45 min · 3,080 words · 6 May 1989
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk begins by setting a motivation for practice and explains why a precious human rebirth with freedoms and endowments offers the chance to avoid lower rebirths. It then teaches the three levels of going for refuge to the Three Jewels, distinguishing verbal from actual refuge, and outlines the eight benefits of refuge.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1989-05-06
Duration: 45 min
UUID: bbf1afb9-47b5-4f1d-b7dd-daf4f70ef64d
Words: 3,076
Put the other two out. Oh.
Yeah. So initially, we should adjust our motivation such that we are going to listen to this teaching as a means to put what is taught into practice. And this in order to attain perfect complete Buddhahood as the method whereby to establish all sentient beings in a state of complete happiness and bliss. So trying to foster such a type of motivation, the motivation of the awakening heart. By awakening heart we mean the attitude which seeks Buddhahood in order to establish all sentient beings and happiness.
If we listen to the teaching with such an attitude, then the teaching becomes a great vehicle teaching. So Candrakīrti in his Entering into the Middle Way says, Having found freedom and abiding in conducive conditions, if you do not make use of them through losing control and falling off the precipice, how will you ever rise up again? So if we begin to discuss the meaning of this quotation that we have found some control over our lives, have some freedom or independence. We have found it’s very precious and significant to be a human being. There are many different types of human beings in the world.
Just as in the case of different types of articles, there are different qualities. Likewise, are different qualities or types of human beings. Amongst the various types of human beings in the world, the best type is that which is able to put into practice the Dharma. And this is necessary to be able to do that. We have to be the type of being who has all the leisures and fortunes.
The eight leisures and 10 fortunes, which allows the freedom to practice and and has the conditions whereby all the contradictory circumstances have been eliminated. So we have this embodiment which allows us to put into practice the Dharma. Now it’s a fact that we all understand that we want happiness and that we don’t want to suffer. But this is even animals understand this fact that they experience this way of acting seeking happiness and not wanting to suffer. But it’s very much a part of the practitioner of Dharma that they seek to understand the causes of happiness and the causes of suffering.
By listening to the teachings on the Dharma, we can put into practice the methods for cultivating the causes of happiness and to eliminate the causes of suffering. So we have a clear minded, and that we have the ability to think well. And that we should take the time to think about the possibilities of future existences that, you know, what type of future do we want? Do we want to move on to a a suffering, a place of suffering, or a place of happiness? And naturally, we would choose, if we were to think about it, place of happiness in the future.
But it is now that we can control, that we have the control over what type of future existence that we’re going to enter into. So now we have the control. Have the freedom, independence to make such a choice to control our future that in our next rebirth that we can be reborn as a God or a human. We have the control or the power to determine whether we can attain liberation. We have the control or power that we can actually attain Buddhahood.
So what do we have to do to attain these ends now that at this time we have the control, the choice in their future existence in order to attain a rebirth as a human or attain liberation or Buddhahood? It is necessary to practice Dharma. Without the practice of Dharma, then we actually have no control over such future types of existences. So, at the time that we have the choice, that we have the control or the power, to make use of that time in order to practice. If we do not practice, then we’re going to if we do not practice by abandoning unskillful actions, those actions which cause us to experience suffering, then in the future that we are going to fall to bad migrations and we’re going to experience unimaginable types of suffering.
In such a situation we have no power to help lift ourselves back up again. In such a situation as exists within the hell realms or the hungry ghost realms, that they are experiencing tremendous suffering. Not only that, but there is no opportunity to practice the Dharma, the methods to rise up or even listen to the Dharma. There is not even anyone who teaches the Dharma. And if we take the example of a dog that having taken rebirth as a dog, then it’s almost impossible for that dog to engage in skillful actions, causes which will create causes which will help it to rise up to a higher state.
But in fact, it’s predominantly involved in the unskillful actions or destructive actions of anger, attachment, confusion, and delusion. So it’s continuing creating the causes for future suffering. Once having fallen into a bad migration, then there’s no refuge. We don’t even know about the refuge and there’s nothing to take refuge in, in such a situation and that we’re very much lost in such an existence. But now that we aren’t abiding in that state, that we have choice, that we have the control over our lives, then we should have to make use of this chance and to practice the Dharma.
There are many different types of religions, many different varieties of Dharma in the world. But the type of Dharma which we are seeking to practice, that is the Buddhadharma, which is extremely rare and extremely precious. You know, can make use of our reasoning to examine it and see that we cannot find any faults in it. And that it has the ability, the methods within it, to bring consummate happiness, to complete happiness to one. And therefore such a type of Dharma is extremely rare in the world and that we’re having the opportunity to put it into practice shows how extremely fortunate we actually are.
Whatever type of Dharma that we might be seeking to practice, whether it’s Christian or Islam, that we have to try to gain faith in our religion. We have to try to gain conviction, gaining faith in the founder of that religion, the teacher, and having gained this faith and conviction in the teacher and the Dharma of that religion to put it into practice. So the teacher of the Buddhadharma within the religion of Buddhism is our teacher, the Buddha, And that we have to seek to gain conviction in his having shown a perfect refuge. And the refuge as the teachings, the actual methods, as the Dharma. And those who support us in our practice, those who assist us as the Sangha, make a perfect refuge.
So it is the teacher, the Buddha, who showed the refuge. And the refuge that he showed is the Dharma. And that is the true cessation and true paths leading to cessation. And the spiritual community of the Sangha who assist us in realizing the true cessation and following the true paths, that is the Dharma. Those who find this as a perfect source of refuge, then they are abiding within the Buddhist Dharma.
If those who do not see this as a perfect type of refuge, then they are abiding in whatever type practice it would be, non Buddhist practice. So all the great masters, whether it’s Śāntideva, Candrakīrti, Chandragomin, they all made the distinguishment between Buddhist and non Buddhist from the point of view of refuge. Those who abide in the perfect refuge of the Buddhadharma and Sangha, then they are Buddhists. Those who do not abide in these refuges are non Buddhists. It’s just as if in the case of whether we’re in the house or outside of the house is determined on which side of the doorstep we’re on.
I think that’s what it’s called. If we’re on the inside of the doorstep or in the house, we’re on the outside of the doorstep or outside of the house, this is the distinguishing mark or factor. So there are three levels of refuge. Three refuges corresponding to the three levels of capacity of beings: the small capacity being, the middle capacity and great capacity beings. So in speaking about the refuge of the being of small capacity, Now there has to be a reason for going for refuge.
There are two reasons for going for refuge. The first is fear, anxiety. We see the refuge as being able to protect us from this fear that we have the conviction, the second cause, that the object of our refuge has the ability to protect us. So the two causes for going for refuge are the fear of future sufferings and the conviction that the object of our refuge has the ability to protect us from our fear, our future suffering. Now, for example, when we die, we don’t become non existent.
We continue on. Now there are two possibilities. Either we’re going to have a happy migration or a bad migration. There are no other possibilities. Happy migrations are our result of skillful actions, but we have created very few of those.
Unhappy migrations are the result of unskillful actions. So most of us are going to experience a bad migration in the future. This is going to be accompanied with a great deal of suffering. So developing a fear of future states of suffering in bad migrations, one goes to refuge to the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha through a conviction that they have the ability to protect one from the sufferings of bad migrations. Such a type of refuge is the refuge of the small capacity seeking to eliminate the fear of the suffering of future bad migrations.
So by way of example, this is as if we don’t plant the seed, then a sprout will not arise. Likewise, without planting the seeds of refuge, then the actual refuge will not arise. And the causes or the seeds of going for refuge are fear and the conviction and the ability for the object of refuge to protect. In the case of the being of a smaller capacity, they see the possibility of future sufferings and bad migrations. And they develop a fear of such experience and have the conviction that the three jewels have the ability to protect them from experiencing the future sufferings, the fear of such future sufferings.
And that with such a these two causes, they go for refuge with a single-minded hope that the object of refuge will protect them from the future exist from such a type of future existence. That single-minded hope, expectation. When we recite the ritual of the Lama Chöpa or Guru Puja, offering to the spiritual master, there’s a section where we recite the refuge. Namo Gurubhya, Namo Buddhaya, Namo Dharmaya, Namo Sanghaya, I’m going for refuge. So this is simply going for refuge from the mouth.
This is verbal refuge. And this is not the actual refuge. Actual refuge takes place in one’s mind. The development, the arising of conviction and faith in objects of refuge is the actual point for refuge. So the recitation of mere words, Namo Gurubhya, Namo Buddhaya, etcetera, even a child can say these words.
This is not the actual going for refuge. The actual going for refuge takes place in one’s mind. That there arises the anxiety or fear of future suffering existences and the conviction, the belief and the ability of the objects of refuge to protect you from this fear. And that even when we though we do recite refuge formula again and again, for example, we say, I go for refuge to the Buddha, I go for refuge to the Dharma, Sanghaya, etcetera, etcetera. We say these again and again and we count these.
And perhaps we count, we do a 100,000 or 200,000. The only reason that we recite these, that we count them, is that later on we can rejoice in remembering that having gone for refuge in this way, having having done this as many times as we did. But this in itself is not the going for refuge. But it’s only done it’s only counted so that later on that we can rejoice in having done this. So there we do recite verbally.
I go for refuge to the Lama, go for refuge to the Buddha, Sangha, Dharma, Sangha, And this is simply verbal refuge. Now the actual refuge takes place in one’s mind that we should recollect the sufferings of bad migrations. Upon recollecting them, generate a sincere fear, anxiety about the sufferings which are associated with such states. And then develop the recall the develop the conviction or the belief in the ability of the three jewels to protect us from this fear. And then this then in putting one’s trust in the three jewels, this is the actual going for refuge.
And then the refuge of the being of middling capacity. With respect to this practitioner, then one generates a sincere fear of the suffering of cyclic existence in general. And having developed generates the conviction that the three jewels have the ability to protect one from the fear and the suffering of cyclic existence in general and putting one’s There is the thinking that there is no there is no other refuge. There’s nothing else that can protect me from the fear and the sufferings of cyclic existence than you. And this is going for refuge from the level of the middling being of capacity.
Then the refuge of the being of great capacity, that one develops a fear of one’s own cyclic, of the sufferings of one’s own cyclic existence, but then extends that seeing that all sentient beings are likewise being tortured by the same sufferings of cyclic existence and develops love and compassion for them. And having developed love and compassion along with the fear of one’s own cyclic existence, one goes for refuge thinking that it is only the three jewels which can protect not only myself but all sentient beings from their suffering and therefore going for refuge in order to attain the Buddhahood as a means to alleviate the suffering of not only oneself but others. So in order that we remember that we are mindful of our refuge, we should it’s necessary to think about the benefits of going for refuge. It’s the same as, for example, a business person. They keep in mind all the profits that they’re going to get from what the deal that they’re involved in, they’re quite willing to go through a lot of trouble.
It’s as if these difficulties didn’t exist because they keep their eye on all the profits. Likewise, a farmer is willing to go through a lot of hardships if he keeps his eye on the benefits of what he’s doing. It seems as if it’s not a great deal of trouble to him. Likewise, if we are mindful of the benefit of going for refuge, then we are willing to enthusiastically engage in putting into practice the actual refuge. So there are eight benefits of going for refuge.
The first is that by going for refuge to the three jewels, one is included amongst the Buddhists, one becomes a Buddhist. And that whatever practices one engages in is a practice of Buddhism, is a Buddhist practice. Then the second benefit is that having gone for refuge then we have the basis, the foundation for generating future vows or precepts. Precepts, the observance of precepts and vows is the basis of our practice. And therefore we need this foundation in order to generate future the various types of vows.
For example, the vows of individual liberation of which there are eight types, the bodhisattva vows and the tantric vows. Having this foundation, having it going for refuge, then these can be generated. They’re not only generated but they remain stable and they’re able to increase them. So the going for refuge is the foundation necessary to generate the vows. If there’s no refuge then there’s no basis for generating vows.
When even if in the past one had gone for refuge, had taken vows, if at a future time one gave up one’s refuge then one would lose it. The vows that it’s necessary to have refuge as a foundation for any vows. Once the refuge is lost then the vows are lost. How can we actually give up our refuge? Having previously taken refuge, we took it well.
That we come to think that in fact that the Buddhist refuge is no good. That there are other better refuges. We take refuge in, for example, a non Buddhist deities such as Ishvara or Indra gods such as these and therefore in this way one loses, gives up one’s refuge. The third benefit is the elimination or purification of past negative actions. Do we collect?
We collect, we create negative actions with respect to two objects. Those are mother sentient beings, in dependence upon mother sentient beings in general or towards the three jewels of Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. So by means of going for refuge to the Buddha, we purify the negative actions we created with respect to the Buddha by going for refuge to the Dharma. Likewise, we purify the negativity we’ve created in the past with respect to the Dharma and the same for the Sangha. When we confess our negative actions, when we acknowledge them, lay them bare, then we at that time we should be applying the four counteracting agents of the four opponent powers.
And amongst these is the power of reliance. In this in this we those negativities we’ve created with respect to the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha in order to purify them we go for refuge to the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. This is the method of purifying the negativities created with respect to them. Likewise with respect to the negativities that we’ve created in regards to sentient beings that we develop bodhicitta. That is the love and compassion in the awakening heart towards sentient beings.
And this is the way we purify negativities created with respect to sentient beings in general.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
- The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- four opponent powers nyenpo tob zhi (Tib)
- The four practices used to purify nonvirtuous imprints on the mindstream. LYWA
- Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
- A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
- individual liberation
- The liberation from cyclic existence achieved by a hearer (shravaka) or solitary realizer (pratyekabuddha), as compared with the full enlightenment of a buddha sought in the Mahayana. LYWA
- tantric vows sang ngag kyi dom pa (Tib)
- Vows taken by tantric practitioners. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.