TBI Recordings

53 min · 2,531 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 53-minute oral commentary on Cittamātra philosophy, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen examines the nature of sensory consciousness, drawing on Je Tsongkhapa’s root text on the Alaya Vijñāna and the mind basis of all. He walks through the philosophical difficulty of explaining how the visual consciousness perceives the visual organ (retina) when Cittamātra asserts that no truly external objects exist. Gyaltsen distinguishes between the eye organ and the visual consciousness itself, clarifies how the five sensory consciousnesses differ from conceptual mental consciousness, and explains the role of sensory input in triggering mental designation and conceptual labeling. Using the analogy of binoculars to illustrate how the retina functions as a medium for visual perception, he addresses the apparent paradox at the heart of Cittamātra epistemology. The teaching concludes with an introduction to how sensory consciousnesses perceive only the present moment, leaving students with discussion questions to deepen their understanding. Designed for practitioners already familiar with Buddhist philosophical debate.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 04042017cittamatra.mp3

UUID: c9f9f497-3821-4265-bce5-8e7dc3e1497f

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Cittamātra

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~2,529

Awesome. As Buddha Śākyamūni said, the worthy mind is both profound and subtle. This means that the Alāyavijñāna is a mind which we do not understand. It is both profound and subtle. We do not understand its aspect, object and so forth.

So the Alaya Vijñāna, the mind basis of all exists within the mind stream of all beings, both of the higher and of the lower realms. It is however, dissimilar in some senses to minds such as bodhichitta, great compassion and so forth, which even though they are not present within our mind stream now, can nonetheless be generated. Then in the case of calm abiding or insight, as we train in calm abiding or insight and improve our minds eventually, our minds become ever more subtle. However, there is a difference between calm abiding and insight on the one hand, and the Alaya Vijñāna on the other hand, which is that we do have the Alaya Vijñāna within our mind streams at present, calm abiding and insight we do not have. Now in the case of the Alaya Vijñāna, the mind basis of all, through repeated meditation, eventually, we are able to perceive it nakedly.

And when we perceive it nakedly, in other words, we perceive it as it is, probably we are at the level of a first grounder. Then if we take the example of other consciousnesses, it is quite straightforward to explain how conceptual consciousnesses function. It is a very different affair to explain how direct sensory perceivers or mental consciousnesses function. In the case for instance of the five sensory consciousnesses, it actually is quite difficult to explain how they function and we would not be able to do so at present. So as far as mental consciousness is concerned, if we take the case of conceptuality, then it’s quite straightforward to explain conceptuality.

Conceptuality can either be a recollection of past events, or an anticipation of future events. In both cases, we’re speaking of conceptions, of thoughts, or of fancies. So as far as the five sensory consciousnesses are concerned, and for instance, the visual consciousness within the five sensory consciousnesses, and I am not referring here to the visual organ, but the visual consciousness, it’s actually quite difficult to posit. It’s something we will understand through careful reasoning together. Then it is one thing to give the definitions of sensory consciousnesses, we have these in Lorig, but when we try to understand the actual state of affairs, the actual mode of existence of sensory consciousnesses, it is much more difficult than formulating a definition along the model of a sensory consciousness is a consciousness which arises in dependence on its uncommon controlling condition, which is a material sense organ, etcetera, etcetera.

When we actually try to understand how, for instance, the visual consciousness functions, this is quite difficult. Then some of you asked about the distinction between visual consciousnesses and the visual organ. They are different. They have different un uncommon controlling conditions. The visual consciousness is a consciousness.

The visual organ is an organ which is said to be constituted of subtle matter, and which functions, if you wish, a bit like a crystal. It is the medium through which the visual consciousness can operate. So at present, let us return to the root text of Je Tsongkhapa’s, the root of the difficult points of mind and basis of all on page three. In the middle of page three, there are five stanzas. Were this not so, a formless one, I have some modifications of the text, would not have gone beyond the discrimination of form, and it would ensue that it could be on a ground endowed with form.

Since apart from appearing as form to consciousness, outside, nothing exists. So within these five verses, the first part of the first verse, were this not so, refers to the fact that even though the object of appearance of the Alaya Vijñāna is subdivided into the five organs and the five objects, it is not the case that whatever is the object of appearance of the Alaya Vijñāna is necessarily either the five organs or the five objects, because this is not the case for the Alaya Vijñāna of a being of the formless realm. So when one states that whatever the is the object of the Alaya Vijñāna, the object of appearance of the Alaya Vijñāna is necessarily either the sense organs or the object thereof. This is only true for the two lower realms. In other words, the desire realm and the form realm.

Otherwise, what one can say is that whatever appears to the Alaya Vijñāna is necessarily the object of a mental consciousness, which engages in terminological imputation on that basis, designating it and saying, this is short, this is long, and so forth. What will help you to understand this is to realize that whatever appears to the Alaya Vijñāna, whatever is the appearing object of the Alaya Vijñāna, is necessarily apprehended by the five sensory consciousnesses, and after that, is necessarily the object of a terminological designation on that basis. This is long, this is short, and so forth. So what at present we do not understand what the Alāyavijñāna, the mind basis of all is, it should be evident to us that after the five sensory consciousnesses apprehend their respective objects, the five sense objects, mental designation occurs and mental designation, which imputes the terms, this is long, this is short and so forth on the object perceived. So therefore, when it is said that the appearing object of the Alaya Vijñāna is necessarily either a sense organ or is one of the five sense objects.

This is only true for the two lower realms, the desire and the form realm, and in our case at present we are beings of the desire realm. Now if you were to ask, is it necessarily the case that the Alaya Vijñāna has an object of appearance? No. Even for ourselves as beings of the desire realm in deep sleep, there is no such object of appearance. So if I were to ask you, why is it the case that in deep sleep, the object of appearance of the Alaya Vijñāna cannot be any of the five sense objects.

What would your answer be? What do you mean by organs? That’s consciousness. One shape. Mhmm.

That’s it. Then precisely because the sensory consciousnesses are non operational, then the sixth consciousness, the mental consciousness cannot designate. So if you ask, what can you give as an instance for the statement, that if something is the object of appearance of the Alaya Vijñāna, it is necessarily either the sense organs or the objects thereof, when the instance you give is Alaya Vijñāna at present. So now take your root text, page three, the previous stanza, the first two verses, as to both apprehended factors of basis of all, since they are apprehended by the five consciousnesses. Now here in the first verse, the apprehended factor of the basis of all corresponds to the object of appearance of the basis of all, and as was explained, this is subdivided into two, both sense organs on the one hand, and objects or sense objects on the other hand.

The sense organs are the five sense organs, from the visual organ all the way down to the tactile organ. The sense objects are the objects thereof. Now since the verse said that these are apprehended by the five consciousnesses, in other words the five sense consciousnesses, this means that the sense organs are apprehended by the sense consciousnesses. How is this possible? What is this mode of apprehension according to you?

So let us set aside the apprehended factor of the Alaya Vijñāna for the time being. As we said, the apprehended factor of the object of appearance is subdivided into two. Sense organs and objects. Within sense organs it says take the visual organ, the eye organ in other words. Now the eye organ is an apprehended factor, therefore it is apprehended by the eye consciousness.

How is this possible? We have to explain this. Right? Do you do you understand the the the doubt here? Mhmm.

You understand that if you go back to this verse here, just under the one one fourteen, as to both apprehended factors of basis of all, both the apprehended factors refer to the sense organs, right, and the objects. The sense objects, that you understand. And the following verse says, since they are apprehended by the five consciousnesses, so these are, according to Cittamātra, apprehended by the five sense consciousnesses. Okay? So if you return to your text, right, as to both apprehended factors of basis of all, the apprehended factors are the sense objects and the sense organs.

Right? And Jetsün Tsongkhapa says, since they are apprehended by the five consciousnesses, these are the five sensory consciousnesses, the visual consciousness, auditory and so forth. Then what this means is that both apprehended factors, objects and organs are apprehended by the sense consciousnesses. Now the first apprehended factor is exterior or objects, and it’s obvious how these are apprehended, the visual consciousness apprehends objects like forms and so forth, But the text also says that, or implies that the visual consciousness apprehends the visual organ, the eye. How is this possible?

And on that account, the eye is imputed. You understand what the visual organ is? The retina. You understand the difference between the eye and the retina? The retina at the back of the eye is what the Buddhist called the visual organ.

The eye is not the visual organ. And what about the ear? One of the ear that you have to go and look. Right? The tympanum.

Right? So therefore, this visual organ, in other words, retina according to Cittamātra, appears to the visual consciousness. So you’re all going to become confused. The key here is to posit the visual consciousness correctly. You have to understand the visual consciousness.

Then my own explanations of the visual organ are rooted in Buddhist texts. I cannot say whether these correspond exactly to reality or not, but in Buddhist texts, the visual organ is described as an extremely subtle form, which can be compared to a pair of binoculars. With a pair of binoculars, you can see what is afar. Without the binoculars, you can’t see anything. It’s always easy to give an example.

No. The eyeball is not the eye organ, the visual organ. The visual organ is inside the eyeball. I think we have used an optometrist, so you know about these things. So the binoculars, in other words, the two lenses whose position, respective position enables one to see at a distance, are an example of the visual organ.

And the meaning of this example is that just as in a binocular, if you have the various lenses which constitute the binocular, you can see at a distance, and if you don’t have these lenses, you can’t. Likewise, with the eye, if the eye contains a visual organ, I. E. The retina, you can see, and if it doesn’t, you cannot see. So this is how the visual organ, in other words, the retina is understood in Buddhist text, and in the Cittamātra tradition, it is said that the visual organ is perceived by the visual consciousness.

Then this is quite mysterious. So are they saying that the visual consciousness can see form which is external to the mind basis of all? But it has already been said that the visual consciousness does see exterior form. You see, instance, Vaibhāṣika does not refer to the visual consciousness a lot, they say the eye sees form. Yeah.

Yeah. Sure. Do you understand the problem in Cittamātra when you say that there is no exterior object, and you are trying to posit a visual organ? Do you understand the problem? You have the Alaya Vijñāna, which within which there are karmic imprints.

The extinction of these karmic imprints gives rise to a sensory consciousness and an observed phenomenon, which appears as exterior even though it’s not. It’s observed by a visual organ, but what’s the status of that visual organ in Cittamātra? So how do you posit it? Because the retina exists, it seems to exist to us. Right?

That’s that is the question Geshela is asking you. What is the status of the retina? Cittamātra says it is perceived by the visual consciousness. How? One measure, different aspects.

With what? Well, one of the problems I’m having understanding this is that, like, for example, a person who’s uneducated about the structure of the eye, how would they know that their eye consciousness was perceiving a retina? So my explanation of the mode in which the visual organ, in other words, retina, is perceived by the visual consciousness in Cittamātra, is in keeping with the example I gave you of the binoculars. With binoculars, if all the lenses of the binoculars are in position, you can see objects which are afar, and if all the lenses are not in position, you cannot see objects which are afar. Likewise, if the visual organ, in other words the retina is present, you can see, if the visual organ of the retina is not present, you cannot see, and this is what is meant when one says that the visual consciousness perceives the retina in Chitamatra.

So in the Chitamatra view, basically you’re saying nothing exists externally. You know just how? External. So in other words, objects don’t exist before eye consciousness perceives them. So does that mean that When eye consciousness apprehends the retina, do they actually exist concurrently?

Look, the visual consciousness and the visual organ are not simultaneous. Okay. So today we have entered in some detail in a presentation of the visual consciousness in Chitamatra. You can see from the two verses on page one one four in the middle, that the both apprehended factors refer to the sense organs and the objects, and that both the apprehended factors are necessarily perceived by the sensory consciousnesses. So we will have to enter into a more detailed presentation of all sensory consciousnesses, but today you should have a presentation of the visual consciousness.

So we will now have the recitations and immediately after the recitations, we will discuss what sensory consciousnesses are in Cittamātra. You can gently, please. Yeah. You can chant in, please. So today we started the introduction to sensory consciousness in Buddhism, and specifically the visual consciousness.

Once you understand how the visual consciousness operates, you can extend this to the other sensory consciousnesses. Now sensory consciousnesses, in this case the visual consciousness, perceive shape and color. They perceive only in the present. They do not perceive past color, nor do they perceive future color. On this basis analyze the other sensory consciousnesses.

The only consciousness which can use indifferently past, present and future events is the mental consciousness. Then discuss therefore among yourselves, how the visual consciousness operates and so forth. Mhmm. Okay. Please.

Okay. Please.

Key terms in this teaching

Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
lorig
Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top