3 h 26 min · 14,198 words · 13 October 2008 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The question of whether the conceived self is identical to body and mind drives this three-and-a-half-hour session, as Ven Jampa Gendun works through the Third Essential of a four-part analytical method for realizing selflessness at the Hearer’s stage. He opens with a guided rejoicing meditation — reviewing positive actions across several recent time periods and extending that appreciation to friends, strangers, and difficult people as an antidote to jealousy — before demonstrating, through a rope-mistaken-for-snake analogy, why sameness between self and body-mind collapses: at least two selves would be required, the self would have to be material, and saying “my body” would be incoherent. Lively class debate tests each absurd consequence. The session closes by previewing the Fourth Essential: whether that conceived self can be found as something entirely separate from body and mind. For students following this ongoing Lamrim commentary series.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 24 3PA 2008 10 13.mp3
UUID: ed067630-43ef-492c-a02b-5d58f526a655
Teacher: Ven Jampa Gendun
Collection: Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Date: 2008-10-13
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 206.6 minutes
Words: ~14,198
How is everybody? Can can you hear me okay? Good. It’s it’s warm in here, isn’t it? Alright.
Maybe it’s okay? It’s heating. Yeah? But it’s heating. It’s heating.
Is it heating? Or is that air conditioning? It’s hard to I don’t know. It might be in heat mode. If I turn off the one, that’s what it’s like.
If it’s on yeah. For sure if it’s on heat. I don’t know. I’d like to begin by adjusting our motivation, bringing ourselves to the present moment and our our present predicament, who we are, who we are, how we are actually experiencing our life in terms of the quality of its feeling. And stepping outside of all our future planning and past remembrances and trying to bring ourselves to the present moment.
And determining that within the present moment, setting some kind of direction, getting back in touch with what are our priorities, what’s important to each of ourselves, what it is that we value. In the course of our busy lives we get out of touch, or more than not we’re continually getting out of touch, and we come late. It seems like it’s a constant necessity to keep reminding ourselves, What’s my real source of happiness? Fulfillment and satisfaction? Where is my bliss?
What is sacred to me? And getting ourselves back on track in ways of being and thinking that are going to help us to express that a bit more in our life, to find some kind of fulfillment in our life. Over and above our usual preoccupation with pleasure and pain and gain and loss, and trying to weave our way through that myriad of distractions and the ups and downs of our lives, and keeping some kind of constant orientation toward what it is that really, in the depth of our hearts, want out of our life. What is with meaning for ourselves? It’s quite difficult, isn’t it, to chart that kind of course for ourselves and keep ourselves on there.
Thinking about navigation, how we Keep us on course. Plotting a course. And I keep correcting. We seem to drift off course quite easily, quite readily. The currents take us in directions that perhaps aren’t in our And our final moments aren’t where we want to go, or are we simply too lazy to resist in some way or another?
So we start drifting in one way or another. We yield to circumstances and drift into the old habits one way or another. So this idea of going for refuge is simply getting back in touch. What’s important to each of ourselves, you know, getting back on course. So we call this this, I guess, where we’re headed, our compass is we call gewa, but how each of us defines that for ourselves at present is unique to each of ourselves.
What qualities, what ways of being we find most fulfilling and meaningful for ourselves. And how are you going to navigate that? How are going to get there? It’s not simply enough to wish it to be so. Have to do something in a positive fashion to bring that about.
And we implement the means that we call the dharma. And this occurs within social context, you know, the social forces which are operating upon us, influencing us for better or worse. Those which help us, which support the direction that we want our life to go, we call our spiritual community our Sangha. Ourselves is participating in that process, in this culture of growth, assisting one another in whatever ways we can. I think just together is doing a lot.
Advising, teaching, talking about encouraging. And trying to raise the level of our motivation again and again, and trying to perhaps continually re evaluate our vision of a successful life in the hopes that we can begin to include a greater widening circle of others in that definition of what the good life looks to ourselves like. I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings.
I go for refuge until I’m awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. May all sentient beings have happiness and the causes of happiness. May all sentient beings be free from suffering and the causes of suffering. May all sentient beings be inseparable from the joy that is without sorrow.
May all sentient beings abide in equanimity, free from attachment for some and aversion toward others. Thus did I hear at one time that Bhagavan was dwelling on Vulture Peak mountain in Rajagriha, together with a great community of monks and a great community of bodhisattvas. At that time the Bhagavan was absorbed in the concentration and the categories of phenomena called profound perception. Also at that time the bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara, looked upon the very practice of the profound perfection of wisdom and beheld those five aggregates also of empty, inherent nature. Then through the power of the Buddha, the Venerable Śāriputra said this to the venerable Śāriputra.
Śāriputra, any son of the lineage or daughter of the lineage who wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom should look at it like this, correctly and repeatedly beholding those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature. Form is empty. Emptiness is form. Emptiness is not other than form. Form is also not other than emptiness.
In the same way, feelings, discrimination, compositional factors, and consciousness are empty. Śāriputra, likewise, all phenomena are emptiness, without characteristic, unproduced, unceased, stainless, not without stain, not defiled, not fulfilled. Śāriputra, therefore, in emptiness, there is no form, no feeling, discrimination, no compositional factors, no consciousness, no eye, no ear, no nose, no tongue, no body, no mind, no visual forms, no sounds, no odors, no taste, no objects of touch, and no phenomena. There is no eye element and so on up to and including no mind element and no mental consciousness element. There is no ignorance, no extinction of ignorance and so on up to and including no aging and death and no extinction of aging and death.
Similarly, there is no suffering, origination, cessation, and path. There is no exalted wisdom, no attainment, and also non-attainment. Śāriputra, therefore, because there is no attainment, Bodhisattvas rely on and dwell on the perfection of wisdom, the mind without obscuration and without fear. Having completely passed beyond error, they reach the endpoint of nirvana. All the Buddhas who dwell in the three times also manifest and completely awakened to unsurpassable, perfect, complete enlightenment, a reliance on the perfection of wisdom.
Therefore, the mantra of the perfection of wisdom, the mantra of great knowledge, the unsurpassed mantra, the mantra equal to the unequal, the mantra that thoroughly pacifies all suffering and should be known as the truth, as it is not false. The mantra, the perfection of wisdom, is declared. Tayata Om gate gate paragate parasamgate bodhi svaha. Shariputa, the Bodhisattva, mahasattva should train in the profound perfection of wisdom like that. Then the Bhagawan arose from that concentration and commended the Bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara, saying, Well said, well said, son of the lineage.
It is like that. It is like that. One should rejoice in the profound perfection of wisdom, just as you have indicated. Even the Tathagatas rejoice. The Bhagavan, having thus spoken, the Venerable Śāriputra, the Bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara, those surrounding their entirety along with the worlds of gods, humans, asuras, and Gandharvas, were rejoiced and highly praised as spoken by Buddha.
Okay. I’d like to stand up and stretch or meditate. The analytic meditation that we’re going to do is we’ve done before. This is helping us to our reality is what we pay attention to. Activities and what we, in fact, do do, selectively choose to pay attention to those who somehow quite often reinforce our self identity by means of which we gain a sense of security.
Having some kind of unchanging, kind of permanent identity in which we can feel safe with, even though for most of us, in many ways, it may be a self defeating, self fulfilling prophecy in how we see ourselves. So, we have to actually, you know, what we pay attention to is more than not a product of our unconscious habitual choices. You know, we attend to what it is due to what we attend to, and what we attend to is due to our choice or intention. And this is very much a product of our habit, and most of these habits are unconscious. So the world about us and ourselves seem to continually be reconfirming our expectations about who we are and what we can expect out of our life.
But quite often, it’s simply a product of what we habitually pay attention to. And if we can begin to alter that and begin to constantly pay attention to other factors within our experience, within what we do do, then we can begin to alter our sense of who we are and perhaps develop a more productive self identity. And therefore, I think this will be a source of encouragement and inspiration for ourselves. We feel like we can do something. We develop a greater sense of self worth and self confidence.
Therefore, out of that we do achieve more, and we become our own source of inspiration. And this all starts with beginning to pay greater attention to what we do right in our lives. So this is just simply a matter of counting our blessings in some respects. So what we’re going to do in terms of our meditation, we’re simply going to pick various periods of our life, beginning with a period more than one month ago, and focus upon something that you feel you did right. It’s okay.
Maybe it’s okay to pat yourself on the back and feel good about yourself. There’s no, you know, there’s no injunction against feeling good about yourself. It would be a mistaken conception of what humility is, to think that you can’t rejoice in yourself, in what you do, in fact, and the qualities that you do, in fact, have. There’s what’s called the pride of a bodhisattva, in rejoicing in what they actually do and what they’re trying to achieve. So for us, we can simply begin with these different time periods more than one month ago, something that you feel good about, that you actually did.
Acknowledge it, go a little bit over the top, it’s okay. Really pat yourself on the back. That was a wonderful thing I did. That was intelligent. That was fantastic.
I’m glad I have that quality. And then we’ll simply going to change time periods. See if you actually feel good about yourself and what you did. We’ll change time periods to more than one week ago to one month ago, and again, reviewing. If you can’t find something, then that should tell you something about yourself.
That’s already some indication, some insight into it. We can. I’m not saying that you have to find it’s not a matter of having found a cure for cancer, you won the Nobel Prize last week or something like that. It doesn’t have to be over the top. I think the more you pay attention to, the more that you pay attention to, and in the sense that even it’s only seemingly insignificant.
For some people, getting out of bed in the morning is a triumph. I mean, that might sound hardly worth talking about to us, but to some people it’s not. So it’s only a matter of degree. Whatever it might be, even if something’s small, we have to build on that and develop the habit of paying attention to what is going right in our life, what is right about ourselves. It’s just developing that habit.
So sometimes it might require that we pay attention even to minor things, things that we normally overlook, we don’t acknowledge about ourselves and what we’ve done. Okay? So that’s what we’re going to do. Then we’ll work with different time periods, yesterday up to one week ago, something that you did today. And really congratulate yourself.
Feel good about yourself. That’s important. And do the same with others. Rejoicing is the antidote to jealousy. Jealousy is when we don’t feel so good about ourselves as a basis.
We’re preoccupied with ourselves and attached to I and mind. And moreover, we resent others who seem to have better or more, or have some kind of advantage that we don’t have. There’s mentality of poverty about ourselves, as if there’s not enough happiness to go around and they’re taking your share in some way, and you resent them for it. You’re jealous of them in some way. But if we can develop a mentality of richness, there’s enough happiness to go around.
Maybe it is probably the reality that not everybody on the planet can own a car. We probably don’t have the material resources. Everybody in China wanted to own a car. We probably can’t do it, or we don’t have that. But everybody in the planet can be happy.
That’s an inexhaustible resource because that comes from our mind. So we can become more generous and we can rejoice in others. Rejoice in ourselves, overcoming our sense of jealousy, and we’ve developed a sense of richness about ourselves, and taking joy in the happiness of others. So we’re also going to look at others, you know, friend, stranger, an enemy, and try to look at what they’re doing right, and begin to focus upon that. You know, our orientation can be one of seeing either the glass is half empty or half full.
You know, to some degree it’s a matter of choice. But most of our choosing isn’t done consciously. It’s habitual habit that we’ve gotten, we’ve fallen into. And we have to ask ourselves, are these habits working for ourselves or not? And if they’re not, then we begin to have to begin to interrupt them.
Okay. So taking a comfortable, firm posture. So a sense of stability and firmness in your posture, but also want a posture that you can hold comfortably for some time. Bringing a sense of dignity, purposefulness. We’ll begin with getting in touch and grounding ourselves and relaxing the body, starting at the crown of your head, the scalp, feeling the wrinkles in your brow beginning to smooth out.
The pressure in and around your eyes diminishing. The muscles of the face softening, relaxing. Your jaws relaxed. And bring your awareness to the back of your neck and perhaps gently turn your head to each side a few times. Gently stretching, loosen the muscles of the back of the neck.
Relaxing the muscles of the throat. And bring your awareness to your upper back and shoulders. Perhaps rotating your shoulders a few times. Lifting them towards your ears and just allowing them to drop comfortably to the side. Feeling some kind of burden that perhaps you’ve been carrying around on your back during the course of the day.
Moving down and through your body into the ground. Your weight’s been taken off your shoulder. Bring your awareness all the way down to your hands. Your hands are soft and loose. Relaxing your lower arms and your upper arms.
Your chest is at ease. Relaxing throughout the heart area, and the lungs, the central region of the back. Stomach. Releasing the tension that we hold in our stomach muscles, allowing your belly to go soft. Relaxing throughout the abdominal cavity.
Keeping your your back straight, your trunk erect, relax your lower back muscles. Consciously softening, relaxing that area where we hold a lot of tension. Your buttocks throughout your upper legs Lower legs. Finally, feet soft, loose. And bringing your awareness to your body in general.
And just roughly scanning through your body, noticing any tightnesses, any tensions which remain in the body. Any areas of discomfort? Focusing your attention on those particular areas and consciously relaxing, softening, breathing into the tension, breathing out, feeling the tension loosen, breathing into the tightness, feeling the tightness diminish, Breathing into the tension, the tightness. Feeling opening, softening. Breathing into the tension and tightness.
Breathing out from the tension and tightness. If there’s an area of discomfort, don’t avoid it or struggle against it. Just like a mother in a little child who’s hurting. Just breathe into that area surrounding it with a caring acceptance. Just cradle it with the kind acceptance of your awareness.
Breathing out to feel it soft and and open. It’s part of who you are at present. Just accepting, allowing that to be. Your body becoming growing comfortable, at ease. A feeling of physical well-being pervading every cell of your body, the entirety of your body.
It’s a nice place to be, comfortable, easy. Nowhere to go, nothing that needs to be thought of, nothing that needs to be done. There’s no one that you need to please, even yourself. Just give yourself a break. Just be your body.
Just for a few moments. Just rest in your body. Stay with your body. Nothing more than that. Keep coming back to your body.
And then we’ll practice the breath exercise. Just breathing in comfortably, normally. Breathing out, extending the exhalation, completely emptying your lungs, forcing all the air out of your lungs. Again, just allowing your lungs to fill up naturally, comfortably. Again, extending the exhalation, completely emptying the lungs.
And then bring your mind to the breath. Just the easy gentle in and out flow of the natural breath. If it’s helpful you can use the techniques of counting and noting. Bring your mind back to the breath. Sitting up When the mind wanders, is distracted, just gently, patiently, without any judgment, bring it back to the breath.
We focusing your attention again and again. Bring your mind back. I’m going to practice consciously cultivating a sense of rejoicing in ourselves first. So just begin by thinking back more than one month ago, something that you did or were or had, bringing that to mind, acknowledging it, and rejoicing in yourself, feeling good about yourself, feeling pleased about yourself, congratulating yourself. That was a wonderful thing I did.
That was very kind. That was very intelligent. That was very wise. That was very courageous. Whatever it might have been.
Feel good about it. Feel pleased for yourself. Yourself to feel that about yourself. We’re going to do the same, but simply change the time period. More than one week ago, but less than one month ago.
More than one week ago, but less than one month ago. Just reviewing what you’ve done, your activities, and so forth. It doesn’t have to major. It’s just fine. There is something.
There’s definitely something. Again, changing the time period yesterday up to one week ago. So beginning from yesterday up to one week ago. And then finally, something that you did today. And then we’re going to shift our attention to what others do, beginning with somebody that you like, a friend or somebody you’re close to recollecting recollecting something that they did that was really positive, beneficial, useful, courageous, generous, whatever.
Being glad for them. So stepping out of your own be happy for them, that they did whatever they did, that they have whatever they have. Rejoicing in their good fortune. I’m thinking of a a stranger, someone that you don’t have a particular relationship with. Maybe somebody television, heard on the news, or you just heard in one way or another, you you know of, that something good happened to them or they did something which was really worthwhile, and being glad for them.
And then finally, somebody you have some problems with. Thinking about some good quality they have or something that they did which was positive, useful, Admirable. And setting aside your own agenda, your own material just for the time being. Being happy for them as best you can. Rejoicing in whatever good fortune they have or did.
And bring your mind back to the breath. And get get in touch with your body. Sensation feeling within the body. In an easy and relaxed manner, become aware of your surroundings. So if you’d like to stand up and How are you doing?
I’m good. Oh, really? Drugs. Also drugs. Is it infected?
Even the bone. Yeah. Very, very painful. Sorry. Suffering.
Working off all this negative karma. Six weeks ago. Six weeks? Of just really low health. Oh.
What They have to wait till the infection clears out first before they can do anything? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It’s purification.
Oh, purifying. Oh, that’s was a danger than this one. Rejoice in your good fortune. We’re looking at the third principle. It’s been two weeks since we had a class together, isn’t it?
Name is Jampa. Remember me? We’re looking at the third of the three principal aspects of the path, the awakened mind. We’re looking at the development of the wisdom, understanding, emptiness and selflessness. As a We’re working at this.
We’re going to work through four different levels of this wisdom. You know, each like rungs on a ladder, and we’re beginning at the first level. It’s the hearer’s level or hearer’s stage. So that’s what we’re looking at now. And at the Hearer stage, we accept that the world about us, all the various things and external reality exists very much as it appears.
It true exists out there, stable, substantial. We, on our parts, as subjects, are simply like mirrors reflecting an already objectively existent reality. We are passive observers, more or less. The only thing which is brought into question is nature of the I, the Self. And this we do call into question because based upon ignorance misconceiving this I, this Self, we go on to develop all the various afflictive emotions.
Misconceiving a particular self which is characterized by being partless, unchanging, independent, we go on to generate attachment, hostility, pride, jealousy, and so forth, due to which we involve ourselves in action, create karma, and perpetuate dissatisfactory cycles of existence. So at this level, we’re trying to overcome a particular level of ignorance by developing this antidote, the wisdom realizing the emptiness of a partless unchanging independent self or I. Okay? And the method that we’re using go about doing this is what’s called the Four Essentials. We’ve looked at the first two of these Four Essentials.
The first, the Essential of Ascertaining, the Object of Negation. So the Object negation is that which is a particular fantasized self, a hallucinated self. In context, it’s partless, unchanging, independent self. That’s what’s to be negated. That is the object of refutation.
It’s something which doesn’t exist in fact, but we believe it does, or that ignorance conceives of its existence. So this is the most difficult and the most important of these four essentials. We must identify what it is within our experience we’re grasping to. What is ignorance holding on to? Ignorance is grasping to some solid, concrete, unchanging singularity which which we identify as a self, which exists independent of body and mind, exists independent of causes and conditions.
At the core of our being, there’s some essence to who we are, which we identify as being I, me, Jampa. And we go on, you know, this to develop attachment to anything which we see as enhancing this I and facilitate anything which we see as a threat to this I. So this is the most difficult part. We have to actually try to identify within our experience. Now we’re we’re supplying some ideas, some pointers to look for.
For example, characteristics that we might observe are that it’s partless, it appears partless, it appears unchanging, it appears independent. We’re with you intellectually, aren’t we? We’re developing a picture, but we also try to want to develop that in terms of seeing it within our own experience. Experience a very strong emotion, the I becomes more vivid and apparent to ourselves, that we’re grasping to, you know, I I can’t stand you. I I can’t live without you.
That I that can’t live without this other person. That that can’t that’s so afraid of death, that feels guilty about what they’ve done in the past. That I, we want to get how does that I normally in our experience experience is composed of essentially two factors, an object and a subject. And then we would there wouldn’t be an overall experience without both of those. We need something which is experience and experience of that object.
Normally, we all of our attention is directed toward the object of our experience. Here we’re trying to in a skillful as possible fashion, generate very strong emotions. But part of our mind tries to become aware of, observe the subject of that experience, the I that can’t do the standing, that’s so angry, that feels so guilty, that’s so afraid? How does that I appear? So we’re just for the present being, for the present time, just to give us some guidelines, something to work with, we’re assigning it.
But it’s important that maybe you can begin to identify. This is the most it’s not easy to do. Anyway, you know, getting I think even an intellectual understanding of the subject is valuable. A part is unchanging independent self. Okay.
That’s the first essential. The second essential is the the essential of ascertaining the pervasion. So this is simply a commitment to what we call binary logic or exclude in the middle. It’s just that, you know, if something is a, then it necessarily is not not a. If if the light is on, it necessarily is not off.
There’s no third alternative. There’s no third possibility. If the light is on, it’s not off. If it’s off, it’s not on. It’s either it’s on or it’s off.
There’s no third possibility. Yeah. So we have to be, you know, with all the various phenomena in the universe, they can be classified in this manner as either being one or many, same or different, singular or plural. These categories are exhaustive. These these these two categories can be applied to all phenomena.
All phenomena must either exist as one or many, same or different, and in this way. So we have to become convinced of that. Why? Because we’re going to use those two categories to exhaustively examine our experience in terms of trying to search for this I. We have to come to a conclusion if it if it exists, if the I exists as it appears, just like as a if the snake exists the way it appears, then it must be either the same as the body and mind or different than the body and mind.
There’s no third alternative. We have to become we have to go beyond fuzzy thinking around this. We have to be totally convinced of the logic involved. Okay. That’s I think that’s as far as we got last or two weeks ago.
Okay? So now we’re going to begin looking at the third of these four essentials. The essential of ascertaining lack of being the same. So by same, we mean identical. You know, two things are the same, then every characteristic of one is a characteristic of the other.
There’s not even the slightest atom of difference. If one atom is different, then they’re different. Same means identical in every way, in every feature. That’s why we’re identical, same. Okay?
So what are we looking for? So, you have to put yourself into this. You have to enter into the mindset, what it is we’re trying to do, what it is we’re looking for. At the Essential One, we identified an I as best we could. For the time being, we’re just hypothesizing as if we did.
Okay? What did we identify? We identified a partless unchanging independent self. Okay? Now, we’re going to Where does that I appear?
It appears somewhere in the vicinity of the body and mind. And if I’m going to look for my I, myself, you know, just like in the case of the snake, there’s an appearance of a snake. In fact, there’s a rope. Okay? But the grass is long.
It’s getting dark. There’s an appearance of a snake. If I want to establish whether that’s a mere appearance, whether there’s an actual snake is there or not, I look where the appearance is, where that snake is appearing. I don’t look over there. And not finding the snake over there will not in any way affect my conceiving of that snake over here.
Yeah. If somebody says, There’s a spider in my bed, and you say, Oh, there’s no elephant in your bed, it doesn’t alleviate their fear that there’s a spider in your bed. It doesn’t quite touch the right point. Okay, there’s no elephant in the head, but that doesn’t help me. Where is this I appearing?
It’s appearing somewhere around this vicinity. For me, at least, top of this seat, this cushion. If I really wanted to check up, examine that appearance, I wouldn’t look in the kitchen right now. I’d look on top of the seat. I wouldn’t look out in the parking lot.
Is my I out there? I look over here. That is in the vicinity of the body and the mind. So we’re going to check within the vicinity of the body and mind. First, we’re going to see if it’s the same as the body and the mind.
Okay? Is that I that we had ascertained, that we identified in the first essential, is it the same as the body and mind? Okay? So you’re going to have to you you have to go along with nonness. Okay?
So we we know what we’re looking for, just like we know we’re looking for a snake. We’re not looking for an elephant or a giraffe. We’re looking for a snake. We’re looking for partless, unchanging, independent self. That’s what we’re looking for.
That’s what we identified. Okay? Now immediately, where are we going to look? In the vicinity of the body and the mind. And we’re going to look at it in the vicinity of the body mind in two different manners.
One, is that I that we identify, is it the same as the body and mind, or is it different than the body and mind? Okay? Okay. So in three, we’re going to look to see whether it’s the same as the body and mind. Or immediately some, you know, some certain problems immediately arise as a consequence which contradicts our experience.
So please, we’re going to get this, okay? This is what we’re looking for, right? I’m going to stand up for this, okay? Immediately some problems arise. What are we looking for?
Somebody? Partless, unchanging, independent, Good, thank you. We’re looking to see. Anyway, this is my gingerbread man, it looks like. We see this, is this the same as the body and the mind?
Immediately, there are some problems that arise with which contradict our actual experience. There would have to be at least two I’s or two selves. Why would there have to be at least two eyes or two selves? So you’re going to have to you may have to follow the logic. Follows on from the it’s an absurd consequence which follows on.
If this I were the same as the body and mind, there would have to be at least two I’s or two selves. Why is that? Why would there have to be at least two eyes or two selves? One for the body and one for the mind. Okay.
We said the I is partless, so only one I could account for one part. Minimally, we have a mental part to ourselves and a physical part to ourselves. So only only one eye, since it’s partless, account for one part. There would have to be at least two I’s, one to account for the mental aspect of ourselves and one to account for the physical aspect ourselves. In fact, there would have to be as many I’s as there are parts to the body and mind.
Foot, knee, leg, stomach, shoulders, head, and all the various factors within our mind. There’d have to be one eye for every one of those. I mean, it’d be a chaos. It’d be a crowd of eyes. Are you following?
This eye appears to be partless. Okay? It doesn’t have if that eye were the same as the body and mind, each eye can only account for one part. It doesn’t have any parts. Each eye can only stand for one thing without any parts.
So there would have to be an eye for the body, there would to be a body eye for the mind, there would have to be at least two eyes. But in fact there would be as many I’s as there are parts because this this I doesn’t have parts. Are you following? Okay. Maybe I’m being pedantic here.
Another contradiction: the body and mind are a singularity. Number one or two would have to be the case. Either there would have to be many I’s or what? Because this I is a singularity. It’s partless.
It’s a singular unit. Then what? If this single unit is the same as the body and mind, the body and mind are a singularity. Either there would have to be many I’s because there many parts there is both body and mind, many parts of the body and mind there would have to be many I’s or mind and body would have to be one singularity, without any distinctions, without any parts. Why?
Because the I is partless, it doesn’t have any distinctions, and they’re exactly the same. This is called reductio ad absurdum. Consequences, if this were the case, and reducing it to the absurd consequences which flow on from this. If what we identified we’re trying to see whether there’s actually a snake there or not. There’s an appearance.
There’s no question about the appearance. There’s an appearance of an eye. This appearance has these characteristics. Now does this eye in fact exist? We’re trying to see if it doesn’t exist, it must either exist the same as the body and mind or different than body and mind.
There are certain immediate problems which arise if it’s the same as the body and mind. It’s identical. There would have to be at least two I’s, there would have to be at least two I’s or two selves. Because there are the parts of the body and mind. Minimally there’s a mental part, physical part, but in fact there’s many.
Or, since the body and mind are identical, these two are identical, and this is partless, the body and mind would have to be partless. The body and mind would be one singularity. That’s not the case. You going along with this? The I is material.
Why would the I have to be material? These two are identical. Is worth testing. This is the I, partners, unchanging, independent. This is body and mind.
If these two are identical, the I would have to be material. Why? Because our body is material, and the I is identical to the body. Is that the case? Material?
Is it matter is it I composed to matter? Then, yeah, you’re shaking your head no. Yeah. No. No.
It’s not as a I mean, it’s something seems like some sort of concept almost. That’s certainly not something you can wrap your hands around. So shake some sense into it. So the I would have to be immaterial. Why?
Because the body’s material. But that’s not the way we experience our I. We don’t experience it as material having color, shape, extension in space, and so forth. The eye depends upon causes and conditions. So if these two are identical, then this I would depend upon causes and conditions.
Why? Why would the I necessarily depend upon causes and conditions? Because the body does and the mind does. Because this guy over here depends upon the cause and conditions, and if they’re the same, then this one must depend upon the cause and conditions. But we’ve already identified it.
It doesn’t depend. It’s independent. So there’s a contradiction. It seems not to depend on cause and conditions. If these were identical, this would have to because this depends upon cause and conditions, this necessarily would have to depend on cause and conditions.
But this contradicts how it appears to us. It appears to not depend upon causal conditions, independent of causal conditions. It makes no sense to say, My body. Why is that? I mean, does it make sense to say my body, my mind?
What do think? Does it make sense? Okay. The I doesn’t have parts. So that’s is that where we’re going with it?
So there would be no point of saying, is part of me? I don’t know. These These two are identical? In order to say, my body, there is a possessor and a possessed. There is an owner and that which is owned.
They must be different. If they’re the same, how can there be an owner and an object possessed if they’re the same? By owning yourself, or possessing yourself. The possessor and that which is possessed must be different. It would make no sense that I am thinking.
Yeah? That’s a difficult one, maybe. I am thinking. It would make no sense. Why?
Are you thinking? I am thinking. Because the I is the thinking. The I is not the agent of the thinking. The I is the thinking.
Why? Because it’s identical with body and mind. So the thinking is the I. There is no I thinking. When you say I am thinking, it’s as if there is an agent who is doing the thinking.
But the I is the thinking itself. It doesn’t do the thinking. It’s not an agent doing the thinking. It is the thinking. Does that make any sense?
The I would grow and diminish. As you eat more, you know, you get fatter, your eye would get fatter because these are identical. Or if you had an amputation, your eye would be diminished. You’d lose part of your eye. It’d be a lesser I.
But that’s not the way that we experience it. This is difficult. The body and mind would become nonexistent. Why would the body and mind become nonexistent? What happens if you realize the nonexistence of this I, and this is identical to that, what happens?
This will become nonexistent. If you realize the nonexistence of this I, and it’s identical with this, the body and mind, then this would become nonexistent because one realizes that it’s nonexistent. Ask me some Maybe one or two of them might kind of resonate. You have to find one that kind of shakes you a little bit. But maybe none of them shake you.
Let’s go back through them, okay? The no eye is emptiness. Not having an eye is emptiness. Here’s the eye we’re talking about, not the general eye. This is the eye that we identified here.
But with no I, there’s emptiness. Is that right? Emptiness is an absence, a lack, a nonexistence of that. So selflessness less the absence of this type of self. Emptiness is an absence of this type of self.
This Is this appearance? If this appearance actually was something more than appearance? Yeah? We have a self representation, which we make use of in thinking about ourselves. We have self representations of all various phenomena, we make use in order to make sense of our world.
We can think about things. I can think about my room at home. I can I have I have my beds over here and my my desk’s over there? So in that process, I’m using representations, maps, images. We also have a self representation, we have a self, an image of ourselves, a map about and this and this is some of the characteristics of a mistaken map are that it’s partless itself is partless, unchanging, independent.
We identify with our idea, our conception of a particular type of self. We we it appears there’s there’s a self representation. There’s a there appears a snake. So we’re trying to see whether there’s anything findable which corresponds to that appearance. There’s an appearance of a snake.
We’re poking we have a torch in our stick. Is is there anything findable which corresponds to that appearance? There’s an appearance of an I, a particular self characterized by being partless, unchanging, independent. We’re poking around with our stick of analysis and our torch or wisdom trying to see, is there anything which corresponds to that appearance? So where we where we poking?
We’re poking around here. That’s where it’s appearing just like where the snake appears. Is there is there anything which correspond is to this I at this place. You know, we’re poking it around this area for that for that snake. And the way we’re going to poke is in terms of either that snake is either that I is the same as the body and mind or different.
If it’s the same, immediately, there are certain problems which arise. There’s there’s an appearance. Okay? But we’re not sure if it exists or not. Just like with regard to the appearance of the snake.
So some would somebody volunteer to explain this first one? Why is that a problem? Why does that follow? If the I were partless, unchanging, independent, if that I were identical to body and mind, it follows that there’d have to be at least two selves or two I’s. Why is that?
I know that you’ve said it’s because there’s a body and the mind. People think it’s parts, it’s two parts. But what is to say that our body and our mind are two parts? Do you experience them as a single part or as two parts or different parts? Are they or different?
Is the body and mind same or different? I see art and I think that’s quite a deep philosophical question. It might need some time spent on it because I think that language in our culture, you know, we talk about our foot and we talk about our mental health. But I don’t have to really think about it as to whether they’re part of the same thing. Oh, they’re parts?
Oh, they’re parts. Okay. Yeah. Are the the the glass and the and the stick, are they the same or different? They’re different.
Why? Because they appear different. Well, if two things appear different, that means they’re different. But, yeah, I I don’t know whether I can disassociate from either my mind or my foot as Are you Is your mind and your foot the same or different? Well, if you think about your other point later on, the I would grow and diminish, people who are amputees actually experience a feeling of diminishing.
A missing limb. I miss it. I miss part of my eye. They feel replaced, and then they talk themselves up and decide that they can go on. Let’s stick with number one.
Is everybody following? Would somebody explain that first one? I think general convention is thinking that there are parts to the body and parts to the mind. Okay. What then there would have to be at least two cells.
Why is that? At least two for each of the parts of the body and mind. And the I that we’re looking for is partless, then they can’t be the same thing. So it’s we’re saying that there’s a part part of the body is a part of us, and the mind is a part of us. There are two at least two parts.
So if it was the same as the partner self, then there must be at least two the partner’s eye, there must be at least two eyes. Okay, good. Let’s see. That’s right. So each eye can only account for one part or one thing, because it doesn’t have any parts.
It’s a single unit. One eye accounts for one unit. The body is a unit, the mind is a unit, so there must be at least two of these I’s. But then we could extend that. On the other hand, the body and mind are a singularity, a single unit.
Why is that for love? It’s either one or you you can go either way, either one or two. The body and mind would have to be a singularity. Why? If this I were identical to the body and mind, the body and mind would be partless.
Because the I is partless and that I is identical to the body and mind. The body and mind must have every characteristic of that I. Therefore, it is partless. It’s also unchanging and independent, but right now, we’re looking at it, the body and mind, be partless. Anyway, it’s an absurd consequence.
The I would have to be material. Why is that? That? Well, to be part of the body, it would have to be material. But I would think that this the mind could fit the same description as the I, couldn’t it?
The mind could also be described as part of some change in independence. In which case, the eye can reside in the mind. Yeah. The eye would be? The eye could reside in the mind.
Resign in the Pardon? Or be a function of the mind. So, but it’s not in this case we’re saying it has to be identical. We’re going to take up the second case, the next one. First we’re going check to see whether it’s identical.
Every characteristic of this is a characteristic of that. Every characteristic of that is a characteristic of that. They’re identical. If they’re identical, then many absurd consequences arise. The I is material.
Why? Because one of the characteristics of body and mind is that it’s material. Therefore, the I would have to be material, and their characteristics are exactly identical. The I would depend upon causes and conditions. Why?
Because these two have identical characteristics, and the body and mind depends upon causes and conditions. Therefore, the I must depend upon cause and condition. But this contradicts what we’ve seen in terms of what we’ve observed as characteristic of the I, but nonetheless it must be. It makes no sense to say my body, because the possessor and the possessed must be different. If they’re identical, how can the possessor and the possessed be identical?
Or I am thinking, there is no agent behind the thinking because the I is the thinking. It’s identical. Thinking is a characteristic of mind. Every characteristic of body and mind is a characteristic of I. Thinking is a characteristic of mind, it must be a characteristic of I.
Therefore, I is thinking. It is not the agent behind the thinking. It is the thinking. The I would grow and diminish. If if you cut off cut off his leg, cut off part of the body, and you cut off part of the eye.
But that’s not the way we experience our I. An amputated arm. I guess I don’t know. The body and mind would become nonexistent. When this were realized to not exist and these two identical, then this would be realized to not exist.
My body and mind would be realized not exist. What do you think? Is that Slippery. Slippery, yeah. So there are lots of these, but in this first case, seeing whether this I as it appears is the same as the body and mind, there are lots of dialectical tests which demonstrate that the I and the body are not the same, identical.
So we should test each of these consequences. These are all these absurd consequences. We try to find something, work and play with them until they shake our belief that the I is the same as the body and mind. That is, the I lacks the lack of being the same as the body and mind. The lack of being the same.
This is the third essential. Okay? You guys are being very quiet. I need some I need some feedback here. Well, the mind the mind.
Yeah. Our mind, I. He’s looking for ways to try and make those true. Make those true. Yeah.
Just like you did before when you’re saying, you know, the the I could could be the mind. Is it is it? You have to accept the premise of the mind and the body and the mind as separate entities as you’ve done by using the word and. But if you just put body mind, stroke Yeah. That changes it to a single entity.
Body One of which is Parkinson’s on changing, the other is physical, but both coexisting and and in the body. Can you run that maybe again, Chris? Having trouble separating body and mind, I suppose, now that I’ve seen this demonstration. So the Separating them as two separate entities, if you like. Body and mind.
So mind is is body is made up of physical elements. Yes. And causal effects. Yes. Yeah.
And and mind is that which is knowing, clear and knowing. So it’s nonphysical. Mhmm. So this yeah. So there’s they’re different.
I mean, so that’s So we have body and mind. Or body mind. Body body slash mind. Okay? Is that is that I identical with body slash mind?
Maybe. I think it’s identical with mind. The mind. Then the Not the body. So is is sugar the same as different than chili and sugar?
Is sugar the same or different than chili and sugar? Is sugar the or different than a mixture of chili and sugar? I would say different. Different. Not the same, is it?
I mean, if you were making a cup of tea, and you say, here’s a mixture of chili and sugar. I don’t want that. I just want sugar. I want something different. I want sugar.
Yeah. If they’re contained within a cup, in this case, the cup is the body. A cup is the body? And and what’s inside it? Elements are inside the cup.
They may be different, but number three, we’re trying to see whether identical. We’re going to go on to see maybe they’re different. Maybe the I and the body and mind are different. What? What is it?
You got something? Yeah. I’m following on your body slash mind. Okay. And if we can’t we can’t actually distinguish between body mind if we actually did interpret body mind as a whole.
As a whole? And what do as a whole. Are there okay. Fine. Yeah.
Okay. If we did interpret body mind as a whole Okay. Then it could be the same as Body mind? Body mind. The I is the same as body mind.
One of the characteristics of body mind is part of it is physical. Part of the eye would have to be physical. Every characteristic of body mind is the characteristic of the I. Therefore, part of the eye would have to be physical. Because part of the bodymind is physical.
But possibly the mind is physical. Because isn’t it I mean, if you look at the physics, isn’t it neurons and flashes and Okay, so do you experience your I as physical? Is it of color? What color is your eye? If I was saying it was the same as body and mind, I’d be saying, Good looking at it.
Your body is your I. I’m not body mind. So you’re a complete materialist, okay? No, you can’t even do that. But I’m a material that is also a verb.
Material? Because I do my body mind. You’re doing your body. My body and mind. So I’m not merely physical, I’m not merely doing, I’m physical that’s doing.
Okay, there’s doing part. So anyway, whatever the body mind is all about, part of it’s physical. Oh, well if we’re saying it’s all the same, then we’re saying all of it is physical. Oh, it’s homogenous. Ah, I see.
It’s got a smear. It’s homogenous, okay? So it doesn’t have parts. That’s the second one. The body and mind are singularity.
It doesn’t have any parts. It doesn’t have teeth, arms, legs. It’s just kind of a smear. What what which things? Which things?
The body and mind. We’re not yeah. We’re we’re not independent of each other. So we’re not talking about whether the whether the the nature of their relationship or Yes. So if they if you wanna go home tonight.
No. If they can’t exist independent of each other, then then are they the same? Is it a singularity? Yes. Do you depend upon food for your for your well-being?
Yeah. Are you are you the same as food? No. I mean, so you’re different than food, but you depend upon food. Okay, got it.
We’re sticking just to the sameness, identical. Even if something sounds stupid, you’ve got to get it out in the open. It doesn’t matter. I mean, you might be right, and we can rewrite. I could be making a mistake here.
So by all means. I mean, just have to every kind of fantastic notion that you have Okay, here you go, see? I’ve been thinking that here we are talking about the I of the body and mind, mind, but I thought that in Buddhism there is no ‘I’. Where? There is no ‘I’.
There is no ‘I’. You’ve been thinking what? I know. Was Stuart. I shouldn’t have Who knows?
We look at it. There’s not that behind it. I agree with that behind it. Yeah? But you said that a few weeks ago that there is no I, there’s no self.
Oh. It’s not in the body, it’s not in the mind, it’s not in the emotion. Then Why? And that’s why you’ve been teaching. That’s why we’re looking for And I know you’re exploring it, but but why?
Like, where are we going with this? Who’s going? Go. But we all go. Well, we think there’s an I because of conditioning, and we can sort of stand aside from and analyze our our emotion and our thoughts, and we think that’s the I.
Yeah? Yeah. Yeah. Through ignorance. So maybe I gave you the wrong impression if I gave you the impression that there is no I.
The I exists. There is a person, Jampa, person, Jampa, self, in my case Jampa. But that’s just the label that you’re putting on all parts, isn’t it? That’s the way the I exist. So that I exist.
But we’re going to come to the place where we understand everything exists in the exact same manner. There’s no in terms of the manner, the way things exist, there’s no hierarchy of existence. The I and the table exist in the same manner. Just in the same way that the table exists, my I exists. They have both the same degree or they are both just as illusory or both just as real as one or the other.
So what do we think of rope is a snake? It’s reconditioning. Doctor. So there are conditions. It’s getting dark.
Maybe you read in the newspaper there’s a lot of snakes around these days. Spring is coming and so forth. There’s a precondition in your mind. The color of the shape and the color of the shape of the object. All this coming a snake appears.
There’s an appearance and you think with regard to that snake. Label snake, you think snake with regard to that. So there is an I, there is a Self, but that I, that Self is not a problem. There is the I which walks and talks and eats and goes on to achieve Buddha. Buddha has an I, a self.
It is not a but it is the misconceived I which becomes the problem. Based upon this misconceived I, in this case, a partless unchanging independent self. We go on to generate all the various afflictive emotions. You will not generate the afflictive emotions in dependence upon the empirical, conventionally existent I. Always it’s always in dependence upon a misconceived I.
I understand misconceived through ignorance and and grasping and Yeah. Ignorance is is grasping at it’s due to ignorance. Yeah. Yeah. So the reason we’re looking for this so hard is to not find it.
Is to become convinced it appears, but there’s nothing behind the parent. It’s just an appearance. Just like that snake appears. But no matter how much we search again and again and again, we don’t find a snake. So it will continue to appear.
So that’s where it’s going. Yeah, that’s where it’s going. We’re looking for this because to not find it. That’s right. But see, yeah, but then it has to be we’re looking for something which we already know doesn’t exist.
But at another level, we believe it does, at an emotional level. Ignorance believes it does. So just saying words, it’s just like pouring oil on water. It doesn’t have any effect on emotional life. Ignorance is still going to arise, grasp at the existence of such an I, and we’re going to generate hostility and attachment and so forth.
So we have to go through this again and again. Because at the depth of our being, you know, we can say this, at the depth of our being, we believe that we are this. If I am not this, then I am nothing. I’m this solid, concrete entity at the core of my being. So we have to go through it.
We have to keep it. We know it’s never done again, but we have to go through the motions again, and again, really getting into it, trying to find it. It must exist. It must exist. Actually, a good sign that you’re getting into the meditation is when fear arises.
There is a fear of going out of existence. Why? Because Because the the I to which we’re most familiar is beginning to see as nonexistent. Yeah. We’re beginning to see through this illusion, this appearance, this what is, in fact, just a mere appearance of something which does not exist at all.
And we identify with that appearance as being who in fact we are. We’re misidentifying who we are, the I. So in psychotherapy, one of the things that is being done in psychotherapy is to help us to be a little more flexible around the need of holding onto our self representations. I’m this way. I’m this much beautiful.
I’m this much intelligent. I can do this. I can’t do that. All these characteristics. And we try to loosen that a little bit so we’re not holding so tightly because it becomes very self limiting in our life and what we do actually achieve and how we act.
Here we’re trying to see through, not only become more flexible fluid. Sometimes we’re smart, sometimes we’re not so smart. Sometimes we’re very inconsistent in a way. But we want to hold on to a fixed idea of ourselves. So we become a little more fluid, and you become more accepting of all the different aspects of yourself.
Here we’re trying psychotherapy and a great deal of Buddhism is trying to help us to be able to do that. But here we’re trying to actually question, does that self representation, is it something more than just that? Is there anything which corresponds to this I, which I think to be this much intelligent, this much beautiful, this much is there anything there which corresponds to that? I think you could ask a question about whether the I line is the same or different as self representation, you’d have a whole bunch of other propositions that you’d be looking at. That’s not the same question you’ve been talking about.
Q: Yeah. We believe what is in fact a self representation to be who in fact we are, Not a self representation. We don’t believe that. Mean, intellectually, I just said that, but we believe ourselves, what is in fact a self representation, to be in fact who we are. We identify with what is in fact a self representation as being me.
And we protect that and enhance that. What? Self representation and the I? Oh, no question about that. Yeah.
It’s just like that. But we’re identifying the I with the self representation, not with the actual self, the empirical, conventionally existent self. The I which is talking to you right now, there is an I. But you don’t need to ask a question like whether the body and mind are the same or different to answer the question of what is my self representation, my self-concept. When the the I is grasping at what is a mere appearance as, in fact, who you are.
So we have to we have to so we have to and the first one, we’re trying to what does that I appear like and then question is that in fact who you are? Okay. Is this maybe, no this is good, this is good. So the I exists. There is what we call an empirically existent I.
There is a body and mind, and dependence upon that we label I, Jampa, Self. There’s I am over here, you’re over there. This is a convenient manner of speaking. How do we distinguish between this body of mine over there and this body of mine over here? It’s the I, that’s you.
We have to have a reference. Yeah, that’s just a handy way of speaking. But shouldn’t think that this way of looking at and talking about the I is any different than looking at and talking about tables and chairs and buildings. That’s done on the table. That’s the next one.
That comes later. Are there any languages that don’t have an I? I don’t know. I know. I don’t know.
You know of any human? Or you. I don’t know. Don’t know. There’s a tribe in Africa when greet each other, they say, I see you.
See you. Instead of, Hello and goodbye, it’s, I see you. I see you. That’s nice. Okay.
So we can I know I’m kind of running this into the ground, but it won’t, you know, if it’s to really be of use to ourselves, really have to play with it? And if it’s something more than kind of an intellectual game. And I think it actually can begin to But we have to enter into this kind of way of thinking and see how the role it actually plays in how we feel about ourselves. It comes down to a feeling, even though it appears to be intellectual. Next we’re going to look at whether this I, which is the object of negation, which we identified in part number one.
The logic has to be foolproof. We identified an I, that I must be either the same as the body and mind, a different body and mind. It can’t be the same because of all these absurd consequences. Now we’re going to come to see if it’s different than the body and mind. And what we may find is it’s not different than the body and mind.
If this I exists, if it’s something more than a mere appearance, then it must be the same or different than the body and mind. We’ve established it’s not the same, we established it’s not different. Though this I appears, it doesn’t exist at all. And how do you make that conclusion, coming to that conclusion, some kind of force, actually kind of shake ignorance, our belief that it does exist? At some level we believe that this I exists.
How do shake that belief? We have to have a foolproof. We have to go through all this again and again, all the absurd nitpicky questioning and excuses, until we become convinced. Wow, we have to come to some really strong conclusion. It doesn’t exist at all.
Do you see what I mean? Sort of. Sort of. I know. Yeah.
Okay, then we’re going to look at the essential of ascertaining, the fourth essential of ascertaining, lack of being different. Here we’re going to look in terms of body and mind down into the five aggregates, you know, and we’re going to examine to see whether we can find an I which is different from the body and mind. Within or within, like Chris mentioned, like something inside of a cup, or maybe separate from the body and mind. Any questions around this? Any disputes?
What was the essential pervasion? I’m kind of mistaken. It’s a commitment to an excluded middle. These two taking all possible alternatives the way this I could exist. If this I exists, it must exist as either the same as the body and mind or different than the body and mind.
pervasion means it necessarily follows. If this I exists, it necessarily follows that it is the same as the body and mind or different than the body and mind. If it doesn’t exist as the same as the body and mind or different than the body and mind, it doesn’t exist. There’s no third possible way. There’s no third alternative.
Covers all possibilities Because you go through both of these and you find it doesn’t exist. Therefore, doesn’t exist this way, there exists this way, doesn’t exist at all. And so you have to be very convinced of that. Don’t know. I made some feedback here.
You guys are getting the blank stares here. Am I belaboring all this? It’s so frustrating. You know? It’s just so pathetic the way it tries to say, you know, Dan’s this and Dan’s that.
You know? Dan, I stand for that. You know? Sets up all these things that are very rigid, like, that you base all your all these thoughts on, and yet it’s just garbage. There’s nothing there.
You can even say is you can point to as being anything of any substance, let alone unchanging and, you know, independent things. You know? Is it helpful or unhelpful to set up a relationship of, like, antipathy with it? Do you know what I mean? Like, to be angry with yourself, self-cherishing or With your with your ignorance.
Yeah. Yeah. With your ignorance and self self-cherishing. Mhmm. There’s some with the Wheel of Sharp Weapons.
There is a mind training text called the Wheel of Sharp Weapons. And in this text it says something like, trample him, trample him, and it is talking about your own self-cherishing. And then when you practice taking and giving, you take the suffering upon not your I empirically, but your own self centeredness, self cherish. So it doesn’t mean beating down your self esteem being or being mean to your mind and body. No, ma’am.
No. So I okay. Anyway, I think it’s good. So let me just cover you exist. Whatever my body does, I do.
My body is sitting on the cushion. I’m talking. The body is talking. I’m talking, I have happy thoughts, I’m happy. It’s simply that the I is labeled, is named upon a particular body and mind.
Just like we talked about the baby. When a baby is born, it’s called John. It depends upon that body of mind. The name is name John is given, and the the baby is thought of subsequently as John. John comes into existence and depends upon that name.
Likewise, I come into existence depending upon I. This is the name I. I’m not a name, but I am a person, but I’m dependent upon language and conceptuality. I have many parts. I’m constantly changing.
I depend upon my body and mind, my social conditions, society and so forth. So there is no I which exists that way. But it appears to exist that way, and we believe it exists that way. So we have to undermine that belief. And the way that we undermine that belief is through analysis.
Just like the belief in the snake, we have to analyze, investigate, and then we undermine our belief in it. And then all the suffering and all the fear and aversion that arose and depends upon what is basically a misconception, it dissolves in the emptiness of its nonexistence, of that snake, for example. Do it make sense to say the body and mind were a singularity of interdependent parts? Then they’re not a singularity because they are parts. Singularity is one homogenous unit.
It doesn’t have to be a homogenous unit. It has to be a singular unit. It has to be one thing. We are one thing with multiple Parts. Parts.
Why do you call yourself one thing? One being. If we’re not a table, we have a great difference to the table being probably a better word. So to my mind, you can say we’re singularity with that construction of the word singularity. And sure I mean, I have all sorts of problems with all of the almost all of those arguments, but final proposition makes a lot of sense to aren’t the same.
Different people are different and all that sort of thing. So I I don’t know what to do with them because to my mind, you know, your proposition previously what is not logical. No. Just give me one example. If this I were identical to bodymind, there would be two selves.
No, it doesn’t follow that mind. Okay, so there could be one self? Yep. Okay, so there could be one self. The body and mind are one.
They’re singularity of the kind I’m talking about, not the kind you’re talking about. I think you’re looking for the convention light because I was doing that. No, not convention. Not one more. I just think.
How many how many how many parts are there? How many aspects of you? Just minimum, just roughly. Whatever, you decide. The the If you mean just an I like a concept of the self, then I would give you a different answer to how many parts of me are if I’m thinking of body and mind.
So I have all sorts of body parts like everybody else. That’s one answer. If you think how those things interact, you might have a different answer again, that there are parts of the body and mind So there are parts to you, right? There are parts. Yeah?
So there must be at least two selves to you. Why? Because there are parts to you. What are you saying no to? Because There’s another concept.
No, no, no, no. We have to follow your logic, the one you just described. You’re saying there are parts to you. This I is partless, therefore there must be many yous. Because there are many parts to you, this I can only stand for one part.
Since there are many parts to you, you have to have as many I’s as there are parts to you. This is the one we identified here. Your little finger. You have to think of it’s not our experience. It’s not our concept.
It’s not our reality. And so to talk about the body or the mind as necessarily being partless and precluding that sort of description. It doesn’t make any sense to me. If if this if this is the case, case, given this, then this follows. You’re saying that you’re not giving me this, right?
You’re not giving me this. If you give me this, then that follows. If this, then that. I just think differently about the word partless. I can see that our experience of ourselves or others is to see an integrated whole.
Integrative Integrative means the parts? A person or body. If something’s integrated, it has parts. A person completely indivisible in the sense that you could talk about their body and their mind, but they So they coexist, wouldn’t they? They’re interdependent, fine, but they’re different.
If they coexist, they’re different, because they’re not different, we can’t what’s the sense of talking about co? Co means two. They’re of an I. Which is a singular thing. They’re part of an I which is a thing Which is one entity.
Part of an I which is one entity? Yeah. So if this I is partless, how can it be a part of an I which is partless? I can’t answer that question any more than I have. I’ve answered it six times, I reckon, and I cannot answer it Okay.
So we have to enter in if this is the idea that we identify here, and then this logic follows that conclusion. Logic follows that conclusion. So we’re trying to we’re not and as was mentioned, we’re not trying we haven’t identified the condition that exists in the I, the I which talks and walks and so on and so forth. We’re talking about the object of negation. It’s characterized with these features.
If it has these features and it follows that we we up with these absurd consequences. Yeah? Not in my mind. I don’t understand why not, to be honest. I don’t know what it’s to tell you.
It perhaps, like, helpful to think like, reflect on a time, like, when you feel intense, you know, anger towards somebody and and analyze how you experience that self that’s getting very worked up. You know? Like, But if you think about that, I think I experience it as does it have parts? Is it I don’t know. It feels very in independent.
I don’t know. It’s just an up thought sometimes. It doesn’t change my proposition. It doesn’t change my proposition whether I’m thinking of that sort of experience or whether I’m kind of, like, sort of thing. Yeah.
The difference is in there’s a big difference in the feeling. Absolutely. And it’s certainly true, as you were saying, with a strong emotion, stuff focuses much more So the I always appears this way, even when we’re relaxed. But it just becomes more obvious and vivid. When we’re emotionally aroused, it becomes clear.
But it always appears that way. We’ll go into next week. We’ll check to see whether this I is different than the body and the mind. It’s it’s more fun. It’s yeah.
It’s more fun. But it’s fun at all. Anyway, it’s a challenge, isn’t it? I can relate to what you’re saying. Explain it to you.
Well, I can relate to what she’s saying. What? But I think that that’s when you analyse the questions with your real life, when you’re analysing it with the real life, but then when then I kind of you get the answers that that you’re experiencing. You know, the things that come into your head, I get when I’m trying to analyse it with the real life, the real life that really exists. Like, okay.
Yeah. There’s not two of me. You know? That that’s the I that’s sitting here. Know?
I am a singularity because I depend on it as a whole. I am material because I do depend on my body. The I depends on causes and conditions. Yes, of course I do. I’m sitting here, I depend on and conditions.
It makes no sense to say my body or I’m thinking yeah maybe our language has got it wrong because if I’m all one because I’m sitting here the I would grow and diminish, yes when I’d chomp it off I’d miss my arm that would be shame because I’m part, you know, I’m all of this. The mind and body would become non existent, yes, yep, because I’m sitting here so then when I die I’ll become non existent. So when I look at the real I that I understand, me sitting here, then I get all of the things you’re doing there. And that’s where my confusion comes. But if I go back to say, but I’m looking for an I that is partless, unchanging, and independent.
Well, then it’s just following the language about that. But but okay. Because because, right, because the one that’s sitting here does have parts. It is it is it does change because I’m getting old and I’ve had a baby, and I know I’m changing. And and and that’s not independent because I need food and I need friends.
So when you when you say partless and unchanging within the mind is something different, would you say you if you think about I, that that you would identify that that thought they have got the eye is partless and trying to be independent? The eye that hurts for itself, the I that that protects itself and wants to build itself up and wants to have things and wants to, you know, I don’t know, be I don’t know. You know? That that that I thinks of itself as needing protection and being able to be hurt. And, you know, it does feel like it sometimes needs a shield up around it to protect it all.
And you know, that is a little emotional, you know, thing that you feel is just yours. And that’s the thing that feels like it can be crushed with a mean word in public. That’s the thing that can be outraged if somebody puts you down. And that’s the thing that feels partless and unchanging and independent. That’s why it feels like it needs to be protected because you’ve only got one.
And so it’s when you’re looking for that thing as the I, not the one you really truly understand is in here, but when you’re for that thing that all of these seem ridiculous. But isn’t it something else that either you’re talking about is not just part of the. It is the the reason for that sense of vulnerability, surely, is because that feels like it’s us, you know, in the deepest sense. So what we’re predicting is our deepest Yeah. It feels like it is.
It feels like it is. It feels like it is, and that’s where we fall down. That’s where we allow ourselves not to be clear and knowing because we’re getting tied up protecting this thing that feels like it’s real, and that’s why we’re trying to analyze for this singular thing that needs to be protected, which is the thing that doesn’t exist. But and that’s the thing that doesn’t fit with all these these things. But if you’re looking at just if you’re looking at the one that does exist, then all of these things do make sense.
Now what is the thing? Isn’t part of that something does exist? Only in our experience. Only in our in our creation, our mind, and our experience, and our emotions, yeah, it’s very real to most of us because that’s what we interact with, you know, twenty four hours, seven days a week because we’re so busy protecting it and nurturing it and thinking about it and wondering how we can make it grow or get better or make it feel okay or maybe help it do some good so it can feel bigger again. I don’t know.
But yeah. So it does feel real because we give it our focus, focus, and we shape our actions around it. So we we make it real. Don’t we? Sounds good to me.
I’ll take a dozen. No, it’s good. That’s good. That’s great. Was great.
Anyway, let’s just keep playing with this. A hint of uncertainty is probably a good start, isn’t it? A says that you Oh, a little bit different context, but just the doubt shakes the foundations of cyclic existence. Just kind of entertaining that, well, maybe I don’t quite exist the way I thought I did. Yeah, that’s right.
But the I quite as substantial. It’s a little more transparent. And therefore, I think, coincidentally, we don’t quite probably have the intensity and frequency of the same anger and so forth that we normally do. So it’s not an eitheror. It’s just the I is not quite as we never really looked at the I, and now we’re beginning to look at it.
And it’s not as substantial as we had presumed it was. The I is not as solid and concrete as we presumed it was. And even that, we are not quite sure about this, but it is not quite as solid. Just to begin the question as we are now, without, you know, unreflectedly going along, just that questioning, I think, reduces. The Maybe the I that’s not as end as we thought it was.
Is that a self-concept? Is that an eye that equals self-concept? No. I mean, the I is a person. The eye is a person.
It doesn’t quite exist the way we normally think it does. But this eye, this eye doesn’t exist at all. It’s like a mistaken sort of mental concept. It’s like the appearance of that snake. Feel free when we make it real, but it’s not there.
If we feel like that, I should. Okay. I don’t know. I don’t I I It’s very hard to let go of. Oh.
I think it takes Yeah. No, I think it’s I’m quite sure. I mean, I’m not quite sure. I mean, most of our ways of thinking, our language and so forth, tends to confirm this a lot of our thinking, it’s it’s it’s going the other way. Not that when you always say, you you know yourself today or whatever.
That’s right. Yeah. Yeah. Know what? I The other self doesn’t change.
When display a different self self which is fairly consistent, people say, You’re not yourself. I’m not myself today. And as if there were a self that you aren’t today. It’s just a matter of which we’re not as consistent as we try to make ourselves have to be, the way that we’d like to think we were. Anyway, let me just finish.
The person exists. Rest well. It just doesn’t exist quite the way we think it does. We can dedicate this positive energy we’ve created together. May beings everywhere, plagued by suffering of body and mind attain an ocean of happiness and joy by virtue of my merits.
May no living creature suffer, commit evil, or fall ill. May no one be afraid or belittled with the mind weighed down by depression. May the blind see forms and deaf hear sounds. May those whose bodies are worn with toil be restored on finding repose. May the naked find clothing, the hungry find food.
May the thirsty find water and delicious drink. May the poor find wealth, who’s weak with sorrow find joy. May the forlorn find hope, constant happiness, and prosperity. May there be timely rains, and bountiful harvest. May all medicines be effective, and wholesome prayers bear fruit.
May all who are sick and ill quickly be free from their ailments. Whatever diseases there are in the world, may they never occur again. May the frightened cease to be afraid, and those bound be freed. May the powerless find power, and may people think of benefiting each other. For as long as space remains, for as long as sentient beings remain, until then may I too remain to dispel the miseries of the world.
Through these skillful actions, may I quickly become an awakened spiritual master and lead each and every living being to that awakened realm. May the supreme jewel of the awakened heart that has now arisen arise and grow, and may that which has arisen never diminish, but increase more and more. In the land encircled by snow mountains, you are the source of happiness and well-being. Powerful Chenrezig, Tenzin Gyatso, please remain until the end of saṃsāra. Thank you for your Good night.
Take care.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- real I
- The I that appears to exist inherently from its own side without depending on causes and conditions, parts or the mind's imputation. It is the object to be refuted. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
- The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
- three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
- The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.