2 h 12 min · 3,914 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen delivers a 132-minute commentary on emptiness and the nature of ignorance, the root of suffering in Buddhism. Opening with the importance of proper motivation—understanding that self-cherishing breeds faults while cherishing others brings all good qualities—he then explains how ignorance, specifically the mistaken apprehension of phenomena as truly or inherently existing, drives the cycle of rebirth. He contrasts this deluded mind with the wisdom that realizes emptiness, showing how these two are directly contradictory and how strengthening the latter eliminates the former. Using vivid examples including a rotating fan and an illusory woman created by ancient magicians, Geshe Jampa illustrates how the moment one recognizes the illusory nature of phenomena, attachment and other afflictions collapse. He then addresses how repeated cultivation of wisdom through hearing, thinking, and meditating on emptiness eventually leads to liberation and, for those who continue further, to enlightenment. The teaching concludes with practical discussion of Buddhist and scientific understanding of the aggregates. Pitched at practitioners engaged with emptiness teachings.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Line in 0119.mp3
UUID: ac57af71-a45d-4f2d-b5db-25107bd2fd61
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Rinpoche's Story
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,907
So one must have a good motivation both to listen and to explain dharma. And when we speak of a good motivation, it is that motivation which understands that self-cherishing is the root of all faults and that cherishing others is the root of all qualities and which through infinite compassion for all mother sentient beings as vast as space, wishing to place them in a state of complete and ultimate happiness bereft of all suffering. With this as a motivation, we should listen to all Buddhist teachings in general, this specific teaching of the three principal aspects of the path, and within the teaching of the three principal aspects of the path, this subsection on emptiness. So with this as a motivation, shall meditate for one or two minutes. Page one one b, refuge and bodhicitta for teachings.
If you’re not familiar with the Tibetan phonetic, you can look at on page two. Page five, Mandala offering. We recite the first and the last verse. As is said in the incontrovertible sutras, in other words, probably the perfection of wisdom sutras, he who sees the appearance of phenomena, the wise who see the appearance of phenomena as dependent arisings will not fall in mistaken views. And as Rinpoche explained last time in the light of the royal syllogism of dependent arising, that understanding of dependent arising as the reason for establishing the predicate emptiness in turn protects us from the two extreme views, the view of eternalism and the view of nihilism.
So one who understands the dependent arising falls neither in the view of eternalism nor in the view of nihilism. So one who understands the mutual dependence of dependent arising on the one side and emptiness, they are mutually affected. Emptiness itself depends on dependent arising and dependent arising depends on an emptiness, will realize easily emptiness and in turn will be able thereby to cut the obstructive afflictions which act as an obstacle to liberation and will attain liberation. So what is this liberation we are striving for? It is a liberation from the sufferings of the cycle of lives, from the suffering of cyclic existence.
This is a liberation we are striving for. So Rinpoche from his own side feels it is difficult for him to explain such a profound topic, and from our side, obviously, we have no understanding of liberation. He nonetheless will put effort in explaining it, and he would request us from our side to put effort in listening. And as to the root of the sufferings which we are trying to eliminate, Buddha Śākyamūni has explained their causes clearly. They are the three broad categories of afflictions, desire, anger, and ignorance.
And from among among these, the very root is ignorance. And to eliminate ignorance, we have to apply the antidote, the specific antidote to ignorance. In other words, that specific practice which destroys ignorance. And the specific antidote to ignorance is the view which realizes emptiness. That is what cuts ignorance at the root.
So when we want to apply the antidote, the view which realizes emptiness
To the root affliction, ignorance. It is indispensable at first to clearly identify that which we are trying to destroy. It is important to clearly identify ignorance. And then what is this ignorance which misapprehends phenomena? The ignorance which misapprehends phenomena is directly contradictory with the wisdom which realizes emptiness or with the wisdom which realizes suchness.
What is meant by this is that is that actually on one single basis and one single referent, two different minds can be specified. One mind which apprehends the basis in the light of ignorance, and the other which apprehends it in the basis of wisdom. One mind which apprehends the basis as truly established, inherently established, and established by its own characteristic, which is an ignorant deluded mind, and another mind which apprehends the phenomena as non inherently established, non truly established, and non established by its own characteristics, which is a wisdom mind. Specifically, if we were to take as an instance one of the aggregates of the five aggregates and posit this as a basis, wisdom apprehends that aggregate as non truly existent, non inherently existent, and not established by its own characteristics. Whereas on the basis of exactly the same aggregate, ignorance apprehends that aggregate as truly established, inherently established, and established by its own characteristics.
So the mind of wisdom which realizes the view of emptiness and apprehends the fact that the aggregates are not truly established, are not inherently established, and are not established by their own characteristics is an unmistaken, incontrovertible mind. On the other hand, the mind of ignorance, which on the same basis with regards to the same referent, one of the aggregates, apprehends it as truly established, inherently established, and established by its own characteristics is a mistaken, controvertible, and deluded mind. These two minds are directly contradictory. The incontrovertible, non-deluded, unmistaken mind is directly contradictory with the deluded, controvertible, and mistaken mind. Therefore, as the first increases, the latter abates.
So while the mind realizing emptiness can abandon the true, quote, unquote, existence of phenomena, The true mind, on the other hand, is nothing to be abandoned since this is what one wants to realize. So generally speaking, ignorance in turn is divided into two categories, that ignorance which apprehends persons as established from their own side, and that ignorance which apprehends phenomena as established from their own side. With regards to the mode of generation of these two ignorances, generally speaking, first, the ignorance which apprehends phenomena as inherently established arises, and then in dependence on this, ignorance which apprehends persons as inherently established arises. So this ignorance is a mind which imputes a nonexistent imputation on an existent basis. What is the nonexistent imputation which is imputed here?
It is the fact that phenomena, which is as we can call the basis of establishment phenomena, are considered by ignorance to be truly established when in fact they are not, is the imputation of true establishment, that they are considered to be established by their own characteristics whereas in fact they are not, and that they are considered to be established by an inherent nature whereas, in fact, they are not. So as said in one of his Lam Rim texts, it is capital to understand the mode of apprehension of ignorance, the mode of apprehension of a mistaken mind, because in dependence on understanding the mode of apprehension of ignorance, we can in turn apply the requisite antidote. So we have experienced countless sufferings in the cycle of lives, and we want to find a means to put an end to these sufferings. So the means to put an end to these sufferings is to cut the sufferings off at the root, and the root of these sufferings is ignorance. Therefore, it is crucial to identify clearly what this ignorance is an ignorance of.
And therefore, we have to understand what makes the wheel of life the circle. What makes saṃsāra go what go around? Now as Rinpoche explained, it is ignorance in general and from within the two categories of ignorance, which is the ignorance of the nature of phenomena and the ignorance of the nature of persons. The first category of ignorance is the more fundamental one, and it is this ignorance of the nature of phenomena which apprehends phenomena as inherently existing, as truly existing, as existing by their own characteristics, which in turn, when it observes the referent of the aggregates which constitute a person, such as a form aggregate and so forth, apprehends those aggregates also as inherently existing, truly existing, existing by their own characteristics, and through applying these nonexistent imputations on an existing basis give rise to the apprehension of a self of phenomena. This apprehension of a self of phenomena in turn gives rise to the apprehension of the I, and this gives rise to this powerful mind which says, I, I, which in turn leads one to the accumulation of all forms of karma, both virtuous and non virtuous through the afflictions, which impel us to take on another rebirth.
And this is how the wheel of lives is activated. And then through these lives, one can go to the peak of cyclic existence, is the highest realm of cyclic existence, and then fall all the way down to the lowest of the low realms.
So there is a quote in Nāgārjuna’s, the 70 verses on emptiness, the essence of which is that all phenomena can be said in the broadest sense of the term to arise from causes and conditions. And those impermanent phenomena which arise from causes and conditions are neither authentic nor can they be said to be truly established. Broadly speaking, there are two categories of phenomena, outer and inner phenomena. Both of these categories of phenomena, there were those which are subsumed by a consciousness and those which are not, can be said to be empty, thereby of true existence. And this emptiness of true existence is the actual nature of phenomena.
Its misapprehension is that ignorance which in turn acts as the root of the motor of cyclic existence which is the 12 links of dependent arising, which are constituted both of causes and conditions. The succession of these 12 links of dependent arising in turn gives rise to what we call cyclic existence. And therefore, the ignorance which apprehends phenomena as inherently existing, as truly existing, as existing by its own characteristics, when it turns inwards, it observes the aggregates, sees the aggregates likewise as truly existing, inherently existing, and existing by their own characteristics and apprehends them as such. in dependence on this ignorance, as Rinpoche explained briefly, the sense of I in turn appears, and in dependence on this, all the afflictions appear. So if one wants to give an example for this, a very good example would be, for instance, a fan or any rotating machine.
The fan rotates through electricity. So as long as electricity is being or as long as the fan is connected to electricity, as long as the power is on, the blades of the fan turn. If we want the blades of the fan to stop, we have to cut the power. So if we kill the power literally, then we kill the fan. In the same way, the cycle of lives is impelled by ignorance.
The ignorance of phenomena and the ignorance of the person. If we can kill, if we can which we use this term, if we can kill the ignorance, which is the motor of the cycle of lives, the cycle of lives stops in and of itself. And then the question arises, what precisely is the means whereby we can destroy this ignorance apprehending phenomena as inherently existing and apprehending persons as inherently existing. And the means whereby we can destroy this is that wisdom which realizes selflessness. So this is the reason for which we must generate this wisdom which realizes selflessness within our mind streams.
So as said, perhaps in his Four Hundred Verses, the view of existence is in the mind, and is therefore from the mind and so forth that cyclic existence arises. Now the meaning of this quote, Rinpoche says, is that the five sense objects and the sixth, the so-called mental sense object, which are the objects of observation of their respective sense consciousness, the eye sense consciousness, ear, nose, tongue, or bodily, and the mental sense consciousness are all apprehended by these deluded consciousnesses as existing in a mistaken, controvertible way, as existing as truly truly established, as established from their own side. It is merely a matter of reverting or reversing that mistaken understanding of the mode of existence of phenomena and seeing them as non truly established, non inherently established to cut the roots of existence. As Dharmakīrti, the great scholar of Pramāna of Buddhist logic said, one who realizes this abandons existence. And the meaning of this quote is that one who realizes the mistaken mode of apprehension of that ignorance which apprehends phenomena as true when they are not true.
Such a one instantaneously eliminates the roots of cyclic existence. So ignorance is this mind which apprehends phenomena as truly existing when they are not. And this is the mind which we have to put an end to.
So, further, he says, to give an example, he would like to mention the case of an illusory or phantasmagorical woman. The magicians of yore were particularly gifted in creating emanations or to illusion the appearance of being such as women, and these women were extraordinarily beautiful. They had a very beautiful form and appearance, very voluptuous, very soft speech, very perfumed and alluring. And these spectators, when they saw these emanated illusory women would be overcome with lust for them because they were so extraordinary in their appearance. And they would be completely crazed with lust until one of them was a bit wiser than the others would say, hey, wait a second.
She ain’t real. And the moment he said that, everyone would back off and say, well, yes. Right. What was I doing? So Rinpoche says, it is exactly the same thing.
This is an example which is given by the Buddha in one of his sutras. So if on the basis of a non inherently existing, non truly existing phenomena, you impute true existence in the same way as on the basis of an imaginary illusory woman, you impute a very gorgeous creature. Then having imputed true existence on this basis, great desire, anger, ignorance, and so forth, all the delusions will arise. The moment someone says to the spectators that the woman isn’t real, then the imputation of a lustful object on her collapses. In the same way, the moment the practitioner realizes that phenomena from their their own side have absolutely no true existence, all the imputations on that basis collapse.
So likewise it is said that, all it is quite straightforward to eliminate the imputation of a beautiful attractive woman on an illusory woman manufactured by a magician since all it takes is that for one of the bystanders to say she’s illusory for that mere statement to eliminate the imputation, it is much more difficult to eliminate the imputation of phenomena being truly existent on the basis of phenomena’s non true existence. And this is so because phenomena appear to ordinary beings as truly existent. They appear to ordinary beings as truly existent through the force of endless habituation over countless past lives. So it is much more difficult to meditating on emptiness to put an end to this misapprehension of phenomena as truly established. And the only way this can be done is through various means.
The various means are specifically the development of the three type of wisdom. The wisdom arisen from hearing, thinking, and meditating, and the wisdom that risen from hearing is mainly that wisdom that risen from attending teachings. The wisdom that risen from thinking is mainly that wisdom which arises from analytical reflection on emptiness over and over again, and not just analytical reflection on emptiness using an ordinary mind, but analytical reflection on emptiness using a pramāna, a valid cognizer, and then in dependence on this pramāna, but not on this pramāna alone, also in dependence on quotes from scripture, one then engages in the development of the wisdom arisen from meditation. And the wisdom arisen from meditation should also be developed in dependence on a pramāna, on a valid cognizer. And one trains again and again in this wisdom arisen from meditation until one gains something akin to an experience of the object meditated upon.
It’s this experience of emptiness which eventually will eliminate the root of cyclic existence. So through repeated familiarity by meditating on emptiness, eventually, one can hope to attain the state of an arhat. And an arhat is a being who has eliminated the very root of cyclic existence. He has eliminated that mind which apprehends phenomena as truly existent, and therefore, he has eliminated all suffering. Because he has eliminated all suffering, all that exist in his mind is happiness.
So his mind is completely suffused with happiness, but he has not eliminated all thoughts because he has not eliminated the apprehension. He has not eliminated self-cherishing. The reason he has not eliminated self-cherishing is because the only antidote to self-cherishing is that mind of bodhicitta. So at this point, the arhat trains in bodhicitta, and through repeated training in bodhicitta, eventually eliminates the mind self-cherishing, maintains a state of full enlightenment. A fully enlightened being is a being who cherishes others infinitely more than himself.
And Rinpoche says, if we analyze our behavior, we can see that we ourselves, through cherishing only ourselves and not cherishing others, have arrived nowhere in our lives, while the fully enlightened beings, through cherishing only others, have reached not only liberation, but omniscience. Very, very good.
Rinpoche says that, basically, when we enter authentically in practice, it becomes critical to eliminate the two main obstacles respectively to liberation and to enlightenment. So says that, generally speaking, both scientists and Buddhists use the same tool. Since scientists accept only one of the five aggregates, which is the form aggregate. This aggregate, they have investigated remarkably well using analytical reasoning and experiments on an extraordinary scale so that Buddhists say their understanding of discrimination, volition, and consciousness, and because they do not accept them and for that matter discard them, then their understanding of past and future lives is nonexistent for all practical purposes. On the other hand, from Buddhist understanding is indeed more profound.
So there is at present a meeting of minds with scientists from the one side contributing what can be seen in the lens of their microscope to Buddhism and having on their side great the discoveries which have been made by Buddhist science in the understanding of the mind using valid cognition.
So So the question is, are one’s heart, lungs, blood, bones, excrement, etcetera, considered to be part of one’s form aggregate? So Rinpoche says, well, basically, the form aggregate arises from the spermatozoa of the father and the egg of the mother. And in traditional Tibetan medicine, it’s considered that the spermatozoa of the father contributes substances such as bone, brain, and marrow to the body of the offspring, while the egg of the mother, what is technically called the blood of the mother, contributes such substances as skin and flesh as well as the organs in the body. So all of these are part of the form aggregate of the child, of the being which is born from them. However, with respect to excrement, urine, and so forth, excrement, urine, and so forth are formed, they are matter, but they are not part of the form aggregate of the being.
They are merely matter which is produced in the process of digestion through the decay of the food which is ingested. You know, So the question is regarding the aggregate of consciousness, is consciousness or our consciousness and, quote unquote, knower synonymous? Rinpoche says, no. They are not. From within the five aggregates, the last aggregate, the aggregate of consciousness is necessarily a main mind, a principal mind.
It has many mental factors which are included in the three previous aggregates, which are feeling, discrimination, and recognition. It’s often called recognition. So these three are mainly secondary minds or mental factors, while the last aggregate is a primary mind. On the other hand, a knower can be both main minds and mental factors. In the same way as a principal mind or a main mind is compared to a king and the mental factors are compared to the servants or the entourage of the king, which serve the king and surround him.
So to give an example, Rinpoche says, an instant of visual consciousness would be a main mind. That instant of visual consciousness is surrounded by many mental factors such as the happy or unhappy feelings associated with that main mind, the discrimination that main mind performs between various visual objects, and the volitional aspects of that main mind. These are all mental factors surrounding the main mind. Okay. Verse nine.
I have to get out. You get my lunch? Hello. I have a couple of announcement. Excuse me.
Can you give me one second? Spare your tongue, please. Okay. The Geshe-la’s teachings on Sunday this Sunday, there will be no teaching and, you know, following Sunday. And, also, this Wednesday night teaching, you know, is every four sessions, then the fifth fifth Wednesday will be a discussion.
I think last maybe some of you maybe not here last time, but Rinpoche encouraged that, you know, to come along for the discussion group that you can learn. And if you want to learn further, I think it’s a good idea to take transcribe on a previous teaching so that you please see Mark, and it only cost $1. And so that’s that. And yeah. Discussion will be the first, you know, the the among the students.
And later, you know, the Geshe-la and I will be here maybe, you know, one hour later or, yeah, before that. I’m not sure yet, but, yeah, something like that. And there’s a compassion day on the May 9 and also April 25, which is the foundation day. And if you have time, please come and join. It’s our fourth anniversary, and we have a very special celebration for our new Gompa.
And so please join. And there is a compassion day on the May 9. And October retreat, now due to the, what do they call, economic downturn so that we’re not going to be held up long at a camp. And it’s going to be here at the center, and it will, you know, help for a low cost for the everyone. And, this will help more people to be able to afford and to able to come.
Really, we this is an extremely rare teaching, and we are very fortunate that Rinpoche accepted, and he’s going to give this teaching. So and it’s going to be a much, much low cost. And so it will be a ten day. And no. I think it’s eleven day, I reckon.
Anyway, and the the course of the retreat will be shortly announced sometime very soon. And so I think that’s all I have to say. And yeah. And if I’d like to ask anybody who are staying on the Western Side. And if you’re going towards working on a city, I think it would be nice if you can let me know because Geshe la will soon he’s going to go to what you call the English class at Randwick Mall so that it’d be nice I mean, sometimes nice to catch a bus, but sometimes it may be more convenient for if somebody going through towards city, maybe pick him up and drive him there.
Yeah. If you have staying on this side of the the town, that would be ideal. Otherwise, that’s it. Yeah. Thank you very much.
And there is a chai, And please enjoy your chai. And come forward and help yourself. And yeah.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- mandala offering
- The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
- The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Are the heart, lungs, blood, bones and excrement considered part of one's form aggregate?
The form aggregate arises from the father's spermatozoa and the mother's egg. In traditional Tibetan medicine, the father's spermatozoa contribute substances such as bone, brain and marrow to the offspring's body. The mother's egg, technically called the blood of the mother, contributes substances such as skin and flesh, as well as the organs. All of these are part of the form aggregate of the child, the being born from them. Excrement, urine and so forth are matter, but they are not part of the being's form aggregate. They are merely matter produced in digestion, through the decay of the food that is ingested.