Public Talks — 2014-08-10

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Public Talks (Khensur Rinpoche)
Public Talks (Khensur Rinpoche)
Public Talks — 2014-08-10
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this three-hour public talk on August 14, 2010, Ilya Gerasimov, a Western Buddhist scholar, delivers a wide-ranging philosophical synthesis spanning physics, biology, Buddhist philosophy, and reincarnation research. Opening with a distinction between life (defined thermodynamically as dissipative systems) and consciousness (defined quantum-mechanically as the capacity to collapse a wave function), he argues that this clarification resolves long-standing confusions in both science and Buddhism. He then surveys empirical data—from Bell’s theorem and quantum mechanics to Stevenson’s verified reincarnation cases, near-death experiences, and psychosomatic effects—that contradicts materialism. He contextualizes these findings within Buddhist philosophy, showing that two schools (Chitamatra and Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika) align with quantum mechanics while two (Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika) do not. Finally, he presents the Four Noble Truths through concrete examples, especially Vijayaratne’s multi-life case study, demonstrating how karma and causality operate. Throughout, he emphasizes logical analysis over faith and urges practitioners to study Stevenson’s work alongside Buddhist texts. Pitched at serious practitioners and those interested in science-Buddhism dialogue.

File metadata (for organising)

File: puja-2014-08-10-kr

Teacher: Ilia Durovic

Collection: Puja

Date: 2010-08-14

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~24,281

So just before we get started, Angela isn’t here. She cooked for us today so I said that I would thank her now on your behalf and pass on our gratitude. And we’ve had food for the body, and so now we will continue with more food for thought. Thank you, Ilya. You’re welcome.

And my dear wife has made me two extra strong cups of coffee, so you better brace yourselves. The computer needs coffee too. So this is the last conference of this cycle where hopefully we draw all the strands together, and you get to assess whether there was method to my madness or madness to my method. I was going to be a preliminary recapitulation now, but I think it is preferable to defer it somewhat, and do it in a couple minutes after I have presented one last distinction I would like to make, which is actually very difficult to make without some of the work we’ve done over this weekend. It’s a distinction I have never heard clearly made by any, Buddhist, speaker.

It’s a distinction between life and consciousness. If you cannot make this distinction, you are unable to, specify the boundary of consciousness. And if you’re unable to specify the boundary of consciousness, where consciousness starts in evolution and where it stops, then it becomes extremely difficult to distinguish life and consciousness and to distinguish what is after all a biological phenomenon life from something which is not a biological phenomenon as we have established consciousness. For instance, both plants and chimps are alive, it’s clear. Chimps are conscious, plants certainly from our standpoint are not.

So what would life be? I start with the traditional presentation, the biological presentation, which I won’t insist upon because I think it’s frankly insufficient. Biologically, life is basically an electrochemical event. Life can be said to occur or a cell can set to be living when you have a boundary, the cell’s membrane, and you have a difference of potential, in other words an electrical difference between the outside and the inside of the cell boundary due to the exchange of potassium and sodium ions. This is the traditional definition of life.

A living cell is a cell or an entity which has such a boundary. This boundary is semi permeable and the control of the flux of potassium and sodium ions, is what basically enables a difference of potential to arise in life to occur. This definition is very limiting because for instance it does nothing to explain whether viruses are living or not. Viruses would be considered as occasionally alive when they’re inside a cell and occasionally dead. When we come to prions, which are even more primitive than viruses, again this definition, this electrochemical definition fails us.

Then there’s a much more general presentation, which draws on the work of one of my namesake’s, professor Ilya Prigogin, in thermodynamics. And you’d never guess thermodynamics has any relation with biology, but it does. Thermodynamics is the study of the exchange of heat. And it is perhaps the most fundamental discipline in physics. We’ve spoken over the last two days of the vagaries of various physical theories, how the special theory of relativity disagrees with quantum mechanics, and reciprocally, the three laws of thermodynamics are universally viable.

It’s actually thermodynamics which establishes the reverse irreversibility of time. And especially the second law of thermodynamics, may have heard about, is one of the most fundamental laws in physics, verified by every physical system. It simply states that a closed system experiences either a steady rate of disorder or an increasing rate of disorder. In other words, it’s a law which states that a closed system in which no energy enters will experience either at best stability, but generally speaking decay. Now this sounds trite, but it is perhaps the most fundamental law in physics.

Perhaps. And this decay is called entropy. It’s a degree of disorder of a system. So to put it a little bit more formally, the entropy of a closed system is an increasing function of time, it increases over time. This means that a closed system can never see its degree of order increase.

It is impossible. Whether you tested this one billion years ago or one billion years in the future, this is not possible. And therefore, if you have a closed system, in other words, not just a cellular membrane but a box, something which allows nothing in and nothing out, the degree of entropy, the blackness inside will increase. If our universe were a closed system, the entropy of the universe would increase over time. However, there are other systems, so called dissipative systems, and they are the ones which are of interest when you try to talk of life.

These are systems which allow energy to penetrate them and increase their degree of order independence on this energy. All life is an instance of a dissipative system. Now if you take a crystal, I don’t if you’ve ever in chemistry class tried to make crystals, You take a solution of salt, pour a lot of salt and so you saturate it basically and then whatever you drop inside basically triggers a crystallization process. If you drop and say a grain of rice, you find that the salt starts aggregating around this very regularly. Order appears naturally.

This is a classic case of a dissipative system. Life is a dissipative system. In other words, any living organism takes energy from the environment and uses this energy to increase its degree of order. We as human beings, as organisms do this. We ingest complex molecules of food, right?

Say, molecules of protein in a very nice steak or whatever. We break them up in their parts, releasing energy in their constituents, carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen. And then we use this these parts and this energy to increase our degree of order at the expense of, excuse me, the the steak. Right? So we are increasing our degree of order at the expense of the environment.

This is life, and all dissipative systems show this behavior whether it is prions, viruses, bacterias, or mammals. This has nothing to do with consciousness. It’s unrelated. So I would propose drawing and Prigogine’s work that we can simply define life thermodynamically. Living systems are occasional consistent dissipative systems, which are the vectors of information.

This means that living systems either increase their degree of order consistently, continually at the expense of the environment, which is a case of all unicellular organisms up to man and above, or do so occasionally, which is the case of viruses. The virus, when it is isolated, it does not do so. When the virus enters a cell, it uses a cell to increase its degree of order at the expense of the environment. And the other characteristic of all living systems, which I have not talked about and we just leave this on the side, is that the living system is a vector of information. This is DNA for the cell, it might be RNA for viruses, it is the information which enables it to construct itself, to construct proteins which on that basis will enable it to reconstruct itself.

This is life. Life is unrelated to movement. I have heard that in conversations His Holiness had with scientists, came to the conclusion that the best definition of life was movement. That is something I do not agree with at all. There are many organisms which are alive and not living not moving.

And there are many entities which move under the path of Brownian motion, let’s say, are not alive. Their definition is insufficient. But the thermodynamic definition is a very strong one, very strong. And I think it will stand the test of time. Then if this is a life, what is consciousness?

Consciousness we talked about. Consciousness is simply whatever can cause the collapse of a wave function. If it can cause the collapse of a wave function, it is conscious. If it cannot, it is not. And therefore, if we look at the relationship between life and consciousness, we can say that one is defined thermodynamically and the other is defined quantically.

So living systems, which we said are potentially dissipative systems, they can be dissipative, they do not have to be as with viruses, include plants, viruses, prions, human beings, turtles, whatever. In every single case, they increase their degree of order at the expense of the environment. Conscious entities cause a reduction, well, it’s technically called the state vector, it’s the wave function. I’ve used the old terminology from the nineteen thirties because that’s what everyone uses, in philosophy, but nowadays one doesn’t speak of a wave function but a state vector. Conscious entities can cause the collapse of the wave function.

Then the intersection of living systems and conscious entities are living beings which are conscious, like us. Human beings, mammals and so forth. But living beings which are not conscious shows a thermodynamic behavior we mentioned, they are potentially disciplinary systems, but they are not conscious. And we have a lot of beings which are conscious but have no bodies, such as spirits, bodily beings and so forth. They are conscious because they can cause the collapse of the wave function, but they are not living.

They’re not living because they do not increase the degree of order at the expense of the environment. So I think this distinction, is a very powerful one. The distinction between living beings and conscious beings. In one case, living beings are defined thermodynamically, and in the other case, conscious beings are defined quantically in terms of the collapse of the wave function. Then if we look at Buddhist philosophy in this light, I think it is very helpful.

So this is the last difficult bit. I tried not to inflict them to you in the afternoons, but that’s how it seems to happen. The time has now come for a synthesis, and as you can see in this drawing, the emperor is naked. The emperor here obviously is the dominant materialistic paradigm. So if we recapitulate, what are the general arguments against materialism and what do they prove?

Personal experience of consciousness. It doesn’t prove anything but it’s a very powerful argument intuitively. I think every single one of us experiences this. Then in biology the presence of altruism and empathy in non genetically related populations where there’s really no rationale anymore for altruism and empathy. In genetically related populations you can say that if you sacrifice yourself for another, well after all perhaps some of your genes are transmitted.

But in primates, let’s say primate groups which are in which the genetic relation is very low, it’s far from clear who benefits. Then there’s no rationale for altruism and empathy. Developmental psychology, as we mentioned this morning, the evidence of pre verbal unlearned ethics and linguistics, the poverty of stimulus argument. In other words, the various arguments we covered yesterday morning at the end of the morning. In every single case, there’s no mechanism and no rationale provided by materialist theories.

A materialist account of consciousness, which says consciousness is a byproduct of the brain, provides no mechanism for the private experience of consciousness, altruism, pre verbal ethics and poverty of stimulus argument, and provides no rationale either. There are however much stronger arguments, as we mentioned yesterday afternoon, drawn from physics. We pointed out that in von Neumann’s of quantum mechanics, the observer of subatomic phenomena who causes the collapse of the wave function or the reduction of the state vector must be non material. It’s non optional. Then this would imply that the mind is non material.

We also pointed out in the light of Bell’s theorems and its repeated violations, which are being confirmed pretty much, if not day by day, month by month, that locality is not tenable. And more recent analysis of the paradoxes which ensue in Groblocher’s work indicate that realism is not tenable. In this case, not only is the mind nonmaterial, but the universe as we know it is either of the nature of the mind or intimately related with the mind. These are the two options we, have to take on board at present. How intimately the the universe might be related to the mind is unclear.

Really, the data coming in indicates it is quite a close relationship. Then we have a third set of data drawn from biology, medicine, and psychiatry, which counters materialism. First as I mentioned, there really is no clear explanation in the materialist paradigm for powerful psychosomatic effects. Use a placebo where a compound which is ineffective helps just through the conviction of the user, or nocebo where it harms. Then in the case of placebo, a modicum of explanation for pain control, through the release of opioids.

It, tends to crumble the moment we deal with more complex psychosomatic effects. Secondly, the research, the ongoing research at the Kreiman lab, at Harvard regarding the existence of single neuron memories. This is highly controversial. There’s strong indications single neuron memories do exist. The question is precisely what sort of coding, is used.

Thirdly, near death experiences occurring during cardiac arrest. If they actually do occur during cardiac arrest, this is completely incompatible with the materialist paradigm. There is no mental activity possible once oxygen flow and blood flow to the brain has ceased and there’s no electrical activity in the brain. Firstly, you can see eight ninety five verified cases of the reincarnation type studied by Stevenson, where we have not just memories of past lives, but these memories were verified independently. And fifthly, the most problematic case for Westerners, the self described cases of possession, which are very difficult to reduce to dissociative identity disorder.

So this is the data drawn from biology, psychiatry and medicine, which is at odds with the materialist account of the mind as byproduct of the brain. Then what models do we have which would be compatible with this data? Such a model has to teach the impermanence of phenomena since this is overwhelmingly confirmed by everything we know in physics. The non material nature of the mind seems a prerequisite, certainly in the light of the formal mind reading of quantum mechanics. And either pure idealism in which the exterior world is seen as of the nature of mind or strong interdependence of mind and matter seems to be a corollary of the later developments of quantum mechanics, developments of Bell’s theorems, Koblacher’s work and so forth.

Reincarnation seems required by Stevenson’s work if it’s confirmed. And in addition, Stevenson’s work intimates that there is a relationship between lives, it’s not a random process, a physical behavioral relationship between existences. Then broadly speaking, it’s the Indian religious traditions which are closest to this model. And within the Indian religious traditions, it’s Urivadanta for Hinduism, and for Buddhism, Chitamatra and Bhasanika. Two lower Buddhist schools, Sattrhandika and Vaibhāṣika, do not comply with the criteria of idealism since they teach that the universe is physically real out there, if you wish, or the interdependence of mind dead matter.

Okay. Do you if this is so, what precisely is the Buddhist stance? Why is it and this is actually something I have heard from physicists, a privileged interlocutor of physics. A friend of mine an old friend of mine is a Christian monk in Switzerland, a Roman Roman author a Christian Eastern Orthodox monk. And he told me, somewhat peevishly, I must say once, the physicists never want to talk to us.

They always want to talk to you Buddhists. And I thought this was quite funny, know. Then they said, well, I’m sure they’ll talk to you at some day. What happened? What am I supposed to say?

And the Buddhist method, and this is what makes it particularly appealing to scientists, is imperial critical. It’s based on experience and criticism, and it is interesting in this respect to read the words of a very great Indian historian of philosophy, the author of one of the best histories of Indian philosophy, Radha Krishna. Keep in mind, this is a Hindu talking about Buddhism. The revolt of Buddhism and Jainism, even such as it was, forms an era in the history of Indian thought, and this is how Indians see Buddhism. For the great Buddhist thinkers, logic was the main ostinence where we’re forged to weapons of universal destructive criticism.

Because Hinduism obviously was on the receiving end of the extraordinary power of the Buddhist arsenal of, criticism. Then I think the Buddhist outlook is beautifully expressed by Je Tsongkhapa in his Essence of Eloquence, the The difference between the interpretable and the definitive scriptures, in other words, what can be accepted literally from the Buddha and what must be interpreted, must be analyzed by stimulus logic. I think this is a perhaps the unique feature of Buddhism in all world religions. Since one who accepts tenets which are contradictory with logic is not a profound or suitable to being a being who is a valid cognizer, and the acceptability of the suchness of phenomena, in other words, emptiness has logical proofs. Emptiness is not transcendental, inexpressible, and unanalyzable.

Emptiness is accessible, and for us only accessible through logic. Upon seeing the first of this point, Buddha Śākyamūni said, bhikshus, in other words, monks or scholars should accept my utterances upon thorough examination, just as gold is burnt, cut, and rubbed and not out of respect. This is a unique injunction in the history of religions. It is a rejection of authority and an appeal to logic and to reason. Then, obviously, Buddhism is not a comfortable, spiritual tradition since there is little place in Buddhism for faith, and there is a great place for study and effort.

So what exactly were the core teachings which the Buddha discovered and eventually disseminated? There are several ways to present the Buddhist teachings, and I have always oscillated between two main ones. Presenting them through the four seals, which is a very philosophical presentation. It is actually easier in access for a western audience because it turns down some of the most problematic aspects of Buddhism for a western audience. The presentation in terms of the four truths, which is really the way Buddha Śākyamūni presented his teachings initially, and the way his holy mr.

Dalai Lama does so, then I think I have little choice but to present them in terms of the fortunes. And I will try to do it drawing as much as possible on the data we have seen so far. And the four truths are highly problematical largely because the first of the four truths is a noble truth of suffering. Suffering is something Westerners do not have a direct experience of in many cases, or very little experience of, and also misunderstand greatly. So the four truths as the Buddha taught them was were the truths of suffering, of the origin of suffering, of the cessation of suffering, and of a path, the path leading to a cessation of suffering.

They are subdivided into two. What is to be abandoned and what is to be attained? The first two truths, suffering and its origin are to be abandoned. They are what is called saṃsāra. This is saṃsāra.

saṃsāra is not the building we live in. It’s not Adelaide. We often hear students at the center talking about something which happened to them downtown saying it’s saṃsāra. That’s completely wrong. If I were to ask you to give me an example of saṃsāra, what would it be?

Yes, exactly. Yourself, right? This is saṃsāra. Is this saṃsāra? It’s not saṃsāra.

It’s not of the nature of suffering. Table is very happy as it is. I haven’t checked, but I’m quite sure it is. And then the truths two truths to be attained, cessation and the truth of the path. Then this gives an eye to an often heard critique of the Buddha’s teaching that they are pessimistic.

Had the Buddha only taught the truth of suffering and the truth of the origin, then indeed you could say that Buddhism was pessimistic. But Buddha Śākyamūni taught ways out of suffering. Whether these are true or not, that is up to us to examine. So what exactly is the first truth, the truth of suffering? This is by far the most difficult point for a western audience.

The first truth has four characteristics, impermanence, suffering, emptiness and selflessness. And I will focus mainly on the two first characteristics, impermanence and suffering. Then when we speak of impermanence, and I thought this photography was magnificent in this respect because I used to meditate on it in India looking at fields of rice swaying in the wind fields of wheat swaying in the wind. You have this constant constant movement, right? It’s quite extraordinary.

So this is impermanence, a constant change of all phenomena. Then there are two types of impermanence. Coarse impermanence, which is the end of the continuum of phenomena. We experience it as our own death. If I were to smash this table and the table cracked, that would be the death of the table, the coarse impermanence of the table.

Right? The end of an object. But coarse impermanence is just an instance, a subset of a much more fundamental form of impermanence, subtle impermanence, which refers to the fact that all material phenomena and all consciousness changes continually instant by instant. It’s imperceptible. In the case of material phenomena, you could you could see this with an electron microscope of a particle with a bubble chamber.

In the case of consciousness, you must check within yourselves. It is this constant change, instant by instant, which eventually leads objects to die, to disintegrate, leads to cause impermanence. Now the rate of this change is still being investigated. So far the shortest interval of time measured in physics is of twenty attoseconds. This is basically 20 by ten minus eighteen seconds.

We can’t even begin to imagine what such an interval of change is. Such an interval of change is an interval of change we do not perceive. It is not accessible to us except through instruments. Our senses are not able to perceive change at this rate. Then what are our senses able to perceive?

It depends on the sense organ, and it is not fully researched, in the case of the eye sense organ, the visual organ can perceive change at the rate of twenty to thirty milliseconds per event, which is basically not too bad. The zero zero two seconds. Events separated by zero zero two to zero zero three seconds can be differentiated by the eye. The auditory sense consciousness is by far the most powerful. It can differentiate events separated by two to five milliseconds.

There is no data as of basically six months ago for the olfactory and gustrative sense consciousnesses. I would assume they are extremely slow compared to the others. And the tactile sense consciousness can differentiate events separated by ten milliseconds. So overall, we can say that the sense organs can differentiate events separated by approximately ten to twenty milliseconds. So what do we have?

We have a situation in which the maximum physical rate of change is actually even smaller than the present measured rate. It’s called Planck time. So the rate of the order of ten minus forty four seconds, nothing has ever been measured changing this fast. But for various reasons it is not possible for events to occur faster than this. At the same time, our senses act as filters which prevent any change occurring faster than in two to thirty milliseconds to be perceived.

And what is quite extraordinary, and perhaps if you have one argument to demonstrate that the Buddhist meditators really had direct experience and were onto something, it is that the Buddhist meditators actually measured this rate of sensory change. And the figure they give is very close to the figure I was able to gather from scientific sources. You find this in Vasubandhu’s Abhidharma Kosha. The Vaibhāṣika’s lowest school considers that the fastest rate of change of impermanent phenomena is one sixty fifth of the time it takes a strong man to snap his fingers. Then I measured this.

I I used my father’s old chronometer, and I tried to stay reasonably fit. So I snapped my fingers, I think I did it 10 times, or taking measuring how long it took. And then I tried to estimate the time it took for my fingers to return from the snapped state back to the unsnap state and subtracted that, divided by 10, and surprise surprise, I come in just the right ballpark. I am around five to ten milliseconds per finger snap multiplied by 65. Then if you take take this and divide by 65, you end up with approximately five to ten milliseconds.

And the Vaibhāṣika said that this was the shortest interval of change perceivable by the senses. Now they have no means to measure this, right, which means to be able to make such a statement, either they as a friend of mine who is British, they sucked it out of their thumb, it came from nowhere, or they must have had mindfulness of each instant. It’s the only possible explanation because they could have said one fifth, they could have said one thousandth. Right? And that is very puzzling.

So you see what I found actually, these are the actual figures, was I could make 31 finger snaps in ten seconds, zero thirty one seconds for a complete snap with return of the fingers, zero one seconds for the actual finger snap, one sixty fifth of zero one is 1.5. So you are within, I would say, eight milliseconds from the largest rate and zero zero five milliseconds from the fastest. It’s quite astonishing, isn’t it? If you want one reason to become a Buddhist, think this is a very good one. Because I I didn’t this figure has always bothered me, to be honest with you.

Many years ago, I thought, my goodness, this is ridiculous. Right? I mean, everyone knows that there are events which occur much faster than one sixty fifth of a finger snap. It’s a it’s a it’s trite. Right?

Until I realized that this is not what’s being talked about. What’s being talked about is a rate of perceived change. And then the problem is getting those figures, and they change in function of the sense organ. Right? But not the same for the eye, the ear, you know?

And then when I was able to get those rates, I thought, okay. Let’s try. Let’s see where we end up. And to my astonishment, we were dead on. Dead on.

You know? And this is quite extraordinary. It’s quite extraordinary. You know? So as we said, impermanence is the first characteristic of the noble truth of suffering.

The second characteristic is suffering, and the Buddhist understanding of suffering is very different from our common sense understanding of suffering. So the sufferings of the cycle of lives of which we talked about, which is this endless flow of rebirth, which Stevenson’s research indicates probably does exist, three, six and eight subdivisions. The most fundamental one is a threefold subdivision, and that is the one we shall look into in some detail. Now the threefold subdivision of suffering is the suffering of suffering, which is actual physical suffering, physical or mental suffering. The suffering of change and more pervasive suffering.

Now the first category of suffering is quite evident. Every one of us in this room understands what physical suffering is and most of us understand what mental suffering is. It’s not terribly difficult. The two latter ones are extremely difficult for us to understand. So if we try to understand what the Buddhist sense or the Buddhist vision of suffering is, I think a graph makes this makes this extremely clear.

If we plot in abscissa time and in order the intensity of painful stimuli, either physical or mental. The suffering of suffering refers to an increase in the intensity of painful stimuli. This is what we know as pain, physical or mental. Unruffling sensation occurs when approximately the intensity of painful stimuli does not change too much, it’s below the threshold of attention. When there is a sharp decrease in the intensity of the painful stimuli, this sharp decrease is experienced as pleasure.

This is a suffering of change. Neutral sensation occurs again, but there is no big difference. And once again, there’s an increase in the intensity of the suffering of suffering, which is experienced as suffering. And then a very sharp decrease, which is experienced as pleasure. The faster the decrease, the greater the pleasure.

Then I will take a coarse but evident example. All the examples connected to our sphincters are very good examples in this respect. It’s example of urination. As your bladder fills up, you feel progressively more and more discomfort. And I don’t plan on freaking you out, but we have another two and a half hours to go.

So you feel more and more discomfort, eventually this impinges on consciousness. You become fretful. The fretfulness increases. This is an increase of the suffering of suffering. Eventually it becomes in supportable, doesn’t it?

And then everyone rushes to the bathroom with little heed for precedence, you know, and when you urinate, you experience a feeling of great pleasure, don’t you? It all comes out, and during the process of urination, you feel profoundly happy. Don’t you? And then it ends, and you have a neutral sensation, right, until the bladder starts filling up again. Now the same thing is true of defecation, and if you forgive me, the same thing is true of sexuality.

These are processes of release of fluids. What we call pleasure is merely the cessation of a painful state of affairs. And precisely because we refuse to consider this as cessation of a painful state of affairs, we see it as something endowed with qualities of its own. Well, obviously, things are a little bit more complex in my chart. So I will show you the next step in complexity, which is when you introduce a pain threshold or a threshold of attention.

When you have a pain threshold, anything which is under the threshold of attention basically won’t be noticed. So if you’re concentrating on the teachings, the need to go outdoors to satisfy the call of nature is there, but it won’t be noticed. Right? On the other hand, if, and I’m sure nobody’s in this case, you’re bored out of your minds, then this need is above the threshold of attention and takes over, doesn’t it? So the threshold of attention defines basically how much pain, neutral sensations, and pleasure one experiences.

And this explains why when one engages in Sattipattana retreats retreats on mindfulness, the first experience one has in a retreat as one starts meditating on mindfulness, is an experience of overwhelming pain and irritation, which increases over time. Why? What are you doing in Sattipattana? Does anyone know? Sorry?

You’re meant to be concentrating but you’re usually capable of concentrating. What are you doing? Yes, increasing mindfulness, right? There you go, the three or the four objects depending how you count them, right? Now when you increase mindfulness of the body and of sensation, what happens?

Your threshold of attention collapses, right? You become mindful of everything. You are suddenly aware of pain which has been there all along. Like, you would notice the moment you sit, if anyone has done Sattipatthana retreats, don’t know if some of you have. The moment you sit and start focusing on your breath, certainly in my case, the first experience is itching.

You start itching everywhere. And then as it goes on, the itches become insupportable. Then the joints pain stopped. It’s like you have the impression you you are sclerotic and rheumatic, you know. And after this, it’s back, you know.

When you analyze this after the session of meditation, wonder what exactly was going on. I mean, these are not obstacles to meditation. This is actually the revelation of our true condition. Our true condition, if the threshold is lowered, is an overwhelming level of discomfort and pain. And this is why I think personally, it is perfectly possible through meditation on Sattipattana to gain realizations certainly of the first noble truth, the noble truth of suffering.

You can understand the suffering of suffering, that’s self evident, but you can also understand the suffering of change, where the reduction in suffering is pleasure. And actually there is no pleasure which is other than a reduction in the level of physical or mental suffering. We speak of the suffering of changes what we’re speaking about. But obviously there are hierarchies of pleasure, in other words hierarchies of the suffering of change. We have the coarsest pleasures which we talked about, urination and defecation, sexuality which is related to the two, it’s just pleasures of the sphincters basically, food.

You have higher levels of pleasure, social pleasures, even higher pleasures, abstract pleasures, and the highest pleasures of all meditative pleasures. Every single one of them is contaminated because every single one of them is simply due to the reduction in the intensity of a pleasurable of a painful stimuli. The faster the reduction, the greater the pleasure. Now you might think that this is perhaps my own bias, and this is why I wanted to quote this passage from Nature Reviews Neuroscience of 04/02/2008. And this is written by a neurobiologist who has no connection or interest in Buddhism whatsoever.

Pain and pleasure have historically been considered opposites. This is very much the western outlook. Emerging evidence from the pain and reward research fields points to extensive similarities in the anatomical substrata of painful and pleasant pleasant sensations. That’s quite striking. Even anatomically, pain and pleasure are intimately related.

Then I will not speak of the third subdivision of suffering or pervasive suffering at present, since this is actually the suffering of being in psychic existence, and I’d like to talk of psychic existence in the context of the second Noble Truth, Noble Truth of the Origin of Suffering. So I mentioned briefly the six fold division of suffering, which is presented in the Lamrim, which certainly for myself is the most powerful for inducing mental transformation. Life in general, psychic existence as a whole, suffer of six faults. Uncertainty, there’s no guarantee. Insatiability, it is impossible to ever be satisfied with what one has.

The thought of dying over and again, and the thought of being conceived over and again. The thought of falling from the high to the low over and again, and the thought of being alone. And we can clearly see them illustrated in the case of young James Leininger of whom we spoke this morning. He was formerly James Houston junior, a Corsair test pilot. He died.

It is unclear what happened in the interval between his death and his rebirth as James Leininger in 1998, some forty years, more than forty years, fifty years passed. It’s very unclear where he was. So this process of death is one he will experience over and over and over, not once. Every single life will end in death. Every life will end in suffering and pain.

Then in addition, he would experience a thought of insatiability, of never being satisfied with what he has, repeated birth, repeated death, in his case, certainly in those two lives not falling from the high to the low, but it is definite that in some future life that will be experienced again. Then meditating on the six fold subdivision of suffering from the Lamrim is highly beneficial when we can link it in this way to such cases of the reincarnation type. And then we have the eightfold subdivision of suffering. The four first suffering specific to a human rebirth in general, or so it is said, birth, aging, sickness and death, and the last four which are general encountering what is unpleasant, not encountering what is pleasant, not getting what one wants, and the general suffering of the five aggregates. Then, as westerners, we have almost no experience of the suffering of birth since birth occurs in hospitals and pain is controlled, and, we have limited experience of the suffering of sickness.

Aging and death tend to occur out of sight, Especially, the final phase of aging leading to death typically occurs in an institutional setting. Many Westerners do not visit their family at this point. I used to visit old people’s homes in Switzerland. Was quite surprising that once an old person entered an institution, the family just stopped coming without its ever being a formal decision. And I’ll never forget I remember this old friend who was a Christian Orthodox monk to one institution.

He had to see an old lady who was Orthodox, and I was speaking with some of the old ones in the lobby. And this old lady came to me and she said, where are you from? And I said, I’m from Lausanne, the neighboring town. She said, oh, you must know my son, mister Pash. Now Pash in Lausanne is about as widespread as Ridley or, I don’t know, Bruce something or something in Adelaide.

Everyone is called Pasha. So I said, well, not not really. Yes. Yes. Mister Pasha.

Mister Pasha. Then she became very agitated. And I said, well, I must know him. Yes. I I really must know him.

And she said, please, next time you see him, tell him, it’s okay if he doesn’t come too often, but I’d like to see him from time to time. This is, you know, how we treat our elderly. It’s shameful, really. There’s no other word for it. We ourselves behave shamefully, and we do not reap the benefit of seeing the aging process, which would cause us to reflect on our own condition.

They, from their side, experience the suffering of abandonment. Then there are four wrong engagements of the truth of suffering, are really topics of meditation. The first is seeing the contaminated aggregates, in other words ourselves, as clean and as happy. This is the materialist mind view. We see ourselves as clean and as fundamentally happy.

To see ourselves as clean, obviously, we must wash frequently. So the West has become obsessed with hygiene, with this endless scrubbing and washing of the body. And I’ll never forget an Indian lady. She was not Buddhist, but she had a very sharp mind. And she put it very bluntly.

We were talking once and she said to me, well, you know, Westerners wash all the time because they want to be always ready to have sex. And I thought that’s exactly it. Sex is a dirty process. Right? It involves basically the urogenital components of the body.

It’s the dirtiest part of the human body. Then, to maintain the fantasy that our bodies are desirable, we wash. Not from time to time, every two or three days in function of need. Every day, twice a day, three times a day. We wash our teeth two, three times a day.

We brush our teeth so much we erode the gums away. Then obviously our teeth become yellow with age, so we whiten them. And then one’s skin becomes wrinkled with age, someone pulls it. I’ve known some cases in Singapore, and I know one or two even in Australia, where you put it the first time, it’s okay. Right?

And when you put it the second time, the person tends to have a bit of a frozen look. By the time you put it the third time, the opening for the eyes tends to shift a bit, you know, then they can’t really smile, they can’t say anything, the face becomes like a mask. It’s quite uncomfortable when you see it. Then this arises from long engagements of the truth of suffering. If one sees one’s body as a locus of suffering and as dirty, I think one’s a much happier person.

Human body is a very dirty business. Then if you want to be convinced of that, there is one key point for meditation every day when you go to the toilet. Go to the toilet, and after you have done what you have to do, look at what comes out. Look carefully. That is the nature of the human body.

That’s it. As a friend of mine who is a very fine Western monk put it, the human body is beautiful at a depth of half a millimeter of skin. Beyond that, it is horror. Imagine removing that half millimeter of skin. Another that is something out of a horror movie.

Really? Then the two remaining wrong engagements are viewing the contaminated aggregates, particularly in this case the mind or the soul, as permanent, which is a view of most of the Indian schools of philosophy, of Christianity, and perhaps of Islam and Judaism, and viewing oneself as having a self, which is and a self here refers to a soul. It’s a permanent one and independent entity. This is the case of all the great religions, as well as all the orthodox Indian darshanas. So you can see that meditation on the noble truth of suffering is very profound.

I cannot encourage you too much to meditate on the first noble truth. The three subdivisions of suffering, suffering of suffering, suffering of change or pervasive suffering, the six and the eight subdivisions of suffering, applying them to yourselves, and then the four wrong engagements of the truth of suffering. And as I mentioned the TBI, and I don’t want to put you on the spot in this matter, but when I went to India with some students of TBI, I was very surprised by the fact that over the days and the weeks in India, everyone was turning much much more gray. I mean, it was quite astonishing. People’s hair was just turning gray by the day.

Then perhaps some people use, what do you call this, colorant hair dye? If you can, it’s good not to use it. If you can accept your own aging, look at your own hair turning gray, look at your teeth turning yellow, look at the wrinkles coming, it’s a great benefit for the mind. And the more you try to make believe you are not aging, the more really you are involved in one of the wrong engagements of the noble truth of suffering, seeing the body as clean and permanent. There are some things we can do on a daily basis, which are not really meditation, and rather coarse, but very helpful.

Very helpful. And the sec second noble truth, the little truth of the origin of suffering, I thought I would present to you in the light of an example, because it is a complex topic, one of the more complex ones. Since basically, the origin of suffering is both karma and klesha. Then we will cover briefly the general features features of karma, and then I will give you an example to show you how it might unfold. So karma is threefold.

We have virtuous karma and non virtuous karma, which lead to rebirths in the higher and the lower realms. And then there is a specific category of karma called immutable karma, which can only be generated with a modicum of concentration, literally with one of the Dhyanas. This comma and only this comma leads to rebirth in the formless realms, and this is basically from the Buddhist standpoint, the goal of all of the non Buddhist Hindu schools. When a non Buddhist Hindu yogi aims for moksha through Samādhi, what he actually is doing is preparing a rebirth in the formless realms, and he will attain it. It’s perfectly possible.

Through single pointed concentration, one creates a cause for rebirth as what really is a god. It’s a formless entity, tremendous mental power, tremendous bliss. But it’s a state of affairs which lasts a very long time but is not eternal. Then, when one falls from the bliss of samadhi, which is the highest bliss in psychic existence, one falls back to the level of a non resentient being without having had the opportunity of practicing any type of virtue. So things can get quite difficult.

And the afflictions, klesha in other words, are subdivided into the well known three poisons, desire, anger, and their root ignorance. So the best way to approach karma is reflecting on its general features first. Karma is definite. It’s an increasing function of time. One will not experience karma which has not been accumulated, and it is indestructible.

When I was a very young novice, I would go to the forests in Switzerland and look at trees and use the pine trees as examples of karma. It works very well. The seed of the pine tree is the karmic imprint. You can see how a very small seed can only give rise to the seed of a pine tree can only give rise to a pine tree, can never give rise to an oak tree. This is the definiteness of karma.

In other words, virtuous karmic imprints can only give rise to happiness. They can never give rise to unhappiness. Karma is an increasing function of time, indeed. Once you’ve cast a pine tree cone and the seed is in the ground, the pine tree will grow and grow and grow, one small cone creates a pine tree which can shelter maybe hundreds of birds. And then one does not experience the results of karma not accumulated.

There’s no such thing as a pine tree for which a pine cone wasn’t cast. It does not exist. Finally, karma is indestructible. The potency of the pine tree’s seed to give rise to a pine tree is eternal unless the seed is scorched. Traditionally, is said, scorched by the fire of anger.

So the definiteness of karma refers simply to the fact that virtue gives rise to happiness and non virtue to suffering, and this is something which we can only understand through the teachings of one who is omniscient. We ourselves do not have the capacity to gain this understanding. We have to be able to look over the cycle of lives in their totality. We cannot do this. We can see reliable memories, maybe one, two, three lives maximum.

People who gain the capacity to see other people’s lives through concentration can see a couple lives in the past, not more than that. Sometimes they say up to a 100 or a thousand, but that’s nothing compared to the totality of lives. Buddha Śākyamūni, as Buddhists we believe, gained omniscience. Then the omniscience enabled him to see the causal relations, to see what deeds led to happiness at some points in the future, and what deeds led to unhappiness. So these elements of the Buddhist teachings, we have to basically accept until we ourselves reach the point where we can verify them for ourselves.

Then, just as a whittle of water, karma is an increasing function of time, and we don’t have time to enter into this here, but karma can very conveniently be understood in terms of chaos theory. You all know about chaos theory, the flutter of a butterfly over China gives rise to a hurricane on the South American coast. In other words, the huge amplification of a phenomenon due to specific initial conditions. Now interestingly enough, for chaotic motion to occur, two factors are necessary. You need a very high sensitivity on it or the sensitive dependency on initial conditions and recurrence, in other words, a feedback loop.

Both are clearly present in the case of karma. Then I talked about this at TBI not quite two years ago, so we won’t enter into it here. But if you’re interested, you might want to read Bernard Mandelbrot’s books on fractal theory and some good books on chaos theory and try to establish the links. It’s quite fascinating. Thirdly, one does not experience the results of karma not accumulated.

What this means is that every pleasant, every experience of pleasure or suffering is necessarily karmically conditioned. Experiences which are not experiences of pleasure or suffering are not necessarily karmically conditioned. So that means, in other words, that not everything is karmically conditioned. We do not live in a rigidly deterministic world. But as I am seated here, for instance, with you, if I observe my own body, when I observe it, I can see that there is discomfort in the back.

That sensation of discomfort in the back is of the nature of suffering. That suffering is a karmic result. It is not fortuitous. If I were to sit in this position and not experience suffering in the back, even though my back is in this position, then it is clear that karma would not have been accumulated. So it is not the event which is the result of karma, it is the pleasure or the suffering in reaction to the event.

Experience, for instance, accidents. You can be an who’s gone beyond karma and causality, and let’s say, stumble on the street and crash. That is not the result of karma. But when the Arhat trips and falls to the ground, the Arhat feels no pain. It’s quite important because otherwise, if one does not make this distinction, then basically one ends up in a world in which we are, in a straight jacket as it were.

Everything is determined by past events and so forth. Then when it comes to neutral events, they are generally or they can be the product of neutral karma, but there is no necessity to this. Finally, karma like a diamond is indestructible, and this has to be qualified. When we say karma is indestructible, virtuous karma certainly can be destroyed, and the one force which can destroy karma is anger. Virtuous karma can be destroyed by anger, like the potency of a grain can be scorched by fire.

When when one thinks about this, anger is by far the most dangerous enemy to our spiritual practice. By far. So these are to repeat the four main characteristics of karma. Karma is definite, it is increasing, one does not experience the results of karma not accumulated, and it is indestructible. Then comma can be subdivided into two, projecting and completing comma.

Projecting comma is karma which defines one life. Completing comma fleshes out that life. It gives the events within that life. So you might have the projecting karma to be reborn as a human being in the next life. But what completing karma you have is another question.

Will you be reborn as a human being in Australia or let us say in Iraq? Will you be reborn rich or poor, intelligent or limited in your capacities? That is all completing karma. Then when projecting karma is virtuous, it leads to a higher rebirth and excuse me, the error should go here when it’s non virtuous, it leads to a lower rebirth. When completing karma is virtuous, it leads to happy events and conditions in the life, and when it is non virtuous, it leads to unhappy events.

So if we look at the permutations between completing and projecting karma, we can see that when projecting karma is virtuous, that was a good rebirth, and completing karma is virtuous, you’re in an ideal situation. You’re born as an Australian and you’re wealthy. Everything is going well for you. When projecting karma is virtuous, you have a good rebirth, and completing karma is non virtuous, you’ll be reborn as a human being, but you will be in India and poor. When projecting karma is non virtuous, now that you have a bad rebirth, and completing karma is virtuous, you’ll be reborn as Mandy’s dogs, Bobby and Meedy.

It doesn’t get better than that. And when projecting karma is non virtuous and completing karma is non virtuous, you’ll be reborn as a dog and it will be in India. So these are the possible permutations of projecting and completing karma. Now for a karmic deed to necessarily lead to its result, this deed must be complete, and a complete karmic deed has four components. Such a deed has a basis, a motivation, a performance, and a completion.

And I won’t enter too much in the subdivisions of the motivation. So what does this mean if we take an example? Let us take the deed of killing a little insect. Let’s assume we want to inflict suffering on a small creature. We need a basis, in other words, an insect.

Then we actually must be motivated to do this. It’s not sufficient for this to happen by accident while we’re walking down the street. We must see the insect, and as Asaṇga puts it, we must perceive it, in other words, recognize it. We must wish to harm it, and that wish must be motivated by an affliction, anger or desire. It must be a motivation.

The deed must be performed. We must actually, let’s say, lift our foot to crush the ant. And that performance must lead to completion. In other words, the ant must die as a result. A deed with these four characteristics is a complete non virtuous deed of killing.

Such a deed necessarily leads to a comic result, unless it is purified. If any of the features is missing, the deed is incomplete, and may not lead to a comic result, it is uncertain. If, for instance, there’s an ant, we’re walking on the street, have no intention of crushing the ant, we crush it by accident, then we have crushed it and the ant dies. The motivation isn’t there. The deed is incomplete.

It is not a complete deed of killing. It will not lead to the maturation of a deed of killing. Then let us take an example of a complete deed of killing, and I have chosen when I presented the TBI in the past, which is I think quite confrontational, but you know, it has to be addressed in our society, which is abortion in general and late term abortion in particular. Then as you know, involves late term abortion especially involves the partial extraction of the fetus and then the deserabration of the fetus, where a needle is injected in the skull and all the brain of the fetus is sucked out. Such a deed is full deed of killing a human being.

Then for such a deed to be a complete karmic deed, let us analyze what is required. The basis, generally speaking, for a deed of killing, the basis can either be a living being in general or another living being, and there’s a debate among Buddhist scholars in this matter whether suicide is a complete deed of killing or not after one is killing oneself. Then Jinsengkopaka considers suicide as a complete deed of killing. Asaṇga does not. Asaṇga considers it is a non virtuous deed that is undeniable, but because one is killing oneself it cannot be a complete deed of killing.

It’s a semantic distinction in either case you know it is a non virtuous deed and a heavy non virtuous deed. Then as we said, the motivation must be present for the deed to be performed, and the motivation in our Sangha’s presentation has three subdivisions: perception, motivation and affliction. Perception means that one correctly perceives being. If for instance, I were to perceive an ant as a grasshopper, and based on that perception kill the ant, perception is incorrect, and indeed will be incorrect. Perception can be affected by drugs, by alcohol, by misunderstanding.

Motivation must be the will to kill. If motivation is absent, or let’s say, if one were to act out of compassion, the deed would not be complete. And affliction must be present. Affliction here refers to one of the major afflictions: desire, hatred, or ignorance. Then in the case of performance, for instance for abortion, abortion can be performed through weapons, drugs, or even through the use of paranormal powers.

In every single case, such a performance amounts to a deed of killing, whether one does it oneself or orders another to do it. Actually, from a Buddhist standpoint, if one orders another to do it, the deed is karmically heavier, because one has drawn another in one’s own non virtuous deeds. And the deed to be complete must lead lead to the death of the victim before the killer dies. If that is the case the deed is complete, comically complete, otherwise not. So let us take the path leading to a complete deed of killing in the case of an abortion.

What does this involve? For an abortion to be complete, the fetus must be alive. If the fetus were dead in utero, there’s not no basis. There can be no basis for abortion. The intent of the motivation must be present.

One must intend to kill. If abortion occurs by accident or let’s say to save the mother, it is not a complete deed of killing. Then the mindset must be motivated by a delusion. Jenny, the cases of abortion I have encountered are often out of anger. If it were out of compassion for any particular reason, again, the deed would not be complete.

The fetus must be aborted, and the fetus must die before the abortionist dies. In such a case, the deed is complete. Then I will not talk here about factors which amplify the karmic potency of the deed. We don’t have time, I mentioned them at TBI in the past. I brought up the case of abortion because abortion is a non virtuous deed in which karmic amplification is very powerful, because of the closeness between mother and child.

Number one, it is generally speaking the mother who does take decision. It is rare for an abortion to be performed without the consent of the mother for medical reasons alone. Abortion, especially late term abortion, is particularly cruel in its performance. Then this cruelty amplifies the karmic consequences. Then I have known one case of someone who I believe it was an illegal abortion in America before abortion was allowed.

Later term, she became a Buddhist later on in life, but the common consequences were very heavy. And actually, she died before her time of cancer of the womb, and she was convinced, she was a good Buddhist scholar, that this was a karmic consequence of a late term of bosom. So such deeds are very heavy karmically. Then if what is in the unfortunate situation where one basically is obliged to perform a non righteous deed, it’s very important to avoid amplification and to purify as much as possible. Obviously, any deed performed with respect to a member of one’s family, by definition, is a karmically powerful deed.

Offending one’s parents, hurting one’s children, abandoning one’s spouse, these are very potent deeds comically because of the closeness between the two parties. Harsh words inflicted to one’s parents are much more potent than perhaps stealing something from someone who has never met. Especially if from the standpoint of the parents, there has been sorry. Especially if from the standpoint of one’s parents, there has been great affection and love. So we have to be particularly careful with those with whom we are closely related.

Then this is a reason for which it is said that the spiritual teacher is one of the karmically most potent beings because, my apologies, the spiritual teacher actually imparts the teachings to us, and there is no greater kindness than this. Then before choosing a spiritual teacher one must reflect very carefully, because one is blinking into the karmic circuit one of the most powerful amplifiers there is. At present the maturation of karma leads to these two paths, non virtuous karma leads here, to jail and suffering, Virtuous karma leads here. People end up with tragic experiences in their lives, not by accident, but because they accumulated the karmic causes for it. People are born wealthy and only experience happiness in their lives, not by accident, but because they accumulated the causes for it.

There is therefore no ground for envy, in our relations with others. We reap what we sow. What we have sown in the past life, we reap in this life. And we have no control over that. But we do have control over what we sow in this life.

What we sow in this life, we will reap in future lives. We may even reap at the end of this life, if the deed is powerful enough. Karmic maturation can be distinguished in terms of three effects. The effect of maturation, causally concordant effects, and environmental effects. The effect of maturation of karma is the same as the propelling comma, it’s a rebirth.

Happy or unhappy, as a human or as an animal. Causally concordant effects are effects which are similar to the cause. So for instance, if one performs a non virtuous deed of killing in a previous life, in a future life, one will have a habituation with killing, a fascination with killing, or may even enjoy killing. This is a causally concomitant result. As a result, one will have a far greater chance of killing again in the future life and experiencing non virtuous karma in a later life again.

And the third karmic maturation is an environmental effect. One is born in a milieu, an environment, which reflects one’s karma. For instance, as a pharmacist one has sold overpriced enforced medicine, very common in third world countries. Karmically, a possible result would be to be reborn in a country in which medicine is unavailable or fake, as is the case in much of India. The environment reflects the karma of the person who has performed the deed.

One has led a violent life in a previous life, harmed others. As a result, one has reborn in a violent and harsh society. Let’s say Afghanistan. In Britain, Afghani told me face to face the only value was revenge. If you can imagine.

Then let us take a case of karmic maturation, is the case of a Sri Lankan Vijayakhani, which I have already presented at TBI. We’re going to analyze it in great detail in con the context of the presentation of the second noble truth, the noble truth of the origin of suffering. So Vijayakhani was born in 1947 in Ugal, Kolkata in Sri Lanka, and from birth he had a marked deformity of the right breast and arm, and a strong resemblance to his father’s deceased brother, Ratan Hami. As in many of Stevenson’s cases, as soon as he started talking at age two and a half, he started talking about his past life. And he said he had been born with a withered arm because he had murdered his wife Porgy Menike in a previous life, and he clearly remembered being his father’s deceased brother.

Now what’s striking in this case is that all the details about his father’s brother had been kept quiet because it had was a family scandal. His father’s brother was a murderer who was sentenced to death for murder and hanged at the gallows. Young child had never heard this. Then the deformities, you can see, are very striking. The right arm is atrophied, and most of the right digits are absent.

He himself attributed this directly to the non virtuous karma he had accumulated in a previous life from killing his wife to be. His right pectoral muscle was also atrophied. There was hyperplasia, of the pectoral muscle and of the third rib. Now what happened to Ratan Hami? The recollected rebirth.

Ratan Hami was rejected by his wife to be, and then if you look carefully, you will see he performed what amounts to a complete deed of killing. Upon being rejected, he walked back to his village and sharpened his knife, his crease, paid off all his debts and returned to his Potimenekis village, his wife to be on foot. It’s very clear premeditation. It’s a cold blooded murder. He stabbed her to death at least three times with his right hand, and the autopsy indicates Portimeneke was stabbed in the back and the left axilla, the left armpit, as she raised her arm to protect her face.

You have here very powerful karmic amplification. One is murdering a defenseless person, a woman, who is trying to protect herself. That the karma of killing would become very powerful. Then upon arrest, he refused to plead guilty. In other words, there was no repentance.

None of the four forces which can act as an antidote to the maturation of karma was present. During the execution in 1928, at the almsgiving for a higher rebirth, alms were offered to Buddhist monks which are present, he told his brother he would return as his son on the gallows, and he remembered clearly being executed by hanging in 1928. Then I shall skip a bit, he will know the details of the execution, but when the trap was sprung his last thought was of his brother, and as the noose was tightening around his death, his neck, he remembered falling in a pit of fire. Vijayakhani, who had these memories, as of the age of 14, still expressed no regret whatsoever for the murder he had committed in a previous life, and said he would murder again if he was rejected. It’s only in his twenties that the outlook changes.

In addition to recollecting this human rebirth, Vidyarhatne remembered non human lives. It’s a very striking case. He remembers dropping into a pit of fire which seems to be a memory of a hell realm, a rebirth, and he remembers flitting through the air perched on treetops. In that life, Ujiratne had a series of psychotic episodes, which caused his internment in its psychiatric asylum, during which he behaved like a bird, making a nest after gathering twigs and hopping on the nest and trying to fly. So if we synthesize the data we have of Vijayaratne’s recollected lives, this is Vijayaratne fourth life, born in 1947.

In that life he is rejected by women, suffers from psychotic episodes, has an atrophied right arm, and chest muscles and ribs are atrophied. The main recollected life occurs three lives before. He recollects a human life as Raghran Hami, rejected by his second wife, who murdered her in 1927 and was executed in 1928. Then between 1928 and 1947, we have eighteen and a half years, which seem to have been spent in the lower realms. There are very few memories.

The memory of the hell realm is only a memory of fire at the instant of the execution, And the animal rebirth we can infer from his memory of flying from tree to tree. This is only memory during that rebirth. So let us analyze carefully the karmic background of the hell rebirth, this rebirth. What is it in life one which caused in life two a hell rebirth? It is a complete deed of murder, the murder of his second wife to be Porimenike.

The basis was present, there was a person, Porimenike. The motivation to kill for revenge for being spurned. The performance repeated stabbing, she was stabbed at least three times. The completion, she died before he died. In addition, powerful amplification amplification was present.

She was defenseless, she was a woman, she trusted him, he premeditated the murder, it was performed with great savagery. After the deed, there was no repentance. He pleaded not guilty in court, and this is evinced by the fact that in his future rebirth, he still felt that what he had done was legitimate. The absence of repentance prevents really any attenuation of the karmic weight of the deed. So what is the projecting karma of this deed of murder during life one?

It’s clearly a rebirthing heroine. This based on his account, no Bardo experience. So it’s at the moment of execution, he directly experiences a hell realm, which means probably he was reborn in Avicii in the lowest hell realm, simply because of the extreme violence of the deed and karmic amplification. Then, as to the completing comet that life, we simply don’t know. There must have been some attenuating factor because the hairy birth was relatively short.

If we consider the life of the bird to be what two years, three years for a bird, then we have fifteen sixteen years in a henrealm. This is fairly short, so something must have curtailed that rebirth. Then what is the karmic background of Vigi Ratna’s fourth life, his human life? But the animal life I will not speak, because frankly we have no details at all. But about his fourth life, we can try to understand the karmic unfolding, what led from life one to life four.

Vijayakrishna had committed murder in life one. What karma in life one could cause a human rebirth in life form? It must be a virtuous comic imprint. Non virtuous comic imprint of murder matured immediately with a hell rebirth. Then for a human rebirth, we need a powerful virtuous comic imprint, and one which does come to mind, and there is no certainty in this matter because obviously we don’t have access to Vigeratini’s mind, is the feeling of compassion for his brother on the gallows.

Now this is actually powerful virtuous karmic imprint, a feeling of compassion with great amplification, because it is for one’s own family member, one’s brother. Do you such a feeling at the very time of one’s death, instance before one is executed, would be karmically very important, and this might act as the comic projecting cause for life, for rebirth as a human being. Then after the completing comma, in other words, what fleshed out the fourth life, Mugirate took a vow at the time of his death to return as his brother’s son. Such vows in general are powerful, but at this time particularly so, and the vow was actualled, he was reborn as his brother’s son, But he also had non virtuous completing karma through the murder of Podiumenicli carried over. And this led to the hyperplasia of the right arm, which dealt the fatal blow.

It’s actually the arm, his arm which struck, which was deformed three lives later. The digits of the right hand which were used in the blow were apophyte, and the pectoral muscle which actually activates the arm was atrophied as well. So you can see here a clear case of good projecting karma and bad completing karma, and you can see how they are probably related to events in his first life. There’s no certainty in this matter, but this is how one would analyze Stevenson’s cases of the reincarnation type using a Buddhist karmic template. So if we look at the permutations between projecting and karmic and completing karmic for comma for Vijayabhatna’s life two, three, and four, there’s not a single life in which he has good projecting and good completing karma, Not one.

There is one life in which he has bad projecting comma and bad completing comma, and that is the second life as a healthy. After this, a slightly better life during which he has bad projecting comma, but a good completing comma, the bird from what little he know we know must have lived a reasonably comfortable bird like life. There’s no evidence to the contrary. And finally, there is one life with good projecting karma and bad completing karma as a human being in a poor country with severe deformities. This is how the noble truth of the origin of suffering unfolds.

Then I think the best approach for us in trying to understand Buddhist teachings is upon studying cases of reincarnation type, which are mentioned in Stevenson’s works, especially cases such as this one, where there are very strong correlations between the two lives, to analyze them carefully, not just to study the case, but read the case carefully and analyze it in terms of the possible karmic connections. This is extraordinarily beneficial for one’s own mind, and it gives one a very strong conviction in the efficacy of karma and causality, and this is profoundly transformative. It is said that the sign of realization of karma and causality is that one becomes very fearful of one’s own behavior. One becomes very careful because karma does mature. So what are the wrong engagements regarding the truth of the origin of suffering?

The wrong views in other words. It is to view suffering as causeless, which is I would say the main Western viewpoint nowadays. Suffering happens for no particular reason, it is always tragic, and there’s really nothing which can be done except to try to alleviate its material causes. It’s at the root of the welfare state, it’s at the root of all our aid programs. Or suffering is seen as having only one cause, which would typically be for instance poverty.

I mean, our western societies seem to believe that through eliminating poverty, somehow we eliminate all the causes of suffering. Yet in developed societies suffering, certainly mental suffering, is as great or greater than in underdeveloped societies. The third wrong view is that suffering is created to having displeased God. This is the case of all monotheisms. Suffering is a penance inflicted by God upon the sinner.

And the fourth norm wrong view is that suffering is permanent in nature. This is the extremes of pessimism you find with some philosophers of the absurd such as Yonesco or Choran. Now the third Noble Truth, which Buddha Śākyamūni taught, is a Noble Truth of the cessation of suffering. After teaching what suffering is, what suffering’s causes are, Muller taught how to eliminate suffering. In the means to eliminate suffering, the cessation of suffering is selflessness, meditation on the selflessness of persons, which is ascertained by all Buddhist schools, and of phenomena, which is only ascertained by the Mahāyāna schools.

Then I shall not enter too much in the presentation of selflessness. Hopefully, we’ll be talking about the view in the last seminar of this year, and Geshe Japagetsin is presenting tenets. Then we will all be covering the view in great detail in tenets. But I’d like to talk about the core understanding of the selflessness of persons, which is shared by all the Buddhist schools, Hīnayāna or Mahāyāna. This is known as the Course surfaces of persons.

In other words, that persons are empty of being permanent, one, and independent. And those of you who attend tenets, this is quite familiar. For those of you who don’t, I won’t enter into too many details. It simply means that depression is seen as impermanent, in other words changing instant by instant, multiplicitous, in other words, composed of many components, both physical and mental, the five aggregates and the constituents of the five aggregates, and not independent, in other words, dependent, dependent on its constituents and so forth. Then in the context of the truth of cessation, I would like to talk about the compatibility of the various schools of Buddhist philosophy and quantum mechanics.

The conclusion, if you wish, of yesterday afternoon’s talk. The world in a drop of water. You have four schools of Buddhist philosophy. Again, this will be easier for those of you who are studying tenets than for the others. Two Hīnayāna schools, the Vaibhāṣika and Sattrantika school, and two Mahāyāna schools, the Chitamatra and Mādhyamika school.

The Vaibhāṣika and Sautrantika schools to this day are the dominant schools of Buddhist philosophy studied in the Theravāda countries, such as Burma, Thailand, Sri Lanka, and so forth. Chittamatra has been extremely influential in China and Japan, Madhya Mika in the later phase in India and especially in Tibet. Of these four schools, two are realistic. In other words, they teach that the outer world exists independently of an observer. It’s the Vaibhāṣika and Sautrantika schools in red.

As realistic schools, they are not compatible with quantum mechanics as we understand it at present. Two of these schools are not realistic. Chitamatra is idealistic. It teaches that now we will cover this briefly, that phenomena and the mind are of one nature. Mādhyamika, especially Prasangika Mādhyamika, teaches the interdependence of mind and phenomena.

Both Chittamatra and Mādhyamika, specifically Prasadhika Mādhyamika, are fully compatible with quantum mechanics. And therefore, I will present briefly the Chitamatra and Prasangika Mādhyamika viewpoints. I thought the drawing was very nice for our topic. We have a person who is effective, but when you examine there is nothing. What is Chitamatra phenomenology?

For the Chitamatra school, each one of us carries what is known as an Alāyavijñāna or a mind basis of all. This is the fundamental mind. In this mind, we find comic imprints. When these karmic imprints mature, let’s say this little comic imprint in blue matures, they simultaneously generate the appearance of the phenomenon being observed, such as a blue color of the sky, and the mind perceiving this, in other words, the eye consciousness perceiving the blue color of the sky, but both are actually of the nature of mind. In other words, according to the Chitamatra school, the perception of exterior phenomena is an illusion.

When I at present look at Aaron, the eye the karmic imprint, which gives rise simultaneously to my perception of Aaron and to the eye consciousness perceiving Aaron has matured. And I have the illusion that Aaron exists independently of my consciousness, that he’s an exterior object. But according to Chitamatra, there is no such thing. Now this viewpoint is profoundly compatible with quantum mechanics. From the standpoint of this viewpoint, we could say that this as a whole, the blue color of the sky and the eye consciousness perceiving the blue color of the sky, are the wave function.

And the reason we encounter such difficulties in addressing the collapse of the wave function in quantum mechanics is simply because we are trying to separate consciousness from the phenomenon perceived by consciousness, whereas they are two facets of one same entity. So the Chikamatra viewpoint is one which is highly compatible with quantum mechanics. The Prasanika Mādhyamika viewpoint is a more complex viewpoint. Pasamika Mādhyamika teaches three types of interdependence: causal interdependence, the interdependence of cause and effect Companential interdependence, interdependence of the part and the whole, imputation interdependence, which is the interdependence between what is imputed in the imputed phenomenon. We will cover these carefully together.

Regarding cause and interdependence, all of these schools of Buddhist philosophy, Vaubashika, Sautrantika, Cittamātra, and Mādhyamika, teach that the effect depends on the cause without exception. The effect could not have arisen without the cause. You cannot have a pine tree without a pine cone giving rise to that pine tree. Prasamika Mādhyamika, in addition, teaches the dependence of the cause on the effect. Since if an effect did not exist, the basis for designating something as a cause would not exist either.

So Prasangika madhyamika considers that there is a two way interdependence between cause and effect. Not only does the effect depend on the cause, but the cause as well depends on the effect. This is causational dependence according to Prasamika Manyamika. In addition, Prasangika considers that there is componential interdependence where the parts of a whole depend on that whole, and the whole itself in turn depends on its parts. So I have taken for in here the directions of the color blue to divide the color blue, but I could as well have taken my own body.

If I take my form aggregate on my body, then clearly we can say that my body depends on its parts. Without legs, head, feet, and so forth, my body does not exist. But the parts as well depend on my body because clearly, if my body did not exist, this hand could not be called my hand. It becomes my hand because it’s part of a totality. So we have a two way interdependence of parts and whole as well.

The most complex topic is imputation interdependence in Prasangika. Imputation just means attributing. So let us imagine that we have the first instant of the blue color of the sky or any other phenomenon. It’s a visual object. A mind observes this and imputes or attributes the name, first instant of the blue color of the sky.

This is the process of imputation. Then clearly, the imputed phenomenon, the first instance of the blue color, depends on the imputing mind. You have to correct this here, the mind. But likewise, this mind which is imputing the first instance of the blue color of the sky could not exist if the blue color of the sky did not exist. So the imputation imputation dependence functions both ways.

The Prasangika viewpoint is therefore a view viewpoint in which everything depends on everything else. It is impossible if you wish to isolate phenomena. Then this is something which I’m sure mister Jabba Gilsson will make much clearer in his presentation on tenets. And the truth of cessation then leads us to a presentation of the four wrong engagements of the truth of cessation, which are all connected with materialism. The first wrong engagement is that the truth of cessation does not exist.

In other words, there is no end to suffering. This is very common as a viewpoint among materialists. The second is that there is a partial liberation of some features. This again would be quite widespread among materialists who feel that some aspects of suffering can be eradicated, let us say through means such as poverty eradication programs, and others cannot. I will skip the third perhaps, but the fullness is quite striking and very problematical.

It is that true liberation does not exist. In other words, that it is possible to attenuate suffering, but it is not possible to eradicate it completely. It is possible, let us say, meditation to lead a more peaceful life, but it is not possible through meditation to eliminate suffering at the root so that it never ever returns, so that it was the abandonment of suffering. Now these are all materialist fallacies, and the source of Bionama has said many times that the most difficult point in understanding the Four Noble Truths is understanding the actual existence of a truth of cessation. This is a very difficult topic because once one understands that the truth of cessation means the actual abandonment of suffering and its causes, which will never return ever again, whatever the conditions, it is a very challenging topic, and one really must examine carefully whether such such a realization is possible.

It is not the elimination of suffering through śamatha, where suffering becomes non manifest for the duration of śamatha and attenuated otherwise. It’s not the elimination of desire through the application of an antidote whenever the desire arises. It is the permanent, endurable elimination of suffering so that whatever occurs later, suffering will never arise. It’s a very powerful statement. And the first noble truth is a noble truth of the Pathe, this is Ajahn Buddha Dasa, one of Thailand’s greatest monks, remarkably close to the Mahāyāna.

It is often said that in terms of view he was very close to Chitamatra. Then the path from the standpoint of Mahāyāna is threefold. One can follow the path of the hearers or the Shavakas, the path of the solitary realizers, or the path of the Bodhisattvas, the Mahāyāna. The difference between the two is the motivation. Hearers and solitary realizers generate renunciation, the wish to be freed of psychic existence, and independence on this they enter either the path of the hearers or the path of the solitary realizers and attain a liberation from psychic existence.

Bodhisattvas generate bodhichitta and independence on bodhichitta and with the path of the bodhisattvas, the five paths, and eventually attain not liberation but full enlightenment and omniscience. Perhaps of all my teachers, I feel closest to Tokish Holiness to Dalai Lama. It is difficult nowadays to meet his holiness with his very heavy schedule, but he has had a very powerful impact on my mind. I feel particularly close to the statement of His Holiness at Dalai Lama. I have done one thing that I think is a contribution.

I helped Buddhist science and modern science combine. No other Buddhist has done that. Then, as a very simple student of His Holiness, I have tried to do something similar within my very limited capacities. This covers what I have to present to you during this symposium. To recapitulate, we covered during the first conference yesterday what materialism was, its genesis, its historical development, the do on of the scientific method, what paradigm shift in science was, the various shifts in paradigm which have occurred in physics, and what characterizes them.

Then during the second conference yesterday, I pointed out that a major paradigm shift was occurring at present in physics because of quantum physics. That this paradigm shift was a process which was not yet fully integrated, and that it entailed abandoning materialism and perhaps as well realism and locality. In other words, it entailed giving up an idea very current in our society that the mind is a byproduct of the brain, and that the exterior world, it exists independently of the mind perceiving it. We then drew on data accumulated by psi researchers to show that there is a lot of evidence that telepathy does occur, and there have been very solid studies establishing the existence of psychokinesis. After this, this morning, I tried to summarize the data from medicine, biology and psychiatry, which moots the materialist viewpoint of the mind, and I pointed out that there were a series of arguments which are very problematical for the materialist.

First, the existence of a single neuron memories, if it is confirmed, then the existence of autistic savants and children. Then we discussed certain particularly troubling cases such as veridical near death experiences, cases of the reincarnation type, of which Stevenson has studied more than eight ninety five verified cases, and cases of possession, which clearly seem to confirm that the mind is a non material entity. And finally, this afternoon, we’re trying to draw all these strands together to see which school of thought, which spiritual tradition if any, can account for this. And I pointed out that a school which could account for this would have to have a variety of features. It would have to teach reincarnation.

It would have to teach that the exterior world is intimately related to the mind. It would have to teach impermanence. And when we went down the list of features, we found among the Indian schools of philosophy that only three satisfied these criteria. This was Vedanta, Chitamatra, and Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika. And then on this basis, we engaged in a presentation of the Buddha’s core teachings on the four noble truths.

As you remember, we try to understand the truth of suffering. It’s threefold, sixfold, and eightfold subdivisions, and specifically the difference between the suffering of suffering and the suffering of change. And I pointed out that there is much evidence nowadays to confirm that pleasure is merely the reduction in suffering, And the speed of the reduction in suffering can describe the intensity of the pleasure. And therefore, that Buddhist teachings on the suffering of change are strongly corroborated by modern neurobiological research, or perhaps research in cognitive psychology. After presenting the noble truth of suffering, we presented the noble truth of the origin of suffering, and we did this in other words, karma and pleasure, we did this through relying on a case, a case of rigiartne.

As you saw with the four lives, there’s a clear correlation between the first and the second life, and the first and the fourth life. Finally, we briefly presented the noble truth of cessation, and specifically within these four schools of tenets, two of which are quantum mechanical compatible, the two first ones, two of which are not excuse me, two of which are not quantum mechanical compatible, the two first ones, and two of which are the two latter ones, Chitamatra and Prasanika Mādhyamika. And finally, we briefly alluded to the noble truth of the path. Then, if you have any questions, we have almost one hour for questions. Yes.

If I may, of all a comment on the screen. I have a comment to make on the screen as it is the present and then a question to you personally. Must be two or three years ago there was a telecast which I was lucky enough to see of a panel of four people discussing the nature of science and the future of the universe. One of the members was the Dalai Lama and it was his practice regularly happy to associate himself in discussions with physical scientists. I was not surprised later but I was surprised at the time when he was asked a question if science proved in a scientific sense you know successfully access accepted the probable a particular truth which contradicted the tenet of Buddhist philosophy what would this situation in understanding that.

That was my view of it. The question is with thanks for being lucky enough to listen to you the last two days. I think you did mention that we were in the process of compiling this kind of material in this publication. So my question is, is it close enough for us to look for a publication and when where? Well, I’ll be doing the index Monday and Tuesday, basically.

So it’s what we are doing is we have created a publishing company, Jungren Publications, to start publishing the works of Khensur Rinpoche. And I’ve been asked to be the director of Jamgan Publications. Then, Hisuasa Dararama asked Khensur Rinpoche to teach on Nagajuna’s bodhichitta Vivarana at TBI. And we have or I have prepared a translation of bodhichitta Vivarana and heavily edited Rinpoche’s commentary on bodhichitta Vivarana in conjunction with a major Tibetan commentary by Nawand Rappa. Then I was going to write an introduction to these, a small introduction.

And the small introduction blossomed into a sixty, seventy page work, which is almost a minor treatise. Because as I was writing the introduction the first time, I asked myself a question, and I think it’s a question we do not have the luxury not to ask. Why basically, in 2014, should a modern educated westerner be studying these works? It’s a question which lies unspoken in the minds of many of our students. Is it purely out of historical or philosophical interest, or is there something else?

Then, as you mentioned, it is very much my feeling. The one question we have to ask systematically is a question of truth. Are these teachings true or not? Because if they are not true, they only have historical interest, and I, for myself, do not really have time to dedicate to that. If they are true, with a capital t, then it is the most important thing there is.

Whether they are true or not cannot be established for everything, but certainly for a large swathe of the teachings which has an intersection with modern scientific research, that question can be answered. That’s what the introduction covers. The introduction covers much of the material we have covered here, perhaps in greater depth. The genesis of materialism in the West, the fallacies of materialism, the arguments which can be invoked against it from physics and from medicine, biology, and psychiatry, and the compatibility of core Buddhist teachings with modern physics and the discovery of cases of the reincarnation type and so forth. And then within this, the introduction also addresses the issue of, which of the Buddhist schools of tenets are quantum mechanic compatible and which are not.

And on this basis, at the end of that introduction, I felt I could say that not only do we have the right to study Nāgārjuna’s works in 2014, we have a duty to do so. These works are not only relevant, they are profoundly significant, profoundly significant. And I would go further, I would say that in my opinion, they provide perhaps a road leading to a resolution of the conundrums quantum physicists have had to face, which seem to me to hinge largely on a mistaken dissociation of subject and object of mind and observed phenomenon, which is unavoidable. I mean, all mathematics is built on that. All mathematics is entirely built on the premise that I am able to write equations and be separate from the equations I write.

Then, at some point in the future, I would like to publish, a book entirely on this topic, but I have to find the time to do so. And also, frankly, it’s very awkward because I do feel that I am dabbling in areas which are not my specialty, which is very unfortunate, but nobody else seems to be able to want to do it. So there’s little choice in the matter. It would be better to have a physicist handle the physics and a biologist handle the biology. And my training is in Buddhist philosophy for me to handle the philosophical side, the Buddhist side.

But we are not able to get or to gain that sort of contribution, so we make do with whom we have. Do you have any other questions? Elia, it’s me again. Thank you very much for presenting the gold. I hope you don’t mind if I rub it a bit.

Sorry. For presenting what? I said thank you for presenting us with the gold. I hope you don’t mind if I rub it a bit. Mhmm.

Mhmm. With the the POS, I think it’s The what? The POS? Positive stimulus, yes. I was googling on the internet last night and I did find, as a matter of curiosity, papers which suggested that the brain was hardwired for language.

That is Chomsky’s position. That’s Chomsky’s position. As I mentioned, Chomsky considers that the brain is, as you say, hardwired for language. In other words, there’s a universal language that’s somehow imprinted in the brain, that this hardwiring is genetic. The basic problem is that when one asks the Chomskyans, it’s the school which holds that position, what the principles of this hardwiring are, what the rules are, in other words.

What they propose, as I mentioned yesterday, is either so simple that basically it doesn’t help at all, or then it is complex enough that it excludes languages, such as, for instance, Tibetan. And the example, I would give is that of basic syntax, in other words, grammar. Take English. In English, the typical syntax of an English sentence entails having a subject followed by a verb, followed by an object. It’s called an SVO language.

Most, but by no means, all Western languages are SVO languages. French is an SVO language, German is an SVO language of the principal clause. Russian is not. In Russian, the verb can be anywhere you want, at the beginning, middle or end of the sentence. In Tibetan, the verb must be at the end of the sentence.

Tibetan is an s o v language. Then if something as fundamental as a sequence of subject, verb, and object varies so much in languages all over the world, The question is, what content does a universal language have? It’s not vocabulary we’re talking about. Right? It’s linguistic structure.

And if it has no content, then as I pointed out, how can a child learn to speak? Because there is a broad agreement that the amount of linguistic data the child receives from his mother during the first couple of years is simply insufficient for the child to be able to extrapolate the rules of the language. But before the child goes to school, he speaks, otherwise, when he goes to school, he couldn’t even understand his professors, right, his teachers in kindergarten. And then, poor Chomsky in a sense, you know, he presented a brilliant argument, but it’s an argument to which he has no solution to offer. So there’s been this sort of, I suppose, gentleman’s agreement in linguistics not to talk about it too much, but researchers like Stromswold, and I mentioned this yesterday, analyzed the number of logical possibilities of auxiliary verbs, like to have, to be, and so forth, a child would have to face in English, which is a relatively simple language, and it was of the order I think of 10 power 22, if memory serves me all, which is huge.

And they found that the child does not receive enough information, linguistic information, to understand how to compose a correct sentence with an auxiliary verb. And yet, in the cases Trondvoort examined, children never seem to make major mistakes. And this is a very strong argument in favor of the transmission of some type of linguistic structure from somewhere. And Chomsky’s case, that it’s genetic or that the brain is somehow hardwired for language, is really not accepted anymore by anybody. Because if my brain is hardwired for Tibetan, it’s not hardwired for English.

I can guarantee that. If it’s hardwired for English, it’s not hardwired for Chinese. I’m not an academic, and the brief reading I did suggested, and there was some recent papers on this, that they believe, a, the part of the brain which deals with language is larger in humans than it is in primates and also suggests that children learn in utero and they were able to recognize words their mother spoke to them when they were born in succulent. Apparently the amount of vigor that an infant expresses on a mother’s breast is a demonstration of its stimulus its brain is receiving. So if its mother was bilingual, it could recognize any words from those two languages.

It’s not words we’re talking about. You see, that’s the key. We’re not talking of vocabulary or even as a vocabulary acquisition, it’s difficult. I I can vouch for that from my own personal experience, because I tried to learn Tibetan from a Tibetan teacher who spoke no English when I was 19, and it was a really pretty much nightmarish experience. We were pointing at things, but we weren’t quite sure what we were pointing at.

And I was quite well educated, you know. I had the the very devil of a time understanding, you know, just very simple things like what walls were and so forth. What we’re talking about in the poverty of stimulus argument is not vocabulary, it’s grammatical structure. Where the verb goes, where the subject goes, where the object goes. And this is something all of us do automatically in English.

Then it’s very difficult to see how this could occur. It’s well known that language has an influence on the brain. So this has been there’s been a lot of research in the last fifteen years on this topic. Speaking a language changes the brain structure of the person who speaks a language. Just one known, you know.

Does that answer your question? Yes and no. But there was another question. We were talking about these issues or instances of reincarnation. It seemed to me that what you were saying that in the majority of cases, Stevenson was able to document of children with memories died violent deaths.

Yes. What is it about dying violently that brings them, seems to bring them straight back as a human rather than going somewhere else. They don’t come straight back as a human. We have no way of knowing where they have been, but they have no memory of knowing human rebirth with the exception of the occasional animal rebirth. You’ll find in Stevenson’s cases, children with huge gaps between the lives, gaps of years or decades sometimes, which are unaccounted for.

But the child has, generally speaking, no memory. When the child has a memory of an animal rebirth, it is typically the type of memory which a rat may had. In other words, it’s a memory of one thing, flitting from tree to tree, or another child who had a memory of a past life as an animal just remembered being shot. Memories of hell realms are exceptional. When they happen, they’re also very similar to Vijayaratne’s memories.

It’s just a memory of fire. Now there are two problems with this. The first is that Stevenson himself, and this is in 20 cases of a reincarnation type, acknowledges that he has not talked about animal memories in the cases he studied. He has a clear bias against animal memories, probably just in my opinion because his research was already controversial enough without bringing in the picture something which is even less acceptable to a Western audience. You do find cases of animal memories, so I had to chase them in Stevenson’s work for you, and I wish I knew which cases were kept Suborza in his files.

But I don’t. Now why there are so few memories and when they happen they tend to be one event? In my opinion, it is simply because experiences in the herald realms or experiences at Anna as animals have nothing in common with human experiences. So you have to translate mental experiences, right? Then any experience in the Herald Realm would probably be meaningless to the mental state of a normal human being.

You might have an experience of horrific suffering or pain, but they would probably be little or no mental image. Animal experiences, you tend to have one or two images. The cases I remember in Stevenson’s research with animal research, with animal memories, is this one of a giraffe, reading from cue to tree, another one of a young Sri Lankan who became a monk after having these memories, who was shot as a rabbit, and another one of a young boy who could not explain what the experience was, but he remembered running all the time, being unable to see side to the right or to the left, and constantly being stung by insects. And it seems he had the memory of being a horse, but he did not identify as a horse. He just had a memory of suffering and of incapacity to look side by side, and he was Sri Lankan.

They used to use, in the interval in which this memory occurred, horse drawn carts. So I hope that goes towards answering your question. Well, since you have the microphone, we can’t say no, can we? It’s just you can’t say no. But the next one is for someone else.

Okay. Probably have a million questions, but I’ve managed to formulate one or two into words. In the context of low risk or mind of mental factors, I was trying to apply In which context, excuse me? Low risk, mind of mental factors. I was trying to apply the Von Neumann cut, and I might be splitting hairs with this, but I was wondering if the threshold of attention affects the collapse of the wave function.

Well, once one talks of Luric, I was going to bring it up in this class, but it’s really complicated and I just thought I would leave it to the side. One has to address the question, which mind causes the collapse of the wave function? Then own minds probably do not cause a collapse of the wave function. In my opinion, it is a valid cognizer which causes a collapse of the wave function. Then do both valid cognizers, inferential and direct valid cognizers, cause a collapse of a wave function?

That’s an open question. Direct valid cognizers, I think, are prime candidates. You really would have to sit down with a very good physicist and look at the consequences of asserting that an inferentially valid cognizer can cause the collapse of a wave function. I don’t know whether it is possible to assert that or not. So that is one path of inquiry.

Another path of inquiry is to consider that it is certain components associated with a mind which can cause the collapse of the wave function. As you know, every main mind has five omnipresent mental factors and five determining mental factors. Within these, you can include intention. Then what I’ve been working upon is whether the mental factor of intention, which is necessarily associated with any main mind perceiving an object, is what would cause the reduction of the state vector. But this is all very theoretical.

Certainly, quantum physicists refer to intention within the measurement process. They don’t refer to consciousness, quark consciousness. But you would really for something like this, you would have to have some very good physicists and some good Buddhist philosophers assembled for a symposium. We we have never had the possibility for something like this. It’s not something one can answer casually.

Yes, any other questions? I don’t know if this had really anything to do with the symposium but is there a Buddhist view on what is today known as the Akashic records everybody seems to be going on about the Akashic records and how it’s a record of everything you say do think all that kind of thing and how you can access your Akashic records and find out basically, your history. It’s not a Buddhist concept. It is a concept which was developed in theosophy, which seems to come from the book of judgment in Christianity. You don’t find the concept of Akashic records in any Indian religion.

Then I have no particular position on it, except to say basically that neither Buddhism nor Hinduism accept its existence. Theosophy drew on several different religious traditions, and I must say has been extraordinarily beneficial. I mean, I remember when I was interested in Buddhism as a very well, young teenager, really. Most of the students at the Buddhist center I became a translator at were philosophically inclined, and it made the transmission of the Buddhist teachings to the West very easy. There were a lot of compatibilities, far more than now.

Now it has become very difficult. Because the theosophists shared a lot of core beliefs, with the Buddhist belief in reincarnation, then there were disagreements about the nature of the person and the soul, but that was perfectly manageable. They believed in mahatmas, which seemed, broadly speaking, to correspond to bodhisattvas. There were bridges. Now what we find is that our public comes really from a spiritual wasteland.

There’s nothing, basically. Then, obviously, they are searching for answers, but it’s very difficult to bridge it build a bridge when you have nothing to build the bridge to. For instance, I remember the most extraordinary conversation I had with a Comedian monk. He came all the way. We were in Lausanne at the monastery.

He came at the period as a big distance from Fribo, some 100 kilometers away. And, it was just to ask one question. And, he came to the monastery, and he said to me, I have only one question. He said, is the trinity, the father, son, and the holy ghost, the same or different from the trikaya? The dharmakaya, the samogakaya, and the opakaya.

And I I I was very struck. This is very powerful mind. You know, someone comes with such a clear question, you know, which hits the nail on the head, you know. And I said to to him, the trikaya is basically different from the presentation of the trinity in the Council of Nicaea, but it is similar to the presentation of the Trinity in the Apollinarian sect. He said, thank you very much.

Goodbye. It’s a very well trained mind, you know, very well trained mind. There’s a very striking case for me of a bridge between traditions, you see, because he was a profoundly devout Christian who had studied theology. It was actually very easy to bridge with him. My, teacher, Geshe Rabten, had very close contacts with Franciscan monks and would teach meditation in Franciscan monasteries in Italy.

And the communication was excellent, simply because once one is well trained in one tradition, one understands very quickly the similarities and different differences with other traditions. Obviously, there are points where there’s no point in discussing because the differences, the existence of God with the non existence of God are fundamental. But there are points where it’s easy to bridge, and one is trained to be able to do so. Nowadays, the situation is very difficult because I think the majority of our students when they come, really believe in nothing at all. Or it’s a big soup, that’s the alternative.

I’m not quite sure what’s the worst. And then, if they believe in nothing, they have a very powerful nichilist bias, which is almost impossible to counter. Because not only do they believe that really there is nothing, but in addition, they believe that it can never prove be proved it proven that there isn’t anything but nothing. And if they have a soup in their mind, and there was a big mixture of Hinduism, Buddhism, Christianity, New Age, etcetera, then whatever you say to them goes in the soup, and the soup has no flavor at all. So it is a very difficult situation nowadays.

So difficult that his holiness really has encouraged Westerners to think very carefully, very carefully before converting to Buddhism, which was not at all the message of his holiness when I started out. I’m sorry. It’s a very long answer to your question. Is it time then for a new religion, so to speak, to combine the best of Buddhism and best of of our science. I see you love soups.

Who’s gonna decide what’s the best? Right? Who says? My personal feeling is when it comes to these matters, we should not be thinking of the collective. All of us are obsessed with the spread of Buddhism in the West or the creation of a new religion.

Basically, these are things which don’t concern us, and we have no power whatsoever in the field. What we do have some control over is our own development. And then I think personally that the way forwards is to focus on our own mental and spiritual development. If we develop ourselves, we will benefit. It’s undeniable.

And eventually, others will be developed, will be influenced by our own development. And in this way, we can really help others. If many choose to go this way, eventually an entire society is transformed. To artificially create some sort of synthesis of Buddhism and Christianity, Buddhism and science, it wouldn’t work. It wouldn’t work.

Over what I think we have in front of us is a is a private individual world. Either we ourselves of course, we have to choose to practice a religious tradition. Many people don’t want to choose. I I think it’s a very characteristic trait of the modern mind to want to have it all at the same time. Choosing something means closing the doors to something else.

So if we choose to be a Buddhist, we close the doors to being a Hindu. If we choose to be a Hindu, we close the doors to being a Christian. If we choose to be a materialist, we close the doors to all spiritual traditions. It’s very important to have mental clarity, to understand that everything is not compatible with everything else. As I said to two very nice old Western students of Kinsura Bridge who are asking me the question whether one could be a Buddhist and not believe in past and future lives, nor believe in karma and causality, I said Buddhism is not infinitely flexible.

I mean, at a certain point, you are not a Buddhist anymore. So this clarity is very important. And then once one has that clarity, one has to choose a spiritual tradition which corresponds to oneself, and then one must practice single pointedly. Nothing is to be gained by soups. Mixing things really from what we see, it never benefits.

At the beginning, we must investigate broadly. Check all the spiritual traditions, monotheistic, the great Indian traditions. There are excellent introduction books on the monotheisms. There are extra excellent books on the great Indian religious traditions, and then find a religious tradition which one sincerely feels is true, and then verify whether it is true to the limits of one’s capacity. That’s what we try to do here in the symposium.

And I’ve tried to give you the arguments which I see, as I see it, make a strong point for core Buddhist teachings. We’re not talking about the teachings about Mount Meru, but core Buddhist teachings, being true in reflecting reality. Then after that it’s out of my hands. So within half an hour my job is done, and your job starts or does not start. That’s entirely up to you.

You have to live with the decisions you will be making. If you never start on a spiritual path, you have to live with a situation at the time of your death. The death of somebody who is a sincere materialist is very difficult. I have been present at a fair number of deaths in my life. Chris Ridley, our director, is has much more experience than I do in the field, and I’m sure he can corroborate that these deaths are not easy.

And at that time, it’s too late. It’s too late. It is while the going is good, while one is still in good health, while one’s head is above the water in all senses of the term, physics physically, psychologically, and even economically, that one has to put effort for the period which is difficult and which is approaching for all of us in this room. I mean, this may be the exception of Maggie in the back. Most of us are 50, 60, Maggie and Lily.

Then that means there’s what? Ten, twenty years? Maybe quite a few less for most of us. Okay. Aaron too is young.

Thirty years for Aaron. Aaron is working very hard, and he is the one who has the most of time in front of him. Right? So that’s what I would say. I would say a human life is short, very short.

Then you have to put effort in what matters. What matters is finding what human destiny is. Where do we go after this life, if we go anywhere? And then it’s been part of the main effort of mankind to find the answer of these questions. Which of the answers are true?

Now we have a fair bit of data which enables us to decide, and if we find something which we think is true, then we have to live it as intensely as we can. It’s entirely up to us, you know, entirely up to us. I think as citizens of a developed country, we are very fortunate in some respects and very unfortunate in other respects. We’re very fortunate because countries like Australia and most of the Western world conditions are exceptional. Right?

I mean, we gather here, we have electricity, we have magnificent setup in India if I was presenting this topic, we’d have no loudspeakers or anything. Right? I mean, if we had loudspeakers, have to have a generator running outside. So the conditions are superb. All of you, all of us are well fed, over fed if anything, in excellent health.

You want a book, you can buy a book. You want to study Buddhism, you can. The police, as in Tibet, is not there to prevent you from studying, because the conditions are superb. The downside is we’re not exposed to any hardship. What we think of as hardship really isn’t hardship.

As in Australia, all the crying and the bleating, now that a conservative government has come to power. It’s it’s pathetic, you know. It’s pathetic. A small change in welfare, and everyone is running around as if it’s the end of the world. There are parts parts of the world where people have no food.

Right? Then one has to have a certain amount of of dignity, you know. I mean, this is a country where everyone gets handouts. Then one gets a little bit less in terms of handouts. It behooves one to be to be modest and accept that, you know, maybe there’s not enough money, and one accepts fewer handouts.

There’s still a handout. There’s still money. There’s food. So great hardship here, one doesn’t experience. As a result, the teachings do not penetrate easily the minds of the student.

And I see a very good contrast with other Western societies. Let’s say, for instance, Russia. I have many Russian friends. I’m fluent. I used to be near native in Russian.

When you present the Buddhist teachings in Russia, a temple like this is full to the brim. People know what suffering is. They know firsthand. Violence, hardship, poverty, difficult conditions, and Russian students are marvelous students to have. They are driven.

They are driven. And the greater the level of comfort in the country, the slack of the student. Right? And what do you do? So that’s why I think it’s a toss.

Right? I hope I can defend you with these comments, but I have seen fairly hard societies in my life, and I just wish all of our students could use the opportunities they have more they have them. It won’t last forever. And now is the time, everyone’s heads above the water, now is the time to put effort. Later on, you may not be able to do so because most of us as westerners, because we’re not accustomed to hardship, we are weak.

Right? When the trouble really starts, will we be able to basically fight, function, survive, and at the same time have some type of practice? I don’t know. Think of a country like Greece or Spain or Portugal, if you know the situation over, these are Western countries, where the economies have tanked in the last two, three years. Imagine if this happened to Australia, how would you handle it?

A good friend of mine is an old friend. He’s a geshe from the health care center at Sera. We go back fifteen more than fifteen years. Excellent monk. He was sent as a geshe to Barcelona in Spain five, six years ago.

Then he loved it, even though he said their outlook is a bit strange. He said, whenever you present the Buddhist teachings about renunciation and so forth, they ask you, what about passion? He said, what is this passion business? I said, well, it’s Latin culture. Right?

But it was very striking because two years ago, we met at CERA, and I said to him, how is it going? The financial crisis had hit Spain. He said, so far, so good. He said, it’s ‘s hit the country big time, but our students are taking it in stride. It has not hit the center too much.

Then I met him this year in India during the internalization of Ketzogre, Ogins reincarnation, my late teacher. And there’s a lot of time he came to me and he had some questions. I just waited until they came out. And I was very struck in one year the difference. He said, our students are facing great hardship.

Unemployment in certain age groups is above 50%. And he said to me, our students live in a state of fear. They fear that if they lose their jobs, they will be unable to pay their mortgages, and they will end up on the street. They are unable to concentrate, unable to study, unable to meditate. He asked me directly, he said, what would you propose?

I’m trying to find something I can say to them. What would you propose? I had nothing. In the past I have always suggested that people reduce their debt load, but in a case like that it’s over. Then if the person has not trained their minds before such hardship happens, then how are they going to train their minds while it’s happening?

It’s too late. So you yourselves, you are not in such a different situation. I mean, Australia has been described by some as a Banana Republic, as you know, totally dependent on middle exports. In many respects, you are satellite of China and Japan, of China mainly. You may know or may not know this, but there’s a big downturn going on right now in China.

I have some contacts in Chinese factories, we communicate an engineer. I know in Shanghai, actually. He wrote me recently. I he asked me how it was here. I said, so so.

I said, so how is it over there? He said, it’s difficult. There’s a big downturn downturn in Chinese real estate, which is impacting all of the Chinese economy. Then when it comes here and your lifestyles are under big pressure, will you have the strength to manage? And will you have the strength on top of that to continue your studies and your practice or not?

We don’t know. We’ll know when it happens. So that’s why, you know, I encourage all of you to put effort now. The conditions are good, reasonably good. We have a good center, we have good teachers, you have access to books, to a library, you have free time, which is a very big thing in life.

If you want to study, you can study, if you want to meditate, you can meditate. Because it may not be possible in four or five years. I was very struck in my last conversation with Kinsor Rinpoche, before Rinpoche departed. Rinpoche’s main focus was the actual survival of the center. The actual survival of the center.

Vahempaji could see or can see quite far. So it’s a long answer to your question, but just to say we have excellent opportunities here and my feeling is there is one place where greed is perfectly legitimate, and that’s spiritual practice. Please be greedy, be demanding, give us a hard time, because that’s what we’re here for. Later on, it may be all you have. It may be.

My family has gone through great difficulties. Most of my family was killed in World War two, you know. And I never forget my father was a very wealthy man in Yugoslavia before the war, was supposed to become minister of health. Overnight everything was destroyed. And he told me what he was left with was some philosophy he had studied in school.

He was put in a concentration camp. He went from being a very important person to someone you could kill, you know, at a moment’s notice. But this philosophy he had studied, that helped his mind. That’s what we’re doing here, You know? Do we have other questions?

Yes, please. We talked about reincarnation and possession. I saw an interview with a heart surgeon who’d done a lot of heart transplants and had written a book after about twenty years of doing the heart transplants and seeing the patients and he came to realize that through studying all the recipients that they very often took on character traits and personalities of the donors of the hearts that they receive. And it could be that they were it could be something simple as like they didn’t used to eat spices at all and now they were vindaloo curry people. It was they were total.

They used to hate jazz now they love jazz they used to hate sex now they’re an infomaniac whatever it would be like because one had received a young young woman who was a prostitute’s heart and she totally changed in character her husband was really surprised so it was really interesting that when we talked about possession and reincarnation and where consciousness and mind sits in the body, that in organ transplant and particularly heart, I would imagine that you could take on a part of the consciousness, mind, spirit, whatever you want to call it, of the donor. So I was wondering what you thought about that. I’ve never heard of that. Normally, a heart is just an organ, right? It’s a piece of matter.

You’ve heard of that too. Then I don’t know about that. Obviously, what is not impossible, you see, is that it’s not so much the heart, which would have an influence, has other factors. Clearly, heart is associated with the life of a person. If you receive a transplant of the heart of someone who has passed on, it’s possible you might attract the spirit of the departed person.

And without speaking of possession, you might be influenced. The Roman Catholic church distinguishes in its demonology, obsession, infestation, and possession, as the three stages leading to possession. And obsession would be the state where a person is under psychic pressure from a spirit. Something like that could be happening, but I don’t know. I have I’ve not read the studies, I’ve not read this case, you know.

Do you have other questions? Thank you for your exhortation to put into practice the Buddhist teachings. It’s very good to hear. My question is a small one compared to that. For a while I’ve tried to understand the increasing nature of karma.

And thanks for the reference to chaos theory, I’ll have a look at that. And I have wondered for quite some time why for the killing deed to be complete, why the victim needs to die before the perpetrator? I don’t quite understand that. Because if the victim dies, the victim dies. I don’t understand why the perpetrator needs to still be alive when the victim dies for it to be complete?

I don’t understand it myself. I think it is related to the creation of a chain of 12 links I within the life of the person. Right. But the topic of karma is an extremely difficult topic. It’s much more difficult than emptiness.

At the same time, frankly, it’s much more beneficial for us. Because we probably will not be able to understand emptiness correctly, and few of us have the time to meditate seriously. But if we are able to live in keeping with karma and causality, then over time, over lives, things will go very well for us. We can progress upwards, eventually become perhaps ordained, and start practicing seriously, gain liberation or full enlightenment with function of our goals. So I don’t have a complete answer, but I think it is linked to the 12 links constitution in one life’s time.

Do you have other questions? I just wanted to reconcile something in my notes. I may have not taken this down correctly, But I have written here not every event is karma, but the pleasure or suffering experienced by the mind is karma. Did I hear that That’s correct, yes. And then Just beyond that, it was mentioned about the type of rebirth, I guess the birth being an event and then the completing karma, which are the events within that life.

These are all events and they’re linked to karma. But prior to that, you had said that not an event is karma, but the mind experiencing the event is karma. Can’t reconcile that. Although it’s casual speaking on my part. Basically, in strict Buddhist philosophy, karma gives rise to pleasant, unpleasant, or neutral experiences.

All pleasant or unpleasant experiences are necessarily the product respectively of virtuous and non virtuous karma. It’s not the case that every single human experience without exception during every moment of the day is a product of one specific karmic event. If that was the case, there would be really no possibility to change one’s behavior at all, would be completely conditioned. Then when it comes to projecting and completing karma, obviously the main features or the nature of a rebirth is a direct result of past karma, past projecting karma, which has to be a complete deed with four features. Not all the features in that rebirth are the result of completing karma, but the features which cause happiness or suffering are.

For instance, in the case of Vijayrapani, the deformation of his right arm is a source obviously of great suffering from birth. Then this is an instance of completing karma. In his life, it’s difficult to see what was the result of virtuous completing comma. Difficult to see. There was a lot of virtuous com projecting karma was his human rebirth, which obviously is a source of happiness since he does not experience the suffering of rebirth as an animal or any henryl.

But let us say, for instance, my buying this laser pointer is not the result of virtuous or non virtuous karma in the past. It’s a result of inter life causality. There may be a karmic link, there may not be a karmic link. But the exact understanding of karma is a very difficult topic. The moment you go beyond the general principles, it’s very difficult.

This is why it is said that all the general principles of karma can be understood independently and inferentially valid cognizer, specific karmic correlations can only be understood by Buddha Śākyamūni or the Buddhas themselves because it needs omniscience. When I presented the case of Vijayaratne, I presented a hypothetical reconstruction. There is no way I can tell you whether this is actually the karmic cause for his rebirth in the hell realm or not, although it looks very convincing, And there is no way I can tell you whether what gave rise to key elements in his human life are related to elements in life number one or not. Again, it’s it seems probable, but it is impossible for an ordinary sentient being such as myself to make such a statement. So this was given as a hypothetical case to show you how it would work.

Buddha Śākyamūni himself was able to do this. Buddha Śākyamūni was able, when given, for instance, a piece of wood, to say exactly what tree, from what area, under whose ownership that piece of wood came from. We do not have that capacity. Do you have other questions? The part about remembering the fire, could that be perhaps remembering death by fire instead of being in hell?

Possibly, but why at that moment? It was the last memory he had. It’s very difficult to know what it is. It could be simply caused by the pain of the moose, but it’s very striking. He describes it as a very clear memory of blazing flames and then death.

Well, then absence. Right? Not death, absence. I have extrapolated this as the first instant of a hell rebirth, Because when a very powerful non virtuous deed is committed and one is reborn in the lowest hell of Avicii, one does not go through the dissolution and one does not go through the Bardo state, intermediate state. Instead, one basically falls down like a stone, you know, it’s a metaphor which is used.

Then the deed in question probably became very powerful because of the factors we talked about. This was an innocent person who was defenseless, who was weaker than him, the deed was premeditated, the poor girl was stabbed repeatedly, then he rejoiced in the deed, did not repent, you know. All of this amplifies the deed and turns a heavy non virtuous deed of murder, the murder of another human being, into a deed which can cause rebirth in one of the lower hells. I suspect Avicii because this is how Avicii is described. Avicii is described as a hell in which oneself is fire and one is surrounded by fire.

The topic of the hell realms is a disturbing topic. I think all of us would like very much that they not exist, but the question is not so much what we would like, but whether it is possible that such rebirths exist or not. And if they do, definitely we should try not to experience them. And it’s interesting that all of the major religions in the world teach the existence of a hell. Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism all teach the existence of hell.

Obviously, you can say, if you are materialistically inclined that this is taught to keep people in the right place. But it is also perfectly possible that great mystics had experiences which showed them that after death, those who had harmed others could experience intolerable levels of suffering. And what’s interesting is that not the details, but the core descriptions of the hells is completely identical. Core description of the Christian hell and the Buddhist hell, there’s no difference. Look at the details, the eight hot hells, the eight cold hells, that is different.

But, the key elements, no. So I have always wondered if this was a core intuition. Then I have not presented those here, but there are a series of distressing near death experiences of typically of people who experience a near death experience because of attempted suicide or drug usage, and who in the near death experience saw what we would call yama muts, helpers of yama, guardians of the hell, come to drag them down to the hell realms, and these experiences were made by Westerners, Americans. And now there’s quite a bit of research on these distressing near death experiences. It’s more than thirty percent of the near death experiences, and it seems to have remained a very taboo topic in the field.

Again, a materialist would say that this is due to the drugs ingested, to the distress at the time of suicide, but it’s also perfectly possible that, these hell guardians exist. Oh, it’s food for thought for all of us, you know. Eliot. Yes. Sorry.

Just within the last few minutes, are you able to comment on the compatibility of the Gangian religions, Jainism, Hinduism, Buddhism, vis a vis quantum physics as opposed to the theistic Mhmm. Religions? Well, I think if we look at the core elements of the theistic religions, are very powerful for mental transformation, I’d like to say this at the beginning. As has said this repeatedly, and I think theistic religions are of tremendous benefit for a large number of people. The idea of a personal god to whom he is personally responsible is very powerful for mental transformation.

But philosophically, all theistic religions teach that God created a universe which is exterior to himself and exterior to us at the beginning. This universe is real and is independent of our perception of it. This is a core teaching of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. It is central to these religions because otherwise you end up with pantheism, where God and the universe fuse. Then if the universe is external to God and external to us as beings in the universe, we’re speaking of philosophically strong realism.

Strong realism is not compatible with quantum mechanics. I think that really at present can be said quite unambiguously. There there are Christian mystics, Muslim mystics, Jewish mystics, who at odds with the dominant theology of their religion have said, for instance the case of Meister Eckhart, that the world is very close to being one with God. These viewpoints were condemned as heresy, so they really are not mainstream. Then such a viewpoint, especially if beings themselves and beings consciousness were seen as fusing or coming close to matter, might be much more compatible with quantum mechanics, but this is not the mainstream view at all.

Whereas in the case of Indian philosophies, specifically Vedanta, Chitamatra, and Prasangika Mādhyamika Buddhism, it is explicitly taught that there is a very close connection between the world and our minds. For Chitamatra, our minds and the world we perceive are one in nature. For Prasangika Mādhyamika, they are interdependent. These views are strongly compatible with quantum mechanics. Does that answer your question, Chris?

Just to follow from that, you said there were two camps in quantum mechanics. There was the measurement camp and the observer camp. And when you mentioned that Chitamatras basically have mind and observation mind as mingled, sounds like they sit in the measurement camp? Those are just terms I use to make it more obvious. Nobody in quantum mechanics says that they are members of the measurement of the observer camp, but I just wondered, sometimes you have to, we say in French, you have to emphasize things a bit excessively to make it clear.

The terms observation and measurement as used in quantum mechanics and as used in Chitamatra are different. Basically what you do have in quantum mechanics is two broad divides between those who assert it is mind, which is non material, which causes a collapse of the wave function, and it is actually an observation with physical means, which causes a collapse of the wave function. This is what I meant when I spoke of the observation and measurement camps. Then obviously, the first camp in quantum mechanics is non materialistic. The second camp, Heisenberg, Niels Bohr and so forth, would probably be materialistic.

The debate continues to the present day. I’m not saying that it is resolved at all, but sympathy has really increased dramatically for von Neumann’s viewpoint. It just seems to fit with much of the recent data. Do you have any other questions before we go our separate ways? And I have a small question for you.

What will you do as a result of this symposium? What are your projects for the next year? Will it have an impact, in other words? Good. Good.

Read Stevenson’s. Very good. Very good. Very good. Anyone else?

Do you have any projects? Is there anything you have sort of resolved to do in the next year or so? Much of it time, how many years out? Diligently. That’s good.

That’s very good. You cannot go wrong if you try to read Stevenson with Lamrim Cemo in the background. That’s not easy. At the beginning, would say perhaps just read Stevenson. At a certain point, take Lamrim Chenmo’s section, calm and causality, and try to see, is this true or not?

Look at Stevenson’s cases. We have some good cases there. We have cases of children remembering two, three, even four lives, remembering human lives, sometimes animal lives, sometimes hell lives. We have the books in the library. If you can afford them, I would suggest to try to order them.

These books are progressively going out of print. Once you follow this path, you will find that you refer to them again and again. And then there is another book I would like to recommend again to all of you, and it is and I’ve seen that somebody has it already. It is irreducible mind by Kelly. As Stevenson’s book on the third bibliography, Irreducible Mind Towards the Psychology for the 20 Century in the general section, it’s still in print, it’s not very expensive, it is a work which is worth studying through in great detail with a magnificent bibliography, and as you know a bibliography basically is what points you to further reading.

Then with Kelly and Stevenson, I think you have really everything that is needed to build your practice on very solid grounds, very solid. Then, Kenny basically is one of the members of the division of personality studies at the University of Virginia, Stevenson’s division, and obviously they have drawn very heavily on the works of a psychologist, a British psychologist, F. W. H. Meyer, who lived in the nineteenth century, and who was trying to explain some of the problems we addressed.

I would say you could jump the sections on FWH Meyer, an irreducible mind. Meyer is a bit of a precursor of Carl Jung. If your focus is a Buddhist focus, it’s not terribly helpful as a system of explanations. So there are chapters there you can skip or you may choose to read them, it’s up to you. But the work itself is exceptional, absolutely exceptional.

Any other questions? Please. I think, ideally, a study of logic, which are the means of thinking, a study of Buddhist logic will be extremely helpful to you. We don’t teach Buddhist logic at TBI because it occurs or it is taught in the context of debate, and this would entail daily debates of one hour or more, and it just is not practicable. Our students do not have that amount of time.

If that is not possible, I think focusing on the courses Geshe Jappa Gelsen gives every Tuesday and participating in the discussions, which are pretty close to debate, will help you tremendously. Then the reading on the side, that you have to do by yourself. Geshela is not trained in that field. It’s basically with the exception of a couple of great teachers like Kishorenas, very few Tibetan masters are able to bridge things in that way. It’s something we have to do individually.

My goal in giving you the bibliographies is to give you some gateways. Then I would suggest, if you can, order the books. Many of the articles can be obtained for free on the Internet. The articles are quite technical, I think you might find them overwhelming. But some of the books are quite accessible, irreducible mind pays careful study, and then you have to study by yourself.

Stevenson, I think reading through Stevenson, studying Kelly, and not reading casually. You take the cases and you have to read them analytically pencil in hand, underlining the key points, and then at the end stopping and asking yourself for each individual case, what does this case prove? If two lives are reported, what is the relationship? Then perhaps go to Lamrim Chemo and say is this in keeping with Lamrim Chemo’s teachings on karma and causality or not? If not, ask Gisha Jaba Geltsi.

Then proceed in this way and progressively your understanding will deepen. At some point in the future, if we can, it would be marvelous if we could have teachings of Buddhist logic and debate at TBI. Thank you very much. Yuliya, once again you’ve shown that the depth and breadth of your knowledge and wisdom and experience is breathtaking and it is such a great privilege that we have been able to gather here for those of us who have been here for the whole weekend or even just today to be challenged and stimulated and pointed in the right direction in terms of our lives, our practice. So we would be eternally grateful if we heed what you were saying, that we have this rare opportunity to be able to have the advantage of hearing what you’ve been presenting.

And I think what you’re saying has literally world shattering implications. And so we will do our best to broadcast what you’ve been saying and we look forward to the publication as you described earlier and we have a lot of, as I said before, food for thought. Just a very tiny token. I know that you have absolutely no attachment to a very fine chocolate, but nevertheless, just as a small token of our appreciation. Look at my wife’s face.

We if you just join me again in thanking Aliyah. Thank you, Thank and my apologies for I didn’t realize you were standing holding my flowers. My apologies. And thank you all for coming. And you’re welcome if you would like to grab a cup of tea before you race off.

And as Ilya said, we’re also very privileged to have the calibre of Geshe Jampagawson here, one of the fine top lamas Geshe’s from Sera Je Monastery who is consistently delivering us teachings Tuesday and Wednesday nights. If you don’t have your name on our email list then feel free to leave it with us afterwards to keep you in touch with what’s happening. And otherwise enjoy the rest of the day and the rest of your lives, however long or short may they be long and healthy. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

completing karma drubje kyi lä (Tib)
Also called finishing karma, the karmic imprints that ripen to determine the type of experiences we have when we are reborn, as opposed to throwing karma that determines the actual rebirth. LYWA
contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
Yama shinchi dagje (Tib)
The Lord of Death, seen on the Wheel of Life. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top