TBI Recordings

2 h 50 min · 18,173 words · 18 December 2010 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Other recordings (Ilia Durovic)
Other recordings (Ilia Durovic)
TBI Recordings
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 170-minute seminar, Ilia S. Durovic presents a comprehensive teaching on Tsongkhapa’s Three Principles of the Path, organised around the four categories of beings in Buddhist practice: worldly beings, and beings of small, middling, and great scope. He argues that genuine practice must align with one’s actual mental outlook, not merely with the teachings one receives, and that authentic refuge arises only from understanding the threat of future suffering and death. Central to the seminar is meditation on impermanence and the six sufferings—especially uncertainty, dissatisfaction, and solitude—as means to generate renunciation. Durovic then explores the royal syllogism as the chief reasoning for realising emptiness and interdependence: all phenomena lack inherent existence because they are interdependent. He addresses the critical risk of nihilism when studying emptiness, the necessity of correctly identifying the object of negation before meditation, and the graduated path from wrong views through doubt and conviction to valid cognition. Throughout, he emphasises that bodhicitta and advanced tantric practice have no foundation unless practitioners first establish conviction in impermanence, refuge, and karma, and that intellectual understanding must ripen into direct perception through sustained reasoning and meditation.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Ilia 18 Dec 2010 TPAP Final.mp3

UUID: a32cb27a-305d-41bc-bdb5-402412ec684a

Teacher: Ilia S. Durovic

Collection: Ilia Seminars

Date: 2010 (exact day not recorded)

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~18,163

Well, good afternoon, everybody. Can you hear me? Yep. Welcome once again to Tibetan Buddhist Institute and to another of Ilya Durevich seminars. Can I just ask if if there’s anybody who hasn’t been to one of Ilya’s seminars?

I think we all have. So you know where the loo is the brief break at halftime for a quick cup of tea. And I don’t think I need to say any more about Ilya other than that he is a devoted student of Khensur Rinpoche, who was one of the last great lamas escaping from China and coming into all the way to good lord Adelaide. Ilya is a faithful student and And important important very like to hand over to Ilya. Thank you.

Thank you very much, Chris. So it’s a pleasure to see you all again for this last part of the presentation of this week, the three principles of the path. I’m absolutely delighted to see that so many of you have resisted the worldly attractions of Christmas in Australia with its outpouring of profound spirituality and religious faith. Then we are going to, since these are Buddhist teachers, take refuge as a preliminary as usual in Sanskrit for auspiciousness sake. Those of you who are not Buddhist are more than welcome to remain seated, you know, and just try to reflect on where you might be going with this life after your passing as a gateway to the teachings.

And then as is the Khensur Rinpoche and Kadampa tradition, before entering into the topic of today’s teaching, we will reflect on the motivation with which to listen to this teaching, which is not a motivation of increasing one’s knowledge or satisfying one’s intellectual curiosity. But the wish to benefit others in the broadest sense of the term, not just the limited range of human beings or for that matter, the limited range of Australians, but all beings with consciousness. In other words, all sentient beings. And to benefit them not contingently in the very short term through, for instance, donations to charity or charity work, but to benefit them much more fundamentally through eliminating the root cause of their existential predicament of their suffering. And with the motivation of learning what the root cause of their suffering is, we will then listen to these teachings.

So for us, it is difficult to meditate, but let us try to at least think a little bit in these terms for one or two minutes. Thank you very much. So as Nāgārjuna says in his famous letter to King Gautamiputra, four types of persons are to be seen. Those who move from light to darkness, those who move from light to the culmination of light, those who move from darkness to the culmination of darkness, and those who move from light to the culmination of darkness. These are the four possibilities which are open to us on the scale of being.

The whole range of being from the lowest scope possible realms in which conscious activity is present, which in Buddhist terms is called the hell realms and which Nāgārjuna calls ultimate darkness, to the highest possible manifestation of consciousness, which is a state of full enlightenment. So I Nāgārjuna suggests that we be those who move from light, in other words, from a higher rebirth in this light to the cOmination of light, in other words, to liberation or full enlightenment. And I think this quote of summarizes the totality of the Buddhist teachings. It summarizes the totality of the Lam Rim, and therefore, it summarizes the totality of the three principles of the path. So if we reflect on what exactly the presentation of the four categories of beings, the beings of the four scopes is, we can see that there are fundamentally four categories of beings.

The first category of being which is systematically excluded in the Lam Rim presentations is a wonder which probably all of us belong, worldly beings. The second category of being is the beings of the small scope. The third beings of the middling scope, and the final one beings of the great scope. Worldly beings are beings like us whose exclusive or at least overwhelming preoccupation is the here and now of this life. This refers to our health, our jobs, our relationship, our family, our financial situation, our social status, the enjoyments of life which depends on one’s social origin.

Those who are from a working class background will enjoy football. Those who are from a highly educated background will enjoy university conferences. From a Buddhist standpoint, this is exactly the same thing. It is basically a fundamental waste of time. A waste of time of in a life where time is counted.

So the situation of a worldly being from a Buddhist standpoint is a tragic situation. It’s a situation of someone who is not aware that the sand in the hourglass is fleeing or who chooses not to be aware of the fact and therefore wastes whenever precious time there is. And the way that time is spent then depends from a Buddhist standpoint on the karmic background of this person. This person has no freedom, no control. They are totally controlled by their past karmic impulses.

If those past karmic impulses are good, it is possible the time would be reasonably well spent. They would have a natural predisposition to help others. If those karmic impulses are bad, the time would be poorly spent, but the person would be completely unaware of the reasons for this. Dharma Buddhism starts with the second category of beings, the beings of small scope. A being of small scope is a being who focuses mainly at least on the future life, preferably on future lives in the plural, but at least on the future life.

The best category of being of small scope focuses exclusively on future lives to the expense of this life. But to qualify as a being of small scope, one must focus mainly on the next life that is enough to qualify as a being of the small scope. From a Buddhist standpoint, good Christians, good Jews, good Muslims qualify as beings of the small scope in the very limited sense of the term we defined. How do we know whether we are beings of the small scope or not? There’s a fundamental difference to be made between the teachings we practice and the type of being we actually are.

All of us in this room have received Mahāyāna teachings from Khensur Rinpoche. Many have received advanced tantric teachings. We may practice these teachings. This does not make us beings of the great scope or Tantric advanced Tantric practitioners. The beings we are, the category of being we belong to depends on our mental outlook.

Our mental outlook is broadly speaking opaque to us. We all of us like to think that we are meditating for the benefit of all sentient beings, but that is actually how we our mind. That is not our mental outlook. Our mental outlook can be understood in the choices of the sacrifices we make under pressure. That is where the core of the person comes out.

Someone who under pressure focuses on health, wealth, relationships, profession, or social status is a worldly being. Has not entered into into the three categories of beings, the small, middling, or greater scope. Someone who under pressure sacrifices this life for the next life is a being of the lowest. So we for ourselves can check where we stand in terms of our own outlook by looking at what our fundamental choices are. And this is very important for us because once we have defined where we stand in the fourfold categories of beings, worldly beings, beings of the small, middle, or great scope, we will know what our main practice has to be.

Because the main practice of the three categories of beings which are Dharma beings, these are the small, middle, and greater scope, are defined or determined to address the core problems of those beings. For us, the Mahāyāna practices are to be blunt useless. They implant karmic imprints, but we lack the foundations on which those practices can bear fruit. For us, which is what is most useful is the core practices connected with the type of being we are. Now, for a being of the small scope, the main obstacle to practice are the so called eight mundane dharmas.

The eight mundane dharmas are pre occupation with gain, in other words, money, loss, reputation or infamy, praise or criticism, pleasure, in other words, happiness or misery. I think if we examine our minds, we will see that every one of us in this room is probably obsessed with those eight worldly dharmas. So this is a main obstacle for the being of small scope because this drags the being of small scope down to the level of a worldly practitioner. It causes him to fall down to the level of a being who’s only preoccupied with his life. The main antidote for the being of small scope to preoccupation with the eight mundane dharmas is meditation on death and impermanence.

If we ourselves are beings of the small scope and we determined as we said our mental attitude initially through checking the sacrifices we make when the knife is put on our throat as it were. If we have determined that we are beings of the small scope, our foremost practice should be meditation on death and impermanence because this breaks the attachment to this life. This ushers us fully in the practice of the being of small scope. And then meditation on death and impermanence leads to the apex of the practice of the being of small scope, which is what we call refuge. Refuge can only arise once we are searching for refuge or protection from something.

Until we understand that we are under threat, we will not search for refuge. There’s no reason for it. Under threat in this life by death, under threat in all lives by suffering. And this initiates the search for a refuge, which is an authentic refuge as opposed to our fallacious refuges in this life. You can see the refuges of a society by seeing where that society spends its money.

In the twelfth to the thirteenth century, France, for instance, spent the equivalent of one third of the yearly national income on the construction of cathedrals. In 2010, where does that sort of money go in our developed societies on health? In other words, our refuge in the twenty first century is this body. Now analysis can show us very clearly that this is a false refuge. It’s a refuge which cannot function as a refuge, which is condemned.

It’s a social illusion. Because we lack refuge and therefore the term refuge is fundamentally misunderstood by Buddhists, Western Buddhists especially, his holiness has said very cogently that perhaps for Westerners, it might be better to define Buddhism as a combined practice of interdependence and non violence. Interdependence not in the limited term of an understanding of causality from the standpoint of modern physics, but from the standpoint of a Buddhist understanding of causality as the karmic connection between deeds and their results. And nonviolence understood as the complete abandonment of the wish to commit harm to others. Now as a matter of fact, if one has true realization of interdependence, one has automatically realization of nonviolence.

But because we do not have true realization of interdependence, these two are formulated separately. Then after the practice of the being of small scope, which all of us have to strive to be, but which I would put to you perhaps no one in this room is. We have to train in the practice of the being of middling scope. Now the being of middling scope is already an extraordinary practitioner. Some of the very great yogis of India, the non-Buddhist yogis would qualify as beings of the middling scope.

A being of the middling scope is someone who has realized that the sum total of all lives without exception, past, present, and future never moves away from being suffering. We do not begin to have that that realization. Once one has that realization, once one realizes realizes that existence never moves away from suffering, at that point, the mind becomes obsessed. The same way as a prisoner. Imagine a prisoner in one, let’s say, of the the American jail in Afghanistan obsessed to escape from torture.

In the self same way, once one has that realization that the past, present, and future lives are all of the nature of suffering without exception, the mind becomes obsessed with the means to be free from this. This is what is known as renunciation. So once this life and all future lives without exception are of the taste of ashes for us. At that point, we can say we are beings of the middling scope. The main obstacle for a practitioner of the middling scope is attachment to the happiness of higher realms.

Now in our case, since many of us do not even believe in past and future lives, there’s no particular attachment to the happiness of higher realms since we don’t believe they exist. But if we imagine future future lives, infinitely more sensorially satisfying than our present human life in Australia. And if let us say some of us attained paranormal powers and had the direct perception of these lives, our attachment to these lives would be overwhelming because we would consider the happiness in those lives to be true happiness. For instance, a mental state state of existence with perhaps no body, the disembodied state, which is what the Buddhists call the god realms, especially the higher god realms. In the form in the formless realm, there is no cause suffering.

There are the imprints of suffering. There is no suffer.

If we actually believed in these realms, our desire to be reborn there would be tremendous. This is actually the main thrust of the practice of most of the non-Buddhist yogis in India, those who practice the Patanjali Yoga Sutras. And yet a practitioner of the middling scope cannot be bothered to be reborn in those realms through the realization that one has to fall from them eventually. So the main obstacle for the practitioner of the middling scope is attachment to the happiness of the higher realms. The main antidote which a practitioner of the middling scope applies is meditation on the three categories of suffering, which we covered over the last two presentations.

Meditation on the eightfold division of suffering. In other words, the sufferings of birth, aging, sickness, and death. Not getting what one wants, getting what one does not want, encountering the unpleasant, and the suffering of the four or the five contaminated aggregates. The six sufferings, which are the sufferings of uncertainty, the sufferings of insatisfaction, the suffering of being born again and again, the suffering of dying again and again, the suffering of constantly falling from the high to the low, and the suffering of being alone. The three sufferings, the suffering of suffering change and the pervasive suffering.

Of these three divisions of suffering, the second is the most powerful for the mind. If we reflect carefully on these six points that not only this life, but every life is uncertain, that everything can be taken away from us at a moment’s notice with no advance warning. Then attachment to this life and attachment to future lives collapses. All of you in this room are in the age group where cancer is a very real opportunity. Some of you have had cancer, others will have cancer.

It’s basically a matter of time. Cancer is one of the ways we can meditate on the suffering of uncertainty. All is fine until that exam when the doctor tells you that all is not well. And at that point, it all stops. At that point, to call things by their name, the next life has started already.

It’s over. This is what is meant by the suffering of uncertainty. The suffering of insatisfaction is one which is well known in western societies. Entire economies are built on creating and fostering in satisfaction, ever greater in satisfaction. Nothing is ever good enough.

This is a motive tremendous suffering in the person. Cultivation of contentment starts to go towards attenuating this. Then the two following sufferings we do not remember. Suffering of repeated birth and the suffering of repeated death, we do not remember. We do not remember the suffering of our birth because it was too ghastly.

Our mother may have received anesthetic. They don’t don’t give anesthetic to the baby. If you want to get generate a strong conviction of the reality of paranormal perception in the great Buddhist practitioners of the past, read Chandragomin’s description. Chandragomin was a great practitioner of the eighth century contemporary of Candrakīrti. Chandragomin’s description of the birth process.

It is not possible to describe the birth process that well without remembering it oneself. Now this does not happen once. This has happened an infinite number of times, and it will keep on happening. It will keep on happening unless we find a means to prevent it from continuing to happen. The suffering of repeated death again, we do not remember.

Most of us are horrified at the thought of our own possible death. And perhaps civilization as a historical phenomenon arises as a means of not thinking about death. The great French philosopher Pascal said, the tragedy of man is that he is unable to stay alone in a room with himself. This is profoundly Buddhist thought. Everything around us is a means of forgetting our incipient demise.

Everything is unimportant, is trite, tried, is even lessened. Once we have realized this, our lives will change. All the more so when we are not we realize that it’s not one time we have to walk away from everything. The Tibetans say like a hair pulled out of a pot of butter. But it has been going forever and it will keep ongoing forever.

The only difference between the 30 or so people in this room and the 25 or 30 refugees whose bodies were shattered on the rocks off Christmas Island a couple days ago is that they died a couple days ago. And with us, it will be in a couple hundred or thousands of days. This is the only difference. The certainty of death is present for all of us in this room. Our suffering in the death process will be as great, perhaps greater than theirs.

It is not evident that dying from cancer is less painful than having one skull shattered on the rocks. So our situation is identical. The only difference is a time lag. They died then, we will die later. If this is not did not happen once, it happened many times.

And then the fifth suffering is suffering from the high to falling from the high to the low. This is something even in this life, in the global financial crisis we have seen. I have many friends in Switzerland who were millionaires. I get friends who are close to being billionaires. Many of them now are bankrupt.

This is falling from the high to the low. My brother-in-law was a high powered banker with the World Bank. He’s now struggling to find a job in London. This is falling from the high to the low. In this country, you’ve had it good.

By coincidence, it will not last. It’s not in the nature of having it good to last. Before the fall, we have to change our minds. Otherwise, this process of falling to the from the high to the low, a falling from being someone who is respected and considered and called sir or madam to someone who is asked to please vacate the premises because he he or she hasn’t showered. This is something which can be extraordinarily painful, which can lead to insanity.

This is not something which has happened once to us. It has happened many, many times. How many Hollywood stars end up as homeless people? I was once in the Cayman Islands. I remember going to the bar and seeing that the pianist at the bar was a very famous Hollywood star who had started Magnum.

When he finished playing the piano, I called him over. I said, what happened? I said, I was Magnum. They stopped. It was a series of the seventies.

They stopped they stopped filming Magnum. They had no work for me. I became nobody. So he earned a living for playing jazz in bars. This is the human reality.

This is my reality. This is your reality. Dharma is the process of transforming the mind in the function of this reality so that the suffering we experience when this occurs is reduced, eventually eliminated. Finally, the last of the six sufferings is one none of us wants to hear about, the suffering of solitude. We are fundamentally alone.

And the two key moments of our life, our birth and our death, we are completely alone. There may be many people in the room, but the experience of birth, which can lead to the death of a child at that instant, and the experience of death ushering the next life are unshareable experiences, completely unshareable. Then in between, we make believe that we have company. We flutter from relationship to relationship, from family to family, from social event to social event to forget our solitude. If we understand that solitude is a fundamental situation, this is not something which is abnormal.

This is the way things are. Then the behavior of trying to forget it on a purely temporary and transient way is profoundly irrational behavior. It does not solve the fundamental problem. It’s exactly the same thing as someone who is sentenced to death and who spends his last hour listening to a jazz record. It is absurd behavior.

Within one hour left to live to waste it listening to music. The only difference between ourselves and that man is a time lag. If we take our lifespan, our potential lifespan, some of you in this room are 40, some are 50, some are 60. Let’s say you live up to 70, 77, let’s say for those from 40 to 77 is thirty seven years. You multiply that by three hundred sixty five days, you get a little bit more than ten thousand days.

Ten thousand days goes like that. Day after day after day, and you will only have noticed as you grow older, the time goes faster. When you are young, one month is forever. At my age, one month happens, goes over quickly. My mother is 19.

The years pass like this. As we grow older, time faster and our capacity to do something meaningful as it collapses. Our physical and our mental capacities collapse. And then the three broad subdivisions of suffering we talked about, which I will not enter into detail because we have covered them first. And secondly, they are more difficult to understand.

They are more abstract. The suffering of suffering, in other words, physical pain, physical or mental pain. As you remember, Āryadeva said, the poor suffer in their flesh and the wealthy suffer in their minds. In other words, the poor experience physical suffering, the suffering of hunger, the suffering of thirst in the third world countries. In this country, the suffering of untreated disease.

And the rich suffer mentally from depression, from anxiety, from fear, from horror at their impending death. But if we reflect on Āryadeva’s quote, the poor suffering their flesh and the rich suffer in their mind, what can be deduced from that quote is that all suffer. The only difference is the modalities of suffering. Therefore, a being of the middling scope is a being who’s reflecting on these three broad subdivisions of suffering, the eightfold, sixfold, and threefold subdivision of suffering, generates a feeling of disgust with existence which is so great that he or she has no time for anything else but finding the means to be freed from existence. And here, the crux is that one must find the right means, the means which work.

It’s not the case that all the ways to break out of the jail are the same. Some work and some don’t. Once you are serious about practice, whether you’re being of the smaller the middle scope, to be blunt about it, you are not tolerant. You don’t have time for what doesn’t work. You check you check very carefully to see whether the teachings work or not.

It’s no longer a matter of intellectual interest or a hobby. If you are in a jail and somebody comes up to you, and he says, pal, I’ve got a plan. We can get out to the sewers. First question you ask is, is he for real or is he an informer sent in by the authorities? It’s not a trivial question.

This being corresponds to the spiritual teacher. The spiritual teacher comes to teach the way out. The first question to be asked is, is he for real or not? Anyone can claim to be a spiritual teacher. The West is full of so called gurus.

The question is, are they authentic or not? It’s not an irrelevant question because you’re going to have to rely on someone who knows the way out. If they don’t know the way out and they haven’t been out, there’s no way they can take you out. Once you realize your situation within the cycle of lives, you want to be very sure because time is of the essence, energy is of the essence, that what you practice works and is based on the teachings of someone who knows what he’s doing. Therefore, it is capital to select a good spiritual teacher.

Then the foremost means to gain liberation from samsaric existence is wisdom. Wisdom which enables us to see phenomena as they are. There are many teachings on wisdom. The non-Buddhist traditions, the Hindu traditions make great claims. The Jain traditions make great claims.

In the Buddhist tradition, there’s tremendous disagreement between the schools on what is the nature of what is known as the object of negation. Within the Tibetan tradition, the Sakya, Ge, Luk, Kagyu, and Nyingma schools each have their own specific understanding of this. And the Chinese schools have their own specific understanding. This is not something which is secondary. If you see wisdom as a means to escape from samsaric existence, you must, from your own side, be 100% sure that what you are meditating upon works.

We’re not speaking here of a matter of tolerance, but a matter of truth. One is friends with all. In your jail cell, you are friends with all the other prisoners. But once you have to rely on someone to scuttle through the sewers to get out, you want to be sure he knows the way, and you’re not gonna end up facing an iron grid. In the same same way, if you’re going to put the rest of your life into effort in meditating on wisdom, you do not meditate on just anything.

You want to be 100% sure that what you meditate upon works. And then in turn, the being of great scope is a being who, having realized that existence is suffering, finds it to able to think think that let alone himself others as well are trapped in the suffering. So the difference between the being of middling scope and the being of great scope is the same one as in a jail cell between the prisoner who plans his own escape and the group leader who, from the beginning, thinks of everyone in the self and is planning the escape of everyone in the self. Both realize equally the suffering of being in jail. One thinks only of himself.

The other thinks of the community which surrounds you. For the being of great scope, the focus, goal is to become enlightened for the sake of other sentient beings. In other words, to reach perfection, the state of all qualities, all thoughts are eliminated, not for oneself as a being of middling scope, but exclusively for the sake of others. If a being of the great scope thinks of his own benefit at that moment, he has fallen down to the level of the practitioner of middling scope. He may attain liberation.

He will never attain for enlightenment. And the main obstacle for such a being, being of the great scope, is called a bodhisattva, is attachment to his own freedom from suffering. In the safe same way as the main obstacle for the head of the posse in the jail cell is to think I could just do it by myself. Why why take the weak, the lazy, the impotent behind me? Let’s take care of number one.

At that moment, he ceases to be the head of the community. The main antidote for the Bodhisattva practitioner is cherishing others. Cherishing others more than himself. Actually, cherishing others as much as he used to cherish himself, which is absolutely. So I said at the beginning, we have to make a very clear distinction the training we engage in and the category of being we belong to.

If we do not make that distinction, we will be deluded about who we are, and our practice would be ineffectual. All of us meditate on the training of the beings of all three scopes, the small, middling, and great scope. Many of us meditate on tantric practices. But it is critical for us to know where we stand in the scale of the Lam Rim because this in turn tells us what practices we have to focus upon, what are the practices which are of main benefit to us. So most of us train in the Mahāyāna, I think we can take it for granted.

None of us in this room is a Mahāyāna being. None of us is a practitioner of the middling scope. Perhaps one or two persons are practitioners of the lower scope, perhaps beings of the lower scope. It is not terribly clear either whether we have actually refuged or not. All of have gone through the ceremony.

We have said the right words. Is there refuge in our minds? This is a very different question. A fundamentally different question. Someone who has refuge is someone who when the going

Gets tough, turns to the Dharma, which is a foremost refuge to the teachings, in other words, to he who teaches them the Buddha and to those who practice them. We are not in that category. If we look at our behavior, when we have cancer, we turn to the doctor. When we have financial problems, we turn to the banker. When we have relationship problems, we go to some relationship center.

When we have general problems in our life, we sneak into self help section of the library and read books on self help. This is a sign of lack of refuge. If we had refuge in keeping with the single pointed prayer of the, we would pray to the teacher that he be our refuge life after life and that we never turn to another refuge. We spend our lives turning to other refuges. I mean, it’s extraordinary easy extraordinarily easy for us to turn to other refuges.

It’s very difficult for us to actually focus on one refuge. Now the reason for this is because we do not understand the qualities of the object of refuge. And the foremost object of refuge is the Dharma. It’s because we do not understand the qualities of the teachings that there is no refugees in our mind, and that’s normal. How could that be?

It is because we have a totally unrealistic appreciation of the qualities of doctors, of bankers, of self help teachers that we turn to them for help. Once we understand that the Buddhist teachings are the antidote to suffering for future lives and even in this life, then refuge in the teachings is easy. It’s not taking refuge, which is difficult. So to do this, we have to actually study carefully the Buddhist teachings in the light of reasoning. It’s in the light of reasoning through again and again, putting the teachings as a French poet, Boileau said, again and again on the table do I put, you know, my work.

Again and again on the table and checking, checking, checking, eventually certainty arises. This transforms the mind. This is this mental transformation. This is refuge. This is why we say we speak actually actually my prayer speaks in of the armor of refuge.

Armor because it protects the mind. The body, there’s nothing we can do about. We cannot protect the body. This life is spoken for. The mind we can protect, but the protection, the harmer is when we have to construct, and we need guidance on how to construct it.

And then, as we said, once one moves beyond the practice of the being of small scope for which an understanding of karma and causality is the main training. This is the main training of the being of small scope. Strategic use of karma. Once it moves to the practice of the being of middling and great scope, one needs wisdom. One needs that wisdom which realizes the nature of phenomena.

This is the only way to be liberated from the cycle of lives. This wisdom is very difficult to obtain. And himself and his life is an instruction for us, struggled tremendously to obtain it, and at the beginning, definitely did not have it. And then through great effort from his side, eventually, through a combination of prayer, of meditation, of study, Tsongkhapa gained realization of the ultimate nature phenomena. And he was instructed by the manifestation of the Buddha of wisdom, Mañjuśrī, on what is necessary for this to happen.

What is necessary is for four conditions to be assembled. We must accumulate merit. In other words, positive karma. We must purify our minds. So whichever means of purification we choose to use, many.

Then we must see the spiritual teacher, not any spiritual teacher. The spiritual teacher who has been checked, who can actually lead us out of the jail of cyclic existence. That spiritual teacher we must see as inseparable of whichever tutelary deity we rely upon. And finally, we must make strong prayers of entreaty. With these four conditions assembled over time, it is possible for us to hope to gain some sense of wisdom.

And I would add a fifth criteria which is implicit in Tsongkhapa’s works and study the great texts. Otherwise, as Nāgārjuna says in his if they view emptiness the wrong way, those of limited intelligence will be ruined. So if one has to choose between studying emptiness casually and not studying emptiness at all, it’s better not to study emptiness because the pitfalls are tremendous. The main pitfall is nihilism. The main pitfall is to be unable to posit the conventional existence of phenomena, which is such a major pitfall it afflicted the quasi totality of great Tibetan practitioners and scholars basically from the tenth century to the fourteenth century.

Once one is unable to pause at conventional phenomena, in other words, phenomena which are not of the nature of emptiness, it is impossible to pause at common causality. Then forget the practice of the being of middling and great scope. The practice of the being of small scope, which is a foundation collapses. There is no practice of calm abiding. Then one is actually at best a worldly being.

At worst, a worldly being with extreme wrong views. And we will now pass on to the root text of Tsongkhapa, the three principles of the path view. The third part of which which was translated and handed out. The reason for which the view is necessary. Says, since one who is not endowed with the wisdom, realizing the mode of abiding, albeit having become accustomed to definite emergence in bodhicitta, would be unable to sever the root of existence, strive at means to realize interdependence.

So as Geshe Rabten famously said, is nothing else but renunciation for others. Is nothing else but the mind of renunciation of the being of small scope extended to the sum total of sentient beings. The two are connected. The path of the being of middling scope and the path of the being of great scope are connected. For this reason, for both wisdom is necessary.

And according to the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka tradition, the same wisdom. In other words, a realization of both the selflessness of persons and the selflessness of phenomena. The schools beneath the Prāsaṇgika school, even for that matter, the Svatāntrika Madhyamaka school, consider that the wisdom which a practitioner of the middle scope meditates upon and the wisdom which a practitioner of the great scope meditates upon are different. Not qualitatively, but qualitatively different. The Prāsaṇgika school considers that there is no difference in the object of meditation between a practitioner who is striving for liberation for his own sake and a practitioner who is striving for enlightenment.

There’s a difference in their motivation. The practitioner who’s striving for liberation for his own sake meditates both on the selflessness of persons and of phenomena. But as soon as he has reached liberation, he stops. He has achieved his goal. The practitioner of the great scope meditating on the selflessness of persons and the selflessness of phenomena with the goal of attaining full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings does not stop until he attains this goal.

And the the root for the fact, the scripture root if you want for the fact that the practitioner of middling scope meditates on the same emptiness as a practitioner of great scope. The Candrakīrti in his Prasannapadā says that that ignorance ignorance which is the first of the 12 links of dependent origination is none other than the ignorance which perceives phenomena as truly existing. If that is the case, then that means that to gain liberation from the 12 links, it is necessary to eliminate that ignorance which perceives phenomena as truly existing. And that ignorance is a set of same ignorance whose elimination the bodhisattva strives for. So this is for those of you who are interested in more advanced topics.

This is the crux. Then this first stanza of the three principles principles of of the the path which we read refers broad broadly speaking to the practice of a Bodhisattva on the path of accumulation. In other words, this is a Bodhisattva, one who has generated bodhicitta in the section we saw last time with the three principles of the path, and in whose mind spontaneously the wish to attain for enlightenment for the sake of sentient beings arises. This This wish is there naturally, spontaneously. It is not cultivated.

And at this point, the practitioner lacks wisdom. He or she lacks that wisdom which realizes the selflessness of persons and phenomena. And this is what this first stanza refers to. So broadly speaking, those of you who have studied sa lam know that there are five paths. We have the path of accumulation, preparation, of seeing, of meditation, and of no more learning.

A Bodhisattva practitioner spends one countless eon on the two first paths, one on the first part of the path of seeing and meditation, the so called first seven grounds, and one on the last three grounds. During his training on the path of accumulation, he lacks the wisdom which understands selflessness, the selflessness of persons and phenomena, and trains in this wisdom, realizing it conceptually conceptually at the level of the path of preparation. Then he trains during the path of preparation for countless lives until eventually that conceptual mind which realizes the selflessness of persons and of phenomena turns into a direct non conceptual perception of emptiness. When that happens, the first instant of this direct non perception of emptiness is a path of seeing. And then this has to be deepened.

This is deepened during the various grounds leading up to the seventh ground. It’s at the level of the seventh ground. The the last instance of the seventh ground that the Bodhisattva actually abandons the so called kleshavaranas, the obstructions which are the afflictions, which an abandons when he gains liberation. So it takes much longer for the Bodhisattva to abandon these. And then during the three last grounds, in this period during training in the three last grounds where the mind is extraordinarily pure, this period is one which lasts one countless year, during which the bodhisattva strives to abandon the final level of obstructions, which are the obstructions to omniscience, to all-knowingness.

And at the very last instant of the tenth ground, the Bodhisattva becomes a Buddha, a fully enlightened being. So these are the paths. And to travel these paths, one has to understand the nature of phenomenon. Now broadly speaking, there are two possibilities. When we speak of phenomena, we speak of persons such as ourselves and everything we perceive with the eyes, ears, nose, the tongue, the bodily consciousness as well as everything we think about.

As far as phenomena are concerned, either they exist as they appear to us or they don’t. Don’t. There’s no other possibility. The consensus in what we could call Anglo Saxon realism, which is a combination of a long period realistic thought which started in the West with Aristotle, is that phenomena exist as they appear with one or two minor qualifications. The complete body of modern scientific research, basically, let us say from Galileo onwards, shows that this is completely wrong.

Phenomena do not exist as they appear to sense consciousnesses. The sun is not of the same size as the moon. The earth is not flat. Living beings are not solid masses. They are composed of cells.

Matter is not a solid block. It is composed of atoms, which is separated by huge expanses of emptiness. If there’s one thing where modern science has been tremendously helpful to Buddhist philosophy, philosophy. It is in breaking through Western naive realism. It is to me incomprehensible that in 2010, so called philosophers should still be naive realists.

It flies in the face of an amount of given data which makes it basically impossible for a rational person. So the very root premise of Buddhism, of all the Buddhist schools of philosophy is proven. Phenomena do not exist in the way they appear. Of that, at present, there is no debate. Then the question is, how do they appear?

How do they exist? Excuse me. And how can we get access to this mode of existence? There are two ways to do this. Most of us do not have the time, the intellectual possibilities, perhaps education to study what is required to do this on our own.

Then we can rely on someone who has actually been there and seen this. Some who has actually seen how phenomena exist from their own side. In other words, we can rely on our gamma on scripture, on faith. The problem is obviously to choose an object of faith, which is a worthy object of faith. Then it is evident that faith and conviction are insufficient.

There’s no debate about this. Unfortunately, in our present situation, this is what we have. As Nāgārjuna said in the precious garland, due to having faith, one relies on the practices. Due to having wisdom, one truly knows. So faith has to bridge the gap into wisdom, into the point where we actually can investigate through reasoning because this is the only thing which actually works.

We are unfortunately not able to do this at present, most of us. Now investigating through reasoning is the thrust of the Buddha’s message. The Buddha famously said to his disciples, bhikshus and scholars, in other words, monks in general and scholars specifically, accept my speech relying upon upon sound analysis just as gold is smelted, cut, and rubbed and not out of respect. So precisely because one values gold, one does not take a piece of gold which is passed on to one by one doesn’t know at face value when checks. To put a modern metaphor on this, many of you have bought a house.

I’m quite sure you have been extraordinarily careful investigating the deed of the house. And you have put great acumen in getting the right sort of mortgage, buying in the right area, borrowing as much as you could, but not more. And this is something which is extremely transient and insignificant. Insignificant. If we put that much effort and analysis in something which is transient and insignificant, how much more should we put in investigating the nature of reality if the nature of reality is a gateway to liberation.

So this is the thrust of the Buddha’s instructions. And therefore, all Buddhist schools share the common assertion that phenomena are not apprehended as they actually exist by an ignorant mind, which means by the mind of most most of us who are not enlightened. Therefore, on the basis of phenomena, with phenomena as a basis of imputation, two sorts of minds can arise. A mind of ignorance and a mind of wisdom. The basis of imputation is the same.

The mind of ignorance is a mind which projects, which imputes something which is nonexistent on an existing basis. The mind of wisdom is the mind which eliminates this nonexistent projection imputation. Now this all sounds terribly complicated, but let’s take an example which most of us in this room have had. The famous case of relationships, the contemporary

Session of western civilization. People are obsessed with each other. Men falling in love with women, women falling in love with men, whatever. And if we analyze the process of falling in love, we can see the exact process of imputation. Falling in love is imputation.

Qualities which are either not present or very distantly present in an existing object are projected on that object or placed on on that object. And the process of falling in love is nothing else but imputing evermore. So there is an object on which these qualities are stacked, but the qualities themselves have very little to do with the object. We know this when we listen to people who have fallen in love talking of the object or the person they’re in love with. People who are not in love with this person are not quite sure what’s going on.

He or she is so patient and we know them as short-tempered. He or she is so wise. They’re always hanging out at the movies. He or she is so stable. We don’t dare to say anything.

You know? Now this is imputation. Qualities which do not exist are placed from our side on an object, a person. Love, in other words, desire, what we call love is actually desire functions like this. Desire is simply a process where qualities which are nonexistent from the side of the object are imputed on the object.

Anger functions in the same way. Anger is a phenomenon or a process where qualities which don’t exist from the side of the object or defects, excuse me, should I say, which do not exist from the side of the object are placed on the object. in dependence on the process of imputation and desire, attraction arises. in dependence on the process of imputation in hatred or anger, animosity arises. In both cases, desire and animosity have very, very little, if anything, to do with the object itself on which these are placed.

Take let us take one example, and then we will take a tea break. Let us take the debate in Australia about refugees. If you were to follow the debate in Australia about refugees as an outsider, you would have the impression that tens of thousands of boats are threatening the shores of defenseless Australians. All of which are basically chock a block with rabbit, desperate to penetrate Australian society in the deep and transform it into Mauritania. This is the impression you would have reading The Australian.

The population at large reacts to this with a classic fear of invasion. They, capital t, are coming. They are going to destroy our lifestyle. Now this is a reaction. Then when you check, you realize that on average per annum, you’re talking of 2,000 boat people as opposed to 100,000 illegal refugees per annum in France.

What gives rise to this difference of reaction? In Imputation. In other words, the imputation of threat, the imputation of danger is projected upon an object which has very little from its own side to do with this. Something, but very little. And the clear sign of powerful imputation is excessive reaction.

So if you want to see whether inordinate imputation is going on, look at the scale of the reaction. Inordinate falling in love means excessive imputation on the object. Inordinate anger and hatred means excessive imputation on the object. Now this affects individuals. This affects societies.

This is why understanding the process of imputation is fundamental. And this is why also put such effort in understanding the process of ignorance, which is the core process of force imputation. And upon these words, I think we will take a well earned break for a cup of tea. So as we said, we can see that understanding the process of imputation is fundamental. And if we were to take one example to see how one object can bear radically different imputations as a gateway to understanding the core mistaken imputation of ignorance.

Let us take one human being who has evoked radically diverging reactions. Let’s take the case of Adolf Hitler. Adolf Hitler was loathed by much of the allied world, assimilated to a monster. The Sefsin man was idolized by his mistress Eva Braun. Her account of him describes a kind, sensitive, thoughtful man.

And if one reads accounts of Hitler’s lives before his accession to power in the early twenties, by all accounts, most people reacted to Hitler with complete indifference. He was as far as everyone could ascertain a non-entity. So we have one person who, from the standpoint of some, produces reactions of tremendous hatred. From the standpoint of others, reactions of great affection and love. And from the standpoint of many until he came to power, reactions of complete indifference.

This is an extreme case, but we can suspect that the mind of the recipient had a very powerful role in this process. In the same same way as in our own lives, if we fall in love with someone who is the enemy of someone else, the person we fall in love with is from our side the recipient of qualities which probably don’t exist in that person or which are exaggerated. These qualities are imputed on him and other source of attachment. From the side of his enemy, this person is a recipient of the imputation of defects which are either completely nonexistent or greatly exaggerated. Then the question arises, what is a person independent of this process of imputation?

We can see that imputation is at the root of desire, where qualities which don’t exist in the object are put upon object. We can see that imputation is at the root of hatred, where qualities which do not or defects which do not exist in the object or only normally present or exaggerated. And the contention of four schools of Buddhist thought, the Vaibhāṣika, the Sautrāntika, the Cittamātra, the Madhyamaka is that underlying the twin process of desire and hatred is imputation upon the object of an ontological status it lacks. In other words, of a mode of existence it lacks. From the standpoint of all four schools of Buddhist thought,

The root of the process of imputation of desire and the root of the process of imputation of hatred is that the object is seen by the perceiver as more real, more solid than it actually is. They disagree then greatly about just how more real and how more solid the object is. But all of the schools of Buddhist philosophy agree upon this. And for that matter, all schools of Buddhist philosophy agree that there are four fundamental imputations which occur. These are the four mistaken conceptions which are at the root of suffering.

The first is apprehending the unclean as clean. The second is apprehending the impermanent as permanent. The third is apprehending what is suffering as happiness. And the fourth is apprehending the selfless as having a self. Now these four conceptions are present in all of us, and they are presented in order of increasing difficulty of understanding.

We can see clearly that, for instance, we impute on other human beings when the nature of others, of living beings in general, is to be unclean. In the West, we are oblivious to this because of our obsession with hygiene, but all it takes is not washing for a couple days to realize that the human body is something which is filthy. It secretes and oozes from all its orifices. Secreting and oozing is part of the functionality of the human body. We sweat.

We produce snot. We produce saliva. We produce earwax. We produce urine. We produce feces.

We offer practical means and purposes a mobile gastrointestinal tube which excretes, ingests clean food, and produces excreta. This is something which is evident to all of us. Every one of us in this room goes to the toilet once a day. All we have to do is after we have done stand up and look, this comes from us, from nowhere else. How is it then possible to desire such a body?

Every day, it is very clear to us the body is of the nature of dirt. The only possibility for desire to arise is through an uncontrolled process of imputation where the quality of cleanliness, which is completely absent in the body is imputed on the body. And then when we’re in love, the quality of supreme cleanliness. The scent of our beloved is perfume. As Śāntideva famously said, if you’re going to fall in love with something, why not fall in love with a nice clean wooden statue?

A wooden statue does not secrete and excrete. It does not ooze. A wooden statue left by itself will gather a bit of dust. That’s all. A wooden statue actually is by its nature clean.

The body is by its nature dirty, yet we desire the body. This is the first mistaken conception. The second which is more difficult to understand is apprehending the impermanent as permanent. Impermanent refers to the transient changing nature of phenomena. Phenomena in general human bodies in particular.

We impute permanence, in other words, durability and unchangingness on bodies which change. People fall in love and the husband says to his wife twenty years later, your face has not changed. I mean, what more extreme case of imputation is there than that? The poor Or as those of us who solely applies to men in the audience, well know, the most damning indictment a lady can ever make is to look at you sharply and say, you changed. But it’s self evident.

What is being said by the person is that she or he, it happened to this man, has suddenly realized the impermanence of the object of imputation. The object of imputation imputation no longer functions to carry the imputation. This is imputation of impermanent of permanence upon impermanent people. The third imputation is more difficult to understand again. It’s implication of what or of happiness on what is suffering.

The human body is a locus of suffering. We do not realize it because we do not meditate. Those who meditate on mindfulness are initially within the first stage of training in Satipatthana, shocked by the level of suffering which arises in the body. Itching, scratching, agitation, aches, joints who didn’t know start to ache. This is not a new suffering.

What has just happened is that the threshold of inattention has been lowered, and suffering which was always there has become manifest. It was filtered out. Now once one eliminates this process of filtering out, one realizes that the existence of sentient beings, human existence in particular is suffering. Yet, we project happiness, a fantasy of happiness upon suffering. And the fourth misconception is apprehending the selfless as having yourself.

This is the core of what we will talk about today. This is apprehending what lacks permanence, unity, and independence as being permanent, one, and independent. So the notion that the person lacks permanence, unity, and independence is the vision of the selflessness of persons, which is common to all schools of Buddhist philosophy from the Vaibhāṣika to the Prāsaṇgika without exception. There’s one minor exception. There’s one subschool of the Vaibhāṣika, the Vatsipotrias, which consider that there is a truly existing person, but they are the major exception in the whole picture.

Now for which reason is it critical to analyze this apprehending of the selfless as having a self? Because as we said earlier, it is through injecting a level of existence in the phenomena which is actually not there that in turn we both desire and hate living beings and objects. Then if we want to cut the root of desire and hating, we have to cut this misapprehension of the nature of phenomena and persons. To do this, we have to understand exactly a, how they exist, and b, what we are what level of existence we are putting on top of that. In other words, we have to understand the mode of existence, existence, and we have to understand the nonexistent imputation which is added to that.

This is where the Buddhist schools disagree. And these disagreements can only be sorted through reasoning. So if we analyze carefully, what is the actual mode of existence of phenomena? The mode of existence of phenomena is what the Buddhists call interdependence. All four Buddhist schools, believe that certain categories of phenomena are impermanent and interdependent.

They disagree about which categories disagree about the meaning of interdependence. The Vaibhāṣika school we will perhaps leave aside, it has somewhat uncommon assertions. And we will start with the Sautrāntika school, which is a lower vehicle school. For the Sautrāntika school, only impermanent phenomena are interdependent. And what the Sautrāntika mean by interdependence is that impermanent phenomena are in a causal relationship with each other.

They are cause and effect. Permanent phenomena can neither be cause nor be effects. So this is the sum total of the Sautrāntika understanding of interdependence. The mind only school, the Cittamātra school also asserts that a certain category of phenomena interdependent. We won’t enter into this too much today within the three natures.

It’s what’s known as the other powered nature which is interdependent. You know, it’s mainly minds for the mind only school. But fundamentally, we can say that for the three lower schools, Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika, and Cittamātra, it is impermanent phenomena which are interdependent. Now within the fourth school, the Madhyamaka school, there are two subdivisions. And the They have enhanced or enlarged definitions of interdependence.

For the not only does interdependence refer to the fact that phenomenon cause relationships. In addition, it refers to the fact that phenomena are in the relationship of the composite and the parts of the composite. Composite. So the relationship between a whole and the parts of a whole is a relationship of interdependence. This is not accepted by the lower schools.

For instance, my parts, the cells and the atoms constituting my body, from the standpoint of the Svatthakamajamika, exist in dependence on my whole, which is my body. In the self same way as my whole, my body exists in dependence on the parts, the cells, the molecules, and the atoms which constitute it. So the in large definition of interdependence. The Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka, however, go one step further, still accepting interdependence as causality for impermanent phenomena, interdependence as a relationship between the composite in the parts for phenomena which have parts. The Prasummita Madhyamaka assert that the relationship between the mind which imputes and the imputed phenomenon is one of interdependence.

And this is the most subtle form of interdependence asserted. So in other words, we have three levels of interdependence. We have course, which is causal interdependence, Subtle, which is the interdependence of compositionality. Very subtle, which is the interdependence of mental imputation. Coarse is asserted by the Sautrāntika, the Vaibhāṣika, and the Cittamātra.

The subtle is asserted by and the very subtle is asserted by which asserts all the previous ones as well. So this is the actual mode existence of phenomena established through the twin activities of contemplation by great practitioners and reasoning. We can say broadly speaking that the consensus certainly in quantum physics is in agreement with the Buddhist present presentation of conventional phenomenon. Much of the evidence which has come from quantum physics confirms the Buddhist notion of the very subtle dependence of phenomena. Those of you who have studied physics have perhaps heard of Heisenberg’s principle of uncertainty that the position of the quality of motion of a particle cannot equally be known with complete certainty.

And therefore, that there is a core uncertainty which arises from the process of observation itself. The process of observation, in other words, affects the observed phenomenon. This is something which was not accepted in classical mechanics. Newtonian mechanics did not consider that observing the attraction, the gravitational attraction between two objects made one iota of difference to the relationship between two objects. It is really after Planck and especially after Heisenberg that the Buddhist notions of mental imputation and the interdependence between the process of mental imputation and the impute phenomenon, we would say in physics between observation and the phenomenon observed arose.

So this is I would say another point which clearly indicates that Buddhist philosophy is very much on the right track. Now the question which arises at present is how precisely the mind perceives or should I perhaps say better. So what stages the mind is trained from wrong perception of the nature of phenomena to correct perception? And we will cover this briefly since we are a little bit short of time. Fundamentally, ordinary beings perceive phenomena as non interdependent naturally.

It’s a non reflective perception, which is present in human beings, in insects, in animals, and so forth. It can eventually become conceptual, however. In human beings, there are human beings who have formalized this. Philosophers have actually said, there are philosophers would teach at phenomena have a nature from their own side. Some Greek philosophers as Parmenides taught that phenomena are permanent.

So most definitely not interdependent from the standpoint of all four Buddhist schools of philosophy. So this would be the basic form of wrong consciousness, which can be non conceptual conceptual. So familiarizing with the idea of impermanence, eventually wrong conception transforms into doubt. The doubt which says perhaps phenomenon permanent. I’m not terribly sure.

And doubt in turn can be subdivided into three into three. Doubt which airs towards a non factual, equal doubt, and doubt which airs towards a factual. Doubt which airs towards a non factual is the doubt of someone who thinks, well, I’ve heard phenomena impermanent, but this sounds very far fetched to me. However, who knows? Equal doubt is doubt which cannot decide.

To familiarizing with the idea of impermanence, for meditating, the person thinks, well, phenomena might or might not be interdependent. And then eventually through the ongoing process of familiarization, when give rise gives rise to a doubt which tends towards a factor. This is a state of mind which probably most of us in this room have as long term Buddhists thinking, yes, phenomena probably are impermanent. Now these two states of mind, wrong views and doubts, what are technically called controvertible minds. We could call them reversible minds.

They can one can fall back from those minds. They are not stable states of mind. The doubt which thinks phenomena probably are in interdependent, which is our state of mind for most of us in this room can quite easily regress back to the wrong view which says phenomena aren’t interdependent after all. So these states of mind are controvertible. It is extremely important for us to transform these controvertible or reversible states of mind into in controvertible states of mind.

And the first in controvertible state of mind is known as conviction in Buddhist epistemology. Conviction arises when one reaches the certainty, in this case that phenomena interdependent, and one cannot lose that certainty again. But it does not arise in dependence on a valid reason. So repeatedly attending teachings, repeatedly meditating, repeatedly becoming familiarized with the teaching, eventually, we get this conviction. Yes.

Phenomena interdependent. It is described by those who have had this as very close to realization. It’s a very powerful inner transformation. It is not something minor. Probably none of us in this room have convictions in the Buddhist sense of of the term of interdependence or for that matter of the existence of past and future lives.

Because when a conviction, in other words, an incontrovertible state of mind arises, even though it is not based on a valid reason, it totally transforms the Weltanschauung, the outlook of the

Unless this has happened to us, we have not had mana pariksha. On the basis of this conviction, we try to give rise to a valid cognizer. Now these are the minds we are trying to generate. Valid cognizers are minds which are totally unmistaken in their assessment of what they observe. And they are of two categories.

We have conceptual valid cognizers, which are born from reasoning and are known as inferential cognizers. And we have non conceptual valid cognizers, which are not born from reasoning. But generally speaking, most of us in daily life have non conceptual valid cognizers. So called Pratyaksha Pramāna. Valid cognizers are known as Pramāna or prime mind.

The non conceptual direct valid cognizers, we have a sense valid cognizers. When I, for instance, look at Chris, the first instance of the eye consciousness seeing the color of Chris’ shirt is a very fresh and pure mind. This is a non conceptual valid cognizer of the brown color of Chris’ shirt. This is naked mind. It’s a very powerful mind.

Unfortunately, it’s not a stable mind. It quickly degenerates. And then when it comes to reflecting on interdependence, what we are trying to do is after gaining conviction in the existence of interdependence to give rise to an inferential valid cognizer of interdependence, which is an incontrovertible mind. That was a mind which cannot revert, realizing the dependence based on a valid reason. It was based on reasoning.

This is much more powerful than a mere conviction. We do not have these minds. These are the sort of minds which give rise to existential commitment. And then once we have an inferential valid cognizer of interdependence, since this is a conceptual mind, it apprehends its object which is interdependence through avail. The veil is what we call a meaning generality, conceptual image of the object.

We can see when we think, for instance, if you have, let’s say, you close your eyes and you think of your mother, what appears to the to the mind is an image of your mother. Now this image image is a bare bones image of your mother. It eliminates all of these salient and uncommon features. This is known as a meaning generality. Meaning generalities are accurate.

I mean, conceptual minds are accurate. All of modern science is built on conceptuality. Mathematics is pure conceptuality. Conceptuality does lead to results. But even though it does lead to results, conceptual minds are set to be mistaken because these are minds to which my mother with the constant state of impermanence which characterizes her, appears in the light of a meaning generality, which has eliminated all of we’re own to features of whatever they represent.

And When so we realize interdependence with an inferential valid cognizer, this is how we realize it initially. We realize it through a meaning generality, which has the global meaning interdependence, but eliminates all the specificities. And then through meditation, to again and again meditating on the reasonings which lead to an understanding of interdependence, this meaning generality progressively weakens until eventually we get naked direct perception of interdependence. This is a goal. This is a goal, and you can see that it is a long process.

We move up from wrong views, to doubt, to conviction, to an inferential valid cognizer, to a direct valid cognizer. There is no other way to go about it. For us at present, the most important thing is to move from wrong views up to doubt. That is a big thing. Big thing.

And then if we are lucky, we can generate a conviction. A conviction might change your life because it is a mind which will no longer fall back. Someone who has a conviction in the existence of past and future lives and of common causality sells everything he has, goes forth, and becomes ordained. If you don’t have a conviction, you do not not do that. Then when one moves up to an inferential valid cognizer, one can explain to others.

One can say, one can give reasonings. And, obviously, one would have to have direct perception to find the reasonings most appropriate for another person. Finally, direct valid cognition. If one gains direct valid cognition of emptiness, one is at that point an ārya being. One has entered the path of seeing.

So how precisely does one move from an inferential cognizer which is conceptual to a direct valid cognizer which is non conceptual. There’s a marvelous passage in one of the Sūtra, the Sūtra, which I would like to quote to you. For for instance, instance, two trees are dragged against each other by the wind and from that a fire starts burning the two trees. The sort of same way, Kāśyapa, if you have correct analytical discrimination, the power of an Ārya’s wisdom will emerge. When it emerges, correct and ethical discrimination will itself be burned up.

So conceptual minds are rafts. They are bridges, which lead us to the goal. They have to be abandoned once we reach a goal. But there is no attaining the goal without these conceptual minds, specifically without conviction and inferential valid cognizers. Then moving onwards in Tsongkhapa’s three principles of the path.

The following stanza is the manner in which the view dawns. Whoever sees that all the the causality of all phenomena of cyclic existence and nirvana is never deceitful and has destroyed the targeted object has entered the path which pleases the Buddhas. This stanza refers to a Bodhisattva on the following path, the path of preparation. Bodhisattva has left the path of accumulation. During the path of preparation, he’s meditating on emptiness and interdependence using inferential valid cognizers.

He gains during this path conceptual realization of emptiness. And to the very end of this path that he gains for the first time, a direct valid cognizer which realizes emptiness and becomes an aria being. And in this stanza, the actual syllogism, which is perhaps the foremost means actual reasoning, which is a foremost means to meditate on emptiness is taught, the so called royal syllogism. The subject in this stanza, all phenomena of cyclic existence and nirvana, in other words, everything. cyclic existence and nirvana is non truly existent because it is interdependent.

Now the root of this royal syllogism that perhaps we’ll write out for you. I will just write all phenomena. What is implicit here is all phenomena of cyclic existence and. The subject all phenomena are non inherently existent. Because they are interdependent.

In this syllogism, syllogism is just a reasoning. This is the subject. This is the predicate, which is what we are trying to prove. And this is the reason which is reduced to prove the predicate. We use syllogisms because we are trying to give rise to inferential valid cognizers.

If we were not trying to give rise to inferential cognizers, we would not use syllogisms. But a reason is syllogism is much more powerful to transform the mind than the mere conviction. Transformation is much more durable and in-depth. Therefore, we follow this path, which is a path of reasoning. And this royal syllogism is basically rooted in a famous passage of Nāgārjuna’s root verses on Madhyamaka.

The Madhyamaka karika, chapter 24 on the four noble truths verses eighteen and nineteen. That which arises dependently, we explain as emptiness. This emptiness is dependent designation. This is the middle way. Because there are no phenomena that are not dependent arising, arisings.

There are no phenomena that are not empty. So the crux of Tsongkhapa’s interpretation of Madhyamaka is to read the totality of Madhya Mika scriptures in the light of these two stanzas, stanzas eighteen and nineteen of chapter 24 of Nāgārjuna’s root verses. Now here in this syllogism, which is known as a royal syllogism because it eliminates the risks in reflecting on emptiness, which we talked about previously, the foremost risk being a nihilism, through analyzing and meditating on the syllogism, simultaneously one eliminates both extremes, the extreme of eternalism and the extreme of nihilism. Thought is a middle road. It’s a middle road between two extremes.

By ex the extreme of eternalism, we mean the assertion that everything exists in an unchanging fashion. Everything actually exists inherently from its own side. By the extreme of nihilism, we mean that nothing exists at all. There is a middle ground between these two extremes. And what that middle ground is has been a source of great discussion among Buddhist philosophers.

But here we will present it in terms of what is considered the highest school, the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school. So here, in keeping with this syllogism, the subject or phenomena, everything which is, which exists, are noninherently existent. The assertion that phenomena are noninherently existent eliminates the extreme of eternalism. It eliminates the extreme of eternalism because it asserts that phenomena do not exist inherently. They do exist, but they do not exist from their own side without depending at all on causes and conditions on their thoughts on the process of mental imputation.

Therefore, the predicate of the syllogism eliminates the extreme of eternalism. The reason of the syllogism eliminates the extreme of Because when we assert that phenomena interdependent, we assert that they exist. Otherwise, they would not be interdependent. Therefore, through analyzing and meditating on the syllogism, we can eventually eliminate simultaneously both extremes. By the reason, we eliminate the extreme of nihilism.

By the predicate, we eliminate the extreme of eternalism. Now I can see you’re looking a bit bewildered, so I won’t enter into too much detail here. Suffice it to say that when we meditate on this, the way we would meditate upon it is we would analyze it in terms of the so called three characteristics of a syllogism. The three characteristics of a syllogism are what makes a syllogism valid. When we say the subject or phenomena are non inherently existent because they are interdependent.

For this syllogism to be valid, the subject must be present in the reason. In other words, all phenomena must be interdependent. This is the first character of the syllogism. The second character of the syllogism is that everything which is interdependent, in other words, everything which is a reason, must be noninherently existent. This is the forward pervasion.

And the third characteristic of the syllogism is a counter provision. In other words, everything which is not the predicate cannot be the reason. Everything which is inherently existent is independent. Independent. Now when we meditate on the royal syllogism, this is how we would meditate upon it.

We’d first meditate on the syllogism in general, then we would meditate on the fact that all phenomena are interdependent. Analyzing this, trying to give rise to an inferential valid cognition which realizes this. Then we would meditate upon the fact that everything which is interdependent is necessarily empty of inherent existence. And then switch and meditate on the fact that everything which is inherently existent is necessarily independent. And since there’s no such thing as independent phenomena, there’s no such thing as inherently existing phenomena.

And in this way, eventually, what will happen is that having given rise to a direct valid cognition that all phenomena are interdependent with interdependence having the three meanings we talked about, causal, compositional, and imputational. Independence in dependence on on that that direct realization, an inferential valid cognizer realizing all phenomena are non inherently existent or empty of inherent existence will arise. When that has arisen, then we have realized emptiness conceptually. And then we will familiarize with this again and again and again until progressively the direct of emptiness dawns in the mind. So fundamentally, to make a somewhat simpler presentation, if we were to try to meditate meditate in the light of on emptiness, how do phenomena exist?

We said phenomena exist as interdependent phenomenon. We gave three main characteristics of interdependent phenomenon. How do they appear to us? They appear as inherently existent. How do they exist?

They exist as mere appearances. So what we have is a situation where from the standpoint of appearance, we have a mixture. The standpoint of appearance, let’s say let’s say if I look at Chris, my eye consciousness perceiving Chris, perceiving the body of Chris, perceives a mixture of two things. A mixture of the mere appearance of Chris’s body and of the appearance of Chris’s body as inherently existent. The two are mixed, totally mixed.

We cannot make a difference between them. And this was a source of tremendous problems in Tibet because in Tibet, when Prasanika was introduced in the tenth century by Patsap, the reasonings were used to negate not just phenomena’s appearance as inherent existence, but all appear

And therefore to negate conventional phenomena in general, then the very foundation of the path collapsed. Because the yogis were not able to distinguish between appearance as inherently existent and mere appearance. Inherent existence does not exist. Appearance as inherently existence, Here is a wrong view. It’s a wrong form of appearance.

Mere appearance, however, is the mode of existence of phenomena conventionally. So how does one go about separating them in meditation? They are a little bit like an emulsion. Many of you have a scientific background, so you know the difference between a solution and an emulsion. A solution, let’s say if you put salt in the water, salt separates into sodium and chloride ions.

And, basically, the ions subsist separately unless, let’s say, you reduce the temperature of the water, the salt precipitates. But if you take two liquids which cannot be mixed like oil and water, if you put oil and water, oil floats on top of the water. Right? It doesn’t mix. But if you were to take put it in a blender and blend it really at high speed, you can get with certain oils and emulsion, which is actually the presence of tiny tiny drops of oil within water.

You cannot see this to the eye, which all is the beauty products, generally emulsions, salted sauces, or emulsions. Right? So it looks like one substance. It’s one paste. But actually, inside, you have two radically different things.

You have oil and water. You can separate the components of an emulsion by centrifugation. If you put your beauty product, if it’s a shame to do this with expensive ones, but imagine, this is what Buddhist scholars do. They buy expensive Buddhist products. They centrifuge them.

You put your beauty product in the centrifuge. You will separate what seemed to be completely completely inseparable. Inseparable. And you will have one layer of oil, one ester, and one layer of some fluid. It might be water or alcohol, whatever.

This is exactly what we do with meditation to separate mere appearance and appearance as inherently existent so that we can negate the appearance of phenomena as inherently existent without negating mere two, mere appearance and appearance as inherently established, and they form a whole. If we negate what appears to the mind without doing anything, we just negate this block, we will have negated mere appearance. And there will be no foundation left one thing that can do appearance as inherent establishment or maintaining mere that. Appearance. The way we do this is that we allow the appearance of phenomena as inherently established to become very powerful.

And when it becomes very powerful under the power of great emotion within our minds, then we negate it because it is evident. We can see it. We can at last see the target. Therefore, when one is actually meditating on emptiness, one allows negative emotions to dawn in the mind, one allows strong desire, strong anger, actually the stronger the better. Because when strong desire arises or strong anger arises, then the object’s appearance as inherently established as existing from its own side becomes very powerful.

The mere established appearance has not changed. Then we can target the object’s appearance as inherently established using the Madhya Mika reasonings and eliminate it without touching the near appearance. If we go about it in any other way, we eliminate conventional reality. So for this reason, one first has to identify the object of negation. And this is the crux, I would say, of presentation of Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka.

At the time, the object of negation in Tibet was not clearly identified. Then the Madhyamaka reasonings are so powerful that if applied at random, they destroy everything. And one ends up with the extreme of nihilism very easily. Tsongkhapa says himself, if you do not identify the object of of negation negation, you will succumb to the extreme of nihilism. So how do we identify the object of negation?

Through reasoning first, we talked about it a bit. And then experientially, through allowing these very powerful objects and emotions to arise in our mind, and then identifying the appearance of the object of desire or the object of hatred. Sorry, Chris. I have neither for you. You’re a good friend.

As the object of negation. And then at this point, the rest of the process is very easy. Because if an object exists inherently from its own side, then in the case of a person in my let’s say my own case, if I exist inherently independently of anything else from my own side, then there’s only two possibilities. If this inherently I existing I of ILA exists, it is either one or it’s different with my components, my aggregates. My aggregates are my body, the form aggregate, and then the four mental aggregates.

If I am one with my aggregates, if my inherently existing I is one with the five aggregates, then it becomes multiple. It becomes fivefold. Or alternatively, the five aggregates become one. Those are the two logical possibilities because to be inherently one needs to be exactly identical. On the other hand, if the inherently existing ilea is different from the aggregates.

Then you have the five aggregates and then you have an ileus somewhere apart from them. And I’ve lived with myself a long time. I can vouch for the fact he isn’t there. It would be as if there were some sort of owner separate of the body in the mind, but you’d have to connect with him, wouldn’t you? So this line of reasoning, the fourfold line of reasoning is extremely powerful once the object of refutation has been clearly identified.

To apply it before that point is an extraordinary dangerous process. So we identify clearly the object of refutation through reasoning first, and then empirically, as we mentioned, allowing powerful emotions to arise and seeing, for instance, how the object of the powerful emotions appears. Then we reflect that if phenomena, let’s say, a person is inherently existing, it can only be inherently one or inherently other with its parts. We must generate certainty about this. This called the certainty of the provision.

That’s the second most difficult point. And then the two remaining points are easy. If he he or she is inherently one with his components, then either he becomes multiple or the multiplicity of the components becomes one. If he or she is inherently different, then you have to be able to point at he or she other than that. You cannot.

And at that point, you meditate on the unfindability of this inherently existing eye. Then it is very powerful for the mind because then you can give rise to an inferential valid cognizer on the basis of a valid reason. Then the moment that slacks and you you lose the object of negation, you don’t sit meditating on some sort of an absence, which is of no benefit whatsoever. Once again, you cause your inherently existing eye or, you know, strong emotion to rise towards a friend and enemy, whatever. And you go through the whole process again.

How does it appear? If it exists as an inherently existing eye or if Chris exists as an inherently existing Chris, he is either one or different with his aggregates necessary. Those are the only two possibilities. Then if he is one, what are the consequences? If he’s different, what are the consequences?

Neither is valid. Then that inherent does not exist. When that sense arises, you stop analyzing. Once again, you meditate single pointedly. This is how one meditates the selflessness of persons.

And then we are going a little bit over time. So I am going to skip quite a bit of material and pass on directly directly to the following stances. For as long as a two fold understanding of appearances as nondeceit ful interdependence and assertionless emptiness appear separate for so long as a thought of the sage not being realized. So for practitioners who have realized emptiness directly. It is not possible until they are fully enlightened to realize simultaneously conventional and ultimate truths.

In other words, it is not possible to realize at the same time with the same mind that phenomena are interdependent and that they are empty of inherent existence. You can realize both in sequence, but you cannot realize them at the same time with the same mind. And therefore, Je Tsongkhapa says, for this reason, the thought of the sage has not been realized. In other words, the goal of the fully united being the Buddha, which is to lead beings to full enlightenment has not been accomplished. Eventually, moving onwards with the three principles of the path, if they are no longer positive separately, but simultaneously, in other words, if one mind can simultaneously realize the predicate and reason of the syllogism which runs the blackboard, which is the interdependence of phenomena and phenomena’s lack of inherent existence.

At that point, analysis of the view has been led to fruition. In other words, at that point, one has reached the state of full enlightenment, the path of no more learning. And then moving onwards with our text, moreover, when appearance dispels the extreme of existence existence and emptiness dispels the extreme of nonexistence and emptiness is understood in the manner of the dawning as causality, one will no longer be ravaged by the view of the extremes. So as you remembered, when we put the royal syllogism on the blackboard, we said the subject, all phenomena of saṃsāra nirvana, lack inherent existence predicate because they are interdependent. And we said that the reason because they are interdependent eliminates the extreme of nihilism.

Whereas the predicate lack inherent existence eliminates the extreme of eternalism. This is the common Madhyamaka position which shared by both the Svatāntrika and the Prāsaṇgika school. The uncommon Prāsaṇgika assertion is that actually interdependence eliminates not only the extreme of nihilism, but also the extreme of eternalism. It eliminates also the extreme of eternalism because if phenomena are interdependent, self evidently, they cannot be independent. Therefore, they cannot be inherently existing in the sense of the extreme of eternalism.

And then the predicate lack of inherent existence from the standpoint of the common assertion of Madhyamaka, as we said, eliminates the extreme of eternalism. However, lack of inherent existence also eliminates the extreme of nihilism. For the very simple reason that when we say that phenomena lack inherent existence, we are qualifying existence by lack of inherent existence. The mere fact of qualifying existence by lack of inherent existence implies implicitly the assertion of existence. Therefore, as a very great Tibetan practitioner, said, in the royal syllogism, both the predicate lack inherent existence and the reason because it is interdependent negate simultaneously both extremes.

One explicitly, the other implicitly. So this is why Khensur Rinpoche in his teachings on the three principles of the path and in his teachings on bodhicitta Vivarana focused exclusively on the Royal syllogism and not on Candrakīrti’s sevenfold analysis of a chariot and its components from which the Royal syllogism derives, but which is much more open to misunderstanding. So meditating of the world syllogism, it is almost impossible to fall into the extreme of nihilism, which is a main threat in our practice. So if there’s any risk of falling in the extreme of nihilism, then it is preferable not to study the view. Because the extremes of nihilism and the extreme of eternalism are not symmetrical in terms of their results.

I have Nāgārjuna says in the Ratnāvali that it is preferable to fall fall in the extreme of eternalism than in the extreme of nihilism. Because on the basis of the extreme of eternalism, it is still possible to formulate common causality. Therefore, ethics is not destroyed. And then finally, Tsongkhapa’s testament as it were his final instructions to are instructions on the necessity of solitary practice. Upon having realized the essence of such three principles of the path, dwell as a hermit or child and having generated the force of enthusiasm, swiftly attain your permanent goal.

So here, as Rinpoche magnificently pointed out, there there are two forms of anachorism. There is exterior hermitism and interior hermitism. Exterior hermitism is living in aesthetic conditions on a mountainside in a very romantic setting, but that in no way guarantees that one’s mind is a hermit. If one’s living in a mountain cave and one’s mind is in the cosmopolitan city of city of Adelaide, then nothing has been accomplished. But if one lives in this cosmopolitan city of Adelaide and one’s mind is on a mountain cliff, then one is truly a hermit.

So this is a meaning of this verse. And attaining one’s permanent goal is evidently attaining the state of full enlightenment, the state in which one is endowed with the four bodies. The wisdom dharmakaya, the nature dharmakaya, the sambhogakaya, and the nirmanakaya. Then in conclusion, how should one practice on the basis of these three principles of the path? One should flash the three principles of the path out with the eight Lam Rims.

There are broadly speaking eight Lam Rim treatises, which present the totality of the path from the standpoint of the Pāramitāyāna. It lead us up to the gateway of Tantric practice. These include first and foremost foundational work, which is said to have read last time I heard him say this 73 times. Then the middling Lam Rim in which gives an alternate presentation of the view. And then, song of realization, which is quite short, which many of us could even memorize if we wanted to, which encapsulates the totality of the view.

in dependence on this series of commentary treatises have arisen. The third Dalai Lama’s essence of refined gold. Then the fifth Dalai Lama’s from the mouth of Manjushin, which is actually a commentary on the third Dalai Lama’s essence of refined gold. The Pänchen Lama’s swift path and the first Pänchen Lama’s easy path. And there is a debate about the eighth Lam Rim.

So some say that the eighth Lam Rim treatise is the essence of nectar, Abhishiktananda, which was taught here at TBI. Some say it is Dakpo Rinpoche’s Lam Rim. Dakpo Rinpoche was a teacher of Khedrub Je Maṅkha Rinpoche. The lineage of that Lam Rim is exceptionally rare. Many say, and that’s my private opinion, that it is which is liberation in the palm of your hand.

In the way one would practice civil order to have a complete

Practice is that one would practice all of the eight in conjunction. Focusing mainly on the view aspect of the path on and complementing it with the meddling and then relying for the method aspect of the path, mainly on liberation in the palm of your hands. All complementing key points of both with reasonings from the other Lamrims, the third Dalai Lama, the fifth Dalai Lama, and the two Pänchen Lamas. Then in this way, drawing on each of the reasons which is of benefit to one’s own mind and leaving the others aside, we’ll be able to progress very swiftly. Alternatively, if one is unable to rely on the totality of the eight Lamrim treatises, one can just rely on one depending on one’s capacity.

The best is Lam Rim Chenmo. It is said that none of the great Gelug Geshes ever went anywhere without a copy of Lam Rim Chenmo. Then if one unable to do that, the shorter one, liberation in the palm of one’s hand is quite accessible. And then the easiest of all is the easy path by the first. So we have finished the presentation of these three principles of the path.

And I would like to conclude with a quote from which I think which I think is magnificent because it is a barometer of our practice. You have reached a crucial point when we’re meditating on the lower levels, you increasingly wish to attain the higher levels. And when studying the higher levels, your wish to practice the lower levels becomes stronger and stronger. Lam Rim is the foundation of our practice practice. Any authentic practice is rooted again and again in the foundations.

So as we practice, we should check our mind and see what is weak in our practice. If we find for instance that we are practicing, let’s say, generating bodhicitta, but that we see our spiritual teacher as ordinary. And since relying on the spiritual teacher is a foundation of the path, we should return to the foundation and use the various reasonings to meditate on how to rely on the spiritual teacher. Then if we are meditating, let’s say, on advanced tantric practices, perhaps generation stage in an anuttara yoga tantra, and we find that we are attracted to this life and realizing that we may be practicing anuttara yoga tantra, but we are actually a worldly being. We should strive to meditate on the main practice of the being of small scope, death and impermanence.

And in this way, moving up and down within our practice in a function of where our mind stands, we can progressively evolve upwards. And now keeping with Khensur Rinpoche’s tradition, we will dedicate the merits of having covered together the three principles of the path to attaining the state of full enlightenment, not for our own sake, but for the sake of all mother sentient beings, progressing endlessly life after life without and with boundless enthusiasm during three countless eons traveling upwards on the path of the being of small scope, of middling scope, of great scope, entering the Mahāyāna, then traveling for one countless eon on on the path of accumulation and preparation, meditating conceptually on the selflessness of persons and the selflessness of phenomena until we give rise to an inferential valid cognizer, realizing both. And in dependence on repeated familiarization with this inferential valid cognizer giving rise at the very last instant of the supreme path of preparation. To a direct valid cognizer perceiving directly both the selflessness of persons, the selflessness of phenomena. And then traveling upwards during one countless eon through all seven grounds from the first to the seventh ground, familiar familiarizing ourselves evermore with both the selflessness of persons and the selflessness of phenomena until all the afflictive obstructions are eliminated at the last instant of the seventh ground.

And then for one countless eon traveling through the eighth, ninth, and tenth ground eliminating the obstructions omniscience through further familiarization with both the selflessness of persons in a phenomena until at the last instant of the tenth ground, we give rise to the omniscient mind which can work endlessly and eternally for the benefit of all conscious beings. Thank you very much. I’m sorry to have gone a bit overtime. And if you have the courage to ask questions, from my side, I will do my best to answer. Yes.

Nothing is wrong. That’s right. Horn of the hair is formally correct and in actuality. The form of the hair, the horn of the hair is a nonexistent phenomenon. That’s right.

Nonexistent phenomenon are noninherently existing. That’s right. They’re noninherently existing because they’re interdependent. How are they interdependent? There is an interdependence between an incorrect imputation, any basis of imputation.

What is the problem with the horn of a rabbit being selfless? So what you’re talking about is genesis of inferential cognitions. Yes. Inferential cognitions, in the context we are talking about here, arise on the basis of direct valid cognizers. So you have a direct valid cognizer which realizes presence of the subject in the reason.

On the basis of that direct valid cognizer, you give rise to inferential valid cognizer, which understands the presence of the subject in the predicate. Now in the case of the horns of the rabbit, it’s open to question whether you could have a direct valid cognizer realizing the presence of the horns of the rabbit in the reason interdependence because the horns of the rabbit are nonexistent. And while the horns of the rabbit themselves are nonexistent, the horns of the rabbit being independent is not a nonexistent phenomenon. It is an existing phenomenon. As an existing phenomenon, it can be perceived by a valid cognizer.

In the same same way as for instance, inherent existence is a non non existent phenomenon. Right? Non inherent existence and negation of inherent existence is an existent phenomenon. And this is an existent phenomenon. So when we speak of the interdependence of the horns of a rabbit, it’s not the same thing as speaking of the color of the horns of a rabbit.

There’s a fundamental difference. The colors of the horns of a rabbit is nonexistent because the horns of a rabbit are nonexistent. The interdependence of the horns of a rabbit is not a nonexistent because the horns of a rabbit are interdependent. Not causally interdependent, not interdependent from a compositional standpoint, but definitely interdependent in as much as they are inscribed in the imputed imputation relationship. There is not a single phenomenon and not a single non phenomenon which is not selfless.

Everything which exists and everything which does not exist is selfless from the standpoint. Otherwise, you have to say the horns of a rabbit are inherently existent, and you don’t wanna say that. I hope. So are there other questions? Yes, Richard.

That’ll be perfectly okay. So best way to understand these terms is to go back to the Sanskrit. Inherently existing in Sanskrit is svabhāva siddhi. Sva means own. Bhava has a whole range of meanings in Sanskrit.

It comes from the verb the root which means to be, and means being or nature. Is to be established. So is established by its own nature or established by its own being. Therefore, established from its own side in and of itself independently of anything else. That’s a meaningless.

Then how it is translated in English is always a problem. Standard English translation is in here in existing, which is okay. I mean, many scholars translated as existing by its own nature. The problem is that in the Gelug tradition, the existence of a nature phenomena is not refuted. It’s the existence of the inherent nature phenomena which is refuted.

So if you translate as established by its own nature, you run into trouble because people think that you’re refuting the nature of phenomena, which is not refuted. What’s what you’re actually refuting is this nature would exist in and of itself. For instance, you take fire. The nature of fire is to burn. That’s a function of fire.

That’s not refuted. What is refuted is that fire exists in and of itself without depending on kindling on matches on a previous instant of a fire. That is what is refuted. Inherent existence would be that sort of existence. That is what is meant by.

Then is interdependent. The key here is to understand means to arise. Some means to arise with. Now the Tibetan does not translate as such. It makes a gloss of it.

It translates it as I just write it out in phonetics. 10. 10 is a basis. Means to be related to. To be related to a basis.

And that gloss really covers more the understanding of whereas a Sanskrit term really has much more of the connotation of the Sautrāntika idea of causal interdependence. Then why is it the case in the royal syllogism that phenomena are not here at the existent because of being independent. Well, if you think of this meaning of, if phenomena exist like this in and of themselves, they cannot depend on anything else. The moment they depend on something else, you have eliminated this mode of existence. Does that does that help to answer your question?

Are there other questions? Yes. Phenomena from the christianic view are not imputed. They are merely imputed. The mirror is very important.

It means there is nothing else but the imputation. All the Buddhist schools consider that, for instance, permanent phenomena imputed. Prāsaṇgika asserts that all phenomena mere imputations. Yes. Yes.

That’s a way of looking at motivation from the viewpoint. All Buddhist schools consider motivation is important even though they don’t all consider that phenomenon a mere imputations because motivation is one of the four factors which determines the karmic potency of a deed, the foremost factor. The imputation occurs can occur with or without motivation. For instance, when you impute qualities on an object of desire, you don’t have the conscious motivation to impute qualities of any type. You may be acting on the basis of karmic imprints.

So you have both categories of imputation, imputation with motivation to impute, imputation imputation without the motivation to impute. Does that answer your question? Yes. No. Because one set of values is false and the other is correct.

I mean, if you take a human body and you spread it out with the dissection table, all it takes is the knife to show that there is

One millimeter of something which is remotely attractive on top of the body, and the rest of it is absolutely disgusting. But but but it’s very natural. It’s just a of meat. Just a piece of meat. Yes.

So when you put colleagues to say that, you know, put an article to see what it really is. Unless you repeat it, it’s a. What? A sack You are, I think, conflating perhaps two different orders of meditation. In one case, one is meditating on eliminating desire to seeing the unattractiveness of the body.

Now this unattractiveness is not an artificially imposed unattractiveness. It’s the actual nature of the body. All it takes to see the nature of the body is dissection. However, clearly, ultimately, then whether one sees the body as meat or one sees the body as beautiful, in both cases, imputation has occurred. Phenomena only exist as imputations from the standpoint.

There’s nothing else we can point at. Yeah. But we cannot speak without imputation. We cannot think we cannot think without imputation. From the standpoint, we cannot perceive without imputation.

From the standpoint, nothing functions without imputation. And is it is it the nature of the life beyond concepts? Beyond language is beyond What is beyond concepts? Concepts? Is So enlightenment can be described.

Enlightenment can be known. If enlightenment could neither be described nor be known, it would be like trying to go to Singapore and not having a clue what Singapore is, where Singapore is, and so forth. On the other hand, the experience of enlightenment that we cannot describe. There’s a lot of Buddhist literature which unfortunately is very misleading and which relies on statements you do find on the inevitability, the unspeakability of certain experiences. What this means is that clearly someone who has direct experience of emptiness, for instance, cannot convey through words what that experience is, but can most definitely describe emptiness and can most definitely lead someone to emptiness.

Emptiness is conceptually apprehendable. And that repeated conceptual apprehension of emptiness leads to the realization of emptiness. From its own side, emptiness is nothing special. The inevitability of the experience, the direct experience of emptiness is the same thing as the inevitability of the experience of tasting chocolate for the first time. There’s nothing special about chocolate.

It’s just that between someone who’s never tasted chocolate and someone who’s tasted chocolate, there’s a boundary of experience. That’s all. You cannot. But that’s the only only tool we have. So if things existed inherently let’s say if Chris, for instance, then he there’s only two possibilities.

He can either be inherently one with his parts or inherently different from his parts. There’s no other possibility. Well, if we see that Chris is inherently one with his parts, we’re saying there’s absolutely no difference at all between him and his parts, which means Chris is multiple. He’s not one. He’s five fold.

He has five aggregates or he has whatever 15,000,000,000 cells, he’s 15,000,000,000 fold. And if he is separate from his parts, then we have to take Chris’s body, Chris’s emotions, Chris’s discrimination, Chris’s consciousness, put all that aside and find something we can point out and say, after all that is put aside, that there is Chris, that there is unchanging. This is actually when we speak of that, we’re speaking of the Christian vision of the soul. This is actually Christian vision of the soul. You find this in Hinduism also.

You know? Well, he is if you were to say that the mere Chris is an imputation on Chris’s parts, that would be perfectly correct. There was a name Chris, the conception Chris. It’s just a label, an imputation, a fixed on Chris’s cells, Chris’s atoms, Chris’s instance of consciousness. That’s perfectly true.

And that Chris is accepted. Accepted. That is a conventionally existing Chris, the mere appearance of Chris. But if you were to say that Chris exists independently on the basis of his parts, That is not possible. Now when I have not seen Chris for a long time and I see Chris again after a long time, my heart is filled with euphoria.

And I say, Chris, and suddenly there is a Chris there which exists apart from everything else that is refuted. That is refuted. Oh, one of the, I think, greatest insights of Tsongkhapa was that to meditate correctly on emptiness, we must understand the process of generation of ignorance. We must understand how ignorance imputes force, qualities, or defects on phenomena. And then when we understand that, we can begin to understand how to meditate on the elimination of that.

So first, we should study ignorance. Are there other questions?

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top