1 h 34 min · 4,579 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 95-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche explores a central puzzle: why does intellectual understanding of emptiness fail to transform one’s outlook the way genuine renunciation does? He works through Tsongkhapa’s three principles of the path, showing that while realizations of emptiness can arise before formally entering the Buddhist path, only the uncontrived thought of definite emergence creates a radical mental shift. Rinpoche details the stages—path of accumulation and path of preparation—where emptiness finally impacts delusions, and explains the critical difference between intellectual understanding and meditative realization. He contrasts Buddhist and non-Buddhist approaches: non-Buddhists temporarily interrupt afflictions through calm abiding alone, while Buddhists seek permanent cessation through insight into emptiness. Extended Q&A follows. For practitioners familiar with the Lam Rim.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Salam240516tues 2.mp3
UUID: d4715042-32fe-4b82-a2ca-381018d2032a
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Emptiness
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~4,580
Mhmm. As I said in Jetsün Tsongkhapa’s three principles of the path, once you have realized the essence of these points, rely on solitude and develop a stable wish. The essence of these points refers to the essence of the three principles of the path. In other words, definite emergence, bodhicitta, and the view. Rely on solitude means to put effort at meditation and habituation with these.
And developing a stable wish refers to attaining one’s ultimate object of attainment. So you have studied the Lambrum. You have received numerous commentaries on the Lamrim. Then of all hearing, one should also engage in thinking. And then in dependence on this, eventually, one develops one’s own system, and one’s understanding becomes stable.
So here, when we speak of, one’s own system, this doesn’t refer to some arbitrary system we create for ourselves. Instead, it refers to a mode, of reflection, a mode of proceeding, which is rooted in the four reliances. In other words, it refers to transforming one’s mind stream. So, we have explained the two main topics. The first is the thought of definite emergence, and the second is the view realizing emptiness.
These are said to be the two main topics in general. Now, clearly, when one is able to generate the thought of definite emergence, there is a very big transformation in one’s outlook. But this is much less the case with emptiness. One can generate a realization of emptiness without nonetheless profoundly transforming one’s outlook. And one therefore has to ask oneself why this is the case.
Why? It’s not a question I’m asking you. It’s a question you have to answer for yourselves. So it is a question you should ask yourself after reflecting carefully on the topics and meditating. This leads to very, very pleasant lines of reasoning.
So if we take the view of emptiness, there are realizations of emptiness which precede entering the path, and there are realizations of emptiness which are subsequent to entering the path. This is not the case for the uncontrived thought of definite emergence or a stable experience of definite emergence. For an uncontrived thought of definite emergence, one must have definitely entered the path. There’s a major difference. So among you, there probably are students who have an understanding of emptiness.
There definitely must be. Then when this understanding of emptiness becomes free of any doubt whatsoever, we are said to have an ascertainment of emptiness. Such an ascertainment means that one has realized emptiness. But such a realization of emptiness does not necessarily transform fundamentally our outlook. On the other hand, when one has an uncontrived experience of definite emergence, then one’s mind has totally changed from the way it used to be before.
This is something which is very difficult to generate. Then once one has generated such an experience of the sort of definite emergence, I suspect this must be the source of tremendous happiness and joy. However, this is difficult to do. And, in our own case, through lack of effort, there is a considerable distance between ourselves and this sort of definite emergence. Now this is due to indolence, to laziness.
So in our own cases, there is too much talk and not enough decision. You have received many teachings on the Lam Rim. You have attended numerous teachings. Now the time has come to think a little bit about them. Now regarding the generation of the afflictions, there probably is no difference in the generation of the afflictions before one has given rise to an uncontrived thought of definite emergence and after.
It is the same thing. What has changed dramatically is one’s resolve to counter these afflictions. However, the uncontrived thought of definite emergence does not act as an antidote to the afflictions. So as the ancient As the Kadampas of yore said in the ten animals’ roles of the Kadampa tradition, the last three ones, Once one has generated uncontrived definite emergence, one is expelled from the ranks of men, one enters the ranks of dogs, and one attains the rank of a god. Then from the standpoint of our society at large, someone who has generated uncontrived definite emergence is seen as crazy.
As was famously said by Jetsün Milarepa, to the world, Milarepa is crazy. To Mila, the world is crazy. Therefore, when one generates a stable experience of definite emergence or an uncontrived thought of definite emergence, there is a profound fundamental transformation of one’s mental outlook. This is not the case when one generates a mere realization of emptiness. Now we should ask ourselves, why is there such a difference?
Now this is to present my own understanding or my own feeling regarding the problem. As far as the realization of emptiness is concerned, emptiness is the mode of abiding of phenomena. It’s reality. It is not merely something which is explained in Buddhist scriptures and texts. Therefore, when we realize emptiness, we’re actually realizing reality.
There is no fundamental shift there. On the other hand, the mind of uncontrived definite emergence calls for a radical shift in our perception. This is perhaps why. So then nothing is said when we cover the stages of the path and talk of first rejecting the vanities of this life and then rejecting the vanities of all life of realization of emptiness at some given point. Since after all, there are beings who have not entered the path, have a realization of emptiness, and there are beings who have entered the path, who have a realization of emptiness.
Then you ask whether someone who had a realization of emptiness was necessarily a Buddhist. My answer to this is you have to examine and not be dogmatic about things. Probably in terms of the view itself, establishment of the view, such a person has a Buddhist view. Then if we told them you are a Buddhist, whether they accept it or not, it’s a very different story.
So the realization, the mere realization of emptiness does not necessarily lead to a profound transformation of our outlook or our mindset. On the other hand, the generation of an uncontrived thought of definite emergence leads to a profound transformation of our outlook since at the very point we have generated such a mindset, we have entered the smaller path of accumulation. As soon as we enter the middling path of accumulation, we will necessarily have realized emptiness. Now, why is this the case? Because once someone has generated an uncontrived thought of definite emergence and has entered the smaller path of accumulation, they are driven enthusiastically towards the attainment of liberation or full enlightenment.
And they ask themselves what the means for such an attainment is. The means is none other than a realization of emptiness. And in this respect, the, supreme form of such a realization is the realization of emptiness in the sense of the union. Therefore, they put effort in this, and it is definite that someone on the middling level of the path of accumulation has a realization of emptiness. That does not mean that someone on the smaller level of the path of accumulation cannot have a realization of emptiness since as we said, there are both beings who have not yet entered the path and beings who have already entered the path who have realizations of emptiness.
However, by the level of the middling path of accumulation, all beings have a realization of emptiness. So you are at present facing one difficulty, which is that we are presenting sa lam grounds and paths from the standpoint of Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka. Now from the standpoint of Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka, it is indispensable for someone on the middling level of the path of accumulation to have gained realization of emptiness in the prasangika sense of the term. This is not the case for lower schools of tenets from Svatāntrika Madhyamaka downwards. For instance, if we take Sautrāntika, one of the Hīnayāna schools, there is actually no discussion of emptiness whatsoever.
Sautrāntika only accepts selflessness. If we take Cittamātra, nothing in particular is said in Cittamātra about someone on the middling level of the path of accumulation necessarily having a realization of emptiness. It is, however, indispensable for someone who is progressing to the middling level of the path of accumulation from the standpoint of Prāsaṇgika to have realized emptiness in the prasanika sense of the term. Realizations of lower levels of emptiness according to Hīnayāna or Cittamātra are only possible on the lower level of the path of accumulation. No problem.
Because if I explain too little tomorrow, you’re gonna raise difficult questions. So, this is why one studies initially after one studies, there is a huge amount of doubts which arise, but as one continues with the study, these doubts dwindle and eventually disappear. So when someone enters the middling level of the path of accumulation, they understand that it is indispensable not merely to have realized emptiness, but to realize emptiness by means of an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness. In other words, they must both have attained calm abiding and train in insight. Therefore, once one has entered the middling level of the path of accumulation, one endeavors to generate an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight, which is focused on emptiness and which is upheld by motivation and uncontrived thought of definite emergence.
Now to generate such an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness, one must initially generate a calm abiding which is focused on emptiness. And in my personal opinion, for so long as one is training in that calm abiding focused on emptiness for so long, one is on the middling level of the path of accumulation, but you should examine this for yourselves. Now the boundaries of the greater path of accumulation occur between the moment when one has attained a calm abiding focused on emptiness and the moment when one has attained in dependence on that, an insight focused on emptiness. This greater path of accumulation is naturally upheld by an uncontrived sort of definite emergence. Now nothing is specifically said within Buddhist scriptures and texts regarding the specific realizations which are to be obtained at the level of the middling and the greater path of accumulation.
But if one analyzes them and links them with these 37 facets of enlightenment, then I suspect these are probably the realizations to be attained. Now, at point where one has generated an insight which is focused on emptiness, one will have entered the path of preparation or. Here, the in dependence on a calm abiding which is focused on emptiness, that factor of appearance of emptiness remains stable, and one generates an analysis, a factor of analysis, which investigates the factor of appearance without leading as was previously the case to the decline of calm abiding due to wisdom. Now when this happens, when there is an analysis of the emptiness which appears to this mind and in dependence on this, the bliss arisen from pliancy arises from analysis, then insight would have been generated. At that point, one will have entered the path of preparation.
Now from the standpoint of the 37 facets of enlightenment, as you remember, within the sevenfold subdivision, we have first the four close placements of recollection, then the four thorough abandonments, and then the four limbs of magical emanation at the level of the path of accumulation. The five powers trained in at the level of the path of preparation. Why does one speak of power in this context? Because one, at the level of the warmth or heat level of the path of preparation, the first level, no longer falls under the sway of the afflictions. So now to recapitulate, we have covered the three subdivisions of the path of accumulation, the smaller, middling, and greater path of accumulation.
And when one has given rise to an insight focused on emptiness, one passes from the path of accumulation to the path of preparation to the level of warmth of the path of preparation. Now, whereas, before, once, training in emptiness was at the level of the wisdom arisen from thinking, At the level of the path of preparation, it is at the level of the wisdom arisen from meditation. And as a result of this intensive meditation, for the first time, the realization of emptiness impacts our delusions or afflictions. Now, for, those who accept, the presentation of the object of abandonment, as cyclic existence and the object of attainment as liberation. There is, on the one hand, an abandonment of the afflictions, which means that the afflictions never ever arise again.
But there is also another presentation, which I suspect may be that of other schools. And that is one in which the afflictions are temporarily interrupted. They simply do not arise, and this occurs through the power of calm abiding. Once one has generated calm abiding, then indeed the afflictions during that period do not arise.
Now in my opinion, this is probably the position of the non-Buddhist schools of ancient India, and this seems to be confirmed by the Lam Rim. They felt that after all, since once one attains calm abiding, one’s mind is immutable, and one is no longer during that period beset by the afflictions, one would have attained at that point moksha or liberation. And since when one attains calm abiding, one experiences both the bliss of physical and mental pliancy, they identified this bliss of mental and physical pliancy with the bliss of liberation or of moksha. So there was a strong rationale to their presentation. And on this basis, they said it was unnecessary to generate an insight.
Calm abiding was sufficient. So the ancient schools of India, in accordance with the Buddhists accept an interruption of the afflictions, but they do not seem to be aware of the notion of an utter abandonment of the afflictions. Such a notion is alien to them. Then clearly, the afflictions within our mind stream are blended with the obstructions to omniscience. So the non Buddhists of ancient India subscribed to a means of stopping the afflictions, but they do not seem to have been aware of the means of utterly abandoning the afflictions.
And to give you a a metaphor, this is similar to how one addresses the problem of stopping the flow of a great river. One can place temporary barriers downstream, but we all know that these barriers will eventually be overthrown. Or one can seek for the source of the river and dam up the source, which is the permanent way of solving the problem. Now, had they been able to identify the source of the afflictions, they would have identified this source as self grasping. And they would have realized that the means to counter self grasping is generating a wisdom which apprehends the opposite of self grasping.
This obviously was impossible for them since they accepted the existence of a self, which was permanent one and independent, as well as a self, which was a substantially existent autonomous entity. Buddhists, on the other hand, fully recognize that calm abiding stops the afflictions. It stops the afflictions, but it stops them temporarily because they, consider that it is possible to decay from calm abiding. And when one has decayed from calm abiding, the afflictions reappear. Therefore, what is the actual antidote to the ignorance which grasps at a self and is the root of the afflictions?
None other than a wisdom which is an insight focused on emptiness. This insight focused on emptiness is necessary. So the Buddhists therefore consider that the non-Buddhist yogis of ancient India could temporarily stop the afflictions by means of calm abiding, but could not do so permanently. But for that matter, within the Buddhist systems of tenets, the Prasanika Madhyamikas consider that none of the schools or the practitioners of the schools of tenets from Svatāntrika Madhyamaka downwards can, on the basis of their view alone, attain even liberation. They can only attain a temporary a temporary interruption of the afflictions.
It is not possible for them to attain a permanent cessation of the afflictions without an understanding of the four noble truths and their 16 characteristics in the subtle sense in which they are understood in Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka. So now within the context of generating the motivation, let us reflect on the fact that on the one hand, through generating an uncontrived sort of definite emergence, we can profoundly and durably transform our mental outlook. Whereas on the other hand, through realizing a mere realization of emptiness, this is not really possible. Mhmm. Let us do this for a couple of minutes.
Please open the preview page one.
So the path of preparation, therefore, is the first time during which realization of emptiness starts to transform our mind. This does not happen below the path of preparation on the level of a path of a the path of accumulation and specifically, the fourfold subdivision of the path of preparation. Warmth, peak forbearance and supreme phenomena reflect various levels during which the realization of emptiness affects the the the delusions evermore. So it is very helpful to reflect in this way on the path of preparation. It’s fourfold definition.
It’s fourfold subdivision and so forth. Then I will not inflict the definitions of the path of preparation and its four subdivisions on you. What is, however, very important is to understand that it is only at the level of the path of preparation that the realization of emptiness can impact the delusions. It does not happen at the level of the path of accumulation or below simply because emptiness must be realized by insight before it can impact the delusions. So I would like to encourage you to study and not to study just anything, but specifically the view.
I know it is a difficult topic. But if you study the view of emptiness and over time, over the years, your understanding will definitely increase. I can see this, in my own case. It is a matter when one studies first of time, then of availability, and frankly, of the caliber of one’s mind. If I compare my level in English now and when I first arrived, then there’s a dramatic improvement.
Then I do appreciate that you have families, you have responsibilities. But if consistently and regularly, you study the view, it is definite your understanding will improve. Then I have nothing else to say if you have questions. Yeah. Geshe la, in the lamrim, it says just the mere thought of emptiness shakes the foundation of the earth.
Would that be referring to the path of preparation? Or what would that those verses be referring to in terms of the level? Yes. I like my translation was strange. So it’s very good question because you’re addressing directly our presentation.
Then when says that to merely doubting it, emptiness will tears cyclic existence to shreds. It refers to a realization of emptiness, which is an ascertainment by means of a valid cognizer. Then you should study carefully this quote because in Tibetan, it reads, saṃsāra will be torn to shreds in the future tense, not existence is torn to shreds in the present tense. So, yes, there are two quotes. The one you were referring to is through mere merely doubting existence will be torn to shreds.
Mhmm. Another. I want to ask a question about Geshe la say about some something about three facets of emptiness before entering the path of the preparation? Excuse me. The three what?
The three faces? The three forms? Faces. Yeah. What exactly?
Faces. Yeah. Of of of The three facets. So the 37 facets of enlightenment are subdivided into seven subdivisions. The four close recollections, the four thorough abandonments, the four limbs of magical emanation, the five powers, the five forces, the seven factors of enlightenment, and the eightfold path of an ārya being, which makes 37.
And other questions? Just wanting to, check about definite emergence that, it happened does it happen as one has entered the path of accumulation at the small level, or does it happen after one has entered the path of accumulation at the small level? Or are either of those wrong? They are simultaneous. In other words, Yeah.
Yeah. When you generate the uncontrived thought of definite emergence at that very instant, you have entered the small path of accumulation. There’s no small path of accumulation without that mind. I’m not clear as to why there is no shift in mental outlook that arises from a mere realization of emptiness at the stage of the path of accumulation. Whereas after calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness and the entry into the path preparation, there is an apparent impact on, a dramatic impact on delusion at that stage, but not earlier.
And I ask why? So the reason is as follows. At the level of the path of accumulation, one only has a wisdom arisen from thinking focused on emptiness. Whereas at the risk level of the path of preparation, due to the presence of a concentration which is an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight, one has a wisdom arisen from meditation focused on emptiness. So a good way to think about it is to realize that at the level of the path of accumulation, the mind which is focused on emptiness remains very distant from emptiness.
Whereas at the level of the path of preparation, this mind has come much closer to emptiness. It sees emptiness from close-up as the table. Can I just ask a supplementary question on that? Second. Thank you.
Is it not the case nonetheless that a mere merely thinking or merely hearing and thinking and a mere realization through those of emptiness gives rise to a different view of or some different view of reality such that it affects one’s perception, including in relation to delusions? It’s difficult for the mere wisdom arisen from thinking focused on emptiness to target the afflictions. You see, there is a wisdom arisen from thinking focused on emptiness among beings who have not even entered the path. There is also such a wisdom among beings on the path of accumulation, but it is not able to counter, grasping at the true existence of the self. You’ve already generated, obviously, a wisdom arisen from thinking focused on emptiness.
I mean, I’m led to understand you have generated such a wisdom arisen from thinking, but are still working at a wisdom arisen from meditation. Thanks for the honor. Another questions. Am I correct in in thinking that even along this Mahāyāna path, we’re still working towards liberation, towards severing the roots of the afflictions right up until the up until the tenth ground. We’re still working on the delusions and the the ignorance grasping at self, and we don’t actually become liberated until then.
So from the standpoint of if one has entered from the very beginning, the the delusions, the afflictions are abandoned on the eighth ground. However, there are arhats which abandoned the Hīnayāna to enter the Mahāyāna. They’re already arhats. Then let’s make it easy. So for the schools of tenets, the Mahāyāna schools of tenets below Prāsaṇgika such as Svatāntrika Madhyamaka, it’s easy.
The afflictions are abandoned for a being who has entered directly the Mahāyāna at the level of full enlightenment. Okay. So the abandonment of the afflictions to omniscience occurs at that level. Any another questions? I’ve tried my best to turn this into a question.
So a couple of weeks ago, Geshe la asked if it was easier to realize emptiness or the uncontrived thought of definite emergence. And I’ve been thinking about it a lot since and this I’ve come to three reasons. The first is that the uncontrived thought of definite emergence is a product of a greater number of realizations. The second with regard to the suffering of change, it’s harder to realize what is pleasurable as suffering. And the all pervasive suffering is harder to realize that what is neutral is a cause of suffering.
And it seemed to me that for those two realizations, one would need a very subtle or subtle level of mind, which seems to require calm abiding. But the presentation so far has indicated that calm abiding may not necessarily be generated until the medium level of the path of accumulation. And so I’m trying to reconcile how one would have realized the suffering of change and all pervasive suffering sufficiently to have developed uncontrived thought of definite emergence without having previously generated calm abiding? In brief, it is not necessary to gain a realization of either the suffering of change or pervasive suffering to have a realization of calm abiding. However, there is a matter for reflection in whether or not calm abiding is necessary to attain the smaller level of the path of accumulation.
And another questions. Have you got other questions? Do you have the questions? Strange, you know, it says as the minutes come close to 08:30, the questions, they just dry out. It’s like doubts are contingent on time.
Do you have another questions? Second question? Yes. I do. I know you.
I was just wondering whether there is a, like like, key point that we can practice that how we can progress from each day? One for all the stages. For, you know, from the small, medium, you know, all the principle of the path and stuff. The foundation is an uncontrived thought of definite emergence of renunciation. That is the basis.
So, initially, we should cover the totality of the five paths from the path of accumulation to the path of no more learning, as well as the paths shared with the beings of the three scopes according to the Lam Rim by means of an overview meditation from the beginning to the end and back. And then after this generating a realization, an actual realization is difficult, but it depends entirely on us and on the amount of effort we put in it. As Tsongkhapa says in his three principles of the path, hence, upon realizing the essence of these three principles of the path, dwell in solitude, and generate a stable wish. Then this is entirely up to us. If we put effort, it will happen.
If we don’t put effort, it will not happen. But the first thing I would like to say is that it is not necessary to be ordained to attain either liberation or full enlightenment. The only reason for ordination is that it unblocks a lot of time. So don’t think that because we are lay people, it is not possible to attain liberation or full enlightenment. It is a matter of one’s personal effort or absence.
I think there are no no more any questions. It depends entirely on willpower and mental strength. The totality of the realizations of the Lam Rim from relying on the spiritual teacher all the way up to the attainment of the state of union depend on willpower. Then at present, we don’t put the effort. We run around town.
Then, obviously, there’s no realization. Okay. Thank you. Stop here tonight. Gotcha.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- five powers
- The five practices to be applied in this life and near the time of death. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
- What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
- Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.