1 h 32 min · 154 words · 19 August 2012 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 92-minute talk, Kyabje Rinpoche explores how to achieve what he calls good work in spiritual practice. He identifies renunciation as the foundational requirement and introduces a particular kind of uncommon motivation that develops within the renunciation experience—the inner drive essential for genuine spiritual advancement. The teaching establishes philosophical groundwork for understanding the prerequisites for meaningful practice.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2012-08-19 – KR.mp3
UUID: 6b7aeabd-6129-431d-8d9d-3b69d7dc6852
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Unclassified
Date: 2012-08-19
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~150
Teacher: Khensur Rinpoche
This transcript was generated using AI speech recognition and correction
File: 2012-08-19 – KR.mp3
Collection: Unclassified
UUID: 6b7aeabd-6129-431d-8d9d-3b69d7dc6852
—
**Teacher:** Kyabje Rinpoche
This transcript was generated using AI speech recognition and has been reviewed for Buddhist terminology accuracy. Some inaccuracies may remain. Please refer to the original audio recording as the authoritative source.
# 01-120819_1204.mp3 > **Collection:** Audio Recordings — Unclassified-No-Transcript > **Duration:** 92.6 minutes > **Words:** 150 > **Model:** Deepgram Nova-3 > **Corrections:** 0 Buddhist terminology fixes > **Transcribed:** 2026-03-02 20:58 — How is it that we set about trying to achieve such a state as good work? What what are the causes for us do we need to put in place…
Read full transcript
[no transcribed speech 00:00:00-00:01:15]
[00:01:15] [non-English speech, 53 s, detected zh 0.44]
[00:03:24] What are the causes do we need to put in place for us to be able to attain good and good? Firstly, we must have renunciation. And in terms of renunciation, there is the uncommon or the unique kind of renunciation specific to the aspirations of attaining bodhicitta, bodhisattva.
[00:03:58] So amongst the renunciations we have this uncommon or unique kind of renunciation that is specific to the attainment of perfect enlightenment.
[00:04:24] [unclear, 8 s]
[00:05:17] [non-English speech, 3 s, detected ru 0.43]
[00:05:46] So in terms of these renunciations, there is the greater and lesser renunciation. So we divide the two different kinds. If we divide renunciation into the greater and the lesser.
[00:06:02] So if we direct our attention first to the greater renunciation, how is it that we are able to practice such renunciation? Well, firstly, we must direct our attention towards an understanding of past and future lives. If we have conviction in our truth of past and future lives, it makes us…
[00:06:31] it provides a sound basis upon which we are able to generate this profound state of renunciation. So it is a topic worth great thought and contemplation and investigation to think about it again and again and again, to try and understand and cultivate a belief and conviction into the truth of past and future lives. And if we’re able to have strong reliance
[00:07:01] upon this conviction of the truth of past and future lives. Then it provides a great basis and enormous benefit to our families.
[00:07:38] [non-English speech, 15 s, detected ru 0.70]
[00:08:14] [unclear, 5 s]
[00:09:01] [non-English speech, 15 s, detected zh 0.56]
[00:09:17] In the context of what is done, it is of enormous benefit to our practice that we have this firm and definite conviction in the truth of podcasting in future lives. It has in fact become one of the best methods for being able to use as a reliance for our ongoing practice and development. Now in Tibet, in the country of Tibet itself, the Tibetan people we know have enormous…
[00:09:48] conviction in the truth of past and future. They have an instinctive belief in it. They have enormous faith in Buddhism in general, but specifically they have this instinctive belief in the truth of past and future lives. And it has enormous benefits for people because on the basis of that conviction
[00:10:18] They are more able to understand the nature of cause and effect. And they are more determined to put their efforts into creating the causes for future happiness and to not create the causes for suffering. And it is much easier to do this if you have a firm belief in the fact that in future lives, whatever we do now,
[00:10:46] the result will in some way affect the kind of future life that we have. And for Tibetans this is very easy because of this unwavering conviction in the fact of past and future lives. They have a better understanding of the nature of suffering and a better understanding of the need to behave in a way that creates causes for happiness in the future. This faith and conviction that we…
[00:11:18] that the benefits have, however, is generally not derived from study and investigation. It is something that they have that is culturally, that is taught through culture from the very other side. And so it provides an enormous basis, an enormous benefit to them in terms of the same important effect and calibrated actions that will result in happiness and doing suffering.
[00:11:47] [non-English speech, 46 s, detected zh 0.45]
[00:13:05] [unclear, 24 s]
[00:14:11] [non-English speech, 15 s, detected zh 0.68]
[00:14:59] The actual consequence of that thinking, we’re more likely to put in place the causes for you and through our understanding of what it is that constitutes.
[00:15:24] good causes for future happiness, then we will undoubtedly devote more time and energy and be far more earnest in our practice and our determination to cultivate kindness or this kind-hearted personality. Now, given our deep conviction in future lives, therefore it inspires
[00:15:53] a more earnest striving to practice well and to cultivate kind-heartedness. And therefore, there is a great deal of mental ease when it comes to engaging in these practices. It is much easier for the mind to have the conviction to sustain these practices and this continual attempt at cultivating kind-heartedness.
[00:16:25] An example that we can use in terms of understanding past and future lives in the context of this ease of mind that comes about through the condition of heaven. If we were to imagine standing at a great height and having to back down from a very great height, if we’re able to look down and see exactly where it is we’re about to land, then it provides us with a sense of confidence.
[00:16:58] and security that we know that if we land in a particular spot that we won’t fall to a tragedy or to great harm or injury. However, if we’re standing at a height and we look back and we can’t see, there is no way of seeing what lays below before we jump, then we have an enormous amount of fear rises in our mind because of this unknown and not knowing what exactly will happen once.
[00:17:26] once we begin to fall and where we will land. So if we have a definite sense of past and future lives, it provides a context in which we understand that our efforts are always going to be rewarded in some way in the future. It’s also similar to when we think about our own time of death.
[00:17:57] If you were to imagine someone approaching death with a conviction in past and future lives, then they understand that all the things that they’ve done in their life have had some meaning and value as it will be transferred as causes that will ripen in future lives, in future events. And there is a sense of accomplishment and meaningfulness at the time of death, and it is very reassuring.
[00:18:25] Yes, shall I suggest that the people who have absolutely no conviction in the past and future lives, who imagine that at the time of death it is a complete annihilation and a complete ending, they would look back over their lives and imagine that whatever they have been doing has come to nothing because ultimately death brings absolute nothingness.
[00:18:53] There would be great fear at this time that everything one has done in their life has counted for nothing and now there is to be an eternal annihilation of one’s existence. A person with conviction in past and future lives has this reassurance that whatever they’ve been doing in their life, the value of that will be transformed.
[00:19:21] to the future therefore their life is meaningful and therefore at the time of approaching death not only can they look back over their lives and value the good works that they have done but they can look with a certain degree of optimism at death that something else is about to arise through this process of dying
[00:19:50] [unclear, 17 s]
[00:20:20] [non-English speech, 2 s, detected ja 0.47]
[00:21:00] So you will be aware that in the past, Geshe-la has spoken about this in the preceding teachings. Geshe-la has spoken a lot on this topic. He’s talked about the pronunciation again and again.
[00:21:14] And you might begin to wonder why it is that it is being forever repeated and that you may have some doubts as to why you should keep listening to it being said over and over again. But the purpose is that it is a way of encouraging you to understand that it requires repeated effort. It requires constantly going over your previous attempts at understanding, at thinking and investigating.
[00:21:44] Continually repeating this message is a way of encouraging you to not accept merely doing it once or twice and thinking you’ve investigated as much as one means. Hearing it again and again and again is a way of reinforcing the idea…
[00:22:02] That you yourself within your own minds need to keep applying this state, applying this determination to understand, to investigate over and over again. And the more that you’re able to do it, these repeated attempts at investigating deeper and deeper into these topics is going to provide great benefits to your question.
[00:22:36] [unclear, 17 s]
[00:24:10] In brief, we can say that I am now talking briefly about the nature of virtuous and non-virtuous actions and ethical conduct. We can see from the world around us that many religions and traditions…
[00:24:40] have some model by which they try to cultivate in people the idea of living ethically and trying to behave and maintain its virtues. And within our practice, we understand that everyone is capable of practicing virtue. Everyone is capable of understanding it and putting it into practice. Now, being able to sustain virtuous actions and maintain it
[00:25:13] provides the perfect basis upon which we can have conviction in the future lives that we will experience being of greater, of being higher reverse, being reverse that are meaningful and provide us with pleasures and endowments. So on the basis of cultivating these virtuous actions and ethical conduct.
[00:25:43] by practicing in such a way, by providing a basis upon which future lives will always arise as fortunate, with, and being mindful of the aspiration towards the state of goodwill. On this basis, we will always be able to look back on our lives as having led a meaningful and a life of value. And this is a great benefit to this kind of practice.
[00:26:17] [unclear, 5 s]
[00:26:57] [non-English speech, 8 s, detected fr 0.64]
[00:27:59] And if we now set our motivation, understanding that here on a Sunday morning, we are taking the time and the effort to put this practice to give energy to our practice and to cultivate our practice with this virtuous ambition. So we are making good use of our time for the highest possible purpose. And we can set our motivation now.
[00:28:29] for just a minute or two in such a way?
[no transcribed speech 00:28:32-00:36:48]
[00:36:48] [unclear, 16 s]
[no transcribed speech 00:37:04-00:38:23]
[00:38:23] [unclear, 5 s]
[00:38:53] [non-English speech, 4 s, detected pt 0.30]
[00:39:22] [unclear, 19 s]
[00:40:50] Now, in terms of this more profound emancipation, I understand that
[00:41:02] In our lives we have greater suffering and happiness, sometimes have greater happiness than suffering, but in general we experience and understand this ongoing experience of suffering that we enjoy. Not the sufferings, there are two kinds of sufferings, there is the physical suffering and the mental suffering that we are capable of experiencing. In terms of the physical sufferings, these relate to empathy.
[00:41:45] relate to sufferings that are related to finding food and shelter, what we might refer to as standard of living suffering, where we have a greater or lesser abundance of food and resources and physical health and security. But in terms of the suffering that is related to the mind, the sufferings that we experience that are related to the mind are anger.
[00:42:14] jealousy and such and similar negative mental states. And these are much harder for us to endure. Now it is on the basis of this, on the basis of existing within psychological existence, within central life, and the basis is the body that we have, that our mind is embodied within.
[00:42:43] And the nature of this body, the nature of this body that we exist within samsara is always going to be prone to these negative mental states. It is within the very nature of this samsara body that we have created the causes to experience. So ultimately, we would be striving to remove the causes of creating
[00:43:15] body that existed in the nature of samsara, as we know that it is for us. And repeated practice will enable us eventually to have such rebirth without this kind. And if we were to practice continually and have success with that practice.
[00:43:46] It is said that there would come a time when, after repeated practice through our waking hours, that at night we would begin to have dreams that we would be. And dreaming about us being separated, existing, separate from the kind of body that we normally exist within. So this could come to us in a dream.
[00:44:15] And if you have some doubts or think that somehow doesn’t seem quite right, then it’s something that wholeness has spoken about repeatedly as well. That continual practice whereby we are seeking to not create causes for this samsara kind of body. When we have success in that practice, it will appear to us in a dream that our consciousness can continually exist without being constrained.
[00:44:45] [unclear, 2 s]
[00:45:16] [non-English speech, 9 s, detected zh 0.76]
[00:45:48] [unclear, 10 s]
[00:46:20] [non-English speech, 21 s, detected zh 0.52]
[00:47:07] We must understand that this requires regular and repeated investigation. It’s something that we need to think about deeply and regularly in order to achieve some kind of results.
[00:47:24] and we need to conjoin that with serious attempts at practice and, importantly, have reliance upon the texts, Buddhist texts that we are able to read and study. Now, simply reading Buddhist texts is very difficult to do. It’s hard to extract the meaning, it’s hard to devote one’s attention to the subtle meanings that are within the text.
[00:47:54] It’s hard to feel reassured that one is continually increasing and progressing their study and practice in a way that is continually improving. It doesn’t always feel like it is. But if one is able to start, as we’ve thought today, about the two kinds of renunciation, the lesser and the greater levels of renunciation.
[00:48:20] if we’re able to continually think about these things, maintain a consistent practice of investigation, and also putting into our other forms of practice, using the text as a reference, slowly but surely it will all come together. So all these separate activities that we engage in.
[00:48:48] in our attempt to progress along the path. One by one, bit by bit, they might seem disconnected and hard to prove and have doubts about whether they’re seriously progressing. But we can rest assured that the more we work, the more we investigate, the more we practice, slowly these all crystallize and come together and we will begin to feel the great benefit that we, to our mind and ultimately to our practice.
[00:49:17] And we remember things such as the last aspects of the path, the other important principles that we’ve studied within the teachings. And Dejlo acknowledges that you’ve come and heard many teachings throughout the course of your interest in Buddhism. You’ve heard many teachings. And one should never ever feel discouraged about all these different components, the different elements of your Buddhist training.
[00:49:57] [unclear, 29 s]
[00:51:29] [non-English speech, 12 s, detected zh 0.81]
[00:51:59] [unclear, 14 s]
[00:52:32] [non-English speech, 35 s, detected zh 0.69]
[00:53:54] So we are attempting to see more clearly and have a better understanding of the native jealousy and anger. And we need to understand what kind of practice we can put in place.
[00:54:07] be able to re-rig us of these negative mental states. Now we understand that this body that we have, this body that we exist within the nature of samsara, as we’ve said before, it exists within the nature of samsara. We can perhaps understand this even better by using the analogy that we have used before in relation to
[00:54:38] a farm in the field where we have seed and we plant the seed, the seed takes sprout and then once the seed takes sprout, the resulting fruit is when the plant grows and ripens. And this is often used as the analogy for talking about causes. So we’re here to understand causes.
[00:55:08] conditions in relation to this example of the seed, the sprout, the plant flourishing within the field. We can understand that our body, this body that we have inhabiting within samsara is the field and the conditions such as the soil and the water and the sunshine, the conditions are
[00:55:38] self-cherishing. And the cause that abides within the seed is the anger and jealousy in similar mental states. So just as the seed will flourish once the soil is rich and there is water and sunshine, so on the basis of existing within this samsara body with the conditions of self-cherishing
[00:56:06] we can see that anger and jealousy will repeatedly arise within our minds. And this is a way of understanding from metaphor the nature of our sense of body, and the way in which self-cherishing provides the conditions in which these momentary states of anger and jealousy, and similarly with the negative states, will continually arise.
[00:56:49] So, thinking of it in such a way is very easy, is an easy way to digest all the essential information that we need to understand.
[00:57:10] [non-English speech, 25 s, detected ja 0.46]
[00:58:10] [unclear, 44 s]
[00:59:49] We understand that this samsaric body, given its very nature and the way it harbors this potential for anger and jealousy, desires to attachment and self-cherishing, we understand that in order to practice well, that our absolute ambition must be to rid ourselves of…
[01:00:17] creating causes for us to be embodied in such, to be embodied in such a way that we can’t all exist in. So we must convince ourselves and have 100% determination that we seek to abandon such a body as this one, a body that comes into existence, bringing with it anger and jealousy and desirous detachment.
[01:00:47] arises on the basis of having this extreme sense of self-cherishing, which comes about on the basis of this continual collective ignorance as to the nature of reality. So we realize that in order to be able to have this firm conviction that we seek to abandon this samsaric body once and for all, in order to have this conviction as strong as we possibly can, we need to engage in.
[01:01:18] our normal study and practice, and importantly, make sure that our motivation is very clear about seeking to abandon a samsaric body, to be reborn and constrained by this samsaric body. Now, as we set ourselves upon the Buddhist path, there are two, and we reach a point where we have
[01:02:10] [unclear, 6 s]
[01:02:33] Hinayana, no good, probably. Hinayana, no good. Teravatt, maybe.
[01:02:53] It was generally described literally from the Tibetan, which says lesser and greater and smaller and greater, which produced the word kinyana, and therefore implied somehow that the kinyana path was inferior to the manhiyana path. From knowing that the manhiyana practice, what we used to call kinyana, it’s more appropriate to use.
[01:03:24] terminology, Theravada, Theravada, and Mahi-Yama. Hinayana carries this implication of being somewhat dismissive towards the lesser, whereas it is equally they have. Now, when he talks about the Theravada,
[01:03:52] In order to be able to practice in such a way, one is driven by this sincere desire to eliminate a samsaric body and to remove all the causes for one’s negative mental state, such as desirous attachment, self-cherishing. One seeks to eliminate these firmly from one’s mind strength.
[01:04:22] to attain this individual liberation which is the focus or the defining characteristic of the Theravadi path is to attain this personal liberation whereby one is no longer constrained by a sense of body that one has eliminated from their mind stream the potential to create the causes for suffering.
[01:04:52] as such as the negative mental states, all jealousy and anger, desirous attachment, self blasphemy.
[01:05:28] [unclear, 17 s]
[01:05:55] [non-English speech, 38 s, detected fr 0.69]
[01:06:54] [unclear, 25 s]
[01:07:26] [non-English speech, 22 s, detected fr 0.40]
[01:07:49] [unclear, 17 s]
[01:08:20] involved in serious practice that is relevant to the way in which we assess the differences between these two paths. And now in terms of both the Theravada practices and the Mahayana practices, both of them are based essentially upon the Buddhist teachings of the Four Noble Truths. So there are in fact, it is in fact true to say that both these paths
[01:08:50] The Theravada and Mahayana are in fact in many ways come from the same source. They come from the same source. The differentiation that we are making comes from when we talk about in terms of Theravada. We are seeking to eliminate from our mental continuum all potential causes for unhappiness, for suffering, and we are seeking to rid ourselves of
[01:09:18] any kind of negative mental state that will result in suffering. And this motivation is sincere and is driven to eliminate completely from one’s own mental continuum any form of suffering in these negative mental states. But when we talk about the Mahayana tradition…
[01:09:47] When we talk about the Mahayana tradition and analyze the differences between these two, it solely boils down to the issue of motivation. Because within the Mahayana path, one similarly seeks to be able to eliminate completely from one’s mental continuum.
[01:10:15] all possibilities of having negative mental states, experiencing suffering. But the motivation is such that one seems to become a life, to manifest as a life where these great individual qualities come about solely directed towards a goal of obtaining great benefit for every other living person.
[01:10:47] And this is where these two paths are set to differentiate on the issue of motivation. The Theravada motivation is wishing to eliminate from one’s mental continuum any form of suffering for the purposes of one’s own personal liberation. In the Mahana path, one is seeking to similarly eliminate from one’s mental continuum any kind of negativity.
[01:11:16] and suffering, but the Mahayana practitioner was driven by striving to attain such a state solely for the purpose to be a beneficial life for the welfare of all other living beings. And it is on this point that we need to be very clear and very focused and understand just how important this
[01:11:46] This issue of motivation is in determining what kind of practice we are pursuing.
[01:12:20] [unclear, 22 s]
[01:13:03] About the cultures that practice Taravayan Buddhism, we know that they are the countries generally within Southeast Asia, such as Thailand and Sri Lanka, where Buddhism…
[01:13:19] Thailand, Sri Lanka, Laos, Cambodia, countries where the Theravadan tradition has flourished. Now if we ask ourselves what exactly is it that they are practicing that is specific to the Theravadan way, well we might suspect that they do not have the same emphasis based on cultivating
[01:13:51] loving kindness and compassion in terms of an aspiration of attaining the state of the Bodhisattva and Bodhicitta, we would suspect that that is not a key component of their practices. So what we can see that is differentiating the two traditions is this lack of emphasis upon cultivating Bodhicitta.
[01:14:45] And so their practice therefore is by being reliant on the vulnerable truth.
[01:14:54] and is seeking to perfect the form over truth, results in the ultimate, the possible result that they can achieve through those practices is what’s called individual liberation.
[01:15:26] [non-English speech, 5 s, detected zh 0.83]
[01:16:01] [unclear, 33 s]
[01:17:27] [non-English speech, 3 s, detected fr 0.50]
[01:18:04] So we understand then that when we, that both traditions, the Theravada and Mahayama traditions are based on the understanding and practice of all noble Truths and development. It’s the difference that we see that exists in this way.
[01:18:28] is essentially in terms of the motivation, where the Theravada tradition can lead us ultimately in no further than personal liberation. Whereas with the motivation of the Mahi Namakata, we understand that on the basis of wishing to attain the great liberation that involves the liberation of all living beings.
[01:18:56] Our motivation is driven by the desire to be able to exist in such a way where we are bringing perfect benefit to all living beings and that is the sole motivation for us. Engaging in our practices that gives rise to the potential of experiencing loving kindness and compassion. Which gives rise to the potential of cultivating perfect bodhicitta and attaining the state of the bodhisattva and then ultimately
[01:19:26] the state of perfect Buddhahood. Now, when we seek to define ourselves one way or the other, we seek to define ourselves, if we seek to define ourselves as Mahayana practitioners, then it is incumbent upon us to have this unique motivation whereby we are driven solely by this ambition.
[01:19:52] to bring perfect benefit to all living beings, and that is the reason for us engaging in our practice. We, just like in the Theravadan tradition, see to perfect the teachings contained within the form of the truth and the 12 things. But we are forced, but we are doing it driven by the desire that we will not simply experience personal liberation, but what we call a great liberation.
[01:20:20] whereby all sentient beings will benefit from the way in which we’re engaging in our practice and spiritual development. And this is the most important issue to understand in terms of working on this text and cultivating our practice, that this motivation, the nature of our motivation, is vitally important in terms of determining what possible outcomes we can hope to achieve.
[01:20:55] [unclear, 3 s]
[01:21:49] Loving, kindness. Loving, kindness. Loving, kindness.
[01:22:02] [unclear, 41 s]
[01:23:01] So, in terms of, we haven’t quite talked specifically about the text where, from the mind training, we’re up to the section on the meditation and compassion. But we understand that in terms of spending a fruitful hour on a Sunday morning, that as long as your motivation has been fixed correctly and has some intensity to it.
[01:23:32] then if that time has been well spent and if you are able to take away from today the value and importance of this motivation and the way that this correctly set motivation will do is has the power to transform one’s practice and not get vastly more meaningful and if one were merely to sit and read books and listen and talk about things better.
[01:23:59] not have such a serious and earnest and intent Mahayana motivation. And that’s the most important thing for us to take away from this and to try to bring to each and every teaching to make them far more meaningful than just hearing a lot of words and spending time talking about it’s important.
[01:24:36] Just one question? Nothing? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[01:25:11] [unclear, 6 s]
[01:25:47] He suspects that they will notice the and so realms such as the four realms you are found within the picture, but not.
[01:26:49] All right. You’re finished, isn’t it? Today? Because today is holiday.
[01:27:25] [non-English speech, 95 s, detected ru 0.48]
[no transcribed speech 01:29:00-01:32:33]
Key terms in this teaching
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- individual liberation
- The liberation from cyclic existence achieved by a hearer (shravaka) or solitary realizer (pratyekabuddha), as compared with the full enlightenment of a buddha sought in the Mahayana. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
- Yama shinchi dagje (Tib)
- The Lord of Death, seen on the Wheel of Life. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.