Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Session 4 Sympossium.mp3
UUID: bb137159-73b9-4dce-89b5-9740d4aacd0c
Teacher: —
Collection: TBI Symposium
Duration: 1h 47m
Words: 12,609
Very well. Then I would like to thank you for attending this presentation. I must apologize. We are technically hugely overextended on this one. It’s one of the reasons we have decided to stop holding the symposium at TBI.
Between having no budget, not finding speakers and so forth, it becomes unmanageable. But Vasilis very kindly prepared a presentation. We were going to, feed her audio which she sent from Switzerland through the speakers, then we have not been able to do it. We were going to have her present it live, but that we don’t have the bandwidth. So since I have the audio, I will repeat what she says.
And unfortunately, you will have to imagine that my rather deep male voice is that of a young blonde Swiss researcher. Good luck with the visualization. Fascinating. And then we will try to connect, with her by Skype at 04:00. We see if it works or not.
It worked when we tested it. So So it’s a bit awkward to present this with having you in front of me, but I will present some studies prepared in our team at the University of Bern. Our plan and what is most important is a presentation of our goal as evolutionary biologists, which is to be able to explain phenomena in a certain framework, which is an evolutionary one. And according to certain rules, which I will try to define later on. In our group, the phenomena we try to explain are cooperation.
I’ll first introduce this evolutionary approach and why altruism reciprocity are challenging in this particular evolutionary approach. I believe that our perspective is not in contradiction with a spiritual vision of altruism, but is just another way of viewing the problem. What is important is to to see that we stipulate nothing about the motivation. Then at first degree, our vision may look cynical, but it is merely an attempt to understand in an evolutionary perspective why one should be good. In other words, how can altruism be maintained through the generations?
After this introduction, we will see that nevertheless, Norway rats are able to cooperate using reciprocity. In a second section, I will say some words about Norway rats and give you some examples of studies involving cooperation with Norway rats. The evolutionary approach. The evolution approach in a Darwinian sense is valid for observed traits which are observed, in other words, phenotypical traits, and only these. Examples would be colors and so forth, including behavior.
These traits, however, are not only genetically determined, but for our perspective to be valuable, they should at least be mainly genetically determined. The evolutionary approach is therefore one which asserts that a trait can only spread any species if it is justified in terms of survival and reproduction. It should therefore not be detrimental on the fitness of the individual. What do we mean by fitness in biology? It is the average contribution to the gene pool of the next generation.
To try to make it less cryptic, let us take the most extreme example possible I can give to illustrate this. Let us assume a gene is responsible for fertility and another for the sterility of an individual. The one which is responsible for fertility will allow the individual to have offspring. And these offspring will carry that gene. If a gene is responsible for sterility, it cannot be transmitted to the next generation.
So this is an extreme example, but helps want to understand the approach. Why is altruism challenging? How can altruism be defined in evolutionary biology? The definition we give of altruism in evolutionary behavior is behavior which is a costly act and temporarily reduces the Darwinian fitness of the individual. And this is to the benefit of another individual.
Returning to our illustration, we can imagine that if altruism is simply defined by one of several genes, if an individual carry these genes by acting altruistically at his own expense, he will reduce his opportunity to transmit these genes to the next generation. Whereas, if a selfish individual benefits from that individual, he will transmit those selfish genes to other offspring. Therefore, it is quite obvious why during decades, altruism has been considered a social behavior which was highly challenging for evolutionary biologists since it was very difficult to justify in terms of survival. Nevertheless, altruism is observed among various species in the field. There are different ways to explain altruism, and evolutionary biologists have proposed several hypotheses.
The first is skin selection, which I shall not speak about a lot. I will mention briefly what it means. It means that if you help someone who is from your family, in other words, who shares a lot of genes with you, this can be beneficial at a genetic level. It’s a very basic explanation of kin selection. But what is far more tricky and challenging for biology is how to explain altruism in favor of individuals who are unrelated to us.
And here, several propositions have been made, including which different forms of reciprocity and coercion. And we have studied this in our rats at the University of Bern. The vision of reciprocity and why it is challenging. Reciprocity is challenging at least concerning Norway rats. If we resume reciprocity, I help you, you will help me later.
This does not mean that I help you because you will help me later. It means merely I help you, you will help me later. Therefore, a decrease in one’s own instantaneous fitness by increasing a partner’s fitness may, but does not have to lead to evolutionarily stable cooperation by repeated interactions between same partners. To better explain this, it is interesting to study an economic example which is a very good illustration of direct reciprocity, Axelrod’s vision of the iterated prisoner’s dilemma. Allow me to explain the prisoner’s dilemma.
The situation is the following one. Two men are in jailed, suspected to be criminals. Both are separated and neither knows what the other will do or say. And both can always say, I am guilty or I am innocent. The other is in guilty.
If they say, am guilty, they cooperate. If they say, I am innocent, they do not cooperate. If both say I am guilty, they will go in jail for five years. If both say I am innocent, they will be in jail for ten years. However, if one says I’m guilty and the other I’m innocent, the one who says I am guilty will stay all his life in prison, and the one who says I am innocent will be freed.
According to that, it is easy to see that if it happens only once, of course, you should say I am innocent. Because when you’re dealing with someone who’s also saying you’re innocent, you may spend ten years in prison, but not your whole life. And when you’re dealing with someone who says he’s guilty, you are free. The problem arises when both say they are innocent. In other words, if neither cooperates, they stay longer in prison than if both say they are guilty.
And therefore, at a general level, for both of them, it is better to say that they are both guilty than they are both innocent. So if you have to have multiple interactions with another party, and they do not cooperate, the benefits for the group would eventually be lower. It is, I think, a good illustration for direct reciprocity and why it is evolutionarily stable. Direct reciprocity has been observed in humans, but what about other species? And the problem with direct reciprocity is that it requires cognitive skills.
We have to recognize individual, memorize what they have done, be able to adapt one’s behavior according to previous interactions. For that reason, during decades, biologists were very skeptical regarding the existence of direct reciprocity in non humans. The requisite cognitive abilities were considered to be lacking. I would like to make here a brief philosophical digression to mention Hume’s dictum of anthropofabulation. Anthropologists always, say that people are anthropomorphic and read human behavior in animals.
They say one must not interpret what one observes in animals in human terms. And, obviously, I would agree that when someone, generally an old lady, comes into a store and says, my dog, Phe Phe loves the color blue, perhaps that is an anthropofabulation. What is anthropofabulation? It is a combination of anthropocentrism and an exaggeration of human cognitive capacities. I would like to read what Hume says.
When any hypothesis is advanced to explain a mental operation which is common to men and beasts, we must apply the same hypothesis to both. Philosophers suppose such a subtlety of thought does not only exceed the capacity of mere animals, but even the common people in our own species. And here, a study performed in humans clearly demonstrates an overestimation of our own cognitive capacity with respect to other human beings. We are more prone to explain our own behavior in term of inner motivational patterns and the behavior of others in terms of causal and cultural patterns. So if this is a case between humans, we can imagine the degree to which it operates within the heterospecifics of the species.
And even though scientists scientists considered direct reciprocity could only be observed in humans, it has been shown that it is present in other species, specifically Norway rats. We are now at the heart of our topic. I would like to say a few words about Norway rats. Why Norway rats? They possess high cognitive capacities.
They are able to perform learning tests. They live in colonies of up to several 100 individuals. They are highly social. They communicate. They possess all the prerequisites for complex cooperative strategies.
This gave us the idea to test whether they were able of reciprocal interaction or not. In our team, we decided to work with Norway rats coming from the University of Groningen in The Netherlands. One type because as we are evolutionary biologists, we are interested in the behavior of natural animals, not lab trained rats. However, for health reasons, we decided to take rats born in laboratories to avoid dealing with specific health issues. Until last year, we worked exclusively with female rats, which are less hierarchical than males.
Nowadays, we work with both. Norway rats and direct reciprocity. Claudio Rutte, years ago, was the first to test direct reciprocity with the task given to RASK we shall now be explaining now. The task is the following one. The rats have to learn to put on a stick to make a platform enter on a stick.
And they learn this through getting a reward when the platform enters the case. As soon as they do this, they never get a reward for themselves anymore. After that, what they do is they have to pull on the stick to make the platform enter into a separate part of the cage, separated by a grid from the rest of the cage. Thanks to which the rat in the other compartment gets the reward. All our studies are done on a certain number of individuals.
And when we say that when we observe something, it means that according to some biological criteria, the majority of the population acts in a certain way. There are naturally variations, but we have criteria in biology which enable us to assert that when a population acts in a certain way, a certain number of individuals do act in this way. The idea of this task was to test a certain number of rats, who would firstly be in front of a cooperator, someone who will therefore pull for them. They will be in the role of the receiver. And at a certain moment, will be in front of a defector.
In other words, someone who will provide nothing, who is trained not to give any food. The test rats don’t know who is a provider and who is a defector. And the second
Is to see how the test rat, when they themselves are in the role of provider, will act when dealing with individuals who have helped them or not. The relevant measures of help here are the number of pulls, mean latency or time between pulls, and latency or time before the first pull. What was observed is that the median pulling delay is indeed shorter for Norway rats dealing with rats who have cooperated before than non cooperators. And they were therefore able to use the direct reciprocity rule. They helped those who had helped them.
However, the quality of the received help makes a difference. I wanted to know to which degree quality would make a difference. I wanted to know if the quality of the received help was an important factor in direct reciprocity. I tried to see if reciprocal help was adjusted to the benefit in Rattus norvegicus. To do that, I used the fact that rats love bananas and are more hesitant about carrots.
And my goal was to disentangle the benefit from the partner’s cost for its help and the identity and condition of the partner. The logic was to only manipulate the benefit and not to have a cooperator and a defector, but two cooperators. One providing test rats with bananas and the other providing a lot of effort to give carrots which are not appreciated. During the two first days, the rats were in the middle of a compartment between two cooperators, one pulling to give four pieces of banana and one pulling four times to give four pieces of carrots. Same cost.
We used 20 test individuals. And then the two following days, the test rat had the opportunity, either in the morning or the afternoon, to help the cooperator who gave a banana, and at another moment to help the cooperator who gave a carrot. And we observed how much he helped them. What we observed was for equal effort of cooperators, rats pulled earlier for those who provided them with bananas, the preferred and high nutritional value reward. Is the quality of received helped relevant independently of other factors for Norway rat’s propensity to reciprocate?
The answer is yes. This was quite interesting. And what was even more interesting is, as I told you, we tested the rats on two days. And the differential reciprocal investment increased significantly even though the two cooperators didn’t pull in between for them. So, what are our conclusions?
We were able to reject the hypotheses that the observed reciprocity reflected copying. It also corroborated the hypotheses that reciprocity is favored by multiple interaction. This leads to some illustrations in nature. Why there are cooperative networks with preferential dyadic relationships which are observed in vampire bats, primates, and so forth. Indeed, if some individuals are more skilled to doing things, they it cost them less effort to do it for others.
And one can understand why individuals should choose to be with other individuals at the expense of others. Indeed, if individuals reciprocate according to benefit, it is better to help when you are competent and efficient because you pay a lower cost and it gives a lot of advantage in the relationship and the counterpart reciprocates more. Another issue we addressed in our group, and for once I will be able to make a small digression on motivation, is the importance of the partner’s condition. It was demonstrated that the hunger state of social partners as well as their condition, in other words, weight, influenced the degree of help. This is also associated with their hierarchical position.
What was shown was that when the receiver was hungry, test rats pulled more often for light than for heavy partners. But when the receiver was satiated, the test rats pulled more for the heavy partners, which is fascinating. Since it seems as if the motivation is not the same in both cases. As if the motivation of test rats changed between context. When helping a hungry social partner after receiving help from someone else, the motivation to help is influenced by the need of the partner, and this might indicate empathy.
Here, to return what I was saying at the beginning, I was unfortunately showing how cynical we can be in these experiments. Generosity may be gratifying to the donor. We haven’t tested this, but it is an acceptable explanation. However, our explanation as evolutionary biologists is that the probability to receive future help should be increased by preferring to help needing partners. This has nothing to do with the reasons for which the individual is engaged in this behavior, but the issue of whether the genes conditioning such behavior can be perpetuated or not.
This could also increase the survival probability of receivers, which would raise the probability that they can help subsequently. Now something somewhat more provocative and darker. Direct reciprocity versus coercion. For us, evolutionary biologists, help under coercion is also a form of altruism. Direct reciprocity, I help you.
You will help me later. Help under coercion occurs when we say, I help you because I’m afraid of what you would do to me if I didn’t. Of course, it doesn’t look very altruistic in the common sense of the term. But if you think that you increase the partner’s fitness by decreasing yours, we can say that it is a form of altruistic behavior. In which context did we investigate coercion?
And when standard experiment performed as a control, test runs neither pulled more nor quicker for cooperators than for defectors. There was absolutely no difference. This was a very bad surprise for us. What we had observed during this experiment was that social partners sometimes manifested aggressive behavior towards test individuals. They would bite them and so forth.
So what I tried to do is to try to avoid the biting attempts in my analyses. And then we observed that test rats pulled more for cooperators who had not bitten them previously, but they also pulled more for defectors who had bitten them previously. The only possible interpretation of these biting attempts was coercion. After attempting to bite them previously, they were rewarded out of fear by providing food. It was not completely surprising since the rule of punishment for coercive acts has been observed in other species, like humans, keys, and so forth.
What is interesting and what we observed was that when individuals or partners were cooperating and punishing at the same time, It did not have an additive effect, but a mutually exclusive effect. Like multiplying two minuses, which makes a positive. The best strategy is either to help or to bite, but not to both help and bite, in which case you will receive no help. I also wish to test the link between direct reciprocity and learning abilities. I wish to test this also because direct reciprocity was considered doubtful because of lack of cognitive ability in the species tested.
I tested 28 rats in a two choice learning task. The rats had to recognize two visual cues to get the food in compartments. At another moment, they had to recognize two different odors. One associated with the food in one compartment and the other with the food in another compartment. And finally, two different sounds associated with two different types of food.
They were given thirty seconds to choose into which compartment they decided to go. Of course, there was a variance among rats in the capacity to perform this test. And there is also a variance in the propensity to rely on direct reciprocity. Some will help quite readily. Some will help cooperatives and defectors more.
Some will help cooperatives even more. But I wish to see if the degree of direct reciprocity was correlated with the capacity to memorize sensory cues. I did this because of the skepticism concerning contingent reciprocity for nonhuman species. Naturally, the ability to recognize and memorize social partners is a prerequisite for direct reciprocity. But we believe it is not the only prerequisite.
When one doesn’t observe direct reciprocity, it can be influenced by other factors. The assumptions were that a lack of observed reciprocal cooperation was caused by subjects’ cognitive limitations, the degree of contingent reciprocity should strictly correlate with the ability to recognize and memorize sensory cues. With regard to sensory cues, to social context, it should be even more important. The results we observed in two experiments on cooperation, individuals who performed better in the learning task with olfactory cues had indeed a higher propensity to exhibit direct reciprocity. However, the most important, in a third experiment on cooperation in which rats could not see their partner, they could only smell and hear it, They were using direct reciprocity rules, and the degree of direct reciprocity was not affected by the learning abilities with the olfactory cues.
The degree of direct reciprocity was never affected by the overall learning capacities. We conclude that it was not a lack of olfactory recognition which impaired the ability to help according to direct reciprocity, but rather that we could observe that developed olfactory recognition induced individuals to direct to rely on direct reciprocity for helping. Basically, in the situation in which the available limited information was limited, but olfactory cues were provided, all rats relied on direct reciprocity rules. It is basically not a question of olfactory mnemonic capacities. Therefore, if individuals fail to help according to direct reciprocity rules, it may not be due to cognitive limitations, but rather to the use of alternative rules such as the results on coercion.
Here, I would like to set aside what I said until now and pass to an anecdote, which is quite meaningful for me and very touching. It’s an account I read in Kim Sheridan’s animals and the afterlife. It’s a nice non scientific story to conclude with. The story of old, obliged, Madeline. Kim Sheridan keeps a lot of rats in liberty in her house.
And at the end of the day, she feeds them. She had an old rat, which is blind, unable to move well, And she feared it would be unable to get quickly enough to food, she thought she should help it. However, she realized that a young rat began to feed this old rat. She was bringing food in front of her and protecting her from the other rats to prevent the other rats from stealing her food. And then she realized that Madeline didn’t need her in the slightest and that the rats could help each other.
Then I will give no scientific interpretation, but it is nice to see that friendship exists among rats. The most important thing I learned from my rats does not figure in these studies. I learned it in their eyes and I keep it in my heart. They were great collaborators. Thank you for your attention.
Thank you to Ilya Jurewicz for having invited me to speak today. Thank you to all the persons who participate in these studies. Thank you to my little lady rats. Then my apologies for the technical limitations. We simply weren’t able to crack the interface between GarageBand or iTune and the central sound system despite three attempts by Tenzin, my wife, and myself.
But I hope you were able to get the essence of Vasilisa’s presentation. Now I know it is quite dry. I think for quite a few of you, it was a a steep slope to travel. But this is how
Serious, solid, stable results are obtained. It is this type of painstaking analysis which enables science to make definitive statements. Like here, her team, it’s actually Professor Taborsky, and all this research is new research. Some of it unpublished by Vasilisa. This research enables them to say that direct reciprocity is not only present in rats, but that, rats respond equally to direct reciprocity and to coercion.
And interestingly enough, I don’t know if you’re in your human relations you have this experience, that if you alternate between the stick and the carrot, it doesn’t seem to work that well. In other words, if one alternates between the stick and the carrot, it doesn’t seem to work that well. In other words, if one alternates between being kind and being nasty, the end result is nothing. Then we’re scheduled to try to contact Vasilisa by telephone at 04:00. I thought we have fifteen minutes.
Maybe Pamela can come here. I didn’t I just wanted to thank you for your brilliant translation. Oh, I didn’t translate. I felt like I was at the UN. I didn’t translate.
But I must recognize, actually, it is better like this because Vasilisa has Swiss English. I’m I was not quite sure you would understand. It is very, very Germanic. Then waiting for 04:00, do you have any questions I will endeavor to answer? And we will try to contact her at four.
I just have an observation from a child because reminded of of their pet cats. And one of the the mother cats who had litters of kittens every six months, probably, every year. And we had a desexed tomcat who used to hunt on behalf of the mother and the new litter of kittens. Mhmm. So this was most unusual behavior.
He would bring kitten rabbits to feed the the new litter of of cats, kittens. So Interesting. Yeah. I’ve I’ve never come across anything like that before. You have any comments about this approach?
For us as Buddhists, what does this material mean? Such strong evidence, not just of cooperation, but in the case of Norway, rats of empathy among animals. Yes. You wonder what’s been happening in past lives. Yes.
Yes. Can you see in these experiments a distinction between affective and cognitive empathy we talked about? It’s striking, isn’t it? It’s open to question whether cognitive empathy is present or not. Affective empathy is definitely present in rats.
What was the question? You want me to send it there? Please. So I was just asking if, our students or the members who are attending the conference could see the difference between effective and cognitive empathy in these experiments. It’s quite striking.
Then you see, I think, really, as far as the Dalai Lama has pointed that this is very much the way forwards for us. And that’s why when Rinpoche initiated these conferences in 2010, we had a somewhat different goal. Rinpoche wanted it just to be a conclave of all the students. And very quickly, with Rinpoche’s agreement, it morphed into an attempt to bridge the gap between what the students were studying at the center and what the world out there was telling them. And the world out there nowadays is science.
Because what we found was was that we were losing our best and brightest after a couple of years because the cognitive discrepancy was too great. People would be hearing an uninterrupted stream of information indicating that basically the mind was the brain. It will all be reduced to activities of the insula and the VM and whatnot. And then eventually, they completely disconnected from Buddhist teachings. And the question which really arose is, is it possible to bridge the gap or not?
Then we had, during the symposium, our own very small little mind life conferences. Nothing as prestigious as the mind life conferences in which his holiness participates, but our own little attempt in Adelaide. And for some of you, this may seem overkill, but I don’t think it is. I don’t think it is because if you are not able to satisfy yourself that the essence, not the details, but the essence of the Buddhist teachings is true, you will not stay. You will not stay.
You will stay five years. You will stay ten years. You will disappear. And then the benefit for yourself is open to question. And to satisfy yourself that it is true, you must link it with what is happening in the world at large.
Certainly for westerners Asians, I don’t know. But, my wife tells me that in Thailand, huge numbers of young Thais have completely disconnected from Buddhism. I know among Tibetans, it’s very widespread. It’s not talked about. Yes.
There is sort of this verbal allegiance to as well as the Dalai Lama as a to Buddhism. But, you can see that more and more the young Tibetans are leading very schizophrenic lives, very split lives. It’s interesting, Ilya, that within the counseling world, the entree of compassion is becoming more not fashionable, but it is in fact, you know, accepted. And to be able to link it into, you know, the sort of studies that you’re talking about and and yourself, Pamela, it sort of strengthens that, you know, takes us away from the selfish gene idea. And I think also the work of Matthieu Ricard with that amazing experiment of the starter pistol being set off against his ear and novice meditators.
And on the EEG, the area of the brain of the novices, the amygdala, associated with fear lit up, but the area in his brain of compassion lit up. So if that’s not proof positive of the ability to rewire the brain, what is? Rewiring of neuroplasticity, which is the technical term, that is pretty much established. Now the extent of neuroplasticity is open to question. Then there is a very Quite a lot.
Lot. There’s a there’s a student. There was a a young lecturer at at the University of Adelaide in economics who had a catastrophic illness that was not diagnosed early and he lost basically a third of his brain. And, I wouldn’t have thought he would have been able to do much, But over the course of two, three years, he was rehabilitated almost to his pre injury state. And that’s that’s neuroplasticity at its best.
The the brain is an amazing thing. It it will do whatever it can to correct itself, which is not to say that it has a motivation or intention or anything like that. That’s just that’s just a way of talking. Mhmm. Yeah.
See, there are some very interesting issues which arise and they’re provocative, but as after all, you know, it’s the goal of this symposium. In, let’s say, pre modern or even, you know, industrial revolution societies in which very little little was done by the state Yes. For individuals who suffered, the practice of charity was very widespread. I read a marvelous book, the life of doctor Bernardo in London in the nineteenth century. Was a a philanthropist, a doctor who worked for the poor, lived in the in the most destitute slums in London.
Then all of us had training in charity. The welfare state was created, I think, with the best possible intentions. I mean, Tenzin often says, he wonders if it was not the work of a bodhisattva. But what are the results? The results have been huge disengagement of all of us towards the destitute, and you see this in daily life.
Since the state basically is seen as the mediator between the person and those who are in need, none of us feel any individual responsibility anymore. In other words, as a result of the welfare state, we no longer train in charity. To which degree does this affect us as persons? You know, getting out of the habit of of of naturally giving. Yes.
Like Yeah. When I was in India, I knew that if I did not help, no one helped. And it when I saw someone who was poor, I gave. And I gave a lot because I thought I remember one case of woman dying of hunger. I gave her 500 rupees.
She was you know the signs of great hunger is when you’re cold and it’s hot. Right? Yeah. She was shivering. It was in a forecourt between two cars and a parking lot.
So that’s a big question for us as a society. And, Eli, yesterday morning, there were 3,000 people that walked marched through the city on behalf of the homeless. And Australia has an incredibly high level of volunteerism, perhaps one of the highest in the world within, you know, CFS, MFS, know, the various emergency services. And, you know, I wonder whether there is this recognition at some level that giving, you know, the interconnectedness of humans and and also the satisfaction that giving gives. And, you know, I wonder whether that’s perhaps overlooked.
I haven’t I’ve got an anecdote, but I haven’t got an answer. One time when I was visiting the first time I was visiting Sarah in 1997, ’98, I was there to putatively learn Tibetan. And there every evening I would go for circumambulation as pretty much everybody does. And there was this little there was this little man, he was Indian and he was he was like a stick figure almost, and he was slightly kind of demented. He was he was he was quite simple, but he had this really beatific smile and he would, you know, he’d put his hands together and I’d always take some, you know, some money and give it to him like, and it was like this this evening ritual.
Right? And one night, I was walking by, the CBD and all the shops and everything and he apparently had got himself some work that day and he was cashed up. And I walked by, and he came up to me and he gave me a packet of biscuits. It was like, you know, he had, so he gave. It was one of the most amazing things that because he had nothing.
He had nothing. I wasn’t even sure where he lived. Mhmm. Mhmm. He really had nothing.
But but he felt, you know, he felt empowered and he and having felt empowered, he was giving. I I it was just it was it was the most wonderful thing. It really does make you feel better, I think. I think so. I think so.
Yeah. No. It this topic opens a big can of worms for all of us. For instance, now, especially in The United States to a much lesser degree here, there are very strong anti cooperation movements. Much of the far right in The United States and Europe also is violently anti cooperation.
They do not want to create a cooperative society. They want to create a confrontational society. As I mentioned this morning, Ayn Rand is perhaps the most extreme proponent of such a viewpoint. Then when you let’s say this as Donald Trump does in The United States, pull away the altruistic, empathetic, cooperative component. And I’m not saying it has to be state sponsored.
I have some strong reservations about how it’s done in Australia, but I think it must be present at the level of individuals. When you remove that, I think you remove the glue from society. Societies disintegrate. And then I I did wish to put you on the spot regarding the Australian model of welfare because so many of our students are on the dole, one way or the other. Precisely because, just in terms of its results here on the minds of our students, my overall impression is that it is negative.
I mean, we have seen the track record, and I’ve been here eight years, the students who are less responsible, less reliable, often will have more mental problems, that are more egotistic, are students who are on the dole. And obviously they might go on the door for that reason. But it is also possible that the state of dependence does not enable the person to stand on their own feet. And that does not mean we have to create an inhuman society. It does mean we may have to return towards a society where humanity is an individual responsibility.
It’s just a question. When I first when I first became aware of of the the welfare arrangements in in Australia, I was also I also became aware that in in the nineteen eighties when I first arrived here, it was possible to have a decent life in Australia with an income below the poverty line because of the way the society was organized. And it was all contingent on owning a home. If people owned a home, they were really okay.
Mhmm. If they didn’t own a home, they were not okay. And a friend of mine who’s an economist at Flinders who is is quite well known did this original study and, you know, when was invited to go to China by the Ford Foundation and stuff like that because she it was it was a it was a a standard. It was a measure that wasn’t income based. And it depended upon and it it it involves social networks, you know, like RSLs, that sort of return soldiers league clubs and that sort of stuff.
There there was there was an incredible social fabric that wasn’t just tied to pensions and that sort of thing. It was That is very good. Yeah. It was it and it doesn’t exist anymore, which is the Allow me to say point. Really One short thing I think we’re trying to ring over, Selisa.
Okay. You know, when the you’ve all heard of the Singaporean model. Yeah. You know? Then Singapore has a very nice approach, in my personal opinion.
So I feel much more Asian in terms of sensitivity in this sense. In Singapore, all are taken care of, but if you’re an invalid, you still have to work within the limits of your capacities. And they have a marvelous system where people who are blind from birth are trained by the state as masters precisely because Really? These mothers. Fantastic.
The best masters are blind. They would be. And they have fantastic touch. They could really feel into I am old fashioned enough to believe in the value of work. Work is something which makes us responsible, integrates us in society.
And it was interesting that when the Singaporean prime minister came to Australia, Lee Kuan Yew, he was very shocked by Australia. And when he left, he said to his Australian host, what have you done? So I’m not sure because Australian model is actually very similar to the Saudi Arabian model. Right? What?
Same thing. Right? Really? It’s a hugely rich country which distributes the riches from the underground to people in the form of handouts as well as fair. Right?
I mean, so Australia, Saudi Arabia, Canada, you have exactly the same social model. And in all three countries, you have similar patterns, which is a certain inertia. Then well, I’m I’m digressing very much. You must excuse me. But it is interesting because you can see how it ties in with altruism and what I would call intelligent compassion.
Intelligent In this day and age though, I think that without a massive enculturation of the population, if you withdrew that, what you would have is No. It’s not possible. Is nature red in tooth and claw. No. No.
It’s not possible. And that it would it would be impossible. No. It’s not possible. It’s not possible.
No. It’s purely theoretically. It would take generations to break the habits. Generations. See it so strongly.
Two would do it. Yeah. You have direct experience. Yes. Okay.
Are are are you on? I will try. Okay. I will. We will ask you some questions.
What questions do you have? Hear me? Do you hear me? Yes. We can hear you.
Hello? Yes. Yes. We can hear you. I’m waiting for the questions of our audience, which is a bit starstruck.
I’d like to ask you one question.
Myself, Vasilisa. Benefit do you think your studies of evolutionary biology had for yourself spiritually? Oh, very nice question. I mean, spiritually, I guess, it has not so much benefit, and I prefer not to think too much of these results, be honest. Mhmm.
I think it’s very interesting in in an intellectual point of view. And as, I guess, I told during the talk, I guess it’s one way of seeing things, which is, of course, right, but which doesn’t give a whole about what is happening and which doesn’t give anything about us as a problem. There’s no way on what what we can consider as really interesting in any kind of spaces. And here, as it is ultimate ultimate mechanism, it’s less interesting in a story to always. But I completely agree.
Just interesting in intellectual way of how the logic can make things happen, but not and actually that’s what we have studied here. Do you have any issues? Or Hello? Do you have any issues you would like to bring up? Hello?
I don’t see well, sorry. I’m asking our students if they have any questions they would like to bring up. Yes, Pamela. I’m sorry. I have to.
It’s hard to convey a phone like that. Sorry. Thank you so much for a wonderful presentation and fascinating work. The first question I’d like to ask were you you mentioned your lady rats. Were there any differences in the degree of direct reciprocity between males and females?
Yeah. Sorry. Can you just repeat? I I was hearing very, very badly. The question is, is there any difference in direct reciprocity between male and female rats in your experience?
Ah, thanks a lot. Sorry. I I was not hearing. We just worked with female rats till now. I know that now a student has done some experiments with male rats, and, they had some interesting little bit different results.
But I remember that also afterwards, they realized that the procedure they used was different too. So till now, what we have observed, what he had observed, it was that males were able of direct reciprocity too. Mhmm. But but we’re not, like, speaking generalized reciprocity. I haven’t spoken about that yet, but it means just help more when they have been helped before by anyone else, which has been observed in females.
And because of that and because of the weight of the student has done the experiments, they said it was for now not comparable between males and females, that we have to redo something to be able really to compare what’s happening. For now, we have also females because females are, yes, irrational, so it’s easier to keep females together. And at the beginning, everyone thought that it would be more obvious to observe reciprocity by females without any other kind of bias of he or she. But for it hasn’t been done until very recently, and for now, the results are not completely clear. Thank you.
One other I had one doubt about, an interpretation of, the equivalence of the the, four pressings for the, the four pullings for the banana and the four pullings for the carrot not being, based on an assessment of energetic investment. This is this is a bit sort of angels dancing on pinheads, I’m afraid. But, we say that to us, it looks like the energetic investment is the same for the cooperator or the defector. But the assessment of the rat might be that there is a greater energetic value in the preferred food because banana is much more calorie dense as well as being sweeter than carrots. Carrots are quite sweet, but they they are not as energetically, valuable.
I hear just the end, which I agree, but I just hit the the middle. I’m sorry. So can you just repeat, please? Yeah. I’m sorry.
Yes. Yes. No. It it was the idea is that the rat who receives perceives the banana as more interesting also not only because it’s better, but certainly also because it’s more energetic. So the benefit he gets from the rat who pulls for the banana is higher.
But the cost of the one who is pulling, I mean, for for the prob from the provider is the same in both cases before because both pull the same way. So it was the idea. It’s very yes. It’s exactly the point. It was to disentangle that.
What the rat will perceive from what he gets from two partners and what the rat will perceive what the partners are doing as an effort. And in that case, if he was only considering the effort of the other one, we would expect him to pull the same way for both. And, actually, he will help according also to the advantage he gets independently of the effort exerted by the provider. But the second point, I would have been very interested in. For now, we haven’t done it, but would have been to observe whether they also can help according to the effort incentives.
So for example, if the provider if we had two cooperators providers providing both banana, but one which would have to pull something which is very heavy and the other one something which is very light, it would be interesting also to see the receiver could also adapt health according to the effort of a provider. And that has not yet been done, but it was one point I wanted also to study, but which is quite more difficult to study in an mental way. I mean, that have to be conscious of, the heaviness according to, for example, of the platform or anything else or, on the so it was more difficult to realize practically. But I guess that both points are interesting. But here, of course, the the banana had more benefits in I mean, as well in the way they prefer that, but also energetically.
You’re welcome. Thank you to you. I’m sorry. Thanks. I found it fascinating, that picture or the image of the elephants nuzzling skulls of their own kind, and you mentioned earlier that they didn’t do that for other, the bones of other species.
And there seemed to be something implied behind that, and I wondered what what you were thinking. It’s not been systematically tested, but it’s been observed by thank you, Nick, if you can. It’s been observed by scientists, so it’s not anecdotal. It was observed and it’s again, we’re interpreting because we do not know what’s going on in the mind of an elephant. That when the elephants approached elephant skulls, they became, it seemed much more contemplative, hesitant.
They turned the skulls over. Their behavior was totally different from that when they approached the skulls of buffaloes, which I gather are fairly similar in size. Then this indicates several things, at least at the cognitive level. An awareness that the skull was a skull of an elephant, which is really a big step. An awareness that this elephant is no more, which means some awareness, a clear, very clear awareness of impermanence and death.
And an awareness that maybe or maybe an awareness that the elephant who is looking at the skulls will go this way too. Then obviously we are interpreting, but the behavior was quite striking, you know. And certainly one of the things which is coming through now in the animal behavior studies is that animal behavior is much more sophisticated than we ever suspected. If anything, we have erred on the way of underestimating the complexity of animal behavior. One word on the elephant issue.
Miss Hassan? A word on the the business of elephants and death. There was a story this year about a troop of element elephants, which except for juvenile males, mainly female, going having been observed at the death of a matriarch and going back to where the bones lay and going back and going back to that site again and again as the bones are picked clean by, you know, birds and hyenas and things like that. And revisiting the site and picking up the bones and and handling them and that sort of stuff and and recognizing that there there is something that was there, is still there, and is and is dead. Yeah.
That’s very fascinating. Classic presentation within Buddhism is, you know, animals can’t remember the exact terminology, you know, ignorance. Isn’t that within Yes. Yes. But, I mean, obviously, that’s a general statement, isn’t it?
Even in Tibetan Buddhism, there are beings of the animal realms, nagas, which are notorious for their mental acumen. The elephants are very intelligent animals, and I was hoping to find you a slide which really says everything there is to say about this one. Yes. It’s known as the Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness. It’s very interesting.
A team in Cambridge, after investigating the studies of the mental capacities of the gray parrot, concluded that the mental capacities were so advanced that it warranted granting them personhood. Yes. This is quite haunting. These are not Buddhists in any sense of the term. You know?
Yes. The Cambridge declaration on consciousness. Oh, right. Birds appear to offer in their behavior, neurophysiology and neuroanatomy, a striking case of parallel evolution of consciousness. Evidence of near human levels of consciousness has been most dramatically observed in African grey parents.
You have the Cambridge declaration of consciousness, and this is by scientists. So we declare the following. The absence of a neocortex does not appear to preclude an organism from experiencing affective states. Humans are not unique in possessing the neurological substrates that generate consciousness. Nonhuman animals, including all mammals and birds, and many other creatures, including octopuses, also possess these neurological substrates.
Octopuses are amazing. Nice. Nice. Are amazing. And where this leaves those of us who eat meat, I don’t know.
Do you have other questions? Just while people are thinking, Pamela, the influence of consciousness on one’s own bacteria and I don’t use that word. Okay. I I I don’t I don’t address consciousness at all Alright. Ever.
Mind. And the reason why is because it is only adequately defined in Buddhist terms. The the western view of consciousness is just ridiculously all over the shop. Okay. I mentioned before to you in the break, I wondered what the bacteria were doing in the insides of somebody like Geshe Rapten.
And I wondered I wondered what you and Ilya’s thinking is about the ones you know, the development of one’s own mind and how that resonates with the, whatever is happening in the mind at a microbiological level. I personally don’t think anything. I think that, because environment. They have their own karma. But if if the environment if an organism is affected by its environment and our mind influences our internal environment, would there not be well, obviously, there’d be a benefit of some kind, but I just wondered if it’s Would it just not enlighten with his hand?
You know, just because just because the person you’re inside is an enlightened being doesn’t mean the cells, the, you know, the worms and everything else within it is going to be, is going to be, you know, magically boosted in in in in in the state I mean, it’s if if if it was that easy, we’d all be enlightened because all the Buddhists and Bodhisattvas would be working like crazy. What about karma? And the other night, Krishna was talking about the power of the object and, you know, the the beings withinside his holiness, for example. I mean, I wonder what the connection to be born as a bacterium in the the the gut of his holiness, as opposed to, you know, a criminal. Yeah.
But you’d better hope you didn’t cause an infection. Hey. The jury the jury is out on this one, Chris. I mean, the boundaries of sentience are a hotly debated topic as well as brings it up with biologists. The last I heard the solution they had offered was motion, which is not very convincing.
Mobility. Then mobility is not convincing as a sign of consciousness. Then when we come to bacteria, the question which arises, if we’re going to assert that bacteria are conscious, how do we disprove this statement? How do we? Yeah.
If we cannot disprove the statement from a purparian standpoint, it’s a non scientific statement. So it’s right now, it’s open. Like, let’s assume bacteria were conscious conscious. How would we prove this? You think it’s difficult to do.
No. We can’t even do it with a man. So even with this with that, it’s the same problem. So until communication existed, even with communication, you run into Turing’s problem. You know, the famous, you know, Turing’s paradox.
Right? One is communicating with an artificial intelligence. How would one know that one is communicating with an artificial intelligence sufficiently sophisticated or not? You know? The same thing with all living beings.
So, actually, we are very limited in what we can say about the level or the presence of consciousness in another, as Pamela was pointing out this morning in the early afternoon, then how let’s say bacteria were conscious. Why would that make a difference to us? I might be filled with conscious bacteria. Yeah. Then they are my parasites.
Okay. They might be my commensals like my dog, my cat. Why should that make any difference? It doesn’t. It doesn’t.
Right? No. I guess I was thinking in terms of health. And Then that’s a different issue. And my teachers was evenly split on that one.
Right. The did never took antibiotics because they did not want to damage bacteria in their intestinal flora. To my knowledge, Geshe Rapten did. Then the problem you run run into there is a huge problem of communication. Yes.
Because when you’re speaking with a Tibetan teacher, you refer to bacteria as boa. Yeah. Boa insects. Yeah. So to which degree we were talking of the same things, do not know.
That’s right. I do not know. I remember a fantastic conversation with an old friend. It started very well, communication of Buddhism and science. We were just talking.
You know, he was talking of
The nervous influx, and I was talking of the nervous influx, and he was talking of the brain, and I was talking of the brain. It it was hunky dory. And then he said, and when the weather is really bad, the nervous influx blows around a lot in the trees, doesn’t it? And I went, yes? Perhaps.
He said, yes. It comes in through the ears, doesn’t it? And we’re talking he’s using the word long, which means in Tibetan, both wind. And it’s actually understood as wind in the vessels. This is understood.
Yeah. Know? So we have to be very careful in these dialogues with Buddhist masters. Sometimes we have the illusion of communication when there isn’t really communication. Do you have any other questions?
Yes, please. Do they have what? Altruism. Altruism. Altruism.
I don’t know. I don’t know enough about wolves is the short answer. They definitely have empathy in the sense that they can like chimps. You have the picture of the the This is chip what chimp, you know, soothing the the the consoling the the really excited, probably defeated You see this? Chimp.
There’s that kind of there’s that kind of consolation and and and kindness, if you will, between wolves. But altruism sacrificing themselves for the benefit of the pack, I don’t know. I I really don’t know. But I I just don’t I I I deal with really, really simple organisms, not really very complex ones. I’d assume they do.
We it’s it’s Pamela says it’s not I’ve never heard of studies. I’d assume they do just because dogs do. And dogs are so close to wolves. Very. I mean, instance of altruism in dogs are well documented.
Well documented. If you look at the documentaries, the wolves actually befriended humans back in the days when we were still cave people, and that’s how dogs came about. They actually grew close together, helped each other, and it was the first relationship between animals and men, I think. Yeah. There’s a lot of debate about how that started.
They don’t know whether the dogs, whether the wolves hung around the the the peripheries of human camps and camps and scavenged. They they really don’t know, but it probably happened with puppies, you know, because there was a the bones of puppies found in in just post ice age hominids. I don’t I don’t know if they’re modern humans or if they’re Denisovans or Neanderthals, but they were puppies, bones of puppies found. It would make sense. Yeah.
Please. I’d like to give a response to my whole feeling of today’s book. Coming up against and having to think about altruism, I find I’m wondering, do I exist as a single individual autonomous? The Buddhist answer is no. Yes.
Yeah. Please. We’re very glad. Welcome to the club. Yes.
Yes. Yes. Welcome to the club. We have a tradition of offering a free glass of tea without sugar when you become a Buddhist. Yes.
All these past histories. Mhmm. And they must be part perhaps they’re part of me. Mhmm. And part of perhaps my idea of myself is a very small perspective, and it might be that I’m not that single, isolated, autonomous person, and that may well explain that capacity for, you know, empathy and altruism.
That’s an extraordinarily helpful state of mind. Yeah. I really if you can cultivate that, it is so helpful. Right now, could be done unnerving. It’s very helpful.
Very helpful. Biology is not very helpful on that head, by the way. That’s whether whether you’re an individual or you’re a multitude is actually a huge philosophical question. Yeah. The work in your presentations.
Well, thank you very much for saying that. Then part of the goal has been accomplished. Part of the goal yeah. You all or all of you, I assume, know the famous poem of John Donne, no man is an island unto himself. Right?
It was written in a Christian context, but it is so true. Please. So what I’m thinking after today is something like, you know, with sometime I’ve read before to see that there’s so many Buddhas within us and as on every cell. So now I’m thinking, well, if all these microorganisms are living as such these sentient beings, I’m not paying enough attention or gratitude to all these other beings living inside of me. You know I mean?
It’s a good way to look at it. Whether they’re conscious or not, we cannot say. We cannot say. With the gratitude. We cannot say.
Yeah. I I feel like I’ve neglected to see something within me, and and that yeah. I’ll be be a a bit bit more more compassionate than to myself maybe. Yeah. I was gonna say, just extend that a little bit further.
You see what is interesting, and it’s in this matter, I think we can learn a lot from evolutionary biology. Yeah. What is really interesting is to ask the question, when exactly in evolution does empathy begin? Now, basically, Wilson was saying that he thinks there is a turning point in insect societies because, really, there is only one gene which conditions insects staying in the nest after their birth versus their departing. Normally, insects depart from the nest.
Then if they depart from the hive, a society is never constituted. But if through a mutation that one gene is affected and they stay in the hive, then almost unavoidably over time, altruistic behavior, empathetic behavior, proto empathetic behavior perhaps, would be selected for the survival of the society. And when this happened, we don’t know. But we are really looking at some time in the Cretaceous Way back. Oh, way back.
Way back. Way back. Then I think you would agree with me, this casts a very different light on the Marianas notion of training and compassion. It’s not training in something which is absent from us. That’s exactly right.
It’s training in something we have the seeds of already. Maybe it’s partial. This is if you read Śāntideva, you listen to Geshe-la’s teachings, the emphasis we have partial compassion. But there is something. Right?
The elements of a chair are there. Right? The wood is there. Yes, please. Sir, I think I understood today the difference between empathy and altruism.
And but I’m just wondering if we could have some definition that is acceptable to both of you or to one or other of you separately as between sentience, cognition, and consciousness. So far as that’s possible. I mean, I appreciate Pamela doesn’t want to use the word conscious. So what does she see as being the dividing line to which she doesn’t want to go? Okay.
I think the three poisons are crucial. I think if you have a system that is interested in in enhancing itself, that is interested in protecting itself, and is indifferent to most things that don’t affect it, you’re well on your way to something being sentient because everything gets grown from that in a way. The the construction of self and other, the construction of like me, not like me, similar similarities and differences. Everything gets gets constructed from that base. Now, cognition, I think, is being able to, in an evolutionary sense I should have this down by now, but I don’t.
It’s changing all the time. Clearing clear and knowing doesn’t help when you’re talking about evolution. No. It doesn’t. It doesn’t help when you’re talking about evolution.
Doesn’t even it doesn’t even help when you’re talking about neuroscience because as Rinpoche said, the scientists don’t know what they’re looking for. They don’t know what they’re looking at. You know, they don’t they don’t even they don’t understand that that there is anything other than the brain. Know, that there is anything subtler than that. So yeah.
I think that self interest self preserving behavior that senses, remembers, decides, learns, feels, discriminates, anticipates, does all those things. Those are all part of cognition in an evolutionary sense. And all of those things are found in bacteria. Basically, yours is yours is a very difficult question. Right?
I mean Yeah. It’s It’s very difficult. Because basically, no answer has been provided. To start with, the basic problem is that scientists don’t accept that there is such a thing as consciousness as differentiated from life. No.
Consciousness is another name given to the brain’s activity. The furthest we go is Searle’s statement that consciousness is an emerging property of the brain, which has become very famous simply because no one really understands what Searle means. Right? No. It sounds it sounds very nice.
It sounds more sophisticated than saying that consciousness is another name given to mental activity, but it doesn’t go much further than that. And I have a personal answer which is personal. Let’s hear. And it’s something which isn’t becoming. Let’s put it this way.
So as I understand it yeah. These are definitions if you will. You can always change the definition. Life occurs as soon as you can talk on the electrochemical boundary. And life occurs within the context of the control of ionic flow through that electrochemical boundary, specifically the balance of potassium and sodium.
Yes. If you want to kill a human being, you give in the heart or in the veins an injection of a a a potassium solution. It causes instantaneous death. Now in this context, I found the work of Ilya Prigogine, as I was mentioning earlier, helpful. Most of you have heard of the second law of thermodynamics, states that all the entropy of a closed system is an increasing function of time.
In other words, that a closed system in which there is no energy influx sees an increase in its degree of disorder over time. Now, a cell is a closed system. Mhmm. Right? But is there or is there not an influx of energy?
If there were no influx of energy It doesn’t. The level of entropy, in other words, of order of the cell, disintegrate or decrease over time. There is an input of energy. And the cell therefore is a closed system which is able to maintain its degree of order through a steady influx of energy. The classic would be, for instance, the plant cell.
Right? Which using photosynthesis is able not only to maintain its level of order, but increase it through reproducing. Now we’ll skip dissipative systems. I would therefore suggest that a thermodynamic definition of life is a living system or living systems, which are consisting of occasional dissipative systems and other vectors of information. Consisting of occasional dissipative systems means they’re closed systems which can increase their degree of order over time, and in addition they are the vectors of information which information specifically that encoded in the genetic code.
So such a definition is one which applies fully to a cell and also applies to viruses because viruses are occasional dissipative systems. They are dissipative systems when they are within a cell, when they basically co opt the nucleus of the cell to stop producing viruses. They are not dissipative systems on the outside. So for life, this would be a tentative definition. I don’t know to which degree biologists would accept it or not.
I think it is not It’s not alien. No. But it’s it’s it’s, there’s there’s a school within the origins of life Uh-huh. Field that that adheres to second law definitions. But there’s also people who work mainly in biology are not generally in that school.
They have a they have a tendency to be physicists who became interested in biology and and, like Schrodinger and people like that. But it’s it’s it’s it’s definitely not a done deal. It’s it’s a real it’s a real it’s an active active active. Don’t don’t like some of the dynamics I know. They don’t like I think I’ve used to have these conversations with my father.
Then my personal definition of quantum mechanic hinges on one of the leading theories, by no means the dominant theory, the von Neumann reading of quantum mechanics, which of quantum mechanics, which considers that consciousness is necessary to cause what is known as a reduction of the state factor. In other words, the cloud of probabilities of possible behaviors and energy levels of a quantum particle. And this consciousness must be non material in von Neumann’s reading. So if this is the case, you can simply define consciousness as whatever is capable of causing the collapse of a state vector. And then and this is my private understanding then, you know, it is open to debate.
But what I would suggest is that you have two sets. You have living systems, which can be understood thermodynamically, and quantum systems. Living systems include plants, viruses, prions, anything which is a potentially dissipative system and is a vector of information. There is an intersection between living systems and quantum systems. Because quantum systems, and this is now a very Buddhist understanding, includes not only material living beings, but also spirits, beings, etcetera.
Now spirits and beings are not living systems in the sense of biology. No. But if we adopt the quantum definition, if they have a consciousness, actually my personal belief is it has to be a direct valid cognizer, then that can cause the collapse of the state vector. And then there’s an intersection of the two, which is most of the advanced living systems we have now, humans, mammals, reptiles, etcetera, which are both living systems and conscious. Then this is just my private attempt to make sense of things.
Am as valid as any other. Not a biologist. I am no longer a physicist, but it’s an attempt to try to sort of conciliate the two. Yes, please, Nick. Why did you consider it has to be a direct valid cognizer in that case?
Basically, because of the importance of observation in quantum mechanics as opposed to an inferential valid cognizer where observation is not present. Yes. If it you included inferential valid cognizers, that would mean that if, let us say, right, you were able to mathematically cause the collapse of a state vector, it would collapse reality, which is obviously absurd. Right? It is not possible.
So in quantum mechanics, it is when you observe a quantum system that that act of of observation causes certain probabilities of events to become zero. It become impossible. You know? Then that is a direct cognizer. And direct valid cognizers, it depends how you understand the definition.
So Sautrāntika says it has to be the first instant of a consciousness, which actually I think is probably right. Says it doesn’t have to be the first instant of a consciousness. But certainly in quantum mechanics, has to be the first instant. And there’s a big debate because the dominant schools in quantum mechanics say that when we speak of the act of observation, we speak of the act of meddling with the system. Like, you set up instruments, you are meddling with the system.
You cannot observe, let’s say, quantum interactions without, in some way, interfering, and that’s means more understanding. System. Interfering with the system somehow by your measuring instruments. And so Neumann has made mathematically a very strong case that this interference has to be due to the act of observation because if it was not and it was only the brain observing the quantum system, the brain can be seen as part of that quantum system. So there is a von Neumann cut.
Then it’s far more sophisticated than what I can handle mathematically, at least nowadays. I have a question. Please. How do you get the base
Six of altruism out of a dissipative system. Frankly, I couldn’t tell you right now. There are some problems with dissipative systems if you don’t include a vector of information because crystal is a dissipative system. What do you mean by a vector of information? Information is a is a problematic term.
Well, you do have definitions of information. There’s about a 100 of them. There’s a lot of them. The difference between information and noise. Information That’s that’s in that’s in Super.
Shannon Weaver sense, but that is strictly about the nature of a communication channel. It’s not about something that exists in the world that that or is even imputed in the world that that animate systems can respond to or use or anything like that. Because it has no semantic content. That I couldn’t tell And you need semantics in order to get in in in order to get value in terms of of fitness fitness benefits, whatever they are and that sort of stuff. So so I I like informatic approaches.
Mhmm. But at the same time, it’s like, you know, what do you mean when you talk about information in a purely physical system? If you And I still don’t I I still don’t understand how you get there from here. If you want a distinction between information and structure, which is I think what you’re asking for, I cannot provide it. But if you want could share that.
No. I can’t. But if you want a distinction between structure and noise, I can. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. No. I understand that. So this is basically just my private understanding of living systems versus conscious entities. It presents two advantages from a Buddhist standpoint.
It enables us to account for modern biology, broadly speaking. Maybe. And it enables us to account for the existence of nonmaterial consciousness. Then any attempt to reduce consciousness to living system prevents us from accounting for all nonmaterial consciousnesses. Oh, that’s a big problem.
Then I’m afraid we have to stop today. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, both Ilya and Pamela, for the extraordinary amount of work that you’ve And, Vasilisa.
I was just gonna say, Especially to organize such a a wonderful opportunity to tap into groundbreaking research and then not only that, but to have her paper and connecting up with Skype. That’s lovely thing to do. This these proceedings will be transcribed. Margaret has that honorable task. So it’ll be part of the heritage of of TBI and especially Poignant being the last in this series.
So thank you so much, Ilya, for instigating that with with Rinpoche. And certainly has given us a lot of food for thought. And and it’s particularly pertinent as you were saying about the current teachings at the moment by Keshe la on bodhicitta and and the importance of developing love, compassion, altruism. And to see to see the behavior within the not just the the animal kingdom, but at all sorts of different levels is also extraordinary. And to think that we can, by working on purifying negative karma, that we can bring these to the ultimate fruition, which, of course, is embodied in the images of the Buddha and personified in the behavior of beings like his holiness, the Dalai Lama.
So thank you very much. And I know that your blood sugar levels have dropped. And and that Since mhmm. And that Ilya has alluded to one of his favorite indulgences. And so we thought, well, rather than just talking about that, we should materialize it.
And so just as a Well done. As a small Ah. As a as small token We I have crispy. And have to apologize to to to Mandy because she may be struggling. Have to apologize to Mandy, but give me access to I would have to struggle to protect these.
That’s what I think. And and and also to to Pamela who I know doesn’t doesn’t eat these at all, but she has such an altruistic Okay. Tendency. They are, please. They know Richard Richard Richard is very skinny.
I happen to know from inside information that Pamela is a mover and shaker within her street. Oh, I am. And and has many has many friends and is always looking for an opportunity to practice her her altruism. We have many people. We have a good home for this.
So you’ll have to you’ll have to live with those. That’s no problem. If we can and I’m sorry we can’t send send them over to to Europe. But but the thought is there. And if you would like to just join with me again in thanking And, of course, we wouldn’t have been anywhere without the very practical application of altruism and empathy and compassion by the wonderful food that we had at lunchtime.
So thank you, Tender, and Carol out there who’s beavering away. And And Mandy. And Mandy. Yes. Mandy.
And thank you, Mandy. And thank you everybody for coming, and we look forward to whatever form these conversations take in the future. And there’s a puja here, of course, at 6:00 for those who are able to attend. So thank you very much. Thank you very much.
And, of course, the the bibliography, as I mentioned, if you didn’t get one up the front here.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- nagas lu (Tib)
- A snake-like being of the animal realm that lives in or near bodies of water; commonly associated with fertility of the land, but can also function as a protector of religion. LYWA
- puja chö pa (Tib)
- Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- three poisons dug sum (Tib)
- Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.