1 h 51 min · 4,889 words · 29 August 2012 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 111-minute session, Kyabje Rinpoche teaches refuge as a reasoned commitment grounded in clear examination rather than blind faith. He argues that real refuge rests on renunciation—a sober turn away from endless rebirth—and requires careful study of Buddhist texts and logic, not temple visits or statues. Refuge is taken in order: first the Dharma, then the Buddha, then the Sangha. He then addresses the spiritual teacher, drawing on Maitreya’s list of ten qualifications and Dharmakīrti’s epistemology to show why the teacher must embody ethics, concentration, wisdom, and realization of emptiness. He outlines three essential marks of a genuine student: impartiality, intelligence, and sincere effort. The talk closes with Q&A on faith, ambition, and valid cognizers. Pitched at serious practitioners.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2012-08-29 – KR.mp3
UUID: 6ce89693-a700-472a-9290-40cb0202cb0b
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Refuge
Date: 2012-08-29
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~4,884
Summer is coming soon. Seasons in Tibet and Australia are totally different. In the seventh of the Tibetan month, which corresponds to the September 9, we are in autumn in Tibet. And India, store. Mhmm.
And India, same. And India, same. Nepal. All is here. Maybe what?
Uh-huh. Or? Everywhere basically follows this except Australia. Australia. The conditions you have in Australia are exceptional, and it is very difficult to imagine any way in the world with such material conditions.
Certainly, India has nothing like this. So this is one’s good luck. Frankly, if one is a Buddhist, one can see this as one’s uncommon environmental conditions, a karmic result. As you know, there are three aspects or three different aspects of karma. The first is the karma of maturation.
The second is the result which is concordant with the cause. And the third is what is known as the environmental condition. A remarkable country with peace and harmony, quiet and peaceful. Not toasted. Foundation for our practice is refuge.
However, it is important for us to understand what precisely refuge is. One can naturally take refuge out of pure faith, but when one takes refuge in the Buddha gem, this Dharma gem and the Sangha gem, it is actually very beneficial to allow doubt to arise within one’s mind and as a result of this doubt to examine carefully the objects of refuge and refuge itself. If one does this, one’s refuge will become much more stable. Now when we take refuge, it is actually necessary to take refuge on the basis of renunciation or definite emergence. There are as you know two forms of definite emergence, near definite emergence and specific definite emergence.
Near definite emergence is striving for one’s betterment in future lives, more definite or specific definite emergence is full definite emergence. It is difficult for us to take refuge on the basis of full definite emergence, but we have to try to take refuge on the basis of mere definite emergence, in other words, to take refuge hoping for improvement in future lives. To do this, we must accept the existence of past and future lives. It is very difficult to understand fully past and future lives without study. Specifically, it is motivated by this mere renunciation, which is a striving for future lives and here when we speak of a striving for future lives, by future lives we refer to higher rebirths, it is therefore with such a mere renunciation that we should take refuge.
Here, what are the means for attaining definite excellence or higher status? The means for attaining definite excellence or higher status are first study. And on the basis of that study, an actualization of that study, a process of interiorization of the studies which become alive within our minds. This leads to a transformation and gives you that sense a certain sensation of sweetness as it as it were on one’s tongue. Then, in dependence on this, one can in turn practice.
Here in this context, therefore, first one must study and then practice and practice what in this context, the Dharma refuge, which generally speaking is two fold. It is subdivided into the truth of cessation and the truth of the path. Whether these are actually what one takes refuge in oneself or not is open to question. But through an understanding of what the Dharma refuge is, eventually faith and a conviction in the benefits of the Buddha refuge, our teacher Buddha Śākyamūni, in other words, arises. Therefore, initially, one takes refuge in the Dharma jewel and in dependence on the Dharma jewel in turn.
In second place, one takes refuge in the Buddha jewel. Practicing in this way what one has studied, one’s refuge becomes very stable. Then one finally takes refuge in the Sangha gem. One takes refuge in the Sangha gem through reflecting on the lineage of practitioners since Buddha Śākyamūni who have practiced the teachings of Buddha Śākyamūni. For instance, and his sons, and so forth, so forth.
Then in this way, one’s refuge in the jewel becomes stable as well. And therefore one must analyze carefully the relationship between renunciation or definite emergence on the one hand and refuge on the other hand. Here in the context of renunciation, Geshe-la mentioned that there are two types of renunciation, mere renunciation and specific renunciation. It is mere renunciation, in other words, the striving for betterment in future lives, which is the minimum indispensable for actually being able to take refuge. Therefore, renunciation precedes refuge.
In dependence on this mere renunciation, one takes refuge in the Dharma jewel, and then in dependence on the Dharma jewel in the Buddha and eventually the Sangha jewel. This presentation of taking refuge, so taking refuge initially in the Dharma jewel and then in dependence on that in the Buddha jewel and the Sangha jewel is rooted in Acharya Vasubandhu’s presentation of taking refuge within the root Abhidharma, the Abhidharmakośa of Vasubandhu, in which Vasubandhu presents taking refuge from the standpoint of the Four Noble Truths. This is an extremely important point. And therefore, one must initially be motivated by renunciation. One must be motivated by a striving for liberation.
One must be motivated by a striving for bodhicitta. In this striving for renunciation or for liberation, one is motivated by the striving facing the fear of samsaric existence and in striving motivated by bodhicitta, one is motivated by striving, aiming for full enlightenment. With these as motivations, it is possible to take refuge. This refuge we talk about is a refuge which is in text, which is in manuals. Without a careful study of Buddhist texts, it is not possible in Geshe-la’s opinion to take seriously and solidly refuge.
Now, why is this the case? Because it is actually upon studying these great works that we take refuge in their meaning, in the actualization of their meaning within our mind stream. This is what protects us. Just to take refuge in the triple gem, such as for instance the representation of Buddha Śākyamūni behind us is a very limited benefit. Why is this the case?
Because basically there is a small amount of blessing and that is it. Otherwise, it would be very strange if just going into monasteries or temples and taking refuge in front of the statues of the Buddha was any type of real refuge because basically what are they? They are just matter. How can matter give refuge? Think carefully about this.
It is actually through study and this actualization, this interiorization of study that one’s own mind is transformed and this is the benefit of refuge. Otherwise, merely formally taking refuge in monasteries and temples can at best implant some vague karmic imprints. It’s the way it is. In Tibet, for instance, people had a lot of faith. They would go to temples and monasteries with their hands folded.
But what the benefit was, it’s an open question. There are many Buddhist countries, it’s probably the same thing in all of them. And therefore we will meditate for two minutes on taking refuge based on renunciation. These lines of reasoning which are developed extensively in Buddhist logic is specifically in are of extraordinary importance for us. Dharmakīrti’s teacher, Dignāgā and Dharmakīrti himself lived more than one thousand years ago India.
Dignāgā was one of the great teachers at Nālānda monastery in India. And it is quite interesting to notice that all the study of Pramānavārttika has subsisted in Tibet, and actually the study of all four chapters of Pramāna Vartika, in the later chapters of which there are some extremely sharp lines of reasonings which are addressed to the non Buddhists. Nonetheless, such treatises were basically not composed in Tibet, which is a great shame because the non-Buddhist teachers which Dharmakīrti was addressing were men of exceptional capacities since many of them had attained both Shamatha and had had an experience of a type of Viparshana. The reason for which such treatises were not composed in Tibet is simply because there basically were almost no non Buddhists in Tibet. And precisely because of Tibet’s lack of non Buddhists, this very dynamic dialogue between Buddhists and non Buddhists which was so productive did not exist in Tibet.
As I said in the first chapter of for those wishing to attain liberation in what is related to liberation, initially one must be close to oneself. Now here what is related to liberation refers to full enlightenment or full omniscience and being close to oneself refers to training one’s own mind. And if oneself therefore follows a correct mind, in turn, one’s mind will develop in the right direction. If one follows a mistaken mind, one’s mind will develop in the wrong direction. Here, a right or a correct mind and a mistaken mind are distinguished in function of their relationship with their object.
A correct mind is a mind which apprehends its object in accordance with its object’s nature, while an incorrect or mistaken mind is a mind which apprehends its object in discordance or at odds with its nature. It is correct minds which we should rely upon. And therefore, if we follow a mistaken mind, we ourselves will be engaged in mistaken practice and in a mistaken path, whereas if we follow a correct mind, we ourselves will engage in correct practice and a correct path. It is for this reason that Acharya Dharmakīrti in the first chapter of Pramanavatika explained valid inferential cognizer. And this is the reason for which Geshe-la after consulting your translator proposes that next year at the center we have teachings on Buddhist psychology.
In other words, on what is known as Lorig or mind and mental factors. There is no difference between Lorig and the presentation of mind and mental factors. And then in dependence on this, we will be able to understand the difference between correct and mistaken minds. And it is in dependence on this that one would be able to be honest and forthright. Now generally speaking, we are honest and forthright, but through understanding clearly mind and mental factors we will be able to develop this.
And it is for this reason that Acharya Dharmakīrti in the first chapter of Pramānavārttika explains inferential valid cognizers. Inferential valid cognizers arise in dependence on a reason and there are countless debates between Dharmakīrti and his proponents on one side and the non-Buddhist scholars on the other side with their own position on what inferential valid cognizers are. Now inferential valid cognizers are nothing to be astonished by. There are inferential valid cognizers within our own mind stream. We simply are unable to recognize them.
Counters the position of the non-Buddhist scholars and expounds his own position to clarifying the nature of the reason on which a an inferential valid cognizer arises. Such a reason is known as one which has the three modes. The term and the English translation of this is quite poor, actually means is or prime mind, is after and is to ascertain. So it is a valid cognizer which arises after repeated ascertainment. Repeated ascertainment by means of what?
By means of a reason. And when Geshe-la was debating on Pramāna Vartika in the annual debates, which are held by rotation in one of the three seats, known as Jamyang Khyentse, the abbot of Ganden Jangtse monastery, who was a contemporary of Khensur Rinpoche and debated with him during the public debates at Buksa, the prison camp, and who was an exceptional scholar. During his preliminary advice to the monks debating on Pramāna Vartika encapsulated the totality of Pramāna Vartika, pointing out how the first chapter was linked to the second, the second to the third, the third to the fourth, and the first to the fourth, and so forth. It was an extremely beautiful moment because he was such an exceptional scholar. And this had a big impact on Geshe-la who thought there was really great depth in Pramāna Vartika.
And he has had the karmic imprint ever ever since. That is right. In the second chapter of Pramānavārttika, the focus of the second chapter is the establishment of Buddha Śākyamūni as a Pramāna being, in other words, as a being who is a valid cognizer. This is done very powerfully, not through a mere assertion of Buddha Śākyamūni as a Pramāna being, which would be a dogmatic assertion, but through demonstrating that Buddha Śākyamūni is not causeless but arises independent on causes. And he does not arise independent on discordant causes but in dependence on concordant causes.
And through such an analysis, it is possible to establish that Buddha Śākyamūni is a being who is, or a person, who is a valid cognizer, and in so doing, to counter very powerfully the position of the non-Buddhist opponents, for which only Īśvara, who is a permanent being, can be said to be a person or a being who is a valid cognizer. On what basis does one establish that Buddha Śākyamūni is a person who is a valid cognizer? It is initially in dependence on his turning the first wheel of the law, wherein the four noble truths are expounded and in dependence on their rational analysis, as well as in addition on his ascertainment and presentation of the existence of past and future lives. And the reasoning to demonstrate the existence of past and future lives are extraordinarily developed in the second chapter of mainly to counter the foremost Indian opponents of the who were the so called materialists or nihilists. In other words, the Charvaka or Lokāyata in Sanskrit.
Then it is in dependence on or an allusion to this that Je Tsongkhapa says, through reflecting on the linkage by karma and causality of past and future lives generate renunciation. It is very clear in this verse that if one does not understand the existence of past and future lives then it is very difficult to see how any renunciation could be generated. It is through reflecting on the existence of past and future lives and on karma and causality that we are able to turn our minds to the well-being of future lives and away from this life. If however, we do not reflect on karma and causality and on the existence of past and future lives and our minds are overwhelmingly focused on this life, it is very difficult if at all possible to counter, for instance, desire or the wish to steal. Since once our mind is focused exclusively on this life, it is the comfort of this life which is privileged above everything else.
For this reason Buddha Śākyamūni, in an extraordinary piece of advice said, I am my own protector, none but myself is my own protector. It is in dependence on this establishment of the existence of past and future lives in the second chapter of Pramāna Vartika that as a further development, the four noble truths are then presented. It is in dependence on the establishment of Buddha Śākyamūni as a being or a person which is a valid cognizer that within the context of the second chapter of the of the spiritual teacher occurs. In the verses which say, it is for the sake of the presentation of what is correct and abstention from what is incorrect that the spiritual teacher is needed. Otherwise, if it is for the sake of seeing at a distance, a telescope will do.
The function therefore of a spiritual teacher is to be a person or a being which is a valid cognizer. And this leads us directly into the Lamrim, Liberation in the Palm of Your Hands. Last time Geshe-la presented the eight advantages of relying on the spiritual teacher and the eight disadvantages of not relying on the spiritual teacher. In this context, it is important at present to understand what the function of a spiritual teacher is. A spiritual teacher must be a being who is able to teach the totality of the path.
Not merely a kindly or benevolent being who is able to teach only partial aspects of the path. Either a limited sūtra presentation of the path or a limited tantra presentation of the path. Why is this the case? Because if such a kindly, benevolent, but limited teacher gets a disciple who is of supreme capacity, who is brilliant, driven, enthusiastic, and dedicated, then such a disciple will waste his precious human life under such a teacher. This is a very powerful piece of advice.
Please reflect upon it. For instance, if one is merely satisfied with a spiritual teacher who is a ritual specialist and knows how to play the ḍamaru and bell and a couple of rituals which are set out on the table in front of him. Such a teacher will not satisfy the conditions. So one must understand clearly the conditions which are required for a spiritual teacher. Why is this the case?
This is the case because we must rely on a teacher who has received the uninterrupted transmission of teachings from Buddha Śākyamūni downwards through Ārya Nāgārjuna and his foremost disciple Āryadeva, Asaṇga and so forth. In other words, a teacher who can present the totality of the path. A teacher in keeping with the presentation at the graduated stages of the path will therefore do the job very well. Generally speaking, there are three modes of presentation of the spiritual teacher in keeping with Vinaya or the Prātimokṣa, in keeping with the Pāramitāyāna, and in keeping with the Mantrayāna. At present, since we are studying sūtra, the presentation which counts is the sūtra presentation, in other words, that in keeping with the Pāramitāyāna.
Says in in this critical passage using the instrumental case, since the attainment of all of the mundane and super mundane qualities depends on a fully characterized spiritual teacher as their foundation. Here, the sense is critical and when one refers to a fully characterized spiritual teacher, one is not referring to a spiritual teacher which has his eyes, his ears, his nose, his mouth, and so forth. So what are the characteristics of such a spiritual teacher in accordance with the Pāramitāyāna, a virtuous friend or a Kalyānamitra? In keeping with Maitreya’s Mahayanasutra Alamkara, the ornament of the Mahāyāna Sutras, It is said, a virtuous friend will be tamed, pacified, thoroughly pacified with superior qualities, enthusiastic, rich in scripture, having thoroughly realized suchness, skillful in expression of the nature of love and having abandoned sadness rely on such a one. These 10 qualities in the Mahāyāna sūtra Alamkara are the 10 qualities a spiritual teacher must have.
The first, tamed, refers to his being tamed by the first of the three trainings, the training of ethics. The second, pacified, refers to his mind being pacified by the training in concentration or Samādhi. The third, thoroughly pacified, refers to the thorough pacification of the afflictions by wisdom. The fourth, superior in qualities refers to his being superior in qualities to his disciples. Otherwise, there would be no point in having such a spiritual teacher.
The fifth, enthusiastic is self evident, whereas the sixth, rich in scripture refers to his being able to illustrate his teachings by numerous scriptural quotes. The second, the seventh, having thoroughly realized suchness refers to his realization of the correct view, the view of emptiness. Whereas the eighth, skillful in speech, refers to his being articulate. The ninth refers to his being loving. And the tenth, having abandoned sadness refers, according to Geshe-la, to his having attained renunciation.
Why should the Kalyana Mitra, the virtuous friend, the spiritual friend have such qualities? Because the disciple will eventually resemble the teacher or the spiritual friend he relies upon. In the same way as if you put a block of sandalwood, which is scented Indian wood, among other sticks of wood, they will eventually be suffused with the smell of sandal. Now here, what is referred to is that the spiritual teacher be superior as far as these qualities are concerned to the disciple. Now, if one is unable to find a spiritual teacher who has fulfilled these five qualities, it is said that the five fulfilling the five first qualities is adequate.
In other words, the three trainings in ethics, concentration and wisdom as well as being superior qualities to the disciple and enthusiastic. One might wonder regarding the 10 qualities whether there is not redundancy between the third quality listed, which is to be thoroughly pacified and refers to the training in wisdom and the seventh quality listed, which is to have thoroughly realized suchness. This doubt is not germane because the third quality listed to be thoroughly pacified refers to a wisdom which understands the view of all the schools up to the Svatāntrika Madhyamaka School whereas the seventh quality listed, which refers to a thorough understanding of suchness, refers to an understanding of the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka view. In the context of the seventh quality, it does not refer to a realization of this view by means of a valid cognizer but a mere understanding arisen from hearing. Don’t worry if you don’t understand the difference at present between the Svatāntrika and the Prāsaṇgika view.
This will come quietly over time and your understanding will increase. Said to one of his disciples that even if it is impossible to find a spiritual teacher with the 10 qualities fulfilled, fulfillment of five qualities would be adequate. These five qualities would be the three first qualities of being tamed, being pacified, and being thoroughly pacified, referring to ethics, to concentration, and to wisdom. And the seventh and ninth quality, which are a thorough realization of suchness. In other words, the realization of the view or an understanding of the view, and being of the nature of love because such a being will be of benefit to others.
However, in the present age of the five degenerations, there is a critical piece of oral instruction which says that there are three characteristics someone should have to be a spiritual teacher. First, overall, they should have more qualities than faults. Secondly, overall, they should focus more on the future than on the present and the future here refers to future lives. Obviously, nowadays everyone focuses on this life. And finally, overall, they should focus more on the welfare of others and less on their own welfare.
Think about this carefully and if you are able to find a teacher who fulfills these characteristics, then remember that the most important in your relationship to him is the advice he gives you. Why is it so critical to rely correctly on a well chosen teacher? Because if the teacher is not a person which is a valid cognizer in accordance with the second chapter of Dharmakīrti’s Pramāna Vartika and the teacher gives us wrong instructions, wrong advice, we will in turn follow a wrong path. For instance, if our teacher tells us in dependence on the practice of anger, you will become an arhat then 99.99% of us will follow directly such advice and following such advice will move ever further away from since anger and being an arhat are directly contradictory. Please understand that from his side, Geshe-la does not have these qualities and his motivation in presenting them to you is not to encourage you in that direction.
The quality he does have is that he has studied reasonably well and therefore he feel that if he expounds these topics, there is benefit for him in expounding them on the one hand and there is benefit for yourselves in increasing your understanding on the other hand. There is in other terms mutual benefit. It is said in the Lamrim that if one intends to be the spiritual teacher of others, one should check oneself to see whether or not one has the 10 qualities, which I mentioned in Mahāyāna sūtra Alamkara, and if one does not, one should generate them within oneself. This is excellent advice, isn’t it? Now this is from the standpoint of the qualities of the teacher.
What qualities should the disciples, in other words ourselves have? First, it is said in Śāntideva’s Bodhicaryāvatāra, these disciples should not be partial. This means that they should be stable and more importantly that they should not be prejudiced and should not cling strongly to their own position and reject violently that of others. In addition to this, the disciples should be intelligent and more importantly should have striving for understanding. Some are indeed intelligent, but there is no effort put in understanding.
Then you should check yourselves and see whether or not you are trainees from the standpoint of the Lamrim. And if you are not, please attain those qualities. And therefore, what are the qualities one should have in accordance with the LAMRIM? One should first not be prejudiced or partial. One should be impartial in one’s assessment.
In addition, one should be intelligent, have a good mind. And one must have striving. One must, in other words, put effort. If these three qualities are present, then one can say one is a disciple in accordance with the Lamrim. So what is meant here by being unprejudiced?
In the context of Abhidharma, is meant by being unprejudiced is not to abstain from analysis. It means to analyze carefully and in detail. And therefore, how would one proceed about this? One should engage in question and answer sessions. And therefore, in a nutshell, we should study the Lamrim and whatever we study, we should put into practice.
So Geshe-la has explained a lot today about these topics. How should we proceed? We should study carefully what has been explained and read as best we can the explanation in Liberation in the palm of your hand. I gave you the page numbers last time. And then progressively develop one’s understanding.
And therefore, we should study carefully the Lamrim and in dependence on this, as Geshe-la explained, improve our understanding of refuge and of the qualities of the spiritual teacher. We will stop here for today. And at present, Geshe-la will take your questions. If you analyze carefully what would the humility of such a teacher arise from? What is its cause?
If you look at the 10 characteristics of a spiritual friend in accordance with the Mahāyāna, one of them is being loving. Then a spiritual teacher who is loving is aware of the suffering of the disciples and naturally has the wish to help them. I think also the fact that the third of the general qualities of a spiritual teacher is that he or she places others mainly in front of himself. The presence of the subject in the predicate forward and reverse pervasion. In other words, pervasion and counter pervasion.
It’s very beautiful once you start debating about the three characteristics of a correct reason. In our case, we have numerous, inferential valid cognizers within our mind stream. We don’t really understand what they are nor where they arise from. And then another question. So regarding being driven or striving with effort, that is indeed identical with competitiveness.
And competitiveness is of two types. There is beneficial and harmful competitiveness. For instance, if you were to be competitive with Buddha Śākyamūni, thinking Buddha Śākyamūni has reached this state and so will I, this is extremely beneficial competitiveness. If however one were competitive with others and was abasing them, then this is negative. Yes, it does happen occasionally that there are miraculous phenomena through the power of one’s own faith.
Through the power of very great faith, it is possible for the mind to perceive things in a different way from normal. What Geshe-la is saying is that he would like to emphasize that we obviously must have faith in all of the representations of the Buddha, idolatry leads to no mental development of any type and this faith alone cannot lead us to the attainment of mental qualities. Mental qualities can only be attained through studying the great text and specifically the Lamrim and then practicing which is what is taught and interiorizing it. Think of your mind. You want the upward movement of your mind to proceed and the downward movement to stop.
It’s a mind one has to think about. Nothing. And yet the causality rests on it. Yet, what is it? Yesterday, you question?
No. No. Oh, yes. Okay. You’re saddened.
Probably, it is a. Yeah. So did you have a question? It’s an excellent question. No, it’s an excellent question.
Basically, all valid cognizers are mind without exception. However, one refers to Buddha Śākyamūni as a being which is a valid cognizer as an application of the term because of a partial feature of the term. The partial feature of the term which is applied to Buddha Śākyamūni is the incontrovertibility or non deceptiveness which are features of valid cognizers. Because the definition of a valid cognizer in the Prāsaṇgika school is a mind which is incontrovertible or non deceptive. Because Buddha Śākyamūni is incontrovertible or non deceptive, he is called a being which is a valid cognizer.
Alright. Tonight. Yeah, thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- five degenerations
- The degenerations that occur as human beings evolve over the eon of existence; they are: the degeneration of disturbing thoughts, of lifespan, of time, of view and of sentient beings. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lorig
- Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- Paramitayana Pharchin thegpa (Tib)
- The Perfection Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
- Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
- Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.