1 h 36 min · 3,824 words · 17 September 2014 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 96-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche explains how genuine refuge arises from witnessing the profound transformation the Lamrim enables in great masters like Je Tsongkhapa and the Dalai Lama. He presents three scopes of refuge motivation: fear of rebirth in lower realms, desire for liberation from saṃsāra, and bodhicitta—compassion to free all beings. Two essential causes for sincere refuge are fear of lower rebirth and reflection on the immeasurable qualities of the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. He outlines the eight benefits of established refuge: becoming a Buddhist, becoming the basis for vows, purifying karmic obscurations, generating vast merit, protection from harm, freedom from lower rebirth, accomplishing all goals, and swiftly attaining enlightenment. Student questions follow on refuge’s relation to the spiritual teacher and conviction in unseen realms.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2014-09-17 – KR.mp3
UUID: 5c9b9aab-ec9b-4b88-a97b-396ff14a10bc
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Refuge
Date: 2014-09-17
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,818
This is the way one should look at things. If indeed, this Lamrim which teaches the path of the beings of the three scopes is something which we from the very depths of our hearts wish to study. Because it is something which we are convinced will lead us to lasting happiness, then it is something we ought to put effort into. Therefore, we have to ask ourselves whether for us indeed, this Lamrim, these graduated stages of the path are really important or not. And if they are important, then we should not study them in a casual haphazard way, sometimes attending, sometimes not attending teachings.
Instead, we should focus and study them in a systematic and concentrated way. If we proceed in this way, it is 99% certain that we will generate true refuge. It is not sufficient, therefore, to just utter the words, I take refuge in the Buddha and so forth, but instead to do so sincerely and to become a follower of the Buddha. This problematic approach to the Lamrim in which one does not relate seriously to the topic arises when one has attended Lamrim teachings for a long time, has meditated on and off, and has not gained any true experience, then one views it as a bit of a hobby. On the other hand, once one is able to relate the learning to oneself and one understands that the graduated stages of the path can lead to a durable state of happiness for oneself, then one studies a topic with intensity.
Then how and based on what reasons does such an appreciation of the Lamrim, the graduated stages of the path arise? It arises when we observe the great beings who have developed themselves to their utmost, thanks to the Lamrim, such as His Holiness the Dalai Lama, such as the holy teacher, such as Je Tsongkhapa, such as Atisha, such as the 80 Mahasiddhas of ancient India, or the 16 teachers who were an ornament of India. All of these beings reached their ultimate development through training in the Lamrim. Then it is in dependence on this type of reflection that true refuge arises. It is difficult for us to posit a definition of refuge, specifically from a standpoint such as the Prāsaṇgika viewpoint.
It is quite difficult, But true refuge arises when we observe the realizations of these holy beings who attained them through the practice of Lamrim. Then through reflecting in such a way, profound faith in the teachings which have been transmitted down from Buddha Śākyamūni himself will arise. in dependence on faith, conviction in these teachings, conviction of faith in the teacher of these teachings, Buddha himself, will arise. And in this way, all three gems of the triple gem, all three objects of refuge will have been taken as object. Now here, one proceeds through understanding the great qualities which holy beings of the past, such as Lama Tsongkhapa and other, has generated through the practice of lamrim.
Where we may be unable to give the definition of refuge, that is unimportant because basically, these lines of reasoning satisfy refuge. And then in this way, faith in the teacher, Buddha Śākyamūni, will have arisen and in dependence on that faith in the teachings, as well as faith in those who have enacted the teachings throughout history, such as Ārya Nāgārjuna, Āryadeva, and so forth. Once such a refuge has arisen within our mind stream, it is clear that it will draw on an understanding of sufferings of the lower realms, and these in turn will draw on an understanding of the recollection of death and impermanence. It would be impossible for an understanding of the recollection of death and impermanence to arise without having, if not, a valid cognition in the existence of past and future lives, at the very least, a conviction in the existence of past and future lives. To generate such a conviction for us is not easy.
It certainly is something which is accessible to through logic only to those who have studied in-depth, which is not our case. So one in general, one might say that the practice of the being of the small scope is a very profound practice. When we look at it in the way which has just been mentioned, we can see that the totality of the cycles of meditation on the practice of the being of the small scope have been completed. Then if we look at it in this way, it is up to us to ask ourselves whether or not the Lamrim is important for us, and it is not sufficient to babble away and to say, yes, it is so important. One must provide reasons for this.
There is no such thing as importance which is unjustified. It is on the basis of these reasons that conviction arises. Then when we inquire what motivation precisely should impel us in our study of the Lamrim, in this context, it is refuge which should impel us to our study of the Lamrim. Indeed, when we become lazy and slothful, it is through generating a forceful, a powerful motivation that one can once again study forcefully the Lam Rim. If this is not sufficient, then the recollection of death and impermanence can act as a prod for the motivation.
If one is unable to generate an intensive motivation, then one should recollect one’s own death and impermanence. This will fortify one’s motivation. And at present for a couple of seconds, we shall meditate on generating the motivation or on death and impermanence. It is said in the concise Lamrim, out of fear of the suffering of the lower realms, I shall definitely generate refuge. It is indeed this fear of the suffering of the lower realms which acts as the fundamental cause for taking refuge.
in dependence on this in turn through contemplating the qualities of the object of refuge, which are immeasurable, one generates an immeasurable amount of merit. And this contemplation leads initially to a conviction in the qualities of the object of refuge and eventually to a faith in the quality of the object of refuge. This is of extraordinary benefit during the period of greatest hardship of our life, which is at the time of our own death. Since at the time of our own death, if such a faith can be generated and a recollection of the immeasurable qualities of the object of refuge, which generates in turn immeasurable virtue, we ourselves will be shielded from rebirth in the lower realms. And, therefore, to give rise to this profound faith and conviction in the triple gem, it is necessary to have generated a fear of rebirth in the lower realms and the associated sufferings.
This can be generated either incrementally after generating the recollection of death and impermanence or conjointly with meditation on death and impermanence. In either way, the foundation of meditation on death and impermanence is the, at best, realization that we have a valid cognizer of the existence of past and future lives, but at the very least, a conviction, in other words, an understanding of the existence of past and future lives. Once this has been generated on this basis, one meditates on one’s own death and impermanence, then one meditates on the sufferings one would experience if one were reborn in the lower realms, and then single pointedly one searches from the depths of the one’s heart for an object or an entity which can protect us, and this is what amounts to refuge. Then in dependence on this, one searches for someone who can bear this burden for us, reflecting on the unbearable, inconceivable sufferings of the lower realms. This acts as the first of two causes for taking refuge.
The second cause is a reflection on the qualities of the objects of refuge which enable them to protect us. in dependence on these two causes, one is able to take refuge sincerely. Then the heart of such a faith arises through these reflections and through the waves of merit which have been accrued thereby. There are three types of refuge. The refuge of the being of the small, of the middling, and of the great scope, and they are differentiated in terms of the motivation with which one goes for refuge.
The refuge of the being of the small scope has just been presented. One goes for refuge motivated by the fear of one’s own potential future rebirth in the lower realms and the sufferings associated with it. The refuge of the being of the middling scope is a refuge motivated by fear of the sufferings of cyclic existence in general and a wish to be liberated from these. When one refers here to the fears of cyclic to the suffering of cyclic existence, one is actually referring in a nutshell to the suffering of one’s own contaminated aggregates, which are beset by desire, anger, and benightedness. Themselves rooted in self-cherishing or egoism, which itself is rooted in ignorance.
One has to differentiate here between two types of ignorance. Causing ignorance or ignorance at the time of the cause and resulting ignorance or ignorance at the time of the result. Causing ignorance is the ignorance which gave rise to the present contaminated existence, and this is what must be abandoned. One searches for someone who can teach one the means to abandon this, and thereby, one goes for refuge. Finally, regarding the motivation of the great vehicle, it is through reflecting on the fact that all sentient beings without exception are afflicted by all pervasive suffering and finding such a prospect impossible to bear that one seeks for means to liberate all sentient beings from this suffering.
At this point, great compassion arises and a profound faith in the capacity of the Buddha and the triple gem to free all sentient beings from this suffering. With this as a motivation, one goes for refuge. This is the refuge of the great vehicle. In addition, there are two types of refuge, causal and resulting refuge or result refuge at the time of the cause and of the way of the result. The presentation so far has been that of causal refuge.
If we take the case of the great vehicle refuge mentioned last, what would be an instance of the resulting refuge in the context of great vehicle refuge? Through understanding the sufferings of all sentient beings within cyclic existence, in other words, the fact that all sentient beings are afflicted with contaminated aggregates, one then searches for a means to free all sentient beings from this suffering. And understanding that if one attains the state of full enlightenment or liberation, it will then be possible to benefit all sentient beings. One then engages in the practice of the beings of the small, of the middling and of the great scope with this as one’s aim. Focusing on these practices with this motivation is the resulting motivation is the resulting refuge of the great vehicle.
Then there are similarities between the refuge of the great vehicle and or the generation of the mind. Since both the refuge of the great vehicle and bodhicitta have great compassion as their substantial cause. Likewise, both the refuge of the great vehicle and bodhicitta have full enlightenment as their object of observation. So one must analyze carefully through study to be able to formulate a difference between Mahāyāna refuge and bodhicitta. Clearly, there must be a difference since refuge is merely the gateway to the teachings, whereas bodhicitta is the gateway to the Mahāyāna.
Do you understand? Really? Yeah. Good. If one is able to generate fully characterized refuge within one’s mind stream, then one will experience the eight benefits of refuge, and it is most important to meditate on them.
The first is that one will have become a Buddhist. The second is that one will become a basis for all vows. The third is that one will exhaust all of the previously accumulated karmic obscurations. The fourth is that one will easily accrue a vast collection of merit. The fifth is that one will not be harmed by either human or non human, in other words, spirit entities.
The sixth is that one will no longer be born in the lower realms. The seventh is that one will be able to accomplish all one’s goals. And the eighth is that one will attain enlightenment swiftly. So the first characteristic, becoming a Buddhist or entering into Buddhism is to be understood as follows through having conviction. In other words, through focusing one’s mind single pointedly on Buddha Śākyamūni, one one has become a follower of Buddha Śākyamūni.
The second advantage or the second benefit of refuge is that one will become a basis for all vows. In other words, one will become a basis for the vows, the vows of individual liberation, for bodhisattva vows, and for tantric vows. Refuge is therefore akin to the foundation of the house. And the following quality is that one will accumulate easily vast collections. This was explained previously through contemplating the immeasurable qualities of the triple gem, one will accumulate easily a huge amount of merit.
The following benefit is that one will purify all previously accrued nonvirtuous karmic obstructions. The instance could which can be given here is that of king Ajatashatru who committed parricide. In other words, who killed his own father, thus accumulating a non virtuous deed of immediate retribution or a heinous non virtuous deed. After killing his own father, he, however, experienced tremendous remorse and turned to the Buddha to find a means to purify this and was able to do so. The benefit of not falling into the lower realms has already been explained, so I shall not reexplain it.
And as for not being harmed by human or nonhuman entities, A small anecdote will illustrate this. A monk who was the recipient of large offerings from lay people became in turn the object of the envy of a thief who wished to steal these offerings from him. And the thief devised a cunning plan to be introduced to the monk and gain his confidence. However, when he was introduced to the monk, the monk asked him to prostrate and take refuge first in the Buddha, then in the Dharma, and then in the Sangha. And at this point, the thief took fright at the prospect of committing a crime against such a being, fearing that he would die as a result.
Then, as to not being harmed by spirits, there are indeed such beings as spirits. However, when such a monk, for instance, goes out and takes refuge, spirits cannot attack him. Do you understand? Yes. Really?
The benefit of accomplishing all one’s goals refers to accomplishing all the one’s contingent and ultimate goals. Contingent goals refer to higher rebirth, whereas ultimate goals refer either to liberation or full enlightenment. Whereas the benefit of attaining rapidly full enlightenment does not refer to attaining full enlightenment within one’s short human lifespan, but to attaining full enlightenment gradually over the lives. So we shall stop here, and I will at present take your questions. About refuge.
Your question’s about refuge. Just refuge. You know? Chris, you just sit and pass the microphone around. Yeah.
That’s it. Exactly. Passing. Naturally. Good.
Good idea. It’s not appropriate for the director of the center to be rising all the time like that. My question about refuge relates to last week when Geshe-la asked us the three questions in relation to refuge and whether refuge was a main mind or a mental factor. And Geshe-la said that refuge is a mental factor. But I’ve been wondering all week whether it could actually be considered both a main mind and a mental factor because all beings have the seed of Buddhahood in their mind or Buddha nature in their mind, mind in their consciousness.
So from that reason I would be thinking, is it possible that it is a main mind as well as a mental factor? Refuge is a motivation. It is described as a focused mental conviction. Then motivations can either be main minds or mental factors. But in the case of refuge, because it is so much of an aspiration and a wish, I think it is a mental factor.
Refuge is also faith. Many forms of faith, but I think it is a mental factor. You spoke of exterior refuge, internal refuge, and what was the third one you mentioned?
I just I read that one about secret refuge. Secret refuge? It’s something I did not explain. There is a secret refuge, but I didn’t explain it. Another question.
In the outline relying on a spiritual teacher we’re instructed to regard our spiritual teacher as being Buddha but within the context of taking refuge Geshe taught last week that we should view our spiritual teacher for example, Khensur Rinpoche as the Sangha jewel, which seems to present a discrepancy in how to regard our spiritual teacher. Could Geshe-la please clarify this? There are two ways of presenting refuge from the standpoint of different mental continuum and from the standpoint of one mental continuum. From the standpoint of different mental continuum, one would posit Buddha Śākyamūni, for instance, as the Buddha object of refuge and Ārya Nāgārjuna and Āryadeva on the one hand and Ārya Asaṇga and his disciples on the other hand as the Sangha object of refuge. From the standpoint of one mental continuum on the other hand, one would posit Buddha Śākyamūni upon the attainment of the goal of full enlightenment as the Buddha object of refuge, but one would posit him as one who has not attained the goal, but has attained the level of the path of seeing, has therefore become an ārya being as a Sangha object of refuge.
Do you have another question? Just in regards to fear of the lower realms Faith or fear? Faith or conviction, sorry, conviction’s probably good. Conviction in the lower realms And in particular, Geshe has talked before about a conviction in the animal rebirth. But the conviction is a conviction necessary in the hot and cold hells?
And if that conviction’s necessary, if he could just briefly talk about a correct reason to develop that conviction in those lower realms. So in the case of animals, animals are obviously empirically observable. In the case of pretas or hungry ghosts, in Tibet, we had various, or there are various categories of spirits, such as the spirits of the king class, the gyalpo, and so forth, and one can sometimes observe phenomena such as objects, cups, and so forth levitating. This is the work of the pretas, or they can cause unexplainable diseases. In the case of the hell realms, we covered the hell realms, the hot hells, the cold hells taught in Buddhist scriptures a while ago in the Lamrim teachings.
I would suggest that you go over that material again. You said something about that the great teachers of whom taking appreciation in is part of developing refuge, and you said that something about the their teachings are transmitted down through Buddha. I didn’t understand what that was about. From Buddha. Buddha.
From Buddha. Okay. So the instructions of the Buddha were transmitted downwards and were eventually received by Nāgārjuna, by Asaṇga, and so forth, who analyzed them. This is the sequence in which it happened. However, from the standpoint of our own generation of faith, the process is the opposite.
Initially, we study the later commentaries, they lead us to a study of the works of Nāgārjuna and Āryadeva, and studying these works gives faith into the teachings of the Buddha. This would be the Tibetan word for this. I’m Natalie. Natalie has a question. Don’t throw the microphone.
Just going back to talking about the great vehicle this evening and once one has achieved bodhicitta and is a practitioner of the great vehicle, Geshe-la was saying that one then returns to practicing the small middling and great scopes, with this great motivation of the great vehicle. So I guess my question is, the practice small of middling and great scopes is more a cyclic kind of practice rather than a linear practice where you progress from one to the next and once you’ve done you’ve practiced one level you don’t need to practice that anymore because you’re in the next level So it’s more of a cyclical thing. Could Geshe-la talk more about that? So the confusion, I think, in both cases arises from the four or the forwards and the backward progression of the cycles of meditation. So when you want to generate these states of mind, you meditate incrementally in the various steps of the Lamrim, from the practice of the being of the small scope to that of the being of the middling scope, to that of the be being of the great scope.
However, when you want to understand how you arrived at here, what the causes of this are, then you look backwards in time, and to generate the practice of the being of the great scope, you must have done the practices of the being of the middling scope. To generate those as a being of the middling scope, you must have done those as a being of the small scope. This is called the reverse order. Need to be confused. In the preliminary practices and one gets to the point of taking refuge and generating bodhicitta, in some texts I’ve read that there’s an actual visualization of the objects of refuge and then later on in the preliminary practice there’s the visualization of the merit field.
However in some texts it doesn’t really differentiate between the two. Is there a subtle difference between the two? You speak of the six preliminary practices. This is the different modes of presentation of different teachers. Some teachers have one presentation of the field of refuge and then another presentation of the field of merit when it is invited.
Others do not. There is absolutely no difference from the standpoint of the field of merit and the field of refuge. It is the same thing. There is, however, a difference from the standpoint of one’s own personal attitude to the field of merit and the field of refuge. Yeah.
Yeah. Alright. Thank you. You’re welcome to stay for a cup of chai and a biscuit.
And if you haven’t seen the flyers already, two days teaching on emptiness: In Praise of Dependent Arising which His Holiness has suggested that we recite for the return, the rebirth of Khensur Rinpoche. So that’s Saturday, October 4 and the fifth. Thank you. Daylight saving changes on thank you Grant On that weekend.
Key terms in this teaching
- causal refuge
- The objects of refuge - the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha - existing in the mental continua of others, as opposed to resultant refuge. Only by relying upon these external refuge objects can we achieve our own internal resultant refuge. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- preliminary practices ngondro (Tib)
- The practices that prepare the mind for successful tantric meditation by removing hindrances and accumulating merit. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.