7,067 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
Audio: the recording of this talk is not available.
About this talk. A seminar introduction and question-and-answer session on calm abiding (shamatha) in the Gelug Lam Rim tradition, drawing on Je Tsongkhapa’s Middling Stages of the Path and Lamrim Chenmo. The speaker recommends further reading and covers the preconditions of ethics, the signs of progress, the pitfall of subtle sinking, and how calm abiding relates to insight and emptiness.
File metadata (for organising)
UUID: 9f02869e-b3e3-45d5-a870-51776cd0331a
Words: 7,063
So I’m delighted to see you all for Rinpoche’s Shine seminar, and I will do my best to answer your questions, A bit on par with Daniel and the lion’s pit nobody asked Daniel’s opinion, he just had to fend with the lions. But before we address the questions, what I thought I would do is we’ve handed out a bibliography and I thought I would cover with you the books in question to give you a sense of how you can develop what Rinpoche is teaching. And I make also one or two comments about the translation you’ve been given. So if you take your bibliography, and maybe I can borrow the copy of someone because I don’t have one myself. Yes, exactly, the reading list.
Can you check, look with yes. So basically Khensur Rinpoche is relying on Je Tsongkhapa’s Middling Stages of the Path. This is untranslated in English, I’ve prepared a draft translation for you. It is a draft translation, it is unchecked. I think it is good quality, but as you can see sometimes, because I was working under pressure, I’ve skipped lines.
So when I’ve skipped lines, I will tell you. Then you have a series of complementary works. The practice of Shine in the Gelug tradition is rooted in the Indian tradition. So, we basically rely on Asaṇga’s works and Maitreya’s works. I have given neither Asaṇga’s nor Maitreya’s works in the bibliography because they are basically either untranslated or too difficult.
However, there are simple presentations which are very helpful. The first is this book, which claims to be by His Holiness the Dalai Lama, but actually is His Holiness’s teachings on Kamala Śīla’s stages of meditation. It’s a translation, a partial translation of the stages of meditation, and His Holiness’s teachings on them. This is the work of Kamala Śīla in which he spoke about this morning. Kamala Śīla was the great bodhisattva who went to Tibet.
I can strongly recommend it. Thank you so much. This is the privilege of translators. I can strongly recommend it. Then, there is a very small book, I’ve not put in the bibliography, because it’s by a minor teacher, but it’s very easy to understand.
It’s Gendun Rinpoche’s Calming the Mind. Gendun Rinpoche still is actually, an outstanding Tibetan Buddhist monk who lived much of his life in retreat and is said to have attained calm abiding. He’s one of Alan Wallace’s teachers. If you want a very simple introduction, this is pretty much it. However, the next step upwards after the text you have been given Je Tsongkhapa’s Middling Stages of the Path, has to be the third volume of Je Tsongkhapa’s Lamrim Chenmo.
The Middling Stages of the Path of Jetsong Kappa is a summary of pages 13 to 103 of the great stages of the path. The main difference is that Je Tsongkhapa, after composing this work, which is basically the fundamental work of the Geluk tradition, His Holiness the Dalai Lama compares the Ngagrim Chenmo to the constitution. After composing this work and basically justifying all his assertions with quotes from the great Indian text, Je Tsongkhapa then took the very essence of this work and eliminated many of the quotes. This is the middling stages of the path. So if you want to flesh out what Rinpoche is teaching, I would strongly recommend that you go directly to Lamrim Chenmo.
We have it in the library, we have it in the bookstore. You can decide whether to borrow it or purchase it. And then, I mentioned in the bibliography one major sūtra we have not received. My friend John Powers translated it some twenty years ago, Maitreya’s should I say Buddha’s Samdhinirmochana sūtra, the sūtra Unraveling the Intent. It’s published by Dharma Publishers, a very good translation.
The eighth chapter of that sūtra is the foundation of all of the Buddhist teachings on calm abiding. So, if you want to rely on the fundamental works, which is the way forwards in one’s practice, I’d say relying on that sūtra, relying on Lamrim Chenmo, relying on Kamala Śīla’s text are the way to go about it. Then there are two commentaries: Neither is easy. This one, calm abiding and special insight, I cannot recommend too highly. It was written by Geshe Gedun Lodro, who was a foremost disciple of the late abbot of Drepung monastery, Khensur Legden.
He was perhaps the foremost scholar of his age. He was appointed professor of Buddhist philosophy at the University of Hamburg in Germany, taught in German. It’s a masterpiece. It presents calm abiding both from the standpoint of sūtra and tantra. He passed on before completing it.
Yes, exactly. Jeffrey. Jeffrey Hopkins translated it. I think this came out in 2000 sorry. 1992.
Snow Lion has a policy revised. Yes, this is revised and Snow Lion has a policy of giving new names to books, which is a very big problem. I think it’s the same one actually. It really has to be recommended. I mean, it’s not easy reading, but it’s a masterpiece.
And then there are two works I have brought only one with me, the other is out of print. It’s an old friend, Leah Zahler’s, doctoral thesis on the form and formless realms. As you know, through the practice of the concentrations one can actually be reborn as gods of the form and the formless realms. It’s a separate topic of study. It’s only for those who want to enter in great depth into things.
And then, I think, at present we will address your questions on today’s teachings and your questions in general. It’s excellent, but it’s out of print. It’s out of print. It’s superb. It’s Leah Zahler’s preliminary to this book.
The difference is it’s a better work because basically it is the teachings of La Ti Rinpoche and Denma Locho Rinpoche. And I don’t know if I put it in the bibliography, yes I did. It’s here Lati Rinpoche and Denma Locho Rinpoche, Meditative States in Tibetan Buddhism. You can get it from Abbey Books. It’s more concise than this one, and it is basically the works of two of the greatest scholars and practitioners of the Geluk tradition, Lathi Rinpoche from Ganden Shardze monastery and Denma Locho Rinpoche from Drepung Loseling monastery.
But there’s only a couple around. So, do you have any questions about ‘yes’? Basically, you have three realms, right? The desire realms, the form realms, and the formless realms. The cause for being reborn as a god of the desire realm is what is called mutable karma.
In other words, it is virtuous karma which can change. The cause for being reborn as a god of the form and the formless realm is known as immutable karma. This is not ordinary virtuous karma, it is the karma which is a result of one of the meditative absorptions. So one can only be reborn as a god of the form and formless realm through the practice of one of the higher concentrations, the very first of which is the practice of śamatha, even though technically śamatha is still subsumed within practices of the desire realm. Then the other difference is that gods of the form, and especially the formless realm, have no body.
A god of the formless realm, when he is reborn as a god of the formless realm, has exclusively a mental body. Then there is some debate about whether a very subtle physical body is present or not. But there is no thought during that state. That entire life as a god of the formless realm, which is extraordinarily long, is completely spent in whatever meditative equipoise has been attained. These are the highest beings of cyclic existence.
We cannot even begin to imagine their capacities. Does that answer your question? Yes, and the big problem, let’s say, for a god of the formless realm, such as, for instance, what is called the realm of neither perception nor non-perception, that beyond which there is nothing, is that they are basically constantly in meditative equipoise. They never accumulate any new virtuous karma. So at the end of this period, whatever their karmic situation was before that rebirth takes over.
We have to quantify. All the practice of the concentrations are shared with the non Buddhist traditions. So these practices you can find in Patanjali’s Yoga sūtra, you find in the Jain tradition, you find teachings on all four levels of dhyana, in non Buddhist and Buddhist traditions. In the Buddhist tradition, one tries to attain sufficient concentration. Sufficient concentration is śamatha.
śamatha is sufficient to actually gain the goal of the Buddhist practitioner, which is direct realization of emptiness. At that point, one basically has entered the path of seeing. In and of itself, the practice of śamatha has a strong virtuous component because, even if it is practiced on an object which is non virtuous, like a pebble or a rock, śamatha, when it is attained, entails the drawing inward of all five sense consciousnesses. śamatha is attained on the basis of the mental consciousness alone. So, as a result of śamatha, generally speaking, it is said that the intensity of the afflictions decrease.
During the practice of śamatha, there are no manifest afflictions. So when someone enters in calm abiding, this person becomes like a rock. There is no vision, there is no hearing, there is no smell, there is no sensation of the body, there is no awareness of breathing. Only an exterior observer can determine whether breathing occurs or not, and what occurs is so subtle one has to check very carefully. I was privileged to see one such practitioner in śamatha, and I can vouch for the fact that the body for practical purposes seemed dead.
Then, because there are no sense consciousnesses and only mental consciousness, and because there is no thought, there is no conceptuality at the moment of śamatha, then śamatha acts as a great reducer of the impact of the afflictions. So it has a strong virtuous component. However, through the practice of śamatha, one does not abandon the afflictions. There’s a very important distinction in the Tibetan tradition between preventing and abandoning. Shamatha prevents the afflictions, but after you come out of śamatha, they can arise again.
However, if you meditate on an antidote to a given affliction, let us say if you meditate on an antidote to anger, which would be love, using śamatha, you can actually abandon anger. Abandoning anger means that anger never ever can arise again. Does it go towards answering your question? Are there other questions? Yes.
You cannot, You cannot. Even a calm abiding which is focused on emptiness cannot in and of itself lead to the realization of emptiness. This is quite technical, so we won’t go too much into this. But basically, you can achieve calm abiding on any object: a material object or a non material object, such as a mind, the nature of mind, or emptiness. You can achieve calm abiding based on emptiness.
If you achieve calm abiding based on emptiness, that achievement is not the direct realization of emptiness. If you achieve calm abiding based on emptiness, you still have to generate within that calm abiding an insight, a vipassana, which analyzes emptiness, and it is compared to a fish moving inside a river, which does not trouble the flow of the river. It is that vipassana, that insight, which occurs on the basis of calm abiding and which analyzes emptiness, which leads actually to the path of seeing. Then after that, you return to a calm abiding, which is focused on emptiness. Generally speaking, you have several objects for calm abiding.
You can use any object you want. However, some objects have greater benefits than others. You can realize calm abiding on the basis of a stone. I think many of the shamans used to do this. This is probably the origin of the practice.
But it has no obvious benefit apart from the realization of calm abiding. If you do not achieve calm abiding, the months or the years spent doing this are wasted. All you will have at the time of death is a very clear image of a rock, which is of no great help. Then you can choose, and this is what Kamala Śīla recommends, the statue of a Buddha. Here one actually visualizes a Buddha in actuality on the basis of a statue.
The advantage is that this is an easy object of meditation, and then, even if you don’t attain calm abiding, nonetheless you will find it very easy to remember physically the appearance of the Buddha at the time of death. And then it is possible to attain calm abiding on the basis of a non material object, it’s much more difficult. So, my teacher, Geshe Rabten, is said to have attained calm abiding on the basis of the nature of the mind. In other words, the fact that the mind is clear and cognitive. This is a conventional practice of Maha Mudra.
This is extremely difficult, because you have the difficulty of attaining calm abiding, number one, and number two, you have the difficulty of finding the object, because before concentrating, you have to identify that object, the nature of the mind. So it is said that that is what he attained, and you could also, but it would be extremely difficult, even more difficult, attain calm abiding on the basis of a non material object like emptiness. But then you would first have to conceptually understand emptiness, be able to bring it to mind, and then train in calm abiding on this basis. So the one advantage of attaining calm abiding on the basis of the nature, the conventional nature of the mind, is that even though it’s very difficult, it trains one after having attained calm abiding for the practice of vipassana. That’s one big advantage.
Then I thought, yes. There’s no difference. There is a difference. We’ll see if Rinpoche will cover this tomorrow. As far as the attainment of calm abiding is concerned, there’s no difference.
It’s just another object of concentration. However, the problem is, from a Buddhist standpoint, since the practice of calm abiding is shared with non Buddhists, and since in and of itself it is not a virtuous practice, it’s just a practice of concentration, you want to put that time to good use. So you have different objects of meditation. You have the general objects of meditation, and then you have objects of meditation for practitioners which have specific afflictions. Now, if there are very powerful afflictions in the mind, it is impossible to gain calm abiding.
Someone with very strong desire, very strong anger cannot gain calm abiding until that is dispelled. If such a person, let’s say someone with extreme anger, tries to attain calm abiding on the basis of an image of the Buddha visualized, he will be unable to do so. It is impossible. He actually must change object of meditation, and this is why one should choose the object of meditation of calm abiding in consultation with one’s teacher. Because one’s teacher knows one’s mental disposition, and if the student has a lot of anger, for instance, would suggest an object of observation, which in the practice of calm abiding counters anger as well.
As a result of this, it is possible to reduce anger and to attain calm abiding. Now, regarding your question about the breath, meditating on the flow of the breath, which can be meditating on the flow of the breath or meditating on the sensation of the flow, is recommended in the Gelug tradition for people who have extremely busy conceptual minds. Since this is the case of most Westerners, whose minds tend to be in a constant state of froth, many Westerners find the Theravada practices of vipassana very helpful. Because this meditation on the breath basically reduces that extreme conceptual agitation. This was not the case for the Tibetans.
Tibetans typically have a very different mental constitution from us. There’s a lot of faith, but often a lot of dullness. There’s not a lot of mental froth. So this is something that Rinpoche will cover tomorrow. We will see the various they call it specific objects of meditation, in a function of whether one affliction is dominant or all the afflictions are equal in strength.
Yes? Obviously enthusiasm for concentration. Enthusiasm for ice cream leads to being overweight, that’s all. The qualities that we These were covered this morning on page four or five. If you take your text, page five.
You have five qualities of concentration. Then the one which matters the most for the person depends on one’s constitution. Many Indians consider the main quality of concentration is the attainment of paranormal powers. But whatever it may be, once one thinks of those qualities, then one is very inspired in one’s practice. That gives great force.
Are there other questions? Yes, exactly. I mean, you have to This is a general presentation of the teachings, present, or Hipoca presents everything, but then you have to follow your own path. It is what resonates with you. For instance, someone who is very much a being of the middling scope, very aware of the general suffering of cyclic existence, will find the notion that by śamatha you can then practice vipassana on the basis of emptiness and become an Arhat.
Very inspiring. Someone who is very much, let’s say, a worldly being, would be very interested in the idea that through śamatha you gain paranormal powers. Anyone who claims to have śamatha has paranormal powers as a result of this. It’s automatic. Then, from a Buddhist standpoint, these things are secondary and unimportant, but they can motivate someone who is very worldly in his practice for that.
Then someone who is a great vehicle practitioner will think on this basis he can attain the path of seeing of a bodhisattva, then go forwards. Does that answer your question? That’s not what we’re talking about, just to set the record straight. Don’t listen to her. Anything you want.
I mean, you can pursue wars. You have telepathy. You have psychokinesis. This is something which is not the goal and they are not shown, but, I mean, once the mind becomes single pointed, then these powers are there, then those who have lived with the Tibetan, the great Tibetan practitioners, know this for a fact. My teacher Geshe Rabten could make a hole in a pile of barley dough mentally.
He just focused and there was a hole which appeared. Now if you think of how fragile, not barley dough, barley flour is, you can see how difficult this is. You have complete control over all bodily sensations. So I mentioned last year during the symposium that Geshe Rabten had cancer of the liver and they were fearing a metastasis to the spine. We took him to a Swiss neurologist to have him checked.
This was in the old days where the image of Buddhism and Tibetan Buddhism was catastrophic. We were basically a sect. So this neurologist was extremely contemptuous from day one. And he said to Geshe Rabten, I was translating, that they had to anesthetize him. To check the behavior of the spine on an oscilloscope.
And in Tibetan, anesthetic is just opium. So when I translated that for Geshe Raptan, he said, No, I will not accept anesthetic. And then this doctor said, Well, then in that case I cannot do anything. Geshe-la was very cold, he said to me, You just tell the Swiss witch doctor to do what he has to do, and I will do what I have to do. So I said to the doctor, much more politely than this, that Geshe Raptan took full responsibility, and we had to sign a series of papers and waivers.
And that was quite incredible. Geshe-la sat into meditative equipoise and as far as I could see basically ceased to be a living being. There was just this rock, this mass there, you know. And the doctor was quite terrified. He thought Geshela had passed on.
And then I told him, you know, you just continue, you know, I had never seen this before, I was 22 years old, you know. And then the doctor inserted the needles in the spine and did what he had to do for some ten minutes, was prove them. And after this, Geshe Rabten came out of this state. And I remember to this day what the doctor said to me, he said, This is medically impossible. He said, This is medically impossible.
He said, I went forwards because I wanted to embarrass you. You had signed the waivers. This is not possible medically. Who is this man? So, these are the direct results of calm abiding.
These are subsidiary results. But in India, where the practice of calm abiding is very widespread, there are yogis. There was one I knew of in Varanasi who could cause you to smell any perfume you chose. Now, why you would choose to dedicate your life to meditation for that is another question. But you would just say, I would like to smell a lotus.
He would cause the smell to arise in the mind through concentration. So it’s a tool. It’s a tool, there’s a way to practice it, and that’s why it is so important to receive teachings from someone like Rinpoche who is rooted in an authentic tradition who is a great practitioner. There’s a very precise way to progress, and there are a couple of major pitfalls. If one falls on the pitfalls, then there are some very particular features which develop in the mind, typically increasing forgetfulness and mental dullness.
When this happens, it is a very clear sign of wrongly practiced calm abiding meditation. I’ve seen this very often in Westerners. Then the practice acts as a cause for an animal rebirth, because it’s a cause, Rinpoche will talk about this tomorrow, one basically dwells in a state of subtle sinking. The mind seems to be stable, actually it’s a dull mind, which progressively becomes ever more dull. This used to be known in Tibet under the name of meditation with complete relaxation.
So, it’s a very, very particular problem when one is blocked at a certain level of the nine stages. Are there other questions? Once calm abiding has been attained or achieved, can it degenerate? Yes. It can degenerate at the time of death.
If one is reborn as an animal, having calm abiding does not mean one has attained a path, right? So a worldly being can have calm abiding. Attaining calm abiding merely means that the mind is very powerfully concentrated and has the two pliancies: bodily and mental pliancies. But someone who has just practiced calm abiding, by that fact alone has not entered even the path of accumulation of the vehicle of hearers, solitary realizers or bodhisattvas. Then, normally, if one practices calm abiding regularly after attaining it, it does not degenerate.
There are many debates about this, but even in one life it is said, if one loses complete interest in calm abiding and very strong delusions arise during the period when one is not practicing, it will lead to the progressive decay of calm abiding. Then, until the level of forbearance on the path of preparation, it is possible to be reborn in a hell realm, or any lower realm, then, obviously, such a being loses calm abiding. However, they have strong karmic imprints. So if they were to practice again, could get it quickly. Quickly becoming enlightened is difficult.
Two of the brightest and best Western Buddhist monks I ever knew, Alan Wallace and George Dreyfus, went in solitary retreat under the direction of Geshe Rabten who had achieved calm abiding, and both failed. It’s not easy. Without ethics, it’s not possible. It’s a question I wanted to ask you, actually, since you’ve asked me many questions: Why is ethics so important for calm abiding? Kind of desire.
Yes, just desire. All afflictions, right? All afflictions. Ethics restraint if you want, but ethics, keeping in vows, if one has vows, is the preliminary to the practice of calm abiding. If one can tame coarse physical and verbal behavior, there is a hope to move upwards to taming mental behavior.
Otherwise it’s not possible. So if people live in any which way, running around, drinking, smoking and what not, there is no hope of getting calm abiding. Because the physical and the verbal behavior are untamed, and taming the mental behavior is impossible. So this is why the best basis for calm abiding is monastic ordination. Now, it happens for lay people, there are cases in Brahma, I know of, yes.
But it’s difficult, very difficult. And ideally one would have at least lay vows, as Rinpoche was mentioning this morning, ideally. And that’s a very important point. The preliminary practice, and it’s one of the preliminaries mentioned here, is ethics. Is there anything else?
The biggest pitfall is not being able to differentiate subtle sinking from good concentration. Now, the problem is that at our level we actually don’t know what subtle sinking is. We only know what thinking is. But from the third and especially the fourth level of the nine stages onwards, one can identify subtle sinking. Unless one has received the instructions to do so, one will think that one’s meditation is progressing very well.
It looks you have stability of the object meditated upon, and you have clarity. It appears to the mind without disappearing, in addition it appears clearly. This is something Robert J. Will talk about tomorrow. What is lacking is radiance.
It is not perfectly clear. It is clear, but not perfectly clear. And then it is very easy to relax into that. This was a mistake of an entire category of Tibetan meditators. It is said that Tsongkhapa came mainly to correct misunderstandings regarding emptiness and calm abiding.
Unfortunately, these teachings survive to the present day, these mistaken teachings. I have met young Westerners who told me they were doing calm abiding retreats. And obviously the instructions were wrong, because when I checked them and I said, so how has your memory been going? So a clear sign of doing well and calm abiding is your memory increases dramatically. If your memory increases dramatically, you’re doing well.
But they told me they can become quite forgetful. But they enjoy meditation a lot. Now, that’s not the goal. Yes, it’s a major pitfall, major pitfall. It’s why it is very important to receive very pure teachings on calm abiding.
Because this was condemned very early on by Sakya Pandita, the great Sakya master. I cannot speak about that. What I can say is it’s generally associated with what is called the wrong understanding of Maha Mudra, the so called white seed Mahāmudrā. As I said, I am not trained in the field. I received Dzogchen teachings, but nobody here has the initiations, maybe you have, no one else has the initiations, I cannot talk about that.
Also, I think one has to be very careful. It’s clear that in all traditions there have been misunderstandings. What is very important is just to try to follow as much as we can the authentic sources from ancient India, and authentic practitioners who have really gained the results. Now, there are other traditions in which these errors have been condemned. For instance, as I said, Sakya Pandita, in the Sakya tradition in the thirteenth century, late twelfth, early thirteenth century, very forcefully condemns what he calls the wrong practice of Mahāmudrā.
He says this wrong practice of Mahāmudrā, not Mahāmudrā in general, wrong practice of Mahāmudrā, in other words, this wrong concentration, which entails basically abiding in a state of subtle sinking, is a cause for rebirth as an animal. This is very sad, really, because you have meditators who put tremendous effort in creating the cause for something they could have gotten with no effort at all. His Holiness mentioned this. He said, in Tibet sometimes there was so much hardship, so much effort for nothing. So that’s why the instructions regarding calm abiding in Lamrim Cemo are exceptional.
I really would encourage you to move up to Lamrim Cemo from the middling Lamrim, because Je Tsongkhapa basically drew the totality of the Indian tradition, and he drew his own experience. Are there other questions? Yes. Oh, the bumi. Yeah.
A bumi means a ground in Sanskrit. So we have the paths and the grounds. All three categories of beings, the hearers, the solitary realizers and the bodhisattvas, progress on five paths: the path of accumulation, of preparation, of seeing, of meditation and of normal learning. So they attain their final goal on the path of no more learning. And they attain before that direct realization of the emptiness of their path on the path of seeing.
Then the interval between the path of seeing and the path of no more learning is divided into 10. These are called the 10 grounds. Bhumis in Sanskrit. So I can’t tell you, this is based on my own personal experience and talking to great meditators. It’s not something I have seen in texts.
It’s a criterion which is used. So the criterion for calm abiding, good results in that meditation, is a steady increase in mental clarity, in concentration and in memory. And then, anything which goes in the opposite direction is harmful. Then an increase in memory not only is not harmful to a meditator, it’s extremely beneficial. There’s a lot of problems which have arisen because of mistaken translations of the terms in English.
So, the term which I have translated throughout as recollection is often translated in English as mindfulness, which is a very bad translation. Smriti in Sanskrit means memory. It means nothing else. Then I chose to translate it as recollection, but if you translate it as mindfulness, then you can’t really understand what the difference is between that and the vigilance, which you have to train in as well, because mindfulness and vigilance in English basically are pretty synonymous. These are two completely different terms.
In one case, at the beginning, you train in memory. In other words, this is the memory of the object of meditation, the recollection of the object of meditation. It’s not the mindfulness of the object of meditation. I think the misunderstanding arose because the terms are used in a slightly different way in the Theravada and in the Tibetan tradition. What you train in, especially during the first three levels of the nine stages of calm abiding, is in the power of memory.
And then from the third level onwards you train in the power of vigilance, which is the awareness of what’s happening. Memory is not the awareness of what’s happening, It’s merely the powerful recollection of whatever object you are meditating upon. So you can see once you use these translations that any practice of common abiding, which leads to the decay of memory, recollection, is wrong. Definitely wrong. So you can check for yourselves if you practice calm abiding.
If you see your mind becoming more dull, if you see your intelligence becoming more dull, if you find yourself more forgetful, you are definitely practicing wrongly. Definitely. Yes. In those circumstances, are you actually practicing calm abiding or is it the case that you’ve not proceeded in a way that would allow you to practice calm abiding? You haven’t attained it by definition.
You were trying to attain it, but have run into what are known as the obstacles to concentration. That’s why this is not easy material, the material in calm abiding is not easy material, but it is very important to work through it carefully, keeping in mind that we in the West, we have tremendous experience in technological success. But we understand very little, if anything, about the mind. From the standpoint of the great meditators, we are primitives in this field. Then they have first hand experience.
For instance, if you take Asaṇga, let’s say, by the time Asaṇga wrote the grounds of the hearers, there had been explicit practice of calm abiding in India for probably close to one thousand years, A bit less than that, maybe. Then, these were specialists. So Asaṇga gave one presentation, Maitreya in his separation of the middle and the extremes gave a different presentation, these are different roads to the same path. As Rinpoche explained this morning, Asaṇga’s presentation is more of a Hīnayāna presentation, Maitreya’s presentation is a Mahāyāna presentation, they are complementary. And Je Tsongkhapa fused the two.
Je Tsongkhapa drew both on Maitreya’s presentation, which was dominant during his age, and on the oral tradition of Asaṇga’s presentation, which came to him through a Kadampa Geshe called Geshe Lhogsampa. And he linked the two, A very powerful linkage. Does that help to answer your question? That Rinpoche will cover tomorrow. The main antidote to sinking is recollection.
But Rinpoche will cover that in detail, what recollection is, how to practice it. There are major, very clear distinctions to be made between forgetting the object of meditation, coarse thinking and subtle thinking. And it is only through observing one’s mind in meditation that one can see that. So in our case, I think for most of us we don’t even know what thinking is. If we try to meditate, I don’t know how many of you try to meditate, does anything, if you try to visualize, appear to the mind?
So if nothing appears to the mind, you’re not even on the first of the nine mental levels. If something appears to the mind and fifteen milliseconds later you think of your grocery list, that’s not sinking. That’s forgetting the object of meditation, you know. So those are extraordinarily our minds are extraordinarily coarse. We’re not aware of this because we do not check, we do not introspect.
Actually, one of the first signs that one is starting to progress in the nine stages towards calm abiding is that one has the impression one’s mind is more agitated. It’s the very first sign. It’s not that the mind is more agitated, but through developing the power of introspection, one actually becomes aware of the agitation which had always been there. That’s the very first sign, you know. People, when they start meditating, let’s say, I’ll come abiding, visualizing, let’s say, an image of the Buddha, they typically will come to the teacher and they say, my mind has suddenly become impossible.
I’m thinking about all sorts of things all the time when I meditate. It’s not that their mind has become impossible, it’s that they had never noticed this before. Yes? In and of itself, abiding doesn’t lead you to any particular realization. As we said, it doesn’t lead you onto a path.
Now, through practicing calm abiding on an object of meditation which counters afflictions, it can lead to a great improvement. If you have a lot of desire, for instance, practice calm abiding on ugliness. Then the mind of desire would definitely abate. Definitively abate. Then the rest is quite technical.
What insight is, how insight arises, independence on calm abiding, perhaps in which he will talk about this at the end. Perhaps. You wanted to ask something, yes? So, basically a practice of the 10 virtues is indispensable to attain calm abiding. There’s no such thing as attaining calm abiding if one lives in sexual misconduct or is a professional thief.
It doesn’t happen. So, one of the questions Rinpoche always asks people who tell him they’re meditating on calm abiding is what their behavior is. Typically, if people are very loose in their behavior, then there is no attainment of calm abiding possible. When, however, we train in calm abiding, we have to make this real distinction between meditation in general and training in calm abiding. It is different.
We’re doing different things. For us, what is most beneficial is analytical meditation. By far. I mean, whether one can practice calm abiding or not in this life, one has to practice analytical meditation. That transforms the mind.
Analytical meditation on the Lamrim. It’s analytical meditation which changes our mind, which changes our behavior. The problem is when we engage in analytical meditation, the mind which is meditating is extremely dull. It’s basically akin to chopping carrots with a dull knife. You can do it, but it causes a lot of force and you don’t do a good job of it.
So, then what one tries to do is to sharpen the tool. Sharpening the tool leads you nowhere towards supper. You can sharpen the knife a lot. Until you start cutting the carrots, you’re not closer to supper. That’s calm abiding.
Calm abiding is sharpening the knife. Now, the difference between the Buddhist and the non Buddhist traditions is that the non Buddhist traditions aim for a razor sharp knife. The Buddhist traditions say, sharp enough is okay, and sharp enough is a mind trained by calm abiding. So, for us, at the beginning, this is what Rinpoche has emphasized, analytical meditation on Lamrim is fundamental. On top of that, if one can train in calm abiding, good.
But this morning, the raison d’etre, the presentation of the preconditions, is to show that it is not possible to gain calm abiding otherwise. You cannot gain calm abiding if you go around your normal life. It doesn’t happen. There are some major misrepresentations of calm abiding in the West, in Australia and in Europe. People think that just going on with their ordinary life, maybe one or two sessions a day, it’s going to happen.
It doesn’t happen. When you train in calm abiding, you take vows, you receive precisely the instructions from your teacher, then you go into a retreat with perfect conditions, which we explain here. You do, it is said, 18 sessions a day, but however number of sessions you do, very short, very targeted sessions, and then independence on this, it’s a toss. There’s no guarantee. At least one very fine Geshe, I know, Geshe Sengchen Rinpoche, said, Well, it is true that calm abiding is fundamental, but so few attain it.
I know that in the nineteen sixties, my late teacher Geshe Raptan was the only Tibetan Geshe known who had attained karma abiding. His Holiness the Dalai Lama’s instructor or counselor for spiritual affairs. His Holiness sent him to teach the other Geshe’s a meditation practice. It is not easy. It’s not just good concentration.
Where it helps us is it enables us to understand what good concentration is and how to eliminate the course obstacles in our own meditation. Someone who has attained calm abiding must actually define the point at which he will leave meditation before he starts. Otherwise, he continues indefinitely. So he sets a boundary. I will leave meditation in two hours.
Otherwise, the meditation, there is no conceptual thought, there is no sense data coming in, there is only the object of meditation, with perfect clarity and stability, as well as bodily and mental pliancies. A bliss we do not even begin to imagine. This is just a worldly concentration, you know. So it’s not easy. I think what the preconditions do is they make it very clear that there are conditions which are required.
I think we have time for one more question. Yes, Richard? Enthusiasm. How to generate it? Well, the first is enthusiasm for meditation, for training in calm abiding.
So If you don’t believe that meditation has any benefits, you’re not going to have enthusiasm. In our case, for instance, if we look at our lives, what do we have enthusiasm for? We have enthusiasm for relationships, we have enthusiasm for money, we have great enthusiasm for going to the doctor for our health. Why? Because we are convinced of the benefits.
Nobody has to tell any one of us that we should be careful investing our money. Nobody tells us about the benefits of relationships, because we think this is a source of real happiness. We have experienced some transient happiness through that. Once one starts experiencing the bliss of meditation, but one has to have tasted that, then it’s actually not meditating which is difficult. That is enthusiasm.
But at a certain point, one has to do the retreats. One has to go there, try and taste. Only experiences come with the experiences conviction comes, with conviction eventually enthusiasm comes. Because there is a cycle, I’ve seen it with many good practitioners, where at first there is a lot of doubt, they just buy the package intellectually, then they do a retreat to see. During the retreat, suddenly they get some very special experiences, one or two.
Suddenly, it’s a big shock. Ah, what the teachers are saying is actually true. The vast majority of Westerners don’t seem to believe that what our teachers are saying is actually true. Then, suddenly, everything else is put in question. They think maybe the other things they talked about are also true.
Then they do another retreat. They gain one experience, two experiences. Then they start thinking, Ah, everything society is saying is perhaps not that dead on. And independence on that, real enthusiasm arises. But one has to go on self, as Geshe Rabten always said, one has to try the chocolate.
He used to say, You can talk about the taste of chocolate until you are blind in the face without convincing anyone of how delicious it is. You have to eat it. So I think with meditation it’s the same thing. Does that go towards answering your question? Good.
Then I think we have to stop for today, and I will do my best to answer your questions tomorrow. Try to have a look at some of the books, think you will find them of benefit. Thank you very much.
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- Gelug
- The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- Mahamudra chag ya chen po (Tib)
- The Great Seal; a profound system of meditation upon the mind and the ultimate nature of reality. LYWA
- pandita khäpa (Tib)
- Scholar; learned person. Often referred to as pandit, (without the final a), which is the Hindi pronunciation of the Sanskrit. LYWA
- path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
- The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Once calm abiding has been attained, can it degenerate?
Yes. It can degenerate at the time of death. Normally, if one keeps practicing regularly after attaining it, it does not degenerate. But if one loses interest in calm abiding and strong delusions arise while not practicing, it will progressively decay. Until the level of forbearance on the path of preparation, one can be reborn in a hell realm or other lower realm and lose calm abiding. Such a being has strong karmic imprints, so if they practiced again they could regain it quickly.