TBI Recordings – 30082017 LAMRIM

4,235 words

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.

About this talk. The talk opens with Śāntideva’s advice to take refuge now rather than at death, using the analogy of sleep and the study of lamrim to reduce fear of death. It then presents the Mahāyāna paths of accumulation and preparation: entry requires uncontrived bodhichitta, and progression to preparation comes with an insight focused on emptiness. Students ask questions throughout.

File metadata (for organising)

UUID: 43395745-98ed-4a33-a0f1-ce76da96c033

Words: 4,231

Okay. As Śāntideva alludes in a stanza of Bodhisattvacharyavatara, at the time of our own death, no one is able to do anything for us, neither our parents, nor our relatives, nor our children. And as the verses read in the four directions, there is none who does not face death. This causes mental suffering. Then obviously Geshela says this causes mental suffering in the young since the old are too dull to understand anything anymore.

Are you afraid of death? Really? Why? Are you afraid of this? And as Śāntideva adds, it is therefore to protect against this fear that we must seek for a refuge.

Now such a refuge should not be seek searched for far away, but close to oneself, and it is not the case as we so often believe that we only can gain protection at the time of our death from such a refuge. It is actually right now that we benefit from such a refuge. So it is therefore not the case that refuge benefits only at the time of death. It is at present that we must seek for refuge in practice, since it is from now onwards that there is a need for protection. It would be very strange if protection was only required at the time of death, yet this is how we feel about it.

And here, what is required is a study and an appropriation of the lamrim. This is what benefits. And therefore, it would be quite odd if it was only at the time of death that dharma were of benefit. It is from the present onwards. However, to be able to benefit from the teachings at the time of death, one’s death must be an easy death.

Must not be a harsh and painful death. And therefore, from the present onwards, we must take care not only of our physical health, but also of our mental health. Now when we speak of mental health, obviously, the mind is not something which you nourish as you nourish the body. Do you understand? And therefore, it is from today onwards that one must practice for this reason, Śāntideva says in his final verse, actually take refuge from now onwards.

Now take refuge from now onwards here does not refer to generating powerful faith, praying with one’s hands folded, and so forth. It actually refers to studying and to reflecting. This is what is meant here. And it is a benefit for this life. After all, they say that the greatest hardship in this life is death.

Now death is destruction or disintegration, but we have to understand the mode of our own destruction, the mode of our own disintegration. Then our own destruction at the time of death is not just the cessation of breath of inhalation and exhalation. This we have to examine for ourselves. What do we mean by our destruction at death? After all, if we are destroyed, then our difficulty is to destroy too, right?

Why? Self cherishing and the destruction of the self narrative that we believe in. Yes, it is true. It is said in Je Tsongkhapa’s three principles of the path that we have to counter the vanities of this life. The vanities, nang si in Tibetan, are really the traps.

So, here, when one refers to, countering the vanities of this life, it refers to countering desire and craving for all the aspects of this life. And this desire and craving in those who experience it are referred to in Buddhist scriptures as ‘dod chen, as the greatly lustful ones or the greatly desirous ones. Now this great desire, this great lust which we have, is a great desire for possessions, for relatives, for our children, for our family, and so forth. And it is at present that we should endeavor to reduce it because it is not at the time of death that we will be able to do so. Do you understand?

So this is something which we cannot relinquish at once or immediately. We can only relinquish it incrementally and gradually over time through careful study. To say one can relinquish this immediately is really a lie. So as you remember, the three roots in meditation and death and impermanence are meditating on the fact that this is certain, that the time of death is uncertain, and at the time of death, all that is of benefit is dharma. Now, at present, it is very difficult for us to understand the third root.

At the time of death, the only thing of benefit is dharma. But it is through reflecting repeatedly on this that eventually we will gain this understanding. And as a result, the fear and the mental disturbance at the time of death, which arise out of attachment, of craving, will be reduced. So in some senses, Australia has a good system because your kids leave leave home when they are 18 years of age, and you are not very close to them. Then this is very different from the situation in Tibet where children live with their parents for much of their life, and as a result, they are very close.

Then this great attachment to one’s children and to one’s parents causes a lot of suffering at the time of death. So in India, it’s like in Tibet. So in Quebec, for instance, a typical family of relatives living together will comprise 15 or 16 people at the least. So now regarding this fear, at the moment of death, let us take, an example, which is the example of sleep. No one is afraid, while falling asleep.

Right? But yet, what is the difference between sleep and death? Then it is quite strange, but Geshek has pointed out many times, no one in this room can say, I fall asleep precisely at this or that time. It’s impossible. They say, I fall asleep around this period.

So, Geshe, I wanted to ask you, are you afraid of falling asleep? Daddy. Why? Why? Why?

Why aren’t you afraid? Morning. So it was just the same thing, right? You definitely will be reborn. Yeah, yeah, yeah, sure.

100%. So where do you go? So in our case, we can either be reborn in the happy realms or the bad realms. And, if through numerous lines of reasoning and study, we understand what it takes to be reborn in the happy realms and do what is required, then why should there be any fear at the time of death? It is a given we will be reborn in a higher rebirth.

The process is identical with sleep. Right? Then the only reason when we fall asleep at night that we fall asleep without fear and with the absolute conviction we will be reborn the next day is grasping at our own permanence. Because after all, there are a wide variety of causes of death during our sleep. Death from water, from fire, from air, from wind.

For instance, there could be an earthquake, or for that matter, a criminal could break in. Then what? And you sleep a lot and a thief comes in, right? The process of falling asleep and waking up in the morning is extraordinarily similar to the process of dying and being reborn. Just as for instance, the dream state corresponds to the intermediate state, the bardo.

So these similarities have been pointed out by great yogis and scholars for a reason, because they are of benefit to us. It’s beneficial to think about this. Do you understand? So if we lead a good, a righteous life, and during that life, we accumulate as much virtue as we can. And when we commit sins or non virtues, we confess them and we restrain from them in the future.

Then we have accumulated all the conditions for a happy rebirth, a rebirth in the higher realms. Then at the time of our death, there will be no fear, because we will know that we will be reborn, we will awaken, if you wish, in a higher realm. Manifested no fear of any type at the time of death. Now this is an absence of fear which is due to study and realization. It is not the absence of fear of some idiot who basically doesn’t fear death because he doesn’t understand what’s happening.

And therefore, we should start preparing from right now. We should not waste time. If we have time, then we should use it meaningfully, and this is the meaning of the verse of Śāntideva, take refuge actually now. So let us meditate at present during a couple of minutes on the lamrim. Now generally, when you meditate, it’s not appropriate to read a text, but it is helpful to have a text in front of you to consult.

And you engage in an overview meditation of the path shared by beings of the small, the middling, and the great scope. And when you forget something, you check quickly in the text. Then in the case of Tenzin Dolkar and Tenzin Khadro, as they are ordained, they have definitely time. And Gesheila suspects that perhaps they read too much, And he would like to suggest to them that they read a little bit less and instead try to engage in this overview meditation on the lamrim, starting with the path shared by beings of the small scope, then the middling scope, and then the being of the great scope. So let us at present meditate during a couple of minutes on these topics.

Kensur Rinpoche gave a very important piece of advice to his disciples, which Geshela would like you to keep in mind. Rinpoche said, when you meditate on the Lamrim, make sure that the Lamrim text you rely upon is on the table open in front of you. Then if you don’t remember a topic, you can check quickly and continue your meditation. Now this obviously applies to beginners such as ourselves and does not apply to great practitioners who know all the fine points. Obviously, you close the text and you fall asleep, that’s not quite the point.

Right? And you close the text and simultaneously, you just doze off. So most of you know the path shared as a being of the small scope, so to take this as an example, initially before meditating, one should reflect carefully on the relationship between identifying a rebirth of leisure and endowment on the one hand, and death and impermanence on the other hand. What is the relationship? And then what is the relationship between that and the suffering of the three lower realms?

And then, what is the relation between the suffering of the three lower realms and refuge? And finally, what is the relationship between refuge and the four general characteristics of karma? Then Geshela is not terribly sure whether you study or not. One should practice and study from now onwards. From now onwards.

One should practice and study Mhmm. From now onwards. And therefore, actually take refuge today. So at present, Geshela will enter into the presentation of sa lam, of grounds and paths. Then Salam here, Geshela will present in a general, rather coarse fashion.

Because if one chooses to present Salam in a subtle, precise way, it’ll take a lot of time and a lot of study, which we don’t have. Now some of your questions are extremely sharp and subtle questions. They’re not really appropriate for this type of presentation, which is a course general outline. So the way Salam or grounds and paths is presented in the great monasteries is this sort of basic general outline. Because otherwise, when you talk of the say of the path of preparation, you must talk of the object of the mind arisen from meditation, which is emptiness, and that is open ended.

It’s infinite. So instead, one just mentions empty emptiness verbally and moves on. So Geshela covered last time the presentation of these three vehicles and of the five paths, five paths for each vehicle. The path of accumulation, of preparation, of seeing, of meditation, and of no more learning. Now Geshela presented last time the path of accumulation.

Geshela would like to ask you what is the characteristic of the path of accumulation? What is the characteristic of a Mahāyāna path of accumulation? Quick, quick, quick. Exactly. So once someone has generated fully characterized bodhichitta, pure bodhichitta, authentic bodhichitta, such a person has entered the Mahāyāna path of accumulation.

Such a person is a being on the Mahāyāna path of accumulation. Then some of you seem to wonder why having entered a Mahāyāna path of accumulation, one could not immediately proceed to full and utter enlightenment, in other words, a path of no more learning. And this is not possible. One must proceed incrementally path by path. This is not the law, but this is actually the nature of things.

One cannot reach the path of seeing without having passed through the path of preparation first. So what sort of a person, what sort of activities are those in which a being on a Mahāyāna path of accumulation engages in? Well, this is not really a being like us who hangs around, gossips and chats with friends. Right? So, such a being, having had the direct experience of bodhichitta, then is totally focused on gaining realizations and specifically understands that he or she must gain the realization of the wisdom realizing emptiness to put things very simply.

So you might wonder why, for instance, there are 10 grounds. Now these 10 grounds are 10 grounds within the path of meditation, the fourth path. But why 10 grounds? Simply because the goal of these great bodhisattvas is to abandon jneyavarana, the obstructions to omniscience. And to do so, they need to generate ever more powerful and ever more subtle minds realizing emptiness.

Therefore, you have 10 levels of abandonment of the obstructions to omniscience. So one should say that while entry into the Mahāyāna occurs only through generating uncontrived bodhichitta. Progression on the paths upwards occurs through a deepening realization of emptiness. Now regarding the Mahāyāna path of accumulation, someone on the Mahāyāna someone who has just entered the Mahāyāna path of accumulation does not necessarily have to have realization of emptiness. He or she may have realization of emptiness.

However, on the Mahāyāna path of accumulation, they will necessarily have to get a realization of emptiness. So to attain the Mahāyāna path of accumulation, one does not need to gain a realization of emptiness. One needs to get an uncontrived realization of bodhichitta. Have you generated bodhichitta? So whereas there is not a multiplicity of modes of assertion of bodhichitta, there’s only one, there are numerous different versions of emptiness in Buddhist scriptures.

All systems of tenets are identical in what they teach regarding bodhichitta, great compassion and definite emergence. So at present, one has to cover the progression from the Mahāyāna path of accumulation to the Mahāyāna path of preparation. Conscious. What happened? No one is attaining the path of progress of preparation.

We’ll just Ishael, we’ll just continue teaching. I will translate. If you have a little telephone to record. Just one is enough. Does it work?

Yeah. It’s a it’s a voice recording. Good. Good. Okay.

Okay. So how precisely does a bodhisattva progress from the path of accumulation to the path of preparation? This progression occurs through gaining experience in emptiness. So during the Mahāyāna path of accumulation, a bodhisattva gains experience and realization, necessarily realization of emptiness. When precisely does a bodhisattva on a Mahāyāna path of accumulation enter the Mahāyāna path of preparation, when he or she has generated an insight, a vipassana focused on emptiness.

So when a Bodhisattva has generated an insight focused on emptiness, that Bodhisattva has entered the Mahāyāna path of preparation. So therefore, a bodhisattva who has generated an insight which observes emptiness has entered the path of preparation. Another way of putting this is that such a bodhisattva has generated an experience arisen from meditation of emptiness. Now experiences arisen from meditation are non conceptual. If they are conceptual, the bodhisattva is on the path of preparation.

If they are non conceptual, the bodhisattva is on the path of seeing. So as we said, it is when a Bodhisattva generates an insight focused on emptiness that he passes from the path of accumulation to the path of preparation. Or if you prefer, a bodhisattva who has generated an experience arisen from meditation focused on emptiness has entered the path of preparation. So as was explained, experiences arisen from meditation are twofold. You have conceptual experiences arisen from meditation, and non conceptual experiences arisen from meditation.

When a bodhisattva has a conceptual experience arisen from meditation focused on emptiness, he or she is on the path of preparation. And when that bodhisattva has a non conceptual experience arisen from meditation of emptiness, he or she is on the Mahāyāna path of seeing. So when we refer to an experience arisen from meditation focused on emptiness, what sort of an experience is this? This refers basically to a valid cognizer which is focused on emptiness. In other words, to an extremely stable mind, and probably to a mind which will not forget its object.

To give an example of how one acquires an experience of wisdom from meditation, let us take the the training in typing on a computer or a typewriter. So initially, you have to know where the keys are and you have to look at your fingers to type. But eventually, with experience and habit, you can look at the text and just type away. It is the same thing. So at present Geshe, I would like to ask you how does one progress from the Mahāyāna path of accumulation to the Mahāyāna path of preparation?

Which experience? What So when you generate an insight which is focused on emptiness, you enter the Mahāyāna path of preparation. So such a practitioner who can generate an experience of the Mahāyāna path of preparation is said to be a being or a person on the Mahāyāna path of preparation. Mhmm. So a person who has gained or has generated an insight focused on emptiness has become a person on the Mahāyāna path of preparation.

Is he a person on the Mahāyāna path of accumulation? Has he progressed? Yes. Has he progressed from one to the other? He progressed.

It’s same thing as going to school. So when you’ve been promoted from grade school to high school, then you’re no longer in grade school, you’re in high school. What example can you give of a Mahāyāna path of preparation? Precisely. Then apart from that, what can you give?

It’s very strange in general. And Daishe, can you give examples? Yeah. Examples of the Mahāyāna path of preparation. Any of the six perfections within the continuum of a being who has generated an insight which is a calm abiding and a union of a union of calm abiding and insight into emptiness.

So you should always say within the continuum of a Mahāyāna being on the path of preparation. So all these examples you gave are correct. Great compassion, bodhichitta, the realization of emptiness, the six perfections, in other words, generosity, ethics, forbearance, enthusiasm, concentration, and wisdom, within the continuum of a being on a Mahāyāna path of preparation, all instances of a Mahāyāna path of preparation. So you understand that both beings on a Mahāyāna path of accumulation and beings on a Mahāyāna path of preparation are not Ārya beings. These are ordinary beings.

Keep this in mind. So what is the difference between a Mahāyāna path of accumulation and of preparation? Please. Quick.. The question is what’s the difference between you don’t know. I’m just I don’t know.

In my mind I thought the difference was the the generation of Buddha Cheetah and is the path of accumulation and the next preparation was the conceptualization of emptiness. But I feel like I’m either really wrong or I’m confused that you have asked this question. It’s a conceptual experience of emptiness. So to answer this question, you can reformulate it in these terms. Someone who is on the Mahāyāna path of accumulation has not progressed yet to the Mahāyāna path of preparation.

Why? So what you’re saying is that on the Mahāyāna path of accumulation, they have not generated an insight focused on So the difference, in other words, is that a being on a Mahāyāna path of accumulation has not attained or generated yet an insight focused on emptiness, whereas a being on a Mahāyāna path of preparation has generated an insight focused on emptiness. The difference hinges on generating or not generating an insight focused on emptiness. Do you understand? Okay.

So in brief, to enter a Mahāyāna path of accumulation, one must definitely have generated uncontrived bodhichitta. bodhichitta is, if you wish, the door, or entry onto the Mahāyāna path of accumulation. However, one does not necessarily have to have a realization of emptiness on the Mahāyāna path of accumulation. There are those who have it when they enter the Mahāyāna path of accumulation, and there are those who do not have it. So, therefore, one does not need a realization of emptiness to enter the Mahāyāna.

Right? Geshela would like to ask you, it’s a rather sharp doubt. So to enter the Mahāyāna, does one have to have a realization of So then in this case, is it possible for non Buddhist to enter the Mahāyāna path of accumulation? Why? They accept Buddhahood.

They accept liberation. That’s really true. They accept liberation. They use it. So you’re saying they don’t generate bodhichitta, have to give a reason for this.

Then if you say that this is because they don’t generate compassion, they generate compassion, and they definitely generate renunciation. Why can’t they generate great compassion? Says who? Why? Why?

Let’s take Jesus Christ. Yeah. So Jesus Christ only wanted liberation for others. He wished nobody to suffer.

So in other words, Jesus Christ was a being on a Mahāyāna path of accumulation. So then, Jesus Christ was a non Buddhist, who was in Mahāyāna path of Yeah. Yeah. The Sami, you know, actually. Yeah.

Yeah. I think, you know. Also. Such a means you lost the debate. So if Gesheera asks you, can a Tīrthika, a non-Buddhist practitioner, enter the Mahāyāna path of accumulation?

Then you’ve just given the example. Because to enter the Mahāyāna path of accumulation, in which to enter the Mahāyāna, one does not necessarily have to have a realization of emptiness. All one needs is to have generated uncontrived bodhichitta. Then if a realization of emptiness was indispensable to enter the Mahāyāna, then it would be very difficult. Let’s say for Jesus to be a Mahāyāna Bodhisattva on the path of accumulation.

So likewise, are we going to say that there are no practitioners in the among the or the other religions which have generated pure definite emergence? And if so, why? I told you this many many times, I never accept. So if you’re going to say that to enter the Mahāyāna path as accumulation, you have to be a Buddhist, you need a reason for this. Obviously, as far as terminology is concerned, yes.

Right? But if you look at meaning, then it’s an open question. So at present, let’s do the recitations. They won’t be refusing for the tutor. Page five, number six.

If a being generates an insight focused on emptiness prior to the path of accumulation, if at the point where they generate uncontrived bodhichitta, do they also enter the path of meditation at the same, the path of preparation at the same time? There’s no insight focused on emptiness before the path of preparation. By definition, if you have an insight focused on emptiness, you have entered the path of preparation. Sorry. A being who has not entered the path of accumulation can have an insight into emptiness.

There is no definiteness that a being on the path of accumulation has So the first question which is asked by the study group before the classes, is it possible to have a spontaneous uncontrived experience of bodhichitta that is not present at all times? The answer is no. Once one creates an uncontrived experience of bodhichitta, then that bodhichitta, Deshila says, is probably present all the time. In keeping with the verse of Je Tsongkhapa in the three principles of the path concerning definite emergence, in which Je Tsongkhapa says, when definite emergence is present day and night, then it has been fully realized. And because this verse applies to bodhichitta, probably the same thing can be said of actually, because this verse applies to definite emergence, probably the same thing can be said about bodhichitta.

Mhmm. Hey, I wanted to buy a word. It’s a good question. So it is during sleep that one has to examine carefully. Is bodhichitta present continuously?

Does it become non manifest during sleep? So the same rule, we lack too, you know, sleep. Too much, so. It’s a good question, that is something we have to examine. Okay, stop here, Thunette, thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
tirthika mu teg pa (Tib)
An outer being, a proponent of a non-Buddhist system of beliefs with tenets that assert either eternalism or nihilism, views which bind them to samsara. Also known as an outsider, one who adheres to an outsider doctrine. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top