Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2014-12-03 – KR.mp3
UUID: ee010bed-89ec-461e-8f2d-c2f8a5528e47
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2014-12-03
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 34m
Words: 3,897
It’s extremely important without, in this context, talking about calm abiding to have a calm, untroubled mind, a mind which has a modicum of independence and freedom. So when we say an untroubled mind, troubled by what? Troubled by the afflictions? Troubled, in other words, by desire, by anger, by jealousy, by competitiveness? If the mind is untroubled, then mental afflictions such as desire and hatred would have no physical or psychophysiological impact.
There is asymmetry however because if one’s mind is troubled then one will experience great suffering. Mind. This has been commented upon extensively by Dharmakirti and Chandra Kirti and we do not need to enter in greater detail. And the more powerful, the sense of I, the greater the trouble and the suffering and we can see for ourselves that as our sense of I increases, we become very narrow minded, very limited and I don’t refer here to physical but to mental narrow mindedness. Then once one understands the thoughts, the defects of anger or of competitiveness, then one will search for its origin, this sense of I, and one will in turn try to analyze the mode of abiding of I.
Therefore, we must find means to reduce the power of this I. What are these means? Initially, we must understand that self grasping or the apprehension of the self is a mistaken state of mind. It is not a correct state of mind. For instance, if I take what is pleasing to myself, this is in no way necessarily pleasing to yourselves.
Likewise, what is pleasing to you will not be pleasing to others. Then most certainly once one understands that grasping or the apprehension of a self is a mistaken mind and not a correct state of mind, its holiness will decrease. Then this is easy to understand under analysis. Under analysis we can see that the apprehension of a self or grasping at a self is a mistaken mind because if I take for instance those whom I find attractive, my father, my mother, my relatives, my sister, my brother, I find them attractive and out of this attraction desire arises. It is however certain that you do not find my relatives attractive.
Attractive or pleasing most definitely will not appear to me necessarily as attractive or pleasing. However, if the attractiveness and the pleasantness was inherent in the perceived phenomenon then we would both perceive it as attractive and pleasing which is not the case. Then an object of refutation such as the apprehension at a self is a difficult object of refutation to understand. However, these lines of reasoning are accessible to us and we can see that as a result of following such lines of reasoning, our grasping at a self will decrease. As our grasping at a self decreases in turns our happiness, our peace and happiness will be enhanced and a byproduct of this will be less fancies and fantasies.
If the opposite occurs, if one’s grasping at the self intensifies, then fantasies and fancies conceptual activity skyrockets and with it unhappiness. Really? Yeah, yeah. Good, good. Qualities of its own.
It might on occasion contingently have some positive aspects but these are fleeting overall. There is nothing positive about it and as we are able over time to reduce its intensity, we will be at ease. We will be at peace. We will experience something akin to pliancing. Then having identified the foe which is self grasping or the apprehension of a self, we must apply the requisite antidotes and the antidote is the wisdom realizing selflessness.
As one becomes habituated to the wisdom realizing selflessness over time, the intensity of the grasping at a self decreases until eventually one is able to eradicate or extirpate it from within our mind with its seeds. When one has eradicated the grasping at itself with its seeds from our mind, then one will have attained a state of immutable, of unchanging happiness and this is liberation. So this demands analysis. Is there such thing as liberation? What are its features?
And so forth. And therefore that which we should be striving for is a liberation which is a liberation from anger and all of the afflictions with their seeds. Ideally within this life, if that is not possible within a future life. If that is not attained then we will keep on circling within the wheel over and over again experiencing the same problems over and over again. There is a Tibetan expression I can’t translate a local expression.
If I understand correctly, it is the behavior of cattle under a yoke which never ends. So such an object, such a goal is the object we should have and to attain such an object as liberation is excellent. And therefore it is such an object of observation we should aim for as is said in Jitsongpa’s Catechal of Realization to obtain the supreme path one requires a basis which is fully characterized. The supreme path here is our goal, but what precisely is a fully characterized basis? It is precisely a human rebirth of leisure and endowment such as the one we have.
However, to attain the supreme path in one life seems difficult. We must therefore attain such a basis over and again. So the usefulness of a rebirth such as ours, a basis such as ours is visible. We can accomplish whatever we wish on this basis. For this reason, Shantideva in Bodhisattva Charyavatara says, should I not put to good use a base such as this, what foolishness would this be?
Then if we want such an attainment, the attainment of liberation then a rebirth such as this one is insufficient. We need such a rebirth again and again. A human rebirth, a human base over and again. Are we sure we can get such a human rebirth? There is no certainty in the matter.
When should we practice? Instead of procrastinating and deferring, it is now we should practice since we are facing death and impermanence. As I read the words of a great scholar, Ginghu, who said, if you want to reap tomorrow, sow today. Facing death in impermanence, study. These are wise words indeed.
He was very famous in this world. And therefore it is critical for us to meditate on death and impermanence. Now, more normally the meditations on death and impermanence occur after the entreaty to seize the essence of this human rebirth through identifying the nature of a rebirth of leisure and endowment, its great importance and its rarity, there is no necessity in this matter and one could perfectly meditate about on it before. And therefore understanding that if we do not at present actualize these practices since within our mind stream we have numerous causes for rebirth in the lower realms, we will unavoidably be reborn in the lower realms and be reborn not once but continually over and over again in the lower realms. It is at this point that great fear should arise within our minds.
Not a mere fear of the lower realms, but a realization that once one is reborn in the lower realms, let us say as an animal, let alone lacking mental freedom which we lack even now, one will also lack physical freedom of which we have at present as human beings a modicum. One realizes that any type of practice, let alone liberation, in the lower realms is well nigh impossible. It is the fear of the impossibility to attain liberation from the lower realms which is a supreme fear we should generate. And at this point, one should try to avoid this situation. And therefore the fear of the lower realms which is of benefit in the context of the Lamrim is not a mere fear of the lower realms which reflects on the great sufferings one will experience in the lower realms but it is instead a fear of the lower realms which reflects on the impossibility to attain liberation from the lower realms.
This is what the fear of the lower realms is meant to be in the Lamrim. And therefore it is through reflecting on the impossibility of attaining our goal which is liberation should we be reborn in the lower realms that fear from the lower realms should arise. At this point, one seeks for a protector who can protect one, who can act as a refuge against such a fear and at this point takes refuge in the triple gem. The actual refuge from the standpoint of Lamrim in the triple gem is a refuge out of fear of the general sufferings of cyclic existence as well as the specific sufferings of cyclic existence. Not a fear out of the mere, a refuge out of the mere fear of the suffering of the lower realms.
And therefore, the innermost essence of the objects or the cycles of meditation of the path of the being of the small scope is fourfold. We have meditation on death and impermanence, fear of the suffering of the lower realms, refuge and karma and causality. Then the three preliminary meditations which are identifying a rebirth of leisure and endowment, reflecting on its great meaningfulness and on its fleetingness are preliminaries to incite one to take the essence of a precious human rebirth. If one is already someone who is taking this essence, these are unnecessary. I cannot say whether you are in this category or not.
I reflected on this topic after a question last time regarding the appropriateness of beginning the meditations of the being of the small scope with meditation on death and impermanence and whether the fear of the suffering of the lower realm should actually not refer to something broader than this. I think this is quite appropriate. It’s a question which arises from study and indeed the fear of the lower realms referred to here is a fear of a state of affairs in which we will be totally unable to practice towards liberation since we need to attain a rebirth such as our present one over and over and over again to attain liberation. So until one has attained a path of abandonment, one is unable to relinquish the fear of rebirth in the lower realms. For such therefore the attainment of a path of abandonment is indispensable.
On the other hand, to relinquish the aggregates of suffering one must have attained at the very least the path of seeing. And therefore the Kadampa geshes of yore were able to abandon this body and to turn away from the vanities of this life. They encapsulated this with the famous statement abandon the ranks of society and join the ranks of dogs. And therefore one should practice these four main cycles of meditation precisely and in sequence. Meditating on death and impermanence, on the suffering of the lower realms, on refuge and on karma.
This is why it is taught in the Lamrim that if one is able to turn this life into something which is secondary and lives from the next one onwards into the principle, one will have the realizations of a being of the small scope. This is however a topic which requires repeated familiarization. And therefore we should reflect on death and impermanence, dependence on this, on the suffering of the lower realms, then on refuge and finally on karma and causality. And understand that to be able to attain our goal, which is liberation with all its qualities, we will need a base such as this one over and over and over again, life after life. And for this we must protect karma correctly.
With this as a motivation we should engage in meditation. Then let us meditate for a couple of minutes. As I mentioned last time, it is As I mentioned last time, it is important to understand that the path of the being of the small scope and specifically death and impermanence is included within the presentation of the four noble truths. Specifically, the first noble truth, the noble truth of suffering has four characteristics. One of these characteristics is impermanence which in turn is subdivided into coarse and subtle impermanence.
The presentation of coarse impermanence actually refers to death and impermanence. Then within the context of the presentation of the 10 virtuous and the 10 non virtuous deeds, some doubts may arise at the level of the path of the being of the small scope. Specifically, you remember, these three mental non virtuous deeds are covetousness, ill will and wrong views. And covetousness is that state of mind which views an object as attractive, a contaminated object and allows that the attractiveness for that contaminated object to increase until the resolve is taken, I must possess this object. At that point, the mental non wretched deed of covetousness has been performed.
Now if this is the case, the following doubt may arise. The goal, the focus of the being of the small scope is the attainment of a higher rebirth. Just as the goal of the being of the middling scope and of the great scope are respectively the attainment of liberation, definite excellence and full enlightenment. If this is the case for the being of the small scope, after all, future rebirths are future rebirths within cyclic existence. They are contaminated.
Therefore, the mind which strives to attain such rebirths would then become contaminated any form of covetousness. Then this very profound doubt is presented in Lamrim Chenmo in Jetsong Kapa’s great treatise on the stages of the path by an unknown opponent, a kachik who says, literally it means if someone says the goal of the being of the small scope is the attainment of a higher rebirth. Higher rebirths are contaminated therefore striving for higher rebirth can be included within craving, can it not? To this, Je Tsongkhapa answers, this is not the case. One must distinguish between ultimate contingent goals.
The striving for a higher rebirth within the context of the path of a being of the small scope is a contingent goal of the being on that path. It is not the ultimate goal. This is a doubt I wanted to present to you. It’s somewhat difficult. I’m not sure if you understand it, but I find it quite interesting.
And then another doubt which arose in the context of the teachings of the holy elder, and which I remember quite clearly was when someone asked Rinpoche, is the path of the being of the small scope an uncommon Buddhist path or not? And Rinpoche answered colloquially, how could it be? And this led to a lot of profound reflection because clearly if the fear of the lower realms which is referred to is a mere fear of a lower rebirth, then it is difficult to see how this could be the case. If it is not a mere fear of lower rebirth but leads to a higher goal, then clearly this is an uncommon Buddhist path. Then this is something which calls for very casual analysis and would not probably arouse in discussions in the country.
But I remember clearly that it is a question Rinpoche addressed to his students privately over again in very vernacular and colloquial Tibetan. And Rinpoche would say, hey, just how do you think it is possible that the path of the being of the small scope is an uncommon Buddhist path? Then you need not doubt since what has satisfied this doubt in my mind is the following line of reasoning. Our ultimate goal must be liberation, but liberation is very far away for most of us. So we need to take a human rebirth over and over and over and over again.
So while our ultimate goal is liberation, our contingent goal must be to have the conditions to continue practicing life after life after life. Do you understand? Yes. Really? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Good. Good ideas. Then we will stop here for today and I would like to ask only one question per person. And if nobody has any questions left, some people can ask a second question. Ilya, I’m not familiar with the term uncommon Buddhist goal.
What I don’t understand uncommon Buddhist. What what is that referring to? I I understand the contingent goal, and I can see about liberation and could be covetousness. But in the small scope, it is contingent goal, but I don’t understand the term uncommon Buddhist goal. So uncommon is what is different from another.
In English we would say specific. Beyond. What what does Geshele think of this? That an Christians of an old kind fear the lower realms, but fear eternal damnation and and look for everlasting life that is granted to them by god. The Buddhadharma does posits no god and sees the lower scope as a contingent goal.
Might this be a difference between other I don’t know about Islam? Might this be a difference that this uncommon is that there is no there is no eternal damnation, and there is no everlasting life. What does Geshela think of this? Your mode of thinking is very good. This is indeed a difference between Christianity and Buddhism but it is not the main difference.
The main difference is posited in terms of the view. Thank you, Geshela. My question is kind of related as well, which is when I contemplate the lower realms and the fear that liberation is not possible from the lower realms, I wonder about those beings that are already in the lower realms. And what what is what is happening with them? What is the future of them, of the beings who are already in the lower realms?
Good idea. Yours is a good question. It is extremely rare for a being from the lower realm to be able to gain a higher rebirth but these things do happen and as the Buddhist scriptures teach, it happens through a combination of the power of the Buddha and the potency of the field. Potency of the field. Potency.
The field. So it’s mainly the activities of the Buddha who are able to detect a karmic imprint within the mind of that sentient being in the lower realms and cause it to mature since it is said that all sentient beings are suitable for the attainment of enlightenment. And Ananda? In the beginning of section on observing force effect, he talks about integration of the various topics or various cycles of meditation in the the in the small scope. And he talks about combining So when you say together, one must distinguish the meaning of together.
If by together you mean simultaneously, it seems very difficult to practice simultaneously meditating on the suffering of the lower realms and refuge. However, what refers to here is the inseparable practice of meditating on the lower realms and refuge and so forth. This indeed is necessary. And another? Kishila, seems that given the instability and the uncertainty of Samsara, it seems very dangerous to aim for a higher rebirth within Samsara.
However, I know from, you know, I haven’t even given up attachment to this life. So would it be fair to say that that’s where having a strong refuge is important because of the basically, the nature of Samsara is suffering where everyone is is is born. So let alone the fear of the lower realms, it’s also the fear of samsara that bothers me about aiming for a higher rebirth. What is your question? So the question is, would it mean the importance of developing a strong refuge at the same time as aspiring for a higher rebirth to protect one from the sufferings of a rebirth in If we are unable to create in this life the causes for a higher rebirth, it is guaranteed we will be reborn in the lower realms since the causes for these rebirths exist already within our mind streams.
It is therefore indispensable to generate simultaneously the fear of such a rebirth together with the conviction that there is a refuge which can protect us from such a rebirth. These two causes, the fear and the conviction act as a cause for a true or a perfect refuge. Just going back to covetousness and craving. So a covetous sort of two parts to one question. Is covetousness and craving the same thing?
And is this the same craving that is one of the 12 links of dependent origination? So regarding the first part of your question, every instance of covetousness is an instance of craving but the reciprocal is not true. In other words, craving is a more all encompassing category than covetousness since for covetousness to occur, the four features of the base, the thought, the application and the conclusion must be present, this is not the case for covetousness. To continue with your first question, even though craving continues to increase, it is possible independence on that craving to be reborn in a higher realm. This is not possible with covetousness.
Now your second question is a very good one. There is an important difference between craving on the one hand and craving within the 12 links of dependent origination on the other hand. First ground Bodhisattvas have craving within their mind stream. They do not have craving within the 12 links of dependent origination within their mind stream. Because once one has seen the truth, in other words, one has attained the path of abandonment, of the path of seeing, even though one no longer has craving which is included within the 12 links of dependent origination within one’s mind stream because one has abandoned it, one nonetheless still has craving.
And another question. Once one is reborn in the lower realms, it will take an extremely long time to attain liberation. There is such a thing as the end of cyclic existence at that point one would. Yes. But my prayer my answer is what place does prayer our prayer for them Mhmm.
Our higher reward for enlightenment is their place. So what one can say is that when one prays for others there is great benefit for oneself. One’s own courage, one’s own mental strength, one’s qualities will increase. Others, it’s very difficult to know. Yes.
This is why it is said I rejoice in the virtue of others. Prayers are virtuous deeds. Have you finished your question? Next week is the last teaching and we will be making a very small offering of body, speech and mind. But the following Tuesday night is Lama Zongkapa and day.
So there will be a Guru Pooja at seven. So that’ll be an opportunity Tuesday, the sixteenth. So that’ll be an opportunity to make a offering to Geshela if you wish. And and just notice on the calendar when the center is closed and reopening in mid January. Geshela has given us our homework for the break to study the small scope and the various meditations therein.
So we’ve got our work cut out. So enjoy some chai. Thank you. And also for people on the twenty fifth on Christmas, there was an email that went out, you’re But just let the office know. Thanks.
Key terms in this teaching
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.