Precious Garland – 1991-05-14 – Attachment and Renunciation – KR

Precious Garland (Khensur Rinpoche)
Precious Garland (Khensur Rinpoche)
Precious Garland - 1991-05-14 - Attachment and Renunciation - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains renunciation as the basis for liberation, defining cyclic existence as the five aggregates held under afflictive emotions and karma. It identifies attachment to one’s own and others’ bodies as the main obstacle and counters it by reflecting on the body’s uncleanliness and on how ignorance exaggerates its beauty. Reducing attachment is presented as the path to ethics of renunciation, then calm abiding and special insight, and the session closes with questions on attraction versus attachment and whether beauty is inherent in objects.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 1991-05-14

Duration: 1h 38m

UUID: 24e40b12-b9cd-409d-b84f-3eba08aec1a3

Words: 3,668

No. Can you hear me now? I want to can you hear me in the back? No. Can you hear me now?

Wave your no. Can you hear me? Okay. Holding more dear than myself in order to free them from all of their suffering, to bring them happiness. I must practice and train well in order to remove all of my various thoughts and bring to culmination all my excellent qualities.

If I were to do this then I would have brought my own welfare to consummation to its final end and I would be empowered to bring others’ welfare to their final end. In that way we’ll be able to serve others by bringing about their ultimate desires in the sense of being able to emanate various teachers from my own self and thereby each of these will be able to teach the Dharma unerringly, the teaching of the Dharma of liberation in a way of achieving omniscience. So with the motivation of the awakening heart cultivated over the next three minutes, determine that in order to bring about this end that I must train well and meditate within the great vehicle. I’m quoting from a verse by Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen where he said, In order to be free, to find freedom and liberation from cyclic existence one must realize emptiness.

Amongst the three higher trainings this denotes the necessity to train in the higher training in wisdom. And as the foundation for the ultimate generation of wisdom, it’s necessary to abide in the ethics of renunciation. Without renunciation, that is to say the renunciation of cyclic existence, there’s no way that we can abide in the ethics of renunciation. What do we mean by cyclic existence? Such things as this room, tree, water, earth, forest, these are not cyclic existence.

These are the environment. Dharmakīrti goes on to define cyclic existence as the five aggregates which are appropriated under the influence of afflictive emotions and karma. The five aggregates being those of forms, feelings, perceptions, thought constructions and consciousness. Terms of speaking of the five aggregates, the first of the five aggregates is the aggregate form and this is constituted of the aggregation of atoms And in dependence upon this aggregation of particles when this aggregation for example becomes hot then we experience suffering. When it becomes cold, again suffering.

When it becomes cool, we experience pleasure. Other times we experience neutral feelings. So, in dependence upon the basis of the aggregation of the atoms of form, we experience the feelings of pleasure, displeasure and neutral feeling. Then the third of the aggregates is that of perception sometimes translated as discrimination or recognition. And this is the knowing faculty which discriminates, this is this, this is that, this is red, this is white, this is yellow, this is a person, this is water.

Than that of the aggregate of consciousness and this is the discursive consciousness which is thinking previously I did this and presently I’m doing this and in the future I will do that. And then the aggregate of mental construction or thought construction are all the various types of consciousness aside from the consciousness which we just described. For example, consciousnesses such as faith, wisdom, attachment, pride, ignorance, all of these grouped together constitute the aggregate of mental constructs. So all beings which have form have the five aggregates. So the renunciation which we are seeking to develop is renunciation toward these five aggregates, but specifically the five aggregates which are appropriated under the influence of karma and afflictive emotions.

Having developed that renunciation, we can then redevelop a striving toward liberation from such types of aggregates and thereby we can live in the ethics of renunciation. So what is the obstacle to the development of renunciation? Obstruction, that is attachment to the body, both the attachment to one’s own body and to the bodies of others. Unless we develop renunciation we will continue to circle within cyclic existence because without the removal of the obstacle of attachment, not seeing the discordant quality of attachment in order to be liberated from cyclic existence, we will remain within cyclic existence and we will not seek freedom from it. Today we’re going to talk about the way in which to bring about a cessation of attachment.

So as was previously taught from a verse by Nāgārjuna in which he said, Rare are helpful speakers. Listeners are rare. He went on to say, But rare still are words which though unpleasant help at once. Though we may hear unpleasant words, if they’re of benefit then it’s necessary that we put them into practice. So up to now, most of the words that you’ve been hearing have been quite pleasant.

But today, some of the words you hear for some may be unpleasant, but of course for some they may still be pleasant. Pleasant or not, they are a benefit and should be practiced. in dependence upon pleasurable feelings we develop attachment. in dependence upon unpleasant feelings we develop aversion. And dependence upon neutral feelings we develop delusion, confusion.

So the body in which the feeling arises upon and the feelings themselves are the basis for both attachment and aversion. So we can develop the afflictions of aversion and attachment and dependence upon the aggregates of form, upon feelings, additionally upon aggregate of perception. For example, if someone were giving a teaching and the view that this teacher was presenting was in accordance with your view, then you might develop attachment towards this person. If it was in discord with your view, you might develop an aversion towards this person. This would be recognizing or discriminating this person and dependent upon their view, you would develop attachment and aversion.

Also in terms of the discursive thoughts of the aggregate of consciousness in which it involves an extreme preponderance of negative actions through the thinking of various negative and positive types of thoughts such as attachment and aversion. But mainly in terms of removing the overcoming or bringing about a cessation of attachment, we’re concerned with the attachment with respect to the body. So, what is going to be presented in terms of the body we can all understand for ourselves. Can each of us apply this to ourselves. It’s not something which was just meant for a monk.

And additionally what is being explained equally applies to both male bodies and female bodies. And to begin with, due to our misconception as to the nature of the body as being clean when in fact it is unclean, we develop attachment for body. So we can begin with our mouth. It’s like a vessel filled with foul fluids like saliva. There is all this filth between our teeth.

And our nose is filled with various fluids. And our eyes are filled, each have their own peculiar filth and also tears. And the body is a vessel filled with excrement, urine, lungs, and liver. But though the body is unclean, we are obscured to seeing it and clinging to it. So if we take an analogy, if there was a pot which is beautifully adorned on the outside but contains filth, would you be attracted to that pot?

And we ourselves are exactly the same. We have these beautifully ornamented bodies but actually full of filth. How can you develop attachment for such a thing? That’s really stupid. We’re just like pigs who pigs enjoy filth a great deal and we’re very much like them.

Understanding the actual nature of our body, those who are wise do not develop attachment towards Our body is very much like a great city such maybe for example Sydney which has a huge sewage work in which emits all this filth out of the sewer. This filth goes in and comes out the various openings and our body has this sewage system in which emits and out of these openings come all of this filth of excrement and pus and blood and etcetera. So you know if we really examine our body we will see that to think it is clean is very much a wrong conception, but in fact it is unclean. And, in thinking of it in its actual terms, to hold it as being beautiful is a misconception. It’s a wrong way of understanding its nature.

So how was our body initially constituted? What was its cause? Did it rise out of a fine cause or repugnant cause? In fact, if we look at the very source of our body, it is the ovum and semen of our parents. This is the very seed of our body.

So how can that which arises out of blood and semen be clean? You know we talked about the internally uncleanliness of the body, but also the external. Our skin is unclean because it arises from the union of the blood and sperm. So if the outside and inside are both unclean, how can we be attached to it? It?

It make sense to be attached to it. So whether it’s a man or a woman, both are internally and externally unclean, and what happens when we rely upon either? So these bodies, it doesn’t matter whether they’re beautiful or ugly, whether they’re old or young, they still all have the same nature. It’s not very pleasant, is it? So, would you be attracted towards filth even if it had a pleasant shape and a nice color.

We simply wouldn’t be attracted to filth even if it had a very attractive shape and color and therefore we wouldn’t be attached to it. This would be similar to the example that we’ve decided previously, a very beautifully ornamented pot which was filled with filth. The body is unclean by its very nature, by its cause. We can look at its shape, its color and therefore what is it that we are to be attached to and seeing it. Can see that attachment makes no sense.

But the fact is we generate, we develop attachment toward our own body. We develop attachment for others’ bodies. This holds true both for females and males. Under the influence of this attachment, the attachment acts to inhibit the development of renunciation and therefore we never attain liberation. In general, we have acquired our beautiful bodies as a result of skillful action and the result of practice of ethics. So say that we we have beautiful bodies.

We can make that determination, but with attachment it’s simply not just the beauty of the body as it impacts by its very nature, there is an exaggeration of the beauty of the body and it’s due to the superimposition of the beauty of the body, of exaggerated beauty of the body that we develop attachment and this is the fault. In general we can talk about the quality of the goodness or badness of objects in terms of their actual nature. I mean certain objects are good and certain objects are bad by their very nature. But here, this we can talk about, this is actual way things exist, the good and bad. Here, due to the fundamental ignorance, under the influence of fundamental ignorance there is a going beyond the actual nature of the object.

There is an exaggeration. We impute qualities which exceed its actual nature and due to this exaggerated superimposition beyond the actual nature of the object, we develop attachment and this is due to the condition of ignorance. So, such beings as Buddhas, Bodhisattvas, Foe Destroyers have abandoned, many of them have abandoned attachment and these beings, they see that which is beautiful as beautiful because they see things in accordance with the way they exist. So, they would see beautiful as beautiful but they do not impose an exaggerated qualities upon the object which is not there because due to the force of ignorance which they have abandoned, they see that which is as it is without exceeding its quality. In order to develop aversion and attachment, all the very afflictive emotions, it’s necessary that it be assisted by ignorance.

Due to the force of ignorance we’re not able to see the actual nature of the object. The person under the influence of ignorance does not see the object for what it really is. There’s an obscuration which prevents them seeing the actual nature of the object and in fact there is an exaggeration with respect to the qualities of the object and out of this we develop the very afflictive emotions such as aversion and attachment. We We have to take care of our bodies. We have to keep our body clean.

We have to take care of our health and this is because is the basis for the practice of Dharma, the human life that we possess, the human body. It has this great power and potential. We want to have a long life so we have to take care of our body and our health. If we have a short life then we’re not going to be able to achieve all that we could and we want to be able to derive all the benefits possible out of it. And we must act in accordance with the prevailing mores, prevailing views of our place that we live and the time.

For example, if it’s acceptable to have a clean body then we must accept that prevailing view and we must try to keep our body clean. If we reflect upon what has just been explained, then our attachment will lessen. That when we understand the nature of the uncleanliness of the body, then we will be able to derive the benefit of developing renunciation to the degree that we reflect upon and become less attached to the body, we come closer and closer to the development of actual renunciation. As our attachment lessens, our renunciation will increase and we will be able to abide within the ethics of renunciation such as the observance of the abandonment of the 10 unskillful actions. And that will act as a condition necessary for the eventual development of calm abiding and special insight.

That is just like preparing a field in which the potential for these will be planted. The cultivating and the meditation on renunciation is extremely beneficial. The cessation of our attachment is very important. Within the spiritual community of the Sangha, of the lesser vehicle, the main initial practice is that of ethics. This is in order to bring about the cessation of attachment.

In order to develop this renunciation, the monks would use the cloth in which the corpses were wrapped prior to their being burnt in the funeral pyre as material for their robes in order to aid in their renunciation. One of the robes of a monk is made up of very small patches which have been sewn together. This is the symbolic of the patches which were begged from these corpse wrapping cloths. These would be sewn together, these small pieces that they were able to get would be sewn together to make their robe. Likewise within the Vinaya discipline of the monks, was necessary that when going for alms one could only go to three homes and whatever was given or not given that was all that one would eat.

And one would live under a tree. One would sit on the ground. And the medicines that the monk would take would be made from the dregs left over from the medicine which was prepared by others. You know the barks of trees, they would crush it up and they would extract the medicine from it and they would throw the dregs away. Then the monk would take those dregs and make his medicine.

All of these were taught in order to cease attachment. in dependence upon cessation of attachment, one could abide well in the ethics of renunciation and dependence upon that one would attain a human life and liberation. So in the development of renunciation we have to take care of our bodies. We have to keep them clean. It would be excellent if we can develop a lesson or attachment to our body.

So we’re going to stop then. Should there be some questions? Attachment and and and attraction. They are very similar. So they’re very similar.

If they arise under the influence of karma and the afflictive emotions, then attraction for an object and attachment to that object are extremely similar, almost the same. If they arise under the influence of afflictive emotions and karma, then attraction and attachment for an object would be very similar. These two, attraction and attachment, would have the same aspect. It is the mind thinking that this object is pleasant. So both attachment and attraction. Attachment and attraction are the mind thinking with respect to the object that this is a pleasant object.

The mind is holding the object as pleasant. These These two are quite similar, attraction and attachment. They have the same function, the way they’re generated and the way they succeed are the same, but we impute different names to these two states. They both are holding the object as pleasant, but with attachment there is a penetration into the object of the mind which exceeds that of attraction. They’re both holding the object as pleasant, but there is a greater entering into the object of the mind, penetration into the object.

Analogy, we can use these same terms. We can say we have attraction and attachment for a person of the opposite sex, but we can also use that word attraction in another sense. We can say, I have attraction for my spiritual teacher or I have faith for my spiritual teacher. At the same time. We have to cease attachment, aversion and delusion with respect to the opposite sex equally important.

So you’re saying that beauty is not the nature of the object. It’s purely coming from the side of the person who sees it that way. So the beauty of the object is coming from So the beauty of the object is coming from the side of the object and the side of the subject. Is by the nature of the object, There is a beauty by the very nature of the object. There is beauty by the very nature of the object and the mind imputes that beauty.

For example, the body of a Buddha is by its very nature beautiful, by its very nature. Also it would not be correct to impute beauty to that which is by its very nature ugly. Such things as faults, things being bad, things being good, All of these exist as by the nature of their object. We cannot call something which is bad good.

Simply by calling it, that doesn’t make it good. It can be the very nature of the object that it’s a fault, that it’s beneficial, that it’s good, that it’s bad. This is in the nature of the object and no matter how much we might call it something else, it doesn’t change the very nature of that object. The way in which these objects come into existence is in combination with their being imputed as such from the side of the object. The nature of the object is, for example, bad and in combination with an awareness imputing upon that object bad, then the bad object comes into existence.

These qualities do not exist from their own side but come into existence through a combination of the nature of the object and the imputing mind. In order for an object to come into existence it has to have three characteristics. It must be not harmed by a worldly convention. It is not refuted by a prime cognition ascertaining the ultimate and it must be able to perform the function as it is described. If an object is able to do that then it exists.

So whether or not one realizes emptiness or not, the body is still unclean. I’m sorry, could you speak up? I can’t hear you well. If we were all taking bodies to benefit sentient beings. If we were all here in order to benefit others, what would be the benefit of having bodies?

I mean all sentient beings if they were all Everybody wanted to help. So it would be beneficial to take a body in order to benefit sentient If everybody was doing Yeah. Yeah. Was. If everybody was a bodhisattva then?

A bodhisattva is a sentient being and she takes a body to benefit each sentient being. In order to benefit others. In order to teach the Dharma. In order to help others. Oh, if you’re all enlightened.

That’s different. That’s the. Then we wouldn’t take one. Okay, we’ve finished our work. Everybody’s become a Buddha and then we can take a long holiday.

The only reason a Buddha takes rebirth is for the benefit of an unenlightened being. If there are none, then he has nothing to do. What does he do? He just hangs out.

He he abides in in equipoise. He abides in equipoise. Once all sentient beings are happy then Buddhas can play. The way people can live without attachment to the body. People.

You would just go along much as you are now but be much happier. So in overcoming attachment to one’s body one can abide in, one will develop renunciation. In developing renunciation one can abide in ethics and develop and abide in the ethics of renunciation. One can develop calm abiding and special insight and through developing that one will abandon their afflictive emotions and gradually attain freedom. All of the previous beings who have achieved liberation proceeded in this fashion.

And if we ourselves want to travel the path of liberation then we have to travel the same path. There is no other. It’d be wonderful when all sentient beings attain Buddhahood.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
three higher trainings lhagpäi lab pa sum (Tib)
The three higher trainings of ethics, concentration and wisdom when conjoined with refuge in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top