1 h 40 min · 5,294 words · 31 August 1999
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk moves to the middling scope of the Lam Rim, explaining saṃsāra as the body and mind that suffering is experienced through, and why karma and disturbing emotions keep us taking rebirth. It teaches the Four Noble Truths, especially the suffering of change and the suffering of pervasive conditionedness, and why recognising saṃsāra’s faults generates the intention to be free. A short question session covers wisdom from hearing, contemplation and meditation, and bodhisattva activity without attachment.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 40m
UUID: 587ee3b2-9b6d-4dbb-9ec8-f0c05dc04efc
Date: 1999-08-31
Words: 5,289
Don’t So now we have reached up reached towards the the the middling scope or the the stages of the path in common with the person of intermediate state. So by by by training in the the the part of the in the part in common part which is in common with small scope or person at the initial stage. And one one increases develops one’s understanding or knowledge, and by completing the small small the part of the small scope, then one transfers in the middling scope and by this one becomes the practitioner of the middling scope. So during the first stage, one is being called the person of the first stage and now you are towards the second level. The practice of the medium scope is that teaches you the reality or the the nature of the cyclic existence or saṃsāra.
In the sense, it means showing the the the how difficulties we undergo through physically and mentally, how we undergo through the suffering, like the having a disease, fairness, combat, problem or suffering of leaving the difficulty, mean, facing difficulty in yeah, difficulty in living, suffering of cold and heat, so forth, which are faced by mentally or physically. So now this is the in in intermediate state or the middling scope shows you how it where from where it comes and how one to how one can overcome all these sufferings now. So there are many difficulties or the self the problems we face and or we experiences. If asked on what basis one one experiences all those occasions or all those difficulties, then we on the basis of basis so basis, there are two which is which are the body and the mind and the body or or they are experienced through physically or mentally. And most of most of them we experience or we experience on our body, you know.
So this party on which is the basis on on which we experience all those difficulties is the is is called the cyclic existence or saṃsāra. And so here, we are we are learning, we will be we will learn that how to overcome all those sufferings. So if we analyze where those sufferings or the problem comes, for example, like, if I may analyze or how how the the problems or difficulties of a human comes out to what means, that it is because of taking a form of human being or form of a human, one receives or one experiences itself more of a human. So likewise, by taking the animal form, experience the self in the animals and it’s so likewise, it’s called same. We say there are these six realms, beings of six realms or six type of beings and which are called divided into two, the good three, good migration and three, bad migration.
And so by taking a form of any of this those any of those beings, one received the suffering of in a particular form. So it is the main the body or the physical or the body is the main basis for one to experience this all those suffering. So what what here one one one is trying to one is going to train is that how one can transfer or or or abandon those difficulties which one experiences on particular basis, you know, or a body. So the way of avoiding those sufferings or the difficulties one has or one is experiencing on particular body is that the what one one should try to try not to take take a particular form or if or the body because because by when when one once one of taking particular form or a body, then the body is the main source or the main basis for one to experience the suffering. So in order to avoid those sufferings or difficulties, one should avoid the taking birth and taking such rebirth in such forms now.
So it is by the influence of those calm the karma and the disturbing emotions, one is forced to take out or yeah, one one to receive take the birth in particular forms, which are the basis of experiencing experiencing the sufferings. So so so in order to avoid to to avoid taking a birth in such a form, what one needs one should try to one should try to abandon those causes or which are the disturbing emotion and the karma or action. By abandoning that, then one can one can avoid taking one can avoid such forms of our body which are the basis of the suffering. So if one fails or one does not abandon all those it causes the karma and the disturbing emotion then one will be born or one will take it one will be born or one will take such form again and again and due to that one one continues or one often or one again and again undergoes through the suffering. So this body which is projected by the influence, projected by the karma and the disturbing emotion is the saṃsāra or cyclic existence, So and which undergoes to the suffering.
And in order to avoid avoid taking birth in saṃsāra, one has to one has to see the disadvantages or or the fault of taking taking taking birth and cyclic existence or or the fault or disadvantages of the saṃsāra. And and without without without having without without knowing the without knowing the disadvantages or the faults of the saṃsāra, then one will one one will find the happiness or one will find the saṃsāra very appealing and due to that, one will never be able to develop the intention to free oneself from the psychic existence or saṃsāra. And without having an intention to free oneself from the saṃsāra, then it is impossible for one to free or be be liberated from saṃsāra. In other hand, we consider this this human rebirth is very precious because it has all those eight leisures and ten endowments, which are the 18 qualities. And by having that and through upon this upon this optimum precious optimum human rebirth, one can by by practicing the Dharma, then one can one can abandon you know, abandon the saṃsāra abandon saṃsāra and being free from the cyclic existence.
So due to that, can on the other hand, in the other hand, we concentrate this precious human rebirth is very precious. In other hand, this body which we have attained is the projected or received by the influence of the emotion and the action. And due to that, as it is produced by the sudden emotion by nature, it is suffering and it is also becomes a sort of sort of sort of sufferance. So for example, it is like a cake and cake in general, we concentrate something very delicious and very tasty and also everyone likes or considers good good food. So but when the cake is being mixed with the poison, then that cake that that that that cake will not function as a cake because because because it is being poisoned and due to that, by having that cake instead, will one yeah.
One will undergoes to inhibit suffering because of having poison in it. So likewise, likewise, this precious optimum precious human rebirth, the body is in other hand, yeah, likewise, this this present body is very good basis to practices or the to practice the Dharma and and can overcome all the sufferings. And by by other hand, it is as it is being produced by by this disturbing emotion and the action and by itself, and it it becomes a source of the sufferings. So on this basis, the particular, the body or the body upon it we experience this loss of experience different feelings of happiness and the suffering And because of that so due to that feeling of happiness, one one develops the attachment and of undergoing experiencing suffering, one one develops the hatred or anger. And by lacking by lacking the understanding or or because of the confusion or the ignorance, one one cultivates lots of action or karma.
And due to that, one develops all those disturbing emotions and karma upon this particular basis of our body and due to that one and one passes from that one passes from partly travels or passes from this body and then take take another form and then that that form again cultivating all those different on the negative actions or disturbing emotions like attachment, anger and so forth by by experiencing a different feelings of happiness and suffering and so forth. So so so due to that, we, you know, we we circles and we circles and cycle existence and we undergoes through huge suffering. So what we need to do is we we should try to avoid circling in this cyclic existence and try not to take such a forms. So so we, the ordinary person, in our mind, in our wisdom or in our mind, it appears that this particular rebirth is very appears very pure and very happy or happiness and becomes also very, very and very stable. But and also find it very appealing and good all the time that and it is finding it is it is formed by the collection of excellence.
So so but but if one asks or examine whether that that mind or the wisdom we see which which sees the particular body is the is source of is the is the pure happiness, happy and stability, then if an examiner whether that mind is valid or invalid, then it becomes that the mind sees this body appealing as invalid or the mistaken. So the searching on this invalid because because because if this body is by nature, it’s happiness or appealing, it it has to be or or be very stable and by nature, it’s happiness, so it should always be happy or a source of happiness because and it it it should never be be a source of never be act act as a so I mean, act as a source of sufferings and the the source of developing developing or generating the disturbing emotions and those actions. And so so but the fact is it is not because it is the source, but because we we undergoes through the many self different sort of sufferings, which experiences all comes from this this body that one has the suffering of suffering of birth, aging, illness, suffering of death, and have faces like suffering of not not accomplishing what what one wish and what wants and not meet and suffering of not meeting with one wants or one wish, not meeting with the appealing or the one one desires and not and suffering or meeting with the unwanted things.
So by nature we can see this this I mean, on this particular basis, on this body one experiences the different varieties of selflessness now. Nice. And so in particular or especially as this this body is being projected or produced by disturbing emotions or non virtuous action. And due to that, it is by nature, it is the by nature, it is suffering. And and if that is not true or so because of that have been produced by the distorted emotional non non-virtuous action, by nature, it has to be or it is the is suffering in nature by nature, it is suffering.
And if it is a happiness, then then then the teaching on those the law of action and law of cause and the the the results should be should be invalid teachings. So we need to clarify some or make some more detailed explanation about the of the middling scope here because the the main practices or the main requirement of the conditions to practice in the in the middling middling scope is that one needs to have intention or develop intention, which we which wishes to free from this cyclic existence or the saṃsāra. And in order to in order to in order to develop such intention or intention freeing one’s of one from saṃsāra, one one has to know the what the know the true nature or the reality of the cyclic existence or saṃsāra. Without knowing the nature or the true nature of cyclic existence, one will not one will never never develop a a or generate a mind or intention of freeing oneself from cyclic existence. It is like, for example, if if for example, one is making a friend becoming a friend with someone else, so opening of a friendship.
If if one made a friend become become a friend with someone else without examining that person just by looking at first time for him and her, one suddenly comes to that person is a good person and without having a proper understanding, one will make become friend with that person and will never have a and or never have the intention to be separated or or end one’s friendship. And so by dealing with the person and having sort of friendship for a long time, and after a while and when one come to know that the person, your friend is not a good person, that he or she lies, steals, and fights and so forth. But by knowing all those all the all the the the bad qualities of the person, then one suddenly develops a intention or a thought to be end to end one’s friendship with the particular person. So likewise, without without having without knowing a proper nature or or or the disadvantages of the cyclic existence, one will never have a will develop the intention of being freeing oneself from the cyclic existence because because one one wants to be with it because one one don’t have the proper understanding.
But knowing this the default the by knowing the the disadvantage of the cyclic existence, then one can or one, yeah, one can develop the the intention of being free from cyclic existence. So the the such an intention being free of cyclic existence is the main conditions or the the, yeah, of the main requirement requirement or condition to practice the practices in the part of meddling scope without having that intention, one is not in the part of not practicing or in the part of the middling scope. So for that purpose, the Buddha Shakyamuni during during the first wheel of doctrine or the I mean, first first nectar of giving the first nectar of teaching at Varanasi, he he set forth the teachings of four noble truths that four noble truths that the the the teachings the the the four noble truths of the suffering origin of the suffering cessation and the true cessation and the true paths. And the teaching of the four noble truth is being set forth by by by summarizing summarizing the the remember so old, summarizing the practices and it’s been set forth in the four truths. So so as for the practice or to to to practice or we practice Dharma, the when when one practices the Dharma and they are doing one’s practice, there there is a two types that one one one thing to abandon and one to cultivate or or to develop oh, yeah, degenerate.
Excuse me. And so as for the abandonment, you know, while doing the practices is that the the the result, which is suffering, which we do not wish, we do not wish suffering. And so as so as we do not wish suffering, which is the result from its causes, one should you know, one we we we are yeah. Should try to or should abandon the causes of the suffering. So as for the as for the abandonment during the practices is that are the two that the suffering and the causes of the sufferings are the two object to abandon.
So from the beginning of the Four Noble Truths, he set forth the suffering and the true suffering. And as for the suffering here, this is not the suffering in which we are talking, say, we physically we have a feeling of the suffering of the the disease like, say the headache and so forth, so these are the self these are the suffering here doesn’t refer to those sufferings. And those those suffering of the the feeling of headache and so forth is not suffering here because those sufferings can, which causes the heart, produces not a good feeling and those suffering can be recognized by the animals. And there is another suffering called the suffering of change, which is the the the the the feeling produces by all the uncontaminated feeling. So contaminated feelings which are the suffering.
But from the beginning, it’s one finds or one has a feeling or one finds that feeling as happiness. Gradually, by using or being you have experienced such a feeling continuously for a long time, then suddenly that feeling changes, the feeling of happiness changes into the suffering. And such is called the the the suffering of changes and which is the also so from the beginning, it finds as a happiness, but that that is not the that that is not the way happiness because if it is a if it is a happy if it is a happiness, then by nature, it should be happy from yeah. By nature, it should be happy and no matter how much one uses that happiness, it always should become happier and happier rather than changing it into the the suffering. So for for for that, this this is called the suffering of changes and here the true suffering is so that this one is also not the true suffering doesn’t reference to that one, that that this this one also which is true, the suffering of changes.
So so you said such a feeling of happiness, which I think is derived from the contaminated feelings. From the beginning, it sees as a very appealing or happiness. And and such happiness is not a perfect or a valid happiness and and also it all it it changes after a while or after helping you experiencing it. So and that that happiness is not a valid happiness and also not and to understand that happiness is not a valid happiness, one doesn’t necessarily could be a practitioner or, yeah, or a Dharma practitioner or religious person because a non religious or non So now, there is another suffering called the suffering of pervasive conditionedness, which is set forth the great master called Dharmakīrti has stated that the one, this this or form which which which led once to circle again circles in the cyclic existence or saṃsāra and studies the one that is the suffering of pervasive condition and it’s also the true suffering from the beginning. True suffering of the Four Noble Truth refers to this suffering which is suffering of pervasive condition.
So to recognize what is the suffering of pervasive conditionedness then we can say that this body which is the projected by the disturbing emotion and the action and it’s called also the contaminated body. This is the yeah, contaminated body is the suffering of pervasive condition. No, no, which is Body which is projected or influenced, taken projected or produced by the disturbing emotion and the action. So for that reason, the the the the lord, Buddha Śākyamūni from the beginning, set forth the the true suffering and which says that the contaminated body is is the suffering because it has been produced by the by the disturbing emotion and the action, the karma. So there are the reasons of proving that the body is suffering, that the contaminated body is suffering and for one reason it has been produced by the disturbing emotion and the action, disturbing emotion and the action.
And in other hand, it is also suffering because because from the beginning, it it has been said that this is the true suffering of the superior beings, which means the superior superior beings which refers to a person are very qualified scholars who have masters or who have recognized the selflessness of persons and realizes the emptiness directly. And such a person has seized as so such a person, the superior being, seized, directly seized this body, this contaminated body is suffering. And it’s been said that as so by sorry, this particular contaminant body is by by nature or it is the suffering as it’s been seen by the superior beings. So in but this this this contaminated body appears to the ordinary person that it appears as by nature, it appears as a as a pure and happiness and and the permanence, very stable. And whereas for for for the superior beings, it appears it appears as impure unhappiness and and not its impermanence changes momentarily.
So the way of appearing this this this contaminated body to the ordinary beings and to the superior beings are right opposite or contradictory. So if I ask then to which is the true now, So if I announce which appearances are are is the truth, are there two eyes appearances of the ordinary beings or the superior beings. And here, the Buddha Śākyamūni has stated that the the the appearance of those the superior beings are are are the valid one and the truth one because because because they they they because because they have the the they have seized those on they have or had those appearances through the through the correct wisdom or the valid cognition, and due to that, they have valid reasons. Whereas for the ordinary beings, they have I mean, had all those appearances. I’m seeing appearances through the lack of understanding and due to that, it’s been established by the invalid invalid cognition and for that, they they don’t have the valid valid reason to prove that those appearances are true.
So there is two kinds of ways of doing a meditation which that by doing a meditation through seeing into the cyclic existence or the contaminated body the way it sees by the superior beings and if one does it by the way it sees by the superior beings then the result of the meditation will be very beneficial and one will have attained a lot of good qualities. And if one sees it, meditate by seeing it as it’s seen by the ordinary person, one will have all those, receive all those unwanted sufferings and so forth and will have the disadvantages of the cyclic existence and met with this or will have the unwanted sufferings. It is because the superior beings, meditating on the way that pits to them, which has been suffering, impure, and so forth, and due to that, they they had liberated or been freed themselves from the cyclic existence or from these sufferings. And whereas for the ordinary person, well, as they have accepted the way it appears to them as a pure and happiness and so forth, and due to that, because of that, they have met with unwanted sufferings and cultivated the the actions and due to that and it happened or or due to that, this they again and again circles in the samsaric existence and would hardly have a time or hardly can say that they hardly predict predict the time that that is the time that they will be free from cyclic existence.
One cannot predict the time of their liberation from the cyclic existence. So there is a danger of teaching about the suffering because because because we do not wish suffering. In Buddhist teaching, they many things. They talk talk a lot about the suffering and there is a danger of like seeing that why is it that they teach us about the suffering and by thinking that there is a danger of disliking the Buddhist teaching. So it happens like some people just say, Oh, there’s only suffering in Buddhist teachings.
So one who has field search that the only suffering in Buddhist teaching then, that person lacks the understanding of the purposes of teaching the suffering and he is okay to make that mistake. So the purpose of teaching suffering is that that we need to we need to generate a intention, the intention to free oneself from the cyclic existence. And it is during the practice of the the practicing in the in the part of middling scope, one needs to develop the pure and strong intention of free of free strong of pure and strong intention to free oneself from the cyclic existence or saṃsāra. And in order to develop such a such such intention, one has to yeah. In order to develop such intention that we are yeah.
The the taught the teaching or the taught about sufferings. So in order to develop that intention to pure and strong intention and of freeing oneself from cyclic existence, one has to one needs to see the know the disadvantages or the faults of saṃsāra. Without knowing this default or the disadvantages of saṃsāra, then one cannot develop the intention to free oneself from cyclic existence. So in order to develop such intention, one has to see the the disadvantages of cyclic existence and in the way of seeing the disadvantages of the cyclic existence, one has to see the sufferings of the cyclic existence. So that proposed with it that proposed that the teaching of suffering has been set forth.
So it’s it’s like a prisoner who is who is in the prison. So if the the prisoner sees the disadvantages or the fault of the the prison, like, he’s been trapped in the four directions and there’s no way to escape and all those difficulties within the prison, he will, from the very first moment, he or she will develop a very strong intention of being free freeing him or herself from the prison or letting escape oneself from from this from the prison. And if the person fail or didn’t see the the faults or the disadvantages of this prison, then he or she will never have intention to free from the freeing oneself from the prison because if the person sees, say, the prison is very happy being in prison, but there’s no work, they feed me and so on and so. And so but so without seeing very happy and not seeing these these disadvantages of the prison, then the one will never have a developed intention of fleeing from the prison. And even if the time the sentence or the punishment is over, like, alright.
Tomorrow is your last day, and you say, it’s your your time to go out and the person, no, I still want to stay. So likewise, if one fails to see the disadvantages of the samsaric existence and sees very happy being in saṃsāra and so forth, then one will one will not develop the intention of freeing oneself from the saṃsāra. So in order to develop the intention of freeing oneself from saṃsāra, the teaching of this teaching about teaching of the true suffering has been or the suffering has been set forth. So and by seeing the disadvantages and the fault of the cyclic existence of saṃsāra, then one will engage in the cultivating of the method of freeing oneself from the cyclic existence and one will work so hard or very enthusiastically and due to that one can free one one can quickly free oneself from the cyclic existence. So I don’t know about the systems in Australia but about in India, say a person has committed a huge crime and then he or she has been sentenced for life imprisonment.
And but but if and then suddenly, the person try very hard to free him or herself from the prison and and connect to the very important contact contact very important person by working with the money and and there is a possibility of person being free within a month instead of a lifetime. So if a person has committed a crime like of murder or murdering someone and by fixing it with the money, the person will become pure or saying that he hasn’t killed anybody. So if the person didn’t try him or herself to free him from the or escape him from the life imprisonment then he has to be in a in a prison for a lifetime. Okay. So we’ll stop here.
Any questions? Is there a key which Yeah, there is a key which is the wisdom of hearing contemplation and meditation. Wisdom of contemplation and wisdom of meditation and through all this, by the power of those wisdoms, one can take Buddhadharma from the head towards the, into the heart and then liberate So if one studies the debating or the philosophy of debates it is the, it’s been set forth the key part to cultivate those wisdom of hearing, contemplation and the meditation. I’m going to use Sanskrit, say, rather than that. So you should become a monk and go to Sera. And you gotta find the key.
The title of the the text itself is saying that the key of the logic and the parts. Very, very good. Just just stick with the daily routine. In order to stick with the daily routine, one does not necessarily need to have the desire or attachment And if one has a compassion, love, and special intention or the bodhisattva, then without any desire and that attachment, one can stick with one’s daily routine as well as benefits or work for the development of all sentient beings. Likewise, bodhisattvas, they have no attachment, desire and so forth, yet they have those very strong compassion, love, special intention as well as bodhichitta and much more or much stronger than we we have and and and due to that, without any desire or attachment, they involve in the activities of benefit, they they involve the whole twenty four hours.
They involve in the activities of benefiting or yeah. For the yeah. For the betterment of of sentient beings and so forth. Help others twenty four hours a day? Whereas if I was, I mean I would think about it and create the motivation to help others.
So beings of that level are beyond that desire to where it just becomes a natural part of do you follow what I mean? Yes. Yeah. Just do the spontaneous thing as opposed to something that we have to make some effort sometimes to generate. A day beyond that need to even think about, contemplate that.
Okay. So about the bodhisattvas, actually there are different numbers of bodhisattvas that even in activities they perform, some activities they a very they don’t especially need to motivate it to perform such action that by spontaneously it is always there within themselves. And also for some cases, some actions they still need to be motivated for So it’s it’s answer for the earlier answer that that so, yeah, in order to benefit the without desire and attachment, they perform these activities. And to to to to perform perfect samsaric activities, then one definitely needs to have those desire and attachment. And without this without this without attachment and desire, then one will fail to perform the samsaric action.
So it is true in the sense you said that to perform with those activities like these samsaric activities then you definitely need a desire and attachment. Okay. Okay. Okay. Yeah.
Thank you. Thank you very much. Yeah.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- six realms
- The general way that Buddhism divides the whole of cyclic existence; there are three lower realms (hell, hungry ghost and animal) and three upper realms (human, demigod and god). LYWA
- suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
- What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
- suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
- Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.