Sun Radiance – Thought Transformation

55 min · 7,500 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Sun Radiance - Thought Transformation (Khensur Rinpoche)
Sun Radiance - Thought Transformation (Khensur Rinpoche)
Sun Radiance - Thought Transformation
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 55-minute Q&A session, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen responds to detailed questions about meditation practice within the Lamrim framework. Starting with a student’s query about why the meditation posture is called Vairochana, he clarifies that analytical meditation is structured, virtuous thinking focused on a chosen object, distinct from ordinary mental wandering. He then contrasts analytical and concentration meditation, using the two-part process of carefully analyzing a topic—such as the uncertainty of death—until a vivid understanding arises, then holding that understanding steadily until it fades. He emphasizes that this alternation between analysis and focus mirrors rigorous academic practice and is central to Lamrim meditation. The session addresses a major historical and philosophical problem in Buddhism: the false view that enlightenment requires meditating without thoughts, tracing this error to the Chinese master Huashang and showing how it conflicts with the Indian Buddhist position endorsed at Tibet’s Council of Lhasa. Geshe Jampa returns repeatedly to a core theme: transformation of mind requires genuine understanding grounded in logic, experience, and study before meditation can work. He cautions against misapplied mindfulness-of-breathing practices in the West and stresses that practitioners must clarify their true spiritual goal before undertaking practice, distinguishing between mundane aims and authentic Buddhist motivation grounded in the realization of impermanence and death. For practitioners with prior exposure to Lamrim teachings.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 8 Verses (D1Q&A – KR.mp3

UUID: 65816c88-ff46-4829-b05d-523b66b34493

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Sun Radiance – Thought Transformation

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~7,505

Then I’m open to your questions. Oh, thank you, honey. Thank you. Please Natalie. Thank you.

So I was wondering why is the meditation posture actually called the Vairochana posture? Does anyone know the answer? Who? Vairochana is the Buddha of form. Yes, Vairochana is the lineage Buddha which was a form aggregate and since the posture is a physical posture then the seven or the eight fold, it’s seven fold without the focus on breathing and eight fold with a focus on breathing, is called the posture Vairochana, the perfection of the form aggregate.

Other questions? When Geshe-la was listed the the the seven topics of the small scope, and you you said said, I was fairly slow writing them down. So I was wondering, are you able to say them again so that slowly enough so that I can With pleasure. I’d ask a volunteer to see Chris without looking at his notes. Precious Human Rebirth, the Eight Freedoms and 10 Endowments, appreciating their special value in the short term, the Lojong and in the immediate present?

Precisely Chris. So number one, identifying a rebirth of leisure and endowment. Number one, identifying a rebirth of leisure and endowment. Number two, Then, its, its importance. Number three, its rarity.

And then the death and impermanence. And then meditation on the lower realms, which gives rise to looking for refuge. And then karma. Thank you very much. So Geshe-la suggested a topic or a line of investigation for us this afternoon.

He suggested that you ask questions on meditation, On hearing, thinking and meditation and how they are related. So do you have questions on those topics? Please. I might have misheard what Geshe-la said but I thought he said that actually that meditation is thinking about the object and so I was wondering what the, I might have misheard him, sorry — thinking about the topic — so I just wondered if I had heard him right, how that would be different from wisdom risen from thinking? Well, analytical meditation is a wisdom risen from thinking.

Right? Then when you engage in analytical meditation on the Lamrim, you are thinking about the Lamrim. What is the difference actually between thinking in general and analytical meditation, if there is one? Is it the focus? Yes, what would the difference be?

Okay so with analytical meditation, mean thinking you could just be wandering around a topic and just sort of la di da di da and distracted but with analytical meditation you try and keep the mind as a sentinel to try and keep it focused on the object of meditation which is in itself a virtuous state. Yes that’s basically it. In other words, basically because you worded it as usual a bit but basically it’s Excuse me. Minds are very good, very good. In that case we are grateful to you.

Those of you who are unaware of distraction and wandering, la reference. So the key indeed that the two points you raised, the first is that it’s a mind focused on a virtuous object as Geshe-la said virtuous object means basically a virtuous mind focused on an object, number one. Number two, it is a mind which one does not allow to be distracted to the difference of general thinking processes. Now what this means in practice is that those whose minds are well trained in thinking in, let us say, a rigorous academic discipline such as for instance mathematics will turn out to be brilliant analytical meditators and that is confirmed heavily by experience. Our best students at Séra Je systematically are engineers, scientists and so forth, people from the humanities do less well.

Mind is simply trained in analytical meditation, you know, and that training can very easily be transposed, you know, to Buddhist studies, you know. So analytical meditation is basically structured and directed thinking. There’s nothing terribly complicated about it. It is one of the two forms of meditation on the Lamrim, the other form is concentration meditation, which one engages in once one has carefully analyzed a topic at a say for instance death and impermanence. Let’s assume you were meditating on death and impermanence along the lines of the three roots, the nine reasons and the three conclusions.

Right? The three roots are that death is certain, the time of death is uncertain, at the time of death only Dharma is of use. Then of these three, the first is the easiest, so you do not insist on the easy points when you meditate. Death is certain, is actually self evident to all of us. It’s like breaking through an open door, especially those of you who are above 60, you know, are probably largely here because your death has become an issue.

Among many of the younger ones among us, we do encounter people who have had near death experiences, accidents and so forth. So you don’t insist too much on the first topic. The second topic, the time of death is uncertain, is the most difficult one. That’s what you would focus upon. You would start by analyzing it, why is the time of death uncertain, relying on logic and examples.

You need both and this must be connected to your own experience. That is analytical meditation. When you get a very strong sense that the time of my death is completely uncertain, it must be very strong, you stop analyzing and you focus on that. That is concentration meditation. You keep the focus on that until you start losing that sense of the complete uncertainty of the time of your death.

How quickly you lose it depends on two things: how thorough your analysis has been, and therefore how clear the object is, and how powerful your concentration, which is like the lamp illuminating the topic, is. If both of these are very powerful you can concentrate for a very long time. If either is weak you will lose the object rapidly. When you start losing it you return to analysis to gain once again a very very clear sense of what the uncertainty of the time of death is. Once it has arisen very clearly in the mind, you focus again on it.

Now this is when I was a student at the Swiss Federal Polytechnicum in math and physics, this is how we, you know, focused on demonstrations. You were asked to demonstrate a theorem, let’s say, linear algebra, sort of rather elementary field, you would basically focus on the analyze a topic, and then at a certain point you’d stop and you’d focus on the problem in this sort of in the hope that an answer would arise. Right? Sometimes it didn’t, know. Then you would go back.

So this is this alternation between analytical and concentration meditation is not something specifically Buddhist. It is used in all of the rigorous academic disciplines. It has been formalized to an exceptional degree in Buddhism, you know. There’s nothing else to meditation on the Lamrim than this. And meditation on the Lamrim works if you do it by the book.

For very simple reason, it is designed as an incremental process, it’s a ladder, you know. So each realization is designed to open the gateway to the next one. Once you start jumping around, which most of our Western students do, then it doesn’t happen. Did you have other questions on meditation? Ilya, just a very basic one, sorry, and a clarification.

So when you’re doing analytical meditation, is it still a formal meditation? You’re in the meditation position Well, let me answer you with a question. Is insight meditation or not? Sorry? Is insight meditation or not?

Insight meditation, yes. Then why would analytical meditation, which is a preliminary to insight, not be meditation? No, I’m not asking if it not meditation, but if I sit home with lots of books and really focus and analyze, That’s study to me, that’s not meditation. So then after that, do I move into what would be called analytical meditation? Well, Westerners are extremely uncomfortable with the concept of analytical meditation.

So it’s been a problem in the transmission of Buddhism to the West from day one. But if you are focusing, let us say, on liberation in the palm of your hand, you have read the section, you stop reading, which is another activity, and you focus on the meaning, trying to understand exactly the meaning, that’s analytical meditation. There’s nothing else than that to analytical meditation. Nothing else, you know. And concentration meditation can only come after analytical meditation.

Because you must have identified the object. Right? Do you have other questions? Just quickly, Ilya, earlier on in Geshe-la’s teaching, he mentioned having a virtuous mind dwelling on a virtuous subject and said that the first two noble truths weren’t virtuous. But then later, we were invited to just to consider the four noble truths as part of the meditation.

So the latter two noble truths are definitely virtuous. They are, if you wish, Dharma, the noble truth of cessation of the path. The first noble truth and the second noble truth are the unfortunate predicament we’re in. You know? Then, as a matter of fact, phenomena are neither virtuous nor non virtuous by themselves.

It is the mind observing a phenomena which turns it into a virtuous or non virtuous phenomenon. For instance, you can attain calm abiding based on pretty much any object you choose. You know, traditionally, one chooses in the Gelug tradition the statue of the Buddha. The Sakya Pandita tradition focuses on a blue flower for various reasons, linked to the transmission of the Kālacakra. A blue flower in and of itself is not virtuous.

If you focus on a blue flower, it’s a neutral state of mind. If you focus on a blue flower with a wish to attain calm abiding, to for instance gain realization of emptiness, that becomes virtuous. You know? So everything depends basically. You know?

Can I ask you a question before we continue? How many of you meditate every day? Please raise your hands. Don’t be shy. One, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight.

How long? Half an hour? Fifteen minutes? Less? More?

An hour, very good. Order did a very good, very good. Anyone does meditate that much? Regularly, every day. You do?

If you meditate, this will make sense to you. If you don’t meditate, it is very academic. So I think for Chris probably it makes sense. I would assume this is how you meditate on the Lamrim. This is how we would talk to meditate, you know.

Then there are many major misunderstandings about meditation, largely due to the view of a Chinese who taught a meditation without any object. Then I think Hua Shan doesn’t agree with me. Basically, this view is sharply contradicted by the Samdhinirmochana sūtra, the sūtra unraveling the knot which I gather must either not have been translated in Chinese in the early eighth century. Hua Shang had not seen it. So the Tibetans always like a good joke.

I don’t think this is true, but that’s what they say. Say that when Hua Shang read the Samdhinirmochana sūtra, he was so upset that he kicked it. Then I don’t know if this is true or not, but it is a fundamental divide regarding meditation. It is, to call things by their names, a wrong view. This idea of meditating without an object, which has caused a lot of damage in Tibet and which has caused a lot of damage in China.

Which is Susho? Sorry? Do you know the Susho name in Chinese? I can give you the Sanskrit name. Samdhinirmochana sūtra.

It’s translated in Chinese, a major sūtra in Chinese. No. Zen Buddhism is mainly based on Lankavatara. Lankavatara is the sūtra of the Descent into Lanka. But Zen Buddhism draws very heavily from non-Buddhist traditions like the Taoist tradition and does introduce this idea of meditating without a thought.

Hua Shang’s view, I’ll explain it to you because it’s always a subtext with our Western students. Hua Shang had he didn’t compose any works, but he left aphorisms. One of his aphorisms is all clouds block the sun whether they are white or black. And this is the classic description of Hua view. In other words, to attain enlightenment both virtuous and non virtuous thoughts are harmful.

This was Hua Shang’s view, this Kamalaśīla explained when he was teaching the Bhāvanākrama. So Hua Shang’s view spread in Tibet, it’s a form of Zen, not all Zen practitioners, Chan practitioners subscribe to this view, but many do. And there was a major debate in Tibet between Kamalaśīla, who was the foremost representative of the Indian position, one of the leading Indian meditators and scholars of his age, And Hua Shang and his disciples. Hua Shang and his disciples were mainly represented at the Tibetan court at the period. It was very much a Tibetan elites which were sympathetic to Hua Shang’s view and there was a very strong political subtext.

If you were pro Chinese you were sympathetic to Huashiang’s view. If you were pro Indian you were sympathetic to Kamalaśīla’s view. So you cannot ignore the political subtext. Then obviously when the debate occurred Kamalaśīla was one of the very great heavyweights, if you wish, of the Nālānda Monastery. Then Hua Shang was well and thoroughly defeated.

And Tibet basically adopted the Indian outlook, which is very important here because Huashang’s view was one which discarded completely the method aspect of the path (also occurs as the wisdom aspect of the past). It’s completely discarded. Hua Shang focused only on the wisdom aspect of the past and a specific aspect thereof. But Hua Shang’s view has survived in many of the Tibetan traditions in a more or less unstated fashion. You find this in Kagyu, you find this in Nyingma, much less in the Sakya tradition.

And there was a resurgence of Hua Shang’s view in what is known as which is called the Mahāmudrā of the one taste, which realizes everything, which is a misunderstanding of Mahāmudrā, which became prevalent in Tibet in the twelfth and thirteenth century, and thought taught basically no thought. So this was very virulently criticized by one of the foremost Sakya scholars of his age, Sakya Pandita, who said: those who practice Mahāmudrā wrongly prepare themselves as great care for rebirth as a dog. Because basically, once you start training the mind in non thinking, what you are doing is causing an extreme dulling of the mental faculties. So this I have seen in many Westerners who train their minds in this way, and the first sign that this is happening is a brutal decline in memory. So if as a result of your meditation, your intelligence and your memory decline, you are meditating wrongly.

It is a given. So I have known many westerners in that situation who have a very cursory understanding of meditation and damage their minds as a result. As a result of meditation, your intelligence should become more powerful and your memory should become far more powerful. If anything else is happening, you’re meditating wrongly and you must learn to meditate correctly. Does all of this make sense?

Then I’m being very direct with you, can see on some of the faces it’s not going down well because this is there is a very, very unanalyzed heavy prejudice against analytical activity among Westerners. People come to Buddhist centers bringing a lot of baggage with them. Then the centers are not responsible for the baggage people have. You know, it’s up to you to handle your baggage. You know, if you got problems with studies when you were young, that’s not our problem.

You know? Or the Buddhist teachings are teachings to develop the mind, And a clear indication of solid practice is after, let’s say, five or ten years of Buddhist teachings, you can look back and you can say, my analytical capacities are far more powerful, my concentration is far more powerful, I can remember things when I was always forgetful. If, and I have seen this with one case I know of a very sincere and dedicated Western practitioner, whose memory just started collapsing in her mid thirties, Forgetfulness became rampant. Do you have other questions? Andrew and I were talking in the break about Geshe-la’s quote this morning from the Lamrim Chenmo about the function of recollection having three parts.

One, the focus on the object. Two, to prevent forgetfulness. And three, to prevent distraction. We’re just, I was just wondering with the second function to prevent forgetfulness, is that forgetfulness of the actual topic that is, that has been understood from the wisdom arising from hearing or is it just, you know, forgetfulness of what you’re actually doing? Doing when?

Well, so well I guess guess what I’m trying to do is get the distinction between forgetfulness and distraction. Whether the forgetfulness is that you have not understood the topic thoroughly through the wisdom arising from hearing, so you’re not remembering what it is, you know, your understanding of it? Well, distraction is the preliminary to forgetfulness. Here when we speak of recollection, it’s smriti in Sanskrit, drenpa in Tibetan, it’s actually memory we’re talking about. I could translate it as memory, but I find recollection is more general, you know.

Meditation is about memory. You remember an object, which you choose to remember, to familiarize your minds with and transform it through that process. Then distraction means that you have lost the object. But if you have lost the object only a short period of time, you will not forget it. Then extreme distraction leads to forgetfulness where you completely lose the object of meditation.

You know? Here, there is one thing to keep in mind. When Geshe-la mentioned this morning the importance of the transition from hearing to speaking to meditating, I’d like to give you a bit of backdrop because otherwise I think there’s little benefit in engaging in meditation. From the standpoint of all the Indian traditions, the mind can be transformed and can be transformed durably. Then this transformation occurs through a process of introspection which is called gom, meditation.

Literally in Tibetan gom means habituation, becoming accustomed to, with the same root as the verb to be accustomed to. But there is a crux here. Our goal is to transform our outlook from an unrealistic to a realistic outlook. An unrealistic outlook is one which sees the world in the way we wish it were. A realistic outlook is a world which sees the a view which sees the world in the way it is.

How do we know how the world is as opposed to how we would like it to be? So, how we would like it to be is our ordinary perception. We all see for instance, take a very simple case, human relationships as permanent. As a result, we are all heavily over invested in human relationships. This is a wish.

Human relationships are not permanent. The slightest analysis shows us the opposite. Relations with the parents are not permanent, relations with partners are not permanent, relations with children are not permanent, are impermanent. But we do not transform our minds in terms of that understanding arisen from analysis and logic. Now, the crux of the Indian traditions is that the mind should be transformed in terms of an understanding of reality by means of logic.

The Buddhist tradition has gone much further than most in subscribing to logic as a tool to understand reality. So to do this, we must understand reality correctly. And this is the place of study and of analysis. For instance, is the world permanent or not? All that surrounds us appears certainly as permanent, and we all live as if what surrounds us were permanent and we were permanent.

The way we function in daily life is that everyone saves money for their old age if they’re sensible. Then at the same time, everyone tries to make believe that they are not changing. So, you know, we dye our hair, we make up, we what is it? Whiting our teeth? I don’t know what people do.

Pull the skin, sometimes it becomes frozen. Right? Then, we seem to be, if you wish, neurotic. At the same time, we like to believe that the world is permanent, at the same time we try to freeze our features, to prevent any sign of change within ourselves. Now the goal from the Buddhist perspective is to bring our minds in alignment with reality.

So if the world is impermanent, then we must transform our minds to see the world as impermanent. That is Dharma. There’s nothing else to it. Now some topics were so difficult that it is not possible based on our logic alone to have access. Typically the details of karma and causality.

So these were taught by Buddha Śākyamūni. Otherwise, most of the Buddhist teachings are accessible to logic and analysis alone. As a result, historians have said many scientists are probably Buddhist without being really aware of the fact. Right? So now you can see that before meditation you need to engage in a very careful analysis of reality and of one’s own mind.

And then try to establish what is true and what is false. Because if you’re going to change your mind, it’s a very major affair, right? You want to change your mind in keeping with reality. If you change your mind in keeping with reality, the more you meditate, the clearer things will get. Right?

And in turn, because you are if you wish, I put this in very un Buddhist terms, more of a Taoist outlook, you are in harmony with reality, there will be less suffering. Does that make sense to you? Right? The more your minds are at odds with reality, this is supposed to be someone we don’t like too much who said this, Vladimir Ilyich Lenin, the Russian communist, said, facts are stubborn. Facts are very stubborn.

If your mind is at odd with reality, then it’s gonna be a painful experience. Right? Very painful experience. So before meditation, for that reason, hearing, in other words, study is necessary. You must study.

And then you must think very carefully. It’s not sufficient that a teacher, let’s say Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen or his Holiness Dalai Lama says something. We hear frequently western students saying, this is not possible because his Holiness said this, which is a very bad argument. It’s an argument by authority. It may or may not be true that everything His Holiness says is true (also The historian has said many things which are not true), it is not.

The historian has said many things which are not true, to help people, is it beneficial for the person? It is certainly of no benefit to ourselves to accept an authority. No benefit. Are there religious traditions like Christianity or for that matter the other monotheistic traditions which are built largely on scriptural authority? And it is problematic in situations of crisis.

Right? So the best way to approach things is to rely on reason and experience. And then have the great texts in the backdrop, and you have to analyze in terms of your own understanding. The reason so many of our students leave the center is because this has not happened. So it is Geshe-la says, and so and so says, and so and so says, and that never elicits conviction.

For instance, someone said a couple days ago the mind was permanent. Then it is directly, it flies directly in the face of one’s own experience. That is something which would have been accepted on authority and is unexamined. Because if one examines, the more you examine, the more problematic such a viewpoint is. Then if you were to say like Hua Shang that no thought is the road to enlightenment, well then the state of no thought is one which is very closely approximated by my dog, Mimi.

And she is certainly not to enlightenment, you know. There’s most of the time not a lot of conceptual activity in her mind. Then if conceptual activity is a problem, my dog is far closer to enlightenment than any of us. Mhmm. You see.

So it is a very major wrong view, this one. It is a wrong view which is an obstacle to all study of any type. It is one if you have it within yourselves, really have to examine very carefully. I should point out, by the way, that everything we have here is a result of thought. To start with the fact that we are talking.

My talking to you is a conceptual activity. Your listening is a conceptual activity. Then this sound system is a result of extreme conceptual activity from scientists. Right? We have liked for the same reason.

So everything we have is broadly speaking the result of conceptuality. To dismiss conceptuality is a very dangerous business. What is taught is that for the fundamental realizations, such as the realization of emptiness, we have to go from conceptuality to non conceptuality, but we must use conceptuality. There is no access to the direct experience of emptiness to say, without conceptuality. Does all this make sense?

Do you have other questions? Please. Question. When you’re doing mindfulness of breathing meditation Mindfulness of breathing. Yes.

And least, I believe the object of that is to develop quite a calm mind. How does the development of a calm mind differ from wanting to develop a mind with no thought? What what’s the what’s the difference between those two? Well, I’m glad you brought up the topic of mindfulness of breathing, thank you very much. Very glad actually, I would have liked to bring it up myself.

Basically, there is a very major problem with the reception of the practice of what is called in Thailand Anapanasati, what we call in the West vipassana in the West. And we have to understand what the mindfulness of breathing was originally in the Satipatthana sūtra, as taught by the Buddha, what its goals were, and the diversion of those goals in the West. So the goal of mindfulness of breathing in the Theravāda tradition is a realization of the three marks. The three marks, does anyone know by any chance? There’s no emptiness in Theravāda, but that’s it.

It is suffering, impermanence and selflessness. So through practicing the mindfulness of breathing, by practicing the mindfulnesses which are taught for instance by Mahasi Sayadaw, the great Burmese meditator, on the body, on sensation, on thoughts, and on Dharma, the four mindfulnesses. Then eventually one gains indirectly a realization of the suffering nature of the aggregates, that comes rapidly. If you’ve ever done Satipatthana, especially in the Thai or the Burmese tradition after a couple days, the nature of suffering is transparent. Everything hurts.

Then impermanence and then selflessness. Now, when these traditions were transmitted to the West, it’s mainly, I think, Goldstein, Joseph Goldstein, who diverted them from their initial focus. And at present they are used by Westerners to calm the mind, to calm an agitated mind, then that is actually not the goal of these traditions in Theravāda at all. It works. I know a friend who is a psychiatrist in Melbourne.

I have personally major reservations regarding the way these practices are used in the West because they’re used for people who typically have mental problems or are borderline and it is unwise for people who are borderline to meditate. The mental issues must be addressed first, the mind must be stabilized, the body too, because the mind and body coexist, and then once the mind and body complex is stable, once the five aggregates are stable, then one can meditate. I told him many times, I encouraged him to study with U Pandita, is a very great Burmese master in Yangon. He never did and there were problems with the group at Monash. One of his colleagues at least, well, how do they put it politely these days?

You’re in the field, Chris, what is a polite term? Had a dissociative experience. In other words, schizophrenic. No one goes schizophrenic anymore. People have dissociative experiences.

Generally speaking, this is what happens when you use a tool which is designed with one goal for another. Now, in the Tibetan tradition there is no practice of mindfulness of breathing in this sense. I mean there are elements of this in Abhidharma, it is not practiced really. What happens is that one practices a focus on inhalation and exhalation to calm the mind as a preliminary to other meditations. It’s never a central practice.

And I don’t know of a single Tibetan teacher working within his tradition who uses this simply because the transmission is not there. It’s a very powerful these Theravāda is very powerful. I think they make a very good preliminary for the Lamrim. But you have to practice them in the traditional way, you know. And if you want to practice them differently, then I think whoever it is first must train in the traditional way.

Because as far as technology is concerned, I think we Westerners have no lessons to take from anybody. But when it comes to mind training, we are babes in the woods, and we should we should really listen to the experts. Does this make sense? Does it answer your question? It answers part of my question.

I think the underlying question is how should I practice? Well it depends. Are you a Buddhist or not? Do well If you’re a hedging, then you probably are not. Mhmm.

Mhmm. I’m not quite sure. Buddhist, to my mind, is is a label. Everything I is a label, I agree with you, but that doesn’t preclude things from functioning. Your watch is a label, but it gives the time.

Are you a Buddhist or not? You see, I asked one question and you answered with something else. You took refuge, does not make you Buddhist. It’s a it’s a ceremony. I suppose I’m not sure.

I’m uncertain of what the definition of Buddhist. Is is it is there a definition of Buddhist? There’s two. Buddhist always have multiples. Right?

Why have one if we can have several? It’s true. Why be simple if you can be complicated? You can be a Buddhist by faith or by reason. By faith, I would say most Asian Buddhists are Buddhists by faith.

They have faith in the triple gem, which means faith in the Dharma. And then in a subsidiary fashion, they have faith in the Buddha, as teach of the Dharma, and faith in the Sangha, as those who basically direct, you know, practitioners. Then you could be a Buddhist from that standpoint. Or you could be a Buddhist from the standpoint of reasoning. Then from the standpoint of reasoning, which is much more powerful, it really means subscribing to the four seals.

The four seals are that all composite phenomena are impermanent, in other words all phenomena composed of parts are impermanent. All contaminated phenomena, in other words us, are the nature of suffering. All phenomena are selfless and empty. And nirvana is peace and virtue. So what these four seals assert is that we are in an impermanent world which changes continually, we ourselves are of the nature of suffering, There is a beyond suffering, which is a fourth seal called nirvana, and the means to attain that beyond suffering is meditation on the nature of phenomena.

And if you accept those four seals, then you are truly a Buddhist. Then you are truly a Buddhist. Then there is no doubt. It is much better, because that is true Buddhism. Then Buddhism based on faith is really in no sense is different from Christianity.

You you see that in the Chinese temples in Hong Kong or Singapore people are clapping their little tablets together, then what that means, I don’t know. Then, to continue with your question, I ask you if you were a Buddhist or not, because we meditate with a goal in mind. So the question is, what is your goal? Is your goal a Buddhist goal or is it a mundane goal? If your goal is, let’s say, mental pacification in this life, it’s not a Buddhist goal.

Then there may be non-Buddhist techniques which will work better. There are non-Buddhist techniques of relaxation. In my time there was the Alexander technique. You would relax each muscle one by one, you know. You got so confused by the end you were really relaxed.

Then the Buddhist techniques, you see, before you meditate, you have to ask yourself, why am I meditating? I mean, time is limited. Energy is limited. None of us lives forever. Am I just meditating to gain strange experiences?

Then you can buy drugs, right? There’s a lot of drugs now. Am I meditating with a goal? What’s the goal? Right?

And that goal defines where you stand on the path of the being of the small, the middling, and the great scope. Now, the important thing is that it cannot be a verbal goal. Verbally, all of us, obviously, great tantric practitioners of the Mahāyāna. Right? But in reality, what drives you deep inside?

That is the question. Then no one can answer but yourself. If your teacher knows you very well, he will give you a pointer. And he will tell you, Rinpoche told me, you’re here, you know, then you know what to focus upon. Why is this important?

Because if your goal is mundane, let’s say your goal is for instance, I say many people interested in Buddhism in the West are interested to calm their minds, then none of these teachings here are really relevant to you, and you will not stay. Many of our students who come from mental problems do not stay for that reason. They get some satisfaction, some peace from these problems and they leave and we never see them again. So you have to ask yourself what is my goal? What what am I going into this for?

Not what I should say at the center to have a good reputation or fit in or whatever. What is my true goal? You know. Then the first goal is the minimum to be a Buddhist is to try to aim for a better rebirth. Technically speaking, you are not a Buddhist if that is your goal.

Because the Hindus aim for exactly the same thing. So the path shared with the being of the small scope is a path shared with Hinduism, with vast waves of Sikhism in India, with the Jains, with a lot of Indian traditions. Right? Then that is already quite a high goal. If you are aiming for a better rebirth in your future lives, then this life becomes less important.

And this is what is meant by turning away from the vanities of this life. It’s not forcing your mind into a corner and telling your mind, you cannot wish for the latest Holden and forget those vacations in Fiji, you wicked mind, because if you do that to your mind it’s going to fight back. Right? Instead, the goal is to try to define your own long-term goal. Then once you say to yourself, Yes, my long-term goal is a better rebirth, then the vanities of this life they naturally fade.

Right? It’s automatic. If that is your motivation, then the meditations you should engage in are those of the being of a small scope. So the key here is to look inside yourself and see where you are on the scale of the Lamrim. And then meditate in correspondence with your level.

That is what is powerful for your mind. And you can do an overview meditation of the totality of the Lamrim to familiarize. That is very helpful. But if you have not begun to turn away from the vanities of this life, it is illusory to believe that the meditations on gaining liberation from cyclic existence for yourself or for all beings are going to have any impact whatsoever. It will remain purely nominal.

And you must meditate, in other words, this process we talked about of analysis and concentration, analytical meditation and concentration, you must meditate until there’s a change. So the way we teach Lamrim is different from the way Lamrim was practiced in Tibet. Largely because the western audiences are much more unstable, and probably if Lamrim was taught here the way Dagpo Rinpoche taught it to Pakmo Drupa, then nobody would stay. You wouldn’t be here.

You know, it’s just it wouldn’t happen. You know? So the way Dagpo Rinpoche taught Pakmo Drupa, he would teach one topic. For instance, as I say, identifying the rarity of a human rebirth, the third of the seven topics of the path of the being of the small scope.

Pakmo Drupa would go to Gampopa’s cell, he would receive teachings based on logic, drawing on scripture and experience, and then Gampopa Rinpoche would send him to meditate and would not receive him until he had gained realizations. So it took six months, it took a year, it took whatever time it took. There were no teachings until there were realizations. After that he came back and he would be taught the next topic. So he was actually progressing on the path.

Right? Most of our students do endless shargom, overview meditations. Then one becomes very glib. The words are facile, but the meaning isn’t there. Do you understand?

Does this make sense to you? So for yourselves, if you want to derive benefit from these teachings, you have to start walking the path. It’s not enough to attend endless teachings and to view the teachings as a means of intellectual stimulation and whatever. At a certain point, our lives are very, very short. So either what is being taught here is, broadly speaking, true or it is not.

You have to decide. If it is true, then you really have to start pushing from your own side. If it is not true, you shouldn’t be here. This is not a business, I’m not here for financial reasons. I’m doing very well.

Thank you. Then Geshe-la has students, etcetera. He does not need to be here. So the question is, you yourselves, does this make sense to you? Do you intend to transform who you are in the light of all of this?

Or is it a way of spending long Easter weekend? Right? Because the first is extremely important, the second is just trivial. So you have to ask the question of truth, and only you can answer. And that does not mean that the Buddha’s teachings on Mount Meru are to be examined.

That is unimportant. But the core teachings, the four noble truths, the existence or non existence of saṃsāra, if there is no saṃsāra, in other words, there’s no reincarnation, then the Buddha’s teachings collapse. You have to have the courage of going to the end of your analysis. Then I’m afraid we have overstayed the question and answer, and I talked more than I should. So my apologies, you know.

Please. When you’re talking about you’re about the goals About what? Goal. Setting a goal. Goals.

Yes. What’s your recommendation so for us to actually set a goal? And because I have been struggling with it and I know I wanna set a higher goal but sometimes I just feel like it’s too far away from myself. Then it is very very good. The way you formulate things indicates that you are taking the teaching seriously.

So you studied accounting here at university, didn’t you? Yeah. I studied economics and accounting. And when you came here, you had a very clear idea of what you wanted to study. Right?

And I would imagine it was there were considerable sacrifices involved from your family and from yourself to come to study in Australia. So you worked very hard, and you accomplished your goal. Then with the Buddhist teachings, it’s exactly the same thing. We go absolutely nowhere if we waffle around. So the first question is to ask ourselves, well, why am I interested in Buddhism?

What do I want? Then if all we want is mental peace, because our minds are troubled, it’s perfectly okay to come to the center and to receive teachings and do our best. But what we will gain is just that mental peace. Nothing beyond it. Once we start asking the basic question, which is a question of death, it’s the one question human beings have to ask to move beyond this life, Then things change.

So I think it is the one question you have to ask yourselves. And then once you start providing answers to that question, you may gravitate towards the path of the being of the small, the being of the great scope, if you’re Buddhist, or you may end up as a non-Buddhist, as a Christian or whatever. I think for many of our students the question of death is not asked, or not asked correctly. This is not your case, and I would speak more generally here. I’ve always suggested in keeping with His Holiness’s teachings that our students explore their own religious traditions first.

So for Westerners, this means you must have explored Christianity and put Christianity aside. And then, asking the question of death, if you’re attracted to the Indian traditions, then you have the traditions which teach the existence of a soul and those which don’t. You must be able to distinguish the two. Hinduism teaches the existence of an Ātman. Buddhism is anātman.

Teach non existence of an Ātman. If you decide to be a Buddhist at that point, then you have to to find which of the three paths corresponds to you. But as I was saying, the first step is to see where you are at present. I think, probably, for all of us, our goal has to be to try to practice the being of the the path of the being of the small scope. That is an awful lot already.

And if we are lucky, maybe in a couple years, you know, we can move up to the path shared with the being of the medium scope, maybe not. Does that make sense? The means for mundane success apply very well in Buddhism. So, in your case, you are successful at the mundane level and you should be successful in your Buddhist practice. People who have not been successful on the mundane level typically are not successful in Buddhist practice.

Because to succeed in worldly affairs, you must have realistic goals, you must know where you go, you must work hard without changing your goal, and then you get there. Then, if you’re a drifter in mundane affairs, you’ll be a drifter in dharma. There’s no big mystery about it. It’s no surprise we see many times at the monastery, people who have done the best predictor of success at Sera Je is having been very successful in one’s professional activities in America or Europe or Australia. Know?

It’s not as much different, isn’t it? No, because the personality is the same, the goals are different. Right? What I would suggest to you, Sheng, is basically: You know where you are at present. Stretch the envelope a bit, but not too much.

So where you are at present is, you know, you are successful, reasonably successful in mundane affairs. You have accomplished your mundane goals. And the question should be, okay, you’re preparing your old age as everyone is, you have a family, but beyond this life, what is there? And then what do we what can you do about it? How do you change your outlook to accommodate that?

That doesn’t mean that you turn away on this life completely. You need a financial foundation, but you stretch the envelope. If you stretch too much, it will break. So you stretch to include future lives. And then, at that point, one must live karmically, live in terms of karma and causality.

And that’s very difficult. It’s not easy. It’s one thing to talk about karma and causality. It’s very different to actually put in practice those teachings. And then stretch that envelope, and eventually, you know, one can hope to become a practitioner on the path of the being of the middling scope.

This is this is why these paths were taught. Otherwise, it doesn’t work. Then I’m afraid we have to stop here. Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
anatman dagme (Tib)
No-self; as opposed to atman (self); the term used for selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
atman dag (Tib)
Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
four seals
The four basic tenets that define Buddhism. They are: all compositional phenomena are impermanent, all contaminated phenomena are by nature suffering, all phenomena are empty of self-existence and nirvana is true peace. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Mahamudra chag ya chen po (Tib)
The Great Seal; a profound system of meditation upon the mind and the ultimate nature of reality. LYWA
pandita khäpa (Tib)
Scholar; learned person. Often referred to as pandit, (without the final a), which is the Hindi pronunciation of the Sanskrit. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

How is analytical meditation different from ordinary thinking, or from wisdom arisen from thinking?

Analytical meditation is a wisdom arisen from thinking. It differs from general thinking in two ways: it is a virtuous mind focused on an object, and the mind is not allowed to be distracted or wander around the topic. It is basically structured, directed thinking. Minds well trained in rigorous disciplines such as mathematics tend to become good analytical meditators. In Lamrim practice, one analyzes a topic, such as the uncertainty of the time of death, with logic, examples and personal experience. When a strong sense arises, one stops analyzing and holds it in concentration meditation, returning to analysis when the sense fades.

Is analytical meditation a formal meditation, and how is it different from reading and studying?

Analytical meditation is meditation, because it is the preliminary to insight meditation, which is clearly meditation. Sitting at home with many books and focusing and analyzing is study, not meditation. Westerners are very uncomfortable with the idea of analytical meditation, and this has been a problem in transmitting Buddhism to the West from the start. Analytical meditation is when you read a section, for example on liberation in the palm of your hand, then stop reading, which is a separate activity, and focus on the meaning, trying to understand it exactly. There is nothing more to it than that.

How should we set a realistic goal in our Buddhist practice?

Setting a Buddhist goal works like setting a worldly one: without a clear aim, "we go absolutely nowhere if we waffle around." Start by asking why you are interested in Buddhism and what you want. If you only want mental peace, that is all you will gain. Asking the question of death moves things beyond this life. Explore your own religious tradition first, then tell apart the Indian traditions that teach a soul from Buddhism, which teaches no self. Then see where you are now. For most people the goal is the path of the being of the small scope, perhaps later the medium scope.

Scroll to Top