46 min · 2,485 words · 23 February 1989
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a Study of the Mind session on the eleven constructive mental factors, covering effort, pliancy, conscientiousness, equanimity and non-harmfulness. The speaker explains each factor’s nature and function, using the analogies of a corpse without wisdom and water that takes on whatever is put into it. The talk links these factors to abandoning the afflictive emotions of attachment, anger and ignorance.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1989-02-23
Duration: 47 min
UUID: d159b512-c67a-43a8-a54d-35388f9eceaa
Words: 2,481
So we should adjust our motivation such that in order to attain Buddhahood, whereby to assist all sentient beings to place them in the complete and perfect bliss and happiness of Buddhahood, that it’s necessary to engage in listening to the teachings on the great vehicle. And therefore, with such a motivation that I’m going to listen to these teachings. So within the context of the discussion of awareness and knowledge, we’re discussing the section on mind and mental factors. And within that, within the various types of mental factors, there are constructive and destructive types of mental factors. And now we’re reviewing the eleven constructive mental factors.
So in dependence upon constructive mental factors, we experience happiness. So I made a mistake. We’re discussing constructive mental factors, and we’ve we’ve reached up to amongst the eleventh effort, this which is the seventh. Śāntideva defines the mental factor of effort as a mental factor which is joyously intent upon engaging in constructive actions, or finds joy in partaking, engaging in constructive actions. Constructive actions, you know, for example, meditating, doing prostrations, all various types of constructive action in mind, mental factor which takes joy in such types of actions, is what is known as effort.
For example, when we do Guru Puja, or offerings to the spiritual master here, then, you know, when one comes in and finds it to be a very happy experience, finds it coming together in this way to be a joyful experience and one makes a lot of finds the activity of chanting and meditating in this way as being a happy experience, then this is the sign that this mental factor of effort is being applied. So, you know, when we talk about the various activities in applying to the specific case of listening to a teaching on the Dharma, a mind which finds a great deal of happiness in listening to the Dharma, which thinks, I really find this very interesting. I find it a wonderful experience to be listening to such teachings. If we just extend this to all types of constructive actions, a mind which thinks that it’s a happy experience to be in the various types of constructive action. So it’s so set your mind as effort Effort, and within the context of these eleven constructive mental factors, is a happy mind, a joyous mind.
It’s laughing. It’s happy. It’s not like it’s engaging in something which it finds extremely difficult. It’s not having a black face. There are many people who like, enjoy engaging in destructive types of actions, unskillful types of actions, they go to a lot of trouble, make a great deal of difficulty for themselves, engaging in destructive actions.
We would not term this as effort. Effort is always the mind which is finding happiness, but only in constructive types of activities. So what is the function of effort? What is its action or function? As Śāntideva says, With effort there is nothing which cannot be accomplished.
What he means to say here is that effort has the function whereby we are able to attain any constructive goal that we seek. It’s because the reason that we don’t achieve our constructive goals is simply that we have the mental factor of effort present. It only applies to constructive types of goals. Therefore, effort has the function of enabling us to achieve constructive goals. It says within the text, Entering Into the Middle Way, that by the means of effort all the various constructive goals will be accomplished.
And it goes on to explain that no matter what types of constructive goals that we might set for ourselves, that for example, whether it’s simply an immediate type of constructive goal, such as the two accumulations of positive potential and wisdom, or whether it’s liberation or Buddhahood, there’s nothing which cannot be attained through the application of effort. But then on the other hand, though we might have wisdom, if we do not have the mental factor of effort, then it’s as if we were a corpse. You know, a corpse is not able to accomplish anything, any type of activity, even though it might and likewise, even though we might have wisdom, if we do not apply the mental factor of effort, we’re never going to accomplish anything. So the the ultimate function of effort is the fulfillment of our of our spiritual activities. Without the the mental factor of effort, we will accomplish nothing.
With it, all our spiritual efforts can come to culmination. So we have to be mindful. Keep in mind this fact that effort is extremely important. No matter what we might do, if we do not in the way of spiritual activities, the positive types of engagement activities, If we do not make effort, then we’re never going to accomplish anything. So the next mental factor, the eleven constructive or skillful mental factors, is the eighth, which is pliancy.
As we were discussing in Tuesday nights, this teaching on calm abiding, there were two types of pliancies, mental and physical. Here we’re talking specifically about mental pliancy. The factor of pliancy has the effect it’s a mental factor which has the effect of enabling the mind to engage and to remain on any type of constructive object that it wishes. No matter what the activity might be, we’re, for example, engaging in meditation, we’re doing prostrations, whether we’re doing the Guru Puja, the offerings to the spiritual master, that we can direct the mind in any direction that we desire, that it whenever we desire, and for however long we desire toward any type of object that we desire. And this is the factor of pliancy.
It’s like a flexibility. So this this ability, which is like a of the mind, you know, it’s like into a flexibility or pliancy — that’s what the word indicates. It’s the opposite of rigidity or a toughness, inflexibility of the mind. Know, whatever we wish, for example, if we wanted to meditate on compassion, the mind would quite naturally engage in that object for as long as we wanted, or whether we wanted to meditate on love, we wanted to meditate on emptiness. We simply, wherever we direct our mind, it flows in that direction for however long as we want and remains there as long as we want toward any type of object that we desire.
So pliancy has the function of eliminating all discordant factors. It has the function of eliminating all discordant factors which interrupt the intentionality of the mind. In our practice, it aids us in being able to abandon, apply the antidotes, and preventing the interruptions of all discordant factors. So it has this function of eliminating, causing us, alleviating and abandoning, applying antidotes, eliminating all discordant factors such as false abandonments, false obscurations. And interruptions.
So it’s extremely important mental factor in developing the the excellent qualities of the mind. Then the ninth of the eleven constructive mental factors is conscientiousness. Conscientiousness. Conscientiousness is which has a nature of guarding the mind from contaminated engage from engaging in the contaminated actions, maybe guarding the mind against engaging in unskillful actions such as guarding the mind against engaging in unskillful actions such as harmfulness such as harming, hurting, desire. So the effect of conscientiousness has the nature of guarding the mind against an engagement in the unskillful actions such as harming, hurting, desire, and influencing the mind toward constructive actions and influences the mind to move toward constructive actions.
This factor of conscientiousness guards or prevents one from engaging in such types of unskillful actions such as harm, harming others, hurting others, desire, and influences one to move in the direction of engaging in positive actions and increasing positive mental states. Increasing the yeah. Positive mental states. Engaging in positive mental actions and increasing positive states. So it’s conscientiousness which would prevent us from, for example, if we had the intention to hurt someone, we would say, Oh, shouldn’t do that.
It’s a If I were to do that action, I would hurt them, this would be very unkind to me. Or if I were going to steal something, prevents you from going ahead and stealing, thinking that such a type of activity would bring harm to another person, it would be unkind to the other person. Therefore, having the intention to engage in some unskillful action, it prevents you or guards you from actually carrying that out. On the other hand, it influences you to act in a positive manner toward others. Conscientiousness has a function of acting as the basis or the cause for bringing to us complete happiness of all the various good things.
So these mental factors that we’ve covered are extremely important to our practice. Without such types of mental factors, there’s no way that we can really develop ourselves spiritually. For example, various factors that we’ve covered such as self shame, embarrassment, conscientiousness, which help us to purify any type of negativities that we’ve created, that we have can actually, in dependence upon these, develop regret and therefore engage in activities like confession and also the mental factor of effort. Without these, then there’s no way that we can really progress in our practice. So these various constructive mental factors are, you know, are are very necessary to our practice.
Without them there’s no way that we can really develop ourselves. You know, we’re very much, to some degree, in a struggle with the negative aspects of our own mind. It’s as if, you know, in traveling a path in Tibet, for example, that used to be the case when traveling the roads in Tibet there was a lot of danger involved. There were a lot of obstacles. There were a lot of hindrances, you know, both natural but also man made such as, you know, people trying to There were bandits, there were thieves, there were robbers.
And they were all trying you know, take away your possessions and they would prevent you from getting to your destination safely. Likewise, in traveling the spiritual path, in our journey we have a lot of hindrances. We have a lot of factors within our own mind which must be overcome, such as the various afflictive emotions. In order to prevent them from creating an obstacle to our spiritual development, we have to make use of various antidotes. And the only way that we’re going to actually implement these antidotes is if we have these positive mental factors in our mind, you know, such as self shame, embarrassment, effort, conscientiousness, and dependence upon these mental factors, then we can overcome the afflictive emotions and travel our paths with that developing on spiritual journey.
So It’s a matter of decreasing the factors within our mind and decreasing those negative factors. You know, our mind, due to prior habituation, we naturally develop afflictive emotions in various mental states. And so we have to actually make effort in applying the various antidotes. As one negative mental state, afflictive emotion arises, we apply an antidote, and that no longer is a hindrance to us. Again, an afflictive emotion arises and again we apply an antidote and this particular afflictive emotion can no longer harm us.
And this way the destructive tendencies within our mind decrease and the constructive positive influences begin to increase in the mind. This is the way we develop in the dharma. So the tenth of the eleven constructive mental factors is equanimity. And, you know, just in general, there are various types of equanimity. There’s, for example, feelings of equanimity, non discrimination equanimity.
There’s various categories. But, in general, if we talk about the various types of afflictive emotions first, There are said to be eighty four thousand afflictive emotions, but of these eighty four thousand, there are three root afflictive emotions. So the three root afflictive emotions are attachment, anger, and ignorance. So in this in the context of the the eleven constructive mental factors, when we when we mention talk about equanimity, we’re talking about a mental factor which causes the mind to not enter into either of these three root afflictions, but on the contrary causes the mind to abide in a constructive state. So it is the mental factor of equanimity, equanimity, equanimity, which prevents us from entering into the three root afflictions, and on the other hand causes us to make effort in the productive and engaging in productive states of mind.
So equanimity has the function of preventing the mind from entering into these negative states and increasing positive states. The eleventh constructive mental state mental factor is non harmfulness. Non harmfulness. This is a mental factor which lacks any intention to do harm, but on the contrary, regards the object with affection, wishes to separate it from suffering. It’s a mental factor which lacks an intention to do harm, but on the contrary, regards the object with affection and wishes to separate it from suffering.
Is non harmfulness. So obviously, non harmfulness is very much associated with the qualities of love and compassion. This quality of affection wishing to separate sentient beings from suffering. So this mental factor of non harmfulness is simply not the lack of intention to harm others. It is that but something more.
There is a positive factor associated with it, which is affection. That is, not only do we not wish to harm others, but we cannot remain indifferent to them. That, in fact, we seek to benefit them and do whatever we can aid them. So it’s lack of harmful intention, but it also has the positive aspect of it, which does not allow us to remain indifferent, but in actuality to do whatever will be of benefit to them. Our mind can compared to a substance like water in the fact that it can take on whatever substance we might put in the water.
If we put something sweet in the water, we have sweet water. If we put medicine in the water, we have medicinal water. If we put medicine in water, that water is not harmful, but in fact, if we drink it, it’s beneficial. So it’s just if we were to you know, just like fruit juice, you know, if we It’s water in which there’s various nutritional elements. It’s very delicious tasting.
So if we drink this fruit juice, then it’s going to prevent us from getting sick. We’re going to have good health. We enjoy it. It makes us happy. Just by putting all these in water, then it has all these beneficial qualities.
Likewise, our mind is compared to this water, which is neutral substance. Whatever we put in our mind, we will have an according experience if we develop and associate our mind with positive mental
Key terms in this teaching
- Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
- A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
- The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
- puja chö pa (Tib)
- Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- two accumulations sambharadvaya (Skt); tsog nyi (Tib)
- Also called the two collections or two types of merit, they are: the merit of virtue, which develops the method side of the path by practicing generosity and so forth, and the merit of (transcendental) wisdom... LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.