Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 — 2009-02-23

2 h 7 min · 13,334 words · 23 February 2009 · Buddha House Adelaide

Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 — 2009-02-23
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. A Beatles lyric — “life is what happens when you’re busy making plans” — opens Ven Jampa Gendun’s reflection on present-moment awareness before this just-over-two-hour session moves to the Heart Sūtra, a guided meditation on breath, body sensation, sound, and choiceless awareness, and the core doctrinal work: ascertaining the object of negation, the first of nine analytical steps toward understanding emptiness. Gendun builds a felt sense of how everyday objects — a letter A, a five-dollar note, a car — appear to define themselves from their own side, independent of the labeling and convention that actually constitute them. A long student Q&A then applies this to lived experience: when someone seems by nature to be a bully, Gendun traces how emotional memory and unconscious projection generate labels we mistake for objective fact. For practitioners already engaged in this ongoing series.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 35 3PA 2009 02 23.mp3

UUID: 4a03cc37-0725-4941-b6e9-6a911265f383

Teacher: Ven Jampa Gendun

Collection: Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 (Ven Jampa Gendun)

Date: 2009-02-23

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 127.7 minutes

Words: ~13,333

Can you can you hear me okay? Can you hear me? Yes. Okay. So as we normally do and maybe I may have to turn it down a little bit.

Okay. How are you? Good. I’m well. And you’re well.

You’re always well. Yes. Okay. You guys are gonna have to tell me your secret. How you do it?

Know, adjusting your motivation. You know, getting in touch with the moment, becoming sincere with what it is that we’re present. Do I bring yourself, your mind to the present moment? Quite often more than not, our minds are caught up in ruminations, in memories about the past or plans about the future. Somehow the present kind of slips by unnoticed.

But in fact, the present moment is the only time that we actually have to experience our life. It is the only time that we have the opportunity to make the kinds of changes that we want to bring about. It’s the only moment that we can apply ourselves to those kinds of changes. So we often talk about how we want to be a different person or we want to develop this or that quality and so forth. And We’re always making plans.

There’s a song by the Beatles. What is it? Life is what happens to you while you’re busy making other plans. That’s what it is, yeah. So life passes by.

Is the only time we have to implement those plans, whatever they might be, to make the kinds of effort. You know, we oftentimes talk about making more effort. And sometimes this sort of we have a sense that our future becomes like a mountain and it almost becomes insurmountable. We are overwhelmed overwhelmed by the prospects of climbing this huge peak, undertaking this huge task that we’ve set out for ourselves and quite often we set ourselves up for failure in one way or another. In fact, the only time, you know, it’s not a matter of making more effort.

It’s simply making, being mindful of the kinds of changes that we want to bring about and making those changes when the opportunity presents themselves in the present moment. We can only make effort in this moment and then the next moment presents itself and the next moment presents itself. Those are the only moments, the only opportunities that we have. In fact, the rest kind of exists within fantasy or within our imagination, and sometimes our imaginations get the better of us, and they can ruin the the best of plans that we would set out for ourselves. So bringing ourselves to the present moment in terms of adjusting our motivation and taking advantage of the opportunity as it presents itself to redirect ourselves and stop speeding, stop reacting.

And getting in touch with perhaps some of our deeper values, our priorities. We have different sets of desires, different levels of desires, superficial desires, to feed our stomachs, clothing, shelter, and perhaps beyond that, a sense of position and material gain and so forth. But perhaps underlying those desires is a desire for what we call our most deeper held values. A large extent these are psychological qualities rather than things material things about us like love and beauty and honesty and loyalty and these kinds of values. And quite often we project them on an external object, on a person or something or other.

We imagine these are the objects of our desires, but in fact they’re just masks behind which our real desire is hidden more than not. You know, we call we we story our lives. We’re we’re always, you know, using metaphors. A metaphor is that which stands for for our experience. And we more than live by these metaphors.

And what is our values are set out in metaphors. When we string these metaphors out into a narrative which describes the quality of the life that we’re looking for, we call that a successful life, a meaningful life, a purposeful life, or just a life, an attractive kind of life. We just call that Buddha, the best possible story that we could ever possibly tell, that we could tell ourselves about ourselves and what we might be able to do with our lives. It’s just a shorthand notation about the kind of person that we might want to become and making the effort to actually bring that about within the present moment. Directing ourselves in terms of what that, you know, what, how does the present moment in terms of what we’re about to do, the activity that we’re involved in here, in listening and talking about these methods of Dharma, how does that lend itself to the kind of person that you want to become?

So the focus of our inner life becomes Buddhahood, which we are trying to achieve by means of the Dharma within this kind of the social context of a spiritual community and those who assist us in the process. And again and again trying to raise the level of our motivation, you know, having a greater vision about what a successful life might look like in terms of of a social commitment, not only to being in this world with others, but being in this world with others in such a way that we make it a better world both for ourselves and others. I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha through my practice of generosity and other perfections.

May I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am awakened to Buddha, Dharma and Sangha through my practice of generosity and the other perfections and have become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. May all sentient beings have happiness and the causes of happiness. May all sentient beings be free from suffering and the causes of suffering. May all sentient beings be inseparable from the joy that is without sorrow.

May all sentient beings abide in equanimity, free from attachment for some and aversion to others. Thus did I hear at one time the Bhagavan was dwelling on Mount Vulture Peak Mountain in Rajgirha together with a great community of monks and a great community of bodhisattvas. At that time the Bhagavan was absorbed in the concentration on the categories of phenomena called profound perception. Also at that time the Bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara looked upon the very nectar of the profound perfection of wisdom and beheld those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature. Then through the power of the Buddha, the Venerable Śāriputra said this to the Bodhisattva, mahasattva, Ārya, Avalokiteśvara, How should any son of the lineage train who wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom he said that and the Bodhisattva Mahāsattva Ārya Avalokiteśvara said this to the venerable Śāriputra, any son of the lineage or daughter of the lineage who wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom should look upon it like this correctly and repeatedly beholding those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature.

Form is empty, emptiness is form, emptiness is not other than form. Form is also not other than emptiness. In the same way feeling, discrimination, compositional factors, and consciousness are empty. Śāriputra, likewise all phenomena are emptiness without characteristics, unproduced, unceased, stainless, not without stain, not deficient, not fulfilled. Śāriputra, therefore, in emptiness, there is no form, no feeling, no discrimination, no compositional factors, no consciousness, no eye, no ear, no nose, no tongue, no body, no mind, no visual form, no sound, no odor, no taste, no object of touch, and no phenomenon.

There is no eye element and so on up to including no mind element and no mental consciousness element. There is no ignorance, no extinction of ignorance and so on up to and including no aging and death and no extinction of aging and death. Similarly, there is no suffering, origination, cessation and path. There is no exalted wisdom, no attainment, and also no non attainment. Śāriputra, therefore, because there is no attainment, bodhisattvas rely on and dwell in the perfection of wisdom, the mind without obscuration and without fear.

Having completely passed beyond error, they reach the endpoint of Nirvāṇa. All the Buddhas who dwell in the three times also manifestly completely awakened to unsurpassable perfect complete enlightenment in reliance upon the perfection of wisdom. Therefore the mantra of the perfection of wisdom, the mantra of great knowledge, the unsurpassed mantra, the mantra equal to the unequaled, the mantra that thoroughly pacifies all suffering should be known as the truth since it is not false. The mantra of the perfection of wisdom is declared. Tadyatha Gate Gate Pāragate Pārasamgate Bodhi Svāhā.

Śāriputra and the Bodhisattva and mahasattva should train in the profound perfection of wisdom like that. Then the Bhagawan arose from that concentration and commended the Bodhisattva, mahasattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara, saying, well said, well said, Son of the lineage. It is like that. It is like that. One should practice the profound perfection of wisdom just as you have indicated even the Tathagatas rejoice the Bhagavan having thus spoken the Venerable Śāriputra, the Bodhisattva Mahāsattva Avalokiteśvara, those surrounding their entirety along with the worlds of gods, humans, the asuras, and gandharvas, were rejoiced and highly praised what had been spoken by the Bhagavan. If you’d like to stand and stretch for a moment, then we’ll sit.

I thought we’d practice as we normally do practicing mindfulness, so using the breath as our main object of training and intention. Know, mindfulness is always asking the question, what am I experiencing in the present moment? Mindfulness is the one way that we can always come back to the present moment. And then we step out of our stories, imaginations about the future, remembrance about the past, and dwell within our present experience. And one way we train with that is simply by focusing our attention again and again on the breath.

The breath is always in the present moment. We can use two techniques to help us in this practice. In terms of counting, we can count the breaths, breathing in, breathing out, counting one mentally. In out two, in out three, in out four, in out five. Having gotten to five, you can come back down to one, go one through six, one through seven, one through eight, one through one through ten.

And if your mind becomes distracted and you lose what number you’re on, can simply begin that particular sequence of counting again. And another useful technique is naming. And what naming does, it clarifies what our mind is actually involved in in the present moment. Sometimes there is some kind of confusion, sometimes it’s not clear to ourselves. We name what it is that we’re actually experiencing.

For example, breathing in. We know that we’re breathing in. This is our experience. We can name that experience simply noting or giving it a name, in. We could call it whatever, but in it’s just a shorthand notation.

Breathing out, experiencing the out breath, we know that we’re breathing out, and we simply give it a name, that experience, just simply to clarify what our mind is involved in. It aims the mind out. So now we have a pattern of counting and naming. In out one, in out two, in out three. In the course of our practice, your mind is going to be distracted.

Your mind is going to wander. That’s what minds do. It might be external object like sounds or the sound of the air conditioner or a car going down Port Rush Road. It might be internal object, it may be the body in terms of some feeling in the body, some sensation, or it might be a mental object such as thoughts. The moment you become aware that your mind is wandered, distracted, then simply note whatever distraction is.

If it’s hearing, simply note hearing. If it’s a thought, just note thinking and then bring your mind back to the breath. And I thought we would experiment in this process using the breath and then we can experiment using becoming mindful of the sounds about us. Rather than focusing upon the breath, focusing upon the external sounds or in fact internal sounds. Maybe your body is making all kinds of sounds.

Maybe you’re hungry. Your stomach is rumbling or something. Whatever sounds present themselves to you, noting sounds, hearing, hearing. And then we’re going to change again the focus of our attention to the mind itself. And this more than not presents itself in terms of thoughts, images, pictures.

So whether we’re you know, it’s not important that the content of the thought, we’re simply concerned with the process, with thinking. You know, rather than being caught up in the content, we’re simply naming what the experience is. It’s only a thought. Whether it’s a good thought or a bad thought, whether it’s a holy thought or a rather mundane thought that’s beside the point. It’s only a thought.

And simply noting, thinking, that’s what I’m actually experiencing. I’m experiencing a thought and noting, thinking. And this can become a useful life skill rather than being caught in the stories involved in the content, we can simply note thinking. Can make shorthand notations, story. We’re going to know certain patterns of stories, certain reoccurring thoughts, patterns of thinking which occur again and again.

We can give those special names as you learn about yourself. It can be useful in short circuiting the process of not getting lost in these stories. You know, we think about something more than twice, we’re probably simply lost in a recurring pattern of thought. It probably has nothing to do with the actual planning or working with our intellect rational thinking. It’s simply a pattern of thought that we’re attached to in some way.

We can be attached even to very painful thoughts. It’s interesting, that seems to be the case. It’s a way that we reinforce our identity. We can do that in terms of pain or pleasure or fantasies or stories that we tell ourselves. But they all make us feel a little solid, a little more concrete.

This I, this self of who in fact we conceive of ourselves, hold ourselves to be. So it’s useful in developing this life skill simply to be able to note thinking or story. And I have my own little notations, but you can develop your own. It’s for now calling them thoughts rather than being lost and caught up in the content. Simply naming what we’re actually experiencing is only a thought.

Whatever the content may be is simply a thought. Okay? So this I think is quite useful training in practice of mindfulness and staying within the moment, the present moment. So taking a comfortable firm posture. We begin with simply getting in touch and relaxing the body.

So starting at the crown of the head, the scalp, bringing awareness to these areas and relaxing, feeling the wrinkle of the forehead beginning to smooth out. The pressure in and around the eye eyes diminishing. The muscles of the face softening, relaxing. The jaws relaxed. And bring your awareness to the back of your neck.

And perhaps gently turn your head to each side a few times. Very gently loosening, stretching the muscles of the back of the neck. And bring your head bring your awareness to your shoulders and upper back and perhaps rotating your shoulders a few times. Lifting them up towards your ears and just letting them drop comfortably to the sides and as they drop feeling some weight moving down and through your body into the ground, like some burden has just been lifted from your back, was unknowingly perhaps there, but now it’s no longer there, a certain lightness. And bringing awareness all the way down to your hands.

Your hands are soft and loose. Relaxing your lower arms. And your upper arms. Chest is at ease. Relaxing throughout the heart area, the center of your chest.

And the lungs, and the central region of the back, Stomach. Releasing the tension that we oftentimes hold in our stomach muscles, just allowing your belly to go soft and throughout the consciously relax your lower back muscle. And your buttocks. Your upper legs and thighs. Lower legs.

And finally, feet. Soft, loose. And bring your awareness to the entirety of your body and just roughly scanning through the body. As you do so, notice any tightnesses, any tensions within the body, any areas of discomfort. Focusing upon those particular areas and breathing in and down into any tightness that you may feel, and breathing out from the tightness upward and out.

As you breathe out from the tightness, imagine or simply feel the tightness loosen, breathing in and down, the tension, breathing out from the tension, imagining, feeling the tension diminish. If there’s some area of discomfort, don’t avoid it, resist it, struggle against it. Just breathe in and down to that area of discomfort surrounding it with a kind, caring acceptance, the breath of kind ness, just like a mother cradling her her child. Breathing out from that area of discomfort, opening, softening. Just allowing that area of discomfort to be without any resistance, without any struggle.

Breathing into the tension, the tightness, the discomfort, and breathing out from those areas. The body becoming relaxed, at ease. You can imagine a sense of physical well-being pervading your body, a sense of physical pleasure pervading the entirety of your body. It’s a nice place to be in the body. Sometimes we forget.

We get lost in our heads and forget the body. So just for this present moment, there’s nothing that needs to be done, nowhere to go, no one to please. Just take a break. Just be with your body. Just as simple as that.

Just stay in touch in a relaxed, easy manner with your body. As simple as just that, just be with your body. Stay with your body. And we’ll practice the simple breath exercise, breathing in comfortably normally. When you exhale, extending exhalation.

Just gently forcing all the air out of the lungs. Again, breathing in comfortably normally. Again, extending the exhalation. And then bring your mind to the breath. Stay easy, gentle in and out flow of the natural breath, wherever the sensation associated with the natural breath is most clear and obvious.

You might want to try using the techniques of counting the breaths and noting, naming your present Bring your mind back to the breath. Now we’re going to refocus our attention to the body and simply become aware of the various sensations, the physical sensations of the body. And you can continue to name them, just giving them a name of sensing or feeling. Might be pressure. It might be a throbbing, tingling, itching.

If your mind wanders, then the moment you become aware that your mind is wandering, for example, to thinking, just note thinking and come back to the sensations of the body. So without choosing any particular sensation, just becoming aware of the entirety of the body and whatever sensations present themselves, whatever dominates. Becoming aware of that, the sensations of the body. Just naming sensation, feeling, Staying with the sensations of the body, the physical sensations. Pay ing attention, naming the physical sensations.

Now, again, I’m going to shift the focus of our attention this time to sounds. You can simply name hearing, hearing. If your mind is distracted to something other than sounds. For example, thinking, just note name that thinking and come back to sounds. Sounds outside of ourselves, sounds internal to ourselves.

Focusing, paying attention to sound. Staying with the sound, focusing, paying attention to sound. And again, we’re going to shift our attention, focusing this time on the objects of mental consciousness. Thoughts, pictures, images. We’re just going to call these thinking.

You can call them picturing, imagining, thinking. It’s very useful to name the thought. Otherwise, you get caught up in it. So focusing upon the objects of the mental consciousness, the thoughts, the pictures, images, and naming them, watching closely the objects of the mental consciousness as they arise. You have to stay aware to pay careful attention.

Just naming your experience, thinking, thinking. Stay aware. Stay awake. Just watching. And now as an experiment, we’re simply going to allow the mind to become involved in any object that it tends toward, whatever is most predominant in the field of awareness.

But we want to maintain awareness, so just naming whatever the experience it is. If it goes to a sound, hearing, if it goes to a thought, thinking, it goes to a body, physical sensation, sensing, feeling, simply practicing choiceless awareness, allowing the mind to become involved in any object that it naturally tends toward without directing it, but being aware, maintaining a perspective, and naming your present experience, whatever it might be. See you can stay aware. Shifting, jumping from various objects. Just be aware of whatever object the mind comes involved in.

And then bring your mind back to the breath. And then get in touch with your body, perhaps the pressure of your buttocks on the chair, on the cushion, your feet the floor. Just some sensation feeling within the body. And then you become aware of the sounds about you. Slowly become aware of your surroundings.

So we’re going through a method of analysis and then coming to try and understand develop the wisdom understanding, emptiness as it’s being presented by the highest school within the various tenet systems of Buddhism called the Consequentialist Middle Way school, trying to develop the wisdom which understands the emptiness of inherent existence, and there’s lots of different terms for this. Independent existence, true existence, objective existence, existence from its own side, self defining existence. And maybe there’s about nineteen different synonyms. But, anyway, they’re all trying to get at the same thing. But somehow, that the notion that phenomena we are intimately involved in the bringing forth our lived experience in terms of what it is that we come to know.

That the appearance to the contrary, things are dependent upon our consciousness for their existence. They don’t exist apart from language and conceptual thought which makes use of language. Our thinking about them as such. You know, there’s no there’s there’s no underlying reality prior to our coming to know it. Nothing exists prior to our knowing of it.

There’s nothing which exists apart from this process. This is the reason that we do this is in order to overcome ignorance, which is a belief in that phenomena define themselves. They exist independent of of language. They exist in dependence upon the conceptual scheme, the context in which they arise. They exist from their own side objectively and so forth.

So these are this this wisdom, understanding that things are empty of that way of existing, that in fact, that way of existing or conceiving of that way of existing is is a a way of existing, and things are empty of that way of existing. And we’re using a method called the nine essentials as a means of analyzing it, come into you know, we’re undermining our common sense, our ordinary perception of the of the way we believe things to exist. And this requires a very concise analysis, a process of confronting ourselves that things can simply cannot exist the way they normally appear to ourselves. But in order to come to that understanding, we have to gain some feeling, a sense of, well, how do objects normally appear to ourselves? And then this this unquestioned acceptance of that things exist the way they appear to us, whether it’s the I, the self, or persons, or whether it’s the external phenomena around us, tables and buildings and so forth.

They all you know, we’re not talking about whether they exist, but the manner of their existence, how they appear to exist as if they exist independent independent of consciousness, independent of language, in dependence upon conceiving them for what they are. They all appear to exist independent of that process. But in fact, we what we’re trying to understand is appearances to the contrary, they don’t exist that way. The method of analysis that we’re making use of is called the nine essentials. And we’ve we’ve talked about we began to talk about this first essential last week, ascertaining the object of negation.

Simply another word for negation is refutation. The object which we’re trying to refute. What is the object we’re trying to refute? It is the solid concrete appearance of things, existing independent of mind. So the object of negation or refutation is an independently existent table, independent existent world out there, independent existent I self in here.

That is the object which we are seeking to refute. That it though it appears that way, and though we see normally see to that appearance, we’re trying to come to understand that, in fact, it would be absurd for an object to actually exist that way. So we’re we’re we’re taking this world of taking for granted truths and beginning to call them into question, these appearances. So the most difficult part is, in this whole process, is this very first point, gaining a sense of feeling of the way things are appearing to ourselves. It is so we have never it is objects have never appeared to us in any other way.

It’s we’ve we’ve never it’s like it’s taken for granted. It’s like a a fish trying to get a sense of what water is like. It so permeates their experience. They cannot they cannot begin to even imagine what would be an alternative to that mode of appearance. That’s why emptiness is so difficult for us to get a a sense of because because it’s opposite, you know, independent existence or inherent existence so permeates the perceptual process that we cannot it’s hard for us to even imagine or grasp some alternative or what it is within our experience which is in fact, fact, You know, when when I look at things, when I look at that glass or I look at this table, and this occurs to all the five physical senses as well as the mental sense consciousness.

There is an element there is a fault element within that appearance. You know? So we’re not calling into question the fact of existence that, you know, that this glass is made of, you know, this table is made of wood or it’s a a rectangular wooden it’s a wooden rectangle with four legs and so forth. It’s brown in color, and it’s shaped in such and such a way. That, you know, that’s our eye consciousness can give us valid information about.

But within that appearance, there’s also an aspect of the way that that table is existing independent of the perceptual process. Within that appearance, there is an aspect of of that appearance in which the table exists cut off and at a distance. It’s over there. I’m an independent I’m an independent observer, and that’s it is if that appearance is the table is casting its appearance toward myself as a passive observer. You know?

So we’re talking about the way the table is and exist for ourselves. We used the example last week. Remember, I think it’s a good example of the letter a. You know, how how the You know, just the letter a. It seems as if, you know, we we ask, well, what is that?

That’s the letter A, obviously. I mean, most even a six year old child would tell you that. What is that? That’s an A, but where does its identity come from? It it appears as if it’s coming from its own side.

It’s like broadcasting a message to us. I’m an A. You know, it’s determining its own identity. But if we were that’s the way it initially appears to ourselves, if we can recognize that fact. You know, when we search, you know, we we this is the left slanted line is not the a.

The right slanted line is not the a. The crossbar is not the a. The ink on the whiteboard is not the a. There’s the surface of the whiteboard is not the you know, there’s no way there’s no way there for that a to hide, that A-ness. You know, it’s just that there’s there’s no there’s no A-ness in there somewhere coming from its own side.

We we learned that we learned to identify this particular configuration of lines as a. We projected whatever A-ness on that upon this configuration of lines. It then appears, at a certain point, it then appears that that A-ness is coming from the side of the object, as if we are simply passive observers. We’re tuning into the message that this is saying, I’m an A. But this is an ongoing unconscious process that we become involved in.

We just we take in it. And this A, which exists, in fact, dependent upon our mind, is all that we can mean by an A. There’s no other A than that. The A which we have which we have labeled, which we have projected, which we have identified. This particular configuration of lines we call an A, and that’s all an A is.

It functions. It functions in words. We can write words using that letter A. We can use it as a as a grade, you know, a b c d e a b c d f. So it functions, but there’s no but it is simply that is what an a is.

There’s nothing more than an a. We we also use the example, I think it’s a good example, of a five dollar note. You know, a note is simply it has it appears to have its own reality. But when we but when we look at it, when we begin to analyze it, we understand it has no intrinsic value in and of itself. You know, it’s just a printed piece of paper with this, you know, various configurations, numbers, and whatnot, and which we is a convention.

And that the the the worth of that piece of paper is all the time shifting. You know, the the currency currency market, you know, is every day this the value of this piece of paper, what it’s worth changes. So it’s simply an agreed upon convention. Within Australia. We we can we can make use of this.

We can go into a local supermarket, and if I give you that piece of paper, you’ll give me some milk and you’ll give me some eggs and so forth. We’ve we’ve come up with this bartering system, this way of trading pieces of paper for these goods and services that we want. And it works. But but there there’s nothing intrinsically worth about that paper. You know, I think at the end of World War two, you know, people had barrel fulls of German German Deutschmarks, and they couldn’t buy a loaf of bread with them.

But they had wheelbarrows full piled up, and they were just pieces they became nothing but paper. They they they didn’t the the conventional worth was completely gone. So determine what things are through language, through conception, and so forth. Things do not define themselves. We define them.

But we we, at some point, and this is this was something which Piaget, the the Swiss psychologist, began to investigate, that we learn these names. We learn we we project these names upon the objects. And at a certain point, we forget that we project them upon the object, and it is as if the object has has come to define itself. That it that the that the characteristic of the object is determined by the object itself, and it in itself is identity, it is instituted by itself. It is what it is from its own side.

That’s the way it then appears. And this is an unconscious ongoing process that we continually evolve in. And this this applies equally to not only the letter A and money, tables, and whatnot, but to beauty, to, you know, all of these objects which have a tremendous emotional association with them. And those objects which we appear attracted to us. We also imputing our sense of beauty on them, our emotional associations on them.

But we we forget it’s simply a project a projection from our own side, and we have oh, it is a it’s not apparent to us. And it but in fact, it appears that that the nature of that beautiful object being desirable and so forth is coming from the side of the object itself. And this out of this, this all induces these various dysfunctional patterns of mind that we call attachment and hatred and jealousy and so forth. This is what we’re trying to undermine. This belief that objects are self defining, that it’s not simply a social convention, which we’ve learned, which we’ve been acculturated into.

That phenomena do not define themselves. We as, you know, we as individuals, but also as a collectively define what they are. What is beautiful? What is ugly? What is an enemy?

What is a friend? So forth. That these aren’t self defining qualities, characteristics of objects in and of themselves. So what we’re doing is we have to identify first the way the object is appearing to us. You know?

This means that we have to identify this self defining appearance. You know? This a as if it I it has an A-ness in and of itself. It’s not a product this is the way the a normally appears to us before analysis. A common sense way of looking at things, That its nature, its identity is coming from the side of the object.

This is what we’re trying to ascertain when we talk about ascertaining the object negation, the object of negation. You can see that this is the most difficult part. We’re going to set up an analysis. We’re going to search for just this solid mode of appearance that objects normally possess. We’re going to search for it, but we have to have some very clear object to search for.

Otherwise, search will, you know, we will have we will not we will in fact not be searching for any object in fact, or we will have such a blurry, vague image that its nonfinding will have no force to undermine the belief in its existence. Nothing whatsoever of the object is coming from the side of the object. And we we use that when we talked about the the rope, the coil stripe rope in the grass. You know, in the in the dim light, you’re walking along the path. And along the path, there’s a there’s a coil stripe rope.

There appears to be a snake. You know, obviously, in this case, there is nothing from the side of the object which makes it a snake. Yeah. But likewise, there is nothing from the side of that coiled woven hemp, you know, coil woven hemp, which makes it a rope. The the equity are simply a product of the perceptual process of conceiving them as such.

Now, there’s a big difference between conceiving of a of a coil of woven hemp as a snake and a rope. Conceiving of that coil of woven hemp as a snake is a wrong consciousness. Conceiving of that coil of of a woven hemp as a rope is a correct consciousness. But aside from one one being a correct consciousness and one being a incorrect consciousness, they both involve the matter of labeling of an object and designating that object as as either a rope or a snake. There is nothing coming from the side of the object which determines that it’s the snake or that it’s the rope.

It is simply a matter of convention. We you know, that that piece of rope will not bite you. If it bit you, then then we would have to say that that was a that’s labeling as a snake was a correct labeling, that it was a is a valid cognition. And conceiving as a rope was invalid. So isn’t it, you know, it is in terms of does does the object function the way in which we’re labeling it?

If it does, that’s a valid labeling process. That’s a valid conception. If it doesn’t, it’s invalid. It’s a wrong conception. Nothing more than that.

So, you know, when we talk about things that are merely labeled by conception, merely labeled by conception, the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school accepts that there is a world external to mind. There is a world out there. Yeah. However, that this external world is utterly dependent upon consciousness. You know, for example, when when a when a god when a a hungry ghost when a god, a human, a hungry ghost, and a hell being look at a look at a glass of liquid, a god will see it as nectar.

A human will see it as water. Hungry ghosts will see it as pus and blood. A hell being will see it as molten iron. So each being will correctly perceive the fluid according to the constituents of their respective sense and mental faculties, according to, you know, the context of which their perceptual process is operating. We cannot talk about a reality of a glass apart from a correct perspective of these various perceivers.

And then we can say, Well, what is really? It’s nothing really in its own side. It finds nothing. To a hell being, it’s molten lead. To a hungry ghost, it’s pus and blood.

To a human, it’s water. To a god, it’s nectar. What it from its own side? There is nothing existing from its own side. So according to and these are very radically different perceptions, aren’t they?

Of the same, seemingly objective object. But they’re all correct consciousnesses. You know, we but we in in our society, you know, in our cultures, we have very radically different perceptions of what beauty is and so forth. And each of them is is valid within the context of of their social conventions. This is beauty.

This is ugliness and so forth. We can’t say that, you know, what it is exists from the side of the object because nothing exists from the side of the object. So the opposite in meaning is so we’re talking about nominal existence. What is the what is the opposite of independent existence? Dependent existence.

What is the opposite of inherent existence or diff is nominal existence or or imputed existence? Existence. These, you know, trying to the objects do not define themselves. We define them. It is imputing mind which perceives them.

We come to recognize the objects by you know, there’s an appearance to the mind, like a coil of woven hemp that stimulates our mind. And it causes us to a conception to arise. Rope. With respect to that, it could, according to certain circumstances, cause perception to remind snake, but that would be a wrong consciousness. There but nonetheless, it could act as a stimulus for us to think of of snake.

This water could, if we were a hell being, act as a stimulus for us to think of a molten iron, conceive it as molten iron. It could act as a stimulus, you know, same glass of liquid could act as a stimulus for if we were a hungry ghost for us to think of it as to see it as pus and blood, to conceive it as pus and blood. It would be pus and blood within that. You know, it could act as act as stimulus for us to conceive it as water. It could act as a stimulus to conceive it as nectar.

You know? So now what we’re what we’re doing is so we’re trying to get a sense of ascertaining the object negation. What an object the way the objects are appearing to us at all times to exist as if they were independent of this conceptual process, independent of language, and so forth, this of labeling. And we’re using we’re gonna use first, we’re going to learn this format in terms of a very simple object, a car. And then once once we simply know that, you know, how to make use of this format, this of these nine essentials, then we’ll apply it to the person, the eye.

Yeah. The eye is a little more complicated. We’re gonna use just simply as a means of training in the use of these essentials. Use a simple object such as a car. But, you know, we want to know how a car appears to us.

A car appears as a whole existing in its own right, independent of of the perceptual process. You know, the opposite of this way of existing is nominal or imputed existence. You know, the fact that the car depends for its existence upon our conceiving it as a car. Without being imputed by language and conceptualities, there would be no such thing as car. Car would not exist.

But the car appears to exist as if it defines itself. It it it it defines what it is. It it appears as if it does not depend on on to define what it is, to designate what it is. There is a sense of a real car established under its own power, from its own side, you know, which we with regardless of our thinking about it as a car, regardless of our labeling as a car, using the term car, still a car would exist when we look for it. The car is that car that exists exist independent of the perceptual process of our conceiving of it as such as the term car.

Exist apart from all of that is the object of negation. That’s what we’re going to search for, that very car. Not car in general, but the car as it’s appearing to it more as it’s appearing to our our perception. A car that a table table that exists independent of of of labeling, of language, a car that that appears to exist independent of labeling, of language, that it is a car table exists from its own side, a car that exists from its own side. That’s the car that we’re going to that’s the which is the object of negation.

That’s what we have to ascertain. Okay. Okay. So what do you what do you what does that mean for you guys? Any questions?

We have a discussion around that? It’s the most difficult point. And maybe, you know, just like that a. You can think of that a or or a dollar bill or a five dollar bill note. Any thoughts around that?

Questions around that? I was first surprised when you said that ascertaining the pervasion was the hardest part. No. Ascertaining the object of negation. Yeah.

The first one. That’s the hardest part? Yeah. Yeah. I was surprised when you said that.

The rest is a piece of See, it seems so easy. A car is a car. And then you go from there. And then you do the sevenfold reasoning. Yeah.

So the rest is a piece of cake. The rest is quite simple. It’s getting a sense. I mean, when we’re using a car, sometimes for some people, like the I, the self, when when we get upset emotionally. The I always appears to us it appears to exist independent of of our thinking of it as I.

It appears to exist independent of its parts, independent of causes and conditions. A car appears in the appears to exist independent of our thinking of as a car, independent of its parts, independent of cause and conditions. This is this table does. So sometimes when we when we get upset, this appearance becomes more and more obvious to ourselves. And when you say, I I hate you.

I can’t stand you. There seems to be an I which is self instituting, which which is a solid concrete entity within our being, at the core of our being, which doesn’t depend upon body and mind, which doesn’t depend upon cause and conditions, you know, which doesn’t depend upon our thinking of it, giving a name I or self. There’s something which do which is who we are, and we identify with that I as being, in fact, who we are. And this holds equally true, but with car. There is something there which is not dependent upon cause and condition, which is not dependent upon its parts, which not that is not dependent upon our conceiving of a car, just like in with the letter a.

There seems to be something there which which exists independent of the cause and conditions, independent of its parts, independent of our conceiving it as an a, our our identifying this as an a, of having learned that this is an a. It is an a by by way of its own nature. And it presents itself to us. And we simply, as passive observers, think, oh, there is an a. It’s telling us what it is.

I’m an a. I’m a car. I’m an eye. I’m a cell. Any thoughts around that?

Is that in the consequential middle way scope, it is so they they still discuss the the other former two points like the object exists in dependence upon its parts and in dependence upon causes and conditions, or is that part sort of transcended by that last school and they just talk about the object arises and dependence on mind labeling it? No. Yeah. So there’s three ways of dependence. Three is when we talk about when it come to we’re gonna talk a little bit about dependent arising.

All phenomena arise all products arise in dependence upon cause and conditions. They depend upon their parts, dependent upon labeling process. Yeah. So they they would yeah. So that that would be very much a part of identifying the object of negation.

Oh. So the car exists not to depend on the I, the self, the car, and so forth. They all appear not to exist in dependence upon cause and conditions, upon their parts, and dependence upon the labeling process, upon conception and language. They they to exist independent of all that. I don’t know.

I haven’t you know, I wasn’t sure if the consequential middle school left those other two behind. And so Yeah. No. They they would say they they they agree with those Yeah. Those modes of dependence.

And they add this third mode of dependence Yeah. That is dependent upon conceptuality and language. So it’s it’s the most far reaching. But they accept those for the those for the first two. As as you were explaining nominal and refuted existence.

Imputed. Yeah. Yeah. Mhmm. I was yeah.

Imputed existence. I I was thinking my mind just went to a situation that I’m in fairly regularly, and it’s a particular person, and I have a particular response to that person and so do other people And it’s really following up that question about the car, like if we use a car to go through the steps of analysis, presumably everybody in this room has a shared agreement of what we mean when we say that word. So that seems fairly easy to go through. Not easy, but clear and probably a shared perception. Whereas if I think of this person and the various responses that seem to get triggered around, I don’t think it would be as clear to ascertain the object of the patient.

I think for example, I might call my difficulty with this person that I find this person arrogant. Somebody else might say find person bullying or whatever it could So ascertaining the object, a) when there’s not a necessarily shared convention of perception, and b) when the pattern of perception is abstract in some sense it’s not abstract because the reaction is similar but the qualities when you start talking about things like arrogance or bullying or whatever they’re quite abstract compared to a couple So I’m just wondering if when when it’s related to daily lived experience of dealing with somebody Yeah. And wanting to deal with them skillfully, very skillfully. Yeah. What the process of ascertaining the object negation.

Yeah. You know, if I’m saying if I’m thinking, yeah, right. A lot of this is coming from me. It doesn’t exist independently. Yeah.

That’s right. Yeah. You’ve got to think about even that concept of me. I’m I’m sort of getting that, but I’m not sure how you would clarify so that you don’t go blurry in your analysis, whether it’s so abstract. That’s right.

Some of what appears to us, I mean, the labels that we use can be very commonly shared. We all have a rather shared experience of this table. So that’s a rather widespread convention. But then it can be just a very narrow minority of people or, you know, the the what would you say? The convention the the collective which is making this kind of imputation can become smaller and smaller.

This is proof of God’s existence, whereas other people, scientists might say, Oh, that’s And then it comes all the way down to, You’re the only one. There’s a sign in the other room by Lama Zopa that A problem is merely labeled. Without the label problem, problems don’t exist. This guy is a bully. And the other person, I don’t know what you’re talking about.

I find him a quite pleasant fellow. So there’s something which stimulates in his appearance, what he says, what he does, which stimulates you to think with regard to him bully. The quality of being a bully, or the aspect of bullying, he seems to have bullying like qualities from his own side. But all of our ways of viewing, there’s always an effective element. There is you know, there’s lots of past memories.

And your child you know, what happened to you as a child? You know, there’s emotional elements which are brought up. That maybe just the way this person, you know, some peculiar physical characteristic, maybe it reminds you of your father unconsciously. And you didn’t you had these feelings, certain feelings about your father, which you then go on to impute on this person. Maybe just the way have a little physical care habit of doing something, which nobody else would pick up at all.

But you notice it and that stimulates you to think with regard to them. You know, do do these all these emotional associations memories and feelings and so forth to to, you know, to label them in a very peculiar way according to your your your particular predispositions which are unshared with anybody else. Some nobody else would, you know, know, they’re, you know, when you that’s what they call it in psychoanalysis, transference, you know, or yeah. So maybe you had problems with maybe you thought you’re, you know, you’re probably with your father, and this guy has certain, you know, unrecognized characters that you were that you aren’t aware of. But nonetheless, you’re picking up, and that stimulates you to think with regard to them, bully or whatever.

So it’s very so there’s something that’s stimulating you to think with respect to this person bully bully. But the object of negation is that that this person that is this quality of being a bully has nothing to do with you thinking them as such. That’s their very nature. And you’re surprised that other people don’t recognize this about them. Where in fact it might be just an idiosyncrasy of yours.

That’s, you know, very something traumatic in your childhood or something. I’m I’m I’m just telling a story about scenario. You know? So it could be just very peculiar to you. It could be very broadly shared.

So something is stimulating you, something appears. When a wooden rectangle with four legs appears to us. That stimulates most people in our society, in our culture, to think table with regard to that. So we have we we have the shared experience of this at this object as a table. Table.

With regard to it when sometimes when it comes down to a very, you know, specific peculiar ways of relating, no one else might think of this, see this, you know, be labeling. You know, it it’s still you know, they’re not paying attention due to, you know, due to a lack of predispositions to a particular physical characteristic, which which is you associate with some childhood memory and so forth, just making up something, and you label that. Without even being aware of it, you’re labeling this in terms of how you felt toward your father or somebody who bullied you when you were little or something because they have the shared characteristic. And that’s enough to stimulate you to think that toward them, and therefore, you label them. And but but but it doesn’t but the object of negation is that you that that quality of being a bully or whatever it is not is in in is it dependent upon you thinking them as such?

It’s it’s it’s in their very nature. And so, you know So ascertaining the object of negation in that example would be clarifying what it is, e. G, bully. Yeah. And then you would apply.

If you wanted to be more skilful and get to that point of recognising, in fact, that it is a lot to do with all sorts of other imputations and so on, this object in the would be going beyond just reactions and trying to define what it is that you are imputing. Forget that you’re imputing. Forget that you ever learned that. But how, you know, how in what way in what way does that that quality of being a bully in what in what way is is it appearing as if it were in the nature of yeah. Seeing how him being a bully is appearing as if it were his very nature.

What is you know, that that that is being a bully is is is is an objective fact about him, that there’s there’s a bullishness about him, that, you know, that that this is in his very nature. It’s an inherent quality about him. He he he is, by his own nature, a bully. And having getting a sense of getting the not not of the quality of being a bully, but a sense of be of this quality existing from its own side. And this is the way the object this is the way that he’s appearing to you.

As if as if this quality didn’t have anything to do with you. It was in in the very nature of him. He he was a bully. You know, you big oof, you big bully. It was like something oozing out of his skin, some kind of, you know, bullishness.

And you were just you were just from your side, you were just you were just aware of that fact, that he’s a bully. You were just like a mirror becoming aware that you’re identifying, hey. You’re a bully, aren’t you? I don’t know. Does that make any sense?

It does. Absolutely. You’re just identifying something. You’re discovering he’s a bully. You’re not creating it being a bully.

I’m glad I discovered that about you before we got married. You know? Yeah. It’s something that you’d come it’s kind of overwhelmed you. It’s come from its own side, and you’ve come to know it.

You’re just an innocent victim here, a passive mirror, and you’re just reflecting what’s already there. He’s a bully. That’s the way we relate with him. That’s the way would go on to relate. We would relate on that basis, that kind of appearance, that he has this nature from his own side.

And given that, these kinds of my reactions are justified. When in fact, it may be just this some physical quirk. I mean, it’s possible. I don’t know. I’m just making up this possible scenario that you associate with some bully in your childhood, and he just and unconsciously shares that physical it might be just a a twitch of the cheek.

And and you don’t even know why, you know, you you aren’t even aware that that you’re labeling him as such. And then we get intuitions, don’t we? Sometimes what we call what we call intuitions. Sometimes different types of intuitions, I think. But some of it is unconscious labeling.

Know, when people do things, we don’t we don’t know quite why don’t he’s not quite trust worthy. We don’t quite know why. Anyway, we’re picking up a lot of stuff and some of these labels are valid and some of them aren’t. By validating, it just means, I don’t know, that he could function as a bully. Then then maybe it’s valid.

I don’t know. This so it’s this is why it’s hard. I I find it, you know, just we have to actually play with this idea. Yeah. Does does that make any sense?

What? Sense that I I can’t I can’t put it in any other words. Yeah. It is. It will show that I might be understanding.

What what what? I can’t. Yeah. I think I’m understanding what you’re saying, but I can’t put it into words that might So this has, I mean, all phenomena, bully, beauty, enemy, friend. These are quite I mean, these these had a lot of emotional association, but so it’s it’s more probably more useful to talk about than tables and chairs and so forth.

But we work with tables and chairs because they don’t they don’t have they’re not maybe as complicated. But but in practice, this is where it applies. The in in real, we, you know, maybe we don’t fall prey to if we’re aware of this, you know, that what part are we playing in the nature of our relationship with others? And due to all of these, you know, just to label somebody these days, to label somebody a Muslim can be very prominent problematic, can’t it? More so than ten years ago if you learn that somebody’s a Muslim.

Now you, you know, you you know, unconsciously might bring in certain associations with terrorism and all that, which we which we might not even be aware of. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It’s quite or just people’s names.

Right? There was a they did a survey of people’s names and that they had, you know, people who applied online for jobs. And they were knocked back quite often simply by the name because these names were associated with some of them were Middle Eastern names, some of them were Jewish names and so forth. So these people were, you know, given all the given, you know, their their CV were equal to others. But because of their names, they were they weren’t asked to come in for an interview.

They they it’s anyway. So they lay there was this, you know, there is this somebody was labeling, you know, that this person’s a problem because simply because of of their name and what’s with the associations around that name. Nothing more than that. Not their CV or whatever. Anyway, this happens a lot throughout our society, and we’re doing it all the time.

The part that our our memory and our predispositions or associations play in how we conceive of things and people. And whereas a lot of it is unconscious. Yeah. But it’s ongoing nonetheless. The object of negation.

So it’s the most difficult. Most difficult. What does how does that bully look from his own? What is it, you know, that that quality the quality of being a bully. And and how does that how does that appear to be that this person is diff is has that nature is of that very nature.

Nature of being a bully, the nature of being a terrorist, the nature of being a terrorist, the nature of being beauty from its own side, the nature of being an enemy from its own side, the nature of being a friend from its own side. You know, if somebody says a nice something nice to us, we think friend toward them. But then, you know, something appears to us, and we think this, and they become a friend. But the friend but the friend exists simply, but there seems to be something very pleasant, attractive, agreeable from the very side of the object itself. If somebody says something nasty to us, we we label them as enemy.

It seems, you know but and then in consequence, there seems to be some something coming from the very side of a disagreeable quality coming from the very side of the person. They’re oozing some kind of repulsiveness. And then this is something in the dark. We don’t want them nearest. Some adds it.

So it’s something that you really have to kind of play with. Is that I don’t know. Make any sense? This this this oh, wait a second. Yeah.

I guess it’s important. I guess we could what would what would be an example? Let’s go let’s let’s go around. An example of an object existing an an object of negation. Oh, okay.

Well, the the self would be a fairly quick Alright? Yeah. The fixed, solid, inherently existing self with its own characteristics, inherently existing characteristics and Okay. Sort of thing. I think in a funny one, like, the way you go on to perceive yourself or, you know, acting a certain way on the basis of who which people you’re around, that sort of thing.

But How is that? Like, you know, you sort of you always play the role and based on who you kind of on how you interpret the people environment that you’re in. You know what mean? You know, like, you you’re around old people, and so, you know, you play a certain role. And then you’re around, you know, your friends from school, you know, guys who who drink a lot or whatever, and you play a certain role.

That’s funny. So wouldn’t that tend to exemplify the fact that you don’t have a fixed identity? I don’t know. Think so. It was just amusing, kind of, almost.

But yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So you have different aspects of yourself which come out in different contexts. Yeah.

Which sort of shows how hollow it all is. Yeah. Yeah. But yeah. No.

But I’m. And when you have the strong emotions, you know, you feel so so fixed, and you’ve got all these really strong, deeply held views and all that. But, you know Yeah. It seemed to could seemed to be in there somewhere. Yeah.

Yeah. Any example? I’ll actually talk about this. So Yeah. So what were what were you giving examples of?

Something an object of negation. But this is like I think as Dan was mentioning, like, I think Dan mentioned different personality types and there’s I believe but this is back. I used to work at the Ramsay bar years before. A few years from accident. And you see people go in there, and people are trying, basically, to try and pick up a partner, a boyfriend or girlfriend, or trying to, you know, get some loving.

And they should just lie through their teeth because they say, oh, I’m this. I’m this. I’ve got, you know, fancy clothes and and fancy this and fancy that. I’m so cool. I’m so I’m so wealthy on this and that.

Yeah. And so if you you you lying, I’m bugger. Yeah. You’re you’re trying to put off this thing that I’m I’m this person yet. You really in fact, you’re this you’re you’re a real bad person yet.

You’re trying to show, look how good I am. I’m so nice. I’m so care. I’m so compassionate. Yeah.

I come and talk to me. I’m nice. And this is a lot of things you were trying to say, you know, you’ve just set your goal. So that’s just really Yeah. Yeah.

Think the problem with labeling good and bad qualities like bullying or goodness come back to the present moment because that is just a behavior of the present moment, and we can take it into the future and think that somebody always behaves like that. That it’s unchanging and undisable. Yeah. All of those things are changing, perceived, labeled good and bad quality. Yeah.

So we might, for some reason, grab onto something and take it into the future and make it a person. That’s their inherent, yeah. That’s a good point. So we take it to be an inherent identity, we don’t distinguish between behavior and the person themselves. That’s a very good point.

I think the majority of Muslims, of, folks who are bullies, people who themselves act themselves, either they bully themselves, get their physical problems, then they sort of they think about putting society Yeah. For what it’s respectable of them. Yeah. Well, basically, they’re using their also, reach on sort of of of because I’m because I feel a lot about myself, and you’re you’re sort of you think I think that you’re better than me. Yeah.

I’ll knock you down. I’ll still say, look, Dan, you’re you’re a bad person. You You you know, this and that. I could bang. No.

Sorry about that. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Could bang, But I just like, no, Dan, you you know, you always wear cool shirts.

Don’t like He does. And, like, basically, I could be saying that, like, no. I hate Dan because he wears short sleeved shirts all the time. Why? It’s a hot it’s a cold night.

Why is he wearing a short sleeved shirt? Yeah. Yeah. And there’s a lot of people like a lot of people do that. Just basically trying to sort of I’ll I’ll I’ll because I don’t feel good about myself.

Is your your sort of the social you’re sort of, you know, the the leader of the group. Yeah. I’ll cut I’ll cut stuff off you so I can put myself up on your level. Yeah. And so I feel better about ourselves because I’ll put you down, and everyone’s like, are you down?

Yeah. So, yeah, it’s my psychology as a group dynamics. Object negation? Well, I can say anything. Yeah.

If you like any word, becomes out of mouth. It’s funny. So that’s how does that appear to be an object negation for you? How does it appear to you in terms of manner of its existence? It’s a bottle with water in it.

So, I mean, it is a bottle with water in it, isn’t it? But what what within that appearance is but but how does it appear in terms of the way it exists? Can I mean, I can as soon as I start describing it, I describe it in terms of its parts, in the collection of its parts? Yeah. So therefore, it’s not it’s not I’m not describing the object in the case.

I I I can’t. I can’t without already as soon as I describe it, I’m already refuting its inherent existence. How’s that? If I describe try to describe that as best I can. It’s it’s a bottle with water in it.

It’s plastic cylinder that has liquid inside it. Without a liquid, it’s not a a bottle of water. It’s just a bottle. But even even without water in it, you still call that a you still call that a bottle of water with the associations. Yeah.

It’s got pictures of mountains in it. It must be water. I can’t I I don’t I don’t know how to ascertain. Says it’s it’s not easy, is it? I mean, how is your bottle can you sense of how the bottle is appearing to you in the manner of its existing?

How does the bottle appear? Does it exist does it appear to exist dependent upon you conceiving it as bottle? Mhmm. It it it it it exists out there. I mean, you’re not you’re not involved in creating that bottle, aren’t you?

What do you any ideas of the object negation? Other than I was talking about with the bullying, the interaction between Yeah. That sense of I, which is Yeah. An object, conceptual object, and then other people’s behavior and how I might, as you said, at different times, modes and the interaction that goes on between those labels and trenching those views, those Yeah. The accumulation.

Yeah. But I smiled to myself during the meditation with the coil and the snake analogy because I was lying there and we were doing the thing about feeling, feeling bodily sensations, and I began to get this feeling of something running in my neck. And eventually I decided it was a spider, which is what got me going a little bit, even because of meditation. It wasn’t at all. It was a scratchy label on the back of the chair.

It was just a lovely sort of book. There’s a point where you label this and say, that’s it. That that’s the appearance of that sensation on the base of that, you labeled spider. Mhmm. And you reacted as if there were spiders.

I see. Perhaps. Yeah. So that was a process of labeling, that sensation. Your example was quite I was looking for something almost the opposite.

Some for example, it should be indivisible and unchanging. If it were if we were to find something which is indivisible and unchanging and perceived by all universally, then would it have inherent existence? I don’t know. I I don’t think I could come up with and I know this could easily very few that in a number of ways would be pain or suffering because I think all humans experience pain and suffering predisposed by all different things, but I would think that everyone would agree that the feeling of pain and suffering. I don’t know.

That’s a bit out there, but it’s just to my mind. Really That it is universal. And, you know, that’s it was just Do you think you think Yeah. Feels like crap. Whatever.

Although there’s some people that, you know, like, the s s and m So, you know, it appears, you know, when the thing you can experiment with is, I mean, you have a, you know, you experience some kind of pain in the body. If you’re willing to and it’s just this mass. And usually it’s something that we have aversion towards and we move away. We want to avoid. If you’re willing to actually go into it, you know, what are you actually labeling?

A particular sensation? As a particular dis when we say a disagreeable sensation, we label that as pain. And if you’re willing to go into the pain, then you come to a point where there’s simply sensation. So what we call pain, it doesn’t inherently exist either. It’s simply being labeled onto sensation.

Particular body’s you know, like when you I know when I’m doing yoga, you know, I can’t hold this any longer. You know, it’s just kind of unpleasant, uncomfortable feeling. But if we’re willing to well, is that in my arm? Is it in my where is that uncomfortable? And when I when I analyze it, I can’t find it.

Yeah. But if I stop and I’m just kind of relating unanalytically to this, it’s just this, oh, I gotta stop this position. I gotta break this position. Something like that. So it’s just these massive sensations which I, for some reason or another, I interpret as discomfort or pain.

The object of negation? Well, everything is an object of negation. And because it depends on our perception and the chair, chair. It’s it’s only a chair because I’ve learned it’s a chair and with the letter a, etcetera. Right.

Yeah. So the object of negation is is every object? Is that right? Can I say every object object of negation? Every object of not.

I don’t know if we could say that area. The way the way the way no. Object of negation does not exist. Object of negation does not exist. So we can’t yeah.

Okay. We’re talking about independent the existing tables, independent existing cars, or true or inherently existing cars, inherently existing tables, inherently existing eye, inherently existing bullies. These don’t exist. They appear to exist. So yeah.

So the the the chair is not an object of negation. The way that table the the table that appears to exist independently, right, inherently. The inherently existent car table, chair is an object of negation. Is the object of negation. The chair exists.

Yeah. An inherently existent chair does not exist. That’s the object of negation. Yeah. We we cannot negate an existing object.

The object that we’re seeking to negate, refute, does not exist. It cannot stand up to analysis. It appears. It’s just like the snake appears, but it doesn’t exist. Likewise, an an inherently existent chair, inherently existent bully, inherently existent eye, they appear.

But just like the snake, they don’t exist. That’s the this is just as the snake is an object of negation, conventionally, you know, inherently just the table and chairs and eyes and cars. They also are objects of negation. They don’t exist. So something is some element within the well, within within the way that this chair normally appears to us is false.

It’s hard to imagine, you know, just like this fish in water, it’s hard to imagine appearing any other way. But it does to a Buddha. It appears quite radically different. It doesn’t it doesn’t have the thick line drawn around it as if it were independent of the of its context, independent of, you know, of everything of all the cause and conditions which are staying sustaining it, which make it you know, everything exists within in in a interconnected lattice of crisscrossing causes and conditions, interdependency on the on causes and conditions of parts and on ourselves as observers. This, you know, is is we we we there’s this interconnected whole and we we break up this whole into isolated chunks.

So, you know, this is the way that we think about them. And they everything appears to us to exist, you know, as these tables over here, independent of the floor, independent of the building, independent of myself. We, you know, we isolated chunks. We break up ecology of this undifferentiated. It’s hard to imagine what it is, but anyway.

Is that the main reason why you can’t, like, create, like, karma, you know, once you achieve liberation. Like, there’s no self and other and no action. That’s what it’s Self and other exist, but the the way they exist is radically way they conventionally exist conventionally exist. They only exist as nominally, conventionally. That’s all they are.

Nothing more than that. So you don’t react to them in the same way. You don’t relate with them in the same way. And, yeah, self and other are just a way of speaking. They’re nothing more than that, but we take them to be, you know, that you’re you’re in the very nature of other.

But but unrelatedly other. But there’s just a way to speak you know, without without self, there’s no other. Without other, there’s no self. They they’re just ways of talking about the existing mutual dependence upon one another. So this was a radically different way of of viewing the world.

It’s because and because yeah. Something so I think it’s hard to even imagine that your your your your way that you your view of the world is truly transformed. You exist. I exist. Everything continue to exist, but the way they appear to exist is radically transformed.

Therefore, the way that we would deal with them is radically transformed. How are doing? Okay. I don’t yeah. I don’t yeah.

Anyway, we’ll we’ll go on. Kinda got stalled in a way in a way. But maybe maybe it was worth it. I guess I guess one of the one of the outcomes of this is that maybe we you know, very practically, you know, we don’t buy into the labels and that we are continually applying as much as we normally do. Maybe we’re willing to if we if we can have the mindfulness, maybe we can see what part we are playing in in the situation, how this person is appearing to us, you know, if we’re mindful enough, you know.

We we we are playing our part in it. It’s not to it’s not valid. You know, we can’t say that just because it’s but there’s a how much of it is effective in an element, how much is emotional, and how much of it is valid. It may be, you know, might be. But that way, would still be simply a convention.

It might be a convention of one. So we can dedicate the positive energy that we’ve created. Created. May all beings everywhere plagued by suffering of body and mind attain an ocean of happiness and joy by virtue of my merits. May no living creatures suffer, commit evil, or fall ill.

May no one be afraid or belittled with a mind weighed down by depression. May the blind see forms and deaf hear sounds. May those whose bodies are worn with toil be restored on finding repose. May the naked find clothing, the hungry find food. May the thirsty find water and delicious drink.

May the poor find wealth, those weak or sorrow find joy. May the forlorn find hope, constant happiness, and prosperity. May the prosperity. May the heavens rain a bountiful harvest. May all medicines be effective and wholesome prayers bear fruit.

May all who are sick and ill quickly be freed from their ailments. Whatever diseases there are in the world, may they never occur again. May the frightened cease to be afraid and those bound be freed. May the powerless find power and may people think of benefiting each other. For as long as space remains, for as long as sentient beings remain.

Until then, may I too remain to dispel the miseries of the world. Through these skillful actions, may I quickly become an awakened spiritual master and lead each and every living being to that awakened realm. May the supreme jewel of the awakened heart that has not arisen arise and grow, and may that which has arisen never diminish, but increase more and more. In the land circled by snow mountains, you are the source of all happiness and well-being. Please remain to the end of cyclic existence.

Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
hungry ghost preta (Skt); yi dag (Tib)
The hungry ghost realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence, exemplified by incredible insatiable hunger and thirst. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top