TBI Recordings – 100418-001

1 h 33 min · 4,185 words

TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings - 100418-001
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. This session continues an earlier Lam Rim series with the opening visualization and then explains Atisha’s Lamp for the Path and the four uncommon features of the Lam Rim. It covers why the teachings are non-contradictory, how all teachings dawn as oral instructions, and the study-then-meditate sequence. It ends with brief answers to questions on the four tenet schools and on the Lam Rim.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 34m

UUID: 7adfcf38-f148-47c5-8a7b-3047a43e8c6a

Words: 4,181

So we will now perform the visualizations in keeping with the usual visualizations before these teachings, which are those performed by the great teachers of the past, as well as by Khensur Rinpoche himself. We will therefore invite to the crown of our head Buddha Śākyamūni and imagine he rests on the crown of our head and from his body, light and nectar, which are the nature of his blessings, penetrate our own body, they fill our body. And as Geshela has explained many times before, we perform them the three purgings. The voiding of all obstructions accumulated through the body, through the lower orifices in the form of black soot and black liquid. The second voiding, the voiding of all non-virtuous karma and obstructions accumulated through speech in the form of black soot and black liquid through the mouth, and the third voiding, the voiding at the heart, where all of the faults are visualized in a heap at the heart and they instantaneously dispelled when the light and the nectar touch them.

We then imagine that thereby we have received blessings from the Buddha to generate renunciation and bodhichitta within our mind stream as well as the two categories of realization, scriptural realization and realizations in the nature of experience. And we then imagine that the Buddha shrinks and descends into our heart and dwells within our heart chakra. And if we wish, we can focus single pointedly on him at that point. And then one can visualize the Buddha at whichever of three points one chooses to, one can visualize him at the center of one’s heart or upon one’s crown or in the space in front of oneself. And within his heart, one should visualize the syllable Hung and around it, whichever mantra one chooses to visualize.

One can also, for that matter, instead of visualizing the Buddha, visualize or another deity. And through reciting the mantra, one will foster the increase in wisdom. So we have finished explaining the last couple times the origins of the Lamrim, and this was done for the sake of fostering conviction and faith from our side in the benefits of the lamprim. And as of today, we will be explaining the specificities of the lamrim. So we have slightly different texts.

So generally speaking, although Atisha was a very great scholar and composed numerous treatises, the very crux of Atisha’s work is his so called lamp for the path, the Bodhipathapradīpa. And we are now on page 45 of your English translation of Lamrim Chenmo. The text of Lamrim Chenmo, the intermediate Lamrim is the same so far. Concerning the teaching to be explained, the root text of these instructions is a lamp for the path to enlightenment. And jumping onwards a little bit, since it teaches by drawing together the key points of both sūtra and mantra, it is comprehensive.

Since it emphasizes the stages of disciplining the mind, it is easy to put in practice, and it is it is adorned with the instructions of two gurus who were skilled in the system of two great trailblazers, which are Nāgārjuna and Asaṇga. It is superior to other systems. These are the three uncommon features of Atisha’s So these are the three specificities of Atisha’s lamp for the path to enlightenment, the Bodhipathapradīpa. And at present, we broach the four uncommon features of Lamrim, which are given on page 46 of Lamrim Chenmo. The first is showing the greatness of the teaching excuse me.

The first is the greatness of enabling one to know that all the teachings are free of contradiction. This refers to the fact, Geshela says, that among the countless teachings the Buddha gave, specifically, it is said the Buddha taught 84,000 teachings, there is a wide range of teachings, some teaching the development of, renunciation, some teaching the development of bodhichitta, some teaching the view. And, the lamrim enables one to understand that all of these teachings are noncontradictory in as much as they are all teachings which enable practitioners to attain full enlightenment. They are merely designed or they merely cater to trainees of different capacities. Therefore, they are said to be non contradictory.

And the reason is provided somewhat further on in our text when it is said that all of the teachings of the Buddha can see can be subsumed into the main and the branch teachings. There is no teaching of the Buddha, which is not part of the main or the branch teachings. And all of the aims of the Buddha’s teachings is to place beings within the state of full enlightenment ultimately. So the bodhisattvas, which try to actualize the Buddha’s teachings, have this and this as their aim alone. And then in function of the needs of the beings, of the wishes of the beings, their teachings are varied.

Some beings wish to attain the state of a deity. Others wish to attain liberations. Others yet again to generate bodhichitta. Others yet again to attain full enlightenment. The bodhisattvas teach therefore in various ways for the benefit of beings, and specifically, Ārya Maitreya taught in these various ways for the benefit of beings.

This is clearly explained in your text on page 46. In the middle of the text, some of the main points of the path, some of the various branches of the path, Bodhisattvas make it their goal to accomplish the good of the world. Since Bodhisattvas must take care of students who are the followers of all three lineages, lineages of śrāvakas, solitary realizers, and bodhisattvas, they must train in the paths of those three lineages. And then the summarized Lamrim, the middling Lamrim jumps onwards to page 47. By stating those benefactors of being or accomplish the good of the world through the knowledge of paths, in other words, indicates in that knowing the paths of the three vehicles of the śrāvakas, solitary realizers, and bodhisattvas is a method for the bodhisattvas to achieve the goals they have set.

So the first reason, which is advanced here, therefore, for the fact that all the teachings of the Buddha are non contradictory, is that from within the broad division of the Buddha’s teachings into the teachings which are common and the teachings which are uncommon or the teachings which are shared and the teachings which are not shared with a great vehicle. The overwhelming majority of the Buddhist teachings can be said to be shared with a great vehicle. Now what is referred to here for instance is the practice of taking refuge of the Śrāvaka for instance, is a teaching which is shared with a great vehicle since Bodhisattvas who are practitioners of the great vehicle must train refuge in keeping with the practice of the śrāvakas. However, the uncommon or specific motivation of the which is to attain the state of liberation for their own benefit, is not shared by the Bodhisattvas. The Bodhisattvas do not train in that since that is not their shared training.

And this is mentioned on page 47 of your text in the middle. There are shared and unshared paths to enter the Mahāyāna. Since the shared are those things that come from the scriptural collections of the Hīnayāna, how could they be something to set aside? Therefore Mahāyāna followers must practice all those things taught in the Hīnayāna scriptural collections with only a few exceptions such as diligently seeking a blissful peace for oneself alone. This is a reason for extensively teaching all three vehicles in the very vast scripture collections of the bodhisattvas.

So Geshela says this is a reason for which it is said the bodhisattvas must practice all three vehicles. And therefore, the Bodhisattva trainees who are aiming to attain a full state of full enlightenment, which is bereft of all thoughts and endowed with all qualities, must perfect all thoughts, must perfect all qualities and eliminate all thoughts. Perfecting all qualities means that they must among others, perfect all of the qualities which the or the have, And eliminating all thoughts means that they must eliminate all of the thoughts which the Srivakas and which Pratyekabuddhas from their own side are trying to eliminate. So there is not a single quality which the Śrāvaka is trying to attain, the bodhisattvas do not try to attain. Nor is there a single thought which the Shravakas are trying to eliminate, the bodhisattvas are not also trying to eliminate.

Therefore, the bodhisattvas train in all three vehicles. The vehicle of Śrāvaka, Pratyaka, Buddha, and bodhisattva. And they also train in all four schools of tenets. And this is explained in Lamrim Chenmo, page 47. Furthermore, a perfect Buddha has not extinguished just a portion of thoughts and accomplished a mere portion of qualities, but has rather extinguished all thoughts and accomplished all types of good qualities.

Mahāyāna practitioners seek to achieve this, since they will then eliminate all thoughts and develop all good qualities, all the different types of good qualities derived from the elimination of thoughts and the acquisition of knowledge within every other vehicle are included in the Mahāyāna path. And at present, a doubt arises as a qualm from an opponent. The doubt is well regarding the mantra vehicle. There is a substantial difference in the time required to attain full enlightenment in the perfection vehicle, in the mantra vehicle. In the perfection vehicle, it instead one should train in the three perfections for three countless eons.

In Yogatantra, it is possible to attain full enlightenment within one short lifetime of this degenerate age. If this is the case, then one cannot say that a practitioner of the mantra vehicle has to practice the totality of the perfection vehicle. And the answer to this qualm is that, while it is true that there is a difference in the time necessary to accomplish the goal of these two vehicles. Nonetheless, the broad outline of the perfection vehicle is to be practiced within the context of the Mantra vehicle, specifically all six perfections are to be practiced within the context of the mantra vehicle. Geshela says, if this were not the case, then one could not speak of a shared component of the mantra and the perfection vehicle.

This is on the bottom of page 47 of Lamrim Chenmo. In order to enter the perfection vehicle of the Mahāyāna, you do need the paths that are explained in the Hana Hīnayāna scripture collection. However, in order to enter into the Vajrayana, this is still the doubt. The paths of the perfection vehicle are not shared in common with the paths of the Vajrayana because the paths are incompatible. The reply is given on page 48, And it relies on a quote from the Vajra Peak tantra.

It’s a better translation than the translation in your English text, the Vajra Climax tantra. Even to save your life, do not give up the spirit of enlightenment. And therefore, the common component or the shared component between the Pāramitāyāna and the Mantrayāna would, for instance, be the Bodhisattva vows, which are present in both the Pāramitāyāna and the Mantrayāna. The uncommon or the unshared component would refer, for instance, to the Tantric vows, which are specific to the Mantrayāna. And then moving onwards considerably in the text, we pass on to the bottom of page 49.

Second paragraph from the bottom, the precious teacher said, my guru Atisher is the one who knows how to bring all of the teachings within a four sided path, literally within a square. These words are very meaningful. This actually says, is one of the key instructions, not so much of Dromtonpa, but of his root teach teacher Atisha. We have to understand here that the instructions are transmitted from Atisha, and they actually represent the inner core of Atisha’s teachings. In the same same way as, for instance, if you were to pull a square rug or a square piece of cloth by one of its corners, the rest of the rug or the piece of cloth follows and all the corners follow.

Likewise, if one practices one of the key points of Lamrim correctly, one should be able to encompass within that practice the totality of the Lam Rim. The reason for this is because to practice one of the piece, one of the key points of Lam Rim correctly, one must understand clearly and practice well what comes before, which is the cause of this. And one must also understand well and practice what will be coming after. One must also practice correctly the foundation or the base of this key point. So if we were to take the example of, for instance, renunciation, to train correctly in renunciation, we must train in the preliminary aspects of the path, the path of the being of small scope, which precede renunciation, and we must also prepare to train in the path of the being of great scope, which follows the training in renunciation.

The same can be said for training in taking refuge, in understanding karma and causality and so forth. And we have finished the presentation of the first uncommon feature of Lamrim, which is to lead to the understanding that all of the teachings are non contradictory, or that all of the teachings are compatible. In dependence on this, one must give rise to the realization of the second specific feature of Lamrim, which is the dawning of all of the teachings as oral instructions. This is a difficult and important point, Geshela says. In a nutshell, if the all of the teachings dawn to us as oral instructions, and all of us all of them dawn to us as speech or as instructions, and we practice all of them.

On the other hand, if we make a distinction between what we study and what we practice, and we do not practice what we study, do not study what we practice, then we are engaged in a practice in which all of the teachings do not appear as all instructions. And this is precisely what is to be avoided. So this is explained on page 50 of the great treatise on the stages of the path. In general, only the scriptures of the conqueror provides the means to achieve all temporary and ultimately benefit and happiness for those who desire liberation. Only the Buddha is free from all error in teaching what is to be adopted and what is to be cast aside.

So all of the teachings dawn as oral instructions when we realize clearly that the goal of all of the teachings is to lead one being to the state of full enlightenment. However, Je Tsongkhapa himself says it is not the case that the fundamental treatises, the great shastras, do not teach explicitly and in great great detail both the theory and the means to train to attain full enlightenment. From our side, however, because of our lack of capacity, we are unable to understand these great treatises, and this is the reason for which summarized presentations such as the various logong texts, such as the Bodhipathapradipas, such as the Lamrim have been composed. And it is with this in mind and this in mind alone that we should rely on these summarized presentations in keeping with the statement on page 50 of Lamrim Chenmo. Therefore the words of the conquer the precious collection of sūtra and tantra are the supreme instructions nonetheless since the students in this later time will not discover the intent of those words by delving into them on their own without depending on valid commentaries in the personal instructions of excellent beings, the great trailblazers composed treatises and personal instructions that comment on their intended meaning.

And then moving onwards in your text, page 51, the great yogi, Jowo Chengawa, says, concerning instructions, complete mastery does not mean gaining ascertainment of a mere small volume that fits in the palm of one’s hand. It means understanding all of the scriptures as instructions for practice. So what is referred to here, Geshela says, is the situation which was prevalent in Tibet before Je Tsongkhapa came, where practitioners would rely on a very very small meditation manual based on the experience of others, and use this as the key to their practice without relying on the great treatises. This is an incorrect way to practice. Instead, one should rely on the great treatise treatises and complement them with the small meditation manuals.

But ideally, one should generate one’s own experience from the great treatises. And as another student of Atisha’s, on page 51 of says. Also, the great elder student said that he understood all of the text instructions for practice by grinding to dust all of the ground actions of body, speech, and mind during one session of meditation on Atisha’s instructions. This refers, Geshela says, to understanding of Atisha’s instructions as a very pith or the very key of the Buddhist teachings, and on the combination in one meditation session of both concentration and analytical meditation on the key points of practice. And therefore, Dromtonpa, on page 51, says that it is a mistake after having studied numerous texts and scriptures to then practice differently.

So Geshela says this refers to studying many shastras and many commentaries, and then practicing in a completely different way from what one has studied. This is a clear indication that one is not allowing the scriptures to dawn as oral instructions. And at present, this actually refers to the actual instructions of Je Tsongkhapa on page 51 of your text. Here the teachings are set forth in the excellent teaching of the Buddha is twofold. Those teachings having a nature of scripture and those having a nature of realization.

There is no teachings of the Buddha which are neither of the nature of scripture nor of the nature of realization. And actually, the teachings which are of the nature of scripture are the cause for the teachings which are of the nature of realization. As this says, there are no more than two types of teachings, scriptural and realized. And then jumping onwards to page 52, thus these two serve as cause and effect. And at present, Je Tsongkhapa quotes the famous passage from Kamalaśīla’s middling stage of meditation.

For example, it’s like showing a horse a race course before you race. Once you have shown it, you race you then race there. So in Tibet and in India, the tradition was to walk a course, a horse around the race course it was going to race before the race. It makes absolutely no sense, Geshela says, to walk the horse around one race course and then race him on a completely different one. And this is what Kamalaśīla says in the famous quote from the Bhāvanākrama.

Further, what you meditate on with the wisdom arisen from meditation is just that which you know with the wisdom that has arisen from study and reflection or hearing and thinking. You do not meditate on something else. This is similar to how you show a horse a racetrack and then race there. So says, first, one would carefully attend teachings and listen to these teachings giving rise to the wisdom arisen from hearing. Then independence on this wisdom arisen from hearing, one would think about the topics in question giving rise to the wisdom arisen from thinking.

And then once this wisdom arisen from thinking has been generated, one would meditate on just that and give rise to the wisdom arisen from meditation. Then moving onwards. This is instructions include in complete form all the key points of the path and the scriptures and their commentary from how to rely on a teacher through serenity and insight. These instructions here refer to the treatises on the graduated stages of the path or Lamrim. They then lead you through a concise stage of practice.

The concise is one of the features of Lamrim, which encompasses all of the teachings of the Buddha, in which we engage in stabilizing meditation and that which requires stabilizing meditation. And you analyze with discerning wisdom that which requires analytical meditation. So Geshela says, if one does this, then one will have realized the second key feature of the Lamrim, which is that all of the teachings of the Buddha dawn as oral instructions. And in so doing, one will generate faith and veneration for these instructions, it is however extremely wrong practice to start studying text. And then when the time comes to meditate, say, well, what I studied was just dharma to be studied.

Now I’m gonna meditate on something else. So we will stop here for today. And if you have any questions, we have a couple minutes. We have a couple minutes for questions. So Geshela would not agree with the premise of your question.

It is not the case that bodhichitta is mainly explained in Chitamatra texts far from there. It is explained by all four schools of tenets. The Vaibhāṣikas teach about bodhichitta, so do the Sautrantikas, so do the Chitamatras, and the the Madhyamikas teach extensively about bodhichitta. However, the Chitamatras and the Madhyamikas call it the mind of the great vehicle, This term is not used by the other schools, which refer to it as bodhichitta. It is, however, the very core of the practice of both the Chitamatras and the Madhyamikas.

You have to make a clear distinction between someone who is of the lower vehicle by path and someone who is of the lower vehicle by tenets. These are two very different things. So someone who is of the lower vehicle by path is someone who is training on the path of the lower vehicle. Someone who is on the lower vehicle by tenets may very well be actually a Bodhisattva who accepts the tenets of the lower vehicle. The difference between the lower and the greater vehicle from the standpoint of tenets is that the greater vehicle from the standpoint of tenets accepts the existence of an omniscience which or an omniscient mind, which simultaneously cognize this all phenomena, and which can only be attained when the obstructions to omniscience are eliminated, which entails eliminating the innate apprehension of a self, of persons and phenomena.

The lower schools by tenets also accept the existence of an omniscient mind, but they do not accept the existence of an omniscient mind which cognizes simultaneously all phenomena. They instead accept the existence of an omniscient mind which can potentially know all phenomena and which arises through the elimination of the afflictive obstructions. They do not accept the existence of obstructions to omniscience. So this is a main difference between these two groups of schools from the standpoint of tenets. Are there a yes?

Yes. Sa-lam is particularly important for training on the path to enlightenment since sa-lam grounds and paths is nothing else but the explanation of spiritual development through the grounds and paths by method and wisdom. Method being the progressive generation of the mind of bodhichitta and wisdom being the generation of the various understandings of selflessness, nonduality, and emptiness. Then, obviously, in addition to Salam, we must study Loric, which explains the actual way in which the mind functions and pull all of these studies within the framework of Lamrim and use them to progress in our training. Are there other questions?

Yes. So most definitely, this is something which is contingent on past life training. Some people who have trained intensively in past lives will, for instance, be able to progress very swiftly to key through key points of the path and will resonate very power with certain lines of reasoning and not with others. This is perfectly appropriate. However, the presentation which is given here is a general presentation and the process of generation of realization is the same for all.

However, the speed of generation depends a lot and the reasonings one connects to as well. Some of the questions as well. Yes. Are there others? Yes.

German speaking English says it’s excellent to meditate, and one meditates as much as one can. However, before meditating, it is very important to generate a very powerful motivation of refuge and of bodhichitta. And then once one has done this, obviously, the results one obtains meditation are very much contingent on the motivation. If the motivation is small, the results are small. If the motivation is great, the results are great.

And one also has to understand how to meditate and generate faith. Then if one has this combination of understanding and faith, attainments are guaranteed. There is absolutely no doubt, but both are necessary. Yes. So there’s tremendous benefit in structuring all of one’s meditation around the Lamrim.

As Geshela explained before, the Lamrim is really what leads us upwards to the goal we’re trying to attain. Are there other questions? If there are more questions, Okay. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
Paramitayana Pharchin thegpa (Tib)
The Perfection Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
tantra gyü (Tib)
Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top