Rinpoche’s Story — 2013-02-23

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story — 2013-02-23
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 100-minute talk, Kyabje Rinpoche presents verified research cases to build a case for rebirth across animal, spirit, and hell realms. He begins with the philosophical argument that human consciousness is non-material, then walks through documented examples: a Sri Lankan boy who remembered being a hunter in one life, then reborn as a rabbit hunted in turn, before ordaining as a monk—his animal rebirth apparently transforming him from hunter to strict vegetarian; cases of spirit possession documented by Stevenson and ethnopsychiatry; accounts of hell-realm experiences from near-death research. Central to his argument is a critique of Western psychiatry’s dismissal of dissociative identity disorder as trauma-based; he argues it is better understood as spirit possession, a reframing that yields more effective treatment. He also addresses the neurobiology of possession and the Nechung Oracle’s role. For practitioners willing to question materialist assumptions about consciousness.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2013-02-23 – KR.mp3

Teacher: Ilia Durovic

Collection: Unclassified

Date: 2023-02-13

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~12,679

There is method in our madness as you can see. We have basically first made the distinction between life and consciousness. Then I have reminded you that over the last three years we made a strong case for the human mind being non material. And pointed out that basically if the human mind is non material, there are some theoretical problems with the idea of a non material mind arising at some point in the process of evolution. And then we have shown that the minds of animals share some basic features with human mind, seven features.

And that there is really no legitimate reason for which if the human mind is non material, the mind of animals should not be non material. At present the question is, can one be reborn as an animal? Is there evidence to prove this? There is actually strong evidence. We will start covering the cases.

First a verified memory of an animal rebirth in Sri Lanka which was studied by Stevenson. The case of the young Vanasiri Adhikari. So I won’t focus on most of the features of the rebirth only on those which demonstrate that there was an animal rebirth. Young Vanasiri Adhikari starts talking at age four as many of these cases to his father about his father of a previous life. He makes a series of recognitions which were verified regarding his previous life.

His family in the previous life and his family Remembers a very brief rebirth after his death as a child who seems to have been still born, dying shortly after. Recognize recognizes his parents from his previous life, has a series of memories regarding his nicknames in a previous life. And a clear recollection which actually was eventually identified of his previous rebirth. So young Vanasiri Adhikari owned and drove a car in his previous life and was fascinated by cars in this life. Was very close to his mother from the previous life in this life, and very close to his mother in the previous life.

Kindly in both lives, but oddly enough is vegetarian in this life and was carnivorous in the previous life, which is a very major discrepancy. And what he was not unusually religious in the previous life became ordained in this life. He was a hunter in the previous human life, and in this life abstained from killing any living creature. So what happened? Normally when you have recollections of past lives, the key features between the previous human rebirth and the present human rebirth are almost identical.

What happened is a memory of a rebirth as a hare, as a rabbit. This is his previous, his present life as a young Sri Lankan boy. His very brief human life, which must have lasted maybe a couple days or weeks, and a clear memory of being a rabbit with only two memories in that life, which is very striking. Of eating grass and of being shot. And before that, the recollected human memory of Ānanda Mahipala.

Now it is quite clear to me, I don’t know whether you will think so as well, that this rebirth as a hare had a very powerful transformative influence on him. It turned him from someone who was a meat eater, which is quite rare in Sri Lanka, to someone who was vegetarian. It is from a Buddhist standpoint probable that the karma of hunting in this life led to rebirth as a rabbit, one who is hunted in the following life. And it is very clear that the memories of at least these two rebirths led to a wish to become ordained at the age of 16, which he did, against the wish of his family. He did become ordained and is by all accounts an exceptional monk.

Now this is a clear case of a reconnection of an animal rebirth within a stream of verified human rebirth. The animal rebirth itself is impossible to verify, because the memories of the rabbit are very limited. Then if you ask yourselves what sort of memories would an animal have, it would be very very few for human beings. Dietary habits, the mode of death, in some cases of recollection of animal rebirth, the person doesn’t even remember their shape, they remember being big, not being able to see sideways, and being stung by mites and insects all the time. Which could suggest rebirth as a horse with blinkers.

There is no self identification, no memory which can be traced. So this is the first of these verified cases we will talk about. We will talk about another more complex case at the end of this conference. I’ll bring it up then because it is also involved with a hell memory rebirth. It’s one of the cases of memories of a hell rebirth.

And at present I would like to talk about spirit rebirth, so preta rebirth. And I wanted to cover the more accessible part of the material during the first part of our talk and this more inaccessible part during the second part. This is a painting of Goya of the spirit of war, a great Spanish painter. Now this becomes very alien for most westerners. So what I will ask you for the time being is to suspend disbelief, and we will work through it quietly.

And then since we have established that the human mind is non material, in other words it doesn’t fundamentally depend on the brain, there is no obvious reason for which minds cannot exist independently of bodies. If you accept that the human mind, certainly the subtle human mind does not need a brain, there is no particular reason for which one couldn’t accept the existence of spirits, which are just minds without of course bodies. Then obviously if we accept their existence, then I think our world view changes rather dramatically. So we will have to see whether this is something which is possible or not. I would point out before we start that of a world population of 7,000,000,000, probably 6,000,000, 6,200,000,000 accept the existence of spirits, and there are some six or 800,000,000 westerners who do not.

It’s a universal belief. In India, in most of the third world countries, in China, when I talked about it with my Chinese friends, it was not going up the walls literally. In South America, etc. So it is not a rare and uncommon belief. And as all universal beliefs, it merits to be tested.

And the way we will broach the issue of spirits is by trying to see how western culture try to account for phenomena akin to spirit possession. And to do this, we have to look a bit at the history of modern psychiatry. Modern psychiatry really was pioneered by three great figures, Charcot who studied hysteria at La Salpetriere in Paris. His student Pierre Janet, perhaps the greatest specialist of what we used to call multiple personality disorders, now dissociative identity disorders, and his student the great Sigmund Freud. What is however very striking is that modern psychiatry appears as an attempt to refute the reality of possession.

And this is really certainly with Charcot and Janet, the agenda of psychiatry. Charcot and Janet are dealing with cases which are very troubling such as this case of lethargy catalepsy in which a woman is actually stretched out between two chairs. Her ankles in one chair and her neck on another and is able to remain in this possession. This case of ecstasy and possession in one of Charcot’s students and they are trying to account for this without bringing anything immaterial in the picture. So what I’d like to point out before we start is therefore that modern psychiatry has a powerful hidden agenda.

Which is a refutation of possession because possession implies the existence of disincarnate spirit. And therefore the non material nature of the mind. If we can establish that true possession occurs, we have established that the mind can exist without the brain and much of the framework of modern neurology and psychiatry collapses. And there is one particular category of mental illnesses which I would like to focus upon within basically schizophrenia. And these are known as dissociative identity disorder, used to be known as multiple personality disorders.

These were simply called possession up to 1890. It was possession by a disincarnate entity, it could be a benevolent or an evil spirit. Now this obviously was completely unacceptable and it had to be accounted for. And much of the work of Charcot, Janet, Freud, but even later Jung, you know, was work in this direction. So what are the key features of dissociative identity disorder?

And I rely here on the standard reference work DSM IV until DSM V comes out. We speak of dissociative identity disorders with two when two or more distinct identities are present in the individual, and they take control of the behavior recurrently. Not only this the individual is unable to recall important personal information and this is not attributed to forgetfulness. And finally as a caveat, this is not a result of substance abuse or for instance diabetes, diabetic coma and whatever. In other words, to the exterior observer it looks as if you have two persons within one body, switching from the one to the other, with different memories, different ways of expressing themselves, different hand writings, different personalities, at times aware of each other, frequently totally unaware of each other.

Now you can see why to an exterior observer this simply looks like a case of an extra mind or maybe several extra minds being present in the body. Now if you accept the existence of a non material mind, this is a natural hypothesis. If you don’t, it is an unacceptable hypothesis. And you can see the degree to which some of the great figures of early psychology such as William James and Myers struggled to try to account for these phenomena which were well attested. Now what is striking is that according to the psychiatrist who specialize in the treatment of dissociative identity disorder, it is extremely difficult if not impossible to cure.

What is called euphemistically as unification of self states appears to occur in only a minority of patients with DID. Now as you probably know from the popular press, the dominant model for dissociative identity disorder, multiple personality disorder is early childhood abuse. Early childhood abuse which is highly traumatic and which causes the apparition of a separate self. This is one diagram showing the way in which early childhood abuse with precipitating events, perpetuating phenomena and predisposing factors lead to multiple personality disorder. From Brown, issues in the psychotherapy of multiple personality disorders.

This was a model which was introduced in the early eighties, and which has remained dominant up to the present day. What is interesting is that actually there’s very little evidence in favor of this model. It has become accepted in the mainstream, and it is taken for granted that if there is no memory of early childhood abuse, it is because it’s repressed, and if there are memories which cannot be verified or which are forced, it is because of the traumatic nature of the abuse. Now this basically is, to put it rather bluntly, a profoundly unscientific way to go about things. You create a theory which actually is unfalsifiable.

Because either the cases are true or they are not, and it has led to huge abuses, which I would not enter into here, specifically in North America where a series of psychiatrist who specialized in the treatment of dissociative identity disorders were found to actually have basically generated the memories within their patients through suggestion. Some of these psychiatrists have been completely discredited, but the model has not. But the question we have to ask is, is this the main or perhaps the exclusive means in which multiple personality disorders arise? Or could it be that this is an untestable theory which has perhaps been pawned off on an unsuspecting public. Now how would we address this?

A very simple way and I am often surprised this seems never to happen in the interaction between psychiatrists dealing with DID and their patients is to ask the patient how he or she experiences this. After all, the main recipient is the patient. Then if you ask the patient, this is from Putnam, when alter personalities are asked whom they believe they are, they say they are often children in eighty six percent of the cases, spirits in eighty four percent of the cases, demons in twenty nine percent of the cases, another living person, dead relatives or a person of the opposite sex. In other words, in every single case, they are somebody else by their own account of the experience. And in a large proportion of cases, they are spirits or demons.

Then unless one is laboring under a massive amount of bias, this does have to be tested. And we will find that it has been tested and there are ways to do so. Faced with this problem and especially faced with these issues in underdeveloped societies in which multiple personality disorder is extremely frequent, and faced as well with the failure of contemporary psychiatry and in this specific case we will talk about French psychiatry. In dealing with this, a new discipline of psychiatry was pioneered in the late nineteen fifty’s known as ethnopsychiatry. Mainly by Henri Collomb, a French psychiatrist in Senegal who was both the chief psychiatrist at the hospital in Dakar and a student of Marcel Mauss, the great anthropologist.

And by two other psychiatrists Georges Devereux and Tobie Nathan who is the chief exponent of ethnopsychiatry in France to the present day. What is interesting with ethnopsychiatry is that the ethnopsychiatry takes what the patient is saying to a degree at face value. We’re no longer dealing with, and I’m sorry to use such a blunt term, a colonial approach to mental diseases, but an approach which is sympathetic to the local culture. And because this approach is sympathetic to the local culture, it leads to the integration of healing rituals from the local culture within the psychiatric treatment. Now so far this would just be quaint and interesting.

Where it becomes quite striking is that the results are remarkable. And this is a case Tobie Nathan reports of preliminary interview with a lady from Cameroon, suffering from multiple personality disorder. She suffered from a serious depression, then the moment he touched her she entered into a trance and declared, keep in mind this is a psychiatrist speaking, in a man’s voice, actually her father’s voice, who had passed on one year earlier, I want Nadine to come at once to my grave in Cameroon. Then turning to me, she said in a man’s voice, just who are you to speak to me? And then added, how can you take care of my daughter when you aren’t even black?

Then as Tobie Nathan says, in this case one either stops the session or one starts negotiating with the spirit which has appeared. It is a later option I chose. So the entire approach in ethnopsychiatry is one of provisional acceptance of the existence of spirits. One just accepts that these are functionalities which manifests, one discusses with them as if they are alternate personality, one negotiates with them, negotiates their departure, without really addressing the issue of whether or not they might exist as alternate personalities which are independent of the brain or not. And it remains an issue whenever one deals with traditional cultures.

This is an article published by a Turkish military psychiatrist, schizophrenia or possession. It had to be published in the Journal of Religious Health because I would imagine that a psychiatric review would probably not accept to publish it. But what is striking is when the psychiatrist says the most common delusion types are as follows, my feeling and movement are controlled by others in a certain way and they put thoughts in my head that are not mine. One approach to this hallucination problem is to consider the possibility of a demonic world. And this is a damning statement.

A local faith healer in our region, this is in the center of Turkey, helps the patients with schizophrenia. His method of treatment seems to be successful because his patients become symptom free after three months. So here we have a situation where the self reported account of the patient indicates multiple independent personalities, and those who accept the self reported account can treat and cure the patient. Modern psychiatry does not accept the self reported account and can neither treat nor cure the patient by its own account. Yet this model, which is rooted on a theory of child abuse, for which as far as I know the evidence is still incomplete, is a dominant model, and the traditional model which is rooted on the self report of the patient which is effective is discredited.

It’s a very strange state of affairs. And this has led a leading American neurobiologist Patrick McNamara who wrote one of the most interesting books on exorcism and possession. I really recommend it to those of you who are interested in the bibliography under possession. To to study the neurobiology of possession. What exactly is happening in the brain when someone is possessed?

Now what is striking with McNamara’s work is that he seems to go much further than the provisional approach of acceptance of possession among the French ethnopsychiatrists. And in an interview in the Boston University Alumni Journal, he says, it’s an interesting clinical fact that even today most cases of involuntary spirit possession across the world occur overnight. The person wakes up possessed. We will see one such cases shortly. And as for people who encounter a possessed person, it is an uncanny experience, it is a terrifying experience if the possessing spirit is demonic.

This does not exactly sound like a neurobiologist speaking to me. So it sounds as if McNamara without ever wanting to put this in print has moved beyond the provisional acceptance of possession to the acceptance of a reality of possession. And we will now turn to one of the few studies in the field, because it is very difficult to get fundings for this type of study, of the actual neurobiology of possession. Now this study was made by a group of Brazilian neurobiologists and by Andrew Newberg who is one of the leading exponents in this field. It was a study of the mental health of 115 spirit mediums.

You remember that the model which is proposed in DSM IV, the accepted model for accounting for DID is that it occurs largely as a result of the trauma of child abuse. Therefore you would expect people who have multiple personality disorders to rate very highly in psychiatric disorder assessment, you would expect troubled personalities and troubled lives. However when they are studied, one finds exactly the opposite. Certainly in Brazil among 115 spirit mediums, subjects had high social educational levels, generally a BA, low prevalence of psychiatric disorders and were well adjust socially. Their experience of mediumship was distinct from dissociative identity disorder.

And this raises the question which I would like to leave pending, could it be that we have pathological dissociative identity disorder and mediumship, and that the two are not necessarily correlated, or in an even more extreme scenario is it possible that what is known as dissociative identity disorder is basically a construction and that we have possession by benevolent or harmful spirits. In the case of possession by benevolent spirits, there are few side effects, let alone death, these lives seem to be quite happy lives. In the case of possession by malevolent spirits, there are a large number of negative side effects. So we will leave these questions pending for the time being, and look at another study which is a sociological assessment of 10 Brazilian psychographers. In other words, people who write when possessed by a spirit, what is known as automatic writing in English.

You will note that of the 10, almost all have university degrees. We tend to have more females than males. Typically they have been involved in mediumship for twenty years or more, they tend to work, and we have what is to be expected a pretty ordinary balance of married single and divorced persons. Certainly not what we would expect from profoundly troubled victims of abuse. Then if we look at the psychiatric assessment of these 10 Brazilian psychographers, what is very striking is that if we look at the SRQ which is the cut off point for common mental disorders, in other words someone which has an SRQ higher than four would be considered to be troubled, four for men and six for women.

We see that almost all of them are beneath this or at four. Again, this does not fit the image of deep mental disturbance associated with DID. There are other criteria which are used, the criteria of the cut off points for depression and so forth. However, we find that very few of them, only one case qualify as borderline personalities, and of the 10 there has been one case of child abuse. As reported by the person and ultimately this is what we have to rely upon.

We cannot say that if the person does not recollect child abuse, there has been child abuse, it is simply that it’s repressed. Then we enter in the realm of magic. Then the quality of the writing in automatic writing was assessed. This was assessed by a professor of literature at the university who was accustomed to grading work and creative writing, and it was done under double blind conditions. What is interesting is that basically the quality of the writing produced is far superior to what any one of these mediums could produce when they were not possessed.

So possession leads seem to lead to a spurt in creativity. We are far removed here you can see already from the vision of multiple personality disorder which has been promoted by Western psychiatry. We have patients who show no sign of abuse, who are well integrated socially, high levels of education, creative. Then the question of the neurobiology of automatic writing arises and this is what is extremely puzzling. Subjects produce complex content in a trance dissociative state indeed, but what is striking is that the sections of the brain associated in this case with writing are under activated during the trance.

In other words, they are producing higher quality writing than they could in a normal state, but the part of the brain which is purportedly responsive, responsible for writing, is under activated. It is clear that we have here something which flies in the face of the dominant understanding first of the repartition of cognitive areas in the brain, but it also flies in the face of the dominant understanding of multiple personality disorders. Then we have to ask, and I think this naive approach is beneficial, the subjects themselves what they experience. After all the subject is at the center of the experience. The subjects unambiguously attributed their trance writing to spirits.

The more experienced the medium, the lower the level of activation of the area of the brain responsible for that activity, in this case writing. And therefore the authors conclude these findings are not consistent with faking or role playing. Planning related neural circuits would presumably be recruited to compose more elaborate texts if the subjects faked trance states. So you can see that these three studies which I presented simultaneously seem to indicate that A) the model of multiple personality disorder as rooted in childhood abuse leading to the creation of a separate personality after dissociation is open to question. Secondly, it seems certainly among the automatic writers which are studied, that they are performing an activity writing at an extraordinarily high level of competence with lesser activation of the parts of the brain responsible in a normal state, which would imply that perhaps there are other sections of the brain which may be responsible or alternatively which is my personal understanding that there are some of these functions which are taken over by the non material mind.

Then having established that the dominant account of dissociative identity disorder is open to question, I’d like to address with you verified cases of possession from Stevenson’s research. Then I have no pictures of the the Sumitra case which Stevenson studied. I included here pictures of a Ghanaian woman in my possession, possessed by a python spirit. It has to be seen to be believed, looking at an egg. You may know or not know that Cobras and Pythons love eggs.

And the face of this woman is something worth seeing. It’s very difficult to imagine impersonation occurring at that level of credibility. Very difficult. And the case Stevenson studied was a case of one Sumitra Singh, who showed all the exterior signs of death in 1985. She resurrected literally after death, after five minutes where as far as her family was concerned she was dead.

Breathing had stopped, there was no pulse they could detect, the body had started to become somewhat cooler. And her entire relationship with her family shifted. She recalled being somebody else. Someone called Shiva Divedi. She refused to recognize the family as her own, but she recognized certain members of Shiva Divedi’s family, and her entire behavior changed.

This woman who used to be a simple country girl suddenly started behaving in a sophisticated level, she had been barely literate, she was writing and speaking fluent Hindi, and indeed the persona she recalled, Shiva Divedi, had a Bachelor’s of Arts in Hindi literature. Now this is the account of Sumeetra Singh’s death. She was polystrous and apneic, face was drained of blood like that of a dead person. The period of death is estimated at about five minutes. After her revival, there was an initial period of confusion which is very common in these cases, and then she began to be behave like a different person and claimed she had been murdered by her in laws.

She was unable to recognize her family which surrounded her, did not recognize her own father, showed no interest whatsoever in her own husband and her own child, rejected any advances from her husband. And now if we compare Sumeetra Singh before the possession, and the personality which is claimed to have possessed her, Sumitra Singh was a lower caste woman, a peasant, barely literate, there does not seem to have been any indication she attended school. The persona which possessed her was of Brahmin caste, middle class, urban, articulate and literate, and had a BA degree. And what is striking is that after possession, this is how Sumitra Singh started to behave. Now these are the verified elements of the case.

She recognized her, the picture of the previous persona whom she had never seen. She told the previous persona’s father the previous persona’s two pet names. She recognized the previous persona’s maternal uncle. Another maternal uncle recognized the childhood friend of the previous persona and that persona’s nickname. So if we actually try to analyze the data, what we end up with is probably this scenario.

Shiva Diwedi dies in May 1985, it is said she was murdered and placed on train tracks. This type of death easily causes a generation of what we know in the West as a ghost basically, this is what we are talking about. Or a spirit, what the Buddhists know as Pretas. As a result Shiva Divedi takes a Preta rebirth from 05/19/1985, she has no memories of this rebirth at all, but this Preta takes possession of Sumeetra Singh and abruptly we have a complete shift, not just in personality, but also in capacities. Now what is striking in this case is that the preta rebirth has to be inferred, there are no memories.

And as I mentioned in the case of animal rebirth, and I think it is a case for hell rebirth as well, the cases where there are memories, they are memories of one single experience, generally an experience of pain, of suffering. Probably because these experiences are so alien, they would make no sense to the person. You remember in the case Vanasiri Adhikari, who remembered being a hare, a rabbit, that he had only two memories, of eating grass and being shot. Now in the case of Sumitra Singh, there are no memories of a preta rebirth. We just have a gap between the death of a previous personality and basically possession, I will use the term from now on, of Sumitra Singh.

Finally, the Hell Realms. This is another painting of Goya who, if he did not see some of these realms, certainly, you know, was a very convincing exponent of their existence. Now regarding the Hell Realms we have two categories of data which seem to intimate their existence. We have data from the cases of the recollection type. This includes Stevenson’s data which is almost always spontaneous, and the data from hypnotically regressed patients.

The other category of data is data from near death experience. So I will present data from all three categories. First the spontaneous cases of past life memories with evidence of hell life rebirth. And at this point I would like to introduce a major caveat against Stevenson’s work, which he acknowledges himself. But which goes a long way to explain some of the lacunae in his work.

Stevenson has an acknowledged bias against memories of non human rebirth, and systematically excluded them from his printed books. Probably because the material was sensitive enough that he didn’t want to incur more criticism than was necessary. So I’ve had to gather the few cases in which Stevenson left some of the evidence intimating non human rebirths. It would be very interesting to have all the material. This is in 20 cases suggestive of reincarnation, one of his first published books.

One clear case of hell rebirth followed by an animal rebirth with verified human data is a case of this young Sri Lankan boy who remembered being hanged for murder in a previous life. It’s a verified case. In other words, his memories from a previous life were verified, the family was traced, he has bodily marks, birthmarks, which correspond to the deeds he performed in a previous life. So the case of Vijayaratne, this young Sri Lankan boy was born with a marked deformity of the right breast and arm and very strong resemblance to his father’s deceased brother his uncle Ratran Hami. His uncle, uncle Ratran Hami was hanged for murder for having murdered his fiancee, quasi wife in Sri Lankan usage.

He himself said he had been born with a withered arm because he had murdered his wife in a previous life. And he had clear memories of his previous life and of his execution as Ratran Hami, memories which were verified. He had memories of the Puja being held by the Buddhist monks at the prison, He had memories of asking his brother to make a donation. He had memories of being hanged of the trial of the gallows. And upon his neck tightening he had one memory of falling into a pit of fire.

Which in my opinion is a hell memory. Rebirthed probably what we would call in Buddhist terms a hot hell. This is the only memory he has of that state. Then you have birth deformities in accordance with as he saw it, the karma of murdering his ex wife. The hand which held the crease was deformed.

You can see you have missing phalanxes on the right hand. Vidyarhatne himself said that his hand was malformed because he had killed his ex wife with it in his previous life, and he had stabbed his ex wife in the breast, and his own thorax was deformed. This combination of deformities is rare. What interests us in this case is not the deformities but the memory of non human rebirth. He remembers clearly after dropping in the pit of fire, flying through the air and being perched on a treetop, Which would seem to indicate rebirth as a bird.

So if we look at some of the experiences of Vijayaratne in his present life, we find that this memory of rebirth as a bird, reoccurs during a schizophrenic episode. Vijayaratne became infatuated with a girl in his high school, was rejected which has been a pattern over the lives he remembered, became delusional, and then thought he was a bird, was very light, started fluttering, and was eventually interned with a diagnosis of Hebephrenic Schizophrenia. If we try to analyze the memories of Vijayaratne, we find we have one human rebirth, which is verified, the rebirth as Ratran Hami, executed for murder in 1928 after murdering his second wife, particularly his second fiancee, it’s considered akin to a marriage in Sri Lanka, by stabbing her with his right arm in the thorax. A memory of falling in a pit of fire, which I think in Buddhist terms would be a hell rebirth, and a memory of flying from tree to tree which account for nineteen years between 1928 and 1947. This is all there is to account for these nineteen years.

Now if a bird’s life, let us say is, I don’t know how long a bird lives, but let’s say two years, three years, that means we have maybe fifteen, sixteen years in a hell realm with one memory. Then regarding memories of animal and hell rebirth induced under hypnotic regression, I’ll draw once again on the work of the French hypnotist and psychiatrist, Albert de Rochas, who regressed his maid Josephine. And in her first regression, we will cover these rapidly, I’ve presented the case already, which was a partially verified regression. Josephine says she is a man from the hamlet of. Such a hamlet did exist, she had no knowledge of it, and she remembers doing military service in Bourbonne from 1832 to 1837, this was verified.

The seventh artillery was in Bourbonne from 1832 to 1837, and dies alone at 70. By all accounts Jean Claude Bourdon, the regressed personality is an atheist and profoundly hostile to all religion. The second regressed personality, previous to this one is a woman called Philomène Carteron, who seems to have at the end of her life a memory of a hell realm being in great darkness tormented by evil spirits. She is irreligious, as she will be in the following life. Again it’s partially verified, these families did exist in the small village of Chougny, keep in mind this two centuries before the internet, it is almost impossible to gain this type of information.

The third regressed memory is that of an animal. A large ape which caused great distress to her, and great distress to the hypnotist, de Rochas, who did not believe in animal rebirth. Then if we analyze this rebirth, we can see we have in the present life Josephine, a maid of 18 without any major education, and in the oldest regressed life a rebirth as a monkey, no clear memories, just a memory of confusion and ignorance. Then a rebirth as a human being, Philomène Carteron, a lady described as irreligious and described by those who knew her as evil. Followed it would seem by a hell rebirth, we don’t know when Philomène Carteron died, it’s hard to believe she lived more than a hundred years, so this hell rebirth must have lasted ten maybe twenty years.

All that is known is that she was in great darkness tormented by spirits. This might correspond to a Buddhist cold hell, And then he rebirthed Jean Claude Bourdon with the pattern retained, you can very clearly see the pattern here of irreligiosity and basically at least as far as until Josephine, probably difficult people. Then I don’t know what de Rochas’s experience with his maid was. He never wrote about it. Maybe she was difficult too, I hope not.

So these are two cases, one of spontaneous memories of past lives with an animal rebirth and a hell rebirth. And another the De Rochas case of Josephine of an induced case with both an animal and a hell rebirth. You will see, you have noticed in both cases very few if any memories. Just an experience. Then the hell memories from near death experiences which are now being studied at the University of Virginia, mainly by doctor Bruce Greyson.

As you know, when the western public became aware of near death experiences, in other words people dying and coming back from the dead, They were presented as almost exclusively happy experiences corroborating a certain naive western vision of Christianity. Then as research continued, it turned out that the very large dose of self censorship from the researchers had been present from the beginning. Interestingly enough, it is the researchers with a new age background who are most guilty of self censorship in this matter. It seems that basically the cases of hell memories from near death experiences, distressing near death experiences as they are euphemistically called, but they’re much more than distressing, Where it’s simply systematically occulted. And there are four such types of memories.

Misinterpreted present pleasant near death experiences, we won’t talk about them. They are typically experiences of falling, in which a person is afraid of falling. And then three experiences of which I will cover the two middle ones. The experience of eternal void, just complete absence, and an experience which corresponds to hell. The fourth experience, judgment, we will not talk about here.

Now according to a recent researcher in near death experiences, almost twenty percent of near death experiences which are reported are distressing ones. Now of the seventeen point seven percent of distressing near death experiences, almost thirty one percent had attempted to commit suicide. So there seems to be a very clear correlation with that element of despair involved in attempted suicide, and very distressing post death experiences. Then when one breaks down near death experience, the distressing near death experiences, one finds that thirty percent are misinterpreted types, forty two percent are hellish near death experiences, and twenty eight percent the eternal void near death experiences. I have not included the judgment cases, they are few and far between within these.

What is striking in Romer’s work, and that’s why these figures have to be taken with a very large grain of salt, is that she found that two out of three of the persons who had near death distressing near death experiences and made an appointment to see her, cancelled the appointment. Only one third came. Therefore it’s open to question whether these figures mean anything when I have the impression there’s a very, very large component of self censorship and denial about the existence of these phenomena and we might be dealing with a lot more than seventeen percent. If we use Romer’s figure we might be dealing with forty fifty percent. We simply don’t know.

If they are not reported, the people don’t come, then how can one basically assess the situation. So this is a typical eternal void near death experience. Let’s say recovering alcoholic who enters into a coma. I was going in and out of coma, suddenly I was up on the ceiling looking down at this thin frail body. Then the room started getting darker and darker.

It was like a void of life, like an absence of light. I felt bound in the darkness like a weight was holding me down. It was what I grew up to know as hell. There is no explicit suffering, there is a sensation of emptiness, meaninglessness, and tremendous waste. My personal feeling is that this might correspond to one of the Buddhist cold hells.

The cold hair is the karmic result of nihilism. Then I saw these black fragments that started to move. I realized they were silhouettes, shadows of people that I could hear chains being pulled, I heard moans and got terrified. I dropped back into my body. And you can imagine that if you have had this sort of experience, it’s not something you’re particularly keen to talk about.

And this is a quote from the Jatakas. In the future life of Naraka, a cold wind will rise in that place of absolute darkness. It will make you so ill that even your bones will be destroyed. Who would want to enter there to help you? It’s interesting that in all of the Buddhist accounts of the cold hells, really you have three features, darkness, cold, and despair.

Since they are the karmic results of basically, mechanism, in other words, materialism. The the rank, the crass materialism which impregnates all societies is none other than mechanism. Then this is a recollection of a hellish near death experience from a nurse who dies or almost dies as a result of suicide by overdose. These things were all over me and they were screaming, then I actually saw these things like horrible human beings, like anorexics. Their teeth were all ugly and twisted, their eyes were bulging, they were bald, no hair, and weren’t wearing anything.

They were grabbing at my arms and my hair and were screaming, they were wet like sweaty, and they smelled so foul like a rotting thing like death. After this I believed in hell. These are very powerful experiences. They can’t be dismissed with the flick of the hand by saying, it is an experience connected to the fact that the brain is shutting down. They have to be taken seriously and I think especially so in the light of the data we have on possession, which shows that the brains of those possessed function in a way which seems to be at odds with what we know about brain function.

The person produces remarkable works when the areas which are responsible for the production of that work, of writing are functioning in a very attenuated way. They self report that they are possessed, but I have not covered the cases of psi involving possession. These cases do exist, but I think they are too alien for a western auditory. So why do there seem to be fewer memories of lower realm rebirth? Simply because as one moves away from this world, from our present experience, these experiences are less and less meaningful.

I’m not quite sure what sense I could make of the mental experiences of our dog, Bobby. It will be an endless expectation for supper and walks. Then there will be no other memories, really, would there? Maybe the memory of death. Does Bobby know he is a dog?

I’m not quite sure he does. What self assessment does he have? When that passes on, what do you remember of that experience? In the case of the memories of hell realms, we have only memories flashes of pain or fear. It seems that with preta rebirths there were no memories.

Animal rebirths one or two sensory memories. So this leads us to the core question of this presentation, does cyclic existence exist? That’s what we’re talking about. Either cyclic existence exists, we transmigrate from life after life, not just from human realm to human realm, but within the whole range, animal rebirth, preta rebirth, hell rebirth, or cyclic existence does not exist. When cyclic existence does not exist, there is nothing to escape from.

If there is nothing to escape from, why go to all the trouble of meditating and so forth. So what are the various versions if you wish of existence? I think the dominant view in the West is only one life. There’s no saṃsāra. No such thing as cyclic existence.

Then certainly theosophy and I think much of the New Age view saṃsāra as one of only human rebirths. From what I understand of both theosophy and the New Age, they believe that animals have group consciousness but no individual consciousness. The Buddhist saṃsāra includes not only human rebirth, but deity rebirth, animal preta, and hell rebirth. And finally, two of the leading Indian schools Vedanta and Jain consider that plants are conscious as well. Therefore the Vedanta and Jain saṃsāra would include plants.

Buddhists do not consider plants as conscious beings. They consider that spirits can inhabit plants, can be connected intimately especially to trees, but they don’t consider that plants on their own are support for consciousness. And I would like to conclude with this quote from Kyabje Kangyur Rinpoche, In the past we almost certainly did not have a human rebirth, but in the future unless we accumulate the causes, we will not obtain one again either. You can only think in this way if you accept the existence of saṃsāra. It’s not a minor topic.

If you accept the existence of saṃsāra, totality of the rebirth, hell rebirth, preter rebirth, animal rebirth, human rebirth, deity rebirth, then the human rebirth is very very rare and the human precious human rebirth even rarer. If you consider that as a human being you are reincarnating from human rebirth to human rebirth, then the human rebirth is certainly not terribly rare. It’s the only option. And if you are a materialist and you consider there is no such thing as saṃsāra, this life is all there is with nothing before and nothing after, then there is no basis for any type of religious practice of any type. And then, was very hesitant about showing you this picture but it’s been sent to me by people I trust, the Sri Lankan center in Geneva.

I take no position regarding its authenticity, But to the best of my knowledge it is not a puja. This is a picture which was taken at a Sri Lankan Buddhist center during a Preta Puja. A Puja for the Preta’s where food is offered to the Preta’s and when the picture was developed, this was found to be there. And whether this is authentic or not I don’t know. I received it from the Sri Lankan Buddhist Center in Geneva.

But if it is, then we have to lead our lives differently, don’t we? Because from a Buddhist standpoint, each of the realms has its own uncommon feature. The uncommon feature of the animal rebirth is ignorance and stupidity. Typically, anything involving habituation to ignorance in this life, can cause an animal rebirth. This is a danger of wrong forms of meditation, which act as a cause for an animal rebirth.

Then a rebirth as a spirit, in other words we can say a ghost or a preta, really they are synonymous. The main cause for that is envy. Envy, attachment, jealousy. It’s a result of this envy that the preta, the spirits cannot enjoy food, or for that matter cannot enjoy any material enjoyment in their life as a Preta. The main cause of rebirth as a hell being is anger.

And in the cold hells, it is the rejection of any type of spirituality mechanism. Then I was going to show you a video of the possession of the Nechung Oracle, but I’m not quite sure that it’s possible with our bandwidth. So I will try and if it goes well, then I will show it and if it doesn’t we will just take questions. As you know the Nechung Oracle is the main oracle of His Holiness the Dalai Lama. It is he is a monk.

Then my apologies. This is beyond my control. I will try to show you a couple images if I can. The Nechung Oracle, he is the main Oracle of the Tibetan government. I have given you a handout in which his holiness describes the possession of the Nechung Oracle.

It’s very striking because here you can see it clearly. His features start to change as the possession begins. Then the helmet which is put on his head, in Tibet used to weigh approximately 40 kilos. Therefore the moment possession starts to dislocate his neck. Therefore the monks had to be very well trained.

And the moment left the body of the oracle, they had to take him at once, you know. In India, the helmet is lighter. I don’t think so. It hasn’t we don’t have the bandwidth for this. My apologies.

I’ll see if I can show you a couple images. Nechung Rinpoche speaks in the Tibetan of the eighth century. So he has his personal translator, a Geshe, who has to basically convey this into modern Tibetans, taken in notes. Generally speaking the prophecies are secret because they are for the usage of the Tibetan government. Then these notes are given to the Dalai Lama and he takes, I’d say, his major policy decisions on this space.

Nechung Kuten, the Nechung Oracle, was the one who warned the Dalai Lama in 1950 that the threat to Tibet was coming from China. By, and it is not clear how this was possible, bowing repeatedly in the direction of China with his 40 kilo helmet. Though his loyalist recounts it, he was convinced that the monk who is the physical support for Dorje Drakden would die as a result of this, he did not. Then it is the Nechung Oracle which found the exact time for the Dalai Lama to flee Tibet after the Chinese had invaded. So there is a very close relationship between the successive Dalai Lamas and Nechung Rinpoche.

Then I was privileged enough to meet with Nechung Rinpoche when I was in Dharmasala. He is a remarkable monk and I wanted to show you, but it’s not meant to be, the process of possession because it raises many questions. The body of Nechung Rinpoche almost doubles in volume. It’s very difficult to see how this is possible. The face changes completely.

Then he has to be restrained by between four and six monks because he is basically just bouncing. It’s quite astonishing to see. Dorje Drakden used to be the protector of Samye monastery. When Guru Padmasambhava came to Tibet, this was the god Pehar, one of the ancient Tibetan war gods. Padmasambhava in the eighth century turned him into a dharma protector.

He has become the protector of the Tibetan government in particular, but he retains some of the mannerisms of a war god and unfortunately some of the modes of expression which go back to the eighth century. So the moment Dorje Drakden enters the Nechung Oracle, he must be handed a sword and a bow. It is very difficult for the monks because he wields them with great experience. And they just are trained to basically dance around him without getting hit in any way. And the moment he sits down and starts speaking, he has one interpreter, a Geshe, who gives a running interpretation of what he is saying in modern Tibetan and this is taken in note.

Then it is printed and is presented to His Holiness. But that’s what I wanted to show you, maybe at some point in the future we will be able to do this. And thank you very much. I hope that you found the build up reasonably convincing. I try to make an argument for the fact that first there is a difference between life and consciousness.

I try to clarify what life is and what consciousness is from the standpoint basically of modern physics of thermodynamics and quantum mechanics. Then I have pointed out without fleshing them out, the arguments which have been advanced here for the non material nature of human consciousness. I think when you look at them in their totality they are very strong. One by one, some of them are quite strong like the argument from quantum physics is strong, but when you look at the totality of the arguments, a strong case is made. And then I’ve tried to show that if the human consciousness is non material, it’s very difficult to see how consciousnesses of the beings which precedes in the evolutionary ladder could be material, as there would have to be some sort of sudden transition from the material to the non material.

And then we analyzed the features of the minds of animal, animal cognition. There are seven features of the minds of animals we talked about. Starting with altruism and empathy and finishing with language and numeracy, which make a strong case for animal consciousnesses being basically akin to ours, it is just a difference of quantity not of quality. And if our consciousnesses are non material, so are animal consciousnesses. Then we addressed the possible existence of spirits.

I’ve tried to make a case for the fact that what is known as dissociative identity disorder is in my personal opinion a case of misnomer and in my private opinion is a case of spirit possession. It is a case of spirit possession because it is described as such by the people who experience it. It can be treated by those who accept that it is spirit possession and that treatment is more effective it would seem than that by psychiatrists who don’t accept that it is spirit possession. Then after pointing out this we move towards verified cases of spirit possession, the case of Sumitra which has been studied by Professor Stevenson, and then cases of memories of animal rebirth and spirit rebirth and finally the data for the existence of the hell realms from near death experiences, memories of hell rebirth from spontaneous cases of reincarnation, from induced cases of reincarnation and from near death experiences. I think there is evidence here for the existence of the lower realm.

And if the lower realms truly exist, we have to live differently from the way we do live. Because you can see that such a rebirth is to be avoided at any cost. So it’s up to you to look into these topics, investigate them. That’s what the bibliography is there for. I think most of you are probably convinced that animals have non material consciousnesses.

It’s probably more the preta and hell rebirth which are problematical. Study the research which has been done on spirit possession and ask yourself sincerely, could DID as we understand it account for that? And then once you have established that within your mind, I think the possibility of the existence of the hell realms is much more accessible. Thank you very much. Do you have any questions?

Spirits? That are not possessed but aware of spirits? It’s very common. Not in the West but in most other cultures extremely common. As there are many people who could see them either continually or occasionally.

Ordinary people tend to see them in dreams, then the problem is obviously distinguishing between meaningless dreams and the vision of a spirit in a dream, which is difficult to do normally. It’s the experience of the person which enables them to see at once the difference. Once someone has seen a spirit in a dream, they know that for a fact. It’s a very powerful experience. Then seeing spirits in daily life happens to normal people normally when the mind is very non conceptual.

For instance, after periods of intense intellectual work, when they are tired, you know. And unlike the movies, typically it is almost impossible to know that what they are seeing is a spirit until it does something which is totally at odds with the law of physics. So just walk in a wall and disappear. Know? Well, I mean it depends if they are practicing Buddhists, then normally a powerful refuge is sufficient to do that.

Then those who have Tantric initiations, if they generate well the common boundary, should be able to block them. We only see spirits if we have a karmic connection with them. These may be beings we have a karmic connection with or it happens for people who practiced invocation, know, goetic magic in previous lives. Then let’s say in Australia it’s probably not a problem, but in Malaysia, in Indonesia, in Thailand, in Tibet, in India it’s very common. Very common.

The people have been These visions of spirits because a person had a connection with that spirit over many lives. Like in India for instance, many ordinary Indians make sacrifices to these spirits. Vegetarian or non vegetarian sacrifices and the connection becomes very strong. And this is one of the ways through which possession happens. Oh, you have a lot in Australia.

It’s the white Australians who don’t believe. You know, the people of the land, know. They know. Do you have other questions? Describe living in trees in a discarnate state and they were near their homes, is that a form of attachment that brings them into that study?

It’s a really good question, I honestly don’t know. I always thought that those were cases of rebirth as what we know as Nagas. Then you probably don’t accept the existence of Nagas. Nagas are specific spirits connected to trees and to a degree rivers and lakes. I mean I had some direct experience of this in India, I don’t know in Australia but in India definitely there are such things.

And I would think those memories are memories of Naga rebirth. Are they considered? No. No, that’s where it’s very awkward with the Naga. Technically the Naga are animals.

But then they have it’s a very awkward it’s a very awkward placement that of Nagas. Technically they are animals, but they are definitely not ignorant like most animals. Why they have been put in the animal realm, I don’t know. But they are never put in with the Pretas. Then most mundane protectors are considered as Pretas, powerful Praetas or the spirits of the ten, the lord class, the king class spirits, are all pretas.

Then obviously the gods of the form, the formless realms, are gods. Possession is possible, I’ve never heard of possession by a Naga, but the python spirit in Ghana might be one of those cases. In India I don’t know the case. Possession by pretas is fairly common. Possession by gods of the desired realm happens also.

Understand the jealous god realm? The Asuras. I didn’t mention them sometime if you divide saṃsāra in six you put them as a separate realm otherwise if you divide it into five they are grouped with gods. I don’t know. Normally the war gods are put in that category and I have always suspected or wondered whether some of the great military geniuses, if you can call them that of human history, were not either reincarnations of war gods or in some cases possessed by war gods.

I mean, I don’t want to take you too far from your comfort zone, but if you look at the life of Hitler it’s very striking. Hitler was an art student, art and architecture student. By all accounts very ineffectual rather sensitive perhaps even somewhat effeminate person who suddenly completely switched within a matter of years and became someone who could actually command the German armies. If you look at I am fortunate enough to speak German, I was watched some of Hitler’s speeches in German. His capacity to control crowds, his oratory capacity is astonishing.

There is there are body mannerisms which don’t seem to be the mannerisms of an ordinary being and which were not reported about Hitler when he was a nurse in World War one. Hitler did not qualify to serve as a soldier but as a nurse. A courageous man, but you know, definitely not a soldier. So these cases where you have a sudden shift in personality, in potency, in charisma, are cases where you have to ask a question. I’d asked it for Chairman Mao, my mother met him in 1946, and she told me he was a completely ineffectual and nondescript person.

No charisma, no oratory skills, he was a backdrop to Zhou Enlai. He was very charismatic she said. Then again something happened. You know it may not necessarily be possession but it is one of the possibilities. Does that answer your question?

In the automatic writing how is the under activity measured? How is what? The under activity measured. Is it with automatic writing There is under activity of the part of the brain. I should, you have it in the reference, it is a technique I have never heard about.

It is, does photon tomography make sense to you? It was non intrusive, that was the goal of the process. Because fMRI is obviously intrusive, then they used a technique I had never heard about. But I have given complete references, you know, check it up. Check it up.

In the near death experience accounts, have you seen many that coincide with the Buddhist description of the dissolution process at the time of death? The various visions. I have not seen in the literature, I know personally of a case. I have not seen in the literature because often they tend to be sudden. Near death experiences from a Buddhist standpoint you would not have the dissolution.

If you die in an accident you don’t have the dissolution. Which is why most of the children remembering past lives had violent deaths. Because normally the memories are greatly affected in the dissolution process. You know the white appearance, red increase, and black near-attainment. But I had a very close friend who had a car accident in Hamburg, then she got skull damage, thorax damage, leg damage, went through the windshield actually, and had a near death experience on the operating table without being a Buddhist.

And after I started speaking to her a year or so later of the Buddhist theories of the dissolution, she had a very strong reaction and she said this is exactly what I saw. And she has since become a Buddhist, a very good Buddhist practitioner with I think more than 1,000,000 prostrations credit. These are typically the people when you have this sort of experience the person knows. I actually asked this question of Geshe-la the other day but I like your opinion on it as well about recollecting past lives whether it’s possible to recollect them in the dream state I would not like to deliberately try and recollect them in the dream state but whether there’s a possibility that some dreams are actually a remembrance of past lives. Yes.

Yes. But you you have to know how to recognize them. Most dreams are not. Most dreams have no meaning. The dreams which are really meaningful are the last ones before you wake up in the morning.

Then typically dreams which may allude to past life experiences, you will have flashes, that’s all. You have one image, if you are lucky two images, maybe as if with one of these, as if using your camera as a camcorder, right? You can basically film for ten seconds, you would have a bit of a street or something. And it will be repetitive. You will have these images not one time, but every week for six months, every month year after year, and sometimes what happens is that each time you have these images, you go a little bit further on the street, you go a little bit further in the valley.

If one is very lucky it is possible to verify these, in most cases it is not. But the flash and the fact that there is generally no other background is often an indicator and the repetitiveness as well. Does that help? Just one more question, Elliot. In cases of reincarnation type, there was quite a few cases that don’t accord with, say the gestational period where a personality, a person has transmigrated in a shorter gestational period so obviously at the point of conception that person couldn’t have possibly migrated because they were still alive.

However the person when born still shows those traits. Is that a piece of evidence around possession? Yes I think so. I think what you have in those cases, if you look at Stevenson’s work, is you may have at the time of conception reincarnation of one mind into that egg and basically the karma of that being does not allow for birth. So they die, three months within the process, normally it could be a still birth, but there is possession of the ovum, the fertilized ovum, you know.

I think that’s probably what’s happening but there’s no way to test it. No way to test it. It’s surprisingly common, you know. Because basically reincarnation and possession are very close. Right?

Reincarnation is taking possession of an ovum which is empty of a spirit. Whereas possession is taking possession of an ovum or a body in which another spirit already resides. Then at times the other spirit can stay there, at times it is expelled. You can have several spirits living in one body. If you consider, which I do, that these cases of multiple personality disorder are overwhelmingly cases of possession.

Is there any recorded evidence or commentary on people who are dying during the death process which might be at the terminal for a month, constantly feeling that someone else is in the room. Oh yeah, it’s very common. That is common. It’s very common. Which would be a spirit perhaps?

Yes, yes. It’s often the spirit of relatives. I knew a case of a Serbian woman who died at the hospital in Geneva. It caused a lot of distress to an old friend of mine who was a Roman Christian Orthodox monk. He used to visit her and she was not terribly pious.

Most Serbs are not very pious. She had terminal cancer. He came to see her one day and she said to him, my mother who had passed on many years ago has come in to see me this morning. I will not last the day. Know?

And she was very peaceful, mindful. Then he tried to reassure her and she said to him, just bother, you know. No need, you know. Then he came to see her the next day and she was gone. You know?

With the accounts of people seeing relatives, if the relatives have been reincarnated, how is it that they, there is this common theme among a lot of the research and what Molly was just saying of those beings. They have reincarnated the spirits. Sometimes it’s a fantasy, but in many cases they reincarnate, the spirits, sometimes they take an oath to protect the family. Then you can know that it is not a fantasy when, for instance, information is given which you would have no access to otherwise. The book that I’m just reading at the moment Professor Eben Alexander, the neurosurgeon, Proof of Heaven, it turns out that he was adopted during his near death experience when he had an attack of a very rare E.

Coli meningitis and there was a guide, a girl with a beautiful face and so on, a butterfly’s wing which he had a strong feeling of recognition but he didn’t know who it was he had no recall of any family at all but it turned out later when he, well to cut a long story short, it was the deceased sister, his birth sister who he had never known before. It happened in my family, you know. My father when he died, left a testament. In his testament he said that if there was a life after death which he believed profoundly, he would return as a spirit to protect the family for as long as was necessary. Then after he died, he came to see me in my dreams every three weeks to every month for seven years, and gave me mainly financial guidance actually on how to manage family assets.

This was very clear. These were not dreams, he would just there was a black background, he would appear surrounded by light, and he would speak. You see, Leah, you know, he’s very helpful. Be careful of so and so, you know, he’s not reliable, you know. One time I remember he told me, Sell everything, the market’s going to drop.

I did, we did very well as a result of that. Then eventually after seven years, I felt that I had my own grounding, and I asked my father to stop coming. Then I had a girlfriend at the period. I asked my father in front of his portrait, and he went to see her in her dreams, and told her to tell me all sorts of things. Then she was exceedingly annoyed by the whole thing, and she said to me, if your father has something to say to you, it is between you and him.

I don’t want to be involved. So these things do happen. My father I think, I have good reason to believe was reborn as a a spirit of the king class, know. A very powerful class of spirit as a result of that vow. It was a dying man’s vow.

Oath, you know. And this is how such spirits can arise in this case with a good motivation. In some cases, the spirit, we would say sometimes in the West, the ghost, arises as a result fear, envy, then these can be malevolent. Which which realm does that correspond to in the Buddhist description? Probably prettas, but very powerful Pretas.

Probably the 10 and the Gyalpo spirits, they’re between the Pretas and the demigods, weren’t they? On Rinpoche-la, can they then choose to stay in that state for as long as they want and not take another rebirth? I doubt so. Tsongkhapa says that the lifespan of pretas on average is around a thousand years. If you do the calculations right, it’s given in a very complicated way as proportions of the lives of other beings of other beings.

It’s around it’s between eight hundred and a thousand years. That fits with the cases of hauntings which I have heard about, where the spirit or the ghost can depart earlier. Hauntings are just a spirit which basically lives in a place out of attachment to that place. But some places can be haunted, it seems, to a thousand years, even a bit longer. So the use of exorcism as the Anglican Church and others, the Pentecostals and so forth, my understanding that’s sort of getting rid of them.

Would it be fair to say that the Tibetan Buddhist practice is to befriend and to tame them? It’s more complex than that. Basically, you first start by trying to befriend them if you can. Then sometimes that is not possible. Then spirits are beings like us.

So obviously you wouldn’t evict someone from their house. You try to have them live in an area. This is a humane way to do it. Then if they are very unsubdued, then you may have to evict them. To evict.

Like, The spirit typically is a former resident of the house, of the area, like in Australia you have spirits of the land and of the rivers, you know. They’re attached to the river, to the land. If one harms the river, it’s a Naga class of spirit. Then they they can actually retaliate against the harm. Then this river, this land is their property.

Now in most Western countries, obviously nobody believes in this and nobody is careful, but normally if you buy land, the first thing you do is to make an assessment of whether there are spirits on the land, and if there are, you make them offerings and you give them a place to reside on the land. It may be a tree, it may be an water, but they are residents too. It is very much to one’s advantage to be on good terms with them. I know of cases in Eastern Europe of people who cut trees wantonly who were paralyzed as a result, and we had to do rituals at a distance. And then, if that is not possible, if it is impossible to reach an arrangement, then more forceful approaches may be required, but it is non virtuous karma.

It is non virtuous karma, right? They are persons like us. The spirits are persons like us. One of the main goals of my presentation was to drive home the fact that it’s not only human beings who are persons and have rights. So do animals, so do spirits, hell beings we do not connect with, but they do.

I used to live in a haunted house in Malta, you know. I normally shouldn’t tell you too many of these stories, it’s very alien for you. But I always loved do you have time more? I loved old houses and this house was on the market forever. Then that should be a dead giveaway.

It’s a little palazzo by the sea. Right? But I thought the Maltese don’t like what is old, they only love what is new, you know. Then I bought it and I couldn’t get anyone to work for me. I had to renovate it.

Nobody wanted to renovate it, and nobody would tell me why. So I had to pay a big premium. Then when it was renovated, they’re only working by day, I couldn’t get a cleaning lady. Eventually, one of the ladies from the neighborhood agreed to come when I moved in to clean, but there was a clause, I had to be in the room with her as she cleaned, you know, and she wouldn’t do the windows. Very high ceilings, very high windows, then she wanted a big premium to do this, so eventually she wanted the premium, I wanted the information.

I got the information from her that the house was considered haunted, there was a lot of trouble. Then I moved in, and the first night was extremely difficult. You know? And as a result of that, I had to reach an arrangement with the inhabitant of the house. So he was banished from my bedroom, but he could live in the bedroom of my mother down below.

The closest. I think that a lot of people actually have had some sort of contact with things that are modern day. Exist. I think people have such scorn thrown on them for talking about it that everyone keeps it quite undercover. But I think it’s surprising the amount of people that have had, even in this country, experiences with spirit worlds.

And yeah, I think it’s just something that has been repressed and it’s culturally said to be not appropriate these days. Any final questions or comments? Well once again Ilya, as I said at the beginning, we were in for a stimulating and challenging presentation and that has truly been the case. Thank you so much for putting so much work research with the motivation to assist us to understand Buddhism and things that are hidden and to help us. So thank you so much.

So if you’d like to join with me, thank you. And thank you for your small donation which will help with the facility costs. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
nagas lu (Tib)
A snake-like being of the animal realm that lives in or near bodies of water; commonly associated with fertility of the land, but can also function as a protector of religion. LYWA
preta
Hungry ghost, or spirit. The preta realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence. LYWA
prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
puja chö pa (Tib)
Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top