TBI Recordings — 2010-10-02 (2)

TBI Recordings (Ven Jampa Ignyen)
TBI Recordings (Ven Jampa Ignyen)
TBI Recordings — 2010-10-02 (2)
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2010-10-02 – KR (2).mp3

UUID: 719c5545-72bd-4c9e-9d65-33b7051a5b14

Teacher: Ven Jampa Ignyen

Collection: TBI Recordings

Duration: 1h 17m

Words: 8,884

Welcome back everybody. It’s my great pleasure to now introduce Jampa Inyan who will be addressing the topic Western and Buddhist views, managing the divide. Some of the central elements of Buddhist worldview especially in relation to the philosophy of mind and discuss how differences will be addressed. Jampa Inyan tradition for twenty years, studied for fifteen years at Serraje monastery and started to be a much retirement of her education practice in. Canada.

Thank you very much, Jampa Ingen. Thank you. Well, this topic is very extensive of course and where to begin? Actually, the first three speakers I think have done a wonderful job in laying the groundwork for our understanding of the issue of how Buddhism may be integrated into the West. Sometimes when we look at this issue, it almost seems impossible due to our own Western world view as it stands.

And also the various elements of our worldview, the dominance of science in our society, the undermining of religion, the hedonism, the materialism, the physicalism and so on. I mean, we’re quite aware of many of the aspects and attributes of the culture in which we live, there are other underlying or more subtle, even subliminal elements of our culture that we’re probably not so aware of. Now, this context, something like Buddhism appears. And Buddhism has a somewhat different worldview. It assesses the world in a somewhat different way than the way we are used to viewing the world in the West.

So what I plan to do here is look a little bit at our western world view and some of the attributes of this. And for instance, as Eliot pointed out, the whole issue of Protestant ethics, of how science has influenced our lives and our thinking, how capitalism has really absorbed much of our energy and so forth. How even the development of science in the fields like biology and so forth, how these also can help us understand to a degree our situation in the world. So firstly, I want to look a little bit at Western worldview. But before I look at Western worldview, I’d like to take a step back and look at just very briefly how Buddhist teachings in the past have been integrated into different cultures.

Because that also gives us an idea about how it may be achieved in our own culture. Now, Ilya has brought up something of the experience of the Chinese. And this I think is very important for us because the Chinese were quite a different culture than the Indian culture from which Buddhism first spread. And if we can understand how the Chinese adapted Buddhism, then it may give us some insight into how we as westerners with a completely different world view, in a sense, the Chinese or the Indians may also integrate something like Buddhism. But even prior to Buddhism spreading from India to China, Buddhism itself had to be integrated into Indian culture.

And Buddhism itself was not an orthodox religion at all, it was a radically different religion. It went against the Brahmanic orthodoxy that existed in the sixth century BC in India. And when the Buddha first started teaching, he was not highly regarded at all, and the small group of outsiders that he led were they were mendicants and the mendicant tradition of course was accepted. But again, was a lot of opposition amongst the especially the the Brahmins, who tried to refute or minimize the influence of the Buddha and his teachings. So to some degree, we look at this, we can see that the fact that there’s opposition today in the West, or that the ideas of Buddhism are not readily accepted, you know, is something that we should expect.

It’s not going to be something that’s instantly absorbed. When the Buddha did attain enlightenment and he started to teach, as already has been pointed out, he was of the Kshatriya caste, meaning the the warrior or the princely caste. And he went against his own caste traditions by taking the mendicant vows. In fact, he should have gone on to become a king. That was his caste duty.

He didn’t, so even that was breaking with tradition. Then he began ordaining, and he ordained into the practice of religion various other castes such as the Shudra and the Vaishya and so forth, the lower caste in Indian society. And that also stirred up the Brahmins, stirred up a lot of opposition in society. He ordained women, unheard of. But you know, it’s for us today, it makes sense.

It’s how it should be. But this also created a lot of opposition. And his ideas about the Vedas, the Vedas are not authoritative, they’re not the Vedas that depict the eternal truth, and should be worshipped on an altar just as an intrinsic object of value. This he didn’t do. The Buddha was someone who demanded that we investigate, we criticize, we analyze, we try and as the Buddha said, you know, imperfections cannot be washed away by water.

We cannot be raised to the state of liberation by the palm of someone’s hand, say a Buddha’s hand even. The only way to attain liberation is through entering the path. Entering the path means developing the mind. Not through accepting scriptures such as the Vedas, the four Vedas and so on. And basically, the Buddha taught the four truths.

So the teaching of four truths is the mark of a Buddha. Any being who teaches the four truths when they’re not they haven’t been disseminated in at that time is a Buddha. I think, in general, we can say that. There may be some exceptions if we were to debate the issue, but we’ll leave that as a definition for the time being. So the Buddha had a particular insight into the nature of reality and that he disseminated and over the period from the age of 35 to 81, he simply elaborated on the four truths.

That’s all. Very simple. But because the mind is very complex, because beings are very complex, the presentation of the four truths becomes very needs great detail. A lot of explanation. So he spent many many years explaining it, and when he finally fully explained it, then he demonstrated the mode of passing into parinirvana.

It said at that point that if his attendant, Ananda, had an opportunity to request the Buddha to remain for an eon, to live for an eon, which sounds impossible, especially from a scientific point of view. If Ananda after the Buddha had suggested twice, three times to him that a Buddha can live to the end of the eon, he didn’t request him to do so, the Buddha then accepted to pass away much sooner. That would have been very good for us. But still, we have other teachers in the lineage such as Kensar Rinpoche. And from a Buddhist perspective, having teachers is absolutely essential.

We cannot discover the four truths on our own bat. They just, you know, it’s so they’re so difficult to understand that one relies on a Buddha, one without any intellectual impediment to see them initially. Right. So we can see that the Buddha, he enunciated a new style of teaching, new religion, a new dharma, and this received a lot of opposition. But still, and there was a lot of slander, if one reads the Vinaya, one can see all the issues that arose at the time of the Buddha, all the opposition that was there, and the fact that the people of that time, you know, were like us.

They some believed, some didn’t, some were wanted to know more, Some were very pure. They took one word and they understood. And so don’t know if any today are like that, one word and they understand. But there was the Buddha himself when you read the Vinaya and Sutra and so forth, you see the issues that come up. These social issues that we grapple with when we look at something like Buddhism And it is a foreign idea to our culture, and we say that we’re, you know, we’re interested in Buddhism and oh, people don’t know how to take that.

But they that’s okay, because they’re not familiar with that. They don’t know what a Buddhist is. Oh, that’s some oh, that’s something to do with India, is it? Or something to do with the Dalai Lama. What is that?

People just don’t know. But there is, of course, a degree of opposition there. This opposition also existed in China when Buddhism first spread to China. Let alone Buddhism, actually anything from India was foreign, and if it’s foreign, it’s treated with suspicion. Of course it is.

We have suspicion in our culture, anything that’s coming in from another culture, we’re suspicious of. We don’t just accept it. It’s, oh, you know, the Chinese think that, or oh, the Russians think that, or oh, this happened there, or whatever. We’re careful about what we take on board, because we live in a culture, we live in a peer group, we live in a place where we have to survive. So you know, we have defense mechanisms.

So this introducing an idea into a culture, a new idea is a problematic venture. And and we can see that in China this happened, early it perhaps spread very early, you know, maybe two, three hundred years after the passing of the Buddha, it spread by the Silk Route into China. But the various kings and so forth, some were you know, like for instance, it said that the first emperor who lived around February to February suppressed Buddhism, which indicates that it pre existed even his time, and that there were missions, there were traders going down the Silk Route accompanied by Buddhist monks who were traveling with them because they wanted to hear the teachings of the Buddha as they traveled to China and whatever. When they got to China, some of them stayed and so forth. Similar process is happening today with, for instance, you know, representatives of Buddhism are traveling from the East and settling in the West and making, you know, some impression in the West.

Not a great deal at present. Buddhism is still very much, you know, has a very small profile. And I want to look a little bit more into why it has a small profile. Then after China, you know, we can also look at Sri Lanka, third century BC Buddhism spread to Sri Lanka by the nephew and niece of Ashoka and so on, and it took root there, and then later Burma and so forth, into Tibet in the seventh century AD, and we probably understand the opposition that Buddhism had in Tibet initially from the Bonpo’s, who again, the owners of the culture don’t like to, you know, give up their authority, don’t like to give up their status, and so forth. And so it took a long time for Buddhism to be established in Tibet.

It really wasn’t up until maybe two hundred years after Songtsen Gampo, the Trissondetzen, King Trissondetzen, actually managed to establish Samye Monastery, and ordinations were conducted from that point on, two hundred years after the first king, first army king. So we can see in when we look at this, that there are issues in every culture, so of course there’s going to be opposition in ours. Now, when also we look at things like the prophecies that exist in the textual record about the spreading of Buddhism to the West. This also is is interesting. I just got a couple of examples.

Probably you’ve heard this first one by Guru Rinpoche in the eighth century, who said that when the iron bird flies and the horses run on wheels, the Tibetans will be scattered like ants, and the Dharma will spread to the land of the red faced people. Which is a very interesting quote. It does exist within the textual record, which demonstrates on one hand, I think, the cultural dominance of technology of western society. I think this does talk about the red faced people are we who live in the West. And it also speaks of the technology, when the iron bird flies and the horses run on wheels.

So at this point, the Buddha Buddha’s teachings would spread to the West. It doesn’t say how long it would take for that spread to occur, but that it would spread. Another quotation is from the general meaning of Abhidharma composed by Jetsumba, Sera Jetsumba, in probably the sixteenth, early sixteenth century, where he cites the this particular sutra, I tried to find the Sanskrit of this and I couldn’t find it, but there’s a sutra called the Lama Jumepe Ergi Toppi Jeppi Do, and which states, two thousand five hundred years after I pass into parinirvana, the holy Dharma will spread to the land of the red faced people. So this he’s writing in, you know, four or five hundred years ago. Then he says after that, regarding the land of the red faced people, Jatunpa states, well some scholars think this is China, the land of the red faced, maybe because of nice red cheeks and so forth.

Others asserted to be the region of Sapna. Now just where Sapna is, I think Sapna was a region on the Silk Route. Other scholars again assert that it refers to the land of Tibet. And then Jetsunpa concludes, this assertion is reasonable. So Jetsunpa thought the red faced people was probably Tibet itself.

The dispensation the Buddhist teachings within Abhidharma, he said the Buddhist teachings will last five thousand years. So two and a half thousand years, according to the Theravada system of dating was 1956, but there is a discrepancy in the Theravada system and it may be up by up to sixty years, so two and a half thousand years might be as late as say, you know, 2016 or after, around that period. Still, it’s interesting, these prophecies were made hundreds of years ago, and they speak at this particular time. Prophecy itself is not a scientific discipline, but they’re just interesting to know, just interesting to understand that these words were said a long time ago. The dispensation will last five thousand years, the Buddha’s teaching is only five thousand years, so we’re halfway through.

It’ll last that long again, another two and a half thousand years. The first five hundred years is the time of the Arhat, when many beings become liberated. The second is when many non returners arise. The third is many stream enterers. In the fourth period of five hundred years, there are many who abide in the higher training of wisdom.

In the fifth, many who abide in the higher training of mind. Now, that’s the one that’s just ended. Now, we’ve entered the sixth period where there are many who abide in the higher training of ethics. So, from an Abhidharma point of view, we’re entering a period where ethics there’ll be many practitioners of ethics. This is actually wonderful because ethics is the absolute basis of the Buddhist path.

It makes everything about the Buddhist path worthwhile. One cannot progress one inch without ethics. And the fact that there are in the sixth period, if there are many practicing ethics, this will be a great foundation for the future development of Buddhism. Okay. So now let’s look a little bit more closely at the worldview in the West.

Now my field really is Tibetan metaphysics, Buddhist metaphysics as presented in Tibet and I have an interest in looking at the issues of worldview and this whole idea of is that the way the German? Somewhere around there, sorry about that. Refers to the framework ideas with which an individual and society views or interprets the world. Now, this whole idea is something that we’re very familiar with. We have all have worldview.

We view the world in a particular way. View itself is a A what? Type of conception for us. It’s a conception that organizes and interprets what’s happening around us, and brings together all the different elements of our our lives and interprets them in a homogeneous, what appreciation of our lives ourselves and what lies beyond us. It interprets for us how we should act in in the world, how we should interpret others and so on.

Now there are those in the West such as Apostol in Belgium, there’s an institute devoted to the study of worldview. He and his colleagues have outlined seven fundamental principles in the definition of worldview, like ontology ontology, the study of reality of what exists, descriptive explanation, futurology, ethics, praxiology, epistemology, and etiology, and so forth. Many of these are exist in the field of metaphysics and I think this is important because really worldview does imply metaphysics, but metaphysics these days has something of a bad reputation in the West and it is or has to some degree been supplanted by the development of science, probably from the time of Galileo, Descartes and so on. There has been a rejection of metaphysics over the scientific method, over the development of scientific method. And as as it is said that till the eighteenth century metaphysics was seen as the principal means for investigating the nature of reality in Western thought, but with the advent of scientific method, the inquiry into the nature of reality became more a pursuit of science as an empirical and experimental endeavor, while metaphysics was reduced to a philosophical exercise, something no longer relevant to the discourse on reality.

And in fact in the West, science has become the leading method for us to interpret the world around us and metaphysics, philosophy have been relegated. We don’t have often I think we don’t really understand the loss there, but it is a loss. Now, what it means is that science, scientific method has become the dominant paradigm. Now, I think science also is a double edged sword here. Science, I think, is one thing that’s allowed Western society to move away from religion, you know, traditional religion and religious values.

And therefore, gives an opportunity for other philosophies, religions like Buddhism, to gain a foothold in the West, but at the same time, science being very materialistic, the nat the sciences, meaning here the natural sciences, tends to counter the ideas, philosophic ideas as found in Buddhism. So, science has a double edged sword. It’s something that we benefit from, but it’s not something that really addresses the deeper issues in life. Although we find that there is perhaps in the background there’s an idea that science eventually will solve the issues, the deeper issues in life. And I think that this is something that we need to be aware of, we need to examine our own culture and see just where scientific ideas pervade and to examine to see whether they’re true or not, and this has also been brought up by Pamela and Ilya and so on.

That we need to be careful because we tend to think that science has all the answers. In fact, reminds me of in Sera in one year, we were studying Abhidharma and we went to see the abbot. The abbot actually was Geshe Jampatechok at that stage and he’d gone away from the conference, and so the former Abbott, the ex Abbott, Kinsalekton, stood in his place, and we went to his quarters and we prostrated, we’re all crouched on the floor. And he was asking, oh, and where are you up to in the text? Or what are you studying?

And it was either Vinaya or Abhidharma. We’re studying Abhidharma. And where are you in the text? And we’re up to chapter three, chapter four, whatever. And at that point, he said, you know, science does not present a path of liberation.

Science, centric in Tibetan. Now at that point I got quite offended. And I’m thinking, what do you mean? You know, like, look at the great advances in the West, you know, like, just look at this shining oh, I don’t know. This great culture, this European culture with the enlightenment, with all the philosophy, the music, the you know, you have these ideas, know, that this western culture is something, it’s really worth taking pride in.

And science will resolve everything. We have this idea that science the material sciences, the natural sciences, physics, chemistry, biology, and so on, that will resolve everything. And my initial thought was, oh, that’s a terrible thing to say, because science is just, you know, really just reflects scientific method. And scientific method is a very good thing. It’s a pramana.

It’s a way of gaining valid information about the world around us. And that’s true. But the essential point he was making is that it’s not the path to liberation. And it’s true, it’s not. You know, there’s no branch of science that is the enlightenment.

Enlightenment studies. Liberation studies. Freedom studies. Getting beyond your problem studies. Is is there any possibility of purifying the mind studies?

And so on. Is there a future life studies? All of these issues have been relegated by the dominant paradigm in our culture to something which we cannot really understand, because of the success and the dominance of the natural sciences. This is a great pity. I It’s something that we need to be aware of.

It’s not as if we have to burn scientific literature, the point that the ex Abbott was making was just a very simple one. When you look at science, I mean, we look in our society, we you know, it’s just amazing the scientific discoveries and you know, we read the journals, we see on TV, we we see the newspapers just how wonderful science is and it really is. It’s amazing. And we take great pride in it. We go to other cultures and we look around and what level of technology do they have and, you know, look at the state of their cars, look at their roads, at their sewage, look at their, you know, we think, oh, but we take pride in our culture.

We take pride in our science. We have to be careful of this. That pride is not very useful to us. Science, you know, is a wonderful scientific method is a wonderful method, and it’s in medicine, in various areas. It’s really established, you know, wonderful therapies, treatments, medicines, strategies for dealing with our problems of this life.

Unbelievable. I mean, who can, you know, perhaps on the verge of eliminating certain diseases through gene therapies and so on. It is amazing. Still, the more basic issues such as what’s going to happen after death are science is put into the too hard basket. Science has given up and it almost to the point where now all that science will accept is what can be materially proven.

What can be physically proven, and there’s a very strong tendency just to hold to that. So as we need to stand back a little bit and observe our own culture, because I think science has opened the door to a degree to scientific method, logical assessment and so on, which does allow you know the West gain to gain access to philosophies of the East and so forth, but if that science is shutting the door to any speculation about future life or rebirth or karma and so on, then we need to examine that. If it’s just if all we’re worried about is this life, then science is fine. We probably don’t need anything other than the natural sciences. But if not, then we have to go beyond science as it’s currently defined.

Some assert that Buddhism is the science of mind and our current Western science is the science of the material universe, the natural sciences, and that may be one way of looking at it, and in fact, therefore, western science and Buddhism can complement each other. But it’s not quite that simple, of course, because at present there is a lot of opposition, and we know it, to Buddhist ideas on rebirth. And if you talk in a if you say you’re a Buddhist, people say, oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, you believe in rebirth. You know, you you think that the mind continues beyond death and so forth. And as Pamela pointed out, the eye science is not able to define what mind is.

It hasn’t defined it. There is a great hope amongst many scientists and many that within the field of the philosophy of mind and so forth, that it will be, the mind will be shown to be purely physical, because that would resolve a lot. Then we’d really be able to understand the mind. If we could understand it in terms of the brain, the neuro physiological activity within the brain, the electrical activity, so forth. The firing of synapses.

If that and that particular theory is like the identity theory, type identity theory, or token identity theory. I was talking with a philosopher in Monash last year about this, and he was head of the philosophy department, and I was just interested to find out where he stood on the issue of what the mind was. And he said, well actually I’m a type identity theorist, I think that is how it is. And I debated him for a while and he was very kind and open, and we got off off track and we didn’t really pursue it as much as we should have. But this is very it’s a dominant view within our society that the mind will be explained by recourse to the natural sciences.

That’s that wouldn’t be a good outcome for us. Oh, well, I mean if it is that way, if the mind is merely the brain, then that’s it. There is no spiritual path, Buddhism is meaningless, any religion is meaningless, we just cease at the end of this life. When the physical body breaks down, we’re gone, we’re finished. However, we do tend to think because it is one of the central issues within our culture that that science this view of science, this dominating view of science, we give it room and without really critically investigating it.

And I think it is important for each of us to investigate this and see the effect or just how pervasive it is. For instance, you know, the promise that science will, you know, isolate the gene for criminality or for ethical behavior or and then all we need is a gene therapy and we’ll eliminate that negative type of behavior. This is we see this and it’s often uncritically accepted. Oh, well, yeah, there will be a happiness gene. There’s a sadness gene.

There’s this type of gene and that type of gene. And of course, we’re at the threshold now of this great science opening up and really developing, you know, answers for, you know, many medical conditions and so forth, and that is wonderful. But whether in fact it’s going to be, you know, the answer to all the mental issues that we have is a completely different question. Right, so I’ll just go through that a little bit again and make a couple of points of the differences between scientific worldview and Buddhist worldview. The scientific worldview tends to be materialistic, rejecting metaphysics and philosophy.

Buddhist worldview tends to be non materialistic based on metaphysics and philosophy such as the perfection of wisdom and so on. So there’s quite a difference there. Scientific worldview is the science of the natural physical universe, the view of the observed physical reality, the investigation of matter, whereas Buddhist worldview tends to be the science of mind, the view of the observer, more of the observer than the observed, and the investigation of consciousness. There’s really a great difference there. Scientific worldview focuses on developing a sophisticated view of the material universe, of explaining on a vast scale of cosmological level, down to the very subtle subatomic level level, where within Buddhism the main emphasis is what’s happening in the mind, which type of mind or mental factor is operating, Is the mind virtuous or non virtuous?

Is karma being produced? What is the status of the object of that mind? Is that object does it exist in the way it appears to exist? What’s the appearing object? What’s the referendum?

What’s the apprehended object? It’s looking more at consciousness and how consciousness manifests moment by moment, rather than standing back and putting the observer to one side and just looking at physical objects and trying to work out how they exist. And scientific worldview promotes the assumption that clarifying the nature of matter will lead to understanding the nature of the mind and the universe. There is a there is that tendency, think, whereas Buddhist worldview promotes the assumption that clarifying the nature of mind will lead to an understanding of the universe. And so it’s there is a difference.

There is a fundamental difference. In brief, science pursues knowledge in all fields without discriminating the relative value of such knowledge. I think this is an important issue, that science is looks everywhere, but it doesn’t discriminate whether understanding that particular thing is going to be a benefit to the individual, we ordinary people, in our ordinary lives. It’s pursuing knowledge for the sake of knowledge without discriminating. And this inability to discriminate what knowledge is better, what is or what is more beneficial, what’s less beneficial, from a Buddhist perspective is a sign of lack of wisdom.

So, here, wisdom being defined as that which interprets what is virtuous and what is non virtuous. Because from within a Buddhist from a Buddhist point of view, it’s really we’re looking for paths of virtue, because they lead to happiness. We’re not just pursuing, you know, it’s nice to know what degree sub, you know, the definitions of subatomic particles or just how subtle they go and just their names, how they interact, and so on. All of this is potentially useful, and it might even lead to something beneficial. But it’s still it doesn’t deal with the fundamental issues of existence.

And if we’re not if we don’t keep the fundamental issues of existence in the forefront, we forget about them. And our life only is meaningful to the extent that we’re pursuing the fundamental issues that confront us. And I think this is one of the tragedies of modern science is that this is assumption that simply acquiring knowledge will be enough, but it doesn’t satisfy. Just the acquisition of knowledge, or how subtle, how broad. Just that in alone in itself doesn’t really bring happiness.

Therefore, to a degree, there’s a lack of wisdom in the scientific approach. The natural sciences are just acquiring. It’s like almost this attachment to knowledge. This attachment to you know having something to say about something really obscure and subtle or distant and remote and so on. Some see this is a strength of science, you know, it doesn’t happen it’s not interested in one thing or another and it’s democratic and neutral and so on.

And some people view back and say, well, how can you you know, as soon as you make value judgments of what is ethical, what is unethical, then you lose the scientific neutrality. But I think this argument needs to be closely examined. In this regard, there’s a statement in Sutra. The blessed one, the Buddha was once living in Kasambi in a wood of Simsapa trees. He picked up a few leaves in his hand and he asked the bhikkhus, how do you conceive this bhikkhus?

Which is more, the leaves that I picked up in my hand or those of the trees in the wood? The leaves in the that the blessed one has picked up in his hand are few, Lord. Those in the wood are far more. So too bhikkhus the things that I have known by direct knowledge are more. The things that I’ve told you are only a few.

Why have I told you them? Because they bring no benefit, no advancement in the holy life and because they do not lead to dispassion, to fading, to ceasing, to stilling, to direct knowledge, to enlightenment, to Nirvana. That is why I’ve told I have not told them and that is why I’ve told and what have I told you? This is suffering. This is the origin of suffering.

This is the cessation of suffering and this is the way leading to the cessation of suffering. In other words, scientific knowledge is like the leaves in the forest, it is vast. And even though a Buddha comprehends that field, He doesn’t bother to talk about the whole field because it doesn’t lead, it doesn’t lead to dispassion or detachment, to fading, to ceasing, to stilling, to direct knowledge, to enlightenment, to Nirvana. So we have to be careful. We have to examine very carefully.

The dominant paradigm, if it is science in our society, it isn’t directed towards enlightenment. It’s not even sure if there is such a thing. But there are many things that science does discover that are beneficial in the in this life, but not for enlightenment. So we need to step back a little bit there and critically examine this. As the Buddha said, you know, test what I say as you would test gold, but don’t accept it out of respect, merely out of respect for the Buddha.

You have to test not only what the Buddha said, we have to test everything and then with the field of everything, we need to test the four truths. I’m just skipping over a couple of things. Now, we talked a little bit about the philosophy of mind, and the philosophy of mind tries to understand the mind body that we possess and differentiate what is mind, what is body. The dominant paradigm in the philosophy of mind these days, so there’s a tendency to see the body being reduced to mind. In fact, there are three possibilities of the mind body, either the mind is physical or the mind and the body have separate substances or the body itself is reduced to the mind, the body becomes mind.

In brief, these are the three basic possibilities within the philosophy of mind. Science tends to think or tends to hold a view that everything is can be reduced to the physical universe, the physical field, atoms and molecules. And this is a view that, you know, is pervades, tends to pervade, or is it is there within our worldview, within our western worldview and culture. And so it’s hard for us to bring up the issue of consciousness and be treated really seriously because people really don’t it’s hard to define consciousness. And if you define it as separate from the physical reality, the physical world, then it doesn’t really sit well with, you know, general views within society at the present.

Buddhism, on the other hand, sees Buddhism has two views on this, that really of duality, that the mind and body are of separate distinct energies, or that in fact body itself is of the same substance or energy as the mind. So in that respect, if we look at the philosophy of mind, can see that Buddhism is at one end of the scale and science as as it’s portrayed, know, in our culture is at the other end of the spectrum, so it’s not easy for us to find a common ground. There is some movement back in Western philosophy to a dualist position, that the mind and body are separate energies or substances. Probably the great dualist that existed within Western society was Descartes, who generated or developed this theory of substance dualism, the mind and body are separate substances. And also the theory of interactionism that the mind and body do interact.

But because of the difficulty in explaining this interaction, how can the mind and body interact, and other issues, similar issues, it fell out of favor, and it’s become more and more the case that monism in the form of physicalism or materialism has become has taken the central ground. It’s not that everyone accepts it, but it’s almost like the implied view, the default view. But these days, there are some dualists, but even even so, the dualists always have the issue of defining how the mind and the body interact. Now within Buddhism, has been from the very beginning a central issue. Why are the mind and body examined?

It’s the mind and body are the basis of designation of the self. The continuum of the mind body, our mind body, as it continues through time is the basis of designation of self, is what we apply the term I to. So, within Buddhism, the mind and body are substantially distinct. In a majority of Buddhist philosophy or Buddhist sects or schools assert that they are substantially distinct. If for the mind only school and for the Svatantrika, Yogacharya Svatantrika, Madhya Mekan school, then the body is asserted to be the same substance as the mind.

Now, the Buddhist views support karma, they support the view of rebirth, they support the possibility of enlightenment. In fact, you really, in order to what, to support those ideas, you need to either be a dualist or an idealist. Materialism cannot support them. And I think that’s where we are in society at present. We’re sort of thinking about these issues of rebirth and karma and overcoming them, whereas the dominant paradigm in our society is that they simply are not issues because everything will eventually be reduced to to matter, to different states of material energy and so on.

So it’s difficult and I think we all also understand for ourselves, for us to actually see the difference between mind and matter is incredibly difficult. On a very subtle level there, and his holiness has spoken at length about this, just this difficulty of separating mind and matter. In fact, if mind is reduced to matter, then, you know, it doesn’t matter. We finish at the end of this life. The only it’s only when the mind and matter are differentiated that, you know, we need to then consider the implications of that.

Implications being that the mind does survive, the mind therefore may be reincarnated in a future body. The conditions that determine reincarnation will be karma and so on. And then the what is the root causes of that process? We need to then investigate what the root causes of that process are because we don’t like the idea of reincarnating. In some respects, if the materialists are corrected and make it so much easier for us, we could sit back and put our feet up and don’t worry about these issues, because as the Ilya and Pamela and Anthony pointed out, it’s so difficult.

Three countless eons. We could work for three countless eons. For us it might even be longer. Probably not. If it had, we’d already be on, you know, the pure grounds and so if we’re on the pure grounds, we should know something at this stage.

On the pure grounds, we don’t even have a normal material body. We have a body of the nature of consciousness. That body appears as form, but it’s not, it’s a substance of the mind itself. Completely, you know, different than what we have. According to orthodox Buddhist view.

So, in one sense, the the task ahead of Buddhists is to establish that the mind and the body are different substances, to create some doubt in the minds of scientists, maybe create a few miracles, you know, that will illustrate that, you know, it’s not just material, That has occurred in the past according to the scriptural record. And those things perhaps do occur in order to get people to think of other possibilities. Because I have to have to say the scientific possibility lying in front of me is not that attractive. You know, just this material Armageddon that we face each of us, you know, at the end of this life and that’s it. But the issue is we have to discern, you know, whether in fact the mind and the body are separate substances.

Not only that, from a Buddhist point of view, the mind is beginningless and endless, and there are two fundamental streams of substance that exist. There’s the stream of substance of matter and the stream of substance of mind that exist from beginning of this time. And the consciousness that we have at present is within the stream that has no beginning. It’s not easy for us to discern the nature of our own mind, but we’re too close to the issue of our own mind. But really, the apparatus that we have for investigating the nature of the mind is our own introspection.

It’s not going to be a microscope, a telescope, a scan of the brain. They will talk about the brain itself and how the brain functions, and perhaps this the interface, the potential interface between the brain and the mind. But physical apparatus are not going to be able to apprehend something that’s non physical. The momentum at present is in the the court of the physicalist, the materialist, but that’s good. Let you know, I think it’s wonderful what’s happening you know within the new neurosciences and so forth.

This fact is great investigation of the brain and how the brain operates. This is wonderful because it will potentially help reveal the nature of the mind, But because the mind is so subtle, again, look up, the mind is so subtle that it’s said that only a Buddha can fully understand the nature of the mind. So it’s no wonder that modern science has put it in the too hard basket. There’s no wonder that that occurs, because even for ourselves, you know, from the beginning of this life, we have various experiences, You know, we’re involved with our mind continuously, but do we know the nature of the mind? No.

How does it comprehend? How does it understand? What is the the essence, the energy of the mind that we have? It’s hard for us to comprehend because it is extremely subtle. It’s a subtler type of energy than physical energy.

Okay, now I’m pushing here the Buddhist perspective, but it needs to be pushed, because we’re so materialistic and that we always with the tendency for us to fall back into accepting our cultural imperatives that all, you know, that everything is just material. And that’s such that’s such a wasteland of a view. It doesn’t hold any possibility from my side, that’s, you know, how I think of it, any possibility of actually addressing the deeper issues, even though it will address many of the temporary issues that we in our society face. There were some other issues I wanted to talk about, but I don’t know, it’s about we’re about on the hour mark here, so I’m not sure if there’s any issues that anyone wants to raise. Yes, yes.

Oh no, that is very true, but it’s still peripheral. This whole the issue of meditation is quite peripheral. People do observe it and they see there is some benefit, they don’t know why. It’s I mean if you have a materialist view on what the mind is, what is happening there, then it’s difficult to really penetrate very far in understanding what the benefit of meditation is or what the actual process of meditation is. But to that extent that there are, you know, therapists, there are cognitive scientists, there are many that are investigating meditation and the effects of meditation and seeing that there are many benefits, that’s wonderful.

And the more mainstream it becomes, the better. Because there are benefits, in fact, in the seventies, eighties, the Smithsonian Institute went sent a number of scientists to Dharamsala for instance, to investigate meditators who were up the mountain at the back of Dharamsala. And one of the things that they did test there was tummo, the tummo practice and the fact that the meditators there could raise the temperature in their fingers and toes by 10 degrees, 15 degrees and you know, through this practice of inner heat. And they like that because you can actually measure it. And you can actually measure some changes in the brain waves that do occur.

Yes. Exactly, I completely agree and I think that’s just a measure, like it’s a a measure of where society is at present and that the whole idea that the mind is different from the physical form and it can exist without gross physical form and so forth. These ideas are likely as a way in our society at present. But science as a knowledge enterprise does not have a metaphysics. Individual scientists who pursue science have a metaphysics.

Determining what is the scientific view is a matter of surveying every scientist on the face of the earth and ticking the box on whether they consider themselves a monstrous dualist, panpsychist or whatever. Something that can even be assertive. And it can’t be assertive because science itself is silence. Yes. Silent on this topic.

The second thing I’d like to point out is that some of the so called physical phenomena that science investigates are such hidden phenomena. They are inferred from physical signs that are so many steps removed from the original thing. How They detected one because black holes are basically a mathematical model. They are a construct built out of mathematics. Based on the mathematics, there are certain predictions about how space ought to behave.

They see how space behaves and they infer that that’s what’s there. They actually don’t know. It’s an inference. Our structure of the standard model of atomic physics was basically put to the most monumental test when they started measuring the background radiation in the universe. Well, guess what?

The standard model can only account for, wait for it folks, 5% of the physical, visible universe. 5%. That’s not really accurate. That’s not really accurate. There’s a problem with the theory or there’s a problem with the measurements or there’s a problem with something.

So suddenly we’ve got dark matter and we’ve got dark energy. What makes it physical? What makes it physical? Yeah. It doesn’t have the last thing is when his Holiness was speaking at ANU here and he was talking to physicists and he was talking to two neuroscientists, He was really, really clear on saying when we’re talking about dualism in the Buddhist system, we are not talking about Cartesian dualism.

We are not talking about anything that crude. Because the subtle body travels with the subtle mind, and they are not separate. They are always together. They are not the same thing, but they’re always traveling with the mind. The mind’s subtle mind isn’t after doing whatever it feels like.

Sometimes it sort of comes back to the subtle body. Yeah. Always together, even in the formless realm. Yeah. Now, that’s that’s true.

No, the Cartesian duality is a very gross presentation and and he also presented things like animal spirits and so forth in order to establish how they interact, the mind and body interact. His views are, yeah, have got nothing to do with the Buddhist form of duality, which is much, much subtler and exists on a gross level of mind, an intermediate and a very, very subtle level. And actually, what the nature of matter is in mind is, to call them substance or dravia, you know, substance is perhaps too gross a term, maybe energy. The trouble is that we have these terms that are quite loaded and they can misrepresent what the actual what is actually meant, so we need to step back a little bit from that. Also, agree with what you say, there are many dualists who are scientists.

Here I’m just talking about a, you know, there’s a tendency within our Western culture to see things from a materialist or go to the physicalist extreme. I’m really talking about that tendency. The dualist, actually this comes up in Kyle has talked about the official doctrine also, which is just the general people of general view of people that the mind and body are separate. People tend to naturally have this view, and it’s really only the philosophers that come up with this, you know, this three basic possibilities of either physicalism, dualism, or idealism. But most people had the idea that there maybe is some sort of soul that leaves, departs from the body, and is reborn in heaven or whatever.

So, that also needs to be put in place. Well, I’m not sure even if that supports the idea of a creator, a big bang. Well, just what that nothing was also is, you know, like that potential from, you know, which created the the anomaly that was the then began the big bang and so forth, that’s it’s all very unclear. Well, I’m sure there’s a that’s a very subtle A dominant idea in the West because people come from a background where Yeah. Perhaps, yeah, creation does fit more with a big bang theory, but I mean, that could be an arguable point.

But of course, from a Buddhist point of view, there is no creator whatsoever. In fact, if there is a creator, then there’s nothing again, we come back almost to a materialist point of view, there’s nothing really that we can do. Everything is preordained, we’re fixed, whatever the creator decided for us will, you know, will come to pass and so forth. Yeah. Not in the least.

No. No, no, I’m just saying that Well, I guess I’m arguing from the point of view that if a creator did exist, then anything is a debate point from the Tibetan that If something impossible were to exist, then you can say anything and it would make sense. It’s a logical argument, that’s all. Sorry. What I’m saying is that from a Buddhist perspective, the creator is impossible.

There’s no sense in even talking about a creator. It’s meaningless. And if it were, then the whole field of Buddhism would be irrelevant because Buddhism explains how, you know, the universe arises due to the causal processes outside of any creating force or creative being. And this is one of the three conditions of it’s one of the three conditions of dependent arising. But anyway, without going into detail on that.

But still, I’m not saying that many people in our society accept the creator and to the extent that believing in a creator impels one to practice virtue, then that is a good thing. And if one needs to believe in a creator in order to practice virtue, then by all means one should believe in a creator. Sorry. Does that mean a creator needs to exist in the sense of No. No, it all I’m saying there is that if someone is predisposed to the view that big, you know, a creator exists, they created the universe, they created everything in it, I should practice virtue because that creative being will punish me if I don’t.

If that helps that person to practice virtue, then that’s a positive thing. From a Buddhist point of view, there is no creator being. A creator being becomes impossible from the point of view of the laws of causation. There is no first cause. A first cause is a logical impossibility.

There’s nothing that causes itself, and this comes up in the first verse of the There is no cause that causes itself. There’s no cause from self, from other, from both, from neither. There is no God that creates himself or herself. It’s a logical impossibility because cause and result is separated in time by definition. Sorry?

Buddhist says karma take that position in terms of Oh, karma only exists in the continuums of individual beings. There is no karma separate from the individual karma. So our creator is our karma, that’s all. Our intention. There’s no external creator.

Yes. Yeah. I mean, that helps, then that’s fine. Absolutely. Yeah.

If if to personify karma as a being, an external being helps in the practice of virtue, then then it’s it’s good. Then, that’s a skillful practice. As each moment passes towards eventual death, I must thank Jumper Egan so much. We have minutes for a cup of tea. Fortunate we will have at last three a panel discussion.

For today and more copies of Pamela’s front here. Feedback sheets? Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
inner fire tummo (Tib)
The energy residing at the navel chakra, aroused during the completion stage of Highest Yoga Tantra, and used to bring the energy winds into the central channel. It is also called inner or psychic heat. LYWA
parinirvana
The final nirvana the Buddha attained when he passed away in Kushinagar, India. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top