TBI Recordings

2 h 22 min · 11,888 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Other recordings (Ilia Durovic)
Other recordings (Ilia Durovic)
TBI Recordings
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 142-minute seminar, Buddhist scholar Ilia Durovic explores the fundamental philosophical divide between Western monotheistic traditions and Buddhism, using it as a lens to examine faith and reason within Buddhist practice. He traces how the Western philosophical tradition chose permanence over impermanence in the sixth century BC—a choice embodied in Parmenides against Heraclitus—and contrasts this with the Buddhist embrace of transience, illustrated through passages from the medieval Japanese hermit Kamo no Chomei. Durovic then introduces Buddhist phenomenology and epistemology: how Buddhists categorize phenomena as manifest, hidden, or extremely hidden based on the mind perceiving them, and why reason rather than faith forms the foundation of Buddhist practice. The second half focuses on subtle impermanence—the instant-to-instant transience of all phenomena—walking through the epistemological hierarchy from wrong consciousness through doubt and conviction to valid cognition. The talk concludes with guided analytical and concentrative meditation on the eighteen constituents, examining how everything perceived through the senses is in constant flux. Pitched at Western practitioners bringing monotheistic assumptions to Buddhism.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Ilia Faith and Doubt.mp3

UUID: 2bbd5f4d-f0d9-4782-aa1d-a9211b3d25e3

Teacher: Ilia S. Durovic

Collection: Ilia Seminars

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~11,889

Thank you very much. I’m always very embarrassed when Chris reads these things, and I think it refers to someone I’m not terribly well acquainted with. So this is the the last talk we could have in this series of talks. And, the topic I have chosen here is one which is actually a topic which concerns Westerners more than it really concerns Buddhists. There is a time honored opposition in Western religions between faith on the one side and reason on the other side, reason which is allied with doubt.

It is something which is very characteristic of Western religiosity and beyond Western religiosity of all of these so called monotheistic traditions. The traditions which teach that one unique god has revealed himself in history for the sake of creation. This is Judaism, Islam, and Christianity. And that his revelation occurs within the context of a text, a book, which is the Old Testament for the Jews, the Old Testament and the New Testament for the Christians, the Old Testament, the New Testament, and the Koran for the Muslims. Buddhism stands perhaps more at odds with that entire stream of religious tradition than any other world religion.

And for this reason, I would like to enter with you first into an attempt to understand the relation between faith and reason in Western civilization as a premise to trying to understand the relation between faith and reason within Buddhism. And then we will take one particular topic of investigation within Buddhism, which we had broached last time. We had talked about impermanence last time, coarse impermanence, in other words, the presence of death within every one of our lives, and we had an experiential presentation of this. Today, we are going to enter into the presentation of what is called subtle impermanence, which is the instant to instant transience of phenomena. And the second part of this talk’s conference will be dedicated to trying to meditate together on subtle impermanence.

We will do it in a much more analytical way than the previous meditations. So to start with, there is a reason for which, even in, a Buddhist Studies Institute, it is necessary to present the context, the Western context of the relationship between faith and reason because perhaps in this room with one or two exceptions, every one of us is a Westerner. We bring our culture with us. All the more so when we take the momentous decision of converting to another religion. It is very important for us to be aware of what we bring with us.

And with the demise of classical studies and religious studies, it can no longer be taken for granted that students who come to a center are aware of their own culture. Then the bias is completely unstated, and it does come through very powerfully. So I would like first to present the context within which the opposition of faith and reason was formulated in the West. Generally speaking, the traditional presentations of Western history view Western history as the history of Greco Roman philosophy leading to some some sort of a synthesis of Hellenistic and Semitic thought around the second to third century of our era. Synthesis which is then put in question at the time of the scholastic reappraisal of the Christian heritage and even more so at the time of the Renaissance and the reformation.

We are the products of this. My personal feeling with this presentation is that it is perhaps an overly simplistic one. It presupposes the existence of a continuum which extends from the early pre socratic philosophers through Plato and Aristotle all the way up to the early twenty first century. And it ignores the fundamental rupture in Western history, which occurred basically between the fall of the late Roman Empire and the beginning of the high middle ages as we know them. This rupture means that there was a rupture in the transmission of reason in Western society.

And we cannot say casually without investigating it that we have inherited the entire analytical rational mindset of our Greek forefathers since the root of the West can be said to to lie in Greece. So it is important for us to try to understand this rupture and to understand before it a moment, which is a critical moment at which the West chooses an orientation which is radically different from that of much of India and radically different of that which Buddhism has espoused. This moment is far out in history. It is set sometime between the sixth and the fifth century BC. And it is presented by the great German philosopher Heidegger in terms of the opposition between two so called pre Socratic, in other words, thinkers before Socrates, pre Socratic thinkers, Heraclitus and Parmenides.

The choice which was made at that point twenty six centuries ago is one which we have carried with us ever since. The core teachings of Heraclitus are the teachings of the fundamental impermanence and transience of all phenomena. All phenomena according to Heraclitus are in a constant state of flux and motion. Heraklitus famously said, all change changes, and used the example of the river which flows and in whose waters one never bathes in the same way two times. In contradistinction to Heraclitus, the other pillar of presocratic philosophy, Parmenides, of whom we are the inheritors, affirms that underlying all phenomena is a permanent being, and this permanent being is what one should strive to understand and to discover.

Now this underlies much of Platonic philosophy. It is present in filigree in Aristotle, and it is also present in the reintegration of Greek philosophy within the context context of Christianity. The this is what we have inherited. So at this one point in the sixth century BC, western civilization made a choice, and this choice is with us today. It made the choice of permanence against impermanence.

It made it the choice of being against the radical critique of being one actually finds in some of the eastern philosophies and specifically Buddhism. And I would like to read to you a small passage from a Japanese hermit, Kamo no Chomei, who had a big influence on me when I was a very young boy. I discovered by accident his his work. It’s called the 10 foot square hut. Kamono Chome, who lived basically at the end of the twelfth and the early of the thirteenth century, lived at a critical period in Japanese history where all Japanese society was collapsing.

And he took refuge in the mountains above Kyoto and built a small reed and bamboo hut, which came for him to symbolize the impermanence and the transience of the entire world he lived in. Now, Kamo no Chomei’s sensitivity in the thirteenth century is identical to that of Heraklitus in the sixth century BC. And that is what is so striking and I would like to point out here with two exquisite passages. The first is the very first passage in Kamo no Chomei’s record of the 10 foot square hut, and it’s quite extraordinary, The river flows on unceasingly, but the water is never the same as before.

Bubbles that bob on the surface of the still places disappear one moment to reappear again the next, but they seldom endure for long. And so it is with the people of this world and with the houses they live in. So you can see here that at the very beginning of Kamo no Chomei’s work, there is an unambiguous endorsement of what we could call quite directly the Heraclitean vision of transience. The Heraclitean vision of transience as far as transience and impermanence are concerned is identical to the Buddhist one. And just one page further, one dies in the morning, another is born at evening.

They come and go like froth on the water. These persons who are born and die, no one knows where they come from or where they go. And these dwellings of a moment, no one knows why their owners fret their minds so over them or are so anxious to make them pleasing to the eye. For both owner and dwelling are doomed to impermanence, no different from the dew or the morning glory. This vision of impermanence is the inner core of the Buddhist teachings.

It is an inner core which was taught by the Buddha himself twenty five centuries ago in India, in Magadha, and there was a brief connection with this inner core in sixth century BC Greece, a connection which was never actualized after. But it is actually something which is part of Western philosophical history. And then I would like, since we are trying to set a context here, and I apologize in advance this conference will be a little bit more difficult than the other ones, but from time to time, one has to put some extra effort. I would like basically to contrast here before we move on to a specific presentation of Buddhist phenomenology. The differences between monotheistic phenomenologies on the one hand and Buddhist phenomenologies on the other hand because they lead us directly to the crux of this conference, which is a respective place of faith and reason in monotheistic traditions on the one side and in Buddhism on the other side.

To really try to summarize things, we could say that in all three monotheistic traditions, Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, cosmology is constitutive of ontology. It is the account of the creation of the world, which in turn builds the science of being. This is a case because it is the fundamental being which the monotheisms consider to be god, which is the source of the physical universe. So this direct connection between cosmology and ontology means that in the monotheistic traditions, epistemology, in other words, the study of mind itself is secondary. In the Buddhist tradition, the mutual relationship is totally different.

Cosmology is secondary. We might even say insignificant. Phenomenology and epistemology constitute themselves in a mutual relationship.

There is really preeminence in the Buddhist concept, in the Buddhist context given to epistemology, to the way the mind perceives phenomenon. And the core interrogation in all the Buddhist traditions is whether this mode of perception of phenomena is compatible or incompatible with reality as it is assessed by reason. So we can see already here a fundamental difference between the monotheisms and Buddhism, which is an atheistic tradition. For the monotheisms, the fundamental object of knowledge is God who transcends reason. The modalities of his transcendence of reason depends on the various schools of thought.

Broadly speaking, the monotheisms with an Aristotelian inclination, whether it is a tradition of in Islam or Aquinas in Christianity, assert that it is possible to access partially to the divine through what is known as analogy. In other words, in as much as cosmologically, the world is created by God. It is to a degree a reflection of God. Therefore, the ordinary attributes within the world by analogy hint at the divine. This, for the Aristotelian monotheistic traditions, is a gateway which leads to perhaps not an understanding, but an approach to the divine.

These are the so called cataphatic traditions, which we talked about last year. Another whole group of monotheistic traditions, these are called apophatic traditions, consider that the main feature of the divine is radical transcendence, and therefore that the divine can only be expressed through negation, the via negativa. In every single case, whether monotheisms are cataphatic or apophatic, all monotheisms consider that the source of meaning for the physical universe lies beyond human reasoning. Hence, any connection which can be established with that fundamental source of meaning can only occur through faith. And this is at the source of the radical opposition set in all of the societies which have inherited monotheistic religious cultures between faith and reason.

Phenomenologically, the Buddhist perspective is radically different. Whereas in the monotheistic traditions, the core phenomenon of investigation lies beyond the scope of the reason of any created phenomenon or or creature. And what can be understood by reason is secondary at best is derivative. In all of the Buddhist traditions, the fundamental object of understanding can fully be encompassed by human reason. So the relative place of reason and faith in the monotheistic traditions on the one hand and in Buddhism on the other hand are radically different.

Tsongkhapa said famously in his Essence of Eloquence. A being who asserts tenets in opposition to logic cannot be said to be a being which is a valid cognizer. A being which is a valid cognizer is the fundamental source of teachings and of wisdom within the Buddhist tradition. So in this quote quote very clearly, Tsongkhapa indicates the preeminence of reason from a Buddhist standpoint. Therefore, if we were to try to divide phenomena and to present Buddhist phenomenology in a more structured way, we can say that phenomena are divided into three categories.

The first are so called manifest phenomena. The second are hidden phenomena, and the third are known as extremely hidden phenomena. All phenomena fall into one of these three categories. In other words, everything which exists is either a manifest phenomenon, a hidden phenomenon, or an extremely hidden phenomenon. They are defined in terms of the minds which perceive them.

So we see very clearly here the Buddhist, the systematic Buddhist emphasis on epistemology. It is the qualities of the mind perceiving a phenomenon which define first the qualities of this phenomenon and then the category within which the phenomenon falls. Manifest phenomena are all the phenomena which can be perceived by sense consciousnesses. So the eye sense consciousness, ear, nose, tongue, and bodily sense consciousness. All material phenomena without exception fall in the category of manifest phenomena.

These are sensorily sensorily evident phenomena. Hidden phenomena are phenomena which are said to be hidden simply because they are not perceivable through the senses of ordinary beings. These are phenomena which can be understood through what is called an inferential valid cognizer. In other words, a mind which relies on a pure reason through logic. This is the most important category of phenomena from a Buddhist standpoint since all the phenomena whose realization is necessary to the attainment of any level of the path leading all the way to full enlightenment are included within the second category of phenomena.

So coarse impermanence, subtle impermanence, the various selflessnesses, the selflessness of persons, of phenomena, coarse and subtle selflessness, everything which is necessary to progress upwards on the path is included within the category of hidden phenomena. From a Buddhist standpoint, especially from the standpoint of the Mahāyāna schools, the Buddha is omniscient. The omniscience of the Buddha, his all knowingness, is a hidden phenomenon. In other words, it is accessible to reasoning. It is, however, not from a Buddhist standpoint one of the main objects of meditation.

It is at best the secondary object of meditation. The main objects of meditation are those objects of meditation such as coarse impermanence, which we meditated upon last time, subtle impermanence, and the selflessnesses, which enable oneself to attain the level of omniscience. Finally, extremely hidden phenomena are a small minority of phenomena which cannot be understood through reasoning alone. And these specifically refer to subtle causality, not the karmic connection between phenomena in general, not the fact that for instance, the practice of virtue happiness will be experienced, and to the practice of non virtue unhappiness will be experienced. That actually can be understood through reasoning alone through analysis.

But extremely hidden phenomena refer for instance to the fact that one very specific deed in one specific life will cause a very specific result many lives after. This is an extremely hidden phenomenon. These can only be understood through the omniscient mind of the Buddha, and therefore, ordinary beings have access to them only by relying on the Buddha’s teachings. So you can see with this presentation of the Buddhist division of phenomena that we are in a radically different world from the world of the monotheism. And it is very important for us to be aware of this since I personally suspect that most westerners bring to Buddhism a strong monotheistic inclination.

It is part of our heritage. This monotheistic inclination means that we tend to rely very strongly on a faith based approach to the teachings, which is actually something which is at the highest level not fundamentally in accord with the Buddhist teachings. The Buddhist teachings fundamentally rely on reasoning. And hence, most obviously, the Buddhist path is not an easy path. And at present, I would like to ask you to pass on to, one of the charts which is handed out, which gives the epistemological hierarchy within Buddhism.

So as we said, basically, from a Buddhist standpoint, it is the mind and the modalities of the mind which ground phenomena and the modalities of phenomena. Therefore, the understanding of mind is always preeminent from a Buddhist perspective. We could say if we compare Buddhism with the western traditions that the Buddhist approach is much more inner oriented, and the western approaches have always been much more interested in the mode of functioning, the mode of existence of outer phenomena. And since phenomena are grounded in the mind, then it is extremely important from a Buddhist standpoint to understand the various types of mind. And specifically, to understand the various types of mind which can be generated with respect to hidden phenomena of which the foremost is emptiness, which is the main topic of meditation in Buddhism.

So we will not talk about emptiness today because the topic is really perhaps a bit difficult. But having talked about coarse impermanence, I think we can move up to subtle impermanence. And subtle impermanence is something akin to the gateway to emptiness. So once one understands subtle impermanence, it’s actually very close to an understanding of emptiness. And the key here is to understand what Buddhists mean when they speak of understanding subtle impermanence.

Buddha Śākyamūni speak of the realization of subtle emptiness. Realization is a level of understanding which perhaps we don’t have any direct experience of in Western societies. It means a complete inner transformation of the person and of the world’s outlook of the person in terms of their new understanding. So if we were to take subtle impermanence, which is the fact that phenomena change instant by instant, the realization of subtle impermanence would mean that we lose any confidence we might have in the stability of phenomena. We see the world at all levels in a constant and almost in supportable state of flux, and we see ourselves in a state of flux within that state of flux.

Once our mind is completely transformed by this, it is something which not only we cannot forget or be unaware of, but it is something which radically shifts our relation to every other human being into our entire life, then we can be set to have the realization of subtle impermanence. Then most definitely, we are no longer the same person as before. And then from a Buddhist standpoint, the question which arises is how do we train our minds up to this realization, and what are the levels leading up to it? Now since subtle impermanence is a hidden phenomenon and is accessible to reasoning, it is first reflected upon, and these reflections are rooted in studies. They are also in the case of subtle impermanence rooted heavily into in modern scientific discoveries.

Well, there’s absolutely no reason to meditate on subtle impermanence in term of the Vaibhāṣika school of thought when we have the advantage of modern physics. It’s very clear at this level. So first, we analyze clearly subtle impermanence. Then we move upwards mentally this hierarchy of consciousnesses starting initially with the wrong consciousness, which is this innate sense that phenomena are permanent. And wrong consciousnesses are subdivided into the two categories, non conceptual wrong consciousnesses and conceptual wrong consciousnesses.

Everything in gray here in the chart is conceptual. Non conceptual wrong consciousnesses refer to the fact that to our sense consciousnesses because of long habituation, phenomena actually seem to be permanent. Our sense consciousnesses, our eye consciousness engages phenomena through seeing them as unchanging. And we have to basically move upwards from that to a realization that we are afflicted by a conceptual wrong consciousness which considers, we would say dogmatically or perhaps as a force of the pressure of society that phenomena do not change. This is deeply ingrained in all of us.

Those of you who have been in failed relationships know that the relationship always ends with one of the parties staring at the other accusing me and saying, you have changed. Well, all this goes to show is lack of realization of subtle impermanence because that is a given. The changing nature of beings is a given. You see? So we have to then move from a conceptual wrong consciousness viewing another object.

I took the case of the body of a female partner. It could be the body of a male partner. It could be a car. It could be a sound. These are all equal from a perceptual standpoint.

Viewing this object as permanent, we have to move from this to doubt. Doubt shatters this apprehension of permanence. And there are three categories of doubt. The earliest we can generate is doubt erring towards the nonfactual, which is after after hearing these explanations, after thinking about them, we start to think to ourselves, perhaps perhaps or we think to ourselves, probably this person is permanent. We are no longer certain that they are permanent, but we do nonetheless believe that they are permanent.

And we move upwards and quietly from this towards equal doubt where we are in a state of ambiguity about whether the person or the phenomenon being considered is permanent or impermanent. We’re not sure. Moving upwards towards factual doubt, where actually we we think, well, perhaps this person, this car, this bank account, you know, this floor is impermanent. This factual doubt then ushers the state of conviction. Conviction is a very powerful transformative experience from a Buddhist standpoint.

It’s a very specific state of mind in which we are actually convinced that the object considered in this case is impermanent. But we are convinced of this without sound analytical grounding, without reasoning. And even though it is a profoundly transformative experience, it is not a stable state of mind. And therefore, all of these states of mind from conviction downwards are called I didn’t put this here in the margin, literally shakable or controvertible. These are states of mind which can be changed.

Even though we are convinced that phenomena are impermanent, because the conviction is not rooted on solid reasoning, it is still possible to fall back to a state of doubt or even to become once again convinced that phenomena are permanent. So even though we should try to generate conviction, conviction is not sufficient. The goal from the Buddhist standpoint is to give rise to the highest level.

Of states of mind, what are called valid cognizers or Pramāna. A valid cognizer is a mind which cognizes a phenomenon such as subtle impermanence truly, but which in addition can no longer be turned back. It is unshakable. It is incontrovertible. This is a realization which the person will no longer be able to abandon.

There are two categories of valid cognizers. The first given here is an inferential valid cognition, which is a conceptual state of mind. This conceptual state of mind is born from analysis, is born from reasoning. It understands the phenomenon, in this case impermanence through analysis. It is far more powerful than a conviction since a person is never the same once an inferential valid cognizer has been generated.

You see the same things, but you don’t see them in the same way. That, however, is but the beginning from a Buddhist standpoint. Since the ultimate goal is to generate this supreme state of cognition, which is called direct valid cognition, where in this case, since we’re talking of subtle impermanence, subtle impermanence is experienced nakedly. It is seen. There’s no conception.

There is no image appearing to the mind. All phenomena are actually seen, heard, smelled, tasted, and felt as changing instant by instant. Once this has happened, the person is said to have the direct realization of subtle impermanence. This is something which is perfectly accessible to us. Emptiness perhaps is not.

Subtle impermanence is not very difficult to understand. We have to struggle against cultural biases. But in the case of subtle impermanence, certainly, from within the threefold division his holiness has proposed of Buddhist science, Buddhist philosophy, and Buddhist religion, we are in the category of Buddhist science. There is, I would say, on this topic, complete agreement between the core of the Buddhist teachings and everything modern physics has basically been telling us for the last one hundred and twenty years. Then we choose not to see the world in this way.

We like to think it is more comfortable to see the world as permanent and not to see it as impermanent. The very fact that we choose to see the world in a way in which it does not exist, that we choose to see the world and beings as permanent becomes a cause of tremendous suffering for us. Since obviously the world from its side changes, we from our side we claim to permanence, then there’s no big mystery about this one. We’re gonna lose this contest. The world changes whether we wanted to or not.

If, as we said last time, we can set our minds in harmony with the way things are, Then we can definitely reduce dramatically, perhaps eliminate all the suffering we experience. Reduce dramatically from my own personal experience I can vouch for. Eliminate, eliminate, I cannot say. But to reduce dramatically, I can say. Why is this the case?

This is the case because since our minds are in harmony with the mode of existence of phenomena, since we actually see beings and phenomena as changing instant by instant, we expect nothing from the phenomenal world which it cannot give. So we cease to be victim of this tragedy of expectation, which is so much I would say the tragedy of the contemporary world perhaps. Very good. And at present, I would like to give a brief presentation of Buddhist phenomenology, and this is on the two handouts, pages one and two, which have been distributed to you. And then we will take a tea break, which I think all of us need, and, try to meditate a little bit on this.

And, the meditation, I think, will be quite transformative, but I’ll also make it a bit difficult this time. There’s a joke I would like to tell you. It goes to show how people think they are talking about the the same thing and don’t. And it is one of the biggest problems with the transmission of Buddhism to the West, That the Buddhist teachers teach, the students come. Everyone thinks we have Dharma centers with ever increasing number of Buddhists until the teachers to their dismay realized that the students who were coming were hearing something they never said.

And the students all along have been hearing something the teacher never mentioned. It’s an old Zen joke. You know, the the Zen patriarchs believed in transmitting their realizations without words. And the abbot of the Zen monastery, who is a very famous Zen practitioner, has unfortunately for him a very dim witted brother who to compound or to add insult to injury is one eyed. So the abbot wants to do something with the brother which is going to be of help to the brother and will limit the harm to the monastery.

And as you know, in Buddhist monasteries, the gatekeeper of the monastery was in a position of honor. You know, he was basically the person who decided who was allowed in the monastery or not. And in Zen monasteries, whoever came to the monastery had to show his realizations to the gatekeeper. And if the gatekeeper was convinced of the realizations of whoever came, Then the monk who came was about to stay in the monastery for one week for free. So this was quite a major thing.

So it’s quite an honor for the abbot’s brother, and he basically takes his position as a gatekeeper of the monastery. And on the first day, this elder, Zen elder comes to the gate of the monastery with his cane. You know? And he looks at the gatekeeper, and he raises one finger. The gatekeeper looks at him, and he raises two fingers.

Then the elder looks at the gatekeeper, and he raises three fingers. Then the gatekeeper looks at him, and he clenches his fist like this. Then the elder prostrates and leaves. And then the story spreads that the gatekeeper of the Zen monastery has the most extraordinary realizations. He’s a hidden patriarch.

And the abbot hears about this, suddenly doubt arises in his mind. And he thinks, my brother, the one eyed imbecile, a hidden patriarch. So he decides he has to investigate. He calls his brother. And before this, he checks with the other elder who had come.

So So the elder, under questioning, says to the abbot, the likes of your brother I have not met. I came to the gate of your monastery, and I raised one finger, meaning there is Buddha. He looked at me dryly and he raised two fingers, meaning, what about Dharma? Then I looked at him and I raised three fingers, meaning, yes, there is a triple gem, Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. And then he looked at me dryly and clenched his fist, meaning they are one in the dharmakaya.

Then he said, what could I answer to such a practitioner? So the abbot is impressed, and he has his brother come and he said, what happened? And the brother said, what a reprobate. He came to the gate, and he raised one finger, meaning I had only one eye. So he said I wanted to be polite.

I raised two fingers, meaning that he had two eyes. Then he looks at me with contempt. He raises three fingers, meaning that together we have three eyes. Then he said, I lost control of myself, and I shook my fist at him. And then he said, he ran away like a cow ard.

This rather quaint story shows how people have the impression of communicating and are in mental universes apart. And that’s a little bit the goal of these talks, which is to try to convey how radically different Buddhism is and to also point out that if his holiness of Dalai Lama is actively discouraging the conversion of westerners to Buddhism, which actually something quite unique among religious leaders, there’s a very good reason for this. This is because, generally speaking, when people convert to the Buddhist tradition, they bring with them tremendous misconceptions, and they end up between two worlds. Neither quite a westerner with a Christian background or even a Christian, nor really a Buddhist, then this is of no benefit. And this little story shows very clearly, I think, one of the problems which we have been having in Buddhist centers for the last forty years, which is there is a gap between what the teacher says and what the students understand.

So we have to close this gap, and this can best be done for us to understanding where we come from and what the tinted lenses we wear are. And then taking on the Buddhist teachings in their full sense of the term. But someone said to me a couple of weeks ago that she felt I was quite rigid. And to be honest with you, I took that as a bit of a compliment because our goal is to present the authenticity of the Buddhist teachings. Then we try to convey them in Western terms, but there’s a big difference between conveying and betraying.

It is up to the students from their own side to see whether this is something which they can authentically integrate and live, which they believe in, which they eventually can become convinced of or not. And if not, then it is better not to come. It is better to have few authentic Buddhists than to have Dharma centers which are full of people who have nothing else to do with their time. And therefore, I think his holiness’s teachings on this matter are a warning to us as Western Buddhists and an encouragement to proceed in the right direction. And therefore, this leads me to the last ten minutes which will make a bit difficult.

It’s a presentation of Buddhist phenomenology, and then we will have a cup of tea. So phenomenology is simply the presentation of phenomena. And from a Buddhist standpoint, we’re on page, one here. Phenomena are divided into two broad categories. Permanent phenomena, which do not change instant by instant, and impermanent phenomena, which change instant by instant.

The phenomena was which we perceive through the senses without exception are impermanent. They change instant by instant. And within impermanent phenomena, you have a subclass of phenomena which are called coarse impermanent phenomena. These are not merely phenomena which change instant by instant, but also phenomena which cease, which are destroyed. A human being, my my personal case for instance, would be the example of a phenomena suffering from coarse impermanence.

I will die in twenty to thirty years, and the person known as Ilya ceases to exist. This is the case for every one of us in this room. This is what we focused upon last time. Not all impermanent phenomena are marked by coarse impermanence. For instance, the mind from a Buddhist standpoint is impermanent.

It changes instant by instant, but it never stops. It is beginningless and endless. So it is an impermanent phenomenon, but it is not within the category of course, impermanent phenomenon. And then impermanent phenomena themselves are subdivided into three categories on page two of your chart. Mind, matter, and a third category which is called non associated compositional factors.

It basically is everything which is impermanent is neither mind nor matter. But what is important with this chart is to understand that from a Buddhist standpoint, all mind, in other words, all of the inner experiences of mind, the sense consciousnesses, the mental consciousnesses, the thoughts, all of these are transient. They are changing instant by instant. There is nothing there which we can rely or rest upon, Whether it is minds, whether it is emotions, whether it is reactions, it is their nature to be impermanent. They will not become permanent whatever we try to do to them.

And likewise, matter, which refers to everything which we can perceive by the senses, what we can perceive through the eye consciousness, ear, nose, tongue, bodily consciousness, matter also changes instant by instant. There is nothing in matter which we can rely upon or rest upon. And then having understood this, it will also be very helpful for us to cover rapidly the categories which overlap completely impermanent phenomena. We call them synonyms on page one of your outline. So phenomena which are impermanent are defined as phenomena which are momentary.

Now the Buddhist definition of momentariness is one which was limited by the context of Indian culture. In the Sautrāntika school of philosophy, momentary phenomena are said to be phenomena which change every one sixtieth of a second. We now know that that is a an artificially high level of change. Then the Prāsaṇgika School asserts it’s every one three hundred sixtieth of an instant of a second. Actually, I I checked and the shortest unit of time known to particle physics is said to be the attosecond, which is one on 10 power eighteen seconds.

This is one on 10 followed by eighteen zeros seconds. This is probably the rate of change of a subatomic particle. This is a rate of change which we should be integrating in these definitions since it is clear that the traditional rates of change have been superseded by modern discoveries. Impermanent phenomena are synonym with composite phenomena. Composite phenomena are phenomena which are composed of parts.

And therefore, here, what is being asserted quite radically is that everything which has parts is transient. Everything which has parts changes instant by instant, and potentially, everything which has parts will be destroyed, will see its continuum interrupted. Now, if we reflect about this, it is quite a powerful statement. If we take the community, which is present here, we are a community of some 30 or 40 people. In other words, this community is an entity composed of parts.

Because this composed of parts, it is changing instant by instant. And this community actually is also marked by coarse impermanence. This community will disappear within one hour, one hour and a half, never to be reformed in the same way again. If we take my body or your bodies, our bodies are constituted of parts. My body is constituted of the course parts, the hand, the arms, the legs.

Then more subtle parts, the inner organs, the brain, the heart, the intestines, the liver. And if we investigate even more, we have even more subtle parts. The various tissues, brain cells, muscle cells, hepatic cells, nerve cells. And if we were to imagine our electron microscope going ever more within the cellular structure, we have the constituents of the cell, then the molecules, proteins, fats, you know, then the atoms constituting these molecules, carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, oxygen, then the atomic particles constituting these atoms, protons, neutrons, electrons, then the subatomic particles. So my very body, our very bodies, everything we see in this room, the walls, floor, the ceiling, the blackboard, is a composed phenomenon.

When we assert that composed phenomenon are synonymous with impermanent phenomenon, we are asserting that everything which is composed

Is changing instant by instant. This body of mine, the floor, the walls, the blackboard. These actually were the last words Buddha Śākyamūni, our teacher, uttered on this earth. But as Śākyamūni said, monks beware, composite phenomena are impermanent. It is rare to meet a Tathāgata, and then he died.

So if these were the very last words of the Buddha, then we can see there’s something that can do the testament of the Buddha. It’s not a coincidence that in Buddhist philosophy, when we study Buddhist philosophy, the standard example of a syllogism is the subject sound as impermanent because it is a composite phenomenon. This is rooted in this core understanding of the Buddha. Then moving onwards in our list of synonyms, the third synonym of impermanent phenomena is an effective thing. An effective thing is anything which can perform a function.

Anything which can, in other words, do work. We could almost understand work in the sense of energy, in the very sense modern physics understands work. Anything which can perform an activity, ipso facto changes, changes instant by instant. And then jumping to the two last synonyms, impermanent phenomena are synonym with both cause and effect. In other words, everything which is an impermanent phenomenon is a cause.

It is a cause of its subsequent instant. I, for instance, am an impermanent phenomenon and my body is an impermanent phenomenon. If you were to analyze my body, it is in a constant state of flux. It is changing instant by instant. Every instant of this body of mine is a cause of the next instant of the body.

It does not abide for more than an instant. And likewise, every impermanent phenomenon is an effect. In other words, every impermanent phenomenon has a cause which has given rise to it. Hence, the Buddhist understanding of the totality of impermanent phenomena as constituting the web of causality. Then I think this is a very good time for a cup of tea.

So we will, now do some meditation on subtle impermanence. And those of you who were there last time remember the core, thrust of Buddhist meditation, which is the alternates of analytical and concentration meditation. I will cover it briefly for those of you who were not there. The process of meditation is a process of repeated habituation of the mind with an idea or a concept. The goal is to progress upwards on the epistemological chart, which was handed up to you from wrong views through doubt, through conviction, to an inferential valid cognizer, to eventually direct realization of whatever we are meditating upon.

So whatever we are meditating upon must first be ascertained using a faultless reasoning since you don’t want to try to gain some sort of direct realization of something which doesn’t exist and which no one else has ever realized before. It might be very awkward. And therefore therefore, in the case of subtle impermanence, there is no doubt to have. This is from our standpoint as practicing Buddhist taught explicitly by the Buddha. It is confirmed by most of the recent scientific discoveries.

This is something we can meditate about upon with no hesitation. How one proceeds is first one uses reasonings. We do it together to generate a sense of impermanence. Once the sense of subtle impermanence has been generated, one focuses on it single pointedly until it starts waning. When it starts waning, then once again, one returns to analysis to analyzing the meaning of subtle impermanence.

And once one has that sense clearly, then one returns to single pointed concentration. And one goes back and forth in this way until eventually when it gets this overwhelming sense of the impermanence of phenomena. So as a preliminary, we will do the we will actually enter into the correct posture. Those of you who can, the rest can please stay on your chairs if it’s more comfortable for you. But if you can sit cross sit cross-legged, then the traditional posture for reasons of stability to brace the body in meditation because the meditator loses awareness of his body when he becomes fairly well trained.

The traditional posture is a full lotus posture or half lotus like this is acceptable. The back should be straight. This is the most important point. Hands should be placed in one’s lap with the right hand upon the left hand. Thumbs touching.

One’s head should be slightly inclined. One’s shoulders should be even, there should be some space between the arms, and one’s gaze should be fixed somewhat in front of one’s nose with the eyes partly open. So this creates a state of reduced sensory stimuli in which it is easier to transform the mind. At present, we will do the nine fold breathing purification, which we did last time. Breathing three times to the right nostril.

Three times to the left nostril and three times through both. So at first, we inhale through the right nostril quietly. Imagining that we are inhaling white light and nectar of the nature of the blessings of all of the omniscient Buddhas. And now we exhale through the left nostril, imagining that all of the non virtues we have accumulated since beginningless time leave our body as black smoke. Then we repeat the process, inhaling through the right nostril slowly and exhaling slowly through the left nostril.

Yet again, And now we do the same thing for the left nostril. Inhaling slowly, white light and nectar through the left nostril and exhaling through the right nostril, all of our non virtues in the form of black smoke. Finally, for the third group of breathing cycles, we inhale slowly through both nostrils, imagining white light and nectar of the nature of the blessings of all of the Buddhas enters within our body, purifies us, and then we exhale through an opening imagined just above our eyebrows, all of the non virtues which we have accumulated since beginningless time. And we do this three times. At present, we will start meditating on subtle impermanence.

We will meditate on the subtle impermanence of the 18 constituents. The six sense consciousnesses, the six sense organs, and the totality of the objects of these consciousnesses. In other words, everything we can perceive. We will start by meditating on the impermanence of all visible objects, everything we can see. Everything we can see changes instant by instant.

Is in a constant state of destruction. Bring to mind a river constantly flowing. Think that all forms, all colors, the bodies of all the people around you are constantly changing at the atomic, molecular, and cellular levels. So fast, you cannot even begin to perceive it. Then think there is no identity.

My body, the body of those I can see around me, is different every instant. And concentrate on this. Now think not only is the body and everything I see changing instant by instant. So is also the eye which perceives and the eye consciousness which receives the information from the eye. Concentrate on this.

Now, move on to sounds, the ear and the ear consciousness. Try to hear the sound of the clock on the table. Imagine that the click of the seconds separates infinite instance of change within which countless sounds impact the ear. Concentrate on this. Imagine then that the ear organ, the tympanum, and the auditory consciousness as well are changing at the same near infinite rate of change as the sounds.

Now think that both visual objects, the eye organ and the eye consciousness, and sounds, the ear organ, and the ear consciousness together are changing infinitely fast, I’m in a constant state of turbulence. Concentrate on this. Think they are never the same. I cannot rely on them. Then, move on to smell and taste together.

Imagine that odors and tastes constantly changing are surrounding you. In addition, the nose sense organ and the tongue sense organ, the nervous receptors within the two organs, as matter are also changing infinitely fast. Finally, imagine that the nose sense consciousness, and the tongue sense consciousness are changing just as fast. Bring to mind all 12 constituents meditated upon so far, changing at infinite speed. Visual objects, eye organ, eye sense consciousness.

Sounds, ear organ, ear sense consciousness. Smells, nose organ, nose sense consciousness. Tastes, gustatory organ, taste consciousness. Concentrate on the fact that these 12 are changing at almost infinite speed. There is nothing there you can rest upon.

Integrate all the sounds you hear, everything you see, everything you sense, you smell, you taste in this process of change. Now move onwards to bodily sensation. The body sense organ, in other words, the nervous receptors spread throughout the body, and the bodily consciousness. Focus on the pain of your posture in the hips and the back. See it as transient, changing instant by instant.

Now focus simultaneously on 15 constituents. The three linked with eye consciousness, visual objects, eye organ, eye consciousness. The three linked with ear consciousness sounds, tympanum, ear consciousness the three linked with nose consciousness smells, nose organ, nose consciousness. The three linked with tongue consciousness, tastes, tongue organ, tongue consciousness, and the three linked with bodily consciousness. Bodily sensations, bodily sense organ, bodily consciousness.

Imagine all 15 changing infinitely quickly. Think There is nothing here I can trust. There is nothing apart from change. Finally, look at the mind itself. See the constant flow of ideas, sensations, hopes, fears, pain.

Reflect the mind, the mental consciousness is changing at the same infinite rate.

As all the previous 15 constituents linked to eye, ear, nose, tongue, and body. Think there is only change. Nothing I can see, hear, smell, taste, touch, or think endures more than one infinitesimal instant. Think. Every instant is an instant of destruction.

Concentrate on this. Bring all the sounds you hear into the meditation. See these sounds as successive instance of death, of destruction. They arise to die and to disintegrate almost instantaneously. Now take your own body as a supportive meditation.

Imagine that you see your body with a microscope. You can see the constant process of disintegration at the cellular level. Cells are dying. Concentrate on the fact. This body of mine is dying instant by instant.

Think. This body is the death process. Now visualize in front of you someone who is dear to you. And think there is nothing in this person which lasts more than an instant. His or her body is disintegrating instant by instant.

His or her mind is disintegrating instant by instant. Instant by instant, body and mind are different. Didn’t think the person I am attached to now within one instant will no longer be. Focus on this. Now think, therefore, there is no stability in human relations.

Everybody and everything is instantaneously changing. I too have changed when I say I. And finally, ask yourself without answering the question. Is there anything within yourself apart from this process of change? So now we will relax the posture and quietly start to emerge.

Being mindful when we look, hear, smell, taste, or feel of the change, the constant impermanence of phenomena. Are there any questions? Memory is a state of mind. So it brings to mind something which no longer exists no longer exists in the way we perceived it. Memory is also a conceptual state of mind.

What that means is that it brings to mind an image, which is a highly simplified image. If you remember, for instance, let’s say in my case, if I remember my my late father. I remember my late father’s face, but that face no longer exists. Probably, there is not even a skeleton anymore. So that memory is a mental image of something I knew twenty two years ago, which is the matter which constituted my father’s face.

Is that No. I’m supposed to because the mental image seems to stay the same. Yes. And therefore, memory is said to be a mistaken state of mind because the mental image appears to exist. The phenomenon appears to exist.

My father appears to exist as I remember him even though he does not. And if we look at our lives, we will find that almost everything we do in this life is motivated by these mistake state of minds. For this when we’re in love with someone, we’re in love with the mental image. The mental image is permanent and stable. The person itself is in a constant state of flux.

We refuse to perceive the person as being in that constant state of flux. If we did, it would be impossible for desire or anger to arise. Since the person is from every single instant different, The person of the first instant, within the time it takes me to breathe, one breath, if you examine my body with an electron microscope, it is a different body. Cells will have disappeared. Cells will have been created.

And then if I take myself or if we take any one of us, I am 47. I’m convinced I am the same person I was when I was 16. Perhaps, not one cell in my body is the same. So this conviction of permanence is profoundly misleading. Almost everything we do, everything we feel is based on error.

We say to someone, I love you. We don’t love them. What we love is our mental image of their body, which is a mental image of the body they had a long time ago, not even the body they have now. Their minds we have no access to. We cannot see or perceive their minds.

So when we say I love you to someone, what do we mean? When we say I hate you to someone, same thing. Yet based on these emotions, we help and we harm others. The moment we start analyzing the falseness of this becomes evident. Our lives are largely constituted by our relationships to our mental images.

I mean, if we analyze objectively, we are all insane. Does that help a bit? Yes. The mind remains in a constant state of flux, but there is a boundary beyond which it no longer goes. The mind, once one has generated these valid cognizers, the mind can no longer unrealize what it realized.

Impermanence becomes part or the realization of impermanence becomes part of who we are. Everything we see is filtered through that. In the self same way as a child, as an infant, learns to recognize faces. Facial recognition is not an attribute infants are born with. They train in this and it is something which is learned so that if I look at your faces, I see instantaneously 30 or 40 different faces.

This is something I have learned. If a chimpanzee were to look at this assembled group of people today, he would see all of us as identical. The chimpanzee would not be able to see instantaneously facial differences. However, chimpanzees see facial differences between themselves and other chimps which we cannot perceive. They cannot unlearn that process.

We cannot unlearn facial recognition. It has become part of how our minds function. We go through life. We walk in the streets. I just spoke.

I see Chris. My my mind instantaneously recognizes a face of Chris. When one has realization of impermanence, then if one looks at someone, one immediately sees change. There’s not an instant between the perception and the sense this person, this body, because that’s all we see. We don’t see the person.

We just see the body. This body is constantly shifting. It is said that every instant is an instant of creation, abiding, and destruction. It’s a way of looking at things. Then if you think about it, if the person is changing instant by instant, they are being created instant by instant anew, which is true.

At the subatomic level, we are being created instant by instant. Elementary particles, electrons change quanta of energy quasi-instantaneously, quasi instantaneous. In addition, the body is in a constant state of abiding. This is true because there is a continuum despite the change. The body is also in a constant state of disintegration, which is what we focused upon today.

Does that help to answer your question? Yes. You’d have to ask a physiologist. I would imagine that probably all of it is gone. Most of it.

It is gone. Most of it. They say that in this room, in the two hours teaching, we have breathed cells which were part of the body of Julius Caesar. The cells which is a part of the body of Julius Caesar have been recycled. Some cells, excuse me, atoms.

Some of the atoms, you know, they say statistically will be present everywhere on earth. We are we have two levels of impermanence. Subtle impermanence, which is a fundamental impermanence. This means everything is changing instant and instant by instant. As a result of subtle impermanence, most phenomena also are destroyed.

But as you say, we grow older, we die. We grow older, we die because every instant we are changing. Actually, biologists tell us every instant we are degenerating. Every time a cell divides by mitosis, there is a progressive degeneration of the information contained in the genetic code of the cell. It’s an endless process of decay, which actually starts at the very instant of conception.

From conception onward, the death process has been initiated. And this is something biologists, I think, would fully agree with. We should ask a geneticist or a biologist about this one. And then by the time we physically become old, it has become evident, you know, then we struggle against the signs of aging, which is just a clear sign of of refusal of the impermanence of the body. But this impermanence of the body is the lot of the body and the mind.

And if we think about this, the mind is a phenomenon which is meaningful because the mind actually is what passes into another body. The body, we leave behind. Does that help? Excuse me. Are there other questions?

Yes. The one part of the mind. The mind isn’t mind isn’t permanent. However, the mind the mind’s continuum is never interrupted. The mind does not die.

However, it changes instant by instant. It’s one of the impermanent phenomena which is marked by subtle impermanence. In other words, it changes instant by instant, but not by coarse impermanence. It is not severed. Its continuum is not severed.

Our bodies are both. Our bodies change instant by instant, and in addition, our bodies will be destroyed at the time of death. One of the very helpful ways to meditate on impermanence, and this is what Kamo no Chomei did this. This is very much in the Buddhist tradition, is to focus on a natural phenomenon which is constantly changing. A river is a classic.

Fields of wheat are very helpful when there’s a wind. It’s a whole field moving. You know? And then you think everything is similar to this field of wheat. Everything is similar to this river.

Nothing lasts. Nothing endures. Everything is always changing. As Kamo no Chomei put it beautifully, where we were, we do not know. Where we where we go, we do not know either.

This is human lot. Then once one integrates these practices, I think they must be a source of tremendous peace. Because in our mind, basically sees the world as it is. We have no expectations, no hopes, no fears. We do not get attached.

We do not have anger. How could you get angry with something which is changing instant by instant? The person who hurt you no longer exists. The person you fell in love with no longer exists. The child you gave birth to is dead long ago.

He is dying instant by instant. You recognize him as your child. He recognizes you as his father or his mother only because of the fantasies of memory, as you said, of conceptual mind. There is and then much, not much, everything we do in society is meaningless, empty, completely meaningless. People run around.

And this is something all of us work very hard at forgetting. I mean, we have created the West industries of distraction. These industries of distraction are there to make us forget one thing, we are going to die. We are going to grow old and we are going to die, and it is a given. Not only is this going to happen, but it is happening right now.

It’s constantly happening. It’s a process. Yes. Yes. But you see how irrational the grudge is, isn’t it?

I mean, even the law recognizes this with the statute of limitations. There is this idea that after a certain period of time for most crimes, you can no longer really prosecute the person because the person is not the same. Twenty years in some countries, and a whole category of crimes has come to escape that status. But even legally, after twenty, thirty, however many numbers of his even from the standpoint of society, one says, well, whatever the man did twenty years ago, that person really no longer exists. He’s no longer fully accountable for that.

We all sense that somewhere, don’t we? Then what we see is that we are in love with our mental images, and we hate our mental images, and we inflict them on other people. We see this in the extreme forms of fantasy, delusional fantasies, obsessional feelings. You know, you’ve all seen these movies, whatever they’re called fatal attraction, think was one, where the person is in love with a mental image of somebody else. The other person is a pretext for the generation of the mental image.

You know? It’s tremendous it’s to inflict tremendous violence in another person to try to force them who are impermanent to fit into a permanent, isn’t it? And then, obviously, if we do that from our side, this can only be the recipe for tremendous suffering. We are in love or we hate this, and this is something which our minds have created based on exterior appearances. And the other person is here and is always changing.

And our minds create this very simplified conceptual image of the other person and use this as a template, as a support for our feelings or emotions. Are are there other questions? Yes. I think I think His Holiness really has issued this warning. It’s a warning about hasty conversion.

It’s a warning that, basically, we do not abandon lightly our past, our cultural past. It’s perhaps also a warning to all of us to first know our cultural past before turning our backs on it. Having said that, His Holiness has made a very helpful distinction in the last couple years between what he calls Buddhist science, Buddhist philosophy, and Buddhist religion. And I think it’s an upward process. Buddhist science basically are those aspects of Buddhism which are compatible with contemporary science in the present state of knowledge.

These, I think, frankly, must be accepted by all persons of good faith, Buddhist or not. I mean, there is no future in flying in the face of physical evidence. To deny the existence of the particulate nature of matter, for instance, is meaningless. Then Buddhist philosophy, I think one can be interested in Buddhist philosophy without being a Buddhist. Many Westerners are.

Buddhist religion starts when one takes refuge. Then I think before one changes religion, one has to think very carefully. And it must be a sincere and full hearted commitment. It is harmful to oneself if the commitment is not sincere and full hearted, and it’s harmful to the religious tradition as well. So His Holiness has commented many times that he finds very high levels of confusion present in people who have changed religions.

Then it behooves a person who wants to change religion to eliminate this confusion. It is not possible to be both a Christian and a Buddhist. It is impossible. It is not possible to be a materialist who doesn’t believe in past and future lives and a Buddhist. It is impossible.

And one has to be very blunt about these things to force people to make a choice. And making a choice is painful. It means closing doors. But, ultimately, the person from their own side benefits and the tradition benefits. And then the states of doubt, they last.

It’s clear. You know? I mean, we saw in the the hierarchy of epistemological hierarchy that we have first a doubt erring towards a nonfactual, then equal doubt, then a doubt erring towards the factual. So if someone wants to become a Buddhist from their own side, then they have to examine. And in the Buddhist tradition, the path forward is based on reasoning and examination.

It is on the basis of reasoning and examination that eventually conviction and finally, a valid cognizer are created. Less than that is not good enough. Does that go towards answering your question? Are there other questions? Yes.

There’s no time. There’s no time. I mean, it’s really from the innermost wells of the person that these decisions have to be taken. His Holiness has warned Westerners repeatedly based on his experience over the last fifty years about the dangers of enthusiastic and premature conversion. There’s a track record now of Westerners who have converted to Buddhism, sometimes have become monks, and who have disappeared and have never been seen again.

This is just it’s it’s a practice of track record. So we don’t have a good track record in terms of stability. I think because we, as a society, as Westerners, we are accustomed to quick fixes, and we are accustomed to quick satisfaction. Now the spiritual path in all the traditions is a long and demanding one. So the best thing is to go slowly.

I know Geshe-la has said that one should be a Buddhist, in other words, have taken refuge. That is what he means in this context. A Buddhist in the religious sense, one must be a Buddhist for five years before receiving an initiation. I want you to be a Buddhist for twenty years before becoming ordained. This is a standard His Holiness has set.

Then, obviously, there are exceptions. But the reason for this is that this gives time for what is a new identity to be constructed. And the construction of a new identity is a long and painful process. It’s also one which demands a lot of honesty. It is very important that in this process of constructing this new spiritual entity, one does not demand that the tradition change to accommodate one’s own bias.

And this has been a very big problem over the last decades with the introduction of Buddhism in the West. West. Specifically in The United States, it is said some 70% of so called Buddhists do not believe in past and future lives. I actually know a Western Buddhist monk who told me upfront that he did not believe in past and future lives. Then then what does one say, you see?

This means that 70% of Americans who call themselves Buddhists are not Buddhists. These are people instead of great confusion because the existence of past and future lives is is nonnegotiable. It there’s no margin there. You know? Believing in past and future lives does not make one a Buddhist.

One can also be a Hindu or Jain. But believing in past and future lives, accepting the existence of karma and causality, believing in a liberation are indispensable to just be a Buddhist, a Hindu, or a Jain. Then the difference between Buddhist, Hindus, and Jains, that was the main Indian religious traditions, lies in how they go about attaining liberation. That’s the disagreement. All agree on the, we would say, the cosmology.

But when it comes to what is liberation from the cycle of lives, how to attain it, then the Buddhist, the Hindus, and the Jains disagree. The Hindus and the Jains assert the existence of a self, an inherently existing self. The Buddhists deny the existence of such a self. So an American Buddhist, one of the 70% of American Buddhists who don’t believe in past and future lives, is not even let alone is not a Buddhist. He’s not even a Hindu or a Jain.

This is why in some talks which were given two years ago, we talked about the Gangetic worldview. This is we can say that there is, if you want, if you forgive me for the the reductionistic presentation, there is a Levantine cosmology and a Gangetic cosmology, which have informed the world religions. The Levantine cosmology, which is at the root of the old and the New Testament and to a large degree of the Koran, since the Koran is derived from the Old Testament to a large degree, is a cosmology of finite time, finite space, and revelation within the context of history. This is the cosmology which underlies our civilization. The Gangetic cosmologies which underlie Indian thought and all of ancient Asian thought are cosmologies of infinite space, infinite time, and no revelation within the context of history.

The two are completely incompatible. And it is important for us as Westerners who are trying to become Buddhist to understand this incompatibility and to see whether we can take this on board. Because one thing I’ve tried to show in the last three years is basically that religious traditions are organic wholes. You cannot pick and choose unless you are extremely well aware of the inner coherence of the tradition. If you take the Buddhist teachings, the Buddhist cosmology, the Buddhist phenomenology, Buddhist epistemology, meditation techniques are all connected.

A very common, for instance, fallacy among Western Buddhists is to think that meditation is practiced to be happy in this life. It’s not the goal at all. As far as the Buddhist is concerned, whether we are happy in this life or not is completely irrelevant. Buddhism starts with the next life. So Buddhist meditation techniques are not designed to make us happy in this life.

They’re not designed to increase mental peace in this life. They’re not designed to reduce one’s problems with one’s partners or whatever in this life. That’s not the goal. They are designed to change the mind for future lives. When Westerners come to Buddhist centers to learn to be happier and better persons within their relationship, they are not even within the pool of Buddhism.

And then, obviously, they don’t stay. Excuse me. Yes.

I think the key to understand the Buddhist teachings is the combination of receiving teachings oneself, studying, and experiencing. The three have to be present. If one has not received teachings, one is just bumbling in the woods. One doesn’t know what’s going on. One may be lucky or not.

If one does not think about things oneself, one cannot gain certainty. But the litmus test is experience. So oneself, one must gain experience. Then from a Buddhist standpoint, we can only help when we ourselves have been transformed. Until that point, our capacity to help is limited.

It’s not nonexistent, but it’s limited. The greater the inner transformation, the greater the help. Hence, the Buddhist emphasis certainly at the beginning of the path on a solitary practice to profoundly transform oneself. And then one sees great beings who have really gone this road, who because they really understand where another person is in their personal tragedy, can sometimes find that that one right word which unlocks everything. But one must be able to find it.

It’s not enough to have goodwill. Then regarding the benefit of meditation techniques for mental diseases, I think that one has to experiment and see carefully. Meditation techniques were not designed to treat mental diseases. Most meditation techniques actually create mental tension. You take for instance calm abiding, śamatha.

For some odd reason, it’s being promoted as a means to enhance serenity. It’s even translated in that way in the new Lam Rim translation. Calm abiding does not foster serenity at home. Calm abiding, which is training the mind so that it can focus single pointedly on an object without any distraction at the beginning certainly creates mental tension. It is not a practice which, for instance, to take that as an example, it’s not a practice which should be taught to someone who has mental issues.

So I think one would really have to one would have to have Buddhists buddhist

Key terms in this teaching

dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
eighteen constituents dhatu (Skt); kham (Tib)
The six sense powers, the six consciousnesses and the six objects. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
tathagata de zhin sheg pa (Tib)
Epithet for a buddha; literally, “one who has gone to suchness.” LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top