1 h 40 min · 5,595 words · 24 February 2013 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Kyabje Rinpoche begins this 100-minute session by establishing psychological foundations — the role of bodhicitta and good thoughts in generating happiness — before moving into a direct exploration of emptiness. Rather than abstract philosophy, he uses concrete analytical frameworks: the five aggregates, 12 sources, and 18 constituents that systematically break down both self and phenomena. The session’s core teaching explores why the self appears to exist inherently and autonomously yet cannot be found under analysis — this gap is emptiness. He then connects this philosophical understanding to the three baskets of Buddhist teaching (ethics, concentration, wisdom) as practical methods that counter afflictions. Extensive Q&A follows, with practitioners applying the teachings to lived experience.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2013-02-24 – KR.mp3
UUID: c0ca27a3-9f58-4fcc-83f1-e1e4c347fb95
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Emptiness
Date: 2013-02-24
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~5,598
So as previously explained, what is important as a preliminary is to generate the motivation. And the motivation we need is one which is held or supported by bodhicitta. If such a motivation arises, then this attendance to a Dharma teaching today will become a Mahāyāna practice. bodhicitta is said to be of the very nature of worthy practices. Good thoughts are important for all of us whether we practice Dharma or not.
It is the very root of our practice. Good thoughts are the foundation of happiness in the world in general within the Dharma center and for one’s own self. Why is this the case? Because once these good thoughts are generated, they create peace and happiness because there are no doubts and no ambiguities between the persons. And what is most important for us is to have mutual trust, lack of doubts regarding each other, and lack of inflated expectations.
If we have mutual trust, then in turn our practice will go well. For instance, if one has to travel to a place with a group of friends, then getting there or not depends largely on the trust between the people involved. Likewise, within the context of a Dharma center, whether the path to liberation is attained or not depends largely on this mutual trust and harmony between the people involved. So within a society, if there is mutual trust, lack of doubts regarding each other, then such goals can be attained. And then in dependence on this, one can attain peace and happiness and prosperity.
And therefore, the root of happiness and peace within this world of ours and within the societies which constitute it meets up with good thoughts. And what is the root in turn of these good thoughts, this good mindset? It lies in the progressive elimination of the faulty components within our minds. And these faulty components are the afflictions. And therefore, one must eliminate the faulty section of our mind, the defective section if you wish, and foster the enhancement of the qualities within our mind such as love, empathy and bodhicitta.
Then it is really up to ourselves to volunteer to initiate this process and to put effort in it. And if we do so, although it involves some difficulty, bodhicitta and love will arise within our minds. The reason for which this can arise with limited difficulty is because it is in the nature of our minds to be in harmony with others and our minds contain the seeds of great compassion and of bodhicitta. Why is it the case that we can say that the seeds of compassion, love and bodhicitta are indeed present within our character, within our personality? It is because it is indeed in our character that when we meet people, we don’t at once feel fear and hostility upon meeting them.
Isn’t that the case? Now clearly, when we for instance encounter tigers or leopards, then indeed we immediately feel fear. Likewise, when we see snakes, we have the immediate wish to remove ourselves from them. This is not the case in human relations. And therefore within human relations there is there are personalities or characters which have compatibilities with love, bodhicitta and compassion.
And therefore we can say within our minds that there are powerful seeds for compassion, love and bodhicitta. Whether these seeds of compassion, love and bodhicitta give rise to good fruit or not within this life is largely contingent on our relationship with our parents and the love and compassion they have shown to us. It is said that if one’s mother, for instance, is naturally loving and compassion, then out of attachment to the mother, these qualities will arise easily within the mind of the child. And as a result of this natural arising of love and compassion, an uncommon aspect of love and compassion can arise within the child. And we can see within human relations that as a result of this paternal and maternal love and affection for the child, after the child’s birth, the child does not experience automatically anger towards the parents.
This indicates clearly that the child has strong seeds of love compassion within his mind. Likewise, the very fact that within our societies when powerful enmities and violence arises, this is something which we view critically and negatively is a clear sign that we ourselves have the seeds of love and compassion within our minds. Likewise, it is on this basis that we can foster the increase of love and compassion within our minds. And since within our minds we have the seeds of love and compassion and our character, our personality is compatible with the generation of love and compassion, it is very important for us to foster love and compassion as much as we can through habituation. Therefore, whichever or whoever we meet, we should try to generate love and compassion towards this person.
If within ourselves this motivation of love and compassion is strongly generated, then from the side of the other person, they will naturally like us. Our bodies and speech naturally follow the motivation. So if our own behavior follows love and compassion, then as a result, we will experience this from the side of others. And clearly, if from our own side our behavior is infused with love, with compassion, and with the supreme thought, then as a result of this progressively over time, we will experience more and more of this from others. For instance, in my personal opinion, the reason for which His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, is so popular and famous in so many different countries throughout the world is because the very essence of his teachings in his practice is love and compassion.
And therefore, the more from our own side we practice love and compassion for others, the more we will experience from their side a reciprocal love and compassion and as a result of this, the greater peace and happiness will be within our minds. Check for yourselves whether there is peace and happiness in your mind when you see another person who is a friend or a relative and when you see another person who is a foe or an enemy. For instance, if we see someone who is a source of anger within our minds, then as a result of this anger, our mind is troubled and this troubling of the mind leads to unhappiness. On the other hand, when we encounter someone who is a source of love for us, then naturally as a result of this, a feeling of happiness and of bliss pervades our mind. And therefore, indeed, love and compassion and good thoughts are extremely important.
So at present, we should think I will set in a state of happiness all of the sentient beings infinite in numbers with which I have some type of relationship. Now because this is an extraordinarily vast deed, it does not arise easily within our minds. Even though we lack the capacity to do this at present, we realize that he or she who has the capacity to do this is he or she who has attained the state of a Buddha. If one attains the state of a Buddha, then one is able to perform the perfect will of others. And therefore, pledging oneself to oneself to attain this state of full enlightenment for the benefit of others is what is known as bodhicitta.
Please meditate for one minute on generating such bodhicitta. So last time Geshe-la explained conventional truths in the light of the five aggregates, the 12 sources and the 18 constituents. He would like to know, was this difficult for you? It doesn’t matter. Last Sunday, Geshe-la explained the five aggregates in detail and entered also in detail in an explanation of the 12 sources in the 18 constituents.
There was little time and it was hard both for yourselves and for him. However, really this topic is not terribly difficult. It is based on his own experience that Buddha Śākyamūni taught that objects of knowledge, in other words phenomena, are twofold: conventional truth and ultimate truth. Regarding ultimate truths, the presentation of ultimate truths, obviously there are numerous systems of tenets and subdivisions of these systems of tenets. As a result of incompatibilities of both views and tenet systems, there are numerous subdivisions even within the Buddha’s teachings.
And while there is debate regarding the actual nature of this ultimate truth between the various Buddhist schools of tenets and the analysis thereof, there is no debate whatsoever regarding the afflictions such as desire, anger, and so forth. However, within all of the system of tenets, the one which accords with reality, the ultimate system of tenets, is the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika system of tenets of Nāgārjuna and Āryadeva. And in that system of tenets what is referred to as the ultimate mode of abiding or mode of existence of phenomena or their emptiness is none other than ultimate truths which are simply those phenomena whose mode of appearance is in accordance with their mode of existence. What is meant here by a nature which is in accordance or in accordance with appearance? If we take the case of the self, the self appears to exist inherently and autonomously within the aggregates and not to arise in dependence on them.
This is at odds with its actual mode of existence. Even though such an I seems to exist nonetheless under analysis when we analyze the body from the crown of the head to the sole of the feet, such an I is not to be found. Why is this the case? Because the parts of one’s body, one’s head is not the I, one’s chest is not the I, one’s feet are not the I either. This non inherent existence is called selflessness.
However, there is an I which walks, there is an I which eats, there is an I at present which explains Dharma teachings. So there is such a thing as an I. And therefore there are two different I’s or two different selves. The I which is rejected or refuted on the one hand and the I on the other hand which is accepted. One is called the non-existent I, the other is called the existent I.
The non-existence of that non-existent I, in other words, the non-inherent establishment of the self, is called emptiness. Since every single phenomenon lacks that inherent existence, every single phenomenon can be said to be empty of inherent existence. There are three different categories of phenomena: interior phenomena, which are phenomena within ourselves such as the mind exterior phenomena, which are phenomena such as forms and so forth and phenomena which are neither interior nor exterior. Inner emptiness here refers to the emptiness of consciousness, which is consciousness’s non establishment by its own nature. Exterior or outer emptinesses are the emptinesses of outer phenomena such as forms and so forth.
In other words, forms and so forth not being established by their own nature. And the emptiness of phenomena which are neither interior nor exterior refers to the emptiness of our aggregates which arise in dependence on both. It is in dependence on such analyses that one will make a distinction between the emptiness of composite phenomena, the emptiness of non composite phenomena and the so called 20 fold, 18 fold and 16 fold subdivisions of emptiness. It’s not too difficult, is it? This is emptiness.
Then conventional phenomena which are the helpers of ultimate phenomena include the five aggregates, the 12 sources and the 18 constituents. Then within the five aggregates, whatever is form is the form aggregate and whatever is mind is the mental aggregate. Those physical and mental experiences of happiness and suffering are called the aggregate of sensations. The second aggregate. These are called the aggregate of sensations.
That component of the mind which subdivides and discriminates, saying this is white, this is blue, this is long, this is short, is what is called the aggregate of discrimination. All minds have this. What is not any of these four aggregates? In other words, what is not the form aggregate, not the aggregate of sensation, not the aggregate of discrimination and not the last aggregate, the aggregate of consciousness, is the fourth aggregate, the aggregate of compositional factors. And why is such a fifth aggregate postulated?
It is to eliminate the ignorance which would not place the mental factors within the five aggregates. Specifically, to eliminate the ignorance which would consider all of the mental factors as one, these five different aggregates are presented. These are the five aggregates. The 12 sources are subdivided into the six outer sources and the six inner sources. Or using a different set of terminologies, the sources from the standpoint of the object and the sources from the standpoint of the subject.
So the six sources from the standpoint of the object, the six objective sources are the forms which are seen by the eye consciousness, the sounds which are heard by the ear consciousness, the smells which are smelt by the olfactory consciousness, the tastes which are tasted by the gustative consciousness, the tactile sensations which are experienced by the tactile consciousness and phenomena which are experienced by the mental consciousness. On the other hand, the eye organ, the ear organ, the nose organ, the gustatory organ, the tactile organ and the mental organ are the six sources from the standpoint of the subject. All objects of knowledge are included within these 12 sources. Why are phenomena subdivided into these 12 sources? It is to eliminate the ignorance or the benightedness which considers all form as one.
These are the 12 sources. It’s not too bad, is it? The 18 constituents are subdivided into three groups of six. The six objects of observation, the six bases and the six which are based upon. The first subdivision, the six so called objects of observation are the same as in the presentation of the 12 sources.
These are forms, sounds, smells, tastes, objects of tactile sensation and phenomena in general. The six bases, the second of the three subdivisions of the 18 constituents include the eye organ, the ear organ, the nose organ, the gustatory organ, the tactile organ and the mental organ. Then apart from a difference of terminology between sources and constituents, there is no fundamental difference here. The third subdivision of the 18 constituents which are the six based upon include the eye consciousness which is based on the eye sense organ, the auditory consciousness, the olfactory consciousness, the gustatory consciousness, the tactile consciousness and the mental consciousness based on the mental sense organ. Therefore it is in dependence on the sense organs which are the base that the consciousnesses which are based upon experience the objects of observation and enjoy them.
The reason for subdividing constituents into 18 is to eliminate the wrong view which sees all minds as one and through dividing them in their operation to eliminate this. All objects of knowledge are subdivided or included within the 18 constituents. Did you get a sense of the 18 constituents? Why does one engage in these divisions of phenomena into the five aggregates, the 12 sources and the 18 constituents? It is to understand the actual mode of abiding of phenomena.
This is taught to understand the nature of these phenomena, their capacity or their potency, their actual mode of operation and what is to be abandoned and what is to be practiced. Through understanding this correctly, the ignorance regarding objects of knowledge is countered. And through abandoning them in turn, one abandons suffering and attains happiness. Because the very foundation of all suffering is that benightedness of ignorance. Through eliminating benightedness, in turn one eliminates the afflictions and one eliminates the suffering of cyclic existence.
Therefore it is important to counter benightedness. To do this, one must understand the nature of phenomena. So this is what I explained previously. Today, we will address the subdivisions within the Buddha’s teachings into the so called three baskets or the Tripitaka and what these three baskets are. Why did the Buddha explain numerous different forms of Dharma?
He explained them to enable beings to be freed from the suffering of cyclic existence. Why have we been suffering uninterruptedly in cyclic existence? We have been suffering uninterruptedly in cyclic existence because our mind is under the thrall, under the control of the afflictions. What are afflictions? Afflictions are those mental factors which trouble the mind or the continuum of sentient beings.
If we are unable to counter such afflictions, we will continue to suffer uninterruptedly in cyclic existence. One needs specific means to counter these afflictions, and it is to explain these means to abandon the afflictions that the Buddha gave numerous teachings. When the Buddha taught beings, he taught them through understanding precisely their nature, their temperament and their disposition. Then when we explain Dharma we do it without understanding the disposition, the nature and the temperament of beings. We just explain it as it is usually explained.
Then as the Buddha could ascertain the disposition and the temperament of beings, his teachings were in keeping with their disposition and temperament. It is precisely because the Buddha’s teachings are in accordance with the disposition of the listeners that the Buddha’s teachings must be divided between definitive teachings and interpretable teachings or those which are literal and non literal. For instance, to some listeners the Buddha taught there is an inherently existing self. To others he taught there is no inherently existing self. The Buddha taught to those beings who had a profound conviction in the inherent existence of a self, Practices to abandon suffering and to train in virtue rooted in that.
If the listeners were profoundly convinced of the existence of an inherently existing self and the Buddha had told them that there was no such self, there was a very big risk that they would have abandoned him. Generally speaking, there is no inherently existing self. However, to train such listeners initially at the beginning, the Buddha taught them that there is an inherently existing self and then progressively moved them to the correct view. Therefore, for one who teaches the Dharma, it is critically important to understand the temperament and the disposition of the listeners. Then an elaborate presentation of the Buddha’s teachings to counter all of the afflictions is the so called 84,000 heaps or bundles of teachings.
Then if we were to expand each of these 84,000 bundles, there would be no time today, would there? These 84,000 bundles are subdivided into four sets of 21,000 bundles. 21,000 bundles which teach the opponent forces of desire, 21,000 which teach the opponent force of anger, 21,000 which teach the opponent force of ignorance and 21,000 which teach the opponent forces of inappropriate or wrong motivation. What is one bundle of Dharma? One bundle of Dharma is a set of Dharma teachings which teaches the complete collection of antidotes to one given affliction.
Then to reduce this vast number of teachings into any manageable amount, they are subdivided into the 12 limbs of teachings. And then to subdivide these 12 limbs of teachings into a more manageable amount, they are subdivided into these three baskets or the Tripitaka. The three baskets are the sūtra basket, the Vinaya basket and the Abhidharma basket or sūtra Vinaya Abhidharma The reason for which these are subdivided into three baskets is thought to be nine fold by Ārya Maitreya. As Ārya Maitreya says in the Mahāyāna Sutralamkara, these baskets are subdivided into either three or two for the sake of conciseness. I assert nine causes thereof.
So for the sake of convenience, we will from now on work with the three baskets. The basket of Vinaya or of discipline includes an explanation of how to take vows, what the vows are, what the subdivisions of the vows are and what the downfalls to be abandoned are. The basket of sūtra focuses mainly from within the three trainings on the training of concentration or samadhi. Whereas the basket of Abhidharma or the Abhidharma Pitaka focuses mainly on the training in wisdom or prajna. And therefore, since the basket of Vinaya focuses mainly on the training in ethics, the basket of sūtra focuses mainly on the training in concentration, and the basket of Abhidharma focuses mainly on the training in wisdom, They teach all three trainings.
And since the main import of the Buddha’s teachings was to explain the three trainings of ethics, concentration and wisdom to sentient beings, the totality of his teachings are subdivided into three baskets. And from within the nine reasons advanced by Maitreya for this subdivision, the foremost one for subdividing the Buddha’s teachings into the three baskets is to teach how to abandon the objects of abandonment. And specifically, so as to teach beings how to practice or how to train in the three trainings of ethics, concentration and wisdom, the Buddha taught the three baskets. Also, to teach beings that there are three different modes of access to wisdom. And within these nine reasons, since the first and the foremost is to teach how to abandon the objects of abandonment, We shall explain in turn these three objects of abandonment.
And the Sutralamkara explains that among these, a major one is that doubt or that hesitation which cannot ascertain precisely the nature of phenomena. And the second object of abandonment is lack of measure in one’s consumption of food and so forth. And the Abhidharma Pitaka was taught to counter the erroneous views such as apprehending the impermanent as permanent, apprehending the unclean as clean, apprehending the selfless as having a self, and so forth. And specifically the affliction which is known as the affliction which holds wrong views as supreme, This is the affliction which reifies the idea that what is unclean is clean, what is impermanent is permanent and so forth. So this is the reason for which three objects of abandonment are presented.
And in addition, three trainings are presented as opponent forces to these three objects of abandonment. So this is what we shall explain now. Are presented in terms of the main training which they focus upon. So the Vinaya basket or the basket of discipline teaches mainly the training in ethics. The sūtra basket or the sūtra Pitaka teaches mainly the training in concentration.
And the Abhidharma Basket or the Abhidharma Pitaka teaches mainly the training in wisdom. I shall explain the last three reasons. The sūtra Pitaka is taught for the sake of explaining both phenomena, Dharma, and the meaning thereof. Whereas the Vinaya Pitaka is taught for the sake of actually realizing dharma. And the third basket, the basket of Abhidharma is explained for the sake of becoming learned in the meaning and the divisions of dharma and phenomena.
So dharma here refers to nouns, syllables and letters whereas the meaning of dharma refers to the topic or the subject thereof. Alternatively, dharma and meaning can be explained as follows: state of omniscience which is to be attained, and meaning are the 37 limbs of enlightenment leading to it. And what is mainly explained in the first basket, the basket of Vinaya, is how to abandon the 10 non-virtues, how to realize the 10 virtues, and the 37 limbs of enlightenment. Therefore, it is in dependence on these nine reasons that the totality of the Buddha’s teachings are summarized into the three baskets. And the topic of these three baskets is the subject of the Buddha’s teachings, which is the training in ethics, the training in concentration, and the training in wisdom.
Therefore, these were taught mainly to explain to beings how to train in the three practices or the three trainings. The first training, the training of ethics which is taught by the Buddha is of benefit to both oneself and to others. The ethics which is taught by the non-Buddhist tirthikas, non-Buddhist Indian practitioners, which includes subjecting one’s body to austerity such as dwelling between the five fires, one in each direction and the sun above, sitting in water or burying oneself in the sand are of no benefit either to oneself or to others. This is the reason for which the Buddhist system of ethics is superior to the system of ethics of the non Buddhists. Likewise, the Buddha’s teachings on concentration act as an antidote to numerous afflictions and conceptual fancies.
Let alone realizing happiness in this life, in dependence on them one realizes happiness is in many lives. And in dependence on this one can obtain ultimate happiness. The samadhis or the concentrations of the non-Buddhist merely prevent the mind from wandering to the outside. With them, one can attain happiness in this life. And they have no capacity to lead one in future lives beyond the state of rebirth as a god of the form or the formless realms.
The concentrations which are explained in the shastras, the scriptures of the non-Buddhist Indian practitioners have no capacity to eliminate the afflictions. This is why the Samādhi training taught in the Buddhist tradition is superior to that taught in the non-Buddhist Indian traditions. Finally, regarding the training in wisdom, the training in wisdom in the Buddhist tradition has the capacity to eliminate both of the misconceptions of the self. Whereas the so called trainings in wisdom of the non-Buddhist Indian traditions do not understand the actual nature of phenomena. For this reason, the training in wisdom in the Buddhist tradition is superior to that in the non-Buddhist Indian traditions.
For this reason, the Buddhist three trainings are called the superior three trainings. Why are they called superior? They are called superior because they are superior to these three trainings which exist in the non-Buddhist Indian traditions. Now we are not saying that they are superior because we are biased towards our own position as Buddhists. But because if one analyzes the actual state of reality, one will find that they are in accordance with reality.
I will stop here for today. Then the next time Geshe-la will start explaining the 10 non virtues and the way to abandon them. And as this is extremely important, he will proceed slowly. I will make no effort to complete the text in the allotted time since if I were to do so, we would not enter into things in detail. And therefore we will proceed slowly so that things are clear.
And if you have any doubts, please clear them up with Geshe-la. Then if you have questions, now is the time to ask them. In the Dalai Lama’s text, the Kamalaśīla text, which is not what’s being taught today, but it’s important to get the distinctions right. The three baskets are referred to collections. One is the collection of knowledge, one is the collection of discourses, and one is the collection, I think, of wisdom.
Which collection belongs to which? Basket of discipline, basket of concentration and basket of wisdom. So the first basket is a basket of discipline. That would be said what? Vinaya, yes.
The second basket is a basket of concentration or Samādhi. And the third basket is a basket of wisdom or prajna. Okay? They translate collection, we say basket. The meaning is the same.
Did you benefit from these teachings on the aggregates, the sources and the constituents or not? There’s a lot of subdivisions. But apart from the fact that there’s a lot of subdivisions, it is actually not difficult. And when one studies Buddhist philosophy, there are lot of debates about this. Right.
So this is an acute debate on the 18 constituents because in the 18 constituents, only one eye is posited. Then the debate runs, well, aren’t there two? Constituents, but there are twenty, twenty two or whatever since there are two eyes, two ears, their respective sense organs and so forth. You And then there are other debates, why are there two eyes since after all one eye is sufficient to perceive four? So the Vaibashikas have the strangest of answers.
They say it’s true that one eye is sufficient to see forms but to see the beauty of forms you need two eyes. And then they say having one ear would be sufficient, but if you have two ears, it’s quite grand. These explanations of the subdivisions of phenomena are really rooted in the Vaibashika tradition. So I had to explain this theory of evolution in thirty seconds in Tibet, which is rather nice, I think. Then Vishnu said, well if that is what the theory of evolution says then obviously three or four eyes would be better wouldn’t they?
That I explained to him. He said following your line of reasoning, the more the better. That is true. There are spiders. Are there other questions?
And the protector is a mundane goddess called Khamasha. She has only one eye. Geshe, the fourth composition of factors, I just wonder if Fourth aggregate. Fourth aggregate, just to elaborate on some of the mental factors that are included in that. Generally speaking, there are 51 mental factors.
From within these 51 mental factors to the mental factor of sensation or sometimes feeling in English and discrimination are rated as aggregates in their own right. The remaining 49 mental factors are included within the aggregate of compositional factors, the fourth aggregate. There are numerous other presentations of the mental factors with more than 51 mental factors, but this is the main one. And the reason for which within these 51 mental factors, the mental factor of sensation and of discrimination are isolated and qualify as aggregates in their own right is because of their importance. The aggregate of sensation enables us for instance to know when we touch a piece of wood whether it is rough or not and gives rise to sensations on that basis.
The aggregate of discrimination enables us for instance to discriminate between correct views and erroneous views. For this reason, they are removed from the 51 and qualify as aggregates in their own right. Is that the case? We can see with human experiences, even in Australia, see, when you say this is my land but this is your land, that you have first discrimination and then feelings which arise. Or if a nomad in Tibet were to say, this is my livestock, that is your livestock, again this involves discrimination and feeling.
Likewise, it enables us to discriminate between the views of the holders of tenets who affirm that there is an inherently existing self and the proponents of tenets who affirm that there is no such inherently existing self and to engage in debates between them. Geshe-la tried to give a very short introduction to emptiness. Did you understand what he was teaching? Then this is something you must investigate by yourselves because really without relying on one’s own wisdom of investigation and the experience one gains through that, it is very difficult to explain something like this. Yes, please.
Geshe-la asked before, is it a benefit to us? When Geshe-la asked before, is it of the way I’ve been applying it is by thinking about my desire for the phenomenon known as mum, my mother. Oh, your mother. Oh, okay. And reflecting on before I can remember, I would have perceived her not as a whole solid object, but as parts, as as a tiny newborn baby, as an eye, as part of an ear, as a sound, as a smell.
And something about studying these aggregates and breaking them down helps me understand that this is not someone solid, that she exists conventionally in her own right, but that she has no inherent existence. And that’s why this is helpful. Taking this as an example for emptiness is excellent. Excellent. Just regarding emptiness, would it be valid when thinking, about it to regard ourselves and phenomena as being more of a process than of, you know, than of a of a as an object that we are composed of many things that’s in a sort of state of movement, like a process rather than an exist object.
Not quite. It is clear that impermanent phenomena change instant by instant and they change instant by instant in dependence on causes and conditions. The fact that they’re changing instant by instant is one of the criteria for their being empty. So impermanence is used as a reason for emptiness. But you cannot say that impermanence is emptiness even though we see impermanent phenomena are empty.
So is the other side of that coin interdependence? The other side of which coin? Impermanence. All phenomena are interdependent. And does that then form the basis of emptiness, that combination of impermanence and interdependence, is that effectively emptiness?
The combination of impermanence and interdependence, is that emptiness? Yes. Well, you can’t quite say it like that. You can’t really say that impermanence and interdependence are emptiness. Emptiness is the emptiness of an object of negation.
That object of negation is the true establishment of phenomena. Then the meaning of interdependence is emptiness. So you can say that the nature of interdependence is emptiness. But you cannot say that interdependence is emptiness. We will stop here for today.
Since today is Sunday, it’s your day off. I’m sure you’re aware of that.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
- As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
- Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
When contemplating emptiness, is it valid to regard ourselves and phenomena as more of a process?
Not quite. Impermanent phenomena clearly change instant by instant, and they change instant by instant in dependence on causes and conditions. The fact that they change instant by instant is one of the criteria for their being empty, so impermanence is used as a reason for emptiness. However, you cannot say that impermanence is emptiness, even though impermanent phenomena are seen to be empty.
Is the combination of impermanence and interdependence effectively emptiness, and does it form the basis of emptiness?
Not quite. It cannot really be said that impermanence and interdependence are emptiness. Emptiness is the emptiness of an object of negation, and that object of negation is the true establishment of phenomena. The meaning of interdependence is emptiness, so it can be said that the nature of interdependence is emptiness. But it cannot be said that interdependence itself is emptiness.