46 min · 2,656 words · 16 February 1989
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. This session continues the study of mental factors, moving on to the eleven virtuous mental factors set out by Asanga. It explains faith and its three types (clarity, wishing to attain, and conviction in cause and effect), then self-shame and embarrassment as the basis of good character, and nonattachment as the opposite of attachment.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1989-02-16
Duration: 47 min
UUID: a02391d5-8028-41d0-87a9-ed34775e2712
Words: 2,652
So we should set our motivations that we’re going to that we’re seeking to practice in order that in order to do this, that we’re listening to these teachings whereby we’ll be able to establish all sentient beings equal to the extent of space in complete happiness and bliss. So we’re now discussing the text awareness and knowledge. And in this text, we’re discussing division into minds and mental factors. And as set forth by Asaṇga, the fifty one secondary mental factors. And previously we have already completed the first division of the first two divisions of the minds and mental factors.
That is the division two omnipresent mental factors and the determining mental factors. And now we’re going to discuss the eleven virtuous or positive mental factors. So in general, we can divide phenomena into three divisions by way of positive, negative, and neutral. Or rather than neutral, you can say unspecified. Positive, negative, and neutral.
And the way we establish that which is positive is that which has been set forth by the Buddha as saying that this is a negative action. That this is a negative act. Well, in the case of positive. This is a positive action, and its result is favorable or has a positive result. So various types of external phenomena do not the question of positive and negative does not apply to positive and negative or virtuous and non virtuous only applies to sentient beings.
From the point of view that activities of our body, physical activities, verbal activities and mental activities, the Buddha said that certain types of thinking, thoughts for example, mental activities have a pleasure or positive result, and therefore, are called positive activities or virtuous activity. So we talk we can discuss about what is the final or ultimate type of virtue or a positive activity, positive object, and this would be liberation. And this is characterized by the abandonment of all suffering along with the various types of fault and the completion of all types of the accumulation of all types of positive qualities. This factor of of the cessation of of suffering and the accumulation of all the positive qualities is the ultimate virtue or ultimate positive phenomena. So as a means, the method whereby we attain this ultimate virtue is through the the virtues of the the physical virtues, verbal virtues, and mental virtues or positive activity.
Among these three activities of physical, verbal, and mental, the root or the foundation, the main positive activities, mental activity. And by way of categorization of these of the mental positive activities, we here, we’re discussing them in terms of eleven positive states of mind or eleven mental activity. So the first of these eleven positive mental activities, mental state is state. So the the meaning of of faith is that upon observing, one of the three characteristics of positive, excellent qualities or the possessor of excellent of those excellent qualities or the abilities or the the power of those excellent qualities, a a a longing to attain such such one of these three. So there’s upon observing the the the factor of an excellent quality or the possessor of of such an excellent quality or the power or the capacity or the abilities of such an excellent quality, a a longing to attain it, either of these three is what we mean when we say faith.
The meaning of faith. So when we talk about the excellent qualities, there’s some types of excellent qualities as the awakening heart, love, compassion, exalted wisdom, various types of realizations and observing these types of excellent qualities. When we talk about the quality possessors, we’re talking about the various types of beings such as Buddha, Bodhisattvas, superiors, the the the superior spiritual community, etcetera. These types of beings who have who possess these excellent qualities. And then when we talk about the the the power which such qualities possess, their their abilities or potency, we’re telling about the conviction in the law of cause and effect that upon creating a positive action that happiness will follow upon creating negative action, then there will there is a consequence of suffering and that understanding that by abandoning all all the suffering, all the faults, we attain the same excellent qualities of liberation and peace, and then, therefore, developing in joy and seeking to develop these qualities.
So it is said that faith is the root of all excellent qualities. It’s that faith and excellent qualities are analogous to a mother and child. That in dependence upon the mother, there rises mother gives birth to a child and the mother is faith and the child has all the excellent qualities. But even after the child is born, as the child grows up, still the mother is needed to guard and protect the child to nourish it. And likewise, even after the excellent qualities have been born, still we need faith in order to guard, protect, and increase our excellent quality.
Likewise, it is said that without without faith, then there are there is no there is no positive action activities of the dharma. There there can arise no excellent qualities. And This is analogous to if a seed is singed, burnt in a fire, then it loses its potency. It doesn’t have the power to germinate any longer. And likewise, faith without faith, then we do not have the potency or the ability to give rise to excellent quality.
So there’s the the story of Devadatta. One who was a relative of the Buddha. And you know he had only this quality that he was the that he happened to be a relative of the Buddha.
But and he listened to all the Buddhist teachings on the Dharma, but he had no faith in the teaching. And though he listened, he stayed with the Buddha for many many years, listened to all the teachings the Buddha gave, still because he had no faith upon his death, So but if one but if an example of the possibilities when one does have faith is exemplified by a story of a mother whose son went to India on a pilgrimage, and the mother asked him to please bring back some remains of the Buddha. And he he traveled back he traveled to India, and on his way home, come and returning to his home, he remembered that, Oh my mother, she asked me to bring back some remains of the Buddha and I had forgotten and should be very disappointed. So he went and there was a dead dog and he removed the tooth from the dog. And he came home and he said, I brought you back a tooth of the Buddha.
And she had tremendous faith and she revered this tooth with great reverence. And due to her faith, her power of her faith, actually, relics arose. Relics came from this this what was actually a dog’s tooth. So all excellent qualities arise dependent upon faith. And, therefore, amongst the eleven positive states is the is listed first.
Also, Tsongkhapa and his text, the great exposition of the stages of the path, says the foundation of the path is faith. So there are there are three types of faith. There’s faith the faith of clarity, the faith which wishes to attain, and the faith of conviction. Explain these three types of faith, the first is the faith of clarity and this is actually seeing clearly for oneself the excellent qualities of say the Buddha, the Dharma, or the spiritual community understanding those qualities for oneself clearly. The second is the wish to the faith which wishes to attain these and understanding these in dependence upon seeing the qualities clearly for oneself, there develops a longing, desiring to, I wish I could be like that.
I wish I could attain that realization of the faith which seeks to attain the excellent quality which has been seen by the faith of clarity. And the third is the faith of conviction, which is understanding that even from the slightest negative causes that that that there will arise having the consequences of some type of suffering, that from the slightest types of positive actions we are going to experience the consequence of happiness. And, you know, it’s perhaps easy to see that just on a gross level that from very powerful types of causes we negative causes we can suffering, but having the conviction that even the slightest types of negative causes can produce an effect of suffering seen as the subtle qualities of the law of cause and effect, for example, is the faith of conviction. You know, we explained the other night in discussion on calm abiding, how it’s actually generated. For example, in overcoming laziness, first we develop faith.
And in dependence upon developing faith, we go on to develop aspiration, dependence upon effort, dependence upon that So therefore, we can see that in this case, the development of calm abiding is dependent upon the initial development of the generation of faith. In this way, we can see that the attainment of all excellent qualities is initially dependent upon faith. So if we talk about the the the function the function or the action of faith, we can it is exemplified by one jewel which is called clarifying jewel. And if you put this clarifying jewel in cloudy water, it has the ability to to to make the water clear, and therefore, we’re able to see through the water very easily. And likewise, faith has the quality of clarifying for oneself, making clear to oneself.
And and making this clear, we no longer are confused. We no longer have interruptions or problems in attaining, but our our ability of producing productive states of mind is increased through this ability to see our objects clearly. I see that which is these qualities clearly. Therefore, ability to produce continuous productive state is enhanced through this power of faith. So the meaning of faith and clarity is the same.
And when there’s clarity of the mind developed and there’s no disturbance, for example, through distraction, disturbing disturbing effects of afflictive emotions. There’s no fluctuating of the mind because its goal the qualities of its goal are seen very clearly. And therefore, this is quality of clarity with respect to seeing these excellent qualities. Therefore, there’s a similar this meaning between faith and clarity is the same. So the second positive state of these eleven is self shame.
So the the the meaning of of shame or self shame. Perhaps shame is is sufficient. If the that would So the the the the ceasing the ceasing of So the the meaning of shame is that the the ceasing the ceasing of none of the negative negative states of negative actions due to one’s own due to one’s own conscience. The ceasing the what do you say? The fore going?
Yeah. That’s not. Before going of negative actions due to the force of one’s own conscience is the meaning of self shame. So, you know, by way of example, if one were to have the idea to steal something and one went to that place and there was all the things set out to steal, but there there arose there arose yeah. There arose thought, oh, this this is not a good thing to do.
I I really shouldn’t do this. This is a this is a very bad thing to do. They’re due to when the force of one’s conscience, one desist or foregoes in this negative action. And this would be the quality of this state of mind is shame. So the then the function of shame is is desisting as it has the the function of preventing one from engaging in negativity.
Shame is extremely important. If if one has this quality of self shame, this will this will actually prevent one from engaging various types of negative actions. Whereas, if one has no self shame, then one one one quite readily engage in whatever type of action negative action. Quite often identify or come to recognize a person as being of excellent character to this to this one quality of having this self shame. So then the third positive mental factor is embarrassment.
Embarrassment. And this is the avoidance of negative action due to other. The avoidance of negative action due to other. So by by way of example, what we mean by embarrassment is that, for example, if one were had the idea to steal something and one actually went to that place and there were these various articles. And but upon thinking of you, upon the about to act actually take the articles, one thinks about how this would appear to others.
For example, thinking about how this would appear to what how the Buddhas might think of you, how the bodhisattvas might think of you, how maybe your spiritual teacher, your lama, how they would think about your actions, you know, how they they would think if they would look at you very poorly. They would have developed a very poor opinion of you. They would say, oh, very, very bad to steal in this way. They’re thinking about how this action would appear in front of others. And in this way, your mind becomes very depressed, becomes unhappy, consider how poorly others might think of you.
And such a type of mind which sees how how this would look before others, this type of action, which actually prevents you from proceeding in the action is what what we mean by embarrassment. Another another example in the case of a of a child who went to, for example, a store and with the idea to steal something from the store. And, you know, and upon reaching there, comes to think, you know, well, what would happen if the police caught me? You know, what would my parents think of me? Here they think, you know, they think they think I’m a they think well of me.
They think I’m a I’m a good child. If there if I were to be caught by the police, they would that I would it would be they would think very badly of me, then they would worry about me. Me and all my relatives would think badly about me. And due to the thinking about how others, this action will appear to others, due to the reason of others, the mind is prevented from actually engaging in this negative action, and this is the property of embarrassment. So these two qualities of self shame and embarrassment are the the foundation for the development of of good character.
So these two qualities, these positive states of embarrassment and self shame are the two main companions of positive states in mind in general, positive types of conduct. If we have, if our mind is accompanied with these two positive states then we won’t allow ourselves to engage in negative actions. Will help us to prevent the arising of various afflictive emotions, the thought to engage in negative action. So the the fourth positive mental factor is not The fourth positive mental factor is nonattachment, and is the opposite of attachment. And with nonattachment, we see the faults of all the various things within cyclic existence.
For example, you know, the various types of possessions, articles, persons. So non attachment, when we talk about attachment is a desire for all the various things that’s inside of existence. For example, you know, all the various foods, all the various precious things, people, etcetera. Whereas non attachment is exact opposite where we have a detachment from all the things within cyclic existence and their fault. Non attachment has the function of the action of preventing whereby we will not engage in the afflictive emotion.
Key terms in this teaching
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- omnipresent mental factors sarvatraga-chaitta (Skt); sem jung kun dro (Tib)
- One of the six groups of mental factors, these accompany every main mind. There are five: feeling, discrimination, intention, mental engagement and contact. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.