Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2014-12-02 – KR.mp3
UUID: 4d504011-7718-49ea-9262-96f53be1fd30
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Tenets (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2014-12-02
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 6m
Words: 2,950
Then let us generate the motivation to receive these teachings as usual. Alright. Alright. The loudspeakers don’t work. So if you came a bit closer, it might be a good idea.
So the topic of tenets is a topic which concerns the view of the Buddhist schools of tenets. And all four Buddhist schools of tenets accept both person’s emptiness of being permanent one and independent and person’s emptiness of being substantially established autonomous entities. Now setting aside the Prasangika Madhyamika School of Tenet for the time being, if we consider the topic of the coarse, selflessness of persons, which is persons being empty, of being permanent one and independent. It seems difficult to have a realization of persons being empty of being permanent one and independent without understanding the existence of past and future lives. Here one refers to the existence of one’s own past and future lives and one’s own person being empty of being permanent one and independent.
If one does not accept the existence of past lives, then probably one will end up with the view that persons are permanent one and independent. Why is this the case? Because if one understands the existence of past lives in a logical fashion based on reasoning then one will clearly understand that oneself has had past lives and independence on this it becomes quite straightforward to accept that oneself is not permanent, not one and not independent. The Gong School of Tenets, the non Buddhist school of tenets consider that there is such a thing as a self which is permanent one and independent. But clearly, if one accepts that one’s own past lives exist and that one has passed from those lives into this life under the power of karma and affliction, karma as main cause and affliction as condition, then one necessarily accepts that this life is dependent and this counters directly the affirmation of independence in the statement that the person is permanent one and independent maintained by the other schools of non Buddhist tenets.
Moreover, if this life has a cause, then this cause of its life and its extinction sets the boundary for the end of this life and intimates that this life is impermanent as well. Therefore it is extremely important to understand the existence of one’s own past lives. Once one has understood that a self or an atman which permanent is one and independent does not exist, it becomes easier to refute the subtle self of persons which is an autonomous person. Well, there are numerous lines of reasoning in the Buddhist treatises which demonstrate the existence existence of children who recollect clearly their past lives intimates that we ourselves who are similar to these children must have had past lives as well. Then there is a case I would like to present which was mentioned to me by an acquaintance of mine.
It occurred in Taiwan a couple of years ago. It was a case of a Chinese lady who only spoke Chinese and who suddenly spontaneously in middle age started speaking in an unidentified language which sounded to be an Asian language. Now this was not a case of possession in which a spirit enters the body of the person Since this lady retained her free will in the matter, she could choose to speak or not unlike in cases of possession, but she herself did not know the language she was speaking nor did she understand what she was saying. It was clear, however, to the onlookers that it had to be an Asian language. Cases like this are strongly suggestive of the existence of past lives.
Then I told her that it would be very good if she could stay in a retreat. She was quite comfortable with the idea of retreats either for two weeks or even one month And then the process of purification of the mind would enable her perhaps to know the origin of the language she spoke. This is clearly not a case of possession by a demonic entity or a ghost. I have known many such cases and in those cases there are marked traits of insanity and lack of self control. This was not at all the case as far as she was concerned.
Do you understand? This is probably the result of very stable karmic imprints from a past life. Obviously there are numerous lines of reasonings in Buddhist treatises, scriptural quotations which demonstrate the existence of past lives but they have little impact on most students. This type of experience where two persons meet and share an experience is very powerful. Then regarding the delicate topic we covered last time of the subtle selflessness of phenomena, In other words, the emptiness of duality and what precisely its object of negation was.
The object of negation of the emptiness of duality is none other than exterior establishment, the establishment of phenomena as exterior objects. This refers therefore to the establishment of the five sense objects as exterior objects and is intimately related to the sense consciousnesses. It refers to the appearance of sense objects as being exteriorly established but there also is a similar component as far as mental consciousness is concerned. The coarse selflessness of persons appears to conceptual consciousnesses and therefore it is easier to refute and is termed coarse. However, the subtle selflessness of phenomena appears or the object of refutation of the subtle selflessness of phenomena appears principally to sensory consciousnesses.
It is sensory consciousnesses to which phenomena’s establishment as exterior entities appears. This is therefore much more difficult to refute since when we are told that this does not exist, that visual objects, auditory objects, olfactory objects do not exist outside of consciousness but depend on consciousness for their existence. We say this is not possible. I see them. For that reason, this object of refutation is more subtle and the corresponding emptiness is more subtle.
Then I’ve heard several times from students in this class that exterior objects do exist. We can see them. How can we refute them? Then this shows how difficult it is. As is said, one must refute the inner extremes for a long time.
The inner extremes here refer to the views of the Vaibhashika and the Sautrantika And indeed the Chitamatha school considers that it is when one analyzes the belief in exteriorly established objects which leads these lower Buddhist schools to the conviction in the existence of partless particles. It is for this reason that the Chitamatra school dedicates such effort to the refutation of the existence of part less particles. Then regarding the subtle selflessness of persons, in other words persons being empty of being substantially existent autonomous entities, this is a refutation of autonomous persons. As you remember the example given in Buddhist scriptures is for those who believe in the existence of autonomous persons that the person is like a king within his court. The king does not depend on the court but the court depends on the king.
And this is a simile of the relationship between such an autonomous person and the aggregates. The person does not depend on the aggregates but the aggregate in turn depend on the person. This view is a view where the person which is the imputed phenomenon, although it is indeed imputed on the basis of imputation which is aggregates is considered not to depend on its basis of imputation. As such, this view is one which appears to the mental consciousness but not to the sensory consciousnesses. Then the lines of reasoning which refute the existence of a permanent unitary and independent person are of great benefit in helping the refutation of a person which is a substantially existent autonomous entity.
Then as you remember, we talked last time of the existence in Chitamatra of three final vehicles. The final vehicle of the hearers or Shavakas, the final vehicle of the solitary realizers or Pratyeka Buddhas and the final vehicle of the great vehicle, the Bodhisattva Yana. As far as the final vehicles of the hearers and the solitary realizers are concerned, the mode of finality is similar. This mode of finality is different as far as the final vehicle of the greater vehicle is concerned. So I would like a present to ask you a question.
What is meant by the finality of the final vehicle of the hearers? Why is it final? Everybody. What about the final vehicle of the Mahayana? So what is the difference in the finality between what is the difference in the finality between the final vehicle of the heroes and the final vehicle of the Mahayana?
We use the term final for both. What’s the difference in the meaning of the term? So we’re not talking here of acceptance. All the Chitamatras within the two aspectarian subschool accept as reality that there are three final vehicles and as you said correctly, the final vehicle of the Shravakayana is characterized by severance of the continuum. So the final vehicle of the hearers and the final vehicle of the solitary realizers are similar in their assertion that after having obtained the state of an and having eliminated both afflictions and their seeds upon the relinquishment of the aggregates at the end of that life, in other words, upon death, the continuum, the mental continuum is totally severed.
In other words, one ceases to exist. This is a different understanding of the term final from that of the term final used in the presentation of the final vehicle of the Mahayana. The final vehicle of the Mahayana is said to be final because its object of attainment as well as its object of abandonment as well as the paths, the grounds and so forth are supreme. This is the difference in the meaning of the term final between the paths of the hearers and solitary realizers on the one side and the bodhisattvas on the other side. Then the second subschool of Chitamatra, the fourth aspectarians consider to the difference of the true aspectarians that all sentient beings are suitable for full enlightenment.
In other words, all sentient beings can attain full enlightenment because the false Aspectarians do not accept the existence of three final vehicles. The final vehicle of the Shravaka, Pratyeka Buddha and Bodhisattva and therefore do not accept the severance of the continuum at the end of the final vehicle of the Shravaka and Prateka Buddha. Then that’ll be it for tonight. And if you have questions, please ask your questions now. So the term false aspectarian is used in the context of the view of that sub school.
It is not related to their opinion that Ahats do not experience severance of the continuum upon death. In the text, which means Right? Yes. So that’s 20%. So the question is there’s a passage which says all such as are truly established and a common locus with what is true.
Lily’s question is, is the meaning of the above sentence similar to stating phenomena are empty because of being dependent or rising? The first is Chitamatra way and the second a Prasangika way which both mean almost the same. Geshela says no, that is not the case. Since were that the case, then the Chitamatra and the Prasangika would have the same assertions regarding emptiness. And their assertions are fundamentally different.
Paths. Then don’t worry about it. It’s something which we will cover in that topic where Mr. Matarov explained a bit. We had a question from our group last week that if the Chitamatran, if they believe the hero’s consciousness is severed, so there’s an end to consciousness, that they also believe there’s a beginning to consciousness.
There is necessarily a first instance continuum. There’s both a first instance of of a continuum and a last instance of a continuum. So generally speaking, our continuums are beginningless in the past. Then in the short term, contingency, they have beginnings in this life and so forth. So I said to Geshela, the question you are perhaps asking is, is there a beginning akin to the Christian concept of the creation of a mind or a soul?
Then clearly in the Buddhist context, this is impossible. Consciousness is beginningless in time. This one, you know? To me, contact you. No beginning.
Right? Cycle. What continuum? What first instance of the continuum are you talking about? I understood that the answer to Judy was that there was a beginning of the mental continuum when I thought, as you were saying, we talk about beginningless.
There is no first moment of mind. So I just wanted to clarify what is actually saying because the the cause of one moment of mind is the previous moment of mind. So it’s just saying that there is a point where that is not the case. So the problem arises because you’re not making a difference between the continuum in general and a specific continuum. There’s no first moment for the continuum in general or the mind in general.
Doesn’t exist. Then there’s a first moment for the continuum of this life which is the moment the mind enters in the you’re very astonished. The first moment the mind enters in the fertilized egg of the mother. That is Geshe was saying. There are contingent first moments.
The first moment of the path of accumulation, the first moment of the path of preparation and so forth. It’s manifestation of extreme astonishment. So if we’re speaking in general, there is no first instant of the mind. Then if you’re speaking of a specific state of mind, a specific continuum or something and you posit the first moment and then you say, ah, but there’s a moment before that, then it’s very strange and it becomes circular. Alright?
I just want to try and understand the false and the true aspect here. So are those words false and true used to describe the Chitamatra schools in the way that we understand true and false? So there’s a Chitamatra school that’s, more correct, which is the true, and the Chitamatra school that’s not so correct, which is the false. Or could Geshela explain? No.
The difference between the true and the false aspectarians is not that one is true and the other is false but it refers to their view of reality. The true aspectarians consider that if we take the example of the eye consciousness perceiving the color blue, the coarse aspect of that color blue does exist. The false aspectarians say that also does not exist. Few weeks ago, Geshela was explaining about the the common factor of appearance and the uncommon factor of appearance of, say, the fan And our own individual experience of that fan is based on our own karma, which is the uncommon experience. Is the common experience of what we would designate external objects, like a fan or a car or something, is that can we talk about it in terms of our collective karma so that as human beings as a collection of people in this room, we have a collective karma to see things in a certain way based on our culture in the same way as perhaps dogs would have a similar response to a bone, for example, and that would be their collective karma.
Would it be true to use those terms? Yes, it is explained in terms of the shared environmental karma. At the beginning of the class, talked about how if one does not accept past and future lives, it is likely that one would see beings as one permanent and independent. So he is positing that if you do sit, understand, and accept past and future lives, then you are more likely to see beings as not being one permanent and independent. So why do so many so many countless beings, you know, such as Hindus accept past and future lives but don’t accept ourselves as being empty of being one permanent and independent.
Then Geshela was saying basically the Hindus accept the existence of past and future lives. They also accept the existence of God and they accept the existence of a person which is permanent, one and independent. This is contradictory. It’s contradictory. It’s certainly contradictory.
Illogical. Then If people accept illogical things, nothing can be done. Put it quite bluntly. He said when people are really silly and they they would accept correct views and you take a club and you say, go here. Last week at the beginning of the teaching, you mentioned nine minds and awarenesses.
And then in our study group, we were trying to find a list of nine minds, and Hero found a ninth consciousness called the immaculate consciousness or Mhmm. In Tibetan. And we were wondering if this was what Geshela was referring to. This is correct. Some schools accept a ninth consciousness which is called stainless consciousness.
Some accept one consciousness, some accept six collections of consciousness, some accept eight collections of consciousness, some accept nine collections of consciousness. Many subdivisions. We will stop here and start our discussion. There are three topics of discussion for tonight. The first is the difference and the relationship between the selflessness of persons and the surfaces of phenomena.
The second is the meaning of finality in the three final vehicles. And the third is my personal opinion that if one accepts the existence of past lives it is easier to accept or to refute the existence of a self which is permanent, one and independent. Then by twos with different partners the next Please start.
Key terms in this teaching
- atman dag (Tib)
- Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- shravaka nyen thö (Tib)
- A hearer; a Hinayana practitioner who strives for liberation from cyclic existence on the basis of listening to teachings from a teacher. There are four divisions: stream-enterer, once-returner, non-returner and arhat. LYWA
- Shravakayana nyen thö kyi thegpa (Tib)
- The Hearer Vehicle. One of the branches of the Hinayana. The path of hearers (shravakas), practitioners who strive for liberation from cyclic existence on the basis of listening to teachings from a spiritual guide or teacher. LYWA
- Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
- The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA
- yana
- Literally, vehicle; a spiritual path that leads to an awakened state. The vehicle and spiritual journey depends on the attitude of the practitioner. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.