46 min · 2,917 words · 9 March 1989
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk continues the explanation of the six root afflictions, completing the five afflicted views: the view of the transitory collection, the view of extremes, perverse view, holding bad views as supreme, and holding bad ethics and conduct as supreme. It explains that ignorance grasping at a truly existent self drives cyclic existence, with emptiness realization as its antidote. It then begins the twenty secondary afflictions, covering belligerence, resentment, concealment, spite and jealousy.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1989-03-09
Duration: 47 min
UUID: 2839d5ab-3000-4d3c-9b7a-9a2a6cb60eac
Words: 2,913
Happiness and peace. So amongst the various minds and mental factors, we’ve completed the explanation of the eleven constructive mental states which are induced productive consequences. And we have begun the the explanation of the six root afflictions and of those six we’ve completed five. So in speaking about view, there are various types of views. There are there are negative and positive types of views.
For example, a positive type of view would be the view which is the realization of emptiness. And generally we talk about the positive states are those which are constructive, having as a result happiness. And negative and negative states are those who are having a consequence a result of suffering. And here when we talk about view we’re talking about afflicted views that is negative negative states of mind which will have as a result unhappiness. So when we talk about the view of the realization of emptiness, we’re talking about the middle way view.
And the reason it’s designated as middle way is because it takes the middle between the two possible extreme views of the nature of existence. That is the view of permanence and the view of annihilation. So the as we’ve mentioned there, the various types of views. The views of the of the ordinary person conceiving of the of the of worldly types of views. And and generally when we talk about view, we’re talking about the view understanding that from positive states comes happiness and negative from negative states of mind comes unhappiness.
So for us this particular view is of greatest importance that, we must, come to a firm conviction in this view that and begin to cultivate those positive states which are going to bring us happiness and as much as possible begin to abandon those possible negative states which are going to bring us unhappiness. So without coming to a thorough thorough acceptance of this view, the the negative states bring unhappiness, positive states bring happiness, then we really will not engage sincerely in the cultivation of productive states of mind and the elimination of destructive states of mind. Now in this in this context of the the six root afflictions, when we discuss view, there are five views. And these are called afflictive views because these are destructive states of mind which will bring as a consequence suffering. So according to the system of Vasubandhu, there are the five afflicted views and these are all to be abandoned.
And the five afflicted views are first the view of the transitory collection, the second is the view of the extremes, the third is perverse view, the fourth is conception of a bad view as supreme, conception of a bad view as supreme, and the fifth is the fifth is bad ethics and modes of conduct. Holding the the conception holding bad ethics and modes of conduct as supreme. That looks that sounds — Shippa? Let’s see. The first the first is the view of the the view of the transitory collection.
And then the view Then the second is the view holding to the to an extreme. The third is perverse view. The fourth is conception of a bad view as supreme. And the fifth is conception of bad ethics and modes of conduct as supreme. The five afflicted views.
So the the definition of the first, the view of the transitory collection is observing I or mind, grasping the conception grasping at the object of observation I or mind as naturally existent as a naturally existent I or mind. The conception observing I or mind and conceiving and holding and grasping at that I or mind to be naturally existent is the definition of the view of the transitory collection. So this is an afflicted wisdom, which is holding a wrong conception and the I which is being observed is the I within one’s own continuum. It’s not the I of something outside of yourself. It is it’s the I is within your own continuum and the mind is holding for example my arms, my head, and observing this I or this mind, conceiving of it to be truly existent and by truly, naturally existent.
And here we’re talking from the point of view of the middle way, Consequentialist school, since they hold that nothing exists as naturally existent. So this is the this is ignorance conceiving the self of persons. So this this acts as the the root ignorance acts as the root motivating force for all types of actions or karma both negative and positive which lead to a perpetuation of cyclic existence. So the the ignorance conceiving of the self of persons is the root of cyclic existence since it’s due to to, this ignorance that we engage in actions and due to engaging in these actions we, perpetuate cyclic existence, due to the force of karma or these actions. Therefore, that is this which is the creator of cyclic existence.
By realizing emptiness we can completely eliminate ignorance, but without realizing emptiness there’s no way it can ever be eliminated. So this is the factor that is ignorance, which keeps this spinning and cyclic existence due to it we engage in all the various types of karma no matter whether it’s constructive or destructive karma. Through constructive karma we simply take rebirth in a happy migration and in dependence upon, destructive karma we take rebirth in a bad migration but, all of these are still within cyclic existence. So the antidote to ignorance is the realization of emptiness. It’s the realization of emptiness, the understanding of emptiness, that is the way that things actually exist, the way that phenomena actually abide, which is in contradiction to the wrong conception that ignorance is.
Ignorance is a wrong conception. And so as our realization of emptiness increases in strength it naturally decreases the contradictory side that is the wrong conception and that begins to decrease in its power. But initially because our our wrong conception that is ignorance is so powerful it’s difficult for us to develop in in the beginning the understanding of emptiness. So the second of the five views is the view holding to an extreme. And the two extremes are the extremes of existence and nonexistence.
Existence and non existence. What what these mean to say is that at the time of death that there is a permanent self which continues on. So that’s therefore there’s the the conception of a permanent self which is unchanging, un deteriorating, which is not changing, which continues on with as a permanent self, conceiving of a permanence of of the self. It has the view of the holding to the extremes takes as object of observation the same object as was in the case of the view of the transitory collection, one in one’s own continuum, the I or mind. The first holds that this is conceived as permanent, that unchanging, it continues on after death without any change.
The second holds that is the view of annihilation. That means that nothing at the at the moment of death and itself becomes non existent. That the self is annihilated. It comes to an end. It no longer exists.
So, there are there is two extremes. The extreme of conceiving of a permanent self and extreme conceiving of the annihilation of the self at death. So both of these are wrong conceptions. At the the time of one of them holds that we become non existent, that we’re annihilated at the time of death. We do we do in fact die, but the there is a continuum of the self or the I which goes on after death.
So there is not the annihilation of of the continuum of the I or the or the mind. With respect to the the the self which the view which conceives itself as being permanent and unchanging, the the self is in fact constantly changing. It is impermanent in the sense that it’s continually, arising, abiding, and ceasing moment by moment. It’s continually going through a flux and therefore there is no, permanent I. This is the view of of the conception of the view the extreme of annihilation.
Annihilation was held by the Chinese — by Ho-shang Moheyan — that is the fact that they they held it when you when you die then you’re finished. You’re you’re no longer exist. So the third wrong the third afflicted view is perverse view. And this is These are the various types of wrong conceptions as to something which in fact exists but is conceived to be nonexistent. For example, that from positive actions happiness results that this in fact is not the case.
That from positive actions there is no happiness. That from negative actions as a result there is no suffering, or holding the non existence of past and future lives. Holding the non existence of the Three Jewels. Holding the nonexistence of liberation. These these are all wrong wrong consciousnesses and perverse views.
So the Chinese held these very strongly, these views. And the fourth afflicted view was the conception of bad views — of a bad view as supreme. And this refers to taking the first three of the five views as objects of observation and thinking how how good these views are that that that the in fact holding these supreme views for for example holding that the future past and future lives do not exist that the law of cause and effect does not in fact exist that and holding thinking that this is a really the best view and holding conceiving that in that way. So the Chinese also held to the conception of Bad Views as Supreme.
They would when they originally came to Tibet they said you know, where where are where you know you believe in are these past and future lives that you believe in? Where is the results of your your positive karma that you’ve created? We don’t see we don’t see them. You know, you you go to refuge you expect the Buddha to to protect you but they don’t they don’t give you any food and you know, if we take your house away how are they going to help you? And so they held to this conception and the bad views as being supreme.
So then the fifth of five afflictive views is bad ethics and modes of conduct. Conceiving as the holding to the bad ethics and modes of conduct. Conception of bad ethics and modes of conduct is supreme and this would so this entails bad types of ethics. For example, under the influence of bad ethics physically killing others conceiving this as a method for progressing along the path for finding liberation, not speaking under the influence of bad views. Now of course it could be If you were under the influence of a good view, then not speaking would be a be a positive form of ethics if it was under the influence of a of a good view.
But in this case, we’re talking about not speaking under the influence of bad views that, you know, this you quit speaking altogether. So these are are bad ethics since they are restraints that you place upon upon oneself, some type of vow, vowing to kill or vowing not to speak under the influence of bad views. And and then the modes of conduct. For example, there was one tradition which held it by jumping off a cliff and onto rocks that this was a way of attaining liberation. Such a system of bad such a bad system that that following a this kind of conduct in a under the influence of of a bad system and thinking that this is great, this is a good system, this is the way to attain liberation.
This would be the example of the fifth type of afflicted view, conception of bad ethics and modes of conduct as supreme. So these are afflicted views. They only create negative karma. They are to be abandoned. They are of no benefit whatsoever.
They can only bring suffering. So under under the under the the reason they’re called afflictive views because under the under the influence of these views that no good can come out of the of the actions motivated by these views but only suffering will arise. Because these these views are not in accordance with the actual nature of reality, they are they are wrong views. They are wrong conceptions about the nature of reality. And therefore and acting in accordance with them one will create negative actions and therefore only suffering can arise and therefore all these views are to be abandoned.
So before I’ve said that before the the Buddha Śākyamūni was born into the world that there were sixty four bad views, wrong, bad views. But we won’t go into the sixty four bad views. It’s difficult. So that finishes the explanation of the six root afflictions. So the reason they’re called root afflictions is because they are the principal factors afflicting the mind.
Therefore they are called root afflictions. Then the root afflictions are like the roots of a tree giving growth to the twenty secondary afflictions. Now the reason they’re called secondary afflictions, sometimes called proximate afflictions, is because, they afflict the mind but they arise in dependence upon the root afflictions. Therefore, they’re secondary to the root afflictions. They rely in dependence upon root affliction.
So there are twenty secondary afflictions. So the first of the twenty secondary afflictions is belligerence. Belligerence. So, belligerence arises in dependence upon the the root affliction of anger. If for example someone were to speak some harsh words to us, initially we would become angry and then this would, induce the the secondary affliction of belligerence which which would cause us to pick up a stick and start beating this other person.
So this is a extremely negative state of mind to be in. We can it even can bring about this is what the factor which would cause us to kill another person out of anger, for example. It would be belligerence. So the second of the twenty is resentment. And again, this arises in dependence upon anger.
One has become angry at another person in the past and the factor of resentment does not allow one to forget this but again and again brings it to mind. Causes us to again and again to continue to remember this again and again in such a way that remembering the harm that was committed to us previously and not able to forget it. And holding and keeping it not able to forget the harm that was brought to you by the other, keep remembering again and again deciding on to return this harm that, you know, in the future I’m going to thinking in some way get back to return the harm that was that was brought to you. And it’s by meditating on, for example, love that we’re able to eliminate the effect of resentment. The third, I believe, is concealment.
Concealment. This is hiding a fault. For example, if one had broken one’s moral discipline, had, you know, committed a fault against one’s bodhisattva vows or Tantric vows. And rather than telling another person of the fault that this infringement that you did, that you created, in fact not only not telling it, not exposing it, but hiding it. Hiding it from others that they might not know about it.
And also from the point of view if someone were to come to you and said, Oh, you did such and such. You broke your vow in this way. And not only not telling this person, admitting that that that in fact you did break your vow in this way, but hiding and concealing the fact that you broke your vow, that you committed this fault, this would be the factor of concealment. So then it also applies to worldly situations. For example, during some kind of work, some kind of activity and you make a mistake and someone points out your mistake to you and you say, No, that’s not my fault.
I didn’t make that mistake. And in fact hiding the fact that you made that mistake rather than simply apologizing and admitting your error, this would be the factor of concealment. And the fourth is spite. Spite is similar, has a similar has a connection with the one that is preceding a concealment. And this is the case where we commit some kind of error and someone points it out to us in a reasonable manner but then instead of admitting their fault we react with harshness.
We speak back for example very harshly back to this person telling them to mind their own business. This would be an example of spite. And the fifth is jealousy. Jealousy. So jealousy is the the mental factor which is not able to bear that which not able to bear or dislikes when another has good fortune, has good quality, has good possessions and oneself does not.
So one is not able to bear the good fortune of others, the good qualities of others, the good possessions of others. One does not like them to have these things when you do not. This is the factor of jealousy. Okay?
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
- The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- tantric vows sang ngag kyi dom pa (Tib)
- Vows taken by tantric practitioners. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
- two extremes tha nyi (Tib)
- Eternalism, seeing things as having an intrinsic reality, and nihilism, seeing things as having no reality at all. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.