TBI Recordings

2 h 30 min · 17,104 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Other recordings (Ilia Durovic)
Other recordings (Ilia Durovic)
TBI Recordings
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Ilia Durovic examines past life regression as a window into karma and causality, drawing heavily on Helen Wambach’s statistical study of over 1,000 hypnotic regressions and Morris Netherton’s therapeutic cases. He addresses methodological critiques of hypnotic regression (cryptomnesia, fantasy, lack of verification), then presents Wambach’s evidence that authentic past life memories show statistical distributions matching historical population patterns across race, sex, diet, and conflict periods. The seminar’s central case follows Anna, a 19-year-old with life-threatening anorexia, amenorrhea, and maternal conflict, regressed through four lives where themes of maternal separation, suffocation, drowning, and fire recur. Durovic then explicates Buddhist karma doctrine: its definiteness (virtue yields happiness, non-virtue yields suffering), its increasing amplification, and its specific karmic structures—including the four factors needed for a deed to be karmically complete, the five weightings that intensify or weaken karmic impact, and the role of vows as karmic amplifiers. He emphasizes practical strategies: purifying non-virtuous imprints, preventing afflictions from triggering latent karma, and skilfully taking vows matched to one’s capacity. A detailed Q&A explores collective karma, the September 11 attacks interpreted through karmic causality, and habituation effects within karmic maturation across lives.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Ilia karma and Causality.mp3

UUID: c5f4c48a-f018-4ba0-a691-a6f5a9a9091f

Teacher: Ilia S. Durovic

Collection: Ilia Seminars

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~17,101

Well, good afternoon, everybody. A very warm welcome. Can you hear me alright? Not very well? Where’s Nick?

My name is Chris. Nick is just gonna make a couple of adjustments. It’s my great privilege to welcome you all here on behalf of our venerable teacher, Khensur Rinpoche, and the Tibetan Buddhist Institute to another talk by Ilya Burzevich. Those of you who have attended Ilya’s talks in the past will know that you are in for a stimulating and challenging couple of hours this afternoon. We’re very privileged to have Ilya with us.

He is here because of his devotion to our teacher, Khensur Rinpoche. He is accomplished in three major areas, Western philosophy, literature, and languages, and in the Buddhist philosophy and traditions, particularly Tibetan Buddhism, but also the integration of these two. And like all authentic Buddhist, he has not only an intellectual understanding, but a profound integration in his own personal life. So we’re very privileged to have Ilya talking today on A Pure Life Living in the Light of Karma and Causality, past life regression and the evidence for the existence of karma. Just before Ilya commences, would just like to say that we’ll be having a short break halfway And there are two toilets around through the kitchen.

And you would have received a handout. If you haven’t, then perhaps see me at the break. Sorry? Two handouts? And so we appreciate a small donation to help to cover the costs.

So thank you very much, Ilya. Thank you very much, Chris. So it’s a pleasure to meet many faces with which I’ve become familiar over the last two years again. And we will be continuing today with the topic which we started to talk about before Christmas. As you remember before Christmas, we addressed the issue of spontaneous past life recalls.

And, I mentioned to you then that the foremost researcher in the field, professor Ian Stevenson, was fairly dubious about the utility, of hypnotic regression. I personally feel that, this is connected perhaps to professor Stevenson’s particular situation as a tenured professor of psychiatry at the University of Virginia, and to the importance for him to try to establish the existence of past lives without any intimation of the criticisms which are addressed often to hypnotic regression, such as cryptomnesia, memory induction, and so forth. I do feel, however, that hypnotic regression with really certain restrictions is of great interest to us. The material must be handled with much greater care than the spontaneous memories, but because of the nature of the material, it opens up onto the issues of karma. And therefore, I felt it was a natural progression to go from a description of Stevenson’s research on spontaneous past life recollections to this talk today, which will be a talk on past life regression and karma, where we will use the material from past life regression as a springboard to not so much demonstrate as give us a sense of the possibility of the existence of karma and of how karma just might function.

So as you remember, Stevenson, and many of the researchers who work with spontaneous past life memories, which are uninduced memories, address, four general criticisms to hypnotic regression as a technique for accessing purported past life memories. The first is that the memories could be induced by the hypnotist. The second is a phenomenon of cryptomnesia we mentioned before December, which is that the subject actually remembers things they knew in this life but had forgotten. And this is attributed to a past life. They had read a book on the seventeenth century, forgot reading it, but the memories were stored in their subconscious and are accessed through the hypnosis.

So this is cryptomnesia, which is which exists, and it’s a very powerful critique against much of the material which is accessed through past life regression. The third critique is also a powerful one. It’s the generation of cathartic fantasized personalities. Hypnotic regression occurs overwhelmingly in a therapeutic context. There is therefore a preselection of the patient.

People come to a psychiatrist, to a therapist, generally speaking, because there are issues. In such a context, it’s quite easy to generate a fantasized past life personality, which basically incarnates these issues. And the fourth critique which Stevenson and the like have addressed to hypnotic regression is that most of the cases are not verified. So every single critique is valid. However, there have been cases of past life, regressions through hypnosis, which have obviated these critiques.

And I mentioned one last time, which was, the one performed by one of the foremost researchers in the field, the French scientist, Albert de Rochas, who in 1911, if memory serves me well, regressed a servant made through several past lives, in which he remembered life as a peasant and then as a highwayman in France, and eventually regressed her all the way back to a life as a wolf. These lives were verified. Albert de Rocha was able able to actually trace the memories of this servant lady, and the memories would have been very, very difficult for her to manufacture. The data was was accurate. So there’s at least, therefore, one case of memories of past past lives accrued through hypnotic regression, which is verified.

You will see that there are several more than this. Then before addressing the issues of, valid methodology, I would like to address, the issues of invalid methodology, and that is why I was very hesitant about, covering this topic with you. Basically, past life hypnotic regression is an absolute free fall, and much, but not all of the material is garbage. A case in point is some of the research performed by Doctor Guirdham, who is a British psychiatrist, and who at the beginning when he started accessing material in patients, which seemed to indicate memories of past lives, had quite an objective stance with respect to the material. So his initial initial research is quite interesting.

And then very quickly, Guirdham got involved with something like a case of folie à deux with his patients, mutually feeding fantasies, you know. And you see in some of the material he has published, which is The Cathars and Reincarnation, which was his first book, a mix of the two. It starts out by being very interesting and then very quickly, there are no dates, there’s no sequence of events. It’s clear he is much closer to the patient than perhaps is wise for this sort of situation, and it becomes very difficult to really separate what is authentic and what is inauthentic. My personal feeling is that much of the material in the the Cathars and reincarnation is actually authentic, but, that Guirdham’s methodology invalidates his procedure.

And then the second case, which is a famous case, which you have all heard of, is, the book published in the nineteen fifties in The States, the search for Bridey Murphy, where a young, or she was not that young. Yes. Yes. Yes. Claimed to have memories, of past life in Ireland and spoke broke and had memories of details of life in Ireland in the seventeenth century.

The book became instantaneously a bestseller. She’d been regressed by an amateur hypnotherapist who was a Colorado businessman. Then the issue became very complicated, and there are two two facets. I’ll present briefly both. Critiques journalists connected to Time and Life magazine investigated the case, and they found actually that, one of her close neighbors, I believe actually even her grandmother, came from Ireland, and that she had had access to much of the material which she was quite honestly and innocently recollecting in hypnosis as a young child.

And therefore that this was very likely a case of cryptomnesia. Then the criticism of the criticism is that there’s a lot of evidence there was a battle at the period between press groups, And that, the press group, owned Time Life magazine, was at odds with the press group which owned, I think, was Bantam Press, which published the case and wanted to destroy the sales of the book. But, it is quite clear that the methodology in the Bridey Murphy case, was unfounded. However, we have cases of sound methodology, the ones of Albert de Rochas, which I mentioned to you, and one which I will rely upon heavily during this, conference, which, are the cases studied by doctor Morris Netherton, who is one of the leading, psychotherapist psychiatrist, actually, who has used hypnotic regression, to access past life memories. His works are mentioned in your bibliography, and they are the works I would heartily suggest to all of you if you’re interested in the field.

His work is seminal and is the foundation work for all of the latter research of psychiatrists and therapists such as Woolger and so forth. As all of the solid researchers in the field, Netherton came to this material by accident. He was not interested in the slightest in past life regression. He just kept having in patients he was taking in in therapy and treating by hypnosis material which he could not make sense of. And in trying to make sense of the material, in the same way as Woolger later on, he was led eventually to the feeling that the only possible explanation was that these patients were accessing memories from past lives.

This is a great plus, obviously, because you’re dealing with a skeptic who keeps a certain stance of skeptical criticism with respect to the materials. Now the advantages of hypnotic past life regression. There are some very definite advantages in comparison with spontaneous recollection. The first and foremost is the possibility to have access to a string of lives or a string of memories of past lives in the continuum of one person, which is almost impossible in spontaneous cases. I think in Stevenson’s corpus, it happens two or three times that a child remembers more than one past life.

With hypnotic regression, it is possible to regress the patient backwards ten, twelve, or more lives in the past. Bloxham did this, for instance, with one of his patients, Ann Ockenden. It was one of the cases I was thinking of presenting to you. Netherton has done it with several of his cases. The second advantage of hypnotic past life regression is especially in the cases where the regression is random.

In other words, the regression is performed on subjects who had no particular interest in it, who were not coming for therapy. It eliminates the bias you find in Stevenson’s work towards violent deaths in past lives. Quite typically, cases of spontaneous recollections of past lives are connected with violent and traumatic deaths in the previous life. In Stevenson’s research, it’s a solid seventy percent of all of his patients, all of his subjects, of spontaneous recall, whose immediately perceiving death is violent. By violent, we we mean here accidental or criminal.

In other words, death before term, not a death of natural causes. The researchers like Helen Wambach who have worked with random cases, where they have just taken students, who were volunteers for general research projects and regressed them, find memories of violent past past deaths in the fifteen to thirty percent of the cases. Peaking interestingly interestingly enough in memories from the twentieth century. So this goes to corroborate something I was mentioning to you last year, which is that the twentieth century has been the most violent century, on human record. So that’s the second advantage.

The third advantage, is that it enables, work of which we will talk briefly today, which is the statistical study of the milieu, the experiences, the vestimentary habits, the diets of the past life memories. And this was particularly done by Helen Wambach. So her work is extremely interesting for us, and it is the first three handouts which are given to you. Because Wambach’s procedure is, in its intent similar to Stevenson’s, in that she sets out to see whether or not past lives do exist, but her methodology is radically different. Whereas Stevenson takes spontaneous past life memories and then tries to check the memory in an extremely time consuming and arduous approach.

Wambach’s procedure was radically different. She also worked with a very large number of cases, in excess of 1,000 cases. I think the case the you are given, the case study covers 1,080 or so cases. And her reasoning was that if induced past life regressions are authentic and are not fantasized, then statistically, the distribution of experiences in past lives should correspond to what history tells us the lives of most people in centuries past were like. In other words, if past life regressions are fantasized, I remember being Napoleon Bonaparte, and the ladies remember being Nefertiti.

Right. So if all of us remembers being Bonaparte, Caesar, or Nefertiti, then odds are we can’t have been all Bonaparte. Right? So Wambach’s line of reasoning, I thought, was quite subtle. She thought if we take a large sample of these cases and they fit the statistical means for the period considered,

Odds are they are reflecting a certain underlying reality. Because why would people fantasize being a a serf in medieval France who died at the age of 21, slaughtered by his lord because he had prayed a a venison in the lord’s forest. I mean, who would want that sort of cathartic fantasy? You see? It is not a cathartic fantasy.

So if you look at your charts, you will find that Wambach’s material fits quite closely with what we know of past history. The first chart on page one nineteen is racial distribution in past lives. And she was quite struck by the fact that in the first groups of past life lives she researched, the majority of the memories indicated a past life as an Asian or someone from The Middle East around 2,000 BC. This corresponds with much of the data we have nowadays, which indicates that population centers around 2,000 BC from 2,000 BC to almost the beginning of the millennium of our era were located in India, in China, in Mesopotamia, and in Egypt. Very few Caucasian rebirths as you can see.

Caucasian rebirths start taking off around the beginning of our era with the spread of the Roman Empire, which corresponds to much of the historical data we have. And then they skyrocket at the Renaissance and as one approaches to the age of enlightenment, which once again corresponds to the demographic data we have. Now these are statistics collated over 1,000 cases. It’s very difficult to imagine the 1,000 cases discussing it with each other and agreeing, you’ll remember to be a Mesopotamian in February because that’s what everyone was. And I remember to be French in 1800 because that’s what everyone was back then, you see.

So this sort of research intimates that there is something else to the memories of past life regression through hypnosis than mere fantasy. If it was mere fantasy, most of us would not recollect being members of another race. And, certainly, that wouldn’t tie in with the statistical distribution of the population throughout the ages. The second item Wambach researched is sex distribution on page one twenty four throughout the time periods. Here, once again, it is quite striking.

See that broadly speaking, sex distribution, the male female ratio oscillates around 50%, which is indeed what we would expect. This flies in the face of the bias most of us have against remembering a past life as a member of the other gender. And more importantly, the male female ratio and especially the proportion of males fluctuates very much in keeping with what we know of the periods of great conflict. We know, for instance, that the period around 1,000 BC was a period of repeated invasions of the Middle East by tribes which are broadly speaking known as the Hittites. It’s it’s recorded in the in the Old Testament.

And we see a dip, a clear dip in the proportion of male births. Then we see the peak, in the period leading up to the, apex of the Roman empire, and they then decline progressively reaching a low with the collapse of the Roman empire to rise once again steadily as various empires in India, the Tang dynasty progressively in China, and obviously the dawn of modern western civilization after the, dark period of the dark ages, starts. Then the third chart I have included And I must ask you which one is there because I have a bevy of them. Yes. Is food distribution throughout the ages?

Again, it’s quite striking to find that the overwhelming majority of, cases regressed regressed by Wambach recollect a diet comprising, largely, cereals and, wild animals, roots, and fruits in the period, broadly speaking, from 2,000 BC up to 1,000 AD. That sort of diet is in fitting with everything we know of development during that period, which is that the majority of human population were either hunter gatherers or small farmers, and that meat was a luxury. Meat in the diet skyrockets, broadly speaking, from 1,000 AD, which once again corresponds with everything we know of the transformation in diet linked with development. So there’s a series of other charts I will not integrate here regarding vestimentary habit and so forth. But I wanted to, present what I think is a very promising approach to the study of, past life memories, which is the statistical study of features of the life and their comparison with what we know about the period.

It seems almost impossible, short of rank dishonesty from the researcher, that this data could have been cooked. So this data clearly indicates that the majority of the cases Helen Wambach regressed were not cases which brought forth fantasized memories. More than that, we cannot say. We cannot say that these are authentic memories. We can say for sure they are not fantasized because we would not have this sort of distribution for fantasized memories.

And then at present, I will broach the central case which I would like to study with you, today, which is, one of the key cases, Morris Netherton, studied from among, I think I think it was some 25,000 cases Netherton worked with, regressed cases. This is one of the foremost 25,000. I think it’s a figure, you know, over some fifth not quite fifty years. He still is is with us. You know?

The case is a very disturbing case, so, I will skip certain details because of the nature of the audience. And if there are any of you who feel uncomfortable during the account of the case, you’re welcome to take a short break. Past life regression in therapeutic milieus is seldom something which brings out very pleasant memories. You know? So we will I will first present the case directly from Netherton’s file.

Then I will give a broad presentation of the Buddhist analysis of karma and causality, and then we will return to Netherton’s case in an analytical, framework. But I would like to give you first the raw data of the case. And I would have distributed this to you, but, unfortunately, there are copyright issues. I apologize for reading sections. The case in question is, a client of Netherton’s called Anna, a 19 year old ballet dancer, American, suffering from extreme life threatening anorexia nervosa, an extremely conflictual relationship with her mother, and amenorrhea, in other words, interruption of the menstrual period.

And, Netherton regressed the patient at her request, over four lives. So we will cover the four lives moving backwards, and I will quote directly from the account of the regression. I will skip some sections. You will see why. The first session starts with the following account.

Anna says, I see a brick wall in front of me. I’m afraid to leave it, afraid to step forwards, afraid I’ll die if they see me. I feel sick in my stomach, and I have intense pain in my head. Many people are moaning and walking aimlessly with blank empty expressions on their faces. They are thin.

Oh god, they are starving. They look like me. They’re my people. I belong to these people. And keep in mind the situation we are dealing with.

It’s a patient who’s in the present life suffering from anorexia nervosa. My parents are here now. My father’s gone. Only my mother is here. She’s so thin.

I feel safe here at the wall. They can’t see me. They won’t come for me again if they can’t see me. They’re holding me down on a cold table. A man is holding my head and pressing me down to the table so hard, my eyes are popping out.

They’re hurting me. I will skip. My stomach is filling up. It hurts. It hurts.

Netherton asks, what are they saying, Anna? This one has not yet started monthly periods. The uterus now contains 1,800 cc of water. As we have seen before, there is an average difference of 1,000 cc in the uterus before and after the onset of menstruation. I asked Anna to tell me where her body is located.

I’m in a prison camp. It’s a concentration camp. I was in a crowd of people when some guards pulled me out and brought me here. It’s like a laboratory a laboratory. It smells awful, and they have these awful looking instruments.

How old are you? I’m 11 years old. I’m just a little girl. I will skip other sections. Netherton mentions Anna’s physical pain and terror are so overwhelming during the regression that she lapses into a state of shock.

The child then is actually raped by the three assistants, returns to the crowd of people, on the periphery. And the first words she hears now are from her mother. This is the mother speaking. If they come again, I’ll help you. I can’t let them hurt you.

If the guards come, I will signal you. Run to the fence and grab it. Press your body to it tightly. The fence is electrified. Hold the fence.

They will not touch you. It will kill you, but at least you will deny these butchers. And the mother then then says to her daughter, go my daughter and remember I love you. Then Anna is brought out of this first regression, and Netherton asks her, Anna, based on this experience, what conclusions do you take with you after death? She frowns a little and says, I never let my mother get too close to me again.

So this is the first past regression. We have a patient who’s suffering from anorexia nervosa. In other words, who is basically when she meets Neverton, even though she’s 19 years old, he describes her as skeletal and, as resembling an old woman despite her beauty. She suffers from an amenorrhea, in other words, interruption of the the menstrual cycles, extremely conflictual relation with her mother. The first preceding past life gives this data, and then Netherton tries to draw out statements statements from the patient on what we would say in a Buddhist context her dying thoughts were.

And there are three, and they connect very powerfully to the experience in her present life. The first we have mentioned already is I never let my mother get too close to me. The second, keep in mind she suffers from anorexia nervosa is, if this is what happens when I’m seen, I’ll never be seen again. These are akin to vows the person takes before dying. Finally, Netherton asks her, what does it mean if you’re singled out?

I’m going to die. Then the cases regressed further after the, standard cathartic effect of the first regression, one of the signs, and we will discuss this later, of effective hypnotic regression is a profound, catharsis purification of the symptoms within this life. They do not disappear, but they’re greatly reduced. This is the second memory. These are all unverified memories, so I will be working with the case this specific case without taking position on it.

Because it’s unverified, I can either say it’s authentic nor inauthentic. You will see when we analyze it that the degree of internal coherence is so strong that I think it meditates in favor of the case being authentic. This is second second memory of Anna. I’m being pulled out of a group of people. Two men are holding my arms and forcing me to stand where others can see me.

Once again, the emphasis on being seen. The whole village is here. Once again, the child, or in this case, a young woman, is removed from the community. They’re angry with me, shouting at me, throwing rocks at me. It’s my mother.

She is near to me, and I hear her close to my ear. And her mother says, I love your soul more than your body. I had to tell them about you to save your soul. I love you. I did it because I love you.

And then around her, she hears a voice saying, I saw her kill the baby. She’s no good. She killed the baby as it was born. Only witches do that. Burn her.

She’s burnt at the stake. And her words in therapy are, it’s just like the fence. It’s just like the fence. The fence. The electrified fence.

This is the second, memory, and you can see the connection in the death experiences as well as the connection in the direct cause of death of the person. You know? Death through the mother both times. Then moving onwards. Because of the nature of the material, I’m skipping a lot of the details.

This is a third case. In regression, Anna says, I’m drowning. I can’t breathe. My body is filling with water. Help me.

She continues these words of trauma who are choking and gasping in terror on the couch. She’s an infant in a basket set afloat on a river. Her slow drowning comes as the basket slowly fills with water, covering and immersing her in sensory panic. Anna remembers that the tribe members believe the crops have failed because the gods are angry with her and her mother. The baby, in other words, this is Anna as a baby, was born with a deformed spine causing the village elders to declare the gods angry and sending bad crops.

The only way to appease her anger is to sacrifice the cursed infant. Her mother then puts her in the basket and tosses the basket on the river and says to the child, again, these are direct recollections, in the state of regressions, I love you, baby, but you must go. If you stay here, they’ll hurt you. They’ll never be let you be happy. Go now so they can’t hurt you.

So here once again, we have the death in a past life caused by the mother wishing the best for her child. And the circumstances of death are different from the circumstances of death in the two first memories, but they connect very powerfully with the experiences of the first regressed personality in the concentration camp, which is being filled with water until she felt she was going to burst. I should mention that in her present life, we will cover this later, Anna had an abortion at age 17. And the words she uses talking about the experience are quite striking. The day of my abortion, I felt depressed and very frightened.

I knew I was killing my baby, but I couldn’t help it. I really felt love for it and talked to it all day prior to the surgery. So you can see already just in these three lives before we come to the last one, you have a comic pattern which is folding and unfolding between Anna and her mother and a child with a community in the backdrop. The final, regressed memory, which is interesting actually, because all of the memories of past lives as an animal are memories in which the patient find it’s very difficult to conceptualize and, speaks in extremely haunting way. Finally, she speaks in a haunting voice and says, I see a small hairy animal.

It looks like a baby fox or a wolf. Its eyes are closed.

I can’t move, Anna says, beginning to cry. If I can’t move, I can’t eat. If I can’t move, I can’t hurt food. I can’t live if I can’t move. I’m hungry, but I can’t get my mother to give me food.

I’m so hungry. Please feed me. I’ll try to move. I promise. I’ll do anything you want if you will feed me.

Do you see the connection with the experiences of anorexia and control of the intake of food four lives down. Anna’s mother comes towards her. The memory is unclear whether it is, the mother is a she wolf or a a fox. And Anna is happy that she will be fed. When mother reaches her, she slowly and deliberately lays down on top of Anna and begins to smother her.

She knows I must die. I’m deformed and she must kill me. And then the final account of the death in that life, I can’t breathe. Mother, I can’t breathe. Get off me.

I won’t eat much. I promise you, I won’t eat much. So as you can see, this is a very powerful and very disturbing case. You can I think all of you can see the pattern weaving in and out of past lives? This is what past lives are.

When we speak when Khensur Rinpoche speaks of the suffering of past lives, he speaks of this. It’s not some sort of abstract Buddhist Buddhist trip. This is a reality we deal with. And, then after presenting this material, actually, I think we will cover directly the analysis of the material and then move onwards to a Buddhist presentation of karma and causality. If you could pass these around, please.

So I must apologize for my chart making capacities. This is not something I do all the time. But I basically put in a chart the five lives, the present life in which Anna is searching for therapeutic help, and the four remembered previous lives, they are not necessarily in sequence. One gets the sense that many of the lives in nonhuman and nonanimal form would be very difficult to recollect. And there may be lives in between, but there’s a causal pattern.

The bold arrows connect the lives. The features of each life are put in a cluster around the life. The community is to the to the left, and key statements a person makes in regression are to the right. So you can see in the life Anna is looking for help in, she’s an artist. You remember the artistic community, a young woman, in a great state of mental suffering and distress with the cluster, I mentioned, a highly conflictual relation with the mother, amenorrhea, which symbolically is a refusal of sexuality, an abortion at 17, after an affair with, someone of another race, and life threatening anorexia nervosa.

Moving back just one life, the gender has not changed, and it’s still a woman, a young girl, perhaps in a German concentration camp, nothing is said about this, subject to horrific medical experimentation leading to a sense of bloatedness of the stomach as well as of bloatedness of the reproductive organs. In both cases, a rejection of those parts of the body can be presupposed. Anna is singled out in the crowd by her mother. This is a pattern in every one of the lives, and sent to death out of compassion. In every single life, the mother kills her child out of compassion.

She dies by electrocution, which as we mentioned, passing on to the following life, is connected to her death at the stake. In her life as a young mother, she’s turned into the village mob by her mother instead of having been turned in, or told to run to the fence to escape the guards by her mother in the following life. In that life as a young mother, she’s accused of suffocating her child. The account is unclear. It indicates that the child was ill.

If one reads the account, one gets the sense she hastened the death of the child. Hence, I connected this with the abortion one life later on. It’s worth mentioning the mother of Anna in her present life had an abortion as well before having Anna. Then the life previous before that in a village, she’s born as a deformed child. Spine is deformed.

Once again, her mother sends her to death on a river at the bequest of the community. She’s pregnant out of wedlock. The mother is pregnant out of wedlock. It’s a pattern in almost every life, And death occurs by drowning. As we said, there’s a connection with the following life, death by suffocation under the she wolf or the mother as a fox.

There’s a connection also with the, immediately succeeding life where, the child is suffocated. In the last life, she recollects. She’s a paralyzed wolf cub suffocated to death by the mother. If you look at the statements to the right which are made, these statements can be said to be somewhat akin to conclusions the person draws at the end of this life. It is said in the Buddhist analysis of karma that the last thoughts of a dying person are extraordinarily powerful in affecting the future life.

They are the dominant cause. We can assume that the statements Anna makes here, these recollected statements, are probably, or very probably the statements which were in her mind as she was dying. The first one at the bottom, as a wolf cub, she says, I can’t breathe. I won’t eat too much. I won’t eat too much.

So the lack of breathing is connected with death by suffocation or inflicting death by suffocation in almost every one of her lives. The pledge, the promise not to eat, is clearly connected to the anorexia in the present life. If I don’t eat, my mother will not kill me. Then the following life moving upwards, the sensation of suffocation, I can’t breathe. Moving upwards again, the same pattern, I never let my mother get too close.

By now life after life, in every incarnation, the mother has been experienced as a source of death, a kindly source of death, but a source of death. And once again, the leitmotif which connects statement number two and the last statement here, if this is what happens when I’m seen, I’ll never be seen again. I won’t eat. I will fade. If I’m thin, nobody can see me.

And finally, the statement in this this life when Anna has an abortion, I knew I was killing my baby. I felt love for it. It’s actually identical to a statement I did not include here, which is what she says to the child, who dies, in her recollection of her life as a young mother. So what can we see from this chart? First, I think we can see a clear connection between the lives.

It’s very obvious. There are leitmotifs in these lives. These leitmotifs, I think, are karmic leitmotifs. It is not that what Anna has done in one of these lives is the cause, immediate cause of what happens in the next life. For instance, you could not say karmically that being suffocated to death by your mother in a previous life is the karmic cause of death by drowning yourself again in the following life.

What I think happens is that you have one karmic imprint, which is a karmic imprint which leads to death by suffocation, drowning, or asphyxia, which matures over several lifetimes. Now there is a debate about this in Buddhist philosophy between two great Buddhist scholars, Vasubandhu and Asaṇga. Vasubandhu says that only that one karmic imprint can only lead to one result. Specifically, one karmic imprint can only lead to the maturation of one life. Asaṇga, however, in Abhidharma Samuccaya says that one karmic imprint can impel a multiplicity of lives.

I think this case seems to corroborate that. It’s clear if we look at the situation that of the deaths, two of the deaths are through a sphincter or suffocation, and in both cases are caused by the mother. I would put it to you that these are the maturation in these two lives of death, which was inflicted on the mother in a previous life through a stricture or suffocation. Then in the following lives, we have two deaths by fire, one by natural fire, one by electricity. In every single case, the death is provoked by the mother.

So this clearly indicates a powerful karmic connection with the mother. One can assume there was probably another karmic imprint which matured in these two deaths. Then, obviously, the memories, the horrific memories of rape, and sexual violence, have a separate source. There’s a separate karmic imprint. And this is how I think by induction, and this is as far as one can go in the study of karma through hypnotic regression.

By induction, one can suspect from the pattern in the sequence of lives the existence of karmic imprints which lead to these patterns. It is said that there are non-Buddhist, yogis, who actually, through training and concentration, can remember past lives, and yet they do not believe in karma. These are called LoTayatha yogis. The reason for this in Buddhist philosophy is given as the fact that even though they can see past lives, they cannot see the direct cause of experiences. So they believe in past lives, but don’t actually believe in karma.

My personal feeling is that this is the case for many Westerners who are attracted to Buddhism. There’s a sort of general nebulous belief in past lives which has become quite widespread, I think, with the new age. There is a lot more hesitancy with respect to karma. This hesitancy is understandable. I think cases like this, when they are analyzed, give us a sense of the probable existence of karma.

There is too much structure for a root cause of each of the structure patterns not to exist. It’s like a thread, a series of threads in a yarn. You have a red thread going through, a green thread going through, a pink thread goes they’re connected. But there is this pattern through each thread. These threads are the maturation of the karmic imprints.

So I think we will perhaps, stop here for tea break. And I I apologize for presenting what is, as I said to you, very, difficult to support material. I have omitted quite a bit. It is a lot worse than what I presented. You know?

This is the reality, of past life experiences. So when we come back, we will do something much more philosophical. Thank you.

We have covered basically during the first hour the empirical data which is available, and there is a gap between, the empirical data which is available and where the Buddhist analysis of karma and causality starts. It is not possible on the basis of Morris Netherton and Woolger’s results alone to deduce the Buddhist explanation of karma. What I’ve tried to show you, however, is that this gap is a lot smaller than people think it is. Really based on some of the results Netherton and Woolger have collected, the Buddhist presentation of karma seems probable. It is asserted in Buddhist philosophy that only the fully enlightened beings themselves, who are omniscient and see the totality of the cycle of lives are able to trace an action back or trace a result back to its original cause.

We’re not able to do that, and therefore, we rely on the presentation, the Buddha himself gave of karma and on those given by great Buddhist scholars such as Vasubandhu and Asaṇga. I will rely myself in this section heavily on Tsongkhapa’s. Tsongkhapa was a great Tibetan scholar of the late fourteenth, early fifteenth century who summarized the corpus of Indian philosophy in a readily accessible way. And I would hardly suggest to all of you who are interested in this material to, try to read Tsongkhapa, the English translation of Tsongkhapa’s great treatise on the stages, to enlightenment. The translation’s excellent.

And, it is a very, very easy way to enter this rather profound topic. So generally speaking, karma is presented first in terms of its general characteristics and then in terms of the specific features of karma. The general characteristics are the ones I would like to emphasize initially. There’s a lot of food for thought for us if we connect them with cases like the case of Anna. The first feature, general feature of karma is that karma is definite.

What is meant by the definiteness of karma is that an experience of happiness down the line can only have as a cause in a previous life virtuous karma. And an experience of suffering or unhappiness down the line can only have as a cause in a previous life non virtuous karma. There is no crossover. Virtue does not lead to suffering. Non virtue does not lead to happiness.

Now virtue or virtuous karma is often defined, it’s only defined by asanga, broadly speaking, as all those deeds of body, speech, mind which do not trouble the mind. So those deeds which do not create this roughness in the mind which we associate with what we call in English evil, basically, are virtuous deeds. This means taking the template of Anna’s case that the result down the line, which is, for instance, the suffering in this life, from anorexia nervosa, can only be the result of a cause in a previous life which is non virtuous. And as we will see later, there is a connection or a correlation between the cause and the result. In other words, a cause such as being unable or refusing to eat excuse me, a result such as being unable or refusing to eat will have as its primordial cause preventing someone else from eating.

There is that connection of similarity between the cause and the effect which matures down the line. We will enter into this in considerable more detail later on. The second feature of karma is perhaps the most disquieting feature of karma. It’s what I think many Western Buddhists find very difficult to take on board, the increasing nature of karma. The increasing nature of karma means that even a very small karmic imprint, whether virtuous or non virtuous, if left untouched, unpurified in the mind, will keep on growing until it overpowers the person.

If it is a virtuous deed, it can overpower the person in the most positive sense. The person becomes ordained, becomes a meditator, a great teacher. If it’s a non virtuous deed, it can overpower the person in the direction of horrific evil. And Je Tsongkhapa intimates in that this increasing nature of karma is actually a a difference between karmic causality on the one hand and causality in the physical world on the other hand. So these two forms of causality function differently.

There’s no increasing component of causality in the physical world. If you fill your tank with 60 liters of gasoline, your car will run on what 60 liters of gasoline can produce. If you wait a couple of weeks, you won’t have 600 liters of gasoline in your tank. Might be nice, but it doesn’t happen. So physical causalities does not have amplification.

Karmic causality does have amplification. As a result, from the Buddhist standpoint, even very minor deeds, because of this amplification, call for great care because even very minor deeds can amplify hugely. A sort of ill will towards another person, if unpurified, can eventually turn several lives down into a mind which can only think ill will about others. A mind which is saturated with animosity. So I would say the second general feature of karma leads us to great prudence, great care in the activities of the body, speech, and mind.

The three ways in which we accumulate karma. The third feature of karma is, I put it in a succinct way, not created, not met. That we do not encounter experiences the comma of which we have not created. In other words, no experience of suffering or happiness in this life arises without having a karmic cause. Neutral experiences, that’s another question.

But any experience of happiness or suffering has a karmic cause in a past life, however far removed. And this cause is similar, that’s the first feature of karma, to its result. So Anna’s experience, the horrific experiences in the concentration camp, are, a result of suffering. That result of suffering necessarily has a cause. It’s not random.

This is very shocking, I think, for Westerners to think that what we experience is not random. The car accident is not random. The car accident which leads to suffering has a karmic cause in our past. And the karmic cause is actually, if it’s the result of suffering, is a non virtuous deed. And the fourth, component of karma is that karma is everlasting.

This has to be qualified. Karma is everlasting if it is not purified. But since most of us do not purify anything, for practical purposes, karma is everlasting. This means that the karmic imprints, once a soul, dwell in the mind like time bombs, waiting for the right circumstances to mature. What causes karma to mature?

What causes these karmic imprints to spring into life as it were? What we call the afflictions. The afflictions are those negative states of mind such as desire, hatred, ignorance, and so forth. I remember reading a case in the in the German press actually as reported in Switzerland, which is very interesting in this refrain, and this shows exactly how karma matures. There was a German engineer who was trying for pedophilia in Germany.

And during the trial, the judge was really very taken aback that this man who was completely irreproachable, he’d been, you know, a family man, very good job, no such pattern of behavior at all, such have should should have succumbed to such an extreme rise. And, he was asked, what what happened? What triggered this? And he said that browsing on the Internet, he had seen by accident these images. And the instant he saw them, he was completely overpowered and lost all control over himself.

He was hooked in other words. This is a classic description of the maturation of a karmic imprints. There is a karmic imprint of pedophilia in the mind stream, which is triggered by one instance of desire. Once it is triggered, it is said to be a direct cause. A direct cause is a cause which can no longer be stopped.

Until it has been triggered, it can be purified. Once it’s triggered, it tends to overpower completely the person. Hence, the strategies for dealing with karma are twofold. First, obviously purification of these karmic imprints, which are like time bombs in our mind stream. And we do not know what they are.

That is the the human the this predicament of beings in general. They are in our background, and they just dwell there in the darkness, ready to spring to life. So there are very purify various purification techniques, all of which, generally speaking, imply to a greater or lesser degree a connection with a religious tradition which acknowledges the existence of karma, which means Buddhism or Hinduism. An alternative strategy for dealing with these karmic imprints is at least if we cannot sweep the attic clean, let’s try to make sure nothing ugly comes out of the attic, therefore, to prevent the delusions from arising in the mind. This is a strategy which is adopted by the great

The have not eliminated karmic imprints. They have just eliminated the delusions. And the karmic imprints are still there. The negative karmic imprints are still there, but they can no longer be triggered because desire, hatred, ignorance, pride, and the competitiveness no longer arise in the mind. So the time bombs may be there, but if nobody ever steps on them, they don’t detonate.

So these are the general features, of karma. And then the specific features of karma are first one of the numerous subdivisions of non virtuous deeds, traditionally subdivided into 10 in keeping with, Vasubandhu’s Abhidharmakośa. Obviously, there are far more than 10 non virtuous deeds. This is just a convenient subdivision, to give one a sense of how to behave in a skillful way. And these 10 non virtuous deeds, most of you, know, are three non virtuous deeds of body, which is killing, the most extreme non virtuous deed.

There is no thought of body greater than killing. Both a human being and any living being, the smallest instance of an insect which is killed is an act of killing. Then stealing. Stealing is literally taking what does not belong officially to oneself and has value. Anything you have not been given and which has value, should you take it, entails an act of stealing.

Insurance fraud is stealing, for instance. Taking, let us say, one kilo of leaves from a public park, imagining they have a resale value, is an act of stealing. It’s a public park. The leaves were not given to one, and it has value. Then sexual misconduct.

There are numerous forms of sexual misconduct. First and foremost, adultery. In other words, taking another’s spouse or another’s partner nowadays. In every single case, one inflicts suffering on the other person. One inflicts suffering on the third party in question.

Then there are other forms of sexual misconduct. If you want to live, in keeping with these teachings, I would hardly suggest that you read through them in Then we have four deeds, four non virtuous deeds of speech. First and the most important, lying. Lying is that non virtuous deed of speech where we say or we intimate something with a gesture to another, which is untrue, and he understands and believes it. If those conditions are met, lying has occurred.

It doesn’t have to be a verbal lie. If someone says, are you an arhat? And let’s say I smile and put my head like this, that’s lying. Lying has occurred. The moment he believes, that statement lying has occurred.

A lesson on virtuous deed of speech is divisive speech. Divisive speech is any speech, true or untrue, which separates two people who are close or which prevents two people who are far away from coming close together. It does not have to be slander. If, there is a couple which is calling and they’re thinking of divorce, and you are asked by one of the partners, should I divorce or not? And you say, it seems to me like a good idea.

That is a nonvirtuous deed of divisive speech. It may be perfectly legitimate. The person may be experiencing great suffering. Your advice may be sincere. It is still divisive speech.

Obviously, if you were to tell an untruth in addition, it would be divisive speech and lying as well. Then the third non virtuous deed of speech is harsh words. Harsh words are any words which hurt another person. They do not have to be considered harsh by the majority of people. If the feelings of another person are heard upon hearing them, then these are harsh words.

The fourth non virtuous deed of speech is idle talk, which is any talk which has no, to be technical, no spiritual meaning, which means most of our talk. Specifically, any talk leading to an increase of the delusions, an increase of desire or an increase of anger. So I would say that much of the popular press leads to idle talk. And if you are the classic example of idle talk, I have, or sightseeing idle talk, I have an example every morning when I check my email on Yahoo. It’s endless.

And that is a classic. Gossip about stars, gossip about politics, talk about the weather, talk about others’ private lives, talk about the finances of others, all of this is idle talk. It’s a minor non virtue of speech, but it is a dangerous non virtue of speech because it leads to everything else. And the three non virtues of mind, the last three of the list of 10, are covetousness, which means desiring something, generally speaking, which belongs to another, but not necessarily any form of desire can ultimately fall into covetousness. Ill will, which is a feeling of animosity towards another, justified or not.

He may be your worst enemy. If you bear animosity towards him, this is the non virtuous mental deed of ill will. And then ignorance, not in the broad sense of the term of ignorance as being uneducated, but much more ignorance of the spiritual realities, specifically in a Buddhist context, ignorance or even refusal of karma and causality, ignorance or refusal of the existence of past and future lives. These are potentially or this is potentially a very destructive delusion. So these 10 delusions are not exhaustive.

There are many which are not included. Pride is not included on the mental level. Competitiveness is not included. Blackmail, for instance, is not included. Many forms of physical non virtue are not included, but these are the dominant ones.

And for them to be karmically complete deeds, in other words, deeds which will impel a future life, four features must be present. And it is helpful to understand these four features to understand how to be skillful karmically. So this is a bit of a longish presentation of the Buddhist understanding of karma, but the goal of this presentation, once we would have completed it in ten, fifteen minutes, is for all of us to get a sense of karmic strategies in dealing with our lives. The key to karma is not to be overwhelmed by the notion that karma exists, but to be skillful in purifying what is lurking in our background and then trying to avoid accumulating more in that direction. So for a deed to be complete, four factors must be present.

The basis, the motivation, the performance, and the conclusion. And I will explain them relate in relation to the first non virtuous deed, which is the most severe of all, the non virtuous deed of killing. And you can extrapolate them to the other non virtuous deeds. If you want a detailed presentation, it is provided magnificently in Tsongkhapa’s Lamrim Chenmo. So what is meant when we say that we have committed the non virtuous deed of killing, and it’s a complete deed which will impel in the future one life?

For instance, a rebirth such as Anna’s rebirth as a child of 11 who dies in a concentration camp. This is a life almost certainly impelled by a known virtuous deed of killing since the conclusion of that life is violent death, premature violent death. For a deed in a past life to impel a future life, it must be complete. In other words, all four features must be present. The four features of the deed in the past life which must be present, the deed of killing in this case in a past life, is first the basis.

The basis refers to the victim of killing. Someone must have been killed. It’s not enough to plan someone’s murder, let’s say, or, to try to perform it and the person does not die. In every single case, the basis, is not there, especially if the person is absent and you’ve just been planning this. There is no basis of killing.

The second feature is the motivation. You must wish to kill that person. Accidental death, where you hit someone with your car, is a deed of killing, but it’s not a deed of killing which is complete. Unless at the last moment, you could have avoided hitting that person and for reasons x, z, you did not. Then it will be complete.

The third feature is performance. Performance means that from your side, you must have used some means to do this. It may be a car. It may be a rifle. It may be poison.

Days of yore, it seems to have been poisoned very frequently, actually. And the final feature is conclusion. Conclusion means that the victim must have died. If you had an intended victim and you planned the deed and you tried to poison them, and thanks to the intervention of a doctor, they were saved and did not die, it is not a complete deed of killing. Such a deed cannot be said to create or to impel in the future necessarily a life in which you yourself will be killed.

It is possible, but it is not certain. So then if these four features are necessary for a deed to be complete, Then one of the first key karmic strategies for ourselves when we are at risk of committing a non virtuous deed is to try to make sure that at least one of the four is not there. Generally speaking, the best is to try to avoid that the deed be concluded, the fourth feature. Otherwise, try to bring the motivation down as much as you can. But try in every possible way to make sure that the deed itself is not complete.

Because a complete deed, unless it is purified, will necessarily provoke a future life carried by that deed. Then the next issue in the specific features of karma are issues which amplify karma. It is here that karmic strategies come to the fore, what is called technically the weight of a deed. And I will write these down. I should mention, by the way, that the fourfold, features necessary for indeed of need of killing to be complete apply to every other nonvirtuous deed.

So, it is very much a matter for ourself of trying to make sure that these nonvirtuous deeds we commit are these which are not complete. And then when we commit virtuous deeds, obviously, we want the virtuous deeds to be complete. Right? So you want to weaken the nonvirtuous part and to strengthen the virtuous part. Then the weight of a deed is of extreme importance, and it’s unfortunately something I think almost all Westerners are oblivious to.

Yes? No. As a matter of fact, if you ask someone to do it, it’s worse. Two persons accumulate. I’ll talk about this later on.

Basically, you’re much better off being a murderer than being a president who has ordered a war. A murderer accumulates a non virtue of killing one person. A president who orders a war accumulates a non virtue of every single human being killed as a result of that decision. So for this reason, if you look at the face of politicians who have ordered wars, as they grow older, they are seldom happy faces. Seldom.

I’m afraid because we don’t have a projection system, you get to put up with my handwriting, which is atrocious. So the issue you were addressing arises precisely, when we talk of karmic weight. The weight of a nonvirtuous deed is first contingent on the attitude with which the deed is committed. The same deed of killing committed as in the case of Anna by her mother, where the mother out of compassion sends a child to die on the electrified fence. The deed is greatly weakened because the motivation is compassion.

It is it is a deed of killing because the intention to kill is there. But the maturation of such a deed will be quite mild. Likewise, the maturation of the deed of a she wolf suffocating her cub because her cub cannot survive is a deed done out of compassion. Such a deed would have a very weak effect, such a deed of killing. On the other hand, deeds of killing, which are committed with great rejoicing in the suffering inflicted on another.

The tortures inflicted on the child at the concentration camp had they led to death. Such deeds are not merely heavy as deeds of killing, they become extraordinarily heavy because of the attitude. The attitude is one of happiness and rejoicing in the deed. There’s not the slightest trace of repentance. Such deeds are very, very loaded karmically.

So this is the first key to comic strategies, which is when we commit nonvirtuous deeds, and we all do, try to make the attitude as beneficial as possible. Sexual misconduct, for instance, I believe is is rampant in the West, pretty much everywhere, but in the West especially. Then if the deed is done with a sense of shame and embarrassment, the impact is greatly weakened. If the deed is done in a very self righteous way, very proud way, the deed becomes very heavy and then matures in infidelity for that person in future lives. The second issue connected with weight is a performance of the deed.

The same deed of killing is lighter or heavier if it’s done in a swift, merciful way or in a sadistic and long drawn way. A soldier who has to execute someone in war and who aims for the heart to give a clean death will incur because of the performance of the deed, less karmic impact than the soldier who aims for the stomach thinking, I want him to suffer a long time. You see, this is in terms of performance. Absence of antidote is one of the major factors in karmic weight. It affects, I would say, the overwhelming majority of non religious people.

Nonreligious people do not believe that what they do has any spiritual significance. This covers all world religions. Then when they commit non virtuous deed, there is no repentance. Actually, especially in our society nowadays, what we call guilt, which from a Buddhist standpoint is an extremely virtuous state of mind as long as it applies to guilt for a non virtuous deed we have committed. Guilt is discouraged.

Guilt, if it

Involves guilt towards something wrong we have done is an excellent thing. When we speak of repentance when I translate, I use the term repentance because I know people don’t want to hear about guilt, but guilt is excellent. This is what reduces the weight of the karmic deed. It is actually an antidote. Then there are more formal application of the antidotes in a Buddhist context context such as the four forces.

But every religious person whether Buddhist, Hindu, Christian, Muslim, Jewish who believes in a code of ethics and who fails that code of ethics feels guilt with respect to that failure. That guilt is an antidote which reduces the weight of the karmic deed. It may not purify it completely, but there is certainly partial purification. The greater the guilt, the greater the purification. Do you mind the distinction between guilt and remorse?

I don’t. Okay. When I translate, I have to because I know people don’t want to hear about it, but I don’t. The Tibetan term gypa is exactly the same. You know?

Guilt has a very bad press in the West because guilt entails not feeling good about oneself. And much of modern western spirituality is about feeling good about oneself. None of the authentic spiritual traditions attach any importance whatsoever to feeling good about oneself. It’s much better to think you’re a bad person than to deny Buddha nature. You can live without denying Buddha nature, and you can live denying Buddha nature.

It makes no difference to the ordinary person. If you have a strong sense of your own thoughts, then you’ll become a better person. That’ll have a big impact on all of our lives. Guilt, as long as it’s guilt about non virtuous deeds, is an extremely beneficial state of mind. It is the dawn of purification.

No guilt, no purification. I mean, one can attain a higher rebirth without ever having heard the name Buddha nature. One cannot attain a higher rebirth if one has committed non virtuous deeds and has been no guilt. So this is the reason for which his holy mister Dalai Lama discourages actively the conversion of Westerners to Buddhism. His Holiness has repeatedly over the years asked Westerners not to convert to Buddhism until they have checked their own religious traditions.

The reason for this is very simple. We are rooted in a and the values of that are generally within a spiritual tradition and they resonate within us. Louder or perhaps in a more stiffer way for some of us, but they still resonate. These values are values which we can live easily. Those of us who are raised in Christian societies, we have in the backdrop of our mind the Christian ethos.

It may not be true anymore for the the forthcoming generations, but certainly for those above 40 or 50, this is in the backdrop of their minds. This means that it is much easier for them to lead an ethical life in a Christian context than in a Buddhist context. And we do see among Western converts to Buddhism great difficulty in living ethically. It’s one of the biggest problems, you know. Buddhism is taken on board at the intellectual level.

It’s taken on board at the verbal level and the person’s life as the Tibetans say is all over the place. You know? If they assess their life from the standpoint of the values they were raised in, they feel guilt about the life they need. This shows that they have an innate sense of right and wrong rooted in their own tradition. That that is something which disappears when you change religious traditions and which you have to rebuild.

So for that reason, religious conversion is not something which should be encouraged. And it’s always I said this many times. I remember I could I could quote this one textually. The best religion is a religion of one’s fathers. You know?

Why? You are rooted in it. And the odds are you have been reincarnating as a member of that community for many lives. This is part of who you are. Therefore, as long as and this is this is a qualifier.

As long as the ethical code of that religious tradition is adequate. And I would say of the great religions, certainly the ethical code of Christianity, Judaism, Buddhism, and Hinduism is adequate. With Islam, there are problems. There are very good aspects such as abstention from intoxicants and charity. There are problematical aspects such as the very notion of a holy war, a justified war, which is obviously something which ethically is unacceptable.

But the other four traditions and even many of the world’s minor religions teach a teach codes of ethics which are of benefit. You know? And when person stray from these, then obviously repentance, guilt arises in the mind. This purifies considerably the non virtue incurred. And then past and future, lives exist with the people who believe in them or not.

Then if the known virtue is reduced, a Christian gets a better rebirth. A Jew who feels guilty, for, let us say, having charged exorbitant rates during a loan, you know, or a Muslim who does not want to lend that interest and feels guilty about this, you know, would greatly reduce whatever known virtuous karma is accumulated and will get a better even if they don’t believe in it. Belief here is not important. It’s much better to be a good Christian than a bad Buddhist, to put it bluntly. You know?

Then moving in this is in this matter, I am not expressing my own opinion. I’m literally the mouthpiece of his holiness. You know? I know this is something most new converts to Buddhism do not want to hear because they’re in a process of building a new identity. But their new identity is a lot less important than their karmic future.

Then the fourth feature is clinging to wrong views. Clinging to wrong views adds tremendous weight to a deed because it gives a sense of legitimacy. For instance, clinging to wrong views with respect to killing would be killing with the idea that this is actually virtuous under the circumstances. You find this with the concept of jihad. This is a classic case of killing under the influence of wrong views.

The community, the ummah, is attacked and it is a duty to kill. It’s actually a virtue. This adds great weight to the non virtuous deed. So this aspect of Islam is very problematic. Unless one gives a spiritual reading to jihad, the concept of jihad is not a concept which is acceptable in a Buddhist setting.

You know? And the final feature, and this rejoins your question, is the power of the basis. So the power of the basis is the power of the recipient. In the case of killing, killing a human being is a much more serious non virtuous deed than killing an insect through the power of the basis. Killing a fetus is a much heavier deed than killing, for instance, an adult through the power of the basis.

A fetus is powerless. Abortion from a Buddhist standpoint is an extremely heavy deed comically, especially abortion performed by a mother because this is a mother killing her own child. So to start with, the child is powerful in the state of the fetus where he is powerless, totally at the mercy of the mother, and then especially in late term abortions often with what has to be called, great cruelty, you know, but that could be heavy in terms of performance. Then deeds which are weighty in terms of the basis obviously are one’s parents. Parasite and matricide are in a Buddhist context, considered to be deeds of immediate retribution.

Even striking one’s parents, I was very shocked when I returned to Switzerland and now in Australia, at the number of children who strike their parents. This is something which is which is just out of out of the realm of imagining. These are deeds which are very powerful to the power of the recipient because of the kindness the parents have shown shown to their children. Certainly, in the case of killing one’s parents, these are core deeds of immediate retribution. There is no bardo.

You know, there’s no intermediate state. The person seeks straight down. And then as you were saying, for many beings, killing a large number of beings. It happens very easily. For the walking around, everyone stomps on ants intentionally.

One is killing tens, maybe hundreds of beings. Then obviously ordering more. That is an instance which is extraordinarily heavy. It is heavy in terms of the attitude. It is heavy in terms of the performance because the death is often atrocious under bombs.

It is heavy because there is no antidote. It is heavy in terms of clinging to wrong views because one feels self righteous and legitimated in giving this order. And it is heavy in terms of the basis because of the large number of victims. So such deeds, the heavier they are, the faster the maturation. At a certain point with the very heavy deeds, there is maturation in this life.

And then we will move onwards. I will go a little bit over time today, if that’s okay with you, not too much. So just to return briefly to the weight here, karmic strategies are obviously to diminish to the maximum the weight of non virtuous deeds, to increase to the maximum the weight of virtuous deeds. This is why it is said in the Tibetan tradition, the non virtuous deeds of the the non virtuous deeds of the wise are light and the non virtuous deeds of the foolish are heavy. Because the wise reduce the weight of the non virtuous deeds.

If, let us imagine, extreme situation killing had to occur, it would be done with regret swiftly with as little pain as possible, and antidotes would be immediately applied. This is a this is a non virtuous deed of the wise. Of the foolish, it would be done in any which way. No antidotes would be applied. There would be rejoicing in the deed, and the deed is very heavy.

The first question is the intention. If the intention is to reduce the pain and not to kill, that’s the question. If the intention is to reduce the pain, then it is not a fully qualified need of killing even if kill death occurs as a result. But if there is this unstated position, yes, we’re giving the morphine to reduce the pain, but actually it’s gonna kill him and that’s, you know, our actual goal, then a full deed of killing has occurred. It’s in the mind of the personnel in palliative care and of the treating doctor that this occurs.

And then, obviously, even if a deed of killing occurs, if it occurs through compassion, it’s still a deed of killing. The weight is reduced. A deed of killing which occurs through hatred. For instance, if one kills oneself, if one commits suicide, through great anger with oneself, it’s a full deed of killing, and it’s a very heavy deed of killing. If one were to commit suicide as many Tibetans did when facing torture, you know, to try not to implicate friends, then it still is a deed of killing, but it’s a greatly more weakened deed of killing, and there are virtuous states of mind which are accompanying it.

Whether such a deed matures or not is open to question. I’ll finish, however, the material and then we will have a a period for questions if it’s okay. So what I would like to broach with you now is a notion of the karmic weight of commitments. Commitments. In other words, vows.

There is a tremendous different between difference in karmic weight between the deed committed by someone without vows and the deed committed by someone with vows. And, here, we have to understand the clear distinction, which is something I think which is hard for us as Westerners to understand between merely abstaining from a deed accidentally and vowing not to do a deed. Most of us, for instance, do not kill. I mean, in Australia, it occurs very seldom. This is accidental.

It is because we live in a safe society. Our abstaining from killing in that context leads to no virtuous karma whatsoever. There’s no intent from our part not to kill. It just happens that nobody is assaulting us in the streets. When one takes the vow not to kill, it’s radically different.

Merely taking that vow causes one to accumulate great virtuous comma because that vow is a statement never will I kill whatever are the circumstances. Even if I am attacked, I will not defend myself. This is a very powerful karmic decision. Such a decision, because of the impact it has on the psyche, amplifies all of the other deeds we do. So if we have one vow not to kill ever, then all of the other deeds we do or such a person does become more powerful because of that vow.

The person is transformed by that vow, in other words. Then if we have the lay vows, for instance, however many we can take, five, four, three, two, even one. Everything we do is amplified by the power of those lay vows. Each of those vows, when it is taken, creates an uninterrupted stream of virtuous karma in the mind because it’s not just a matter of saying, I’m not, you know, I’m not gonna kill, but, you know, if someone comes at me with an axe, I may reassess my decision. It’s radically different.

It’s never ever will I kill. Never ever will I drink. Never ever will I commit sexual misconduct in the case of the lay vows. Each of these creates a powerful stream of virtue within the mind, which is accumulated by day and by night whether we are conscious or not and transforms all of the other deeds we perform. Then the next level of vows are the vows of those who take ordination.

It’s called vows of individual liberation, Prātimokṣa vows. These vows are much more powerful because you have, in some cases, 36, in other cases, 227 or 253 vows. Each vow creates what is called a stream of abandonment within the mind stream. If we abandon killing, it’s a stream of abandonment of killing. If we have the 5 lay vows, it’s five streams of abandonment.

If we have the 36 vows of a novice monks, it’s 36 streams of abandonment in the mind stream. Here we have the 227 vows of a bhikṣu, of course, in some traditions 250 and some. These are 227 or 250 streams of individual virtuous streams of abandonment within the mind stream which are created, like threads within the mind. Then what such a person does with such vows is more powerful. It is more powerful to the power of the base that person themselves.

For good or for bad. Vows, in other words, act like karmic amplifiers. So one of the key karmic strategies is to incorporate within our life or our lives the karmic amplifiers which we can control. Take on board enough, but not too much. The more we take on board, the more powerful our deeds become.

So if we are leading lifestyles where we are not able to lead very controlled lifestyles, we have to be very careful about taking on board a lot of vows. Because each vow which is broken creates an uninterrupted stream of negativity within the mind. Vows are like a sword which runs both ways. It can cut to the out, to the in. So the key comic strategy using vows is to assess realistically our lifestyle.

What community am I living in? Am I living in a lay community? Am I living in a monastic community? Am I living in a religious country? Am I living in a totally atheistic and hedonistic country?

What sort of a job do I have?

Things to say I’m a soldier, then then we have to be terribly careful. You know? And then to skillfully add on top of one’s own life those vows which give greater reach to our virtuous deeds, but which are not so heavy that if we are in the situation to commit non virtuous deeds, those non virtuous deeds return in our face. So this is the skillful use of vows. There are three categories of vows.

The so called Prātimokṣa vows, the vows of individual liberation, which are vows for laymen and laywomen, vows for novice monks and novice nuns, vows for fully ordained monks and fully ordained nuns. They are the vows with the least amplification. But they are easy to keep. Very easy to keep. They are just physical vows.

Physical and verbal, you know, it’s quite easy to control. The next category of vows is the Bodhisattva vows. The Bodhisattva vows are much more powerful because they are vows we take with the goal of helping an infinite number of others. The amplifying power of the vow is very great. Then such vow should be taken very carefully, because the vow can turn against the person who took it.

And the highest category of vows are the three, tantric, excuse me, the tantric vows. And then certainly in this tradition, the Gelug tradition, one has encouraged the to become what is known as the bearer of the three vows. In other words, a fully ordained monk who has bodhisattva and tantric vows. Then the power of karmic amplification of such a person is tremendous. And such a person then becomes his or her best friend or his or her worst enemy.

It is much better to be a lay person who goes around killing, raping, and stealing than to be a monk who steals just one bag of tea from the dharma center. In other words, takes a bag of tea without permission. That’s what means to steal here. Because the layperson, the power of the base is weak. There’s no amplification.

The monk, the power of the bass is huge. And then if you add the other vows on top, it’s even greater. So this was the notion of the karmic weight of commitment. And then karmic results, I will cover quick quickly. And after that, I think we will pass directly to questions and answers if you have survived the experience so far.

There are three categories of karmic results. The results of maturation, the so called causally concordant results, and the environmental results. So one karmic imprint can lead in the strongest case to what is called I’m sorry. I don’t know the English terms by heart. A result of maturation which is a full life.

In the case, for instance, of Anna, which we covered, three of the lives were human. That is a result of maturation from virtuous deeds in the past. She obtained in three lives of human rebirth. One of the life was animal as a fox or wolf cub. That’s a result of maturation of a non virtuous deed in the past.

Then you have the causally concordant results. The causally concordant results are events within the life of the person which are similar in aspect to the cause which creates them. So we talked about this in the case of Anna. Some of these horrific experiences, for instance, let us say, the experience of being burned at the stake in the second life she remembered, is similar in aspect to a karmic cause in her past. In other words, since the experience was suffering and death due to fire, the karmic cause must have been inflicting suffering and death due to fire.

How far back, we do not know. It seems to have matured in at least two lives since it matured in one life as death at the stake and in another life as death through electrocution. So in that case, the result is similar in aspect to the cause, and you can extend this by extrapolation to the other cases. Then environmental results are the karmic results due to deeds in the past which lead to our environment, the area we live in. Typically, it is said, for instance, an environmental result of sexual misconduct would be to be born in a very dirty place.

In Anna’s case, the environmental result she faced was being born in areas of great violence in three lives and being born in communities or tribes. So this is an environmental result which arises from a cause in her past where most probably she harmed communities. Through harming being born in a community and harming a community, she created the environmental result of being born in a in a community in the future and being harmed herself by that community. How far back this happened? What exactly it was, we cannot say.

And then the last distinction I would like to make here, and then we will address your questions, is the distinction between impelling and completing karma. Impelling karma is the karma which impels or propels one full life, or as a Asaṇga says, several lives. The actual rebirth, in other words. The impelling karma for Anna’s three human rebirths would be three virtuous deeds in the past or one virtuous deed leading to these full human rebirths. The completing karma is what fleshes out the story in that life.

The details within the life, it’s not exactly details, but within the context of a life they are. The sufferings experienced, the mode of death, the relation with the mother. These would be generated through the completing karma. It is perfectly possible to have good completing karma, which is a good impelling karma, which is Anna’s case, with three human rebirths and horrific completing karma. With one rebirth ending up in a concentration camp and dying on an electrified fence and another rebirth being burned at the stake by one’s village.

The impending karma is good. The completing karma is horrific. An instance of the opposite, horrific impelling karma and excellent, completing karma would be, for instance, the case of, your pet dog or cat, who has the karma of being reborn as an animal, which is a rebirth of great limitations. But the completing karma is very good. He’s a chouchou of his master or his mistress.

You know? And that’s very nice. You know? So this is the distinction between impelling and completing karma. And I think with this, we have covered everything I wanted to cover today.

And if you have any questions, I’m happy to answer them. Yes. Yes, please. If you if you check the statistics, of Helen Wambach, which I gave to you, most of the modes of death are peaceful, the recollected deaths. What happens is obviously people who come for hypnotic past life regression generally come because of major issues in this life, phobias or obsessions.

Phobias or obsessions are almost always connected with the mode of death in a past life, which is generally difficult. So there’s a preselection which occurs. If you were to take a group like this and hypnotically regress everybody, assuming you all had memories, most of you would have memories of peaceful deaths. I’d say two thirds would have memories of peaceful deaths. However, those who were to come to a psychiatrist to ask to be regressed, odds are the memory would be of a difficult death.

Odds are. Odds are. Are there other questions? Yes. Anna?

Do you know what happened to Anna? I don’t have a clue. The case is anonymous. Liz, actually, actually improved a lot. After having tried various modes of psychotherapy, this had a cathartic effect.

Why it had a cathartic effect from a Buddhist standpoint is open to question. I think personally because this process of recollection goes hand in hand with a process, an implicit process of confession and regret. And that liberates the person from most of the experience. But we don’t know what happened. Yes.

Yes. Yes. Well, I would suspect in a case like this that what you have is a steady stream of crossover. That’s what I would suspect. The mother reincarnating as a daughter, the daughter reincarnating as a mother, but you have only four lives of a stream.

There’s no dates, so we don’t know by how many other lives they are separated. Then the sort of material is is limited. One can only conclude so much. You know? But that’s what I would suspect.

Yes. That’s what I would suspect. Yes. Yes. Yes.

Yes. I’m sorry? But there is collective karma, but it’s it’s a it’s accumulated individually by members of the community. For instance, let us take I never know if I can take these controversial examples or not in the world we live in anymore. You know?

Let us imagine, I suppose one could, the September 11. And you have you make a karmic analysis of what happened. The karma of killing was accumulated by the radicals on the plains collectively. Now that’s a a small collective karma. However many radicals there were, you know, accumulated the karma of killing those 2,000 and some persons.

Then all those who rejoiced in that deed accumulated the karma of killing as well collectively. All those who are watching television on their days rejoiced and then function of the weight of the deed, greater or lesser. You know, if they rejoiced greatly, if they legitimized it, then the karmic weight of the deed is perhaps heavier for the person rejoicing than for the person committing the deed. In terms of the result, what happens is that all those who committed a deed together or rejoiced in it will experience the result, generally speaking, together in the future. So the karmic analysis of what happened on the September 11, I will just go out on a limb here.

This is my personal reflection, based on karmic principles. If you think a little bit on what happened, you have Islamic radicals attacking a high building in which mainly, Christians and some Jews lived. Most of the victims fell to their death or were burned to death. So from their side, the karmic experience of falling to one’s death or similar or or being burned alive is similar to the result which caused it in the in their past, which is causing others to fall to their death or burning them alive. It will be inflicted by those to whom they caused this to be inflicted in the past, generally speaking, because once again, the effect is similar to the cause.

So it will be inflicted to the it was inflicted, upon them by Islamic radicals. One can infer they inflicted this on Muslims in the past. This was standard, during the Crusades in, the besiegement of the, Arabic fortresses in Palestine. The fortresses were besieged. Greek fire was used to break the will of the inhabitants of the fortress.

Greek fire was a mixture of phosphorus and bitumen, the the ancient equivalent of the flamethrower. And more often than not, the inhabitants would commit suicide by jumping from the battlements, to avoid the, wrath of the Crusaders. So although we cannot say that the two thousand three hundred victims of the September 11 were in past lives crusaders who caused such a death to be inflicted on Muslims, there is a possibility. It would make sense comically. Those who attacked in turn, would be connected directly to the victims, inflicting on those who had tormented them in past lives the very tortures which they had experienced.

And what is very striking to me or was very striking to me at the PLA, I heard about this in India, was that the dialectics of the crusade erupted immediately in the mouth of the politicians concerned. And these are politicians which had no particular knowledge of history. Bush, actually, who by all accounts was not terribly interested in history, spontaneously used this terminology and identified with something, I think, probably in his own karmic past. The very same dialectic was used by mister Bin Laden. So if we analyze these events karmically, we cannot say this with certainty.

This is extrapolation. But the comic result of the exactions committed by the Frankish knights in Palestine between the eleventh and the thirteenth century. It is said that when the Crusaders captured Jerusalem by a Christian witness of the period, they waited knee deep in blood. It was that bad. Everyone.

Muslims, Jews, know, Christians, you know, the Armenian Christians, everyone is killed. You know? That karmic imprints perhaps is one of the imprints which matured during the September 11. It’s very striking that these two leaders of the communities, because they came to be perceived as leaders of their respective communities, reenacted this dialectic of the Crusades. It is something with which they were very well acquainted.

So this is a possible analysis of what happened. And that would be how collective karma would work. You know? There’s nothing we experience in term of sufferings which we have not sown ourselves. There’s nothing we as a community experience of which we are not guilty.

That sense of guilt is the most powerful tool for purification. That leads to atonement. No guilt, no atonement. The greater the rejoicing in the perpetuation of the deeds, the greater the amplification. This is why the advice his holiness the Dalai Lama gave to president Bush was very, very powerful.

It was interesting that the period was not really reported in the press which was made public. The Dalai Lama who has very good English and doesn’t have to use these terms said, no captain of war can ever overcome all his enemies. He never did say no president, no prime minister. He directly projected the president of The United States back in the role of a crusader chieftain. So this might be how those things work.

Does that make sense? This is just speculative. You know? This is but these principles of karmic algebra are what we experience within our lives. And then to decrypt our lives, to decrypt history and the experience history is the the collective experience of the community.

We can apply these principles. And then we get a very clear sense of how to prevent our lives from perpetuating these patterns and how to prevent history from perpetuating these patterns. So I’m afraid reaction of the West to this situation was one which guaranteed the perpetuation of this pattern. Yes? So there is no principle that the greater the negativity.

Thank you. There is no principle that the greater, the negativity, the more immediate, the karmic consequence. There is. Well, five hundred years or whatever. Seven hundred years seems like a long time.

Yes. But we don’t know what happened to these people individually. Right? Each one of them individually. Let’s take this example.

As I said once again, it’s hypothetical. Each one of these crusaders individually, and there

Accounts of hypnotic regressions leading to crusader past lives. It tends to be ghastly business. So the the romantic image of the crusader as a pious knight is something which has nothing to do with the crusader’s reality. But each one of these men would, in their own individual past lives, have karmic fruitions connected with violence and so forth. But they would experience together at some point what they had inflicted together.

That, unfortunately, they would have to experience as well. Does that answer your question? There’s a case Woolger. This was Woolgar, regressed, of an American homosexual. There’s a lot of pent up anger and strong pedophiliac tendencies.

Who came to see, Woolger’s, one of the leading British psychiatrists working with regression, came to see Woolger and Woolger was able to regress him to a series of past lives moving backwards into lives of horrific, absolutely horrific cruelty, and ending in one life as a crusader where, he actually captured a young boy and used him for a long period of time before before executing him. And these memories, once they were brought back to the surface, had a very powerful cathartic effect on this man, and he was able to change, his mode of behavior. So all of us here, you know, we have some of these things in our background, maybe hopefully not as much as this, you know. And all of us, you know, should try to use strategies of purification to try to prevent the past from catching up with us and use also strategies to try to make sure that in the future, we do not have more horrific experiences, especially in the world we’re going into. So oh, yes, please.

Both. You have an effect which is similar to the cause. Having killed in the past life, you yourself will be killed in a future life. In addition to that, having killed in the past life, you have an effect in the future of habituation to killing, which is that you yourself will like to kill. You will enjoy killing.

And you see in young children these karmic effects of habituation very powerfully. You take young children ages three or four, and you get a very clear sense of where they may have come from. Some young children are quiet and stay in a corner. They like to study. Otherwise, others like to fight.

Others enjoy killing literally. For with no provocation, they take a small animal, they torture it. Others spontaneously steal. They think stealing is something very pleasant to do. This is the karmic result or the karmic maturation of habituation.

So if one is still, there is still coming in and. Yes. There’s this big debate as I was saying between Vasubandhu and Asaṇga, but whether one karmic imprints impels one life or not. The consensus is that one karmic imprint can impel many lives and, unfortunately, many maturation, not just one. It would be nice if it was.

Normally, it would be nice if it was. That’s why we we are told to rejoice when difficulties befall us because it means that karma is maturing. What tends to happen is that there is partial maturation, and in the next life, the person will experience situations of great danger, will be aggressed, may or may not be killed depending on the power of the initial karmic imprints. Well, all effects are similar to the action, but one karmic deed, one cause, it can lead to one effect, which is a life. Let’s say if you kill, you’ll be reborn as an animal.

Or it can be completing karma within that life. You manage to be reborn as a human being because of other virtue, but in that life you are killed. You may even be reborn several times as a human being through having accumulated considerable merit through protecting ethics, And yet you have this parallel stream. These are like the threads. Right?

The parallel stream of killing. And in every one of those lives, you will be killed. And you do see when you associate with people who have that sort of background that karmic imprints in your own mind are activated. I saw this several times in my life, you know. It’s quite striking when you see it happen.

That’s how collective karma seems to work. If you have a moment, I’ll tell you an anecdote. Are you very tired? I feel sorry. When I was at Sera, you know, I had to travel back and forth from Bangalore a lot by car.

We never had cars since I had my driver. He was a monk, very good, big four wheel drive despite the robes in India, you know, buses, trucks, and everything. There was always he and I in the car, and I was ordained at the period. And then one day, there was this Danish girl, very young, you know, with her boyfriend. And she wanted to go to Bangalore and she was quite poor.

So she asked me if she could come in the car with her friend, you know. I said, yes. Okay. Why not? You know.

So she came in the car and we start, you know. Just normal driving. And my driver then had to pass. It was a bus the first time. As he is passing the bus, and we are on this side of the road, this small road, a truck arrives from the opposite direction.

And I I honestly thought it was over for all of us. And he went off on the hard side and managed to get the car back on. So we were really, you know, a bit shocked. A mere fifteen minutes later, the same thing happens this time again, but with a truck in front of us and a bus coming from behind. And my driver says to me, Ilya, Tenzin Tempa, what’s going on?

We’ve never had this you and I before. What’s happening? We we both knew something particular was going on. And the girl in the back says, oh, this happens to me. She didn’t know what you’re saying to me.

This happens to me all the time. She said, 19. She said, I almost died in the Sahara on a camelback. I got lost and they found me when I was within an inch of death. So I said that to my driver and then we were doing mantra all the way.

So that is the karma of the girl. And when you’re in a community with her, you start participating in that. Some karmic imprints from our past, his and mine, were triggered. We didn’t have the karma to die, but we had we had the karma for other difficult things. You know?

So that was the anecdote. Yeah. Yes. The comment that what the term whether you have. It’s hard to say normally the strength.

Wow. Normally the strength. But when you go into the details of this matter, it becomes very quickly so complex and so subtle. It’s very difficult to know for a given deed if it will be a completing karma or an impelling karma. And then you have issues in addition to the strength such as the power of intention, which is what we call the power of prayer.

Prayer is intention. If you pray for a deed to mature in a certain direction in a life as a human being, then the energy, the karmic energy is oriented in that direction. So I think we will call it quits for today. Thank you very much. Would you like to just join me in thanking Ilya for such a cogent and challenging presentation?

And I would like to invite you to check out the newsletter, the website. There are teachings here throughout the week, throughout the months and the years, and especially about purification. And if you’re interested in today’s seminar, then tell your friends and grab a pamphlet about the next one on the March 13 and another one on the April 24 and then May 8. And the next topic will be Buddhism in the forthcoming dark ages. In the face face of the forthcoming global crisis, how can Buddhists be of help to themselves, yourself, and to others?

So we hope that we’ll see you again. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
completing karma drubje kyi lä (Tib)
Also called finishing karma, the karmic imprints that ripen to determine the type of experiences we have when we are reborn, as opposed to throwing karma that determines the actual rebirth. LYWA
Gelug
The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
individual liberation
The liberation from cyclic existence achieved by a hearer (shravaka) or solitary realizer (pratyekabuddha), as compared with the full enlightenment of a buddha sought in the Mahayana. LYWA
intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
possessed result
One of four ways we can experience the result of an action, also called environmental result; possessed result is the environment we find ourselves in when we take rebirth. LYWA
tantric vows sang ngag kyi dom pa (Tib)
Vows taken by tantric practitioners. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top