TBI Recordings

2 h 38 min · 18,454 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Other recordings (Ilia Durovic)
Other recordings (Ilia Durovic)
TBI Recordings
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 158-minute seminar, Ilia Durovic presents a sweeping examination of reincarnation from scholarly, empirical, and Buddhist perspectives. He begins by mapping world religions according to how they treat rebirth, showing that reincarnation is marginal to monotheistic traditions but central to Buddhism and Hinduism. He then traces the history of Western scientific investigations into past-life memories, from hypnotic regression cases in nineteenth-century Russia to Ian Stevenson’s landmark spontaneous-case research at the University of Virginia, which documented 2,500 instances between 1961 and 2007. Durovic analyses four major case studies—David Llewelyn, the Pollock twins, the Īśvara twins, and Maung Aung Tho—highlighting birthmarks, personality transmission, behavioural phobias, and physical deformities that correspond to past-life trauma. He addresses methodological strengths and weaknesses, explores why violent deaths dominate remembered lives, and discusses the relationship between Stevenson’s findings and Buddhist karma theory, concluding that this research is a crucial bridge for Western practitioners seeking conviction in rebirth.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Reincarnation.mp3

UUID: 586c146d-ee5b-4f87-90b6-2cb275c0c83e

Teacher: Ilia S. Durovic

Collection: TBI Recordings

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~18,470

It’s yeah. Very warm welcome everybody to this afternoon seminar with Ilya. My name is Chris and it’s my pleasure to introduce Ilya to you. We’re very fortunate to have such a gifted translator here at TBI and, he’s here because of his devotion and loyalty to our teacher Khensur Rinpoche. Ilya comes with many skills and abilities in both Western and traditional Tibetan philosophy, having studied and fluent in many languages, including having translated for His Holiness the Dalai Lama in French, and comes with a deep insight into Western thought, literature, theology, and we’re very fortunate that he’s able to also embody the practice of Buddhism having been a monk for many years and studied in the monasteries, and is able to give a presentation not just in an academic sense, but also from his own deep realizations which, including reflections on the meeting of East and West, and I think one of the pivotal and core subjects that interests many of us in the West, and is central to Buddhism, of course, is the whole teaching on rebirth, reincarnation, past, future lives, and, the whole notion of karma and what we can do to, address the problem of suffering in our lives is contingent on this topic, so, we’re very fortunate that Ilya is able to bring his vast experience over many years to help us, grapple with these issues.

So, without any further ado, I’d like to hand over to Ilya. And then some of you here are Buddhists, others are not. So those who are Buddhist, if they feel like, can join me in taking refuge before this teaching since we will be covering specifically Buddhist material. And those who are not Buddhist can just relax and sit down quietly in their chairs and watch the rest of us. So we’ve had a series of talks this year, which in a sense have been leading us up to this talk.

As I have mentioned to several of you over the last two years, I have been coming here. My personal feeling is that one of the problems in the transmission of the Buddhist teachings to the West is that the gap between the present state of Western society and the level at which the teachings on Buddhism start is not bridged. So the goal of these talks has been to bridge this gap. And this final talk, I think, is really the final step in this respect. The Lam Rim teachings, which are the beginning of Buddhist teachings for the Tibetans and most Asians.

Lam Rim used to be taught in ancient India, albeit in a different form. The Lam Rim teachings start with disciples who believe in reincarnation, for whom reincarnation is a fact of life. This is not at all the case in the West, and therefore we have tried to build up to this concept, and I would like to cover today the issue of reincarnation from several different standpoints. First, I would like to present a typology of world religions from the standpoint of reincarnation. So as you know, we presented during these courses a typology of religions from the standpoint of ontology.

We will now look briefly, because it’s not the main thrust of this conference, on a typology of world religions from the standpoint of reincarnation. And then we will cover the attempts at empirically demonstrating the reality of reincarnation in the West. It may be somewhat painstaking, but it is extremely beneficial as it does convey a very strong sense, you will see, that there is a reality of reincarnation. It’s not just part of the Buddhist world view which we sort of take on board tentatively. And to put it rather bluntly and directly, there is no Buddhism without reincarnation.

Buddhism stands or falls on the issue of reincarnation. It’s a nonnegotiable point. Someone who does not believe in reincarnation is not a Buddhist, nor can he be, for that matter, a Hindu or a Jain. These are it’s a shared premise of what we have called in earlier talks of Gangetic traditions. So this was the reason last time I presented a brief analysis of Stephen Batchelor’s positions as representative of precisely the type of predicament so many westerners are in, a natural attraction to Buddhism and Buddhist philosophy, at the same time, a cultural incapacity or a repugnance to accept the notion of reincarnation.

Now you will see based on today’s talk that the charges I levied against Steve last time seem fair to me, because there is a very large body of serious work which has been done in the nineteenth and especially the twentieth century, which establishes that in some cases, reincarnation does occur, and that is some of the material we’ll be covering today. So first, regarding the typology of world religions from the standpoint of reincarnation, This is relevant for us because, generally speaking, the cases of reincarnation which are studied tend to occur in societies which believe in reincarnation. So it is important for us to understand what these societies are. And also it is important to understand the organic religious and philosophical context in which reincarnation is present. Some religious systems lend themselves to the integration of the notion of reincarnation better than others, some do not.

So broadly speaking, if we were to consider the three broad groups of religions, theistic religions subdivided into monotheistic and polytheistic religions, and the one well known case of atheistic religions, which is Buddhism. And if we were to try to see how the notion of reincarnation is integrated or not within these religious traditions, we would find that within the monotheistic religions, specifically the so called revealed monotheistic religions, which represent Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, reincarnation has very short shrift indeed. None of the three great monotheistic religions accepts or acknowledges reality, the reality of reincarnation. And I put this one rather bluntly precisely because there’s a strong tendency now among members of the monotheistic religions to try to drag reincarnation into the picture. So the reason all three revealed monotheistic religions give very little shift or very little space to reincarnation, actually do not acknowledge it, is because reincarnation limits the power of the almighty creator, which is predicated as the root of the universe and is revealing himself within history for the monotheistic religions.

Now each of the monotheistic religions actually has certain sects which accept the existence of reincarnation, but they are minoritarian. In the case of Judaism, it’s Kabbalah and the Hasidic teachers who accept the existence of reincarnation. In the case of Christianity, Origenist Christianity acknowledges the existence of reincarnation. Origen was a great Christian church father of the late second century of our era. In the case of Islam, the so called Ismaili and Druze sects acknowledge the existence of reincarnation.

In every single case, this is a minority position which puts those schools massively at odds with the dominant tradition. In every single case, in the case of Kabbalah and to a degree the Hasid, in the case for Christianity, of originistic Christianity, and in the case of Islam with the Ismaili and Druze traditions, you will find that the concept of reincarnation enters these traditions through Plato’s thought, through Neo Platonism. So we covered Plato’s thought briefly a couple teachings back. It is through Plato and before Plato from Pythagoras that a subterranean current in Western thought, which believes in reincarnation, has been present. And I do emphasize subterranean because it was not a dominant view even in the classical world, in other words, in the Greco Roman world.

And when the monotheisms took over in the case of the West Christianity, and in the case of much of the Middle East Islam, reincarnation became very much the preserve of the esoteric movements. This is not at all the case in Asia, where belief in reincarnation has, broadly speaking, been dominant. So we have now covered the monotheistic religions. In the context of polytheistic religions, the issue of reincarnation is much more congenial with polytheistic, in other words, religions with many gods, simply because it does not confront face on the issue of limiting the power of an almighty creator. And broadly speaking, polytheisms can be divided into two groups, those which accept reincarnation, which would be for instance Hinduism, and those which do not accept reincarnation, which is the vast majority of the religions of the classical world, in other words, traditional Greek religion and traditional Roman religion, again, with the exception of the mystery cults.

And then we have the one atheistic religion, perhaps the one only major atheistic religion in the history of religions, is Buddhism, which does not acknowledge the existence of a creator. In other words, does not acknowledge the existence of a god as the term is used in western religions, for which reincarnation is central. Reincarnation is central for Buddhism because it is not only the basis of the of the underlying cosmology, it provides the foundation for ethics. In the monotheistic tradition, the foundation for ethics is simply the will of the creator, you know. If you read for instance the 10 commandments, the 10 commandments are passed on to the Hebrew nation by Moses with a sole justification that they are the will of the creator, no other justification is advanced.

In the case of the Buddhist tradition, in addition to the Buddhist conviction that reincarnation is a reality, there is also the fact that reincarnation, when connected with karma and causality, provides the foundation for ethics. Therefore, a Buddhist standpoint, reincarnation is nonnegotiable, as we were saying earlier. There’s no there is no margin of maneuver in this respect. It is perfectly legitimate not to accept the existence of reincarnation, but in that case, one cannot say one is a Buddhist. So having covered this material, and I must apologize it’s rather brief, but it just helps us to set the ideas.

The question we have to ask then from a contemporary standpoint is, how do we understand the issue of reincarnation? So I would put it to you that from a contemporary standpoint, the issue of reincarnation is directly connected to what philosophers call the mind body problem. In other words, the relation between the mind and the body. The contemporary consensus, which I think is broadly speaking, the scientific consensus, explicit or implicit, is that the mind is an epiphenomenon, a manifestation of the brain’s activity. In other words, when the brain ceases to function at a death, the mind ceases.

Now this is not necessarily formulated in terms which are as blunt as this, but this is very much the implicit message. And this has generated a tremendous anguish in the West, which we have covered in the last talk, since this is de facto, a strong, from a Buddhist standpoint, a strong nihilistic position. And there have been subterranean currents within the orthodox scientific establishment which have tried to analyze the phenomenon of the mind to establish whether it could indeed be said to be a mere byproduct of the activity of the brain or not. Much of this work has somewhat unfairly in my opinion, being discredited, where initially the methodology in many cases was quite sound. It’s broadly lumped in what we now call parapsychology.

And parapsychology has a very little audience now in the University Millieux, which is rather unfortunate. But in every single case, I think one can say that one of the core issues in parapsychology is this issue of the relationship of mind and body or mind and matter. It is such a sensitive issue since from a modern scientific standpoint, certainly from the standpoint of modern biology and even from the standpoint of modern physics, there is no such thing as a nonmaterial mind. And therefore, one of the problems much of the research in this field has had to face is that the burden of proof, which is requested from investigations in this field is much higher than that which is requested from investigations in other field. And you will see, and it’s quite striking when one does some research in this field, that there have been remarkable studies which seem to establish the existence of a non material mind, and yet they have almost no impact.

It’s almost as if the standard of proof has become so high that it is impossible to establish the reality of a nonmaterial mind. And this was a bit the sense I got in preparing these these con

References that the bias of the culture and the bias of the scientific world is so great that in a sense, it becomes almost irrelevant what evidence we bring forth. It may very well never be accepted. So I would not enter in detail here with in the the research which was done, I would like to quote some of it just from memory before we pass to the directly to the scope of our talk today. Much of the research in this field was initiated in England and in France with the colonial age. It is really the colonial age which put the West in contact with the East, which brought to the fore the questions of not merely the survival after death, but the survival after death over many lives of a mind.

And a series of societies were created to investigate these phenomena. Perhaps one of the most famous of them is a Society for Psychical Research, which was created in London in 1882, and whose American branch was created in 1885. These societies have played a big role since actually some of professor Stevenson’s early work, which we’ll be referring to largely in the second part of this talk, were contributed in the context of papers submitted to the American Society for Psychical Research. The second group of researchers who investigated the nature of mind and the possibility of mind being a nonmaterial phenomenon were the researchers who investigated telepathy. Telepathy for us is a fundamental phenomenon since if telepathy can be established objectively, we have established or we have a very high odds for the establishment of the minds being a non material phenomenon.

Much of the research in this field was done by Rhine at Duke University, but one of his greatest forerunners, whose research in my opinion is much more interesting, perhaps because he had far fewer scruples in Rhine, is a great Soviet researcher, Leonid Vasilyev, whose research on telepathy at the University of Leningrad is pioneering research. The third broad category of research, again, on the nonmaterial nature of the mind, actually is military. Vasilyev’s research became military very quickly, Vasilyev actually disappeared in the sixties, and it seems was transferred to one of the Soviet military cities. The US Navy pioneered extensive research in telepathy and then what is called remote viewing in the context of the Stanford Research Institute. The goal, obviously, of telepathy from a military standpoint was communication with nuclear submarines, undetectable communication, and the goal of remote viewing was intelligence.

The research at the Stanford Research Institute has been partly declassified. What they called remote viewing, we would have called in the old days clairvoyance or precognition, and some of the results they obtained are quite extraordinary. This research actually is of the highest caliber. It was done under the edges of two of America’s leading physicists, Targ and especially Puthoff, a very famous quantum physicist. And then we come to the scope of our talk today, which is research on reincarnation.

Research on reincarnation actually starts a lot earlier than is widely believed. The earliest case I could trace of memories of past lives with hypnotic regression dates back to 1862. It was actually performed by the Russian scientist and musician, prince Nikolay Borisovich Galitsyn, who was able in 1862 to regress through hypnosis, a Hessian, no, the German servant made, to a previous life in which she turned out to speak fluent French, which she had never learned. Now French was a court language at the Russian court, so Galitsyn was obviously for practical purposes native in French. And he actually, it’s quite extraordinary in a case this early, checked her memories.

She actually remembered being an Italian countess whose name he does not give in full, he only gives the initial countess y. And he tracked the previous incarnation down to Italy and found indeed that as the Hessian maid has said, in a previous life, as the Italian counter, she had murdered her husband. And according to her, this was, you know, or the result of this was that she had been born as a maidservant. This is the only the earliest case I know of. And then the foremost researcher in the field of hypnotic regression was the French scientist, Albert de Rochas, who was none less than the director of the Ecole Polytechnique, which in France is basically the equivalent of MIT.

His research was highly controversial for the period, but he regressed regressed a series of subjects into previous lives. And in one famous case in, I think it was nineteen o four, yes, in nineteen o four, was able to get verifiable memories. In other words, the memory of the past life was verified against actual events. So I think Colonel de Rochas probably qualifies as the first to pioneer the use of hypnotic regression as a technique for investigating past lives. However, the thrust of our conference today will be not so much hypnotic regression as a work of professor Stevenson, Ian Stevenson, the late Ian Stevenson at the division of personality of perceptual studies at the University of Virginia.

I think we can say that for us, from a Buddhist standpoint, and this is true for all Gangetic religions, Stevenson’s research is a milestone. And I have distributed to you the obituary of professor Stevenson to give you an idea of the life of this extraordinary researcher. I will cover it ever so briefly from a memory. To give you a sense of the quality of the man and the caliber of the research. Stevenson was Canadian, studied medicine at the University of McGill, and obtained the top aggregate of grades in medical school at Magill, which means he was basically the top student in his class.

Then did some brief studies in biochemistry before training in psychoanalysis at the Washington Institute of Psychoanalysis, and was appointed chairman of the division of psychiatry at the universe University of Virginia in 1957. The University of Virginia has historically had one of the three top medical schools in The United States. So this is a reflection of Stevenson’s competence as an orthodox psychiatrist. Early on, Stevenson showed a mindset which was in at ease with the orthodox dogma of modern psychiatry, and he contributed a paper to the American Society of Psychical Research on the evidence for the existence of past lives. This paper actually won the award of the ASPR, and launched Stevenson on the path which became his, which was to study from 1961 onwards until his death in 2007, the accounts of past lives and to try to verify them.

So where Stevenson’s work is completely different from that of Galitsyn or Galitsyn or de Rochas, and from the general approach of hypnotic regression, is that one of the cases of hypnotic regression, one induces artificially through hypnosis, a memory of past lives into the subject. In the case of Stevenson and his colleagues, Stevenson and his colleagues investigated only spontaneous cases of recollection, which almost always occurred in young children, where the child actually recollects events from his past life, the child is not put in hypnosis, and then Stevenson and his team checked these results. So this was the broad thrust of Stevenson’s research from 1961 onwards, funded largely by the by Chester Carlson, who patented the Xerox process. So if there is one person we owe gratitude to for Stevenson’s research, it is this American millionaire who early on funded what eventually became hugely controversial research. Stevenson published then in 1966 the first book which is on top of my collection of books here, 20 Cases Suggestive of Reincarnation, which is the first book of Stevenson I ever read.

I fell on it by accident at the University of Virginia. And in 1967, Chester Carlson passed on, and all the funding for Stevenson’s research seemed compromised until it was revealed that he had endowed Stevenson’s research to the tune of 1,000,000 US dollars of the period, which you can multiply by 10 or 15 nowadays. And this caused a huge controversy at the University of Virginia with a sizable number of Stevenson’s colleagues demanding Stevenson’s de facto expulsion from the university. One of his colleagues actually said he can take the million dollars with him and go wherever he wants. Stevenson then resigned as chairman of the Department of Psychiatry, but created within the Department of Psychiatry at the University of Virginia, the so called division of personality studies, where his research was pursued until 02/2007.

Now to give you an idea of the scope of Stevenson’s research, from ’61 to 02/2007, professor Stevenson investigated two thousand five hundred cases of spontaneous memories of past lives, and these were not investigated in a casual fashion. Stevenson or his team met with every single one of the children who had these memories. The memories were then collected, each of them was checked, and the cases were divided into two broad categories, what are called the solved and the unsolved cases. The solved cases are the cases where the child’s memories could be corroborated. The unsolved cases are the cases where the child’s memories could not be corroborated.

And I brought with me today some of Stevenson’s publications to give you a sense of the volume of the material. I have only a bicycle, so I didn’t bring everything with me. You’ll forgive me, you know. But this was the first major work Stevenson wrote, 20 cases, suggestive of reincarnation. And this in turn was Stevenson’s following magnum opus, a collection of cases of the reincarnation type gathered in India, Sri Lanka, Lebanon, Turkey, and Thailand, and Burma.

Each case, as we mentioned, systematically investigated, followed by what many considers Stephenson’s masterpiece, the two volumes of reincarnation in biology, which are a systematic study of the impact events in a past life can have on the physiology of the child who remember these events. Many of these events actually, you know, have been investigated in the light of medical records. And finally, one work which was published after Stevenson’s retirement, is of considerable interest for us, European cases of the reincarnation type. The cases are less thoroughly investigated because many of the cases are cases through memory, but they are of considerable interest for Westerners since it relates material to those of our own culture. So before going any further, I would like to analyze the differences between cases of the reincarnation type which are obtained through induction, in other words through hypnotic regression, and the spontaneous cases.

And the reason for which I think to establish the existence of reincarnation on a scientific basis, the spontaneous cases are preferable. This is actually a huge debate among the specialists who study reincarnation. Broadly speaking, one gets far more spectacular results through hypnotic regression. And for this reason, in popular culture, these are the cases everyone is aware of, The search for Bridey Murphy, Jane Evans case, Glenn Ford’s memories of himself as a French nobleman, and Brian Weiss. I’m sure many of you have heard of the American psychiatrist who worked many lives, many masters, who regressed many of his patients into past lives.

The problem with hypnotic regression is from a methodological standpoint, first, a very major risk of induction of memories by the hypnotist himself through leading questions. Now this is a problem with hypnosis in most forms of investigation. The second problem, and this was a charge which is leveled against the case of Brady Murphy, and it is a very major problem with hypnotic regression, is what is called cryptomnesia. Cryptomnesia are memories of events the person knew, but has forgotten, which are resurrected under hypnosis. One of the things which hypnotists have established over the century and a half, two years of two centuries of the systematic practice of hypnosis is that most of us have near total memory, but much of the material is buried.

One of the big problems with hypnotic regression to past lives is that the events described may actually be known by the person through perfectly natural means. They may have heard about them on a television program, they may have overheard them in a conversation, and they will have completely forgotten about them. These memories will resurrect in the context of hypnosis, and fantasies may be constructed around these memories, which seem to refer to something the person had no natural means of knowing. So cryptomnesia is one of the strongest arguments against the use of hypnotic regression as a means of investigating the existence or non existence of past lives. Then the third objection, which I feel can be leveled against Brian Weiss’s work, which is widely read and studied, is that much hypnotic regression has first and foremost as a goal therapy.

The therapist is not terribly interested in whether what comes up in therapy is true or not, it’s not the goal of therapy. The goal of therapy is to help the person, to heal the person. And it’s very obvious in Brian Weiss’s work. When the memories of purported past lives arose, in the case of Catherine, one of the subjects of Brian Weiss, Weiss actually wasn’t terribly interested in whether these memories were authentic or not. They seemed to have this patient, which as far as its psychiatrist was what he was interested in.

Eventually, he became convinced that these memories were authentic, but he actually did not really investigate them carefully. And this is the third charge which can be leveled against hypnotic regression. Hypnotic regression can very easily lead to the recollection, and actually the generation of cathartic fantasized personalities. Personality which is generated by the patient on the hypnosis, which has a therapeutic effect, a healing effect, but which does not actually represent something which actually happened. And then finally, one of the last objections to hypnotic regression is that most, by no means all, but most of the cases are not solved, in which they are not verified.

And the famous exception to this rule are Albert de Rochas’s cases. So unfortunately, his book Successive Lives, is not translated in English. It remains, I think one of the masterpieces of the research on hypnotic regression, because in one

Case at least, de Rochas regressed his cook. He seems to be very careful being by being the cook of a French scientist. Any things get done to you, you know. He regressed his poor cook to a series of past lives, and he had that same element of ruthlessness you find in Vasiliyev, in his research on telepathy. His cook was quite resistant at a certain point to regressions.

And de Rochas, who was a gifted hypnotist, had found means of convincing her that he could age her. So he told her that if she didn’t cooperate, he would prematurely age her. But the program from that point obviously was very cooperative, you know. But he regressed his cook Josephine to several past lives, and the first past life, this was done in nineteen o four, was that of a French peasant, Jean Claude Bourdon, who was born in 1812, and while the birth itself was not ascertained, the existence of the family was ascertained, and she, in hypnotic regression, described clearly his military service in a small French town called Besancon, as well as the division he was serving with. And de Rochas, who was an engineer in the military, checked the data and was able to corroborate it.

So this is a clear corroborated case of hypnotic regression in nineteen o four. And then he regressed her to one life before this, which was unchecked, and interestingly enough, and we will talk about this later on, he regressed her to an animal life. She recollected being an ape to her great dismay. You can imagine how a French peasant girl in nineteen o four feels describing her experiences as a large ape. It wasn’t terribly comfortable for her, and I think it wasn’t comfortable for him either.

So these are the cases where hypnotic regression has actually led to solved cases. Now Stevenson himself rejected entirely the approach of hypnotic regression, which I found rather puzzling initially, because I feel the method does work. I don’t think it can be used for systematic careful study. It’s too open to criticism, but it does work. Stevenson himself, it seems only used it privately and was quite virulent in his criticism of it since he felt that most of the personalities which manifested were fantasized personalities.

I personally suspect that we have to understand Stevenson’s criticism in the context of the period he worked in. Stevenson was trying very hard to maintain a place for the research he was doing within the department of psychiatry, in other words, within the field of orthodox science. Much of the polemic at the University of Virginia hinged around evacuating the division of personality subject studies from psychiatry and creating a division of parapsychology. Now parapsychology as a discredited discipline for practical purposes poses no threat to the orthodox worldview. So I think Stevenson’s rejection of hypnotic regression comes largely from the fact that he felt it would give arms to his adversaries.

Be that as it may, this led to a major controversy between Stevenson Stevenson himself and the wife of the foremost parapsychologist of the period, doctor Louisa Rhine. Stevenson, as we said, focused in all of his research on spontaneous cases. Rhine and his wife from the beginning focused on the induction of paranormal phenomena, and Louisa Rhine actually attacked Stevenson in print on his reliance on spontaneous cases, are circling, and I think we can see history has proven her wrong, that spontaneous cases never led anywhere. So we will cover now the alternate explanations to be excluded in cases of the reincarnation type before getting to the study of a series of actual cases which are in the folder which has been handed out to you. And so I know this is pretty tedious material, but this sort of goes hand in hand with trying to establish things objectively as opposed to leaping to conclusions.

So we saw the problems with hypnotic regression as a technique. With the spontaneous cases, what are the issues one has to address? The methodological vices first are first and foremost fraud. Fraud unfortunately is rampant in all research on what is broadly called paranormal phenomena. One of the very great strengths of Stevenson’s research is that Stevenson’s personal integrity has never been called in question by his colleagues, even those who disagreed strongly with him, and that his research was undertaken by a team of scientists.

Stevenson had some six collaborators and collaborated as well with other scientists from other universities. The research has also been repeated. As you know, in theory, in scientific investigation, all major studies should be repeated by separate teams of scientists. In practice, this seldom happens. In the case of Stevenson’s work, there’s been a series of repetition of his research, which I have listed in the articles in your bibliography.

The second methodological vice is self deception, self deception either of the investigator or self deception from the side of the family of the child who claims to recollect past lives. Now this charge has been leveled against Stevenson. Stevenson came from a family which practiced spiritism. He himself clearly is interested in reincarnation, possibly believes in the reality of reincarnation, and his colleagues who are never putting in question his integrity did say that they put in question his interpretation. Deception from the side of the family is another charge which is often leveled against research of this type.

You will see when we start looking at some of Stevenson’s research that it doesn’t really cut the ice precisely because these are spontaneous cases in which the family from its own side has no financial interest. Stevenson and his team never paid the family. In many cases, the family actually faces major difficulties socially from the reincarnation. Some of the cases which are the most revealing in this context are the obvious cases of Indian children who are born in Hindu families, and remember being Muslims in past lives, which does not go well with a Hindu family, or even worse, Muslim children born in Muslim families which do not believe in reincarnation, claiming to be Hindus in past lives, which goes down even less well. The family has absolutely no interest in promoting this type of fantasy.

And actually, Stevenson reports that in some 40% of the cases he investigated, the families actively, actively means through physical means, try to encourage the child to stop talking about these things. So basically it was beaten out of the children, you know. Now the third methodological vice with cases of the spontaneous type are alternate sources of information for the data the child provides regarding its past life. This is a very big problem for large categories of Stevenson’s cases, specifically the Burmese and the Thai cases. There’s some 750 Burmese cases under the 2,500.

In most of these cases, the child remembers or claims to remember the past life of someone who is from the same family or lived in the same village. So in cases like this, it is very difficult to exclude that the child gained knowledge of this information by some other means. And therefore, I think that Stevenson’s research has to be assessed on those cases where this is not possible. So there are some Burmese cases where the child has information, we will cover one, which is not accessible by other means. In many of the European cases as well, the child remembers something he or she has no way of remembering by any other means, and these are the cases which bear the weight of the analysis.

The second category of alternate explanations to be excluded in studying cases of the reincarnation type are alternate paranormal phenomena. This is much more difficult to exclude. For instance, if a child remembers a past life as, let’s say, the local baker who passed on three years ago and gives a lot of details, how can we say for sure, even if the details are accurate, that the child does not know these details through telepathy, through contact with someone else from the baker’s family who knows these details. It is very difficult to exclude. The second category of paranormal phenomenon which poses major problems is what is called by one of Stevenson’s critique, This is a very high degree of clairvoyance, the sort of clairvoyance which, let’s say, the Tibetans believe certain spirits have, which enable one almost to know everything one wants.

Now if a child had this, he would have access to vast swathes of information of the past life of someone who has passed on since, and it would actually not be a case of reincarnation. And the third category of paranormal phenomenon, which has to be excluded, is possession. A possession is something which we in the West do not encounter a lot of. Having lived in India, I can vouch for the fact it does exist. It’s something one does see quite a bit of unfortunately.

Now broadly speaking, of these three categories of paranormal phenomena which interfere with the possibility that it’s an authentic case of recollection of past life, the most problematical is super-psi. The most problematical because it’s impossible to exclude. If that level of clairvoyance existed, then everything is possible. So as Stevenson himself pointed out, the hypothesis is non-falsifiable. As a non falsifiable hypothesis, it’s not a scientific hypothesis, we cannot test it, in other words.

Telepathy and possession are fairly easy to exclude based on the characteristics of these cases. What is striking in every single of these spontaneous cases of recollection of past lives, there’s one or two exceptions, is that the child says, I was this and this, and I did this and this. In other words, the child identifies with the events. He doesn’t say the baker had such and such a car, He said I had such and such a car. Now this identification does not occur when telepathy is present, and in cases of possession, we have a completely different dynamic where there’s a switch of identity at the time of possession.

This is not present in the cases of spontaneous memory of past lives. In the cases of spontaneous memory of past lives, the pattern is very much that when the child starts speaking at age two or three, the first things he says tend to refer to the past life and he identifies with this. So the only of the three paranormal hypotheses which is problematical is super-psi, and it cannot be excluded. But I personally feel that the hypotheses of reincarnation to explain children who spontaneously have these memories is a simpler hypothesis. As a simpler hypothesis, I think it has to be given credence first.

And now we can do one of two things. We can have a cup of tea and then address the cases, or we can start with one case, which is quite a haunting case, and then have a cup of tea. So what would you prefer? Cup of tea first. One case and then comes the other.

It’s got both one case. Very well. This is a case of David Llewelyn, which is in your folder. And if I could have one of these as well, thank you very much. Or maybe you keep yours.

I’ll take it from the book, actually. Yes. Page 18. This is pages 80 to 86. I don’t know where it is exactly in your folder.

It should be at the beginning, but it may not be. You don’t miss another dog, do No. No. No. So David Llewelyn’s case is quite quite striking because this is a child who actually has no memories, clear memories of a past life, but whose behavior is completely at odds with that of the family he is born in.

He was born in an English family, a non Jewish family, probably of Welsh origin by the name, and yet very early on shows behavior which is completely absent in the family. The first characteristic which is very striking is very strong levels of fear present in the child from early on, fear of darkness, fear of being locked up, and nightmares. The child starts describing events, and he was born in 1970 in England, which have no relation to his milieu. He seems to describe events related to life in the concentration camps. He describes pits in which men and children were thrown alive and often burned.

He describes children being preselected from groups of prisoners and executed. And when this child David starts to write, he insists to write from the right to the left, which is the way the Hebrews and the Semitic people write. He does not want to write from left to right. He actually has to be trained to write in the normal Western style from right to left. The case is extremely embarrassing.

It actually led to the separation of the parents because the mother had had an affair with a Jewish man, and it would seem that David actually was the offspring of this Jewish man, a fair of which the husband was unaware. I will read you some of the passages from Stevenson’s account of the case. It’s on page 82 for those of you who have it. David described his nightmares as scenes of large dark holes which were deep and he was afraid he would fall into one. He could see bodies in the hold.

There were people with guns and he could smell the stench of dead bodies. David also complained of an unusual odor in his bedroom. On one occasion, he and Susan visited one of his aunts who cooked with gas. His mother had did not have a gas oven, and the boy said, it was like the smell in my room at night, it’s going to smoother me. Moving onwards, when he drew, David always included a star.

At the same time, he seemed to have a phobia of stars. Once when he and his mother were in a shop, he suddenly began to cry and ran out of the shop. His mother ran after him asking what the trouble was. David said, it’s that necklace I saw, I am afraid of it. Susan asked him to which necklace he was referring, he said the one with the star sign, it is beckoning to me.

The necklace had a star of David attached to it. As you know, the sign which the Nazis had the Jews wear on their lapper was a star, the star of David. It was a sign which marked one as a Jew and marked one as this subject of discrimination, you know. So it’s quite striking that a young boy, a young English boy with no connection whatsoever, culturally with the Jewish world, should be so affected by this. David also had a strong dislike for the color yellow on page 83 of your handout.

Susan said he had a hatred of the color yellow. The stars which had to be worn by those of the Jewish confession or those of Jewish origin, should I say, were, you know, in color. David also had a marked fear of camps. When he was six, Susan once proposed that they have a vacation at a holiday camp. David resisted this vehemently.

His mother asked him why. He said there’s no happiness there. People are caged in in a cold.

Hungry and frightened, they never get out. This is a little boy in England. Moving onwards, and you have to know something of Jewish customs to be aware of how relevant this is. When he was still a young child, David surprised his mother by asking her whether some of the food she was serving had blood in it. And as you know, one of the strictest rules of for those of the Jewish confession is that the food which is eaten, the meat which is eaten must have no blood in it.

There are other rules of as well. What is striking is that David never himself stated that he lived in the scenes he described. So this is a case where the child does not identify with the experiences, and my personal suspicion is that the traumatic, the extremely traumatic nature of the experiences goes a long way to explain this. Moving onwards on page 85 of your handout, later when David watched television, he had no access to television as a child, he disliked programs about war, moving onwards. He showed fear and anger when he saw Germans on television program.

He also had such emotions when he encountered live Germans. So this case is a very interesting case, because a child never claims memories of past lives. Yet the child’s behavior is totally at odds with the family milieu and the culture he is born in. And the child, through his behavior, shows a very strong identification with a group with which he had no contact whatsoever. And this was why I wanted to cover this case with you first.

There are two cases of this nature, which Stevenson treats, the case of David Llewelyn and one Finnish case, the case of Teuvo Koivisto, which is is a very disturbing case, so we won’t cover it here. But in every single case, one has to ask oneself how this can be explained. It can’t be explained through the family background of the child, it can’t be explained to the culture, it has to come from somewhere. So this is a case where I think one can infer that reincarnation is a possible, maybe even a probable interpretation. And then maybe we can stop and have a cup of tea now.

So we will move from this first case of the case of David Llewelyn, which is an impressive case, but when which is by the standard of the cases Stevenson has obtained, believe it or not, a weak case, to much stronger cases. And I will cover three more cases with you. The two cases I want to cover now are I think two of the strongest cases Stevenson has collected. From among the two thousand five hundred cases Stevenson has, he has some thirty five cases of twins. Of the cases of twins, he has two cases of monozygotic twins.

Monozygotic twins are true twins. In other words, these are twins with the separation of the zygote, the fertilized egg occurs after fertilization. Therefore, these twins have exactly the same genetic material, and unsurprisingly, phenotypically, are almost identical. Such cases are extremely rare. To get monozygotic twins with memories of past lives is exceptional.

And the first case we will cover is a case of Gillian and Jennifer Pollock, which is a British case. It is in your folder. It’s pages 89 to, I think, 93. And the second case is a case of the Īśvara twins, Sri Lankan twins, which is even stronger than the case. I wanted to cover the case of the Pollock twins first because even though it is weaker than the case of the Īśvara twins, it is a case which occurs among Western children.

And for that reason, it’s it is quite easy for us to relate to. So the case of Gillian and Jennifer Pollock actually was covered in the Discovery Channel documentary. It was covered on the BBC. If you are interested, you can actually download clips on this from YouTube. I was going to show one to to you, but my I live in the stone age, so I I cannot do that for you.

But you’re all very technologically aware, you can work this one out by yourselves. The case itself is a tragedy since the Pollocks were basically a run of the mill British family whose two daughters were killed, Joanna and Jacqueline, were killed by a crazed driver on a sidewalk instantaneously with, as you can imagine, devastating impact on both parents, especially the mother who came close to a nervous breakdown. The father was convinced that the girls would return, and even more so, was convinced that they would return as his future children. So this is one of the interesting features of this case. It is also one of its weaknesses since clearly one of the parents is basically expecting the return of the twins.

Now on page 90 of your text, this is clearly stated. This is Stevenson has covered this case two times. Once in reincarnation in biology, it’s too extensive, and once here in European cases, which is an easier summary. John Pollock, on the other hand, had a strong belief in reincarnation for many years. After the death of the girls, he became convinced that they would be reborn in the family and as twins, and indeed his wife had twins.

But what is striking is the degree to which the twins actually remembered being these two daughters and the differences between the twins. When the twins became able to speak, they made between the ages of three and and seven a small number of statements about the lives of Joanna and Jacqueline. Now the parents actually overheard the twins talking about the accident which had befallen to them. And what is striking in this case is that even though the twins are monozygotic, in other words, they should be for practical purposes identical, doctor generally considered that one of the criteria for monozygotic twins is that the faces are basically indiscernible. We should ask Sarah here who has twins about these things.

But Jennifer and Jillian and Jennifer had closely similar faces. I believe that anyone seeing only their faces would conclude that they were monozygotic as they were. Their physiques, however, to some extent corresponded with those of Joanna and Jacqueline. Jennifer had this is one of the twins, had two birthmarks, whereas Gillian had none. A birthmark on Jennifer’s forehead near the root of her nose corresponded to the scar of an injury that Jacqueline, this was a child who had passed on, incurred when she fell in a bucket at the age of three.

The child also had a a birthmark on the flank, which corresponded to a mark on the body of the child whose life she remembered. Now what I found extremely striking in this case was that the two young girls in the previous life had not been twins, and they had different levels of education. One was basically good writer, the other had barely started to write in school. And these learned characteristics were carried over in the next life or the remembered next life. As I mentioned, Joanna, on page 91 of your text, had been 11 years old when she died and she could write well.

Jacqueline, however, was only six and had not learned to hold a writing implement properly. She grabbed

In her fist instead. When the twins first began to write at the age of about four and a half, Gillian, the one who had learned to write in her past life, immediately held a pencil properly, whereas Jennifer held it in her fist as Jacqueline had done. She persisted in writing this way until the age of 23. And if you look on the next page, you have a picture of the two twins. They have learned to write at exactly the same age, and you can see very clearly that one of the twins is holding her pencil properly, and she’s actually right handed as a child in the past life wars.

The other twin, who was left handed in a past life, is now using the pencil in her right hand, but is holding it in her fist, and has continued in this behavior and continued this behavior until the age of 23. Now this is quite striking. These are two children who are twins who are monozygotic. They have the same genetic code. They’re raised in exactly the same families.

They go to the same school. So as far as genotype is concerned and as far as milieu is concerned, the children are facing exactly the same background, yet there are substantial differences. Both children remember past lives, and these differences seem to correspond to events in the remembered past lives. So cases like this are quite thought provoking. Now what weakens this case is obviously the parents’ belief in reincarnation and the parents’ wish for the child or the children to return.

I actually watched the documentary, and I was quite struck there are pictures which I was not able to include. And indeed, the wound on the forehead of the infant in a past life corresponded exactly to the birthmark on the child who remembered that life. That was quite striking. And also I must say, this is a very subjective element, and I would encourage you to watch these programs. I was struck by the sincerity of the parents who had no particular interest in talking about reincarnation in England in the nineteen seventies.

It was not something which went down that well. And the next case we’re going to address is a much stronger case. It’s the case of Indika and Kakshapa Īśvara. So it should be in your handout. These are page 1970 onwards.

And this qualifies as one of the strongest cases Stevenson has, so I wanted to build up to it. Such cases are very rare indeed. These are monozygotic twins, again. They’re monozygotic twins which are born in a family which is loosely speaking Buddhist, but you will see from the lives of the remembered lives of the twins, the parents were not terribly clean, especially in the case of one of the twins, that she he, excuse me, remember the life he remembered for political reasons. And the differences, both physical and in terms of behavior between the two twins are very striking.

So Indika and Kakshapa Īśvara were born in 1972 at Wuligama in Sri Lanka. The twins are monozygotic. This was established by Stevenson based on the serological tests at the University of Virginia. The twins began to speak coherently when they were two and a half years old, and at three spoke about previous lives. Kakshapa, the first of the twins, spoke first and said that he had been shot by the police.

He made a few other statements that suggested the life of an insurgent. As you know, Sri Lanka was torn apart by a civil war in the early seventies, which has continued almost to this day. The young Kakshapa actually remembers being shot by the police and will keep a lifelong aversion to the police in general, as well as disciplinary problems of various types. The family laughed at Kakshapa for his statements. Actually, the family, it’s implicit in Stevenson’s work, you get this from other sources, the family actually rather encouraged the child not to talk too much about this for obvious reasons.

The other child, on the other hand, Indica, spoke copiously about the life that he remembered. He took the names of places and people that made it comparatively easy to trace the family, so this is a solved case. In the case of Indika, it’s solved. In the case of Kakshapa, it was never solved. In other words, in the case of indica, Stevenson and his team actually checked all the elements the child gave.

In the case of Kakshapa, who remembered a life as an insurgent, it could not be checked. With the information furnished by Indika, he easily found a family of Balapitiya, another village called Samarasekara whose oldest son Dakshana had died on 01/24/1968. It was some four years before the birth of the twin in question. With some trivial exceptions, everything Indika had been saying about the life in Balapitiya was correct for Darśana and his family. Now we will jump to the presentation of the recollected events, but one thing I would like to point out in this case, which makes it extremely strong by Stevenson’s rigorous standards, is that not only was the case solved in the case of Indika Īśvara, but Stevenson’s colleague, mister Samaratne, I’m sorry, it’s Sri Lankan names are difficult for me.

Mister Samaratne was present at the time of the first meeting of the two families, the family of the children in this life, and the family whom they remembered from a previous life. This is very rarely the case. Generally speaking, when the investigators arrive on the scene, the two families have met already, and the charge leveled against many of these cases is that the two families have harmonized their version of what happened, involuntarily. So in this case, at the time of the meeting, a third party, a neutral observer, who was well trained was present, and therefore there was no possibility of harmonizing the accounts. Now we will perhaps jump directly onwards to page 1977, and this is the standard presentation which is adopted by Stevenson for all his cases.

So you can see the care with which this has been done. In this table, you have the various items the child recollects, the source, the informants for the item. Then the item in question is verified by a an investigator of Stevenson’s team, and there are comments related to the verification. In the particular case we are talking about, you have some 41 different memories remembered by the child. Of these 41 different memories, most were corroborated, and you will see some are quite haunting.

For the first item, he was called baby mArhata, it was the nickname given to young Darśana in a previous life, this was corroborated. Then all of the family elements, he had known a sister, where he lived, what the house was like, the fact that the house in his previous life had electricity, his present house doesn’t did not have electricity. All of these were corroborated. He remembers the class he attended. He remembers the school he attended he attended.

He actually remembers some of the characteristics of the Buddhist temple he went to. Item 26, for instance, on page 1981. The child, this is Indica, remembers that there was a red curtain in the temple where the Buddha image was. This is the source of this information is mister Smaranayake. This was checked actually.

This is the monk who was in charge of the temple, and actually, at the time it was checked, that was no longer the case. However, at the Balapitiya Temple, there had been a red curtain in front of the Buddha image up to 1966. The curtain in the temple which the child attended in his new village was not of this color, And actually, was no curtain, a a white curtain was installed later. And we go through item after item of this nature. So certainly in the case of Indika Īśvara, this is a strong verified case.

In the case of his twin brother, Kakshapa, there was no possible verification. However, what is very striking is if you move a little bit onwards to page 1994, observation of differences in the behavior of the two twins. Keep in mind these are monozygotic twins raised in the same family, same cultural milieu. Indika is a child who remembers life as young Dakshana, who by all accounts was a very pious young boy. Kakshapa remembers life as an insurgent.

If you go down the list, it’s quite striking. Indika’s behavior is religious. Kakshapa’s behavior indifferent towards religion. Indika’s gentle manner and in court and calm, Kakshapa is inclined to be hostile and violent. Moving downwards to point four, which is corroborated by the teachers, Indika is more intelligent and has an excellent memory.

Kakshapa is less intelligent, memory not so good. Indika is interested in schoolwork and good at studies. Kakshapa is indifferent to schoolwork and weak at studies. Indika who actually was driven to hospital in a car in which in the after which he shortly passed on has a phobia of vehicles. As young Darśana, has no phobia of vehicles.

Indika as young Darśana in the previous life was very fond of chilies, a Sri Lankan special specialty, in his present life is fond of chilies. His brother is not. Now this is a striking case, and it’s a corroborated case. Now there was one item I actually had missed in the account of the life. There was unfortunately, it’s not listed here.

There was in the house, which Indica remembered, a concrete pavement, and the young child, Dakshana, whose life he remembered, had actually put an imprint of his foot in the concrete pavement, which is after covered up. Now young Indica actually remembered this, and the family in Palapitiya was able to corroborate this. This was an item of information which it was basically impossible for him to get by any conceivable normal means, short of supposing massive fraud from all parties involved. So this was the second case of monozygotic twins I wanted to cover with you, And then I would like to cover a particular category of cases, which are very impressive cases, most of which unfortunately are unsolved. But it’s a special subcategory of cases within the Burmese cases.

These are the cases of Burmese children who remember past lives as Japanese soldiers. Now within the broad category of Burmese cases, some 750 cases, there are a couple tens of cases of Burmese children who remember being Japanese soldiers in Burma during World War two. As you know, Burma was occupied by the Japanese, and it was, by all accounts, quite a horrific occupation. No normally minded Burmese child, let alone Burmese family, would be terribly keen to have one of their children claim to remember her life as one of the Japanese occupants. Yet such cases do occur, and they are very striking because of the great difference in personality.

The young child shows by comparison with the standards of the culture. In this case, they’re very close to my heart, I must tell you, because my father almost ended up in Dasha, you know. And my mother served in China at the end of the Chinese the Japanese occupation, and she saw firsthand what had happened in China. So when I ran these cases, I could really emphasize a lot with this material, and that is why I really wanted to cover these these cases with you. So the case in question is the case of Maung Aung Tho, pages 1311 in your handout.

And this is a particularly striking case because like many of the cases of Burmese children who remember having been Japanese soldier, the child has extreme bodily deformities. In the case of Maung Aung Tho, these are deformity deformations of the extremities. If you look at the pictures on pages 1318, 1319, and 1320, you will see that all the fingers with the exceptions of the thumbs, are reduced to the level of stubs, so are many of the toes. Now one of the standard mutilations which is inflicted on the Japanese soldiers captured by the Burmese was the amputation of the extremities before execution. As I mentioned before, there was not a lot of goodwill at the end of the war between Burmese and Japanese.

Most of the cases of Burmese children who remember past lives as Japanese soldiers, soldiers saw very surprising deformations. And one of the most interesting aspects of Stevenson’s work in reincarnation in biology has been comparing the frequency of these deformations in the areas where these children were born with the standard distribution of such deformations in the population in general. Now the deformations in question, some I did not present here, are often very rare. Typically, for instance, the Japanese soldiers would be would be bound up with wire before execution, often for several days. And Stevenson has a series of cases of children with the most extraordinary deformation of the limbs, where basically the limbs are creased, you know, almost exactly as if the creases corresponded to the place where wire had been used to bind the child up.

These cases are without exception cases where the child recollects a life as a Japanese soldier, and also where the child shows behavior which is commensurate with that of someone of Japanese origin. Now a skeptic would say that the deformation occurred, and then the child on the basis of the deformation constructed the fantasy of being in a previous life a Japanese soldier. That is possible, but you will see that the level of construction of the personality it calls for is is quite astonishing, and I personally find that objection rather weak. All the more so when you think that most of these children were born in Burma at a period where there were no Japanese citizens in Burma at all. After 1945, and broadly speaking, until the mid seventies, especially in the villages in Burma, nobody had any contact of any type with someone of Japanese origin.

Yet they show strong Japanese traits, which it is very difficult to see the origin of. So in the case of Maung Aung Tho, his family is an army family, which eventually turned to weaving and spinning. And at the age of three, so basically as soon as he starts speaking on page 1311, he began to speak about a previous life. He said that he’d been a Japanese army officer, and that during the retreat of the Japanese army in Burma, the soldiers in his command had mutinied and tortured him so that he died. And the past of the the past life we collected is a very grim one.

Maung Hung Tu on page 1312, as a young child, had said that in his previous life, he killed members of his family and joined the Japanese army. Before he left Japan, he could kill the members of his family, his parents, wife, children, and two sisters, because he did not wish thoughts of them to distract him while he was fighting. My mother knew cases like this in China, you know. Maung Aung Tho recalled that he intensely disliked Burmese villagers. It was still the memories.

He said that after making the Burmese villagers on page 1313 work for him, he would kill them. He remembered the retreat of the Japanese army in 1945. There were 22

Soldiers in his unit. They ran short of food and became convinced that they would be captured and killed. Some of his men committed suicide. Others accused him, their officer, of incompetence. They mutinied, tied him to a tree, and then tortured him by chopping off his fingers and toes.

The mutinies placed a bomb behind the tree to which he was bound. Now what is striking with this child is if you look on page 1314, keep in mind this is Burmese village life. The young boy, from a very early age onwards, as soon as he could choose his garb, dressed in the fashion of a Japanese soldier, not in the traditional Burmese fashion using a sarong, which you see as the traditional way of dressing on page 1315 of the interpreter. So showed behavior that was unusual in his family and that could be regarded as typical of Japanese people, preference in clothing, wearing trousers, a large army belt, and boots. And on page 1315, he had Japanese tastes in food.

He objected to the chilies and other hot spices used liberally in Burmese cooking, and liked to eat raw or partly cooked fish and meat, which is very much, you know, a Japanese culinary habit. When he was a young child, he showed some difficulty in learning to speak Burmese. And then on page 1316, you have features which are characteristic of this subgroup of Burmese cases. The family’s testimony shows that the child is very un Burmese in attitude. He was hardworking and compared with other children insensitive to pain.

She said, one of his family relatives, that he put salt on the wounds he received. Along with these traits, Maung Aung Tho showed a longing to go to Japan. He had a prominent streak of cruelty in his character. He liked to hunt and kill small animals such as insects, frogs, fish, and birds. He told us that if he caught a frog, would take its legs off one by one while it was still living.

He stopped going to school to have more time for hunting. Moving downwards, Maung Aung Tho then showed some resistance to Buddhism. For instance, he would not prostrate before monks as Burmese Buddhists ordinarily do unless he was asked or even forced to do this. Maung, on page 1317, Maung Aung Tho’s father, we were assured, provided no model for such behavior. He had been a pious person and kind to animals.

And this is quite striking, and this is characteristic of all of the so called landmark cases of children who remember having been Japanese soldiers. There’s a specific article quoted in your bibliography where Stevenson studies these subcases. And we really see in these cases habits and personality traits passing through to the next incarnation. So I would like at present having covered particular cases to cover some of the general characteristics of these cases, and there are some limitations to this work. The problem is that of the 2,500 cases Stevenson has studied, only around 1,100 have been processed statistically.

A large database exists at the University of Virginia, and each case is coded according to 200 different criteria. Less than half have been inputted, so the studies in question are partial. But there are some characteristics of all of the cases Stevenson has studied. These are the so called universal features which derive from eight fifty six cases from Burma, India, Lebanon, Sri Lanka, Thailand, and The US. There are four universal features of all the cases.

The first is an early age at which is the child starts talking, ages two to four. The second is a slightly older age when the child spontaneously stops talking about the past life. The third is an extremely high incidence of violent death in the remembered previous life. Now the incidence varies in function of the sample studied. It’s anything between sixty five and more than eighty percent, seventy five percent being pretty standard.

The force is a frequent mention of the mode of death in the child’s statement. Now from our standpoint as Buddhists, this basically makes a lot of sense. Death is one of the most traumatic events in an individual’s life, and if the mode of death was violent, especially if accompanied with great pain, it would imprint itself very powerfully on the consciousness. And we do see when we look through the additional features of these cases, are no longer universal features, these characteristics. So I have subdivided the additional features into three categories, those of body, mind, and behavior.

Those of body are particularly puzzling. There is a physical resemblance of the child in the present life to the remembered life in the past. And this is quite striking because it is not something which from a Buddhist standpoint is easy to explain. We will see at the end of our talk that there is a possible explanation, but it is not evident. The second bodily features, which are not universal, they don’t occur in all cases, and which Stevenson dedicated these two volumes, reincarnation and biology, are birthmarks, deformations, or abnormalities connected with wounds or the mode of death in the previous life.

These are among the most puzzling and even disturbing cases in reincarnation of biology since some of the cases which I do not present here, which are solved by Stevenson, in other words, these are cases where the memories were verified, also present wounds or birthmarks on the child in this life, which correspond exactly to the site of the wound which caused death in the previous light life. And some of these cases, not all, but some of these cases are corroborated by autopsies of the body in the previous life. There’s one case in particular, the case — these things do happen — the abbot of a monastery who was unfortunately murdered by a monk for theft, and who was struck on his head with a mallet. And the child who remembered this past life had a clear indent on the crown of his head, which was clearly visible at the point where he claimed that the wound had been inflicted. And the case was solved, in other words, Stevenson was able to track down the previous rebirth, the abbot of the monastery, and to find the autopsy of the body of the abbot with, I forget if it’s pictures or a drawing of the site of the wound which correspond exactly.

Unsurprisingly, in his present life, the young child was afraid of monks. You could see why. So the second category of additional features are the mind. Again, this is not universal, but very widespread. The first is similar temperament and personality.

This is I think almost universe, and I’m surprised Stevenson did not include it. The personality or the temperament of the past life and the present life are strongly connected. The second category is the experience of deja vu, of having seen something already. The child in the present life travels somewhere, sees a building, and has this overwhelming sensation of having been here before, of having seen this before. This happened to a close friend of mine, a French lawyer, who traveled to Ajanta and Ellora in India.

He was a devout Roman Catholic, and upon seeing the shrines there, burst into tears and told me he had the sudden realization he had lived there before. He returned to France, and he renounced Roman Catholicism, became a Buddhist, and founded the Kagyü Center in Strasbourg, and which is one of the most successful centers in Europe now. So this is a classic case of deja vu. Memories, we have case after case after case in Stevenson’s archive, so the child who has clear memories from past lives. And then one fourth category, which I will cover if we have time at the end of this talk, which is vivid recurrent dreams connected with past lives.

Now I don’t want to enter into too much detail about this because this is really very difficult to verify in any objective fashion. But the accounts of these dreams, which are clearly present or clearly mentioned in reincarnation of biology, and there’s some very strong cases in European cases of reincarnation type. The accounts of these dreams show that these dreams are completely different from ordinary dreams. The child has one or two images and is often not really able to connect the images with any narration, any background information. The images are very powerful, and these dreams are frequently, but not always recurrent dreams.

They occur again and again, sometimes over years. Now the third group of additional features is behavior, and this actually is very striking. In terms of behavior, there is a clear connection between phobias, the child manifests in this life, and the mode of death in the remembered previous life. Stevenson mentions in an article in your bibliography, phobias in children who claim to remember past lives, that in a series of 387 children, thirty six percent had phobias connected to the mode of death in the previous life. And this, I think, I have always felt is one of the stronger common sense arguments in favor of reincarnation.

As you know, modern psychology tends to assume that the child’s personality is conditioned by this life, and certainly in Freudian psychology is defined, broadly speaking, by the age of five. But when you have phobias, which are basically uncontrollable forms of behavior or obsessions, which manifest, one has to be able to posit some type of cause for the phobia. If there’s a cause in this life, well and good, but in the case of many phobias, it is not possible to find an event in the child’s life which justifies such a powerful emotional reaction to something which in and of itself is neutral. For instance, you have phobias of water, I know what one case, phobias of fire, phobias of insects. And I would say that this is a strong common sense argument for the fact that there is perhaps something before this life in which these experiences may have arisen, which would warrant such an emotional reaction.

Certainly, it seems to be the case in Stevenson’s research. The second category of behavior which is uncommon is unusual play. Where the child engages in play which is totally unrelated to anything in its life. One young child playing at weaving when he’s born in a very upper class family, who turns out to have been a weaver in the recollected memories of a past life. And obviously, predilections, we saw in the case of David Llewelyn, a clear case.

In the Burmese case, we covered strong dietary predilections for Japanese food, which has no clear justification in the life of the child. And I included, I believe, a chart in your handout comparing on the one hand, the European cases, and on the other hand, the cases from of non European origin, which is interesting for us, because one of the arguments addressed against Stevenson’s research has been that so many of his cases come from cultures in which the belief in reincarnation is widespread. This is not the case in the European cases. And if we look at the handout on page two fifty, you will see that the broad characteristics, the four universal characteristics Stephenson mentions, are broadly speaking occur broadly speaking with the same prevalence, whether the cases are European or not. The mean age of speaking is broadly speaking age three.

The mean age of ceasing to speak spontaneously is broadly speaking age four to five. The mention of the mode of death by the subject occurs in The mean? The mean, yes. The mention of the mode of death by the subject occurs for non European cases in seventy six percent of the cases, for European cases in eighty five percent. One can assume there is more mention in European cases because since a culture itself is refractory to the notion of reincarnation, the children who remember past lives would have to have particularly strong impressions from past lives, and violent deaths would provide this.

And a violent mode of death in previous life occurs in sixty eight percent of the cases in other countries and seventy three percent in Europe. Again, with violent death, one has to be very careful because there are some areas studied by Stevenson such as the Lebanon, where most of the deaths were violent at a certain period of time. So this does tend to, you know, affect the statistics. Lebanon. Lebanon.

Lebanon. So we’ll now cover an assessment of Stevenson’s research, future directions of research, and then I will try to give you a Buddhist viewpoint on Stevenson’s research. The assessment of Stevenson’s research, broadly speaking, what is very what was very striking to me, I was telling Pamela preparing this talk, is how far-reaching Stevenson’s research was and how little impact it has had. So here is the former head of the department of psychiatry at UVA, who’s widely respected for his studies in a large number of rounds of psychiatry, the impact of mescaline and schizophrenia and whatnot, who has published over forty one years works, of which two thirds are published by the University of Virginia press, and the remainder are published by a medical press, Prager, and yet this work has no noticeable impact on the medical community. And actually, you read the reviews of Stevenson’s work in psychiatric journals, the American Journal of Psychiatry, the Journal of Nervous and Mental Diseases, time and over again, credit is given to the care he uses in his methodology, the integrity of the researcher, and no comment is made about the results.

It’s almost as there is no echo. And here you have two thousand five hundred spontaneous cases of children remembering past lives, of which, broadly speaking, I think more than one thousand are solved, in other words, are verified by a team of six researchers with local informants. Nobody has ever questioned the methodology or the integrity of the researcher. Nobody has ever bothered out of the community around Stevenson to replicate his research.

The research has had no impact worth talking of. And this I think really shows that there is such a massive bias from the scientific community in general against the mind being anything else than the byproduct of the brain, and in the West in general, against reincarnation, that the work is simply not going to be addressed. Then the critiques addressed to Stevenson, there are three broad categories of critiques, and it is quite impressive in Stevenson’s work that he has addressed each of the critiques. The first category is that the cases reported in the past rely excessively on the informant’s memory. Now obviously, Stevenson is informed of or was informed of the case by informants in the country.

He actually had to travel to the country to interview the persons in question, and he generally arrived months or years later after the two families had often met. So then a study which is in your bibliography covers cases which have been treated early on, and where one of Stevenson’s colleagues was present at the time when the two families met. There is no statistical, no significant statistical difference in the universal characteristics between those cases and the cases in general, which means that there probably has not been widespread collusion between the families in the cases in general. The second critique addressed to Stevenson is what is called imposed identification. In other words, the parents would impose an identity on the child.

Parents, especially in cultures which are cultures which accept the existence of reincarnation. Now this has been addressed by Satwant Pasricha, another colleague of Stevenson. The works are mentioned in your bibliography. It’s Pasricha 1992 and Mills in 1990. Pasricha simply studied the cases of children who remembered Muslim rebirths.

In Hindu families and children who remembered Hindu rebirths in Muslim families. She found again no significant difference statistically between those cases where clearly the parents are not going to encourage a child to remember that he was of another religion, and the cases in general. So this second objection objection is the systematic study of cases with the written records made before verification. In other words, many of the cases are cases which are documented very late in the processing. And it often becomes very difficult even if there’s no collusion between the families for members of the families to clearly remember what happened precisely.

So this is addressed in another study in your bibliography, Stevenson and Samaratne in 1988. So I personally find it very impressive that Stevenson has and his team went to the trouble of verifying these cases at a great personal with great personal hardship. I mean, are cases in India, in Sri Lanka, in Thailand, in Burma. They had to travel, they had to check these cases. Now what are the future directions of of research?

As you know, Stevenson passed on in 2007, and his then successor Jim Tucker has taken somewhat of a secondary position in the division of personality studies at the University of Virginia. Now Tucker’s main focus is completing the processing of Stevenson’s data. Of the 2,500 cases Stevenson has collected, 1,100 have been inputted in the database at the University of Virginia. They are working at a very slow pace, some 70 cases a year are based on my my personal estimation, with only one research assistant. It will take a lot of time before this is finished.

And unfortunately, my personal impression is that the focus of UVA’s division of personality studies has changed. The focus is more near death experiences, which is something which is more, if you forgive me, sellable with the Christian public in The United States than studies on reincarnation. So Tucker has stepped down as director of the division, and the director of the division’s main interest now is near death experiences and what are called OBEs, out of the body experiences. So this does not bode well for the future. And those particular types of cases, neuroscientists are working feverishly to establish a brain basis for?

Yes. I mean, OBEs, I mean, they seem to be getting there really. Yeah. They You know? I mean, the from what I know.

So it’s really awkward. It’s really awkward. So in addition to the completion of the database, what are the other directions of research? I think it is important and Stevenson started to do that to to demonstrate the invariance over time of his results. In other words, that the data basically remains broadly speaking the same in the studies made in the sixties, the eighties, and in more recent studies.

That seems to be broadly speaking established. One also has to establish the stability of results over cultural space. This has not been done. Most of Stevenson’s results come from societies which subscribe to reincarnation. So one of the focuses of Jim Tucker now is to try to gather more Western and American cases, to try to see if we get the same results in a Western society.

And then one would like to think that replication studies will be made. It doesn’t seem to be happening. Replication studies are studies where scientists who are not connected to the University of Virginia independently study the type of phenomena Stevenson was studying and see what results they come up with, to see whether there was bias in his study or not. And then a personal wish I would have is that there’d be more studies of monozygotic twins. These are exceptionally rare cases, unfortunately, and probably would have to be studied in cultures where you have a very large number of children who remember past lives.

So you would probably have to study them in Thailand and Burma. But these are, in my personal opinion, the strongest cases because they introduce the notion of a third factor in addition to the genetic and environmental factor. And these are cases which really have to be answered by an objective investigator. So summa summarum, and I reassure you we’re coming to the end of this very difficult material, what does Steven Stevenson’s research indicate and what doesn’t it indicate? What Stevenson’s research seems to indicate is that reincarnation occurs.

That I think based on the volume of material there is clear. Stevenson himself can suppose that of the 2,500 cases he has, could he cites some five top quality cases, which he cannot reasonably explain by any other means. The second point Stevenson’s research indicates is that there is a connection between experiences in a past life and the mental constitution in the present life. That I think is established. The third point which is I think established, which is one which for us calls for considerable reflection, is that there is a connection between major physical trauma in the past life and birthmarks, deformations or abnormality in this life.

It’s not a systematic connection, but there are too many cases in reincarnation biology for us not to accept that this does occur. The fourth case, or the fourth element, is that there is a transmission of elements of the personality from the past life into the present life. Now what does it what doesn’t Stevenson’s research indicate? I mean, the first thing Stevenson’s research does not demonstrate is that reincarnation is a general phenomenon. In no way, Stevenson demonstrates that there are children who have memories of past lives.

He does not demonstrate that every child has a past life, and I honestly don’t see how he could do so based on the techniques at his disposal. The second point Stevenson’s research does not demonstrate is karma in the broad sense of the term, that there is a connection. Yes. Does it demonstrate that karma operates? No.

This is something from a Buddhist standpoint, I would say we would be very comfortable with, since Buddhist philosophers have always said that, for instance, the the materialists are divided into two sub-schools, one of which believes in reincarnation, and based on their paranormal powers which enable them to see past lives, but they do not believe in karma, because their paranormal powers are too limited to trace a karmic seed back to its root. And the third point, which Stevenson’s research according to him does not indicate, and you hear this talked about a lot in Western Buddhist circles, and I wanted to address it head on, is nonhuman rebirths. So one does hear a lot from Western Buddhists that Stevenson’s research does not establish that there are animal rebirths. This actually comes from an incomplete perusal of Stevenson’s work. Stevenson himself seems not to believe in animal rebirths, But there are at least two major cases, the case of Wijeratne in cases of the reincarnation type volume two from Sri Lanka, page three nineteen, where he remembers a rebirth as a hare, he remembers being shot.

And the Sri Lankan case of Wijeratne, which is in one of Stevenson’s first works, 20 cases, on page one sixty six, where Wijeratne actually, at a certain point in his life, identifies so strongly with a bird that he flaps his arms around to break twigs, And he actually, poor man gets interned for it, you know, so they they they cure him of his obsession, you know. And obviously the case of de Rochas where Josephine clearly remembers, as we said, de Rochas’s French cook remembers being a monkey in a past life, you know. So from a Buddhist standpoint, how can we understand Stevenson’s research? I think the first thing to keep in mind is that the methodology of Stevenson means that he is examining the huge process of rebirth with a very, very small window of perception. This is the memories in a spontaneous case over one or two lives.

This is not going to provide evidence for or against the Buddhist understanding of karma because karma does not mature over one or two lives. It can happen exceptionally, but normally it does not. And I will basically then try to connect at this point with Geshe-la’s teachings on Thursday regarding karma and the process of maturation of karma. As you remember, there are three, from a Buddhist standpoint, three broad categories of karmic effects. The maturing effect, the effect similar to the cause, and the environmental effect.

And if we try to look at Stevenson’s research in the light of these three categories of effects, the maturing effect is the karmic result which impels a new life as a human being, an animal, or whatever. Regarding the maturing effect, certainly as far as impelling karma is concerned, in other words, the determination of the actual rebirth, nothing in Stevenson’s research in any way corroborates or infirms Buddhist teachings of the matter, there’s just no data, you know. Regarding the completing karma, in other words, deeds in the past life which lead to results in this life, there are a series of cases in Stevenson’s work which indicate that such a phenomenon does occur. It’s not indicated it occurs systematically, but indicates it does occur. And the case I would point out, we probably don’t have time to cover it, is a case of Corliss Chotkin in reincarnation of biology volume two, pages thirteen sixty one onwards.

Moosa Peck is a very interesting case of a Tlingit man, in other words, an Eskimo fisherman from Alaska, if memory serves me well, who had to slave away at fishing for most of his life, and the Tlingit actually believe in in future lives. So he said again and again to his family and relatives, Never again will I be reborn with a right arm which has to work this hard. After his death, one of his family members gave birth to a child who was born with a missing right arm. The arm actually was a stub, and the child when it started speaking had clear memories of of being Moosa Peck. So from a Buddhist standpoint, this is a clear case of completing karma, and actually completing karma through the power of a prayer.

It’s a very powerful wish. A wish, a very powerful wish is a prayer. So it’s a little bit of a warning to all of us to be rather careful for what we wish for, you know. Then the second category of effect is effect similar to the cause. This, in a Buddhist sense, is divided into two categories, the mind similar to the cause and the experience similar to the cause.

Because of the mind similar to the cause, I think that is clearly established. It is clear that mental characteristics in Stevenson’s research are transmitted from life to life. And that, for instance, those who cultivate very peaceful religious states of mind in one life tend to be very peaceful and religious in the next life. Those, for instance, this is time honored category of cases, the Stevenson’s research, who enjoy drinking in one life, have a natural attraction to alcohol in another life, you know. This is a very clear case of the transmission of mental characteristics.

Regarding experiences, in other words, that the person experiences what he or she has inflicted on others in past lives that is not corroborated or informed in Stevenson’s research. As far as the environmental effect is concerned, in other words, the idea that, for instance, someone who engages in sexual misconduct would be reborn in the dirty environment, that again is not corroborated nor informed. As we said, the focus of Stevenson’s research is too narrow to allow this to be corroborated. So then, where does this leave us regarding Stevenson’s research? I personally feel it is a major contribution to the Western understanding of reincarnation, perhaps the major contribution.

I think for Western Buddhists, it is the royal road forwards to generating clear conviction in the existence of the phenomenon of reincarnation. And therefore, I would heartily encourage all of you, if you have the possibility, to read, if not through all of Stevenson’s work, is a little bit daunting, through the simpler summaries, which I included in the bibliography. You have some introductory works, which are written by Stevenson, by Tom Shroder, by some of Stevenson’s colleague, Jim Tucker wrote a very good book. These are accessible. Then those of you who are seriously interested, I think you owe it to yourself to at least read 20 cases of the reincarnation type.

That is accessible. And then if you have the possibility to work through the other tomes, so much the better. Otherwise, try to work through some of the articles. So from my standpoint, I think I’ve more or covered what I wanted to cover with you, and I apologize for a very technical conference and a huge amount of material which was thrown your way, but I hope some of it has been of benefit. And I am wide open to any questions you may have in your exhausted state.

One question. Have you come across any evidence of past class of, say, hell realms or hungry ghost spirits? Hungry ghost spirits, there’s many accounts in the Burmese cases. The problem is that in Theravāda Buddhism, the realm of the hungry ghost and the Bardo realm are identified. They’re called the Preta Loka.

And actually, it’s standard in the Burmese cases. The child remembers being in the Preta Loka before reincarnating. It’s also standard in the Burmese cases as the child will announce to his parents his forthcoming rebirth in a dream. So I didn’t cover these cases because I was trying to cover cases which are easily accessible to a Western audience. I know the barrier of disbelief from the standpoint of Western is very high in this matter, so I wanted to establish the basics.

Regarding hell realms, I think we have the same problem as animal realms. I I have wondered why there are so few cases in Stevenson’s work. I think there are several issues. First, it’s clear Stevenson from his own side is skeptical regarding non human rebirths. You can see it in some of his footnotes.

Secondly, I think the experiences one would have in the animal realm, let alone in the realm of hungry ghosts or hell realms, are experiences which would be meaningless to a human being. You see, for instance, just take take a simple case, an animal rebirth. Imagine that in a former life, we were a cow. What would we remember? Much much.

Right? What would it be? What sort of memories would we have to draw upon? We might have like a friend of mine said to me once to my great dismay, I’ve always loved taking cows to the pasture and I find the smell of manure exquisite. Well, what what can I say?

Know? She is very pretty too, so I didn’t want to offend her. Now if you take rebirth as hungry ghosts, where the mind is obsessed with craving, or rebirth into hell realms where the mind is overwhelmed with anger and suffering, those are the characteristics. There would be no, probably no memories a human being could make a lot of sense of. Would there be?

Craving for food, maybe? Constant Yes. Constant craving, bulimia, those features are features which we could easily associate to a past rebirth as as a preta, for instance. Sadism, you know, viciousness, a strong propensity to savage cruelty, you know, an extremely dark mindset, we could associate with rebirth our past life as a hell being, you know. But would we remember anything?

It would be difficult. Difficult. So I think that may be the expression. It’s quite striking to see us in the research that there are gaps in the memories. So the previous remembered rebirth died fifteen years

Go to child that’s reborn fifteen years later. There’s this gap, which is completely unaccounted for, you know. Yes. Well, I don’t think or I don’t really see how we could demonstrate using Stephenson’s methods that the Bardo lasts, let’s say, a maximum of seven times seven days. I don’t see how we would go about it.

I don’t even see how we would demonstrate the existence of a Bardo. Yeah. You see. And yet there are many cases which are recounted in the Burmese cases. Many cases.

Yes. Sorry. I found that somewhat confusing element with the the Burmese case of the Japanese. Mhmm. Dead dead in 1945, then reborn in 1962, these defamations, and and sort of to replace the question of what’s been happening in the the seventeen years in between.

So it was the the Pollock twins where, obviously, the there was all so there was a gap. So there was a gap of two years or something, two and a half years. So, I mean, my goal in this talk has really been to present Stevenson’s research, and I think what as he says himself in at the end of of reincarnation of biology, a rational person can accept. What is, I think, from my standpoint, demonstrated at present. Now as far as I’m concerned, it’s obvious there is a Bardo state.

There’s no doubt about that. Is that something which we could empirically demonstrate using his method? I don’t see how. Mean, I can get accounts of people who remember it, but how would you verify it? It’s not verifiable.

There was one case I was gonna cover with you, and if I don’t know how tired you are. There is one very interesting case. It it moves us out of the realm of Stevenson’s research, but it gives us a sense of how karma operates. So if you have five minutes, I’d like to cover it with you. It’s a case of William Hens.

It’s a case which Stevenson studied. This is the case of a man with a long standing interest in spiritism, who had a series of extraordinarily vivid dreams over several years, and he came to the conviction that these dreams were connected with past lives. Now you will see when we start covering the dreams why it is very interesting for us. And obviously, this is completely out of the pool of something which can be verified empirically, You know? Yes.

What’s his surname? William Hens. Hens, H-E-N-S. So William Hens was born in London on 10/06/1899. He had no formal education worth talking of.

He became a mechanic and worked all his life as such. And he had three dreams. Of the three, I will cover the two last. I’ll read them to you there not long. The next vivid dream perhaps having a bearing on reincarnation was of a time about fifteen hundred AD.

In this dream, I was an attendant to an executioner. I was dressed in a leather jacket and tights, a girdle of cord, I was about 17. The scene opened in the vault like dungeon, I will skip a little bit. The executioner was holding the axe head on the floor just scattered with straw. By the low block stood two ladies, one of whom was in a state of extreme distress, the other trying to console her.

Both were dressed in black as was the executioner also who wore a mask. As I stood there, my feeling of pity was so great that I went over to one of the ladies, putting my arm around her shoulder, and I said, come along madam, it must be done, it won’t hurt. With that, I pressed her to her knees and placed her head on the block. I immediately with a swift action, slid around in front of her and grabbed her head just under the cap she was wearing and put her head her head hard on the block. The executioner stepped forward and raised the axe.

That was the end of the dream. In this dream, I felt intense pity for the lady. It welled up inside me. That’s the first dream. Now if you listen to the second one, I think you will see why it is it is quite interesting.

I should point out by the way that according to Stevenson, an old German print showing the beheading of a woman in Regensburg in seventeen eighty two shows that this was a standard procedure in executions, to pull the head, excuse me, of the victim forwards on the block, taking the hair out of the path of the axe to prevent partial decapitation, obviously. The second dream William hence had, the next dream seemed to relate to the early eighteen hundred. The scene opened with me being taken into an engineering shop. Under a brass oil lamp suspended from a beam was a bench with a man filing a block of steel about three inches squared, four inches long. He was dressed in a white apron with a bib.

He seemed proud of his filing as he ran his fingers over the smooth surface. I felt that I was a young man in my twenties about to start a new job. The next scene in the dream was that I was working on a railway coach, the early type used in the days of George Stephenson. The coach was over a working pit with railway lines across the edge, and I was working on the floor, not in the pit. The prints were of a coach pattern with thick forged spokes.

I had my head to the wheel tightening up some square knots, where the coach began to move forwards, and I felt my head being crushed against the back of the coach body. The dream concluded. I should point out that William Hens has had repeated repeated headaches throughout his life. So for us, obviously, there’s no way to establish whether these these dreams correspond or not to remembered past lives. If they did, they would show a very clear case of completing karma, where the karma accrued through being the assistant of an executioner, beheading another person in 1500, matures as a karma of having one’s one’s own head crushed between the wheels of a rail in 1800, three centuries later, and there is still residual karmic results in this very life with lasting migraine headaches.

As I said, it’s an unverifiable case, you know. From our standpoint, it’s a very interesting case, and I personally suspect this is probably how things operate. So One question. So most of the cases you’re talking about have some dreadful traumatic death or there’s some at the time of death, So that’s remembering to the next one, who is or future. What about a happy, peaceful death?

I mean, are there any cases of people dying happily? Or is it just the trauma that makes the remembering possible? That’s a good question. I was going to cover this, actually. The real question with Stevenson’s research is why seventy five percent of the deaths remembered are violent.

I think remembering past lives is not a natural process. So from a Buddhist standpoint, what we call the dissolution of the elements, which means the dissolution of the core areas of consciousness into ever subtle levels of consciousness. Eventually, the dissolution of conceptual consciousnesses into non conceptual consciousnesses, which occur in the normal death process, lead to the forgetting of events connected to that life. They can be brought back to the surface by meditators, but it does not happen normally. In the case of a violent death, and by violent I mean sudden, it can be accidental or the person can be on the receiving end of a crime.

In every single case, this gradual dissolution is collapsed, and in the accounts of death and dying in the Tibetan tradition, it is said that the person often goes immediately or almost immediately to the level of the mind of the clear light of death. I think this increases greatly the odds of remembering events from a past life. So I think this is why most of the death deaths remembered are violent. Because of death? I think so.

I think so. You know? It would make sense, basically. It would make sense. Are there any other questions?

Yes. Well, there are two the two answers to this question are covered both. There is the answer from the standpoint of Buddhist theory, and then there’s Stevenson’s data about when consciousness enters the egg, well, the the zygote or the fetus. In Buddhist theory, the mind enters the ziggoat at the instant of fertilization or perhaps shortly after. So in the case of twins, you would have two different minds entering the zygote probably after the splitting has occurred.

Otherwise, it’s difficult to see how this would be possible, how it’d be possible for them to have different memories. So this is the the textbook answer. Now what Stevenson’s research actually shows, and these cases would have to be analyzed in much greater detail, is that you have cases where the mind seems to enter the fetus very late in the pregnancy. You have cases where there even is personality change in the child after rebirth, which would be more akin to case cases of possession than cases of reincarnation. And therefore, I think on an empirical level, the issue is a little bit open.

But in terms of, let’s say, Abhidharma, you know, then if you were speaking of twins, fertilization would occur and you would assume that the two minds which are going to reincarnate would reincarnate when the zygote has actually split, you know. But then I wasn’t there. So Yes. Is there anything else? I’ll watch snow.

Mhmm. And the guy said to him, he said, oh, we’re going to kill the wolves. He said, no, we can’t kill them. He said, why? He said, because they’re our ancestor.

Mhmm. Well, the belief in reincarnation is is very wide spread in the tribal cultures. It seems to be one of the core beliefs of many forms of shamanism. Now the detailed understanding of reincarnation in shamanism and in Buddhism is different. Right?

Most shamanist religions consider that there is a group spirit of the animal, you know. It’s not accepted in Buddhism, you know. But I think something of the same experience is there. I mean, it’s clear that there are human beings who have animal characteristics. It’s clear there are animals who are quite evolved.

You know, I’m of of Yugoslav origin, you know, and not an emigre actually. So when the war started, the civil war started in Yugoslavia, because of my family background, I was asked by many Yugoslav exiles to create a unit which would fight in the war. I refused. I have never been in favor of that type of activity. And then reading accounts of what happened in the war, I heard that when ethnic cleansing occurred in the villages in Bosnia, many of the men in the units who went in the villages to perform these heinous crimes, you know, eventually, that’s quite quite odd, became almost as it were possessed and started howling like wolves, and these are the accounts one heard time and over again from those who saw what was happening.

Now this is perhaps an identification with some sort of totemic spirit. It could also be very easily memories. See what? And Could easily be memories. And stuff like that.

Used himself a kid about to move that moves. All of us, you know, have had many many animal rebirths. We don’t remember them. We don’t like to think about it, but it is very much there. I can’t do it all the time.

Those those things are present. Those things are present. I mean, you can only wonder what it is which leads people to have this extraordinary affinity to certain animals. Like some people are cat people, some people are dog people. Well, why?

I mean, you know, some people are horse people, you know. This comes from somewhere. So Stevenson’s research does not give us a lot of explanations for this, but I think it opens gateways. And I think really in conclusion, what I would like to do is I would like to encourage you all within the limits of your capacity to read up on this material, to try to connect it with what we are doing here. And you will see it doesn’t mesh perfectly, which is to be speaking a good sign.

Because when things mesh perfectly, have to wonder whether they’ve been made to mesh. Here there’s enough discrepancy that you will have to exercise your judgment, you know. Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

clear light ö sel (Tib)
The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
completing karma drubje kyi lä (Tib)
Also called finishing karma, the karmic imprints that ripen to determine the type of experiences we have when we are reborn, as opposed to throwing karma that determines the actual rebirth. LYWA
hungry ghost preta (Skt); yi dag (Tib)
The hungry ghost realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence, exemplified by incredible insatiable hunger and thirst. LYWA
Kagyü
The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded in the eleventh century by Marpa, Milarepa, Gampopa, and their followers. One of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. Cf. Nyingma, Sakya and Gelug. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Why are most past-life memories linked to violent deaths, and does remembering depend on trauma?

Remembering past lives is not a natural process. In the Buddhist view, the normal death process involves the dissolution of the elements, in which the core areas of consciousness dissolve into ever more subtle levels, and conceptual consciousnesses dissolve into non-conceptual ones. This leads to forgetting events connected with that life. Meditators can bring such memories back to the surface, but it does not normally happen. In a violent death, meaning a sudden one, whether accidental or the result of a crime, this gradual dissolution is collapsed. Tibetan accounts say the person often goes immediately or almost immediately to the mind of the clear light of death.

Scroll to Top