46 min · 2,814 words · 30 March 1989
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues the study of the fifty-one mental factors, covering the four changeable factors: sleep, contrition, investigation and analysis. The talk explains how each takes its positive, negative or neutral nature from the motivation and the preceding state of mind, and urges that understanding be put into practice to subdue the afflictive emotions. It closes with a brief question on the difference between investigation and analysis, followed by a few exchanges.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1989-03-30
Duration: 47 min
UUID: 2de54757-a927-4864-8ff7-16d23e6f3c19
Words: 2,810
So we should adjust our motivation to develop the kind heart by which to listen to this teaching under the profound great vehicle as a means to put into practice the means of attaining perfect Buddhahood whereby to be enabled to place all sentient beings in complete and perfect bliss and peace. So we have been explaining the fifty one secondary mental factors according to the tradition of Asaṇga. We have completed the five omnipresent factors, the five object determining factors, eleven virtuous factors, the six root afflictions, the twenty secondary afflictions. Now we’re going to complete the fifty one by discussing the four changeable factors. So previous to this, when we discussed the constructive states mental factors, then these were always constructive no matter when they arose.
On the other hand, the afflictions are always negative no matter what times they might arise. They always have this character. But here in discussing the four changeable factors, they are said to be changeable because at times these factors are positive, at times they’re negative, and at sometimes they’re neutral depending upon when they arise. So the first of these four changeable factors is the mental factor of sleep and this is what we experience every night. So while we are still awake just before sleep, if we have a positive state, a positive thought in our mind such as faith or compassion, love, these positive qualities, then the sleep which is as a continuation of that positive state will be by its nature positive.
So whatever types of constructive or wholesome states of mind that we fall asleep with, then that will bring about the that our sleep will be a positive state in itself. On the other hand, if we were to fall asleep with a destructive state as preceding your last waking moments, as preceding sleep, your last waking moments being destructive, such as attachment or hatred or pride, non faith, and all the various afflictions that we do afflictive mental factors that we discussed, then the sleep would by its nature become negative. On the other hand, if the last waking state was neither constructive or destructive, neither negative nor positive, but was unspecified, let’s say neutral, then the sleep would have the character of being neutral. So, you know, considering the fact that the sleep will take on the character of the immediately preceding awakened state of consciousness. If it’s positive, you know, through thoughts of love and compassion and awakening heart, faith, and the sleep will be by its nature positive.
On the other hand, the immediately preceding waking state was negative, and if sleep is negative, it changes. If it’s unspecified and neutral, then the sleeping state becomes unspecified and neutral, then it’s necessary that we try to fall asleep in with positive states in mind. So this is the reason it’s called changeable because the nature of sleep changes in accordance with the preceding awakened state. So the second of these four changeable mental factors is contrition or sometimes referred to as regret. Contrition or regret.
So in this second changeable mental factor contrition, according to the tradition of Vasubandhu, there are only two possibilities. Either it must be constructive or destructive, positive or negative. There’s no unspecified or neutral. But in tradition of a Sangha, there are all three possibilities, positive, negative, and neutral. So the first of these three possibilities when the contrition would be a positive mental factor would be upon either oneself or ordering another person to do some kind of negative activity, destructive activity such as stealing, and after having committed oneself or ordered someone else to commit it, think, Ah, that was wrong thing to do.
And thinking this in developing this regret or this contrition, then since the activity was negative, then the regret would be a positive, would be a wholesome or constructive mental factor. So as we talked about before, when one is acknowledging a negativity, is confessing the negativity created in the past and making use of the four powers, the first of the four, you know, sets of the powers of recollection, reliance, antidote and reverse. The first of these is recollection and this makes use of contrition that we’re regretting and saying, Ah, that was wrong. I’m wishing I hadn’t done that. And developing this regret is the positive quality of contrition.
It enables to destroy or lessen the potency of the action, the power of the action. So by enacting this positive factor of contrition, though we have committed a negative action and it’s finished, it has the quality of being able to lessen the power of that negative action that we’ve created. On the other hand, if we were, for example, developed through the motivation of compassion or altruism that we engage in a practice of giving generosity. And for example, we might give somebody a hundred dollars. And after having given that a hundred dollars, because the motivation was positive, then the action would be positive, this generosity, this giving.
But I gave him too much money. I don’t have enough money for myself. And we develop a sense of regret at having given, then this mental factor of contrition or regret would be negative since we’re regretting something which is a positive action. So we can carry this example to we can apply it to various possibilities. Whatever positive activity that we engage in and then upon having completed it, we with, Ah, that wasn’t a good thing to do.
Having developing regret, then this regret or contrition is a negative mental factor and it lessens the potency or the power of the latency of that positive action that we created. On the other hand, if having created a positive action and upon completing the positive action, were to rejoice. We not only do not regret that action, but we rejoice in it. And this would increase the potency of that positive power of that action. So the third possibility is that if we were to maybe doodle, make some doodles on the wall, on paper and with, you know, the then upon having doodled, made these marks without any specific motivation, just passing the time, we thought, I shouldn’t have marked up the wall that way, or I shouldn’t have marked up the paper that way.
Since the action itself was unspecified and neutral, then even though we developed this mental factor of contrition or regret, it is by its nature unspecified and neutral. So the third changeable mental factor is investigation. In Tibetan it doesn’t show up in the translation, but Tibetan it’s the same word, is being used as in Tibetan word is and this means it also translates as conception. Generally it’s translated as conception when we study awareness and knowledge. The same exact word is usually translated conception, meaning the determinant of consciousness which apprehends the suitability to associate a meaning generality and a sound generality, conception.
But here it is not used in that way at all. It means investigation. And this is both in the tradition of Vasubandhu and tradition of Sangha. And investigation is the engaging in the object the mode of engaging the object apprehending only its rough characteristics. So so if we were similar to we say, well, you know, we’re talking about what is Buddha, and somebody said, well, that this is Buddha, And they would point to a statue and you would get a a rough impression that that the Buddha was a you know, had these these various characteristics which appear to your eye consciousness.
This would be this is a fact a factor of wisdom, you know, which is understands the object in a very coarse and gross way. So this is a factor of wisdom which apprehends its object in a very rough way, you know, using the example of the Buddha, just seeing the Buddha and seeing his general shape and but if we were just seeing its general characteristics, if we will begin to investigate looking what, you know, what its eyes and its ears and where its nose was and all the various features of the Buddha, that is to say in more detail, then it’s no longer investigation, we call that analysis, which is the fourth of these changeable mental factors. The difference between investigation and analysis is that they are both factors of wisdom, but one simply takes to understand, apprehends the coarse aspects of its object whereas analysis understands the details of its object of apprehension. So now we can exemplify the difference between investigation and analysis. If we were going to town to buy something and we had something in mind, we were just walking along looking, searching in the windows, searching along the in the stores and we that which we were going to be we want to buy.
So we just see it just its mere appearance. It’s sitting over there on a counter on a shelf. So that is investigation. But we don’t buy it right away. We want to check it out.
See what its quality is. You know what we might if we’re buying flowers, know, we we smell it. You know where we are if it’s food we taste it or what we examine it very closely to see what this is the right one we want to buy. So the first is just searching out and we find the object and then that’s investigation and then we then we make a real careful examination to see if it’s the right quality for us and this would be the factor of analysis. So we taste it with our mouth and smell it with our nose.
So if if, the object of observation, of investigation or analysis is is constructive, is positive, such as, you know, if we were observing emptiness or paths or liberation, any type of constructive object, then the investigate the mental factor of investigation and analysis would be by their nature positive or constructive. On the other hand, if the object were were negative, that was an object which So if we were to take a particular object as a a object of observation motivated by positive motivation, the object would be of a positive nature. And then we would by investigating and analyzing the mental factor would be positive. If on the other hand, if we’re motivated for example by desire and taking an object as our object of observation, a particular object, and then we were to carry out an investigation and analysis upon it, then these two mental factors would be by their nature negative. So the changeability of these two mental factors is dependent upon the motivation due to which we engage in the object, and then the mental application of how we engage in that object.
For example, with positive motivation, taking positive and having the thought that this object is to be abandoned or this object is to be cultivated, that is the positive type of mental application, then the investigating and analyzing the object, these mental factors would be positive. On the other hand, if by motivated by desire and then applying ourselves to appropriate that object as a mental application, then the observe investigating and analyzing the the object, these mental factors would be come would change into negative by nature. And likewise, the third possibility, if our motivation is unspecified, that is to say neutral, and then the object which is taken as an object of observation and investigated and analyzed these mental factors. Investigation and analysis would be unspecified by their nature or neutral. So these three possibilities.
If having positive motivation, taking a positive object, then any type of analysis and investigation would be by its nature positive. If our motivation is negative and the object is negative, then our investigation analysis would have the nature of negativity. And then if we had motivation as unspecified, the object is unspecified, then the investigation and analysis would be unspecified by nature. So these factors are extremely important in the sense that their quality, their nature is determined by the way in which we’re thinking, whether they’re going to be positive or negative. If we whether we’re awake or whether we sleep, if they’re induced by positive motivation and positive thoughts, and they’re positive.
If they’re induced by negative thoughts, negative motivation, then negative. So there’s in fact, in those who are practicing, can see that since we engage in these actions all the time, these mental factors are rising then we have to be be it’s important what types of thought that that depend upon which they arise whether they’re negative or positive. So as we you know, it was mentioned during the retreat this past weekend that, you know, in Tsongkhapa when talking about the Dharma and the the the mode of the way in which to be practiced is that first we seek to listen to the teachings, and it’s necessary to listen to the teachings in order to The benefit of listening to the teachings is that we come to an understanding of the teachings, that we understand what is to be adopted and what is to be rejected. But what is the necessity for coming to an understanding? It’s in order to practice.
That if we don’t practice, then it’s the same as if we didn’t know. There’s no difference. Know, people who are going to in the future be reborn in a bad migration, it’s simply not people who don’t know the Dharma. There’s no difference between someone who doesn’t know the Dharma and someone who knows it and doesn’t practice it. They’re both in the same situation with respect to going to a bad migration.
So, you know, we’ve we’ve finished our discussion of awareness and knowledge. And this subject is extremely important that, you know, the Buddha you know, we talked about the the practice of Buddhism. Buddhism is is involved the place of practice is in one within one’s own mind. So it’s nest that therefore understanding how our mind is operating is extremely useful. It it helps us in whatever the level of our practice might be, whatever great states we may seek to attain it, and understanding the nature of the mind, and it’s going to be a great benefit.
So what we have learned, should not forget. Try to understand it, and whatever you do understand, no matter how much it might be, to put it into practice. So whatever the Buddha taught, whether it’s whatever the teachings are, whether they’re the actual discourses of the Buddha, whether the commentaries, the thoughts of the Buddha, they’re all meant as a means of subduing the mind. That that if they don’t subdue the mind then they don’t become Dharma. And what do we you know, they’re all the teachings are meant to be a method of subduing the mind.
And what do we mean by subduing the mind? That is the elimination of the afflictive emotions within the mind. If our the practice involves the gradual elimination of the afflictive emotions from the mind and the increase of constructive states, if in fact no matter what we may study and if it doesn’t go towards lessening our afflictive emotions and and and we don’t gradually develop more and more constructive states of mind, then it isn’t becoming a practice of Dharma. So we we finished discussion of awareness and knowledge. And as we did in the the final discussion of opening the eye of new awareness, now we won’t.
So if you have any questions or doubts that you might like to clear up some kind of qualms, so we can take those first. If you don’t, then Rinpoche will ask questions. Oh, I’m sorry. So you would so you would take particular object to mind, perform analysis, investigation, and then is there another Yeah. Step after that?
That would be positive. So if we were to take an example, we take emptiness as our object of observation. We perform first we perform an investigation, then we begin to perform analysis. So we’re performing analysis emptiness. At the same time we couple this with a calm abiding, this single point of concentration.
Then as we proceed in our investigation, then this mind would turn into special insight. We proceed with our investigation more and more, and then we would be able to develop the power through this investigation of proceeding along all the various paths and stages throughout the path and finally completing Buddhahood in dependence upon this investigation. Now, I’m not interested in I’m sorry. Analysis. Analysis is defined.
Analysis. So if there’s no questions on awareness and knowledge then we can take other questions.
Key terms in this teaching
- changeable mental factors anyathabhava-chaitta (Skt); zhen gyur sem jung (Tib)
- One of the six groups of mental factors, these are factors that can be virtuous, nonvirtuous or neutral depending on one's motivation and the specific situation. There are four: sleep, contrition, investigation and analysis. LYWA
- four powers
- The four types of attainments often described in tantric initiations. They are: pacification (of delusions), increase (of realizations), control (of whatever needs controlling) and subduing (of negative forces). LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
After taking an object to mind and performing investigation and analysis, what is the next step in developing special insight?
Taking emptiness as the object of observation, one first performs investigation and then begins to analyse emptiness. At the same time, this is coupled with calm abiding, a single-pointed concentration. As the investigation proceeds further, the mind turns into special insight. Continuing the investigation more and more develops the power to proceed along all the various paths and stages, and finally to complete Buddhahood in dependence upon this investigation.