Rinpoche’s Story

1 h 51 min · 3,755 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this nearly two-hour commentary on the opening verse of the Three Principles of the Path, Ilia S. Durovic presents a detailed Madhyamaka analysis of how dependent origination serves as the logical foundation for realizing emptiness. He walks through the royal syllogism—all phenomena of saṃsāra and nirvana are empty of inherent existence because they are dependent arisings—examining how this reasoning protects against the extremes of eternalism and nihilism. The teaching distinguishes between the Svatāntrika and Prāsaṇgika schools’ approaches to countering these extremes, emphasizes the critical importance of identifying the object of negation (the false sense of a partless, independent self), and illustrates how meditators can recognize this misapprehension in powerful emotional moments. Pitched at serious practitioners studying Tibetan Buddhist philosophy and seeking to establish the logical foundation for emptiness meditation.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Line in 0120.mp3

UUID: 014150ac-935e-4ab9-b2ad-e11cf3a600d4

Teacher: Ilia S. Durovic

Collection: Rinpoche's Story

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~3,747

So there is great benefit in listening to teachings such as this teaching principles of the path with the appropriate motivation, which is generally from the standpoint both of the hearer and from the standpoint of the teacher, a good motivation. Now within the various good motivations, the supreme of all good motivations is that motivation of bodhicitta, which aspires to attain full enlightenment for the benefit of others. If we can generate such a motivation for a mere five minutes, the benefit derived thereby is almost inconceivable. So this is what we should train into, and this will in turn give great flavor to the teachings we receive into our practice. So reflecting on the fact that we are only one and mother sentient beings are infinite in numbers, we should cherish them infinitely more than ourselves.

And if we analyze carefully, we will find that without exception, every single one of them has been both father and mother to us an infinite number of times. And then we will realize in turn that we from our side would like to place them in a state endowed with all qualities and freed from all faults. We do not have the capacity to do so at present and must strive to attain ourselves a state where we can do so. And this is the generation of the motivation of bodhicitta. So if we meditate on generating this motivation for one or two minutes and then listen to the teachings, there would be great benefit.

All the preliminary prayers, Page one is the Tibetan, and the page two is in English. If you’re not familiar with the Tibetan phonetic, then please you can read on page two. We start with the one b. Page five. Mandala offering verse six.

We recite the first and the last verse. John.

So says, we have now entered the explanation of the view in the context of the three principles of the path, and this focuses specifically on the way to meditate on the view. Now because these instructions were imparted to Je Tsongkhapa by Mañjuśrī himself, they are uncommonly clear as they well should be. And Rinpoche will therefore comment in detail on the verses in question, which I will retranslate to keep the sequence of the verses. He who of all phenomena of saṃsāra and nirvana sees the incontrovertible causal relation will destroy totally the target of observation and will enter thereby in the path which pleases all Buddhas. Commenting on this verse, Rinpoche says that the first word of the verse, he, is a relative pronoun in Tibetan.

It refers to the totality of practitioners who sees all phenomena of saṃsāra and nirvana, which means the totality of phenomena which act as the basis on which emptiness is predicated. And continuing with the second verse, sees as incontrovertible the causal relationship. The second verse here is actually the reason of dependent origination on which basis the predicate emptiness is affirmed. So this is obviously through these two verses an allusion to the royal syllogism. Moving onwards, the third verse reads, will destroy completely the target of observation.

Now the term destroy here refers specifically to emptiness. Well, completely, Kun in Tibetan, is a qualifier, which refers to the totality of imputations on the basis of all phenomena, samsaric existence and nirvana, imputations such as being established inherently by their own characteristics, true establishment, and so forth. And the target which is observed or the target of observation, which is quite unfortunately translated in English by false perceptions, actually refers to that wisdom which apprehends phenomena as true existence. And therefore, going in even greater detail in the analysis of this stanza, which alludes to the royal syllogism, the first verse of the stanza, he who of all phenomena of saṃsāra and nirvana, that first verse posits the subject of the the royal syllogism. The subject of the royal syllogism is the totality of phenomena referred to by saṃsāra and Nirvāṇa.

And this means the totality of all phenomena from the form aggregate of ordinary beings all the way up to the omniscient mind. The form aggregate of ordinary beings in this context is to be understood as alluding actually to all five aggregates, in keeping with the famous quote from the Heart Sūtra which says, all five aggregates are to be seen as completely empty of any inherent existence. In addition to this, all of the phenomena both of saṃsāra and nirvana, such as the grounds and paths, all of the realms, the 12 links of interdependent origination and so forth, all of these are included in this subject, which is extraordinarily vast, and the Tibetan term tamche, all at the end, emphasizes this. The second verse of this stanza, who sees as incontrovertible causally related phenomena refers in turn to dependent origination, which is actually the reason in the royal syllogism, which in turn demonstrates emptiness. So to put this stanza in syllogistic form, the syllogism would read or the consequence specifically would read the subject cyclic existence and nirvana is empty of inherent existence because it is a dependent arising which arises from incontrovertible causes.

This is a classic formulation of the Royal syllogism. It is capital to generate an understanding of emptiness in dependence on such a syllogism or such a consequence. One cannot generate an understanding of emptiness based on the consequence, the subject, cyclic existence, and Nirvāṇa are empty of inherent existence because they’re empty of inherent existence since the reason then presupposes the predicate. It is a redundant syllogism. So such practices are fundamental to lead us to an understanding of emptiness without which on the basis of mere renunciation and mere bodhicitta, there can be neither liberation nor all the more so full enlightenment.

Now regarding the royal syllogism, the subject, cyclic existence in Nirvāṇa, is empty of inherent existence because of being a dependent arising. It is important to understand the various levels of understanding of dependent arising. All Buddhist traditions acknowledge that certain categories of phenomena are dependent arising. The three lower schools, the Vaibhāṣikas, the Sautrantikas, the Chittamatras consider that things, in other words impermanent phenomena, which are eo ipso causally related phenomena, are dependent arisings because the effects thereof arise from causes. So they acknowledge exclusively causal dependent arisings.

The lower of the two Madhyamaka schools, the Svatāntrika Madhyamaka school has a more subtle understanding of dependent arising, understanding dependent arising in terms also of being structured in terms of components or parts. So wall for the three lowest schools, dependent arising are necessarily impermanent. For the Svatāntrika Madhyamaka school, dependent arising phenomena are not only impermanent, but they can also be non impermanent phenomena, but it’s permanent phenomena. Finally, for the Prāsaṇgika school, which has the most subtle understanding of dependent arising, dependent arising is to be understood as all of the above as well as the understanding that all phenomena are mere nominal and conceptual imputations on the basis of a basis of designation. This process is best understood if we use, for instance, the example of a person.

A person is a mere nominal and conceptual imputation on the basis of the five aggregates. The five aggregates are the basis of designation. The term person is a nominal or conceptual conceptual imputation. Now if we understand this process of nominal and conceptual imputation, imputation thinks most probably realization of emptiness would follow almost immediately after.

Yeah. See what it is? So the big danger if one were to meditate on emptiness without using such a reasoning is to fall into the two extremes of eternalism or nihilism. The extreme of eternalism is that view which superimposes a nonexistent phenomena on an existent basis, such as, for instance, superimposing true existence on the basis of non truly existing phenomena. The extreme of nihilism, on the other hand, would be that extreme which would lead one to affirm that impermanent causally related phenomena actually do not exist even conventionally.

It is very easy to fall in these two extremes without relying on the reasoning of dependent arising, the royal syllogism. Now the ways in which the royal syllogism enables one to develop an understanding of the middle way without falling into two extremes is as follows. When we say the subject, all phenomena, cyclic existence, nirvana, it follows that it is not inherently established because it is a dependent arising. The reasoning of dependent arising here prevents succumbing to the extreme of nihilism because if phenomena are dependent arisings, specifically from the standpoint of the understanding of the three lower schools, are causally related. If they are causally related, then it seems impossible to say that something which has causes is nonexistent.

For instance, we would never dream of saying that the child whose parents we know is nonexistent because we know the causes. So, obviously, the child is in existent. So the reasoning of dependent arising precludes the extreme of nihilism. On the other hand, the reasoning of dependent arising also precludes the extreme of eternalism. It precludes the extreme of eternalism because if anything were truly established, inherently established, or established by its own characteristic, this means, Rinpoche says, that it is established as a non dependent phenomenon.

Obviously, if something is a dependent arising, an interdependent phenomenon, it is not a non dependent phenomenon. Therefore, automatically, it cannot be truly existing. It cannot be inherently existing. It cannot be defined by its own characteristics. Therefore, this reasoning eliminates the imputation on the basis of phenomena that they are truly existing or inherently existing.

This mere elimination of the nonexistent imputation on an existing basis is actually emptiness. So the two first verses of this stanza might seem to be sufficient in as much as they clearly point out the royal syllogism. All phenomena of cyclic existence and nirvana are not true establishments, are empty of being truly established because they are dependent arising. But it is a very uncommon element of the oral tradition here that the third stanza actually points out very clearly that process whereby we are bound to cyclic existence, and it reads through destroying all of the targets of observation. The targets of observation here are specifically that ignorance which apprehends phenomena as truly established.

That ignorance which apprehends phenomena as truly established is the binder, is what binds us to cyclic existence. And it is an uncommon feature of Je Tsongkhapa tradition that great emphasis is put on understanding precisely the ignorance because it’s only through understanding precisely the ignorance that one can apply an antidote to it and eliminate it. And if one eliminates it, then one eliminates the apprehension of phenomena as established inherently, as truly established, or as established by their own characteristics. Buddha, very, happy. And the last verse of this stanza reads, enters the path that pleases the Buddhas.

Now why would such a realization of emptiness please the Buddhas? It pleases the Buddhas because the goal the only goal of the Buddhas is to lead sentient beings to happiness, and that which prevents sentient beings from attaining both liberation and full enlightenment is the non realization of emptiness. So it is only through the realization of emptiness that it is possible to attain both liberation and enlightenment. Now more fundamentally using the two first verses of this stanza, a being who would meditate on the syllogism, all the subject, all of the phenomena of cyclic existence and nirvana are empty of inherent existence because of being dependent arisings would on the basis of the reason of dependent arisings realize the predicate, the emptiness of inherent existence of all phenomena of cyclic existence and nirvana. But such a being, which would most probably be a being of the Mahāyāna category, and in addition to that, a being of very sharp faculties, would then switch the predicate and the reason, and would also meditate on the syllogism, all of the phenomena of cyclic existence and nirvana, all phenomena are dependent arisings because of being empty.

And then switching from the one to the other, from the reason of emptiness going to the predicate of dependent arising, from the reason of dependent arising going to the predicate of emptiness, he would gain full and complete realization of emptiness. Such a being could only delight all of the Buddhas because such a being would perform his own welfare and reach a state of liberation or full enlightenment, bereft of all suffering, but more importantly, would also perform the welfare of others. This is why this verse reads, has entered the path which pleases all the Buddhas.

So from within the Madhyamaka school, there are two subschools, the Svatāntrika and the Prāsaṇgika school. They have different understandings of what precisely counters the extremes of eternalism and the extremes of nihilism. Regarding the Svatāntrika school, the Svatāntrika school considers that in the royal syllogism, the subject, all phenomena of saṃsāra and nirvana, are empty of true existence because they are dependent arisings. The reason dependent arising actually acts as a specific counter to the view of eternalism, while the predicate are empty of true existence acts as a specific counter or antidote to the view of nihilism. Now this is the ordinary Madhyamaka position.

However, the Prāsaṇgika position, because the Prāsaṇgika school is much more subtle, is an uncommon position, and it is actually much more difficult to understand. The Prāsaṇgika position is that in the context of this syllogism, the which would read the subject cyclic existence and nirvana. It follows that it is empty of true existence because it is a dependent arising. The reason dependent arising acts as an antidote to the extreme of eternalism or the extreme of existence, or the predicate, which is emptiness of true existence itself, acts as an antidote to the extreme of nihilism or the extreme of nonexistence. In other words, as said, dependent arising acts as the antidote to the extreme of eternalism, and emptiness acts as the antidote to the extreme of nihilism.

This is very difficult to understand, and rare are those who will be able to understand this. What is being asserted is a dependent arising which is endowed with emptiness, and actually a dependent arising which can only function through emptiness. It is actually through the power of emptiness that causality is able to operate. And the independence of this, one can speak of dependent arising. So Rinpoche would like to point out the problems in the English language connected with speaking of shunyata as emptiness or even worse, nothingness.

shunyata is not a nonexistent and should not be understood as a nonexistent. shunyata actually is an existent. Emptiness is necessarily an existent, an existent. As is said in Madhyamakāvatāra, from the reasoning of emptiness, everything arises. And as it’s said in Nāgārjuna’s root verses on emptiness, from emptiness cause and effect come.

So this understanding here of the uncommon Prāsaṇgika position is very profound and difficult, and it is best to try to understand it in the light of a clear identification of the object of negation first, and then the realization that emptiness is the mere refutation of this object of negation, specifically the mere refutation of establishment by its own characteristics or true or inherent establishment. So says, each of the four schools of Buddhist philosophy has its own presentation of the extremes of eternalism and nihilism. And each of the four schools claims to cleave to the middle ground between these two extremes. So for the Vaibhāṣika school, the which considers that the cause disappears before the effect arises and that each phenomena has three instance, an instant of arising, abiding, and destruction, that nonexistence of the cause at the time of the effect eliminates the extreme of eternalism, while the existence of the effect eliminates the extreme of nihilism. The Sautrāntika school has a completely different understanding of these two extremes.

The Sautrāntika school considers that all impermanent phenomena change instant by instant. One instant is defined as one sixty fifth of the interval of time taken for a strong healthy man to snap his fingers. And this is what or this this impermanence of phenomena is what eliminates the extreme of eternalism or of existence. All the fact that phenomena are being destroyed instant by instant eliminates excuse me. The fact that phenomena arise instant by instant from causes eliminates the extreme of nihilism.

Now regarding the Cittamātra school, the Cittamātra school asserts three natures, imputed natures, other powered natures, and thoroughly established natures. Generally speaking, for the Cittamātra school, imputed natures are considered to be non truly established, while other powered natures are considered to be truly established. For the cittamatras, the fact that other powered natures are not truly established, excuse me, the fact that other powered natures are truly established is what eliminates the extreme of nihilism, or the fact that imputed natures are not truly established eliminates the extreme of eternalism. Finally, the Madhyamaka school with which we are more familiar asserts, and this is the case for both of the sub traditions, the Svatāntrika and the Prāsaṇgika, that that mere existence of conventional phenomena eliminates the extreme of nihilism, or the fact that phenomena are not truly established eliminates the extreme of eternalism.

I may summarize a bit. So the question is, can I speak for a few minutes on how reasoning and logic are valid cognizers? How can logic help us to identify the objects of refutation? So Rinpoche says this is actually a fundamental question. The thrust in meditation and emptiness is identifying the object of refutation.

Once the object of refutation is is identified, everything else is easy. This identification of the object of refutation is very difficult. The best way to proceed is first through general reasonings, trying to understand actually what is being refuted. So philosophically, what is being refuted is the non true existence of all phenomena, of cyclic existence and nirvana. To actually understand what is meant by the non true existence of all phenomena, we must understand what is meant by the opposite of this.

What would be meant by the true existence of all phenomena? Now, obviously, phenomena do not truly exist, so we cannot actually realize this. But we engage in something akin to a thought experiment, thinking, well, let’s assume all phenomena were truly existing. What would the world be like? What would it this be like?

And we pursue this line of reasoning, trying to see all phenomena as truly existing to see whether it works or not. Eventually, we will realize that if all phenomena were truly existing, then there would be many logical contradictions. And then we will say to ourselves, well, most probably, phenomena are not truly existing. And then we pursue this line of investigation to see whether or not they are non truly existing. This is a reductio ad absurdum philosophical procedure.

However, it is capital to understand how that ignorance which apprehends phenomena as truly existing functions because that is actually the motor of cyclic existence. And the best way to understand how this ignorance functions is to examine our own self when a very strong sense of I arises. For instance, Rinpoche says, his actual name is Lobsang Thubten. And whenever someone says Lobsang Thubten, there’s a part of him which responds, yes, I’m here. But then if someone were to say to Rinpoche that Rinpoche had stolen something, then immediately this sense of I becomes very powerful.

And then there is a part of Rinpoche which would say, I have not done anything, and anger arises in the mind. Now at that moment, if we observe the I which is arising in the mind carried by this anger, we will find that it is an I which actually is partless or appears to be partless, appears to be independent, appears to exist by its own characteristics inherently. In other words, appears to be truly existing. This is the object of negation. So if we can identify this, then it’s very easy to eliminate because upon identifying it, all we have to do is see whether it exists as it appears or not.

And When we analyze, we will find it doesn’t exist as it appears. There’s a mental process of imputation of imputing imaginary phenomena on the basis of an existing underlying reality which occurs. And then what we have to say is these imaginary imputations don’t exist. This is actually emptiness. Likewise, for instance, says some who study a lot end up by being quite quite inflated by their studies and rather proud.

And then when they speak, there is this rather strong sense of of self worth which arises in them. Again, they can analyze the I on that basis. But it is capital to identify clearly the object of negation in the same way as we have to identify a target when we want to shoot an arrow or a rifle. Otherwise, if we just shoot at random, we will not hit anything. So whenever these very powerful emotional experiences arise, for instance, when we’re very frightened, if someone, for instance, starts screaming or shouting at us, at that moment, a very powerful sense of I arises.

This is the moment when we can engage in meditation on emptiness. So first analyzing clearly the object of refutation, this powerful inherently existing I which arises, and then applying the countless reasonings we find in the great scriptures on this, such as the diamond sliver reasoning, the reasoning of cause and effect, the royal reasoning, and so forth, until this inherently existing I is demonstrated to be nonexistent.

The question which I will summarize is more a person is alive, the current person Okay. Page nine. Mandala offering. Verse nine. Because our our dear friend is going to be leaving, then in keeping with the western tradition, we have a farewell party, and there’s a big present for him, which is a cake.

Sorry. Yeah. But he says that the interpreter translated for for many years at Buddha House and became really very much of a friend, and he will miss him quite a bit.

He feels a bit lonely. Okay. Thank you. Thank you very much. Yeah.

Yeah. Okay. Where’s the candle? Okay. And, please, there’s a child there, and the will be served.

Yeah. Okay.

Key terms in this teaching

Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
two extremes tha nyi (Tib)
Eternalism, seeing things as having an intrinsic reality, and nihilism, seeing things as having no reality at all. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top