as unrelatedly different. Or you can say, you know, like, a house, a house and the bricks and walls and roof that make up the house.
I can talk about a house, and I can talk about the walls and the and the and the foundation and the ceiling and the roof without, you know, talking about the house. But in fact, they’re one entity. They cannot be, in fact, separated one from the other. And likewise, with regard to the car. The car and its parts are appear appear unrelatedly different.
There is a sense of a concrete findable findability of of each separate from the other as if we could find the car separate from its parts. We could find the part separate from its car. However, if the car and the so we’re looking at the car is inherently different than its parts. It is is we identify this car. There’s a sense there’s a sense that we could find the car separate from its parts.
If we if we jump ahead just for a moment, there’s a sense we could find the I, the self, separate from the body and body. This is this is where this is kind of leading us to. There’s a sense we can find the car separate from its parts. Let us say, you know, if that were the case, this is the way we have a sense of the car, the way the car appears to us. My car.
We’re not talking about the parts. Just like we talk about color without talking about shape, we have a sense that they’re separate in fact, not just separate in the way they appear, we can think about them. Just like they’re separate in the same way a table and a chair are separate. If they were separate in that way, let’s say inherently different, somebody could damage your bumper, but your car would remain undamaged, would remain fine. Because you could damage a chair without damaging the table, since they’re in fact separately different, and unrelatedly different.
There’s no connection between the two. What happens to one doesn’t necessarily happen to the other. So, you know, we have a sense, and this is the way the car and its parts are appearing to us. Just as sometimes we say, I can’t stand you. I hate you.
I and body and mind appear unrelatedly different. When we say, I can’t stand you, we’re not talking about body, we’re not talking about mind, we’re talking about something unrelatedly different to body and mind, as if we could separate out an I and body and mind. If the car and its parts were in fact unrelatedly different, then we could separate out all the parts of the car and the car would remain sitting there. Or we could somehow remove the car and the parts will remain. Just as we have a sense that we could we could remove body and mind and there would be an I.
You know, I could set the body over there, the mind over there, and there would be an I sitting on this cushion. Yeah. It’d be there’s there would be something left over remaining, which isn’t the body and mind, which is separate and relatedly different than the body and mind. Just like we can move table and the chair will remain. Likewise with the car, likewise with the I, we have that sense.
This reason that there’s no car which is inherently different than its parts can just as well serve to refute the next two reasons, five and six. Since why? Because here it talks about there is no car which inherently depends upon its parts. There is no car upon which the parts inherently depend. For two things to depend, they must be different.
And we establish that they’re not different. But we go on to work with these two in detail because they just help us to refine our understanding. We’re approaching it from a different point of view, the ideal of depend. But dependence requires that if one thing depends upon another, they necessarily are different. And we’ve already refuted that they cannot be inherently different.
Nonetheless, we go on to look at each of these two possible ways of dependence. So here dependence there’s two senses of the word dependence. It can mean is on, depends on, or is is in. You know, for example, you like your hand. There’s a sense how did my how does my hand depend upon the fingers and and the palm and so forth and the thumb?
That we can have one sense where the hand is slightly within the parts. Entity of the hand pervades the parts but it’s slightly inside. And this is just a sense, a little little bit inside the parts that make up the hand. And thus, it depends upon the hand. The hand depends upon the parts for a place for the hand to abide.
This is where it exists. The hand exists within its parts. I don’t know if you’re following this or not. Another way is the hand slightly extends just it extends throughout the part but just a little bit further. The parts, like, hang off the hand.
The hand is the place where parts are hum from. So it depends on that way. Anyway, we’re going go through these two positions. The fifth position. There’s no car which inherently depends upon its parts.
Maybe we’ll hold off on that. Identified a car. The way it is the way that it appears to exist for us at all times, the way this table appears to exist for us. We ascertain the If that table exists the way it appears, it must be either the same as its parts or different than its parts. There is no which is inherently the same as its parts.
There is no car which is the same as is inherently the same as its parts. You know, there is a rectangular wooden piece with four legs. If it’s the same as its parts, then every characteristic of table should be a characteristic of each of its parts since they are identically the same. What defines table should define each of its parts. But if we go through the parts, this is not a table.
This is not a table. This top piece is not a table. So it or none of it’s parts of the table. If if it were if the car if every characteristic of table define its parts, there’s one table, therefore, there’d only have to be one there can only be one part since the characteristic of the table is that there’s only one of them. Therefore there can only be one part.
On the other hand, because there’s many parts and every characteristic which defines the parts, defines the table, then there would have to be many tables because there are many parts. So we can use these kinds of reasoning. Don’t know, maybe it sounds like sophistry at the moment, I don’t know. Just like so many words. We have to kind of play with these feelings and work with them.
It may become more apparent when we work with the I, the self. The table is, there’s no table which is inherently different than its parts. If the part if the table and its parts were unrelatedly different, like a table and a chair, then we could I could I could, you know, burn one of the burn I could chop the pieces of one of the the legs, and the table would remain unaffected. Just like I can chop a chair without affecting the table because they’re unrelatedly different. They’re separate entities.
But in fact, that’s not the case. If I if I chop the leg, if I damage the leg of the table, I I damage the table. If I damage the top, I damage the table. They’re one entity, though they appear as different entities. They’re thought.
When does when do the parts become a table? When do the parts that’s that’s that’s when we look at dependent arising. We talked about this a little bit last week. You know, something appears to the mind and something stimulates the thought. And this is ongoing and unconscious, the thought table with regard to that.
We don’t see all the parts of the table. We can’t see all the parts of the table. Moreover, you see parts that I don’t see. So a portion of the table, some of the parts from a particular angle appear to you. And you think table, I think table.
This is a learned convention. Something stimulates your mind, something stimulates my mind. And we form the shared reality. It can be so this is everything is dependent we have a consensus about what is appearing to us. We call it a table.
Sometimes what we talked about this a little bit last week when we talked about bullies. Sometimes the consensus is only of one person. Something appears to you. But our labeling process isn’t we about tables, cars and things like that. But these have very little emotional associations with them.
But what happens when memories and feelings become mixed in with this process of labeling? Then, you know, just we can we can some characteristic of a person, for example, maybe just some little twitch can remind you unconsciously of someone who you didn’t like when you were young. This process is ongoing and unconscious. This twitch appears to you and you label bully or unlikable person, whatever. And you might be the only but for you that’s a valid label.
Know, we’re not there’s nothing inherent which makes them that way. The same holds true for beauty, for friends, or anything. Once we have this sense with regard to these seemingly objective phenomena, objects about us, then can begin to apply it to what we normally see as more subjective. What is beauty? What is ugliness?
What is friend? What is stranger? What is likable or dislikable? We can see if we create these seemingly objective phenomena, if the labeling process is intimately involved in bringing them forth into our experience. What to say of those which are you know, we have this idea.
We have the same beauty is in the eyes of the beholder. That we’re we’re we’re bringing forth all of these. Once that once that understanding begins to to what do they call that? Trickle. What do they call that?
Trickle down. What’s the what’s the coffee? Percolate down. Percolate down into our thinking process. It’s not that people don’t this labeling process will continue, but we don’t buy into the label.
You know, we hold those appearances to be truths as to the same degree. They don’t have as much impact or weight. They don’t overwhelm us. We don’t become captivated by appearances. We gain some perspective on appearances.
And then eventually, you know, they no longer will be seen as such anyway. Anyway, we’ve got a bit more work to do. Okay. I hope this hasn’t been a little bit too what? Phyllis abstract?
One of the things I find, Jennifer, as you as you speak, and it’s very complex, is there are moments when I think, And then another moment where I’ll be quite puzzled, and that is going all the way through. And it’s it’s puzzling, and it’s and it’s very good. Right at the end there, I had a bit of an when in response to something you just said, and it was, right. So if a car is coming on the road and it looks like it’s gonna hit me, it makes absolute sense to hop out of the road because that’s a concrete reality. Or if somebody whose behaviour I have experienced as bullying comes in the room, maybe I’ll decide not to hang around.
That’s maybe sensible in a concrete way, but the shift is not to see the car or the person as intrinsically car or a bully, but both things can interplay. It sort of feels like there’s an application there for living. That sounds good. That’s the two levels of truth. There’s the conventional level of truth, which is superficial appearances, function, and then the the deeper level which in which we come to understand the way in which those appearances are false.
Though they’re able to perform the function, they don’t exist the way they appear. So you still wanna get out of the way of the car because it’ll run you down. It’s able to perform that function, but it doesn’t it doesn’t exist the way it normally appears in that or, you know, the car is one thing, but a bully is another. He appears to be that way by his own nature, and he’s not. He’s able to perform the function of a bully, but he doesn’t have the nature of a bully.
Okay, so we can dedicate. Oh, next Monday is a holiday. They get a break. Morning? In the program, I thought Thursday morning didn’t happen anymore.
No, that’s a mistake. It’s in the Oh, I see. That’s on the website? Yeah. That’s a mistake.
I’m sorry. No, it’s okay. So Yeah. Thursday at ten Thursday at ten, okay. So I have to say this Well, at least you’ll understand.
I appreciate your understanding. May all beings everywhere plagued by suffering of body and mind attain an ocean of happiness and joy by virtue of my merits. May no living creature suffer, commit evil, or fall ill. May no one be afraid or belittled with a mind weighed down by depression. May the blind see forms and deaf hear sounds.
May those whose bodies are worn with toil be restored when finding repose. May the naked find clothing, the hungry find food. May the thirsty find water and delicious drink. May the poor find wealth, those weak with sorrow find joy. May the forlorn find hope, constant happiness and prosperity.
May there be timely rains and bountiful harvests. May all medicines be effective and wholesome prayers bear fruit. May all who are sick and ill quickly be freed from the ailments. Whatever diseases there are in the world, may they never occur again. May the frightened cease to be afraid and those bound be freed.
May the powerless find power and may people think of benefiting each other. For as long as space remains, for as long as sentient beings remain, until then may I too remain to dispel the miseries of the world. Through these skillful actions, may I quickly become an awakened spiritual master and lead each and every living being to that awakened realm. May the supreme jewel, bodhicitta that has not arisen, arise and grow. And may that which has arisen never diminish, but increase more and more.
In the land encircled by snow mountains, you are the source of all happiness and well-being. Powerful Chenrezig, Tenzin Gyatso, please remain until the end of cyclic existence Thank you. Have a good evening. If you’d like to stay and have a chat, we’ll grab a cup of tea.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
At what point do the parts become a table, according to dependent arising?
We never see all the parts of a table, and each person sees different parts from a particular angle. Something appears and stimulates the thought "table", an ongoing, unconscious process. It is a learned convention: the same appearance stimulates each person's mind, and we form a shared reality by consensus and call it a table. Labels such as bully, beauty or friend work the same way, though they are mixed with memories and feelings, and sometimes the consensus is only one person's. Nothing inherent makes them so. As this understanding percolates down into our thinking, labeling continues, but we do not buy into the labels.