TBI Recordings

1 h 41 min · 4,836 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 101-minute teaching, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen opens with two profound verses from Ārya Asaṇga on emptiness and the cessation of rebirth, emphasizing the importance of memorizing them. He then provides detailed commentary on the Buddhist path, distinguishing the path of accumulation from the path of preparation—the latter subdivided into four stages: warmth, peak, forbearance, and supreme dharma. The core of the session focuses on karma theory: how virtuous and non-virtuous actions accumulate, and how karma increases in potency both through outer manifestation and inner habituation. Geshe-la stresses that the power of karma depends not only on motivation and intention but equally on the qualities of the recipient or object. He illustrates this with examples ranging from offerings to the Buddha to insults directed at monks. The final two-thirds of the talk consists of extended Q&A, where students probe the mechanics of karma, the role of awareness in accrual, the significance of the moral base receiving an action, and how Buddha-nature relates to the differential effects of karma. Pitched at serious practitioners with prior study of Buddhist philosophy.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Salam02082016 2.mp3

UUID: 0c4e8284-180e-4d8c-a8b6-c8d869ecf2fe

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Emptiness

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~4,834

So as Ārya Asaṇga says in the, upon seeing the truth, there is no more impelling karma. Upon eliminating craving, there is no longer rebirth. Seeing the truth here refers to the direct realization of emptiness by means of a direct yogic valid cognizer. And upon eliminating craving, there is no longer rebirth refers to the attainment of the state of an arhat upon eliminating the afflictions. I would like to suggest to you that you memorize these two verses of Asaṇga.

They are short and they are very profound. I’ll repeat the two verses. After seeing truth, there is no impelling. Once bereft of craving, there is no more rebirth. Obviously, you should memorize them in English.

Right? So these two verses are easy to memorize. The first verse, upon seeing truth, there is no longer impelling refers to the fact that upon seeing emptiness by means of a direct valid cognizer, there is no longer creation of impelling karma. The second verse refers to the fact that once one has attained the state of an arhat, there are no afflictions left. So the first verse, therefore, refers to the fact that upon gaining direct realization of emptiness for the first time, in other words, when one has entered the path of seeing at the first instant of becoming an ārya being, from that point onwards, one no longer generates impelling karma.

This is quite straightforward to understand. The second verse is more complex since its understanding depends on the schools of tenets. It is an open question whether all schools of tenets accept these two verses of Asaṇga or not. But either way, the understanding of the second verse in the light of the latter two schools of tenets is that once one has become bereft of craving, in other words of the afflictions, there is no longer ingress into cyclic existence under the power of the afflictions. The understanding of this verse in the light of the two lowest schools of tenets, in other words, Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika, is that once one has become bereft of the afflictions, there is no ingress into cyclic existence, period.

So the understanding of this verse in the likes of the various schools of tenets is complex. The lower schools of tenets consider that, there is only one Buddha, one teacher Buddha, Śākyamūni. And upon completing his cycle of teaching, this is position of the lower school of tenets. Upon his entering into Parinirvana, he ceases to exist. His continuum is severed.

And this is a case for all who attain that state. Then since the lower schools of tenets do not accept, actually do not refer to the existence of pure lands from their standpoint, if the Buddha were to be reborn, in other words, if his continuum were not severed, then he could only be reborn in this world of ours. In other words, in cyclic existence. And such rebirth, they consider is only possible under the power of afflictions. But Buddha Śākyamūni abandoned the afflictions and eliminated them.

So this is, therefore, the position of the lower schools of tenets as far as the meaning of this final verse is. Having become bereft of craving, there is no longer rebirth. Means for these schools of tenets that the continuum of the being is severed. He or she ceases to exist. This is not the understanding of the higher schools of tenets.

In other words, Cittamātra and Madhyamaka. So please answer in only a few words. What’s the difference between the path of accumulation and the path of preparation? At at the path of preparation, you would have achieved insight Mhmm. Calm abiding and insight.

Before that before that, you haven’t developed that insight. So it’s a so so answer. You have to add focused on emptiness. So at the level of the path of preparation, you have attained an insight, actually a union of an insight and calm abiding focused on emptiness. Before that, broadly speaking, you have attained a calm abiding focused on emptiness.

Now this question presupposes that one has entered the path. In reason, for a being who has entered the path, in other words, who has generated stable, uncontrived, definite emergence, the period extending from that point up to the point at which an insight focused on emptiness is generated is a path of accumulation. From the point of the generation of that insight focused on emptiness up to the direct realization of emptiness is a path of preparation. Now the path of accumulation is, briefly speaking, subdivided into three, the small middling and great path of accumulation. The small path of accumulation begins at that instant at which one has generated, broadly speaking, an uncontrived definite emergence.

In other words, the stable experience of definite emergence. And the middling path of accumulation begins with the realization that to attain the state of liberation, one needs a direct realization of emptiness, which is generated by an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight. For this, one needs an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight. And for this, one must first generate a calm abiding focused on emptiness. And at the level of the middling path of accumulation, this is what one generates.

The great path of accumulation in turn extends from the instant at which one has actually generated a calm abiding focused on emptiness to the moment just before one has generated an insight focused on emptiness. The first instant of an insight focused on emptiness is the first instant of the path of preparation. So the path of preparation is subdivided into four, warmth, peak forbearance, and supreme Dharma or supreme phenomenon. At the instant of entering the path of preparation, one enters it at the level of warmth. And warmth here refers to heat.

In other words, the heat produced by fire and such things which is so so useful. The metaphor warmth is used here because for the first time, one gains a realization of emptiness by means of inseparable union of calm abiding and insight, and this acts as a very powerful antidote to the delusions in the same way as fire can destroy kindling and so forth. The following level of the path of preparation is peak, called peak because at this point, the afflictions lose their potency or their power. The following level is forbearance, called forbearance because at this point, one is no longer afflicted by the doubts or the fear which arose previously. And the final level of the path of preparation is supreme Dharma because at this point, one is a supreme among all ordinary beings.

All levels of the path above this are paths of abandonment.

At this point, one will enter the path of seeing. And as you said, upon seeing truth, there is no longer any impelling. Once one has entered the path of seeing, one no longer produces impelling karma. Therefore, one must clearly understand that the producer of impelling karma is necessarily a being on the level of supreme Dharma of the path of preparation and below. At this point, it is appropriate to offer an explanation of causality.

Generally speaking, karma is subdivided into physical, verbal, and mental karma. Shall set aside mental karma because we don’t have time to enter in the analysis. And physical and verbal karma in turn are subdivided into virtuous and non virtuous physical and verbal karma. Generally speaking, virtuous physical karma is the impelling cause for rebirth in a higher realm. Nonvirtuous physical and verbal karma is the impelling cause for rebirth in a lower realm.

So this analysis of karma applies obviously to this world of ours when we speak of virtuous physical and verbal karma. It is in the realm of desire. Probably in the form and the formless realms, there is no particular means to generate physical and verbal karma. All karma is mental. So let us analyze the mode of accumulation of karma, for instance, virtuous karma.

And in this context, within the abandonment of the 10 non virtuous deeds, let us analyze the virtuous karma arisen from the abandonment of killing. When one decides not to kill another person with as a motivation, the thought, if I kill this person or this being, I will experience a lower rebirth in the future. I will experience a shorter life in my future lives, and others will harm or endeavor to kill me. At that point, one has accumulated virtuous karma, the virtuous karma of the abandonment of killing. The second instant of that is a potency which carries over into the future.

Let us analyze at present the mode of accumulation of non virtuous karma. For instance, the non virtuous karma of killing. Initially, one generates the motivation or the intent to harm another person. And after generating this motivation, one then uses the requisite means to harm this person. It can be all sorts of means, including weapons or explosives.

And, when one has actually harmed this person, if as a result of this harm, the person’s person dies, then one has accumulated a non virtuous deed of killing. Now this in worldly affairs is a crime. It is a crime. We call it a sin. It is carried by the intent to harm another person.

Who incurs that sin? None other than the person who committed the murder. So this is the first general characteristic of karma, the definiteness of karma. Now the second general characteristic of karma is the increasing nature of karma, literally in Tibetan, the increasingness of karma. You have two words here, increasingness and karma.

Karma refers to the cause. Increasingness or increase refers to the multiplicity of effect one karma can cause. This is the meaning of the increase of karma. So within the four general characteristics of which I assume you know, the definiteness of karma, the increasing nature of karma, the fact that one does not encounter uncreated karma, and the inexhaustible nature of karma, this is the second outline. So when karma increases, this increase is both manifest in the exterior physical world, and there is an interior mental increase.

The exterior increase impacts the interior mental increase. So let’s give an example to clarify the issue. Let us take a seed. For instance, the seed of the mango tree. Now when we plant the seed of the mango tree, eventually a mango tree will rise, and this mango tree will have a trunk, numerous branches, leaves, and will itself produce numerous mangoes.

In this way, one cause, the seed of a mango tree, produces numerous effects, numerous mangoes down the line. This is the meaning of the increasing nature of karma. Same thing with apples. You plant one apple seed and you get a tree producing many apples. We could also give the example of money.

If you set money aside, then over time, you know, in the bank account or whatever, it would increase and produce ever more money. These are examples of the increase of Another example of the increase of karma occurs when we make a distinction between the accumulator or the performer of karma and the base on which karma is accumulated. In other words, the recipient, if you wish, of the deed. And an example which is given is that of someone who insulted numerous monks, calling some dogs, other donkeys, and others by other unsuitable names. As a result, just for calling a monk a donkey, he was reborn for 500 lives in that aspect.

So, obviously, such non virtuous karma would only be accumulated with respect to a monk with pure ethics. Then the second example which is given is that of a lady who, out of deep faith, offered to Buddha Śākyamūni a handful of rice. And as a result of this, in the following life, attained the state of a Buddha or a solitary realizer. This is due to the power of the base, Buddha Śākyamūni, who out of his kindness taught manifesting deeds of body and speech. Then the Tibetan term for increase of karma is is karma rgyas pa.

Karma means action, and rgyas pa means to increase. So refers to the increase, refers to the result. As was said, karma has both interior and exterior manifestations, and also this increase in karma depends on the power or the force of the object. Please, therefore, meditate during a couple of minutes on this to generate the motivation, and then ask whatever questions you have. Okay?

Yep. In in the Guru Puja, there’s a verse that says, please bless me to see that all the sufferings that arise to be the ripening of my negative karma in the prayer. Mhmm. Can comment a little bit on this this verse? If you can give the exact first, he will comment.

If you give me the text, I can give you. Another another question. Okay. My question is in relation to the third stage in the path of preparation, the name forbearance. I I don’t understand the translation.

In English, for the word forbearance basically roughly translates as patience. Mhmm. Mhmm. But the meaning of this stage of of the path of preparation is to not be reborn in a lower realm. So why does it get why is it translated as the the word is forbearance?

Why? So forbearance of patience is subdivided into three. The forbearance of focusing on emptiness, the forbearance of accepting suffering, and the forbearance of not retaliating against those who harm us. Here, the usage of forbearance, the first is the first usage, the forbearance of focusing on emptiness. And the reason for which at this stage, one is no longer reborn in the lower realm has probably little to do with forbearance as forbearance, but much to do with the habituation of focusing on emptiness.

So in addition, and this is perhaps more cogent, to be for non virtuous karma, and we have accumulated large amounts of non virtuous karma to act as a cause of a lower rebirth, conditions are required. These conditions are the afflictions which cause a maturation of non virtuous karma. Now at the level of forbearance of the path of preparation, these conditions are no longer able to cause a maturation of non virtuous karma. At the level of the path of seeing, it no longer happens at all. Do you understand?

Really? Good. Thank you. You’ve asked many times about forbearance. I think it’s a third time.

I’m very patient. Okay. Maybe you won’t be be born in the lower. So this stanza in the lama chöpa which reads, should the receptacle and the beings within it be suffused with sin and should unwanted for suffering fall upon us like rain, bless me to see this as bless me to take evil conditions on the path seeing them as an exhaustion of previously accumulated non virtuous karma. The meaning of this stanza is that when in our life we encounter numerous difficulties, we should view these as a maturation of previous non virtuous karma which we have accumulated.

So regarding my explanation of the increase of karma, was that clear or not? If it was not clear, what are your questions? To understand about karma. What do you understand about the increasing nature of karma? Really?

A 100%? Maybe 85. Okay. Yeah. Chris.

I have a question about the power of the object with respect to positive or negative results. With the example of the person who called the monk a donkey and had experienced 500 lives as a result, was that person aware of the pure vows within that monk? If not, what is the significance of the subject’s awareness of the power of the object to bring about a positive or negative outcome?

So the it is extremely important for the base to be powerful in this case, that the base should have pure ethics. Now first in the example I gave of the lady who offered rice to the Buddha, it is because of the qualities of the Buddha’s body, speech, and mind that this offering of rice became such a powerful offering. Then in the case of the monk who called another monk a donkey, it is precisely because of the purity of the vows of this other monk that the first monk incurred such heavy karma. Did that monk know that that sorry. Did that person who called the monk a donkey know that that person had such vows?

Is there is no definiteness in this matter. In other words, there are such accumulators of powerful karma who know that the recipient has pure ethics, and there are those who do not know. So what is the significance then of the mind of the subject to be what is the mechanism at work if the if the subject And the unaware of of the base of the object, you know, to affect to affect such an outcome? Because we could have such heavy karma because the recipient was a powerful base. Good.

That’s, you know, result. But but the what is the mechanism? Because the the subject doesn’t know that. So it is irrelevant whether the performer or the perpetrator of the deeds knows the qualities of the recipient or not. And let me give you an example.

Let us imagine that someone, let us say yourself, were to murder the prime minister. Then after that, you would you claimed you didn’t know he was a prime minister. Would anyone believe you? What difference would it make? So that would mean that everybody who has contact with his holiness, the Dalai Lama, has karmic a karmic connection, which will ripen in a positive way even if they because of the power of the Dalai Lama.

Depends on the motivation. Must be motivation. You need the motivation. Oh, should you understand? I expect I expect Talk up.

Talk up? Can you hear me? Yes. Okay. Alright.

Talk up. I expect like Natalie,, this is the third time I’ve asked this question, but I find the issue of physical and mental karma a bit baffling in the context of abandon abandonment of the determination to kill abandonment of killing. In the first place, I find it surprising that that constitutes physical a physical act or physical act of karma as opposed to a mental one when it doesn’t involve a physical act. It involves a mental act. And secondly, just to label, to consider that that act of abandonment, whether it’s physical or mental, is virtuous seems surprising when I would have thought that to have had the motivation to kill in the first place is is a non virtuous.

The fact that you’ve abandoned it is only a partial improvement upon the situation. At least, I suppose you haven’t gone gone through with it, but but the the not there would there’s a higher element of non virtue in in having had the motivation in the first place. To answer your first question, the reason for which restraining from killing is called a physical virtuous karma or a virtuous karma of the body is because the deed of killing is related to the body. Then on this basis, one designs or one calls the restraint from that a virtuous physical deed. So regarding your second question, you misunderstand what is meant by restraint from killing.

One does not initially generate the motivation to kill and then abstain from it. Instead, one reflects on all the thoughts and disadvantages of killing, and then one abstains from killing. Really enjoyed Chris’ question. I just like to follow-up from that, which is the following. I think if the unknown power of the face can still have an important implication on on the outcome from from the karma, then it can lead to adverse situations.

So for example, if I know that a person I’m going to call donkey a is someone that is not particularly good, then I can call that person any type of name I like without incurring too much negative karma despite the fact, in my humble opinion, whether I call someone who is bad a donkey is just as poor as calling the prime minister a donkey. And secondly, if you kill the prime minister, I will presume your sentence in the law would be just as bad if you killed any other person. Please, let’s stop talking about the prime minister because I don’t want ASIO to show up. Okay? So take another example.

So Yes. What you say is true. However, basically, even though there is a thought in calling someone whatever inappropriate name you choose to call him when he has no qualities, it is less than calling a powerful base by that name. In the text, one refers to the difference in power of the field. Can I ask an auxiliary question?

Just a minute. So I’d like to ask you a question. I mean, all of us in this room, you know, we eat meat, we kill flies, we may even have killed pigs and so forth. But when we speak of killing a human being, we say this is a big, big crime. Oh, why?

Alright. Yeah. That’s okay. Maybe not for the fly. You know, it’s it’s all relative, really.

You know? But if if I were to look at it from the other perspective, the lady that donates a gift of rice to the Buddha, then my question is, what is more important? The motivation behind the gift or the power of the base? Because it depends, therefore, I would say, how altruistic the the giver is relative to the power of the base. So which one dominates?

I can play for it, frankly. I know this person who bought a gift. I’m gonna give praise because I know I’m gonna be rewarded. Whereas there’s a poor person there who’s insignificant, I won’t donate anything. So to me, again, I see adverse outcomes from from this particular concept.

It’s a valid doubt, but I don’t think that the lady who offered rice to the Buddha had such ideas in her head. She just offered rice out of faith in the qualities of the Buddha. However, the karma which is accrued depends on the power of the base here, and this comes from the side of the base. This follows on from Richard, but in a sense, Ralph’s question may have been answered. In the example, Geshe la, of someone refraining from killing because they’re frightened of what’s going to happen to them, they may have bad rebirths.

That doesn’t seem to me virtuous. That seems to be grounded in self-cherishing. What to me seems virtuous is someone who doesn’t kill, not because there’s a law of the land and they might go to prison, but because they genuinely value the other human being, and they think I they deserve happiness as much as me. Their happiness is more important than mine, and I mustn’t harm them.

What you say is true. When one abstains from killing another wishing not to be reborn in the lower realms, but to be reborn in the higher realms, That is indeed motivated by self-cherishing by egoism. It is a virtuous deed motivated by egoism. There are virtuous deeds motivated by egoism. Not all virtuous deeds are motivated by the wish not to harm others or for that matter to benefit them.

Oh, I think percruise. Mhmm. Do children accumulate less karma due to their minds being immature? Light or heavy? What do you say?

The children accumulate karma to a lesser extent. Yes. I think because they don’t have a lot of motivation, most of the karma they commit is neutral. Mhmm. I wanted to ask is that somebody, you know, like, they steal for stealing for their living, and they don’t see this as a fault in their life.

So they see this is right. Mhmm. And we see it’s wrong. So they they commit the number just did, but I think this is the right way. Mhmm.

Mhmm. So is it that karma to be like that? Or or so it’s a big they they can, you know, like unless they see it’s wrong, they will come out of it and change their account. So in this matter, it’s very similar to the way of the world. Whether people accept karma or don’t accept karma, when they steal, they accumulate non virtuous karma.

In the world also, whether you say that stealing is okay or not, if you steal, the police comes after you. My question is about the base, and I won’t talk about prime ministers, but I’m just wondering about president Kennedy, for example. Was he an example like, was would he be considered very strong base compared to just another human being who would be murdered? So how does a how does a strong base actually get how do you get to be a strong base? So it’s an example I gave the prime ministers.

I just meant to say that if in worldly matters, you harm the prime minister, then you’re in big trouble. Then whether president Kennedy or the prime minister is a powerful base or not, it depends on their qualities. We have to examine. Right? Just you know?

Okay. Isn’t the point that we can’t know another person’s mind? So we we can’t see who has qualities and who doesn’t have qualities, you know, because of because of that reason. So this talk about who is someone that is maybe someone we shouldn’t harm or not irrelevant because of that? Yes.

It basically makes no difference whether we know or do not know that the person with respect to whom a deed is performed is a powerful base or not. The qualities of the person affect the power of the deed which is performed. Now if we take the deed of killing, killing is a non virtuous deed whatever happens. But if in addition, the victim is a powerful base, the deed becomes more powerful. But if we all have the potential to have if we all have Buddha nature and we all have the potential to be Buddhas, then the qualities of the person really aren’t relevant.

I mean, the deciding that one person is better qualified than another. I have to explain a little bit where you people are coming from because otherwise, we could go on in this a long time. No. The presence of Buddha nature, what you call Buddha nature, what is called buddha gotra in the sūtra tradition, is just the presence of a buddha nature which can be developed or not. If that potentiality is developed and developed, one progresses on the grounds and pass.

Otherwise, if one makes no effort and no study, then nothing happens. Yeah. Enjoy. Okay. Yes.

Exactly. If you make exactly the same offering with the same motivation to one person who is a monk and other person who is not a monk, you will accumulate more good karma, more virtuous karma by making offerings to the monk and to the person who is not ordained. So your merit from the monk offering is more than the beggar? Yes. It is what is taught in the Buddhist scriptures.

And wine? So because of the power of the base, now, obviously, it is not sufficient that the recipient be ordained. They must be someone who is ethical, who is putting effort at the practice of virtue. Then in addition, we also have to take into account the motivation. Is the motivation one which is aiming for a higher rebirth through this offering, aiming for liberation through this offering, or aiming for the attainment of full enlightenment through this offering.

Chris, I think just a quick question. You are very busy, and I think Geshe la said that after the supreme Dharma of the last part of the path of preparation, all paths above that are paths of abandonment. If at the middling level of the path of accumulation, one is no longer going to fall into the lower realms, would that not be considered an abandonment as well? So why would it be from the path of seeing upwards that it’s called paths of abandonment? So if you want to assert that, that is your personal private position.

Because the boundary of the attainment of a path of preparation is a direct perception of emptiness. Okay. That would be a good question. Thank you. So do be mindful of the fact that it is not only independent of the power of the base that powerful karma is accumulated, but also dependent on the motivation, the motivation of benefiting others.

Okay. Thank you. Jo-ha-ta..

I would like to announce

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
parinirvana
The final nirvana the Buddha attained when he passed away in Kushinagar, India. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top