Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 — 2008-09-29

2 h 5 min · 11,872 words · 29 September 2008 · Buddha House Adelaide

Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 (Ven Jampa Gendun)
Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 — 2008-09-29
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this two-hour session, Ven Jampa Gendun introduces the Four Essentials — Tsongkhapa’s method for investigating whether the self we emotionally grasp actually exists. After a Heart Sūtra recitation and a guided loving-kindness meditation expanding from self outward to all beings, he turns to the Hearer’s stage analysis of selflessness. The session centers on the first and most difficult essential: identifying the object of negation — the partless, unchanging, independent I that ignorance misapprehends. He offers a vivid practical instruction: stir a strong emotion in controlled meditation, then use part of the mind as a “spy” to observe the grasping I before the emotion collapses. The second essential, binary logic (the self must exist as either the same as or different from body and mind — no third option), is illustrated with a sugar-and-chili analogy. A Q&A closes on what a realized being actually feels and does. Suited to practitioners already working with analytical meditation on emptiness.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 23 3PA 2008 09 29.mp3

UUID: 5c99c6d5-1eef-4235-97b7-d66580ba45ca

Teacher: Ven Jampa Gendun

Collection: Three Principle Aspects of the Path 2008-2009 (Ven Jampa Gendun)

Date: 2008-09-29

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 125.6 minutes

Words: ~11,869

How is everybody? Some old Can you hear me okay? Yes. Some old faces. I didn’t mean anything personal about that.

Give me a break. It’s been a hard day. Shucks. I still have this in my mind. Next Monday is a holiday, isn’t it?

October sixth is Labor Day, so there won’t be any teachings. Give him more time to meditate. No teaching, but meditation. Oh, no, I’m sorry. No, no, it was a joke, bad joke.

No, no teachings, nothing on next Monday, okay? What about Thursday morning then? Thursday morning will happen, yeah. We decided to keep Thursday morning. Thursday morning will happen.

We’re going to keep Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday. Just Monday. So we begin by adjusting our motivation, bringing ourselves to this present moment. In terms of our intention, making some of our choices more conscious in terms of what it is that we want for our life, the kind of person that we want to be, maybe ten years from now, twenty years from now, somewhere down the line, not own or control or have or possess, but be. The greatest reward that we gain through all the blood, sweat and tears that we expend, all our struggles, our planning is not so much what we get for it, but who we become by it, the person that we are as having done what we’ve done.

So I guess it places a large responsibility on ourselves in the sense of becoming the authors of our life and determining for yourself what kind of person you want to be. However you might define whatever works for you, what is the value for you, what has meaning and purpose for you. We stop yielding to the force of circumstance, we resist the momentum of our past habits, and we begin to create a new future for ourselves, orientating ourselves toward that person. You know, I think, I guess what in terms of Buddhism, you know, develop some criteria, some way of looking at that, you know, what we call Buddha. I guess, you know, the Buddha is simply the the best possible story that we could tell ourselves about ourselves and what we could do with our lives and who we could be.

This life which is someday going to stop. How are we going to fill it out in terms of the quality of our life? We talk about wisdom and love and compassion, and personal power, finding some meaningful and skillful ways to express this, and benefiting others. I guess that’s the model of sanity which Buddhism tries to help us to orientate toward a rich, full and meaningful life. So we can approximate that in various ways that we do.

But within that, I think it’s necessary to make it relevant to ourselves, uniquely define our own Buddha for ourselves, in terms of what is a value to ourselves now. So it doesn’t seem quite as abstract, some kind of goal which is going to be more struggling for in some future life. But it’s seen as, in some way or another, an extension of qualities which we already now possess. But it’s not a matter of qualitative, it’s a matter of quantitative difference. Beginning to work with our own potentials, and beginning to appreciate and recognize them inside of ourselves, and determine to make them a growing part of our waking life.

Trying to embody what it is that we want for ourselves, embody our personality and all uniqueness. We’re all very unique in that, aren’t we? You know, I guess why we call that authentic. You know, there’s some kind of correspondence between what are our inner held values and how express them in our everyday life. There’s a correspondence.

There’s kind of a unity between the two. There’s no kind of split. You know, taking taking these these ways of being, these meaningful goals, these values out of the treasure chest within our hearts, and trying them on from time to time to see how they bring about the changes we want for our life. And then creating that space where we begin to express these fragile shoots of love and compassion, wisdom and personal power in everyday life. I guess taking a risk, taking chances, and purposely cultivating the person you want to be.

It probably won’t happen by accident or by serendipity, by chance. We have to be a little more directive. There’s a force of momentum of our past, which kind of perpetuates what we who we’ve been in the past, you know. Who you are now is what you have done, and what you do now is what you’re going to become. So we have to take some kind of initiative if things are ever to be different in terms of the quality of our lives.

And, you know, I think we have methods to work with, which is kind of, in one way it’s very inspiring, but another way it places a responsibility in ourselves. And to become aware that you could be, that life could be quite different than it is now. It means that you have to stop blaming other people and situations for what is going on in your life at some time, at some level, and get on with the need for change and working with the methods for change. Quit abdicating the responsibility to others. The more our lives are accounted for by our histories, by what happened to us a long time ago, the more our life becomes the stories of a victim.

We have to, you know, give up that victim mentality and take control. And we can do that to a lesser degree, not complete, not all at once. But there are possibilities, openings, opportunities. We have a very special life. We have what is traditionally termed a life of leisure and fortune, richnesses, endowments, freedoms and opportunities.

Lots of different ways of expressing that. We are quite fortunate, even in terms of the general overall circumstances of the people on the planet. We have all our material necessities easily met. We don’t have to work all that hard like most of the people on the planet do. There are millions and billions of people who go to bed hungry, who don’t have the freedom and opportunity to be doing what we do, either in terms of the material or social or economic.

There’s all these restrictions on what the limitations which are placed upon their lives. I guess we have to read, from time to time we have to count our blessings, don’t we? So we don’t take it for granted. This life of freedom and richness, which we all unknowingly or unappreciatively all have in some way or another. So we all have the outward circumstances, but we also have the seeds of the person that we want to become within us at present.

It’s simply a matter of nurturing. It’s all there. And then we’re not trying to become somebody other than who we are. And it’s not becoming more of who we are, who we already are. And I guess not settling for a life of emptiness, hypocrisy, meaninglessness, and all, you know, what passes for life, a substitute kind of life.

And I, you know, I think we should need a balanced life in a sense that having the good things of life in terms of significant relationships, very important. And all the material good things of life, a nice home, car. Okay. All these things are important. A job which you find meaning and purpose and value in doing what you do.

But over and above that, making these kind of inner changes. And without we can have all the good things of the world, you know, if it how we can have a poverty mentality. Always wanting more is never enough. Or we can have almost nothing but feel richness in our being. And we have enough because of who I am, not what I have.

So I think we’re quite fortunate, both in terms of the general quality of our lives, having all these freedoms and richnesses and so forth, also having some, you know, being inspired in some small way, to a lesser or greater degree, to work with our minds. The mind is its own place, and in itself can make a Heaven of Hell, a Hell of Heaven. Know, recognizing that if only to a small extent, and determining to bring about changes within our mind. And we have some really profound methods. And it’s quite a rare juxtaposition of lots and lots and lots and lots of variables which have come together to be in a situation that we all have, which we, perhaps to a large degree, take for granted.

It’s not going to last forever. We’re all going to die. And what do you do? What do we do? You know, this person is going to whose life is going to stop.

What are we going to do between the present and when that life stops? How are we going to live out that time? What kind of experience do we want to create for ourselves? To a large extent, it is in our control. If we take control.

If we don’t, then it’s not. If you deny your freedom of choice often enough, it’s as if you didn’t have it. It’s not there. It’s not available to you any longer. And then you simply become an expression of past habits in the context of the present way that the circumstances are pushing and pulling you in terms of your environment, in terms of social situation.

But there is no conscious choice involved. So we stop yielding to the forces of our circumstances and begin to choose. And we would begin to take conscious choice rather than having the momentum of our past unconscious habits simply perpetuate themselves definitely into the future. Just for one moment, you know, maybe that’s all we can do. Just for moment to moment make conscious choices for ourselves.

We don’t know what’s going to happen in the future, but just for now, we sit here at Buddha House on a Monday night making some kind of choice just for now, that what I’m doing, I’m doing to become that better person, to express those values and be able to lead that kind of life that I want for myself. But over and above that, I’d like to do that if for only one other person. And I’m beginning to step out of exaggerated self preoccupations with only ourselves, just for a moment, be there there with somebody else. That what we’re doing, I’m doing it for you as well, this one of the prisons. So making a choice of the path of heart.

And then, you know, that’s all we can do. Keep making choices. So choices are intention. Intention is karma. And out of our choice, we create our future.

So this process of choosing the inner focus of life we call Buddha, which we need to actually the work to bring that about, in fact, which is the Dharma. And this occurs within the social context. Those who inspire us and support us in our choices, help us to make the choices, the courage to make the choices, and the willingness to be consistent. And it is a consistent choice of the path of heart, which the Bodhisattva is different than the ordinary person. One knows that one is choosing the path of heart, when there is a feeling of oneness with yourself and the people about you.

There is a healing in the division of the schism within the depth of our being. I think our life is elevated to a higher order of being. I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha through my practice generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I’m awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings.

I go for refuge until I am awakened to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. Through my practice of generosity and the other perfections, may I become a Buddha for the sake of all sentient beings. May all sentient beings have happiness in the causes of happiness. May all sentient beings be free from suffering in the causes of suffering. May all sentient beings be inseparable from from the joy that is without sorrow.

May all sentient beings abide in equanimity, free from attachment for some and aversion toward others. Thus did I hear at one time that Bhagavan was dwelling on Vulture Peak mountain in Rajgirha together with a great community of monks and a great community of bodhisattvas. At that time the Bhagavan was absorbed in the concentration on the categories of phenomena called profound perception. Also at that time the bodhisattva, Mahāsattva Ārya Avalokiteśvara, looked upon the very practice of the profound perfection of wisdom and beheld those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature. Then through the power of the Buddha, the Venerable Śāriputra said this to the bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, Śāriputra how should any son of the lineage train who wishes to practice their activities of profound perfection of wisdom?

He said that, and the Venerable Śāriputra. Śāriputra, any son of the lineage or daughter of the lineage who wishes to practice the activities that profound perfection of wisdom should look upon it like this, correctly and repeatedly, beholding those aggregates also as empty of inherent nature. Form is empty. Emptiness is form. Emptiness is not other than form.

Form is also not other than emptiness. In the same way, feeling, discrimination, compositional factors, and consciousness are empty. Śāriputra, likewise all phenomena are emptiness, without characteristics, unproduced, unceased, stainless, not without stain, not deficient, not fulfilled. Śāriputra, therefore in emptiness, there is no form, no feeling, no discrimination, no compositional factors, no consciousness, no eye, no ear, no nose, no tongue, no body, no mind, no visual form, no sound, no odor, no taste, no object of touch, and no phenomena. There is no eye element and so on up to and including no mind element and no mental consciousness element.

There is no ignorance, no extinction of ignorance and so on up to and including ageing and death. There is no suffering, origination, cessation, and path. There is no exalted wisdom, no attainment, and also no non attainment. Shari Putra, therefore, because there is no attainment, bodhisattvas rely on and dwell in the perfection of wisdom, the mind without obstruction and without fear. Having completely passed beyond error, they reach the endpoint of nirvana.

All the Buddhas who dwell in the three times also manifestly completely awakened to unsurpassable, perfect, complete enlightenment in reliance on the perfection of wisdom. Therefore, the mantra of perfection of wisdom, the mantra of great knowledge, the unsurpassed mantra, the mantra equal to the unequaled, the mantra that purely should be known as the truth since it is not false. The mantra of perfection of wisdom is declared, Śāriputra, the Bodhisattva, mahasattva should train in the profound wisdom. Then the Bhagavan arose from that concentration and commanded the Bodhisattva, Mahāsattva Ārya Avalokiteśvara, saying, well said, well said, son of the lineage. It is like that.

It is like that. One should practice the profound perfection of wisdom just as you have indicated. Even the Tathagatas rejoice. The Bhagawan, having thus spoken, the Venerable Śāriputra, the Bodhisattva, Mahāsattva Ārya Avalokiteśvara, those surrounded in their entirety along with the world of gods, humans, asuras, and Gandharvas, were rejoiced and highly praised what was spoken by the Bhagavan. Should we stand up and stretch for a moment?

I thought we would meditate on loving kindness. Begin by taking firm posture. Most essentially, just a posture where you feel stability. You can maintain for some time without moving, but also when it’s comfortable. So finding some balance within that.

We’ll begin with the process of becoming aware of and relaxing the body. So starting at the crown of your head, the scalp. Feeling the wrinkles in your forehead, your brow beginning to smooth out. The pressure in in and around your eyes diminishing. Muscles of the face softening, relaxing.

Jaw is relaxed. Bringing awareness to the back of the neck and gently turning your head to each side a few times, stretching, loosening the muscles of the back of the neck. Relaxing the muscles of the throat. Bring your awareness to your upper back and shoulders. Perhaps rotating your shoulders a few times.

Lifting them and just allowing them to drop comfortably to the sides, feeling a burden or a weight that we oftentimes carry around on our backs moving down and through your body into the ground. Bringing your awareness all the way down to your hands. Your hands are soft and loose. Relaxing your lower arms and your upper arms. And chest chest is at ease.

Relaxing throughout the heart area. In the lungs, the central region of the back, the stomach, Letting go of the tension that we hold in our stomach muscles, just allow your belly to go soft. Relaxing throughout the abdominal cavity. Keeping your back straight, your trunk erect, relax your lower back muscles. To keep your back straight, your spine straight, it gives you an opportunity to relax your lower back muscles.

We hold a lot of tension there. Your buttocks. Upper legs. Lower legs. Finally, feet is soft, loose.

Bringing awareness to your body in general, just roughly scanning through your body. Noticing any tightness or any tensions within the body, perhaps some areas of discomfort. And focusing upon those areas, breathing into those areas and breathing out from those areas, feeling the tension diminish, the tightness loosen. If there is an area of discomfort, don’t try to avoid it or but don’t struggle against it. It’s like a mother and a little child who’s hurt.

Breathe into that discomfort surrounding with a caring, kind acceptance. It’s part of who you are at present. Be kind to yourself. Breathing into the area. Breathing out, feeling the discomfort diminish.

Breathing into the tightness, feeling the tightness loosen. Breathing into the tension, breathing out from the tension, feeling it diminish. Breathing in, breathing out, the body becoming comfortable, at ease, the feeling of physical well-being pervading every cell of your body. Nowhere to go, nothing to do for a while, nothing that needs to be thought of. No one to please.

Just give yourself a break just for a few moments. Accepting and dwelling within the present moment to just be your body, to stay with your body. Just stay with your body. And we’ll practice the breathing exercise, breathing in comfortably, normally, breathing out, extending the exhalation, completely emptying the lungs, forcing all the air out of the lungs gently. Breathing in normally, comfortably.

Breathing out, extending exhalation. And bring your mind to the breath, the gentle in and out flow, the natural breath. If it’s helpful, you can use the techniques of counting and noting the breaths, noting the distractions, consistently choosing to bring the mind back to the breath. Bring your mind to the breath. We’re going to meditate on loving kindness, and we’re going to begin with ourselves.

Whatever mistakes you feel you may have created in the past, you can simply develop a healthy sense of regret, and you can begin again. And whatever you want to become in the future, you can do that, you can become that. But just for this present moment, we want to make friends with ourselves, all the various parts of ourselves, be kind to ourselves, and wish ourselves well. So just generate and direct some kind, caring feelings towards yourself, wishing yourself the good things of life. May I be happy.

May I be at peace. May all go well. May I be healthy. Just generate and direct toward yourself some kind, caring feelings. Be kind to yourself.

Wish yourself well. Now think of someone that you like, that you love, and bring that person to mind. If you can see them, that’s great, but if you can’t, it doesn’t matter. It’s not so important. Just feel it.

These feelings that you’re developing are being directed toward them. Remember some the kindnesses that this person has shown you, some of the ways in which you’ve shared happiness together. And begin to direct out toward this person the kind, caring feelings which naturally arise when you think of this person in this way. The feelings are wishing them to be happy. May you be happy.

May all the good things of life be yours. May you be well. May you be at peace. Wish them well. Wish them happiness.

Now think of someone you have no particular connection to, maybe a stranger of some sort, someone that you see from time to time, maybe in a shop or on the street or at work. You don’t know this person’s story, but the one thing you do know about them is that they want to be happy and they don’t want to suffer. That much you do know about them. In that way, they’re just like yourself. Simply, of a sense of generosity, there’s enough happiness to go around for us all.

And out of the goodness of your heart, just wish them well. Wish them that they had that happiness. It won’t cost you anything. He will make you glad in your heart. Wish them well.

Wish them happiness. Now think of someone that you have some problems with, some difficulties, someone perhaps you don’t like. Imagine that person there in front of you. This person wants to be happy and doesn’t want to suffer just like yourself. Perhaps their way of about finding their happiness and solving their problems is come in conflict with your methods, finding your own happiness and solving your own problems.

It’s just a conflict of self interest. And just as you have to begin to forgive yourself for the mistakes that you perhaps made in the past, maybe it’s time to begin to forgive this person. So just for this present moment, set aside your hurt or grudge, and try to see someone very much like yourself doing the best they can to get some happiness out of life, and oftentimes making many mistakes along the way. And just for this moment, let go. Forgive.

If you’re ever going to be free, we have to learn how to forgive, to let go. Just for this moment, let go and wish them well. That’s all. Just for this moment. Make a choice.

Choose love. And then all the people in this room, you know, people who are taking responsibility for their lives, for their happiness, and exploring, searching other possibilities. Wish that everyone in the room had whatever it is they’re looking for, whatever it might be, whatever would bring them happy, whatever would solve their problem, wish that they had it. Just generate and direct out a wish of happiness and well-being to everyone in the room. Extending this wish out to all the Burnside and people in their homes cooking, eating, watching television, getting ready for the bed.

People on the streets, cars, and shops. It to reach out to all of Adelaide. People in department stores, offices, and factories, in their homes, and buses, and trains, and cars, walking along. Extending his wish out further and further to all of South Australia, all the little towns, all the isolated homes. Melbourne, Hobart, Sydney, Brisbane, Cairns, Alice Springs, Darwin, Perth, the entire country.

However, you might imagine that. Extend that wish. Eastward to New Zealand and northward to East Timor and Indonesia, Singapore and Malaysia. Southeast Asia, all of Asia, And westward to Europe. The the entire world into your heart.

All the people, black, white, red, yellow, all the animals, all the insects, everything that lives on the earth is touched by a wish that they be happy, that they not not suffer. And extending this wish out in all the directions of space. And further without any limits, without any feelings of limitation. Without any boundaries, without any center, pervading all of infinite space, I wish we all be happy. May there be only happiness.

May there be peace. Just vast, infinite open space and a deep wish of peace. This vast, infinite space. And I wish you peace. And then bring your mind back to the breath.

And get in touch with your body, perhaps the pressure of your buttocks on the cushion, on the chair, just some feeling sensation within the body. In an easy and relaxed manner, slowly become aware of your surrounding. So if like to stand up and stretch, you’re welcome. We’re looking at a particular level of understanding the deeper nature of reality in terms of the self, the I, the person. It’s called the Hearers’ stage.

And here at the hearer stage, we’re not calling into question the things about us, the various desirable and undesirable objects that we get involved with. We accept those as existing objectively, much as they appear to us, solid, concrete. And we, on our part, are simply passive observers, like a mirror, simply reflecting what’s already there. That’s the notion at this level of how we relate with the world about us. The only thing that we call into question is the I, the Self, the person.

That we call into question. And we’re calling into question because essentially we’re making some basic mistakes around its nature, and this is the factor of ignorance. Due to this misconception, this wrong belief in the nature of the Self, believing in a partless, unchanging, independent Self, we go on to create all the various sufferings that we do. Ignorance is the origin of suffering. Believing in a concrete, solid I, we then go in conjunction with our self attachment, self centeredness, develop an absolute distinction between self and other.

There’s me versus the world. Anything we see as a threat, anything out there which is seen as a threat to this self, this now misconceived self, we develop a hostility. Anything which we see as enhancing this self, we want to make it, we develop attachment, we want to make it a permanent part of mind. So all of these movements of the mind, in terms of hostility and attachment, all rise on the basic misconception of ignorance, and misconception as to the nature of the I the Self. And here at this level, the hearer stage, it’s particularly characterized by the Self being conceived as partless, unchanging and independent.

So that’s what we’re analyzing at this level. We’re going to go on to analyze it at a more subtle level. You know, as we move through the stages, this is the we are looking at now. Last week we talked about, we analyzed some of these terms, partless, unchanging, independent. And again, to be emphasized that we have to make a distinction between our rational, analytic conception of itself, the I.

If we reasonably and analytically and rationally analyze itself, we wouldn’t conceive of the self as being partless, unchanging, independent. But we’re talking about an emotional response, a non analytic, non rational conception of the Self, not a reason analytic conception of the Self. Okay? So it becomes most apparent when we become strongly emotional that we are grasping to and holding on to a notion that we, the I, the Self, is partless, unchanged, existent. This is our emotional reaction.

It becomes most apparent when we have strong emotions. We said that in terms of partless, there is a singularity, at the core of our being there is an indistinct, homogenous unit. I hate you. I can’t stand you. That I, it doesn’t have any distinctions.

It’s a singularity. It’s unchanging. That I ness has always been there, consistently and constantly, without changing, since I was a child, then I moved to such and such a place, grew up in such and such, and I got married. That I ness does not change you from moment to moment. It’s independent.

Doesn’t seem to depend upon, rely upon its existence on the body, on the mind, on conditions, on our culture, on our society, on values. It seems to be independent. I can’t live without you. I I have to have you. That I, a solid, concrete, independent, isolated entity at the core of our being.

We have a self We’re questioning, we’re calling it a question whether that self exists or not. We believe at a deep level of our being that it does. This is ignorance. in dependence upon the belief, all the other movements of the mind in terms of attachment and hostility arise. There’s always something there that needs to be defended, something which consistently needs to be confirmed.

Our life is preoccupied with the struggle with regard to enhancing or defending what is in fact a hallucinated Self. Now, in all of this discussion, we’re not saying that the I or the person, the Self does not exist. It does. Yeah? I am speaking.

Maybe you are listening. I am a male. I was born in the United States. Do all these I eat, I talk, I walk, I do all these various activities, I function in various ways. This body and mind over here I call I, that body over there I over there I call you, you call it I, I call it you.

As long as you don’t get confused, we’ll be okay. There’s no problem. It is the misconceived I that we’re talking about, that I which is conceived over, held by ignorance. It has these qualities. So that’s what we’re looking at.

That’s what we’re trying to analyze. We have a self representation, we have a model of such an I. And As we talked about again and again, just because we can conceive of something doesn’t mean it exists. Just because something appeared just like that snake, where in fact there is a rope, doesn’t mean there is a snake there. There is an appearance of an I, is apart of its unchained independent.

That appearance exists, that self representation characterized in this way exists, that model of a type of self exists. But it doesn’t correspond to any findable reality, just like Tolkien’s map of Middle Earth. No matter how you try to follow that map, you’re never going to find anything which corresponds to reality. No matter how much we have to find, what we’re going to do by using what I call the Four Essentials, is we have a model, we have a conception, we have a self representation, like a map. And what we want to do is to see if in fact it corresponds to any findable reality.

If we consistently come to see that it doesn’t correspond to any findable reality, the appearance can remain, but will slowly diminish our grasping at the truth of that I. Just like the snake, the conditions might remain such that the snake continues to appear, but because we’ve analyzed it, we know it’s a appearance, rising dependence upon circumstances like there’s a there’s a coil stripe or rope, and the the light is dimming and so forth. Due to certain circumstances, there’s an appearance. But then it’s a false appearance. There’s nothing which corresponds to it in a final reality.

There’s an appearance of a partless unchanging independent I, due to circumstances, mainly due to the circumstances of ignorance, but also the ingrained tendencies from the past. That the I appears innately, instinctively. So we have to search, does that appearance correspond to any findable reality? If we do that consistently enough, if we contradict that appearance enough, we’ll slowly not believe in the reality, the truth of that appearance. It will no longer have the same influence.

Its influence on the way that we think and the way we act will diminish in force until we can actually remove that appearance altogether. So this is what we’re doing. This is what we’re going to do. So we have to proceed in investigation of that appearance. And the means that we’re going to use is called the Four Essentials.

Tsongkhapa says this is like a foolproof method for proceeding in this analysis, in this search, in this investigation. Just like poking around with a stick and torch, where there’s an appearance of a snake. Our stick and torch are the four essentials. We’re going to make use of. We’re going to investigate whether or not such a type of self, as it appears to us, actually exists in reality or not.

Can that Self, which normally appears to us, withstand analysis? It is, if we search for it, will we actually find it? We’ve never really found it. We just assume it exists. We’ve never even thought about it.

So, you know, for a knowledge to go beyond misconception and mere speculation, it has to be based upon a disciplined, systematic observation and investigation into the nature of the object that, in this case, misconceived self. So this is the method we’re going to make use of. We’re going to go through this, we’re going to begin to go through this tonight. We’re talking about one particular level of ignorance, one particular level of misconception. I don’t mean to make this and if you could understand this, your life would be radically altered the way you approach your life.

It would transform your life. So when I say it’s one particular level, it’s an extremely profound level. That’s where we begin to look at this. So, the four essentials. The essential of ascertaining and then we are going go through all these.

These words probably sound rather strange. I mean, they sound strange to me even now, but anyway. They sound rather foreign and alien. We are going break them down and find out what their meanings are. The four essentials.

Sometimes there is this term, the four point analysis, the four keys, different names. It is essentially the same. The Essential of Ascertaining the Object of Negation, The Essential of Ascertaining the Pervasion, The Essential of Ascertaining the Lack of Being the Same, and The Essential of Ascertaining the Lack of being different. So we’re going work through this. This is our method of analysis.

Wisdom is an analytic consciousness. It is trying to penetrate, and here trying to penetrate the deeper nature of the way things exist. It’s an investigative quality of mind that is able to perform that function we call wisdom. So the first of these four essentials is ascertaining the object of negation. Object of negation means another word is object to be refuted.

The object to be refuted, the object to be negated. It is the most important, and I’m sorry to say, most difficult of all these four essentials. Which is too bad, but what are going do? That’s Samsāra, what are you going do? Do?

The most important thing. Start at the bottom and work our way out. What do we mean by negation? Negate. Negate means to refute.

To the self. What was that? Was just going take it into to know the nonexistent self, that’s great. To know the nonexistent. Yep, pencil.

No, that’s good. No, no, you’re exactly right. There’s an object and we want to know its nonexistent. But we have to know what it is that we’re trying to establish the nonexistence. That’s the bone in the fish.

Anyway, at this point in the analysis, we want to gain a clear picture of the way the partless unchanging, independent self appears to us. How does that self normally appear to us? We have to be able to identify that first intellectually, but then within our own experience. Just like with regard to that snake, there’s an appearance. And due to that appearance we react with aversion and hostility and fear and so forth.

So there’s an appearance which we react to because we believe it to be true. In order to find the absence of snake, in order to investigate, we have to know what it is that doesn’t exist. What are we looking for? If we’re going to search for something, we have to know what it is that we’re looking for. Otherwise, its non finding won’t make a damn bit of difference to us.

Such a type of self does not exist, but its appearance does. There is a model of such a type of self, a self representation, a concept of such a type of self. How does that self appear? You know, and just as the appearance of a of a snake exists, when in fact there is only a coil of rope. There is the appearance of a partless unchanging independent self, though in fact no such type of self exists.

So one of the keys to understanding, coming to understand selflessness is, or emptiness, they’re both negations, refutations, that is, the establishment of the non existence of something. We have to understand what it is that doesn’t exist. How do we understand that? By understanding its non findability upon analysis. Non findability.

That’s the key. At the depth of our being, we believe something to exist, and we search for it. We know what we’re looking for. We search in every possible means, without leaving any stone unturned, as it were. There’s no other possibility.

We don’t find it. If that search has enough intensity, and is methodical enough, systematic enough, the non finding of what we believe to exist will have an earth shaking effect on us. If that doesn’t exist, then nothing exists. It is a prerequisite to any real search that we have to know what it is that we are looking for. The clearer we know what we are looking for, the greater will be our conviction in its non existence.

And the impact upon being able to find it where it should be. You know, not being able to find it where it should be will begin to shake our conception that it does exist. At the depth of our being, you believe there’s a snake there. The non finding of that snake, the in the absence of that snake, the non existent snake, has the potency, the ability negate, to remove, to act as an antidote to the conception that a snake is there. If you don’t know quite what you’re looking for, then there’s no real coming to some conclusion of any particular thing not existing.

If we do not identify clearly the appearance of an independently existent self, of a partless, unchanging, independent self, or I, the analysis cannot proceed for the reason that either there is no actual object being searched for or because we have only a vague and blurry image. And its non finding ability will not possess the strength and conviction to overcome our deeply ingrained conception that it does exist. So, you know, normally we focus upon our when we have an experience, we focus upon the object of our experience. Yeah? When you’re both positive and negative emotions, you know.

I love you. That’s beautiful. I can’t stand you. Whatever. The focus of our attention is on the object.

Here, what we have to do is we have to we are trying to bring to conscious awareness an unconsciously held model of a type of self upon which most of our emotional life depends, most of our thinking depends. An unconsciously ly held model, all which is founded upon, our emotional life is founded upon a model of a type of self, and which acts as the root cause of our suffering. In order to realize that such a model is baseless, that it doesn’t correspond to anything. Since there’s nothing, there’s no reference in reality which corresponds to it. You know, just like Tolkien’s map.

So we’re setting up a target, you know, and we’re going to shoot our arrow of reasoned analysis and observation at. So the analysis is only effective to the degree that we’re able to identify within our own experience this appearance of the model. This is the most difficult part. We are not trying to identify empirical self, the conventionally existent self. It’s important to keep making that kind of distinction.

The I that is talking, the I that is listening, the I that walks, talks, eats is a male, born in the United States. We’re not trying to identify that is what we call the empirical self, or the empirical I, or the conventionally existent I, the conventionally existent self. We’re not trying to identify that. This self is not a problem. It’s to you that’s a problem.

And this self cannot be negated because negation means to come to establish its nonexistence. We can’t establish the nonexistence of something that exists. What appears to exist in reality does not, in the course of analysis, becomes more and more apparent, more and more obvious to ourselves. What is what well, on the other hand, what appears to exist, and which in fact does exist, will become more apparent upon analysis, will become more obvious upon analysis. You know, just like this snake in the rope and so forth.

So the essential in ascertaining the object negation is to identify the self or the I which is wrongly presumed to exist. So we have to, you know, this is the real skill around coming to a real, you know, first we’re going to do this, initially it’s an intellectual exercise, isn’t it? We’re at the listening stage. We’re getting together all the facts, the methods, we’re learning the terms, the overall concept of the teachings, how they relate. Then we to be able to take what is simply a reasoned analysis and an intellectual description, partless, unchanging, independent, and begin to gain an experiential sense of what that means in terms of our own experience.

You know, what how how is the self actually I hate I I hate you. How is it appearing? Appearing? Can we identify that within our own experience? These are like pointers trying to give us some indication of what it is we are trying to get at, what we are trying to see.

But you can’t just be satisfied. You know, like when somebody points to the painting, you know, don’t get hum up in the finger. What is that finger trying to refer refer you to? There’s something at the core of our being. We have a model of a Self.

And this model is characterized the Self which is being representative in this model is characterized by being partless, unchanged, independent. How do you experience that partless, unchanged, independent self? We have to be able to identify it in terms of our experience. So what we do is calm the mind. That in itself is no difficult, is no easy feat.

Calm the mind. And we remember some type of great fear, or we imagine some emotional experience when you had an accident or you had a broken relationship. Or maybe it could be a happy experience, you you just won the Nobel Prize. Don’t know, maybe somebody in here, I don’t know. Anyway, something has an association with a very strong emotional feeling tone to it.

Then we kind of relive that experience as best we can. So initially we analyze that experience as being good or bad or wrong or right or anything. We’re just trying to relive that emotional experience within the controlled laboratory of our meditation. We just want to feel the fear, or maybe the depression, or the happiness. Activating the strong emotions will cause a strong sense of I to arise.

You know, I’m scared. You when you were just about to have an accident. You know, we have to use words, don’t we? I’m scared. When you’re scared you usually don’t think, we don’t usually have those words running through our head, I’m scared, you are the fear.

But we talk about it in this way, okay? Or I feel terrible. What is it? Okay? You might think, I’m a terrible person, but actually there’s a feeling, an emotion of feeling bad about yourself.

There’s some kind of special feeling. I’m so happy. Happiness is not the words I’m so happy, but there’s a happy feeling there, a strong emotion. So you cause that to arise. Observe.

Now, this is the difficult part. Trying to Okay, I’m just describing this to you, and it’s something that you’re going work with. And we’re going to work with all of these. And we’re going to work with reasoning and intellect and dialectics. So, you know, this first part is not easy.

We’re just describing the whole thing, process. A part of our mind is like a spy. While the emotion is occurring, while you’re experiencing fear. That’s why in like in it’s said that these great yogis, they they meditate on the edge of a cliff. You know, they sit there and they look over the edge of a cliff.

Some kind of fear arises. Or they meditate at the edge of a well, and they’re looking over it, some kind of fear arises. You know, think the Dalai Lama’s brother once said, Ngarig Rinpoche, he was a member of the Indian Army paratroopers. Used to say, Jumping out of an airplane is a great time to meditate on the I. A very strong sense of I arises in these powerful emotions, associated with these emotions.

To we want So a part of our mind is observing. This the skill. The emotion is still occurring, occurring. Part of our mind is watching the object. Usually we are caught up in the object of our experience, right?

The snake. But here we want to observe the subject of the experience. Who is the I that’s so afraid? Who is the I that’s so depressed? Who is the I that’s so happy?

Normally all of our attention is being directed toward the object. I hate you. Here, is that I that’s doing that hating, what does that look like? While the emotion is still manifesting in the mind, a part of awareness is investigating, observing, what does that I look like? So, there’s analysis that’s going on.

There’s an identification process. It’s like a spy, a process of observing. In the course of this, errors will arise. Some people, when they generate a sense of ‘I’, by means of strong emotions, some kind of strong feelings, then they make an effort to determine how this Self, how they experience, how they sense this Self. And at the time of the analysis, this kind of a darkness appears to them, a blankness appears.

So this only happens sometimes. It doesn’t happen to everyone. It’s neither good nor bad. It simply is a result of the mental force. First, you allow the emotion to develop, going over what this person does, he he did this, over here, you know, really, really getting into it.

But then you have to have the presence of mind so you’re not lost in the emotion that part of your mind is going to spy. Now what happens is we’re like a bull in a china shop. There’s inability of our ability to maintain that emotion while at the same time observing. We will interrupt the process, the emotion. Our mind will go blank.

There certain exertion or force of effort in the moment when you decide to analyze, when you decide to observe, which will interrupt the emotion, and you are left with a blank, with a kind of darkness. Okay? That’s simply the subtle mental force which people apply when they attempt to explore the nature of the I. So they aren’t subtle enough in attempting to identify the subject of the experience. Others might experience experience a kind of tension or a kind of tautness within their body.

So this tension, this tautness is not the object of negation. It’s simply the result of the sudden concentration of the mind. You know, when all of a sudden you go to observe the I, investigate. It’s the result of the investigative effort. It’s not subtle enough.

You know, a tightening of the muscles disturbs the circulation of the wind energies in the body. So you have a strong sense of the body. In the case of other people, only maybe the physical body appears. That’s because the I is normally associated, to a great extent, with the body. But the conventional existent self is closely related with the body, and so when one attempts this kind of fine analysis, it seems if only the body appears.

In other cases, when we attempt to locate the Self, to observe that Self, nothing at all may be experienced. This is the result of beginning the analysis too late. So this is really a skill. Have to be If our analysis You generate emotion, the fear, having the presence of mind, some point while the emotion is still manifesting, to identify the subject of that emotion, to observe without two things: interrupting the emotion, or losing your complete awareness and lost in the emotion. If it’s too strong, you interrupt the emotion.

If it’s too subtle or too weak, or if there’s no analysis, then you’re just getting uptight. You’re just experiencing fear for no reason at all. You’re not meditating. We’re using a part of our mind to observe another part of our mind, that part of the mind which is holding on to the sense of an I, how does that I appear? If a sense of I does not arise, then you simply calm the mind, relax the mind and then start all over again, generating an I.

I am angry. I can’t. Oh, if he ever does that again, I’m going to kill him. I’m not going take this anger. I just That I.

So try to get a sense of it, a feeling, a sense, the impression that you have. This is the first of the four essentials, the essential of ascertaining the object of negation. Does that make any sense? Okay, I don’t want to dishearten you. We’re going to get an intellectual understanding of this process.

This is like a lifetime’s work. Even just intellectual understanding is going to diminish the force of ignorance, if you’re mindful. I don’t want you to get disheartened if you try this a few times and you don’t get anywhere. That’s all I’m saying. Just the intellectual understanding, working with these ideas is going to be of real value.

And then from time to time actually we’re working with it. But it doesn’t even have to be always within your meditation session, you know, when we’re getting emotional throughout the course of our day. And you can take that as an opportunity to get a sense of what’s behind that experience, subjective aspect of that experience. Anyway, think as we go through it will become a little more We’ll see how it fits in with this framework. And even this intellectual explanation will help you get a handle on what we’re on about, what we’re working toward.

The first of the four essentials: essential of ascertaining the object and negation, identifying the object, the partless unchanging independent I or self. How do I experience that? How does it appear to me? That’s the most difficult and the most important. The second, okay?

We’ll look at it next week. The second, the Essential of Ascertaining the Pervasion. This is what we call a commitment to binary logic or excluded middle. Excluded middle. Either A or not A.

There’s not there’s not A or not ‘e’. There’s no third possibility. Do we mean by that? Either ‘e’ or not ‘e’. Whatever existence we may examine, must necessarily be included in either of two categories.

Either it is singular or it is plural. Either it is one or many. Either it is the same or different. Okay? Like, we’ll take this for a singular or plural.

No matter what you, no matter what it may be, it is either singular or plural. It could be a table, a flower, a whiteboard, a person, a universe, an army. These are all singular. Or it could be plural. It could be a table and a chair.

It could be body and mind. It could be Tom, Dick and Harry. Those a plural. Anything that anything that any phenomena that we that we take must exist on either of these two categories. It cannot exist.

That it extends to all known phenomena. These two categories, it’s exhaustive. So, having ascertained the object of negation at the first essential, we really know what the I looks like, right? We really identify the appearance of a part of this unchanging independent self. We are going to analyze whether this identified self is the same as the body and mind or is different than the body and mind.

And we have to, you know, we have to be convinced that there’s no third possibility. We identify this I, this Self. We have a model, we an appearance of an I. Does that I correspond to any findable reality? Where does that I appear?

It appears in the vicinity of the body and mind. If we’re going to search, we search for an object where it’s appearing to exist. If I was looking for my eye, I wouldn’t look in the kitchen right now. I’d look on this seat. That’s where I would look, because that’s where it’s appearing.

You know, if I’m looking for whether that snake exists or not, and it’s over there, I search over here. I look at the vicinity where the object is appearing to see whether there is any findable reality that corresponds to it. So we identified an appearance of a part of this unchanging, independent self. Where does it appear? It appears somewhere over here.

We don’t quite know what it’s all about yet, but it seems to be over here somewhere, in this vicinity. So we have to commit ourselves to this idea that if that Self exists, it must be either the same as the body and mind, or it must be different than the body and mind. There is no third possible place, way that it could exist. We want to make sure there’s no way out for our mind, some way it can squeeze out of coming to a firm conviction, an inalterable conclusion. Oh, maybe there’s a third possibility.

I search in the body of mind, I search outside the body of mind, but maybe there’s probably another way it exists. Then it doesn’t affect, it doesn’t have any force or conception of ignorance. The independently Somebody might say, Oh, okay, maybe it’s both. It’s both the same and different than the body and mind. It’s kind of a mixture.

But that’s no real possibility. For example, is a mixture of chili and sugar the same or different than sugar? Is a mixture of chili and sugar the same or different than sugar? Well, if you invite me over for a cup of coffee and you ask me if you want sugar, I sure don’t want the mixture of sugar and chili. So sugar and chili is different than sugar, isn’t it?

Sugar and chili is not sugar. It’s not the same as sugar. Okay? I realize this sounds almost simple minded, but it’s necessary to go through this simple minded process. A mixture of sugar and chili is definitely not the same as sugar.

It is different than sugar. So if the independently existing itself, it must either exist the same as the body and mind or it’s different than the body and mind. We have to go through the trouble of seeing it for ourselves, that, yeah, I agree. If it exists, it necessarily exists in one of these two ways. If it does not exist in either of these two ways, it doesn’t exist at all.

That’s what we have to become convinced at. If the independent existent self that I identified, if it exists, it must exist as either the same as the body and mind or different than the body and mind. If it doesn’t exist as the same as the body and mind or it doesn’t exist as being different than the body and mind, it doesn’t exist at all. There’s no third possibility that way we could exist. Those two ways of existing exhaust all possible ways of existing.

Place where the independent self appears is in the vicinity of the body and the mind. If the independent existence itself is something more than a mere appearance, but in fact exists, then upon searching the place of the body and mind, we should be able to find it, if it exists. And if it exists, it must either exist as either the same as the body and mind or different than the body and mind. It has to exist in one of those two ways, if it in fact exists. So this is the essence of the second essential.

Determining that this partless, unchanging, independent self, which appears to in fact exist, if it’s it’s simply more than an appearance, if it’s something more than just an appearance, then if it actually in fact exists, it must exist either the same as the body and mind or different as the body and mind. There is no third possible way that it could exist. Why? Because over the remaining two essentials, we’re going to test just those two possible ways of existing. If if we if we understand that it must exist in either of these two ways, we’re convinced it must exist in either of two ways, upon searching it as being the same as the body and mind, we find it doesn’t exist.

Upon searching it as being different than the body and mind, we find it doesn’t exist, the mind must conclude, though it appears, it doesn’t exist at all. There’s appearance, but there’s nothing findable which corresponds to that appearance. That understanding, that is a wisdom consciousness, and that, upon analysis, is an understanding of selflessness. When you’re working through that method, that systematic analysis comes to that conclusion that what appears is not findable. There is an absence, in fact, of such a type of self.

That is a wisdom understanding selflessness. So we’re going to going to So next week, we’ll start on the third, okay? This is the Essential of Ascertaining. It’s kind of fun, the third and fourth. The first one is difficult, I’m afraid.

If you get the first one, the rest is piece of cake. Anyway, even an intellectual understanding, I think, is quite useful. Next week we’ll take up the third and fourth essentials. Any questions around this or comments? The third one’s easier?

The first one I understood what you’re talking about, but my second one. Oh, second one. Okay, so if you have Because I wasn’t sure what the right answer was. Is it that it is the same or is it that what’s the answer that went after? No.

If you have let’s say this is what we identified as being the partless, unchanged, independent self, okay? We identified that. So we have this is the body, this is mind. So if have a sheep, a goat, a sheep, a goat and a cow in a pen, if you remove the sheep and the goat, you should be left with a cow. So we have a body and mind, and we have at least the appearance of an independent existent self.

Now, if we can come to understand that the body and mind are not the independent existent self, they are not the same. And then at the fourth essential, if we search and we set aside the body, we set aside the mind, we should be left with a cow. We should be left with the independent self. Independent self must either be the same as the body and mind, identical in every way, or it must be different, even the slightest different than the body and mind. So there’s no third possible way it can exist.

And then we’re going to proceed to see whether that independent self is the same as the body and mind, identical to the body and mind, or whether it’s different than the body and mind. If we search in those two ways, there’s no third possible way it can exist. If it exists, it must be one of those two. We’re going to search and we’re going to we’re going to find it’s not the same as the body and the mind, nor is it different than the body and the mind. If it in fact exists, it must be one of those two.

And I’ve established it’s not the same, and I established it’s not different, I can only come to the conclusion that it doesn’t exist. It appears, but that appearance is false. Just like the snake. The snake appears, but there’s nothing which corresponds it. It’s a mistake in appearance.

It’s a false appearance. If you keep doing this enough, you know, it’s like a phony, you know, somebody who you know lies a lot. The first couple of times they say something, you believe them. You trust them and you go along with them. Then after a while you begin to say, well, I don’t trust him as much.

You know, he keeps contradicting. You know, my experience contradicts what he says. After a while, keeps talking, he keeps saying these lines, you know, you don’t want to buy into them. Doesn’t have any influence on you any longer. You just can’t believe him.

He’s pathological liar. It doesn’t matter what he says. It doesn’t have any force. So we buy into this appearance appearance as if it were true. And we react as if it were true, and that’s how our emotional life arises in dependence upon what is in fact a falsity.

And if we can keep contradicting that appearance, just like this within our own experience, keep seeing that this guy keeps lying, we come to understand more and more and become convinced he’s just not being honest. He keeps saying these things, but it’s not true. There’s this appearance, but it’s just not true. And therefore we don’t quite believe in it as much as we used to. We don’t buy into it as much as you said, and our emotional life becomes less and less influenced by what is in fact a false appearance.

Yeah. Yeah. I you know, we’re gonna go through these next week. Any other other comments, questions? Okay.

Can I just ask how how a person who realized selflessness, how how would that person conduct themselves in real life? Would they not care what happened themselves? Would they be indifferent to anything that impacted the problem? They still have emotions, not No. Subversion?

So they still have they’re based their their emotion there are two classes of emotions. Those are based on reason, those are based on mistaken reasons. Faith, love, compassion, they’re quite reasonable, necessary, and true. You know, people no one wants to suffer. Everybody wants to be happy.

And if we’re to have compassion, which wishes them not to suffer, and that they have happiness is quite is in keeping with the nature of reality, and with the actual experience of people. I think a Buddha, or I don’t think people become melancholy automatons. I think, like the Dalai Lama and these people, are quite passionate. So they are tremendously feeling, but these feelings are what we call positive feelings as opposed to negative feelings because they are no longer arising on the basis of ignorance. I think there is a transformation.

There is no longer Okay, the first part of the question, Chris, was I think you still have to take care of your body and your mind. You have to eat properly, keep it, you know. It’s like, you know, when if somebody threw a stone at you, you put up your hand to protect your body. And that’s quite a reasonable thing to do. But if you were to go on to react as if we’re protecting a partless, unchanging self.

And then we go on to retaliate because we are under threat. So I think it’s quite reasonable and rational, and I think even a Buddha would put up their hand to protect their body if somebody threw a stone at them. So we have to protect and we have to take care our body and mind. We have very powerful, positive emotions. But there’s no longer anything to defend.

Think there’s a certain freedom and spaciousness in mind, and above all, a spontaneity. We don’t have to watch ourselves. We’re one with our being. We embody who we are completely. And there’s a lack of suffering, a lack of anxiety, a fear at the most basic, subtle level.

I think it’s quite rather radical way of experiencing. We always live in fear. We always have a way to protect. I don’t think you have to fear to protect your body. I think I don’t know.

Anyway. That’s an interesting question. So we’re not losing anything in the sense that we don’t I think sometimes people think that if you get rid of, if you realize selflessness or you become a Buddha, become like a Buddha machine, know, of turning out this compassion and love. Think we maintain some uniqueness about ourselves. I think we become more and more of ourselves, whatever.

I’m wading into some dangerous territory here. We embody who we are, our personality. I think the Dalai Lama, think these great masters, they’re real unique people. They have real personalities. They are more of who they are than we are.

We have to shrink from that. We live in a certain degree of fear and anxiety. I guess you become much more of who you are, I think. There’s nothing to be afraid of. I’m sorry, what’s going on?

Can dedicate the positive energy we created together. Did I ever show you this? Did I show you that last week? I wonder if the pain that’s right. It’s a karmic.

It’s called Hi and Lois. And there’s two boys walking home from school. You know, one boy is holding his he just got back his exam results. And he says Yes. He says to his friend there, that new teacher really did a number on me.

In the second box he says, I thought I’d get a B on that test and he gave me a C. And the third box he says, How did he know I was a C student? And he thought he could pull a wool over there. It was a new teacher’s eye. New teacher who didn’t know him, he tried to pretend he was a B student.

But, you know, he couldn’t his new teacher was too sharp, and he could see through his pretense. You know, this guy had kind of a C-ness oozing out of his skin. You know, I mean, really, if you look at him, obviously he’s a C student, you know. Who are you trying to kid? You know, at the core of a being, he’s a C grade person.

And he’s going to go on, you know, to get a C grade job, find C grade wife, and teach his kids how to be C grade people. And then holding on to some some fixed idea about who we are is at the core of our being. And our life becomes a self defeating, self fulfilling prophecy. And then there’s around these self representations that we have about ourselves. And then we develop a sense of identity about ourselves, and we see it as being unchanging, independently existing.

That’s who I am. I try to pretend like someone else, and I’m struggling. But it’s preoccupying. I can’t be spontaneous. There’s always the persona that I’m trying to present and who I feel myself to be.

This ongoing struggle, fear. So that’s what most of us are, or lesser degree or greater involved in. I think this understanding that there’s no that there’s a light on, but nobody’s home. And that’s that we don’t that’s not at the core of our being. It’s just not there.

There’s never been a snake there all along. And so I think it could be quite liberating. So we can dedicate dedicate the positive energy toward that end. May beings everywhere plagued by sufferings of body and mind obtain an ocean of happiness and joy by virtue of my merits. May no living creature suffer, commit evil, or fall ill.

May no one be afraid or belittled with a mind weighed down by depression. May the blind see forms and the deaf hear sounds. May those whose bodies are worn with toil restore and find in repose. May the naked find clothing, the hungry find food. May the thirsty find water and delicious drink.

May the poor find wealth, those weak with sorrow find joy. May the forlorn find hope, constant happiness and prosperity. May there be timely rains and bountiful harvests. May all medicines be effective, let wholesome prayers bear fruit. May all who are sick and ill quickly be freed from their ailments.

Whatever diseases there are in the world, may they never occur again. May the frightened cease to be afraid, and those bound be freed. May the powerless find power, and may people think of benefiting each other. For as long as space remains, for as long as sentient beings remain, until then may I too remain to dispel the miseries of the world. Through these skillful actions, may I quickly become an awakened spiritual master and lead each and every living being to that awakened realm.

May the supreme jewel, the awakened mind that has not arisen, arise and grow. And may that which has arisen never diminish, but increase more and more. In the land encircled by snow mountains, you are the source of all happiness and well-being. Powerful Chenrezig, Tenzin Gyatso, please remain at the end of cyclic existence. Thank you.

If you’d like to get a cup of tea, we’ll have discussion. Otherwise, have a good evening.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top