Bodhisattvacaryavatara — 2012-08-15

1 h 50 min · 6,452 words · 15 August 2012 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Bodhisattvacaryavatara (Khensur Rinpoche)
Bodhisattvacaryavatara (Khensur Rinpoche)
Bodhisattvacaryavatara — 2012-08-15
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 110-minute commentary on Śāntideva’s Guide to the Bodhisattva’s Way of Life, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen focuses on practical antidotes to anger, the most destructive of our inner enemies. He opens by establishing how jealousy, anger, and malicious competitiveness interrupt happiness both personally and globally, then walks through three types of patience from the text: patience with physical suffering, patience when others cause harm (recognising they act under the power of negative mental states, not free agency), and patience grounded in insight into the interdependent nature of reality. He then applies these teachings concretely to everyday situations—managing anger towards children in the home, maintaining trustworthiness and honest speech in workplace jealousy and conflict, and extending compassion to all beings. In the final verses of the chapter, Śāntideva argues that pleasing sentient beings, not appeasement of kings or enemies, brings both immediate happiness and the causes for Buddhahood. Geshe-la emphasises patience as a lifelong practice requiring repeated, consistent effort, not sudden transformation, and encourages participants to study the Dalai Lama’s teachings on patience and anger to deepen their understanding.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2012-08-15 – KR.mp3

UUID: 84d4138d-a2ec-4665-9545-e3284adf5fbf

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Bodhisattvacaryāvatāra

Date: 2012-08-15

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~6,456

So when we find ourselves in this world, we find ourselves taking birth in this world as a consequence of past lives. And we are currently enjoying a lifetime on the basis a lifetime that is based on looking for ways to experience happiness. And in Buddhist terms, when we talk about how we’ve come to be as we are in this world, it is on the basis of past lives. And the happiness that we have, able to experience is based on past lives. And what we may hope to gain in the future is based on the happiness we seek to build in our present life.

So in the world, we find that all living beings are striving to bring happiness to their mission. What motivates them is to experience happiness and their own meaning, their own purpose. And we understand that there are some people who are able to be more successful at gaining this happiness than others. So while it is that we all experience happiness and create the means by which we’re able to be most happy, we realise that there are interruptions to our happiness and the interruptions to our happiness come in the form of various kinds of sufferings. There are the physical sufferings and the mental sufferings.

We understand easily the physical sufferings as related to our standard of living and our means to provide ourselves with sustenance and security. And then there is the suffering comes then there is the suffering that we refer to as the mental suffering. And mental suffering generally comes about on the basis of negative mental states such as jealousy, anger, and malicious competitiveness. So we can see that on the basis of these of mental states such as these, we will invariably experience an interruption to our happiness. Indeed, we will begin to feel more and more suffering.

Now when we feel ourselves confronted by an outer enemy, we feel as if it is easy to observe and recognize and to gather some kind of resources to to act as a defense for us against an external enemy. But in regards to these internal enemies, we understand that jealousy, competitive malicious competitiveness, and anger, these mental once we are under the power of those negative mental states, we will forever have constant interruptions to our happiness. We will always be experiencing suffering. And if we do not apply a technique, a means by which we can eliminate these negative mental states from our mind, then of their own nature, they will multiply, and they will become stronger and stronger within our mind and create ever more increasing sense of unhappiness. So these internal enemies of jealousy, anger, and malicious competitiveness will, if left alone, grow and develop more and more power.

And we will be more and more we’ll find ourselves more often under the power of these negative mental states and therefore experience less and less happiness. In chapter one of The Way of the Bodhisattva, Śāntideva’s text, there is a verse, verse 28, that says, those desiring to escape from suffering hasten right towards suffering. With the very desire for happiness, out of delusion, they destroy their own happiness as if it were an enemy. So when we think about happiness and the means by which we are able to achieve it, we need to have some understanding of the we need to have a definite method for seeking to attain it. It’s not something that will come about simply by its own happenstance.

Now when we understand that we have these powerful enemies to our happiness that are within us in terms of these negative mental states, it is important that we recognise it in such a way that we recognise it as it as having a power to diminish our happiness and thereby something recognising it as something that we must eliminate. That continual happiness will will simply not be possible. It is an an impossibility to sustain happiness while these negative we are under the power of these negative mental states. And in chapter four in verse 28 of chapter four, Śāntideva writes enemies such as craving and hatred are without arms, legs, and so on. They are neither courageous nor wise.

Then how is it that they have enslaved me? And we have spoken about it, earlier in these teachings, it’s come up about, the manner in which we are able to maintain our mental states in our within our home life and in especially in regard to homes where there are children to look after. And there are moments when people have, recounted stories of where they have been feeling anger towards their children when they’re trying to get their household organised or get something done and they’ve been experiencing some anger. It’s important to remember first and foremost that when people talk about the anger that they have towards their children when they feel they’re misbehaving, important to remember the distinction between the motivation of the anger and the motivation for anger that one experiences in the context of having a real and serious enemy. Now the motivation when you have a real and serious enemy is to act as strongly and as powerfully as you can to protect yourself and eliminate the enemy.

Whereas the motivation that a parent or guardian or relative has towards a child is that they are trying to provide the best possible circumstances in which the child can live and grow. They’re trying to provide opportunity and trying to provide a sense of security and love for their children. Now this is the motivation that is driving a person in their interactions with their children. So anger that arise, even though you report that it is a very powerful and strong anger, it is important to be mindful that the context in which this anger is occurring makes it a vastly different kind of anger to the anger that you experience towards an enemy. Even though it might stand out and feel like very strong and powerful anger, you are not driven by a desire to cause harm to your child, which is what you might be motivated to when you are confronted with a serious and dangerous threat from a real enemy.

When if we feel as if we are prone to being angry towards our children or that the opportunity to get angry is likely to occur. It’s very helpful in the evenings, in the evenings at night before bed, we look towards the day ahead and try and prepare our mind so that we understand the value of not getting angry, of not appearing angry whenever, when the next morning comes about and trying to get ready and trying to get organized and things are going wrong to set your mind in the evening, the night before to, so that you will be vigilant in the morning to protect your mind to, so that you will protect yourself from allowing this anger to arise. Because it’s important to remember that if we engage with our children in a manner that is gruff, that is, that uses harsh tones, that expresses anger, we’re in fact teaching our children to behave in such a way. As the person in charge, as the person who is responsible for the welfare of these children, it’s incumbent upon you to always try your best to always appear pleasant and loving and to use the nicest possible language to maintain the nicest possible, demeanor and body language because this is what your how you are teaching your children to behave.

If you’re repeatedly angry and gruff when you are not getting the situation to pan out as you wish it to be, then you’re in fact teaching your children to respond like that when they find themselves in a situation where things aren’t going their way. And that is most unhelpful to a child. And so, it’s important to remember the value of always trying to remember your deep motivation, which is always loving and compassionate and allow that to be expressed through the way that you treat your children even in times when you’re feeling frustrated and annoyed. And another, the situation that people have referred to where they feel themselves in situations where, anger occurs and when they find themselves in an environment that is, conducive to being angry, which can be the workplace and people who are finding themselves in workplaces the where the, the relationships between people is strained and difficult and where we find that jealousy and anger is easy to arise and affect the way that people are able to experience and enjoy their day. So the most important thing that we should try and remember is that, and when we’re on our own or in our house, we’re able to, if we feel ourselves being overwhelmed by a negative mental state, we’re able to pull ourselves back in the safety and security of our own environment.

But when we are in the working environment, it’s much harder because we are in a shared space. It’s much harder for us to have that controlling effect over our negative mental states. Firstly, we try to remember when we are having to work in such a situation is the motivation that we normally should feel ourselves to be motivated by at all times, which is the motivation of the great liberation where we feel we are motivated that we, by the way that we live, should be cultivating liberation in ourselves and others thereby being mindful always of being beneficial to other people. And if we are able to remember that that is our motivation when we go into these environments, it will have a stronger effect on our mind to remain continually mindful of this motivation that, we are inspired to act and conduct ourselves in a manner in accordance with the aspirations of the great liberation. When we are amongst other people and whatever mental states we other people might be manifesting or whatever we might manifest ourselves.

It’s very important that we are able to always represent ourselves within the workplace as being trustworthy and reliable. And if while other people are overwhelmed by negative mental states, if we are able to maintain an air of reliability and of trustworthiness that we are not easily drawn in to backbiting or bitterness or dissension. If we are able to maintain that standard, it will be of immense benefit to us in the long run. It’s very difficult to maintain, to sustain in the short term when there are a lot of short term problems. But we must always be remembering that we have both short term and long-term goals when it comes to the way that we are when it comes to the way our mind is working and the way we interact with other people.

Jealousy and anger, competitiveness, these will always arise in situations when people are working with each other, especially when they are working again and again and again finding themselves in the same environment. When we feel ourselves in the midst of this, it is also important that we are able to always keep control over our speech and the manner in which we talk to others and the way we talk about others. If we are always able to maintain at a time when everyone else is falling under the power of anger and jealousy. If we are able to maintain a manner of speech whereby we never speak badly of other people, where we never contribute to a feeling of backbiting or dissension. If we’re able to maintain our speech in terms of the conduct of our speech whereby we are always speaking well of others no matter what the situation.

Again in the long run this will have great benefits for us because it will forge a reputation. It will forge our reputation whereby people will remember that in moments when anger and jealousy have flared, you’ve been able to maintain speaking well of others and being reliable and being trustworthy and being the one who is looking for, calm in every situation rather than dissent. And we remember again where we’ve talked about having drawing people close to us who we feel responsible for. When we have talked about this circle of love where we have the nearest and dearest to us who we take a serious sense of responsibility for in wanting to protect them and cultivate happiness in their lives. Have the If we use the workplace as an opportunity to try and draw people closer into our circle, it is another opportunity for extending our circle of love and thereby being able to practise better our motivation and wishing to benefit other people.

And these are situations that are quite hard to maintain to sustain these mental states. But as the Dalai Lama has said himself many, many times, if you’re able to maintain these attributes, especially in times when there is dissension in the workplace, When your manner, your demeanour, your speech and the way you talk about people and your trustworthiness, it will be remembered even if in the short term it feels difficult to do. You most certainly can feel that there will be 100% effect on your long-term reputation to be able to ride out those situations where everyone else seems to be losing their composure. So now we’ll use the next two minutes to try and set our motivation where we understand that the opposing power to anger is love and that this the mental state that which we wish to make most steadfast and prevalent in our mind. And we can use the next two minutes to set this motivation.

Today is very nice, very nice cup of tea. Lots of probably milk. But one day Coming to the end of our, towards the end of the text and we are to Śāntideva’s Guide to the Bodhisattva’s Way of Life or the practices of the Bodhisattva. We can understand that in terms of us trying to experience happiness as best as we possibly can, that negative states such as jealousy, anger, and competitive maliciousness are the most powerful forces in making us unhappy. And we can experience that in terms of our daily lives and have an experience or understanding of the way that works.

And we can also see in the world around us that when these three negative mental states are motivating the authorities in countries around the world that it inevitably leads to war and suffering. So we can see on a personal level and on a global level the power of destructiveness that these negative mental states create. And we understand that these negative mental states aren’t righted by their own accord. They won’t by their own nature simply abate and diminish. It requires a conscious and deliberate and planned action to be able to eliminate those mental states from our minds.

And so within, Buddhist terms, it is a topic where we understand that we must apply ourselves to the study of the means by which we are able to eliminate these negative mental states and the practice of how we are to apply our knowledge into our experience, into the way that we live and think in our lives. We understand that through what we’ve been going through, in the course of these teachings, we’ve understood that anger is extremely powerful in disrupting our ability to enjoy happiness both within ourselves and in our social worlds. And we have talked about how to apply patience as a way to diminish firstly diminish anger and make it impossible for us to continually live under the power of anger, for us to once again attain authority over anger and these negative mental states. When we have spoken about the kind of patience that we are trying to cultivate in our minds, we’ve talked about three different kinds of of patients. There was the patience that we talked about in relation to the suffering that we experience.

We all have experiences of physical suffering and we know that if we are able to apply patience and have we are able to diminish the effect of that suffering on our mental states. And we’ve learned through the teachings we’ve learned that there is no point responding with anger to physical suffering. We remember, the expressions that we use that if there is something to be done, then there is no need to get angry. And if there is absolutely nothing to be done then there’s no point getting angry either. And so we’ve covered and we talked about this first kind of patience.

The fact that we respond to physical, the sufferings of a physical nature. Not with anger, not with being annoyed, not with being disappointed, not with being frustrated by not continually being in a perfect physical state. But we understand that the suffering that the suffering that we experience should not be cause for us to alter our mental state. We understand that moments of suffering that we experience in our lives come about as a result of previous causes and the accumulation of causes and their resultant effects. So we understand that suffering comes about as a result of a cause we have already put in place.

And again, there is no point getting angry within the moment of this suffering, understanding the context of the way this suffering has come to arise. So if we’re able to focus on the fact that we have in fact been the agents in creating this cause. It makes us less prone to seeking blame or to be, having our mental states disturbed by physical suffering. We also talked about the suffering that comes about in relation to harm that is caused to us by others. And under the power of anger we’ve experienced people who have treated us badly and we try not to react because of an understanding that we have gathered through our investigation that when people treat us badly, they themselves are under the power of negative mental states.

And it is not the person themselves with great agency to who is seeking to inflict, harm on us. They themselves are the ones who are under the power of a negative mental state and making an investigation in making such an investigation once again diminishes the anger that might arise in a normal situation where someone is causing us harm, where we recognise that they are powerless in this situation because they themselves have been overwhelmed by negative mental states making them an object of pity rather than to be feared and reacted to with a negative state of our own. This kind of investigation has led us to the third kind of patience we’ve discussed whereby we use the teachings, the Buddha’s teachings to further investigate into the nature of reality. And the more we investigate into the nature of reality and the concept of there being multiple causes for every experience, we come to apply a patience that is based on that insight, insight into the mechanisms of reality, which make us see that things come about for a variety of causes and that reacting with anger and feeling justified or warranted in having moments of anger actually goes against the understanding we have gathered through investigating the nature of reality in its totality.

So when we come to we also understand that, people who, inflict harm on us are doing it momentarily and that it is not in their they do not possess a permanent and unchanging nature to be angry or else they would be angry all the time. And this is another example of using the dharma to be able to investigate the nature of reality to diminish our sense we may have that we are warranted or justified to respond with anger in any situation. So through these three different ways of approaching the teachings on patience is, we have followed these three different ways of approaching patience through Śāntideva text. So now we come towards the, and in regards to the root text that the teachings have been based on, we come to the very end of the text where Śāntideva uses the the last, I think six verses that, begin with, for example, should some of the king’s men cause harm to many people, Far-sighted ones would not return the harm even if they were able to do so. For they see that these men are not alone, but are supported by the might of the king.

Likewise, I should not underestimate weak beings who cause me a little harm. So in this scenario, Śāntideva remembering the time in which the text was composed and remembering the way that people lived in various kingdoms at that time. So you can imagine then if you put your mind back way back at that time where this text is located. It’s easy to understand when a king in particular kingdom where a king would direct his minions or his soldiers or the people who work for the king to act in a way that is harmful towards the people and that the people themselves would feel as if great harm was done to them and they would want to retaliate to the harm that is caused to them. Śāntideva makes the point that there is no point getting, there’s no point responding against the soldiers of the king because they are merely acting under the directions of the king.

So if there is any reason that you would have, opposition or resentment, it would be directed towards the king rather than the people who are doing his bidding and working on his behalf. And in the same way, when we think of people who are causing us harm, that we can understand that these people are acting in a way that comes about as a result of negative mental states, which are a result of previously created causes. So in effect, can say because of karma. So people who are acting under the force of karma are causing us harm. So should we get angry at the person who is causing us harm or the negative karma that is creating such behaviour.

And Śāntideva directs us to identify the karmic causes rather than the momentary represent the resultant behaviour of people who are causing us harm. Verse 130 says, for they are supported by the guardians of hell and by the all compassionate ones. So behaving like the subjects of that fiery king, I should please all sentient beings. And that is that verse ties up the previous point whereby we are talking about that we should be identifying the cause of such harm that is being directed to us. And in response, we are trying to always bring to other living beings a state of mind, bring benefit to other state bring benefit to other living beings and to be motivated by that and be able to extract from any situation, not a misidentification of the causes of the harm that we ex are experiencing.

I should please all sentient beings. The text goes on, even if such a king were to become angry, could he cause the pain of hell, which is the fruit I would have to experience by displeasing sentient beings? And, again, this analogy metaphor is taking us into our response to the situation whereby no matter what actions that king would perform, if we should respond in such a way that would engender negative mental states, we ourselves are the ones who will experience the consequences of those negative mental states, which may well in fact be worse than whatever kind of suffering that king is trying to afflict on us at some time. So in fact, the worst kind of harm that could be done in such a situation is the harm we will cause ourselves by generating these negative mental states and harm towards other living beings. Verse 132 says, and even if such a king were to be kind, he could not possibly grant me Buddhahood, which is the fruit I would obtain by pleasing sentient beings.

So once again, if we are able to respond to the harm that is being done to us, with a negative mental state, but in fact by being driven to bring benefit to other living beings, by working to bring benefit to other living beings, we are creating the causes that will enable us to travel along the path towards Buddhahood. Therefore, no matter what we were to experience as a consequence of the king’s behaviour pleasing the king or in some way trying to be accommodating to the king and pretend that we are going in a certain direction just to give to show signs of allegiance. None of these behaviors are behaviors that will in fact over time create the causes for us to experience higher happiness, higher spiritual development, and ultimately Buddhahood. So there is nothing that the king is able to grant us. There is nothing that will come from our reactions to the king that in any way compares to the benefit we are able to experience if we remain driven to bring benefit to other living beings.

Verse 133 says, why do I not see that my future attainment of Buddhahood as well as glory, renown, and happiness in this very life all come from pleasing sentient beings? And and Geshe-la says that within this text, this is a very important verse and a verse that it carries immense weight and something that we should use, to inspire us to think deeply on this topic and to, remind ourselves of what it is we’ve been learning about in these teachings. That in terms of us attaining Buddhahood, in terms of the actions that we engage in, in order to attain Buddhahood, it is something that is perhaps for our situation, that is a long way off in the future. Future. What we can focus on more importantly from this verse is the reference that is made to the benefit that we experience by continually working to benefit others.

And as we’ve seen throughout the text that it is on the basis of other living beings that we are able to accumulate virtue, which enables us to experience positive results. So thereby, where the verse says, why do I not see that my future attainment of Buddhahood as well as glory, renown and happiness in this very life all come from pleasing sentient beings. And here is the crux of Śāntideva’s text where he is urging us to recognise the value in the way we treat other living beings. And so the final verse of the chapter reads, while in cyclic existence, patience causes beauty, health and renown. Because of these, I shall live for a very long time and win the extensive pleasure of the universal chakravartin kings.

Now from this we can see the weight or the power that Śāntideva places on our ability to practise patience and the consequences of us successfully doing so. If we are repeatedly in all situations able to practise patience, it is said that we create great happiness for ourselves and for others in the future. And through the practise of patience, we are able to lessen the effect of the negative mental states such as jealousy, anger and competitiveness. As these things diminish in the nature of the relationships people have with other, then there it is quite obvious that the world will become a better place. And it is something that once again, His Holiness has talked about repeatedly where he has called upon individuals to enact this kind of practice in order to contribute to a much larger and a much greater happiness.

And that is not simply the happiness that we ourselves will experience, though it is certain we will experience greater happiness based on such practices. But the happiness that we will see manifest within the world when relations between living beings, are driven by people by this ability to practise patience and minimise negative mental states and cultivate this sense of welfare for all other living beings. So draws us to the end of the actual root text itself. Geshe-la says we’ve done very well to get through this chapter of Śāntideva’ text and that he understands fully that most of you, during the day go to work and work very hard and have a tight schedule and have much on in your lives and that to devote some time to come and listen to Buddhist teachings in the evenings. It is an effort and that effort is recognised and is grateful for that effort that you have made to come and listen to teachings.

In a Buddhist context, we always say that if our motivation is sincere, we will always attain favourable results. So when it comes to understanding the teachings that we have had and understanding the nature of patience, then if our motivation is sincere and while we have been listening to the teachings, then of course we will experience great benefit. It’s very important to maintain within our minds an understanding of the nature of patience For we should always be striving to cut the causes of anger in such a way so that we are able to eliminate it from our lives. If we are able to understand very clearly the faults of anger and the destructive power of anger, it’s easier for us to be able to maintain a vigilance to continually practise patience in such a way that will put a secure barrier between our lives and the effects of anger. Now this is something to permanently for us to make a fundamental transformation in our minds in terms of cutting anger out for once and for all.

It is a very difficult task and it is a task that will be accomplished little by little over a great period of time. It’s not something that a short sharp shock will be able to, bring about a transformation in our minds. It’s continual repetitive work on understanding the virtues of patience and the faults of anger and continually devoting whatever time you are able to afford yourself, whether it be a few minutes, twenty minutes, even longer, depending on the time that you have to yourself to devote to this work. If you are able to do so, if you are able to do it consistently, then there is no doubt that there will be great benefit come to your mind. Benefit that comes to your mind, comes to your social worlds.

And it brings about a state of greater happiness. And of course, the context of understanding past, present, and future lives, it most definitely helps create causes by which we will experience happiness not only in this life, but in future lives to come. So when we are fully aware and fully aware in a very deep and meaningful way about the faults of anger, of the destructive nature of anger, and we’re able to continually habituate our mind to that understanding, Then over time we’ll begin to be able to find we will likely to find ourselves in situations where we are seeing anger arise, especially if we see anger arise in others that we can just see so clearly. Will suddenly seem to take on a whole new appearance in the sense that you are able to recognise the destructiveness of it and how distasteful it is and how it is something that is just where previously you may have accommodated it in some way, in some way become so familiar with it or used to it that it hasn’t really shocked you so much. But as your practise develops, there will be times most certainly when you will start to see moments of anger in a very stark way and be really shocked and horrified by it.

And it’s a sign that when you are able to develop your practice that you’re beginning to see anger in this way. But it is something that requires continual and consistent application, something that requires repeated practice and practice and practice. So we have to try whether depending on our schedules and how we live with the time that we’re able to put towards it, whether we have time, a great time or a little time, however much time we have, if we’re able to devote to practise, it will be of benefit. And in terms of furthering our knowledge and understanding of patience and what has been written and taught about patience also anger and its faults. Then there are books written by his holiness, the Dalai Lama.

And of course, all of you are quite literate and it’s very easy for you to pick up a book and to read it even if you don’t have very much time on your hands. Being very literate, you’re able to get through books quite quickly. So if there are many resources that the Dalai Lama has written that provide a basis upon which we are able to further our knowledge, further our understanding, thereby strengthen our practice. And Geshe-la says he encourages you very much and hopes that you will take the opportunity to seek out such references and use them to the best of your ability to help improve your practice. All right.

But now At 32, how many what? How many? So few question. So there’s a few minutes left. And if people have some questions, this is your chance to clear up some final question.

To ethics. You mean like? Answer. So you understand why they’re separate? So in terms of the six perfections and these are a graduated process of practice where you’re developing your mind in particular stages where at the beginning one is slightly practice of giving is slightly easier than what comes subsequent to that.

So it’s in that context that why it is that it’s in the context of a practice where a graduated practice that the difference exists. So when it comes to, for example, if you were to, practice giving, it’s quite obvious when there is a person to give towards and you’re able to practice giving in such a way. And it’s quite a straightforward transaction with the right motivation. Whereas when it comes to ethics, this is where it requires deeper thought and taking responsibility to redirect the way that you think and the responsibilities and burdens you take upon yourself. So in that regard, it is quite different.

So Geshe in response to the part of the question that said, so is there any kind of, what was it, good beneficial anger or was it? Yeah. Well, Geshe-la says the only, what is beneficial about any experience of anger is that it provides the opportunity for practise patience. And if there’s no anger, there’s no opportunity to practise patience. And that’s the sole benefit of anger.

So, yeah, in the context of recognizing that we are under the influence of self-cherishing, self grasping, then that’s appropriate to respond with, some kind of the kind of quote anger, but it’s in relation to where Geshe-la said previously, recognising this enemy within. So previously we’ve talked about recognising that self-cherishing as the enemy and as the inner enemy that we don’t apply patience to, it’s the enemy we must seek to destroy. So in that sense, that anger is as long as it’s tied up in that kind of framework, that anger towards self-cherishing is valid. Justification for the anger at self-cherishing. Geshe-la said in the context of that where you’re recognising it as if you’re recognising it as the enemy because of living under the power of it, if you recognize that as the enemy, then there is some rationale to saying you’re angry about In the context of Geshe-la saying under the power of the internal enemy, remember we had the external enemy internal enemy.

Internal enemy traces back down to self-cherishing. And so you recognize that as the enemy and then to be angry at that is valid. Alright. Yeah. Yeah.

Yep. Sorry. Okay. Well, he said, yes, but of course, so how I said it was this. Śāntideva lived at Nālānda.

At the time he was living there he had the appearance of being very lazy so they conspired to humiliate him as a way of getting him expelled. What kind of people would do that to someone if there’s supposedly these practitioners living at, Nālānda monastery? That’s how I said question. Wherever there are people live, are people who have ill will towards others. And these were some people who are like that.

Not everyone who lives in a monastery is arhats or what we call a foe destroyer. Not everyone who lives in a monastery is a perfect person. So where you said that they were described as great practitioners, I think in the historical rendering, Nālānda is described as a place of great practitioners, but there are just some people like there is whenever you’ve got 100 people in a room, one of them is not whatever the word is, you say the word. So that’s just for advice. So we’ve had, I think it’s nine times we’ve had come together in the evenings to discuss, to have this introductory discussion to the various dimensions of patience and how to practise it.

And by coming along to these teachings and listening intently and sincerely, it is a way that you have done a very virtuous thing that you should feel that is a great accomplishment that you’ll come to engage in something that is the basis for accumulating such great virtue within your mind and is something you should be congratulated for. And if you can remember when we come to the end of the teachings, as usual when we do our dedications, that it would be good to be mindful the aspiration that our intent and desire to study and practise and achieve this understanding of patience finds its ultimate expression through a peace that is experienced not solely in our small domain but across the entire world and that we have in some way are contributing to this for this force for peace and happiness to exist around the world.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Is there any kind of anger that is good or beneficial?

The only benefit of any experience of anger is that it gives an opportunity to practise patience. Without anger there would be no opportunity to practise patience, and that is its sole benefit. There is one context where anger is considered valid: anger directed at self-cherishing and self-grasping. Self-cherishing is recognised as the inner enemy, the one enemy we do not apply patience to but must seek to destroy. Because we live under its power, recognising it as the enemy gives some rationale for being angry at it, as long as the anger stays within this framework of the internal enemy tracing back to self-cherishing.

Scroll to Top