1 h 36 min · 3,983 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. This Lam Rim teaching explains generating a powerful, stable altruistic motivation of bodhicitta, with merit and forbearance as supports. It then presents Āryadeva’s four-verse stanza that counters the non-meritorious, the coarse self and all views, and identifies the person with the mental consciousness that transmigrates between lives. The teacher says the view of emptiness is needed alongside bodhicitta, and the talk closes with questions on substantial and cooperative causes and on the realization of emptiness.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 37m
UUID: fdfb03f5-1fb7-4a45-a1b6-9f9350676d0b
Words: 3,979
So the most important at the beginning is to generate the motivation. And here when we speak of motivation, obviously, we are referring to the supreme motivation. Now generally speaking, motivations are twofold. We have good and bad motivation. So here, one is referring to bodhicitta.
Then evil motivations are only the source of suffering. If we take, for instance, the, terrorist attack in Kabul, today, I believe, Geshe-la was saying that the bomb caused the death of, some 80 people. Then when we speak of a wrong motivation, an evil motivation, we are referring to a motivation which is under the sway, under the power of the afflictions, and such a motivation can only give rise to difficulties and suffering. Then, when we generate a powerful motivation to benefit others, this qualifies as a good motivation. And here, one must distinguish between the weighty motivations such as this one and superficial motivations, which within the flow of a weighty motivation lead us to engage in this or that deed.
So here, one must initially generate a powerful altruistic motivation, a powerful motivation to benefit, others. And this powerful motivation must be stable. Once this motivation is stable, then whatever deeds we engage in based on this motivation will accomplish their purpose. So here, both Śāntideva in his and Je Tsongkhapa in his have said that through trying to generate bodhicitta, we accrue huge accumulations of merit. And here, merit refers to virtue.
So you know the distinction between virtue and non virtue. In brief, virtue refers to qualities. Non virtue refers to thoughts or defects. Mhmm. And therefore, through trying to generate bodhicitta as best we can, we accumulate very large collections of merit.
Now here, the merit of virtue can also be accumulated through training in practices such as forbearance or patience, which enables us to counter afflictions under the sway of anger. And then at this point, once we have tried to do this, we should think to ourselves how marvelous it would be if all living beings, and perhaps that is difficult, but at least all human beings had this. Then, among us in this room, probably, everyone understands the faults of afflictions such as anger or general jealousy. In other words, everyone understands these faults as faults and identifies these faults as faults. That does not mean that anger, jealousy, and envy do not arise within our mind streams.
But as is said, when the afflictions arise, then we counter them forcefully. In other words, we don’t just sit back and cringe. We are forceful in our countering. Then all the problems in this world of ours at present arise from not seeing the thoughts of anger, from not seeing the thoughts of anger as thoughts. In other words, just as one does not see the thoughts of envy and jealousy as thoughts as well.
Then, obviously, it would be ideal to eradicate these within our mind stream, but they are there. However, at the very least, we should see their thoughts as thoughts. Then when we think of, the qualities of human beings in this world, this capacity to discriminate between what are qualities and defects in, we should think to ourselves how marvelous it would be if we could gather together all those who see faults as faults, how much more pleasant and more peaceful this world would be. And then if at this point, we take the resolve, this is something which I shall do, then this probably qualifies as bodhicitta. Then we can see that those who have fallen under the power of afflictions such as anger wherever they go, slaughter and kill.
They kill with cars. They kill with buses. They kill with bombs. The means are indifferent. They kill with the anger in their mind.
And then we should take the resolve from our side to do everything we can to gather, to collect all the people in this world who see the afflictions as faults. And we should not be timid and narrow minded. Instead, we should aim to become like great beings, like his holiness, Dalai Lama. And therefore, in dependence on Bodhicitta, we can gain vast collections of virtues to help the millions of beings in this world. Now although we understand the meaning of bodhicitta and of definite emergence, we have in no way at present generated within our mind streams, fully characterized bodhicitta and definite emergence.
Now when we stay as we are at present, relaxed in a comfortable environment and we reflect on sin and its faults, then we can think, my goodness, sin is really something to be shunned, to be avoided, but it does not go really beyond that. It is when we meet someone who is profoundly ignorant and who does not understand this, that from our side, a very powerful emotion arises, then it is easier to generate bodhichitta. So at present, let us generate this motivation of bodhicitta through reflecting initially on its advantages. And here, let us realize that once we have generated an uncontrived motivation of bodhicitta, then ordinary deeds such as drinking some tea or some water, because we engage in them not for our own sake, but thinking I’m doing this for the sake of my aggregates of my body so that I can serve and help others become very powerful deeds. Yeah.
Then regarding this practice, it actually begins with when we eat our meal. We should eat our meals not out of attachment to food, but with the thought that we are doing so to have a strong stable body to be able to help others. And then you might think initially, well, we are too busy taking care of children and family, and we have jobs and so forth to be able to think of these great topics like bodhicitta. In reality, that is not the case. It is possible to think so sporadically.
And therefore, within this deep motivation of bodhicitta, as was mentioned, we generate the various superficial motivations such as eating our meals and so forth for the sake of others. Then if we are able to do this, we will be very fortunate and we will reap benefit. Mhmm. Yep. Just now meditate on this.
A few couple minutes. As is said in Jetsongkapa’s Three Principal Paths, even though we had realized definite emergence and Bodhicitta within our mind stream, without the, wisdom realizing emptiness, it is neither possible to attain liberation nor full and utter enlightenment. This is why says, put effort at the realization of interdependence. In other words, put effort at the realization of emptiness. Then the topics of the Lam Rim are the paths shared as the being of the small, of the middling, and at the path of the being of the great scope.
And within the path of the being of the great scope, one should explain the view. Then if we were to focus on the view, I think you would find it difficult. Therefore, it makes more sense to present it in a scattered way, a bit here, a bit there, a bit up, a bit down. So here, the main goal of the Lam Rim is the generation of bodhicitta And within the context of this generation of bodhicitta, then the view realizing emptiness is an adjunct. Now there are numerous presentations of the view realizing emptiness in function of the various schools of tenets.
However, I would like to rely on the approach, which has been pioneered by Āryadeva’s 400, the Chatuhshataka, which is also explained in Kyabje Pabongka Rinpoche, which is liberation in the palm of your hand. So the stanza from would like you to remember is the following. Those who are bereft those who are bereft first counter lack of merit. In the in the middle, counter the self. At the end, counter all views.
One who understands this is wise. So, Geshe, I would like to ask you to memorize this stanza. There are only four verses. And in the poem of Yogini is translated in English, You can also find the verse of Āryadeva within it and memorize the translation which is given there if you prefer. So Yeah.
I think we have covered the explanation of the first verse initially counter the non-meritorious in the explanation, which Geshe la gave of the existence of past and future lives and the fact that it is one’s mental continuum which transmigrates from past to future lives. So this first verse of Āryadeva who was the foremost spiritual son of Nāgārjuna, initially countered the demeritories, is critically important. And I think it does not call for additional commentary since that was already given in the context of an explanation of past and future lives. Initially, counter the non-meritorious, this is a very weighty verse, isn’t it? So when we speak of past and future lives, we are speaking of one’s own past and future lives.
In other words, the fact that one’s own continuum of consciousness, one’s own mental continuum transmigrates from body to body, from life to life. So after commenting this first verse, initially, counter the non-meritorious. The second verse of is in the middle, counter the self. Now this self refers to the coarse self of persons. In other words, to a person being permanent one and independent.
This is something which you might find a little bit difficult to understand.
And the core surface of persons abuts on the impermanence of the person. So here, when we say we, we are referring actually to ourselves, to I. And what is this I? Some people might think that the I is nothing other but the activity of the brain. But a majority of us probably believe that the I is to be found somewhere deep within consciousness.
So here as to the mode of assertion of the I, Buddhist scholars diverge considerably. It is my private opinion that you will find the Prāsaṇgika presentation of the I as a mere nominal or conceptual imputation very difficult to understand, and it is preferable for you to focus on the I as the mental consciousness, which is what transmigrates from life to life. Now here, when we speak of mental consciousness, we are speaking of the fifth aggregate within the five aggregates, which are the form aggregate, the aggregate of sensation, of discrimination, of compositional factors, and of consciousness. And the substantial cause of this fifth aggregate is none other than our mental consciousness in previous lives. On the other hand, the substantial cause of our body at present, our physical body is the spermatozoa and the ovum of our father and mother.
So, therefore, it is the mental consciousness which we should identify as the person. As you know, there are four schools of Buddhist tenets. And setting Prasanika Madhyamaka aside for the time being, then the majority of the lower schools of tenets consider that the person the instance of the person is the mental consciousness, and this is what, we should adopt. So let us look at it this way. We have transmigrated from former lives to this life.
We will transmigrate to future life. Obviously, it is not our body or our aggregates which transmigrate. Then what transmigrates? It is actually the mental consciousness which transmigrates from previous lives to this life to future lives. When when I suggest to you that you should consider the mental consciousness as the instance of the person, this is obviously the position of the lowest schools of tenants.
Is this one you are at ease with? And then, obviously, I think, some of you, will answer, well, we’re Prasangikas after all. Then Āryadeva himself, as you know, was a but he had disciples who were in other words, whose view was different from his. Asaṇga, they say, was a Prāsaṇgika for his private view, but he had disciples and he taught the Cittamātra view, and he had disciples such as Dignāgā and Dharmakīrti who were Cittamātra and so forth. So it’s perfectly possible to have a different view from your teacher.
They are good. You understand? They are well. We don’t get this view. It’s too hard.
Right? The view of Buddha Śākyamūni himself was a prasangika view, but Buddha Śākyamūni taught four different systems of views, four tenets for the sake of his followers, his successors. In other words, there must be benefit. Now here, the, backdrop is the person, of all of these schools of tenets. The person is the receptacle of the imprints, the karmic imprints.
This is the foundation. Is this a help to you? As Asaṇga who was a direct disciple of Maitreya says in his, we assert that the mental consciousness is the person. This is what takes existence. It is as clear as it gets.
So here, when we say that the mental consciousness is an instance of the person, Then, obviously, since the mental consciousness is impermanent, the person is impermanent too. This is something which Geshe la will explain quietly for our sake. What is important is to understand that when we think of impermanence, we typically think of coarse impermanence. In other words, the end of the continuum of things. This is not what is being referred to here.
So here, the I is not something abstract. The I is directly connected with the mind. So when I say my book, my house, my car, my child, my relatives. Then what is this I? To put it in brief, simply, it is a mental consciousness.
So here, the mental consciousness is impermanent. However, when we say impermanent for the mental consciousness, we don’t mean it in the way we mean it when we say that a car or a house or a person are impermanent. When we say a car or a house are impermanent, we mean that it gets old. Then that is not the case for the mental consciousness. So what is meant when we say the mental consciousness is impermanent?
So this viewpoint that the person is in mental consciousness is a very beneficial viewpoint since it is one which is adopted not only by the Svatāntrika Madhyamaka, but also by some Chitamatrans and by some Sautrantikas. So here, if we proceed rapidly, it will not be possible to gain understanding. These are difficult topics. So one must proceed slowly and carefully. So the way we typically proceed is that we cover the totality of the path shared with the being of the small, the middling, and the great scope in one teaching or one meditation session.
Then this is not how I would like to proceed here. I would like to take the topic of the mental consciousness and its impermanence and examine it carefully with you over time. You think about it from your side. So I would like to proceed in the same way as I proceeded when I explained the existence of past and future lives in terms of substantial cause and cooperative conditions, and we spent several teachings on this topic until you understood it well. Likewise, I would like to enter in-depth in a presentation of the impermanence of the mental consciousness and not do so rapidly, but do so as it is done in the great monasteries.
You’re relying on numerous examples covering the easy points rapidly and the difficult points in-depth and going over and again on over the topic. So Bodhicitta is of the nature of a prayer because when we generate Bodhicitta, we think, if I could attain, then in and of itself, this is of no benefit because in dependence on that alone, we do not attain. We need something to cooperate with bodhicitta to enable us to attain the state of full enlightenment, and that which cooperates is the view of emptiness. Therefore, an explanation of the view is necessary. So let us at present in conjunction with the motivation, meditate during a couple of minutes on the union of method and wisdom.
Please open the paper, page one, and we recite one b, two, three, four, and also page five, number six, Mandala offering, first one and the three. So when we speak of a human being, a man, this human being is imputed on the basis of the first aggregate, the form aggregate, the body. Mhmm. But actually, are five aggregates. The form aggregate, the aggregate of sensation, the discrimination, of compositional factors, and of consciousness.
And the person is imputed on the basis of the fifth aggregate. So when we say that the instance of the person is the mental consciousness, what we mean is that the instance of the person is the substantial continuum of the mental consciousness or the continuum of similar type of the mental mental consciousness, which proceeds from past lives to future lives. So this is a topic which we should explain quietly. I’m very happy to have been able to introduce it. Do you have questions?
Questions? I like that this is very practical, so that’s where I’m coming from. If the mind, continuum is, as the Tibetans say, heart mind experienced sort of in the heart area, does the realization of emptiness end the mental continuum by piercing something? Does it does it not I’m gonna say kill it, but does it puncture it? Is that what liberation is, the end of the mental continuum through puncturing it through the realization Why are you speaking of the heart and the mind?
Well, Geshe la, because when you met me in the car park the other day, you said heart, mind, and and and because I heard a story about the Dalai Lama’s with speaking to monks about emptiness. And a monk clutched his heart area, and the Dalai Lama said he understood. And I imagine that if the mind if it is a mental experience and not an abstract idea, but a physical thing, that if you experience emptiness, you would experience this physical feeling. And so I thought, is that the death of the mental continuum? Is that what?
So the wisdom realizing emptiness has no relation with the heart. It is related to the mind. Yes. Does it stop does it stop the mental continuum of other is past and future lives? Does it do something to the mind so that it that it can’t go on?
Independence and the wisdom realizing emptiness one severs the afflictions. Yes. So if you still have afflictions, you haven’t done It’s not that easy. It is not sufficient to have realized emptiness. One must meditate over it on it over and again over time.
Just going back to the subject of substantial causes and cooperative conditions. Is there also a subdivision of effects so that there would be a substantial effect and then other secondary effects? So if we take the example of a tomato, then the tomato is a substantial cause for the substantial effect, which is a later tomato. Then the cooperative conditions of the tomato would include water, heat, manure, and light. But these are present before the arrival of the latter tomato.
There’s no particular relation after that. What do you mean by something similar Well at the level of the effect? I was for the example, I was thinking of karmic imprints is the substantial cause of say affliction such as anger. So could that then be called the substantial result and the secondary result perhaps being suffering that arises from that anger? Yes.
Why not? Why not? I mean, at the level of the result, these are all
Following on from Jill’s question, what is the substantial cause of karmic imprint? So what exactly the substantial cause of a karmic imprint is? Course for careful analysis, it is best understood through taking an example. If we, for instance, meet someone today and he asks us, what exactly did you do yesterday? Then we remember immediately what we did yesterday.
We are able to do so because the karmic imprints of what we did yesterday foster the memory. Therefore, there is a connection with yesterday. And and and and. Next question. Andrew?
I’ll do my best to keep this clear. I’ll try. It seems odd to say that an instance of the person can be given as the mental continuum because in a previous life, a person may have been an animal, and there is no direct, correlation between the identity of the current person and the animal. So when we say that the instance of the I or the person is a mental consciousness, I think the source of your confusion is that you see the mental consciousness as something else, something which owns houses, which eats meals, and so forth. It’s not the mental consciousness.
I think that’s the way of thinking perhaps. I’m Doug. I’ll debate with you now. So it follows from this that the eye which eats meals and so forth is not the mental consciousness and by extension, the eye which studies texts and so forth is not the mental consciousness as well. It’s helpful to look at this as two.
So it’s not a topic we’d understand at once so easily. We must cover it over and again quietly. Yeah. Just to be clear on what we said before, is there Okay. Is that working?
Yeah. Is there a difference between the desirability of so they could be trying to work on removing the afflictions, and they could be realizing emptiness. Is there are they separate like that, or is there an a desirable order that you should try to remove afflictions from one’s mental continuum and then realize emptiness, or can you do it in any order, or am I totally confused? Initially, one realizes emptiness. And then through meditating on it repeatedly, one will abandon the afflictions.
So that we should try to realize emptiness first. That that is desirable. Yeah. Yeah. Yes.
Slowly, slowly. Yeah. Yeah. It won’t happen quickly. Yeah.
Okay. Keshe la, towards the beginning of the teaching, you said about thinking about the qualities of humans, their capacity to discriminate between thoughts and qualities, and then to think how good it would be if people did this and then this would probably qualify as bodhicitta. Is that not missing one of the aspects of bodhicitta, the aspiration to attain enlightenment therefore, how can Geshe-la say it’s probably bodhicitta? Yes. Indeed.
The object of observation of bodhicitta is fully nurtured enlightenment. And therefore, when we think to ourselves, may all beings be free of these faults, then as a natural extension of this, we seek for the means to freedom of these faults. And as extension of that, we resolve to do so ourselves. And then this leads to bodhicitta. Then there are numerous conditions for bodhicitta.
Okay. Thank you. I was just a question arose following on from Brian’s question about the afflictions, the sequence of eliminating the afflictions and the wisdom realizing emptiness. Could it not be said that the process of eliminating the afflictions starts at the level of the small scope in abandoning the very coarse afflictions that lead to nonvirtuous actions and also in practicing the forbearance that can withstand anger. It is not possible at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope to just abandon the afflictions.
They can only cease temporarily. It is possible to abandon the afflictions only by means of the wisdom realizing emptiness, and this occurs at the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope. Okay. Stop here tonight. Thank you.
Just a couple of announcements. The soup for tea, Tuesday and Wednesday starts next week, half past five.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mandala khyil khor (Tib)
- A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
- mandala offering
- The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
- Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Does the process of eliminating the afflictions begin at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope?
No. At the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope, it is not possible to actually abandon the afflictions. They can only cease temporarily. The afflictions can be abandoned only by means of the wisdom realizing emptiness, and this occurs at the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope.